Skip to content
Share this page

Numbers 11:4

“The Demand for Meat and Moses’ Despair”Numbers 11:4–15

King James Version
And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
And the mixt multitude H628 that was among H7130 them fell a lusting H183 H8378: and the children H1121 of Israel H3478 also wept H1058 again H7725, and said H559, Who shall give us flesh H1320 to eat H398?

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
Meanwhile, the rabble among them had a strong craving for other food, and again the Israelites wept and said, “Who will feed us meat?

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
And the mixed multitude that was among them lusted exceedingly: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
The mixed multitude that was among them lusted exceedingly: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, “Who will give us flesh to eat?

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
And a nomber of people that was amog them, fell a lusting, and turned away, and the children of Israel also wept, and saide, Who shall giue vs flesh to eate?

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
And the rabble who are in its midst have lusted greatly, and the sons of Israel also turn back and weep, and say, `Who doth give us flesh?

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
14 Hebrew words
  1. וְהָאסַפְסֻףve·ha·saf·Sufand the rabbleH628Conj-w ¦ Art ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteוְandהָtheאסַפְסֻףrabble
  2. אֲשֶׁר'a·SherwhichH834RelParticle Relative
  3. בְּקִרְבּוֹbe·kir·Bo[was] in its midstH7130Prep-b ¦ N-msc ¦ 3msNoun Singular Masculine Construct with suffixבְּ[was] inקִרְבּmidstוֹits
  4. הִתְאַוּוּhit·'a·Vuthey cravedH183V-Hithpael-Perf-3cpVerb Hithpael Perfect 3rd Plural common gender
  5. תַּאֲוָהta·'a·Vaha cravingH8378N-fsNoun Singular Feminine Absolute
  6. וַיָּשֻׁבוּvai·ya·Shu·vuand they returnedH7725Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecImperf-3mpVerb Qal Consecutive Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculineוַandיָּשֻׁבוּthey returned
  7. וַיִּבְכּוּvai·yiv·Kuand they weptH1058Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecImperf-3mpVerb Qal Consecutive Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculineוַandיִּבְכּוּthey wept
  8. גַּםgamalsoH1571AdvAdverb
  9. בְּנֵיbe·Nei[the] people ofH1121N-mpcNoun Plural Masculine Construct
  10. יִשְׂרָאֵלYis·ra·'ElIsraelH3478N-properNoun Proper Location
  11. וַיֹּאמְרוּvai·Yo·me·Ruand they saidH559Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecImperf-3mpVerb Qal Consecutive Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculineוַandיֹּאמְרוּthey said
  12. מִיmiwho?H4310InterrogPronoun Interrogative
  13. יַאֲכִלֵנוּya·'a·khi·Le·nuwill he cause to eat usH398V-Hiphil-Imperf-3ms ¦ 1cpVerb Hiphil Imperfect 3rd Singular Masculineיַאֲכִלֵwill he cause to eatנוּus
  14. בָּשָׂרba·SarmeatH1320N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Hebrew Masoretic text, the same tradition the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “the LORD” where the word-by-word meaning reads “Yahweh”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Hebrew. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 4,029 of 31,102 · 13.0%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

The mixt multitude that came out of Egypt with Israel begins to crave, and the children of Israel take up their weeping again, asking who will give them meat to eat.

“And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting:”

The craving began with the people of other nations who had left Egypt with Israel, and the Hebrew doubles the idea: they longed with a longing.

“and the children of Israel also wept again,”

Israel joined in, turning back to the complaining they had done at Marah, Sin and Rephidim, and only just at Taberah.

“and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?”

Meat was the food of feast days, and they wanted it every day, as if no one were feeding them.

Passage studyNumbers 11:4–15

The Craving for Meat and Moses’ Despair

Summary

Soon after Israel sets out from Sinai, the mixt multitude travelling with them begins to crave meat, and the children of Israel take up their weeping again. They remember the fish and vegetables they ate in Egypt at no cost, and they complain that they have only the manna to look at. Right beside their complaint stands a description of that manna: small as coriander seed, coloured like bdellium, ground and baked into cakes that tasted of fresh oil, and falling with the dew on the camp every night. The weeping reaches Moses from the door of every tent, the anger of the LORD burns greatly, and Moses, sick at heart, brings his own complaint to God. He asks why the whole people has been laid on him as if he had given birth to them, where he could find meat for them all, and how he can carry them alone, and then he asks the LORD to kill him at once. Here we see how quickly a rescued people can grow tired of the bread God gives, and how a servant at the end of his strength may bring the whole weight of it to God.

The mixt multitude and the craving for meat

Israel had only just broken camp at Sinai and set out in the order God had given (Numbers 10). The trouble in verse 4 begins with “the mixt multitude that was among them”. The Hebrew word, ʼăçpᵉçuph (sometimes written asaphsuph), is formed by repeating a root meaning to gather, so it pictures a crowd gathered up together from many places, a mixed assembly of people. These are the people of other nations who came out of Egypt alongside Israel (Exodus 12:38). Some may have come because they had seen the LORD’s power over Egypt, and some for the sake of their own freedom. They stood outside Israel’s tribes and families, and their craving spread quickly to the rest of the camp. Paul’s warning that bad company corrupts good character (1 Corinthians 15:33) describes what happened next.

“Fell a lusting” joins two Hebrew words, the verb ʼâvâh, to wish for, long for or greatly desire, and the noun taʼăvâh, a longing or desire. Together they say that the people longed with a longing. Both words can be used of desire in general, and here the setting makes it a craving that turned its back on what God was giving every day. Before the chapter ends, the place where it happened is given a name meaning “graves of craving” or “graves of lust”, Kibroth-hattaavah (Numbers 11:34).

“And the children of Israel also wept again.” The verb bâkâh means to weep, bemoan and make lamentation, the kind of weeping others can hear, which is how Moses comes to hear it in verse 10. “Again” stands for shûwb, to turn back or return, and Israel was turning back to a weeping it had done before. The people had complained at Marah (Exodus 15:24), in the wilderness of Sin (Exodus 16:2) and at Rephidim (Exodus 17:3), where God gave them water from the rock (Exodus 17). Just before this, fire from the LORD had burned among them at Taberah until Moses prayed (Numbers 11:1–3). The same pattern would lead to the refusal to enter the land at Kadesh (Numbers 13–14), where the LORD says they have tempted him ten times (Numbers 14:22).

Their question, “Who shall give us flesh to eat?”, uses bâsâr, flesh, the ordinary word for meat as well as for the body. Meat was a luxury, kept for feasts, sacrifices and special days, and the people wanted it as their daily food. The question asks who could feed them, while the God who was already feeding them every morning stood ready to be asked.

Why was it wrong to want meat?

The sin lay in the craving and in what it said about God. He had given them manna every day, enough for every person, and they wept for Egypt’s table as though his gift were worthless. The meat itself was good food, and before long the LORD would send them quail (Numbers 11:18–34). Their hearts were set on what their appetite wanted, and the craving became a judgment on God’s wisdom and care.

Scripture traces this path of desire for us. James describes a man drawn away by his own lust, and lust, once it has conceived, bringing forth sin, and sin bringing forth death (James 1:14–15). John warns against “the lust of the flesh” (1 John 2:16). Psalm 78 retells how Israel tested God in the wilderness by asking for food for their craving, and how he sent the birds and his judgment with them (Psalm 78:17–31), and Psalm 106 remembers the same craving and the same judgment (Psalm 106:14–15).

Remembering Egypt

“We remember the fish, which we did eat in Egypt freely.” The verb zâkar is the ordinary word for remembering, and the memory the people keep is a narrow one. They remember the fish (dâgâh, a word often used of fish in general) and the cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions and garlic that grew in the well-watered land of Egypt along the Nile. Those were common foods there. What they leave out is the taskmasters and the hard bondage that made their lives bitter (Exodus 1:11–14), in a land where Israel had stayed 430 years (Exodus 12:40).

“Freely” translates chinnâm, which means gratis, at no cost, and is used elsewhere of something done without a cause or in vain. The food came free, and the people who ate it were slaves. They had said the same thing at the wilderness of Sin, when they longed for the flesh pots of Egypt (Exodus 16:3), and they would say it again.

“Our soul is dried away”

In verse 6 the people describe themselves. Nephesh, “soul”, is a wide word, covering a breathing creature, life, self, person and appetite, so “our soul” takes in their whole selves along with their hunger. Yâbêsh means dry or dried away, and they speak of themselves as withered. “There is nothing at all, beside this manna, before our eyes”: the particle biltîy means not, without, except or unless, and here it means “except”. They had the manna and nothing else.

Their complaint is about sameness. The manna kept them alive and well, and they were tired of seeing the same food every morning. Later still they would speak of it with open contempt (Numbers 21:5). The word for “eyes” here, ʻayin, comes back in the next verse as “colour”, so the manna they are tired of looking at is described by its look.

What the manna was like

Set beside the complaint, verses 7 to 9 show how good the manna was. Its name, mân, means “what?”, from the question the people asked when they first saw it (Exodus 16:15). The whole story of its first giving is in Exodus 16.

It “was as coriander seed”, small and round. The word gad names coriander seed from the furrows on it. “The colour thereof as the colour of bdellium” uses ʻayin, eye, for its look, both times. Bdellium, bᵉdôlach, is probably a fragrant gum, perhaps like amber, and some take it to be a pearl. It is named with gold and onyx in the land of Havilah (Genesis 2:12), so it was a fine and valued thing. Exodus adds that the manna was white and tasted like wafers made with honey (Exodus 16:31).

Verse 8 shows the people at work with it. They went about the camp gathering it, ground it in mills or pounded it in a mortar like grain, and cooked it in pans. The verb bâshal means to boil up or be done in cooking, so it covers baking and boiling alike. They made cakes of it, and “the taste of it was as the taste of fresh oil”. Ṭaʿam is taste, and shemen is oil, especially olive oil, which Israel prized for food, anointing, light and medicine. So the manna was rich and pleasant, and the people called their souls dry while eating food that tasted of oil. God gave it, and the people still gathered and prepared it every day, which is the shape of the daily bread Jesus teaches us to ask for (Matthew 6:11).

Verse 9 tells how it came. “The dew fell upon the camp in the night”, and the manna fell with it. Ṭal is dew, the moisture that covers the plants at night, and in a dry land dew is a blessing, as in Isaac’s words, “God give thee of the dew of heaven”. The verb yârad, to go or come down, stands under both “fell”s in the verse, for the dew and for the manna. While the people slept, God set their food on the ground around their tents, and they gathered it in the morning before the heat of the sun melted it (Exodus 16:21). The full account of the manna’s rules and its Sabbath is in Exodus 16:4–35.

Scripture gives the reason for this daily gift. Moses later told Israel that God fed them with manna to teach them that “man doth not live by bread only”, but by every word from the mouth of the LORD (Deuteronomy 8:3). The psalm that retells this story calls the manna angels’ food and the corn of heaven, and in Nehemiah’s day the Levites thanked God that he kept giving the manna and sustained Israel all through the wilderness (Nehemiah 9:20–21).

Did Israel eat manna for all forty years?

Israel ate the manna until the day they ate the food of the promised land. “And the children of Israel did eat manna forty years, until they came to a land inhabited; they did eat manna, until they came unto the borders of the land of Canaan” (Exodus 16:35). It stopped at Gilgal, after they had crossed the Jordan and eaten the produce of the land (Joshua 5:10–12). God went on giving it through this complaint and through every complaint after it.

The weeping at every tent door and the anger of the LORD

Verse 10 shows how far the craving had spread. Moses “heard the people weep throughout their families, every man in the door of his tent”. The weeping (bâkâh again) went on in every household, out in the open at the tent door, where family life was lived and seen by the neighbours.

“And the anger of the LORD was kindled greatly.” Chârâh means to glow or grow warm, and so to blaze up, and it is the same verb Scripture uses for human anger. “Greatly” is mᵉʼôd, vehemence. “Moses also was displeased” reads in Hebrew that it was evil in the eyes of Moses: the verb râʻaʻ, to be bad, to displease or to be sad, with ʻayin, eye. The LORD and Moses both see the weeping as evil. At Taberah Moses prayed for the people, and here his own distress comes first, and he turns to God with a complaint of his own.

Why was the LORD so angry over food?

The people’s weeping was aimed at the LORD himself and all he had done for them. He had brought them out of Egypt on the night of the Passover (Exodus 12), opened the sea for them (Exodus 14), and fed them every day since. To weep for Egypt’s food was to call slavery better than his care, and to treat his rescue and his gift with contempt. The rest of Numbers 11 tells the outcome: the LORD sent quail in abundance, and while the meat was still between their teeth he struck the people with a very great plague.

Paul writes that these things happened as examples for us, so that we would keep from lusting after evil things as they did, and from murmuring as they murmured (1 Corinthians 10:5–10).

Moses brings the burden to the LORD

Moses takes the weight of verse 10 straight to God. He is the man with whom the LORD spoke face to face (Exodus 33:11), and he speaks to him here with the same directness.

“Wherefore hast thou afflicted thy servant?” The verb for “afflicted” is râʻaʻ, the verb behind “displeased” in verse 10. What was evil in Moses’ eyes he now lays before the LORD as harm done to his servant. It is the cry of a man in pain who knows that his calling came from God, and so he brings the pain to God as well. “And wherefore have I not found favour in thy sight”: chên is graciousness, favour or kindness, and Moses feels as though the favour that carried him this far had gone. “That thou layest the burden of all this people upon me”: massâʼ is a burden, a load carried on the back, and it can also mean tribute, or an utterance a prophet carries. The people’s needs, their complaints and their sin had become a load Moses carried every day.

In verse 12 he presses the point with a picture from family life. “Have I conceived all this people? have I begotten them?” Hârâh means to be or become pregnant, to conceive, and yâlad to bear young, or to beget. “Carry them in thy bosom, as a nursing father beareth the sucking child.” The verb behind both “carry” and “beareth” is nâsâʼ, to lift or carry, the verb that returns as “bear” in verse 14. “Nursing father” is ʼâman, which in this use means to support, nourish or foster, as a nurse or foster-parent does. A baby at the breast needs everything and gives nothing back, and that is how the people felt to Moses. “Unto the land which thou swarest unto their fathers” names the oath to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and so reminds the LORD that the end of the journey rests on his own promise.

Moses’ questions point to the true parent of this people. The picture he uses for himself is the very one Scripture uses for God. Moses later told Israel that the LORD bore them through the wilderness as a man bears his son (Deuteronomy 1:31), Isaiah pictures the LORD as a shepherd who gathers his lambs and carries them (Isaiah 40:11), and a psalm likens the LORD’s compassion to a father’s pity for his children (Psalm 103:13). Moses is right that the work is beyond him, and right about who must carry it.

Verse 13 turns to the meat itself. “Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people?” ʼAyin means “where?”, and with a prefix “whence”, from where. Moses has nowhere to turn for meat for so great a company. “Flesh” is bâsâr, the word of the people’s question in verse 4, and “give” stands twice in the verse, once for what Moses lacks and once in the people’s demand: “Give us flesh, that we may eat.” They weep to Moses for something only God could supply, and God does supply all his people’s need (Philippians 4:19).

In verse 14 Moses says it plainly: “I am not able to bear all this people alone, because it is too heavy for me.” Bad, “alone”, comes from a word for separation, and means apart or by oneself. Kâbêd means heavy, and it is also used of a group that is large and numerous, and figuratively of what is severe or difficult. So the weight Moses feels is the sheer size of the people and the hardness of the task together. Earlier, on Jethro’s advice, Moses had shared the judging of the people with other men (Exodus 18:13–26), and now the LORD would give him helpers of another kind. The rebellions to come would test him again, from the people’s murmuring after the spies’ report (Numbers 14:2) to Korah’s challenge (Numbers 16:1–3), and Moses himself would fail to honour the LORD at Meribah (Numbers 20:12).

Moses’ confession is the honest word of a servant who knows his limit. Paul learned that God’s strength is made perfect in weakness (2 Corinthians 12:9–10), and he tells the church to bear one another’s burdens (Galatians 6:2), which is what the LORD was about to arrange for Moses.

Moses asks the LORD to kill him

Verse 15 is the end of Moses’ prayer. “And if thou deal thus with me”: ʻâsâh is the broad word to do or make, so Moses means “if this is how things are to go with me”. “Kill me, I pray thee, out of hand”: the verb hârag, to kill, stands under both “kill” and “out of hand”, because the Hebrew repeats it, and the KJV gives the force of that repetition as “out of hand”, at once. “If I have found favour in thy sight” takes up the chên of verse 11: if the LORD still favours him, the kindest thing would be to end his life now. “And let me not see my wretchedness”: raʻ means bad or evil, adversity, affliction or calamity. Moses asks to be spared the sight of his own misery, and of whatever ruin he fears is coming on him and on the people.

Was Moses wrong to pray this way?

The LORD answered this prayer with help. He told Moses to gather seventy of the elders of Israel, and said he would take of the spirit that was upon Moses and put it upon them, so that they would bear the burden of the people with him (Numbers 11:16–17). Moses asked for death, and God gave him company in the work.

Moses’ prayer stands in Scripture beside others like it. Elijah asked the LORD to take his life (1 Kings 19:4), Job wished he had died at birth (Job 3:11), and Jeremiah cursed the day he was born (Jeremiah 20:14–18). The psalmist asks his own soul why it is cast down and tells it to hope in God (Psalm 42:5). Each of them was in deep distress, and each brought it to God. Moses’ words came from despair, and he spoke them to the One who could answer.

Christ, the bread from heaven and the bearer of burdens

The manna points beyond itself, and Jesus takes it up in John 6. When the crowd reminded him that their fathers ate manna in the desert, he answered that his Father gives the true bread from heaven, and said, “I am the bread of life” (John 6:31–35). The fathers ate manna in the wilderness and died, and whoever eats of the living bread that came down from heaven will live for ever (John 6:49–51). He promised eternal life and resurrection at the last day to whoever eats his flesh and drinks his blood (John 6:54), and he said that his words are spirit and life (John 6:63). Many of his disciples found that saying hard and went back (John 6:60–66), tiring of him as Israel tired of the manna. He came that we might have life more abundantly (John 10:10), and he sets us free from the law of sin and death (Romans 8:2–4), a bondage far worse than Egypt’s.

Moses could not carry the people, and Christ carried their sin. He is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29), the servant Isaiah saw bearing our griefs and the iniquity of us all (Isaiah 53:4–6). In Gethsemane his agony was so great that his sweat fell like drops of blood (Luke 22:44), and he went on to endure the cross for the joy set before him (Hebrews 12:2). Moses felt he had lost God’s favour, and Jesus could say that he always did what pleased the Father (John 8:29). God showed his love in that Christ died for us while we were still sinners (Romans 5:8), and Christ bore the anger our sin deserved.

Moses asked whether he had begotten this people. Christ gives all who receive him the right to become children of God, born of God (John 1:12–13), and the promise sworn to the fathers was made to Abraham’s seed, which is Christ (Galatians 3:16). He is the good shepherd who lays down his life for the sheep (John 10:11). As our high priest he is touched with the feeling of our weakness (Hebrews 4:15), and he lives for ever to intercede for us (Hebrews 7:25). He calls all who labour and are heavy laden to come to him for rest, and his burden is light (Matthew 11:28–30).

The God who feeds and carries his people

Through all this weeping the manna kept falling with the dew, every night, for forty years. God’s faithfulness outlasted the people’s complaint. The same God heard the despair of a tired servant and answered it with help, putting his Spirit on others so that Moses would carry the load with them. Moses’ prayer shows that a servant of God may speak to him with full honesty when the burden is too heavy, and Peter gives the same invitation to every believer, to cast all our care on God because he cares for us (1 Peter 5:7). The bread God gives us now is his Son, and the One who carries us is the Shepherd who carried our sins.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Numbers 11:4–15. He set out his notes in a three-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 12 verses
Passage under commentNumbers 11:4–15
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

These verses represent things sadly unhinged and out of order in Israel, both the people and the prince uneasy.

I.Here is the people fretting, and speaking against God himself (as it is interpreted, Psalm 78:19), notwithstanding his glorious appearances both to them and for them. Observe,

1.Who were the criminals.

(1.)The mixed multitude began, they fell a lusting, Numbers 11:4. The rabble that came with them out of Egypt, expecting only the land of promise, but not a state of probation in the way to it. They were hangers on, who took hold of the skirts of the Jews, and would go with them only because they knew not how to live at home, and were disposed to seek their fortunes (as we say) abroad. These were the scabbed sheep that infected the flock, the leaven that leavened the whole lump. Note, A few factious, discontented, ill-natured people, may do a great deal of mischief in the best societies, if great care be not taken to discountenance them. Such as these are an untoward generation, from which it is our wisdom to save ourselves, Acts 2:40.

(2.)Even the children of Israel took the infection, as we are informed, Numbers 11:4. The holy seed joined themselves to the people of these abominations. The mixed multitude here spoken of were not numbered with the children of Israel, but were set aside as a people God made no account of; and yet the children of Israel, forgetting their own character and distinction, herded themselves with them and learned their way, as if the scum and outcasts of the camp were to be the privy-counsellors of it. The children of Israel, a people near to God and highly privileged, yet drawn into rebellion against him! O how little honour has God in the world, when even the people which he formed for himself, to show forth his praise, were so much a dishonour to him! Therefore let none think that their external professions and privileges will be their security either against Satan's temptations to sin or God's judgments for sin. See 1 Corinthians 10:1, 1 Corinthians 10:2, 1 Corinthians 10:12.

2.What was the crime: they lusted and murmured. Though they had been lately corrected for this sin, and many of them overthrown for it, as God overthrew Sodom and Gomorrah, and the smell of the fire was still in their nostrils, yet they returned to it. See Proverbs 27:22.

(1.)They magnified the plenty and dainties they had had in Egypt (Numbers 11:5), as if God had done them a great deal of wrong in taking them thence. While they were in Egypt they sighed by reason of their burdens, for their lives were made bitter to them with hard bondage; and yet now they talk of Egypt as if they had all lived like princes there, when this serves as a colour for their present discontent. But with what face can they talk of eating fish in Egypt freely, or for nought, as if it cost them nothing, when they paid so dearly for it with their hard service? They remember the cucumbers, and the melons, and the leeks, and the onions, and the garlick (precious stuff indeed to be fond of!), but they do not remember the brick-kilns and the task-masters, the voice of the oppressor and the smart of the whip. No, these are forgotten by these ungrateful people.

(2.)They were sick of the good provision God had made for them, Numbers 11:6. It was bread from heaven, angels' food. To show how unreasonable their complaint was, it is here described, Numbers 11:7-9. It was good for food, and pleasant to the eye, every grain like an orient pearl; it was wholesome food and nourishing; it was not to be called dry bread, for it tasted like fresh oil; it was agreeable (the Jews say, Wisd. 16:20) to every man's palate, and tasted as he would have it; and, though it was still the same, yet, by the different ways of dressing it, it yielded them a grateful variety; it cost them no money, nor care, for it fell in the night, while they slept; and the labour of gathering it was not worth speaking of; they lived upon free quarter, and yet could talk of Egypt's cheapness and the fish they ate there freely. Nay, which was much more valuable than all this, the manna came from the immediate power and bounty of God, not from common providence, but from special favour. It was, as God's compassion, new every morning, always fresh, not as their food who live on shipboard. While they lived on manna, they seemed to be exempted from the curse which sin has brought on man, that in the sweat of his face should he eat bread. And yet they speak of manna with such scorn, as if it were not good enough to be meat for swine: Our soul is dried away. They speak as if God dealt hardly with them in allowing them no better food. At first they admired it (Exodus 16:15): What is this? "What a curious precious thing is this!" But now they despised it. Note, Peevish discontented minds will find fault with that which has no fault in it but that it is too good for them. It is very provoking to God to undervalue his favours, and to put a but upon our common mercies. Nothing but manna! Those that might be very happy often make themselves very miserable by their discontents.

(3.)They could not be satisfied unless they had flesh to eat. They brought flocks and herds with them in great abundance out of Egypt; but either they were covetous, and could not find in their hearts to kill them, lest they should lessen their flocks (they must have flesh as cheap as they had bread, or they would not be pleased), or else they were curious, beef and mutton would not please them; they must have something more nice and delicate, like the fish they did eat in Egypt. Food would not serve; they must be feasted. They had feasted with God upon the peace-offerings which they had their share of; but it seems God did not keep a table good enough for them, they must have daintier bits than any that came to his altar. Note, It is an evidence of the dominion of the carnal mind when we are solicitous to have all the delights and satisfactions of sense wound up to the height of pleasurableness. Be not desirous of dainties, Proverbs 23:1-3. If God gives us food convenient, we ought to be thankful, though we do not eat the fat and drink the sweet.

(4.)They distrusted the power and goodness of God as insufficient for their supply: Who will give us flesh to eat? taking it for granted that God could not. Thus this question is commented upon, Psalm 78:19, Psalm 78:20, Can he provide flesh also? though he had given them flesh with their bread once, when he saw fit (Exodus 16:13), and they might have expected that he would do it again, and in mercy, if, instead of murmuring, they had prayed. Note, It is an offence to God to let our desires go beyond our faith.

(5.)They were eager and importunate in their desires; they lusted a lust, so the word is, lusted greatly and greedily, till they wept again for vexation. So childish were the children of Israel, and so humoursome, that they cried because they had not what they would have and when they would have it. They did not offer up this desire to God, but would rather be beholden to any one else than to him. We should not indulge ourselves in any desire which we cannot in faith turn into prayer, as we cannot when we ask meat for our lust, Psalm 78:18. For this sin the anger of the Lord was kindled greatly against them, which is written for our admonition, that we should not lust after evil things as they lusted, 1 Corinthians 10:6.

(6.)Flesh is good food, and may lawfully be eaten; yet they are said to lust after evil things. What is lawful of itself becomes evil to us when it is what God does not allot to us and yet we eagerly desire it.

II.Moses himself, though so meek and good a man, is uneasy upon this occasion: Moses also was displeased. Now,

1.It must be confessed that the provocation was very great. These murmurings of theirs reflected great dishonour upon God, and Moses laid to heart the reproaches cast on himself; they knew that he did his utmost for their good, and that he neither did nor could do any thing without a divine appointment; and yet to be thus continually teased and clamoured against by an unreasonable ungrateful people would break in upon the temper even of Moses himself. God considered this, and therefore we do not find that he chided him for his uneasiness.

2.Yet Moses expressed himself otherwise than became him upon this provocation, and came short of his duty both to God and Israel in these expostulations.

(1.)He undervalues the honour God had put upon him, in making him the illustrious minister of his power and grace, in the deliverance and guidance of that peculiar people, which might have been sufficient to balance the burden.

(2.)He complains too much of a sensible grievance, and lays too near his heart a little noise and fatigue. If he could not bear the toil of government, which was but running with the footman, how would he bear the terrors of war, which was contending with horses? He might easily have furnished himself with considerations enough to enable him to slight their clamours, and make nothing of them.

(3.)He magnifies his own performances, that all the burden of the people lay upon him; whereas God himself did in effect ease him of all the burden. Moses needed not to be in care to provide quarters for them, or victuals; God did all. And, if any difficult case happened, he needed not to be in any perplexity, while he had the oracle to consult, and in it the divine wisdom to direct him, the divine authority to back him and bear him out, and almighty power itself to dispense rewards and punishments.

(4.)He is not so sensible as he ought to be of the obligation he lay under, by virtue of the divine commission and command, to do the utmost he could for his people, when he suggests that because they were not the children of his body therefore he was not concerned to take a fatherly care of them, though God himself, who might employ him as he pleased, had appointed him to be a father to them.

(5.)He takes too much to himself when he asks, Whence should I have flesh to give them (Numbers 11:13), as if he were the housekeeper, and not God. Moses gave them not the bread, John 6:32. Nor was it expected that he should give them the flesh, but as an instrument in God's hand; and if he meant, "Whence should God have it for them?" he too much limited the power of the Holy One of Israel.

(6.)He speaks distrustfully of the divine grace when he despairs of being able to bear all this people, Numbers 11:14. Had the work been much less, he could not have gone through it in his own strength; but had it been much greater, through God strengthening him, he might have done it.

(7.)It was worst of all passionately to wish for death, and desire to be killed out of hand, because just at this time his life was made a little uneasy to him, Numbers 11:15. Is this Moses? Is this the meekest of all the men on the earth? The best have their infirmities, and fail sometimes in the exercise of that grace for which they are most eminent. But God graciously overlooked Moses's passion at this time, and therefore we must not be severe in our animadversions upon it, but pray, Lord, lead us not into temptation.

Historical interpretation

Fourteen Centuries of Reception

3 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

3 quotes · AD 430–1781
Post-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
400500600700800900100011001200130014001500160017001800

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceConfessions 10.31.46
The people in the desert deserved to be reprimanded, not because they desired meat but because they murmured against the Lord as a result of this desire for meat.
d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceTRACTATE ON THE GOSPEL OF JOHN 73.2
Do we not see that the Israelites got to their own hurt what their guilty lusting craved? For while manna was raining down on them from heaven, they desired to have meat to eat. They disdained what they had, and they shamelessly sought what they had not, as if it were not better for them to have asked not that their unbecoming desires be gratified with food that was wanting, but that their own dislike be removed, and that they be made to receive rightly the food that was provided. For when evil becomes our delight and good the opposite, we ought to entreat God to win us back to the love of the good rather than to grant us the evil.
d. AD 1781Richard ChallonerMedieval
A mixt multitude: These were people that came with them out of Egypt, who were not of the race of Israel; who, by their murmuring, drew also the children of Israel to murmur: this should teach us the danger of associating ourselves with the children of Egypt, that is, with the lovers and admirers of this wicked world.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Numbers 11:4 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8