Skip to content
Share this page

Psalm 78:18

“Israel’s Rebellion and Temptation”Psalm 78:17–33

King James Version
And they tempted God in their heart by asking meat for their lust.

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
And they tempted H5254 God H410 in their heart H3824 by asking H7592 meat H400 for their lust H5315.

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
They willfully tested God by demanding the food they craved.

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
And they tempted God in their heart By asking food according to their desire.

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
They tempted God in their heart by asking food according to their desire.

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
And tempted God in their heartes in requiring meate for their lust.

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
And they try God in their heart, To ask food for their lust.

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
6 Hebrew words
  1. וַיְנַסּוּvay·na·suand they put to [the] testH5254Conj-w ¦ V-Piel-ConsecImperf-3mpVerb Piel Consecutive Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculineוַandיְנַסּוּthey put to [the] test
  2. אֵל'elGodH410N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
  3. בִּלְבָבָםbil·va·Vamin their heartH3824Prep-b ¦ N-msc ¦ 3mpNoun Singular Masculine Construct with suffixבִּinלְבָבָheartםtheir
  4. לִשְׁאָלlish·'olby requestingH7592Prep-l ¦ V-Qal-InfVerb Qal Infinitive Constructלִbyשְׁאָלrequesting
  5. אֹכֶל'O·khelfoodH400N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
  6. לְנַפְשָׁםle·naf·Shamfor their selvesH5315Prep-l ¦ N-fsc ¦ 3mpNoun Singular Feminine Construct with suffixלְforנַפְשָׁselvesםtheir
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Hebrew Masoretic text, the same tradition the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “the LORD” where the word-by-word meaning reads “Yahweh”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Hebrew. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation differences
Translation
Details
In the KJVVerse 15,132 of 31,102 · 48.7%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

In their hearts the people put God to the test, demanding the food their appetite wanted while he was already feeding them every day.

“And they tempted God in their heart”

“God” here is ʼêl, the Mighty One, the God whose strength they put on trial.

“by asking meat”

“Asking” is a verb that means to request and, by extension, to demand. Their request was a demand.

“for their lust.”

Food for appetite’s sake, asked while the manna was falling every morning.

Passage studyPsalm 78:17–33

Fed from Heaven, Yet They Believed Not

Summary

Psalm 78 is a maskil of Asaph, a psalm written to teach. It tells Israel’s story so that each new generation will know the works of God and put their trust in him (Psalm 78:1–8). Just before this passage it recalls the parting of the sea (Exodus 14) and the water God brought out of the rock (Psalm 78:12–16). Verses 17 to 33 tell what Israel did next.

They sinned yet more. They tested God by demanding the meat their appetite wanted, and they asked aloud, “Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?” The LORD heard, and his anger burned, because they “believed not in God, and trusted not in his salvation”. Yet he had already opened the doors of heaven and rained manna on them, and now he drove in the quail on the wind until birds lay all around their tents. They ate and were filled. While the meat was still in their mouths, his wrath struck down the strongest of their young men. “For all this they sinned still”, and that generation’s days ran out in vanity and trouble.

These verses show us a God who gives generously, who hears every word his people say about him, and who takes unbelief seriously. They also hold out the psalm’s lesson for every generation after: God’s gifts are given to lead us to trust the Giver.

Israel Sinned Yet More Against the Most High

Verse 17 follows straight on from the rivers in the desert: “And they sinned yet more against him by provoking the most High in the wilderness.” The verb for sinning, châṭâʼ, properly means to miss, and from that it became the common word for sin. “Yet more” is yâçaph, to add or to go on doing a thing. Israel kept adding to sins already committed, and each fresh gift from God was met with fresh complaint. The same verb for sinning returns in verse 32, “For all this they sinned still”, so the passage opens and closes on it.

“Provoking” is mârâh. Strong’s gives its root sense as to be bitter or unpleasant, and its figurative use, the one here, is to rebel or disobey. Their rebellion was against ʻelyôwn, a word meaning high or upper that serves as a title of God, the Most High. The one they defied stands above all things, and that is what gives the sin its weight. The wilderness of this verse is a parched, barren land. God had just made water flow there, and there they rebelled.

Moses later told Israel to remember how they had provoked the LORD in the wilderness (Deuteronomy 9:7). A later psalm warns against hardening the heart as Israel did there (Psalm 95:8), and Hebrews takes up that warning for believers, because the wilderness generation fell through unbelief (Hebrews 3:7–19).

They Tested God in Their Heart

Verse 18 shows where the sin began: “And they tempted God in their heart by asking meat for their lust.” To tempt is nâçâh, to test, try or prove. The testing started in the heart, lêbâb, the inner person, where thought, feeling and will are found. Before they said a word, they had already decided to make God prove himself.

“Meat” here is ʼôkel, the ordinary word for food. “For their lust” stands for nephesh, a word for a breathing creature, for life and the self, which can also mean appetite. In this verse it is the appetite, and what surrounds it shows a greedy one. God was already feeding them every day with manna (Exodus 16), and they asked for food to please their craving. Numbers 11 tells the story. The mixed multitude among the people began to crave, and soon all Israel was weeping for the fish, cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions and garlic they had eaten in Egypt (Numbers 11:4–6).

What Does It Mean to Tempt God?

To tempt God is to put him on trial, demanding that he prove his power or his goodness on our terms after he has already shown both. God remains exactly who he is under such a test. The sin lies in the distrust, which treats all his past care as an open question. The law forbade Israel to put the LORD their God to the test (Deuteronomy 6:16). Paul names the wilderness as a warning to us, written to the intent that we “should not lust after evil things, as they also lusted” (1 Corinthians 10:6), and James traces how desire, once given room, brings forth sin, and sin brings forth death (James 1:14–15).

Can God Furnish a Table in the Wilderness?

Verse 19 records the people’s unbelief spoken aloud: “Yea, they spake against God; they said, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?” The verb dâbar is the everyday word for speaking. Their speech was sin because of what it said, and what it said was against God. “Furnish” is ʻârak, to set in a row, arrange or put in order, the way a meal is set out on a table. “Wilderness” is midbâr, which Strong’s traces to an open pasture where cattle are driven, and so a desert. Verse 17 shares the English word, with a Hebrew word of its own. The question asked whether God was able to lay out a meal in a land without fields, and it was a challenge thrown at him in scorn.

Verse 20 shows how strange the challenge was, because in it they admit what God had just done: “Behold, he smote the rock, that the waters gushed out, and the streams overflowed”. “Smote” is nâkâh, to strike, and “gushed out” is zûwb, to flow freely, as water does. This is the rock at Rephidim, which Moses struck at God’s command (Exodus 17:1–7). Water came from a rock again later at Meribah (Numbers 20:1–13), but the psalm’s earlier lines point to the first. Then comes the doubt: “can he give bread also? can he provide flesh for his people?” “Bread” is lechem, food and especially bread. “Provide” is kûwn, which properly means to stand upright, and so to set up, make ready or provide.

Their reasoning ran backward. Having watched water pour from a rock, they doubted whether the same God could give bread and meat. They had complained in this way from the start, over water (Exodus 15:24) and over food, when they longed for the flesh pots of Egypt (Exodus 16:2–3). Hebrews calls it “an evil heart of unbelief” (Hebrews 3:12). Moses told Israel that God led them through the wilderness and fed them with manna to teach them that “man doth not live by bread only” (Deuteronomy 8:2–3).

Is It Wrong to Ask God for Food?

Asking God for what we need is what Jesus taught his disciples to do, in the prayer for “daily bread” (Matthew 6:11), and Paul tells us to make our requests known “in every thing by prayer” (Philippians 4:6). Israel’s sin lay in the spirit of their asking. They asked in doubt, as a demand that God prove himself, while he was feeding them every morning. Jesus tells us that the Father who feeds the birds of the air knows what we need (Matthew 6:25–34), and Paul assures the church that “my God shall supply all your need” (Philippians 4:19). Asking in faith honours God, and asking in order to test him is the sin of this psalm.

The LORD Heard, and Unbelief Was the Root

“Therefore the LORD heard this, and was wroth”. Every word spoken against him in the camp reached him, because he sees and hears all that his people do (Proverbs 15:3). “Was wroth” is ʻâbar, a verb whose common meaning is to cross over, used here of God’s fury. “So a fire was kindled against Jacob”: nâsaq means to catch fire or kindle. Fire pictures God’s anger, and at Taberah that fire was real, when fire from the LORD burned the outskirts of the camp because the people complained (Numbers 11:1–3).

“And anger also came up against Israel”: the word for anger, ʼaph, properly means the nose or nostril, and from the hard breathing of strong feeling it came to mean anger. Jacob and Israel are the two names of the one people, so the second line repeats the first and strengthens it. The same Hebrew words for “anger” and “came up” return in verse 31, “The wrath of God came upon them”, where the anger that rose here falls on the camp.

Verse 22 gives the reason: “Because they believed not in God, and trusted not in his salvation”. “Believed” is ʼâman, from the root that gives us “Amen”. In its simplest form the verb means to support or nourish, and here it means to believe, to hold God reliable. “Trusted” is bâṭach, which Strong’s explains as to flee for refuge, and so to trust and feel secure. “Salvation” is yᵉshûwʻâh, deliverance, help or victory. They had been brought out of Egypt and were fed every day in the desert, and still they held back from resting on the God who saved them. The name of Jesus, Yeshua, comes from the same root and means that the LORD saves.

Scripture holds to this all the way through. Faith is needed to please God (Hebrews 11:6), those who stand, stand by faith (Romans 11:20), and God’s wrath is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness (Romans 1:18).

How Does God’s Anger Fit with His Love?

God’s anger in these verses is the holy displeasure of a faithful God (Deuteronomy 7:9) toward a people who doubted him after all he had done. It was slow in coming. He gave them water and bread again and again before it fell, and a few verses later the psalm speaks of his compassion toward them (Psalm 78:38–39). His wrath and his mercy belong to the same holy God, and his mercy shows in how long he held his anger back.

Manna, the Corn of Heaven

Verse 23 begins with “Though”, which ties it to the unbelief of verse 22. They doubted, “Though he had commanded the clouds from above, and opened the doors of heaven”. “Commanded” is tsâvâh, to give a charge or an order, and the clouds did what God told them. “Opened” is pâthach, to open wide, and “heaven” is shâmayim, the sky above. The doors of heaven picture God’s storehouse thrown open, like the windows of heaven opened at the Flood (Genesis 7:11) and in God’s promise of blessing through Malachi (Malachi 3:10).

Verse 24 says what came through those doors: “And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.” “Rained down” is mâṭar, to rain. “Manna” is mân, a name taken from the question the people asked when they first saw it, mān hū, “What is it?” (Exodus 16:15). “Corn” is dâgân, grain, the staple food of a farming people, and here it is grain that fell from the sky. “Given” is nâthan, to give.

God had promised to rain bread from heaven and told the people to gather it day by day (Exodus 16:4–5). It came every morning except the Sabbath and spoiled if it was kept over, so Israel lived from God’s hand one day at a time. Numbers describes it (Numbers 11:7–9), and Nehemiah’s prayer remembers the bread from heaven (Nehemiah 9:15). It lasted the whole forty years (Exodus 16:35), until the day after Israel ate the produce of Canaan (Joshua 5:12).

What Is Angels’ Food?

Verse 25 says, “Man did eat angels’ food: he sent them meat to the full.” Angels’ food is the manna, called the bread of the mighty ones because it came from God’s heaven and was fit for the exalted beings who serve him. “Man” is ʼîysh, a man as an individual, each one of them. “Angels’” is ʼabbîyr, the mighty or strong one, which the KJV renders “angels”. “Food” is lechem, the same word as “bread” in verse 20. They had asked, “can he give bread also?”, and God gave mortal men the bread of the mighty. The phrase honours where the manna came from and how fine it was, and it makes no claim about what angels eat.

“Meat” in this verse is tsêydâh, food or provision, a different word from the “meat” of verse 18. It most naturally continues the manna, and some take it to include the quail that follow. “To the full” is sôbaʻ, satisfaction or fullness. God gave in abundance, and every one of them had enough.

Quail on the East Wind and the South Wind

Verses 26 to 28 turn from the bread to the meat. “He caused an east wind to blow in the heaven: and by his power he brought in the south wind.” “Caused to blow” is nâçaʻ, a verb that properly means to pull up tent pins and set out on a journey, and here God sets the wind on its way. The east wind, qâdîym, is named from the front, the east, and in Scripture it is often a strong wind. It brought the locusts on Egypt (Exodus 10:13) and blasted the ears of grain in Pharaoh’s dream (Genesis 41:6). “By his power” is ʻôz, strength or might. The south wind is têymân, the south, named as lying on the right hand of someone facing east. Quail cross the Sinai on their migrations, and God turned the winds to bring them down on the camp (Numbers 11:31–32).

The winds belong to him. The LORD has his way in the whirlwind and the storm (Nahum 1:3), he commands the stormy wind (Psalm 107:25), and he directs the south wind (Job 37:17). When Jesus rebuked the winds and the sea, his disciples marvelled that even these obeyed him (Matthew 8:26–27).

Verse 27 says, “He rained flesh also upon them as dust, and feathered fowls like as the sand of the sea”. “Rained” is māṭar, the same verb used of the manna in verse 24, so the meat came down from the sky as the bread had. “Flesh” is the same word as in verse 20, where they asked, “can he provide flesh for his people?” This is his answer. The comparisons are dust, ‘āpār, and the sand, chôwl, of the sea, yâm, pictures Scripture uses for a number past counting. Exodus records quail along with the first manna (Exodus 16:13), and Numbers tells the fuller story of the quail that came with judgment.

Verse 28 says, “And he let it fall in the midst of their camp, round about their habitations.” “Let it fall” is nâphal, to fall, in a form that means God made it fall. The camp is machăneh, the place where people live in tents for a time, and “habitations” is mishkân, a dwelling, which can be a tent or a hut. God laid the meat at every tent door.

Kibroth-hattaavah: Given What They Craved

“So they did eat, and were well filled: for he gave them their own desire”. “Eat” is ʼâkal, and “filled” is sâbaʻ, to be filled to satisfaction, with “well” adding that they were filled to the utmost. “Desire” is taʼăvâh, a longing or craving. It is the same word as “lust” in verse 30, and it gave its name to the place where these things happened, Kibroth-hattaavah, the graves of craving (Numbers 11:33–34). God gave them what they had set their hearts on, and it became their judgment. Paul speaks of God giving people up to the lusts of their own hearts in the same way (Romans 1:24–28).

Verse 30 opens, “They were not estranged from their lust.” “Estranged” is zûwr, to turn aside or become a stranger. Their craving stayed with them even as they ate, because its root was in their hearts, and a full stomach left it untouched. “But while their meat was yet in their mouths”: “meat” is ʼôkel, the same word as in verse 18, the very food they had demanded. Numbers tells it in almost the same words: “while the flesh was yet between their teeth, ere it was chewed, the wrath of the LORD was kindled against the people, and the LORD smote the people with a very great plague” (Numbers 11:33).

Verse 31 finishes the sentence: “The wrath of God came upon them, and slew the fattest of them, and smote down the chosen men of Israel.” “Wrath” is ʼaph, the anger that came up in verse 21. “The fattest” is mashmân, fatness or richness, used here of the stoutest and strongest men. “The chosen men” is bâchûwr, a young man, a word Strong’s derives from a form meaning “selected”. The plague fell on the strong and on the young men in their prime, the ones with the most strength to rely on. Paul lists these things among the examples written for our warning (1 Corinthians 10:5–11).

Why Would God Give What Would Harm Them?

God gave them their desire as a judgment. They had preferred meat to trusting him, and he let them have it in full, so that the emptiness of the craving showed itself in the very place they had chosen. The gift brought their sin into the open and made its end plain. Desire itself is part of how God made us, and Scripture speaks of the heart that delights in the LORD receiving its desires from him (Psalm 37:4). The craving in this psalm grew from discontent with God’s daily bread and a demand that he serve their appetite.

For All This They Sinned Still

Verse 32 sums up: “For all this they sinned still, and believed not for his wondrous works.” Both verbs are back. “Sinned” is châṭâʼ, as in verse 17, and “believed” is ʼâman, as in verse 22. “All this” is everything the passage has told: the rock, the manna, the quail and the judgment. “Wondrous works” is pâlâʼ, a word for what is set apart as great and wonderful, deeds beyond anyone but God. Faith is a matter of the heart, and the wonders left their hearts unchanged. At Kadesh the LORD asked Moses how long this people would despise him (Numbers 14:11), and Moses warned Israel to beware of forgetting the LORD (Deuteronomy 6:12). John records the same of Jesus’ miracles, “yet they believed not on him” (John 12:37).

Verse 33 gives the end: “Therefore their days did he consume in vanity, and their years in trouble.” “Consume” is kâlâh, to end, finish or bring to completion. “Vanity” is hebel, whose base sense is breath or vapour and which most often means futility. “Trouble” is behâlâh, panic, terror or sudden ruin. That generation refused to enter the land when the spies came back from Canaan (Numbers 13–14), and they even spoke of going back to Egypt (Numbers 14:1–4). They wandered until they died in the wilderness, all except Caleb and Joshua. Their forty years passed like a breath and were spent in fear. The Preacher’s cry, “all is vanity” (Ecclesiastes 1:2), uses the same word. The wilderness was meant to test and train them (Deuteronomy 8:2–3), and Hebrews says that they could not enter because of unbelief (Hebrews 3:17–19).

Christ, the True Bread from Heaven

Where Israel failed, Jesus stood. He was led into the wilderness and tempted there for forty days, and he answered the tempter, “Man shall not live by bread alone” (Matthew 4:1–11). Israel tested God in the wilderness, and Jesus trusted his Father there. He answered the question of verse 19 in a desert place, where he fed thousands (Matthew 14:13–21).

Jesus spoke at length about the manna in John 6. John records the manna as “bread from heaven” (John 6:31), and Jesus said that it is his Father who gives the true bread from heaven (John 6:32–33). Then he said, “I am the bread of life” (John 6:35). The fathers ate manna in the wilderness and died (John 6:49), and he is the living bread, who gives his flesh for the life of the world (John 6:51). He spoke of eating his flesh and drinking his blood as the way to life (John 6:53–56), and he told the crowd to labour for the food that endures to everlasting life (John 6:27). The Lord’s Supper keeps this before the church, in the bread that is his body broken for us (1 Corinthians 11:24). The people of verse 20 asked whether God could give bread and flesh, and in Christ he gives both, for ever.

The rock of verse 20 points to him as well. Paul says that the spiritual Rock that went with Israel was Christ (1 Corinthians 10:4), and Jesus offers living water to the thirsty (John 4:10–14).

The anger that burned against Jacob points to the wrath that all sin deserves. Jesus is “the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world” (John 1:29). God made him to be sin for us (2 Corinthians 5:21), he redeemed us from the curse (Galatians 3:13), and those who trust in him are saved from wrath through him (Romans 5:9). God commends his love toward us in that Christ died for us (Romans 5:8), Christ lives for ever to intercede for his people (Hebrews 7:25), and by faith we have peace with God (Romans 5:1).

Israel “believed not” and “trusted not in his salvation”. Salvation now comes by grace through faith (Ephesians 2:8–9) to all who confess Jesus as Lord and believe in their hearts (Romans 10:9–10), because God so loved the world that he gave his Son (John 3:16). The Word became flesh and dwelt among us (John 1:14), and in him all God’s promises are yea and Amen (2 Corinthians 1:20), the Amen the wilderness generation withheld. The rest they lost through unbelief remains open to those who believe (Hebrews 4:1–11), and Jesus came that we might have life “more abundantly” (John 10:10).

A Faithful God Who Spreads the Table

These verses give us a full view of God’s goodness. He opened the doors of heaven, rained bread on people who doubted him, and laid meat at their tent doors. The scornful question “Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?” was answered every morning for forty years, and Paul says that God is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think (Ephesians 3:20).

They also show us that God hears what his people say about him and weighs the heart behind their asking. Israel was fed and still hungry, because the craving itself was never given up. Paul, who knew both plenty and want, learned to be content through Christ who strengthened him (Philippians 4:11–13). Jesus warned against covetousness (Luke 12:15), and the Spirit gives believers power to put to death the deeds of the body (Romans 8:13) and to walk free of the lusts of the flesh (Galatians 5:16).

Psalm 78 was written so that children would learn from their fathers. The God of these verses fed a doubting people in a dry land and later gave his own Son as the bread of life. His gifts of yesterday are a reason to trust him for tomorrow.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Psalm 78:9–39. He set out his notes in a four-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 31 verses
Passage under commentPsalm 78:9–39
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

In these verses,

I.The psalmist observes the late rebukes of Providence that the people of Israel had been under, which they had brought upon themselves by their dealing treacherously with God, Psalm 78:9-11. The children of Ephraim, in which tribe Shiloh was, though they were well armed and shot with bows, yet turned back in the day of battle. This seems to refer to that shameful defeat which the Philistines gave them in Eli's time, when they took the ark prisoner, 1 Samuel 4:10, 1 Samuel 4:11. Of this the psalmist here begins to speak, and, after a long digression, returns to it again, Psalm 78:61. Well might that event be thus fresh in mind in David's time, above forty years after, for the ark, which in that memorable battle was seized by the Philistines, though it was quickly brought out of captivity, was never brought out of obscurity till David fetched it from Kirjath-jearim to his own city. Observe,

1.The shameful cowardice of the children of Ephraim, that warlike tribe, so famed for valiant men, Joshua's tribe; the children of that tribe, though as well armed as ever, turned back when they came to face the enemy. Note, Weapons of war stand men in little stead without a martial spirit, and that is gone if God be gone. Sin dispirits men and takes away the heart.

2.The causes of their cowardice, which were no less shameful; and these were,

(1.)A shameful violation of God's law and their covenant with him (Psalm 78:10); they were basely treacherous and perfidious, for they kept not the covenant of God, and basely stubborn and rebellious (as they were described, Psalm 78:8), for they peremptorily refused to walk in his law, and, in effect, told him to his face they would not be ruled by him.

(2.)A shameful ingratitude to God for the favours he had bestowed upon them: They forgot his works and his wonders, his works of wonder which they ought to have admired, Psalm 78:11. Note, Our forgetfulness of God's works is at the bottom of our disobedience to his laws.

II.He takes occasion hence to consult precedents and to compare this with the case of their fathers, who were in like manner unmindful of God's mercies to them and ungrateful to their founder and great benefactor, and were therefore often brought under his displeasure. The narrative in these verses is very remarkable, for it relates a kind of struggle between God's goodness and man's badness, and mercy, at length, rejoices against judgment.

1.God did great things for his people Israel when he first incorporated them and formed them into a people: Marvellous things did he in the sight of their fathers, and not only in their sight, but in their cause, and for their benefit, so strange, so kind, that one would think they should never be forgotten. What he did for them in the land of Egypt is only just mentioned here (Psalm 78:12), but afterwards resumed, Psalm 78:43. He proceeds here to show,

(1.)How he made a lane for them through the Red Sea, and caused them, gave them courage, to pass through, though the waters stood over their heads as a heap, Psalm 78:13. See Isaiah 63:12, Isaiah 63:13, where God is said to lead them by the hand, as it were, through the deep that they should not stumble.

(2.)How he provided a guide for them through the untrodden paths of the wilderness (Psalm 78:14); he led them step by step, in the day time by a cloud, which also sheltered them from the heat, and all the night with a light of fire, which perhaps warmed the air; at least it made the darkness of night less frightful, and perhaps kept off wild beasts, Zechariah 2:5.

(3.)How he furnished their camp with fresh water in a dry and thirsty land where no water was, not by opening the bottles of heaven (that would have been a common way), but by broaching a rock (Psalm 78:15, Psalm 78:16): He clave the rocks in the wilderness, which yielded water, though they were not capable of receiving it either from the clouds above or the springs beneath. Out of the dry and hard rock he gave them drink, not distilled as out of an alembic, drop by drop, but in streams running down like rivers, and as out of the great depths. God gives abundantly, and is rich in mercy; he gives seasonably, and sometimes makes us to feel the want of mercies that we may the better know the worth of them. This water which God gave Israel out of the rock was the more valuable because it was spiritual drink. And that rock was Christ.

2.When God began thus to bless them they began to affront him (Psalm 78:17): They sinned yet more against him, more than they had done in Egypt, though there they were bad enough, Ezekiel 20:8. They bore the miseries of their servitude better than the difficulties of their deliverance, and never murmured at their taskmasters so much as they did at Moses and Aaron; as if they were delivered to do all these abominations, Jeremiah 7:10. As sin sometimes takes occasion by the commandment, so at other times it takes occasion by the deliverance, to become more exceedingly sinful. They provoked the Most High. Though he is most high, and they knew themselves an unequal match for him, yet they provoked him and even bade defiance to his justice; and this in the wilderness, where he had them at his mercy and therefore they were bound in interest to please him, and where he showed them so much mercy and therefore they were bound in gratitude to please him; yet there they said and did that which they knew would provoke him: They tempted God in their heart, Psalm 78:18. Their sin began in their heart, and thence it took its malignity. They do always err in their heart, Hebrews 3:10. Thus they tempted God, tried his patience to the utmost, whether he would bear with them or no, and, in effect, bade him do his worst. Two ways they provoked him: - (1.) By desiring, or rather demanding, that which he had not thought fit to give them: They asked meat for their lust. God had given them meat for their hunger, in the manna, wholesome pleasant food and in abundance; he had given them meat for their faith out of the heads of leviathan which he broke in pieces, Psalm 74:14. But all this would not serve; they must have meat for their lust, dainties and varieties to gratify a luxurious appetite. Nothing is more provoking to God than our quarrelling with our allotment and indulging the desires of the flesh. (2.) By distrusting his power to give them what they desired. This was tempting God indeed. They challenged him to give them flesh; and, if he did not, they would say it was because he could not, not because he did not see it fit for them (Psalm 78:19): They spoke against God. Those that set bounds to God's power speak against him. It was as injurious a reflection as could be cat upon God to say, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness? They had manna, but the did not think they had a table furnished unless they had boiled and roast, a first, a second, and a third course, as they had in Egypt, where they had both flesh and fish, and sauce too (Exodus 16:3, Numbers 11:5), dishes of meat and salvers of fruit. What an unreasonable insatiable thin is luxury! Such a mighty thing did these epicures think a table well furnished to be that they thought it was more than God himself could give them in that wilderness; whereas the beasts of the forest, and all the fowls of the mountains, are his, Psalm 50:10, Psalm 50:11. Their disbelief of God's power was so much the worse in that they did at the same time own that he had done as much as that came to (Psalm 78:20): Behold, he smote the rock, that the waters gushed out, which they and their cattle drank of. And which is easier, to furnish a table in the wilderness, which a rich man can do, or to fetch water out of a rock, which the greatest potentate on the earth cannot do? Never did unbelief, though always unreasonable, ask so absurd a question: "Can he that melted down a rock into streams of water give bread also? Or can he that has given bread provide flesh also?" Is any thing too hard for Omnipotence? When once the ordinary powers of nature are exceeded God has made bare his arm, and we must conclude that nothing is impossible with him. Be it ever so great a thing that we ask, it becomes us to own, Lord, if thou wilt, thou canst.

3.God justly resented the provocation and was much displeased with them (Psalm 78:21): The Lord heard this, and was wroth. Note, God is a witness to all our murmurings and distrusts; he hears them and is much displeased with them. A fire was kindled for this against Jacob; the fire of the Lord burnt among them, Numbers 11:1. Or it may be understood of the fire of God's anger which came up against Israel. To unbelievers our God is himself a consuming fire. Those that will not believe the power of God's mercy shall feel the power of his indignation, and be made to confess that it is a fearful thing to fall into his hands. Now here we are told,

(1.)Why God thus resented the provocation (Psalm 78:22): Because by this it appeared that they believed not in God; they did not give credit to the revelation he had made of himself to them, for they durst not commit themselves to him, nor venture themselves with him: They trusted not in the salvation he had begun to work for them; for then they would not thus have questioned its progress. Those cannot be said to trust in God's salvation as their felicity at last who cannot find in their hearts to trust in his providence for food convenient in the way to it. That which aggravated their unbelief was the experience they had had of the power and goodness of God, Psalm 78:23-25. He had given them undeniable proofs of his power, not only on earth beneath, but in heaven above; for he commanded the clouds from above, as one that had created them and commanded them into being; he made what use he pleased of them. Usually by their showers they contribute to the earth's producing corn; but now, when God so commanded them, they showered down corn themselves, which is therefore called here the corn of heaven; for heaven can do the work without the earth, but not the earth without heaven. God, who has the key of the clouds, opened the doors of heaven, and that is more than opening the windows, which yet is spoken of as a great blessing, Malachi 3:10. To all that by faith and prayer ask, seek, and knock, these doors shall at any time be opened; for the God of heaven is rich in mercy to all that call upon him. He not only keeps a good house, but keeps open house. Justly might God take it ill that they should distrust him when he had been so very kind to them that he had rained down manna upon them to eat, substantial food, daily, duly, enough for all, enough for each. Man did eat angels' food, such as angels, if they had occasion for food, would eat and be thankful for; or rather such as was given by the ministry of angels, and (as the Chaldee reads it) such as descended from the dwelling of angels. Every one, even the least child in Israel, did eat the bread of the mighty (so the margin reads it); the weakest stomach could digest it, and yet it was so nourishing that it was strong meat for strong men. And, though the provision was so good, yet they were not stinted, nor ever reduced to short allowance; for he sent them meat to the full. If they gathered little, it was their own fault; and yet even then they had no lack, Exodus 16:18. The daily provision God makes for us, and has made ever since we came into the world, though it has not so much of miracle as this, has no less of mercy, and is therefore a great aggravation of our distrust of God.

(2.)How he expressed his resentment of the provocation, not in denying them what they so inordinately lusted after, but in granting it to them.

[1.]Did they question his power? He soon gave them a sensible conviction that he could furnish a table in the wilderness. Though the winds seem to blow where they list, yet, when he pleased, he could make them his caterers to fetch in provisions, Psalm 78:26. He caused an east wind to blow and a south wind, either a south-east wind, or an east wind first to bring in the quails from that quarter and then a south wind to bring in more from that quarter; so that he rained flesh upon them, and that of the most delicate sort, not butchers' meat, but wild-fowl, and abundance of it, as dust, as the sand of the sea (Psalm 78:27), so that the meanest Israelite might have sufficient; and it cost them nothing, no, not the pains of fetching it from the mountains, for he let it fall in the midst of their camp, round about their habitation, Psalm 78:28. We have the account Numbers 11:31, Numbers 11:32. See how good God is even to the evil and unthankful, and wonder that his goodness does not overcome their badness. See what little reason we have to judge of God's love by such gifts of his bounty as these; dainty bits are no tokens of his peculiar favour. Christ gave dry bread to the disciples that he loved, but a sop dipped in the sauce to Judas that betrayed him.

[2.]Did they defy his justice and boast that they had gained their point? He made them pay dearly for their quails; for, though he gave them their own desire, they were not estranged from their lust (Psalm 78:29, Psalm 78:30); their appetite was insatiable; they were well filled and yet they were not satisfied; for they knew not what they would have. Such is the nature of lust; it is content with nothing, and the more it is humoured the more humoursome it grows. Those that indulge their lust will never be estranged from it. Or it intimates that God's liberality did not make them ashamed of their ungrateful lustings, as it would have done if they had had any sense of honour. But what came of it? While the meat was yet in their mouth, rolled under the tongue as a sweet morsel, the wrath of God came upon them and slew the fattest of them (Psalm 78:31), those that were most luxurious and most daring. See Numbers 11:33, Numbers 11:34. They were fed as sheep for the slaughter: the butcher takes the fattest first. We may suppose there were some pious and contented Israelites, that did eat moderately of the quails and were never the worse; for it was not the meat that poisoned them, but their own lust. Let epicures and sensualists here read their doom. The end of those who make a god of their belly is destruction, Philippians 3:19. The prosperity of fools shall destroy them, and their ruin will be the greater.

4.The judgments of God upon them did not reform them, nor attain the end, any more than his mercies (Psalm 78:32): For all this, they sinned still; they murmured and quarrelled with God and Moses as much as ever. Though God was wroth and smote them, yet they went on frowardly in the way of their heart (Isaiah 57:17); they believed not for his wondrous works. Though his works of justice were as wondrous and as great proofs of his power as his works of mercy, yet they were not wrought upon by them to fear God, nor convinced how much it was their interest to make him their friend. Those hearts are hard indeed that will neither be melted by the mercies of God nor broken by his judgments.

5.They persisting in their sins, God proceeded in his judgments, but they were judgments of another nature, which wrought not suddenly, but slowly. He punished them not now with such acute diseases as that was which slew the fattest of them, but a lingering chronical distemper (Psalm 78:33): Therefore their days did he consume in vanity in the wilderness and their years in trouble. By an irreversible doom they were condemned to wear out thirty-eight tedious years in the wilderness, which indeed were consumed in vanity; for in all those years there was not a step taken nearer Canaan, but they were turned back again, and wandered to and fro as in a labyrinth, not one stroke struck towards the conquest of it: and not only in vanity, but in trouble, for their carcases were condemned to fall in the wilderness and there they all perished but Caleb and Joshua. Note, Those that sin still must expect to be in trouble still. And the reason why we spend our days in so much vanity and trouble, why we live with so little comfort and to so little purpose, is because we do not live by faith.

6.Under these rebukes they professed repentance, but they were not cordial and sincere in this profession.

(1.)Their profession was plausible enough (Psalm 78:34, Psalm 78:35): When he slew them, or condemned them to be slain, then they sought him; they confessed their fault, and begged his pardon. When some were slain others in a fright cried to God for mercy, and promised they would reform and be very good; then they returned to God, and enquired early after him. So one would have taken them to be such as desired to find him. And they pretended to do this because, however they had forgotten it formerly, now they remembered that God was their rock and therefore now that they needed him they would fly to him and take shelter in him, and that the high God was their Redeemer, who brought them out of Egypt and to whom therefore they might come with boldness. Afflictions are sent to put us in mind of God as our rock and our redeemer; for, in prosperity, we are apt to forget him.

(2.)They were not sincere in this profession (Psalm 78:36, Psalm 78:37): They did but flatter him with their mouth, as if they thought by fair speeches to prevail with him to revoke the sentence and remove the judgment, with a secret intention to break their word when the danger was over; they did not return to God with their whole heart, but feignedly, Jeremiah 3:10. All their professions, prayers, and promises, were extorted by the rack. It was plain that they did not mean as they said, for they did not adhere to it. They thawed in the sun, but froze in the shade. They did but lie to God with their tongues, for their heart was not with him, was not right with him, as appeared by the issue, for they were not stedfast in his covenant. They were not sincere in their reformation, for they were not constant; and, by thinking thus to impose upon a heart-searching God, they really put as great an affront upon him as by any of their reflections.

7.God hereupon, in pity to them, put a stop to the judgments which were threatened and in part executed (Psalm 78:38, Psalm 78:39): But he, being full of compassion, forgave their iniquity. One would think this counterfeit repentance should have filled up the measure of their iniquity. What could be more provoking than to lie thus to the holy God, than thus to keep back part of the price, the chief part? Acts 5:3. And yet he, being full of compassion, forgave their iniquity thus far, that he did not destroy them and cut them off from being a people, as he justly might have done, but spared their lives till they had reared another generation which should enter into the promised land. Destroy it not, for a blessing is in it, Isaiah 65:8. Many a time he turned his anger away (for he is Lord of his anger) and did not stir up all his wrath, to deal with them as they deserved: and why did he not? Not because their ruin would have been any loss to him, but,

(1.)Because he was full of compassion and, when he was going to destroy them, his repentings were kindled together, and he said, How shall I give thee up, Ephraim? How shall I deliver thee, Israel? Hosea 11:8.

(2.)Because, though they did not rightly remember that he was their rock, he remembered that they were but flesh. He considered the corruption of their nature, which inclined them to evil, and was pleased to make that an excuse for his sparing them, though it was really no excuse for their sin. See Genesis 6:3. He considered the weakness and frailty of their nature, and what an easy thing it would be to crush them: They are as a wind that passeth away and cometh not again. They may soon be taken off, but, when they are gone, they are gone irrecoverably, and then what will become of the covenant with Abraham? They are flesh, they are wind; whence it were easy to argue they may justly, they may immediately, be cut off, and there would be no loss of them: but God argues, on the contrary, therefore he will not destroy them; for the true reason is, He is full of compassion.

Historical interpretation

Historical reception

1 surviving comment on this verse from the historical church.

1 quote · AD 430
"And they tempted God in their hearts, in order that they might seek morsels for their souls" [Psalm 78:18]. It is one thing to ask in believing, another thing in tempting. Lastly there follows, "And they slandered God, and said, Shall God be able to prepare a table in the desert?" [Psalm 78:19]. "For He smote the rock, and the waters flowed, and torrents gushed forth: will He be able to give bread also, or to prepare a table for His people?" [Psalm 78:20]. Not believing therefore, they sought morsels for their souls. Not so the Apostle James does enjoin a morsel to be asked for the mind, but does admonish that it be sought by believers, not by such as tempt and slander God. "But if any one of you," he says, "does lack wisdom, let him ask of God, who does give to all men abundantly, and does not upbraid, and it shall be given to him: but let him ask in faith, nothing wavering." [James 1:5-6] This faith had not that generation which "had not directed their heart, and the spirit thereof had not been trusted with God."
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Psalm 78:18 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8