TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Genesis 19:4–11. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.
Now it appeared, beyond contradiction, that the cry of Sodom was no louder than there was cause for. This night's work was enough to fill the measure. For we find here,
I.That they were all wicked, Gen 19:4.
Wickedness had become universal, and they were unanimous in any vile design. Here were old and young, and all from every quarter, engaged in this riot; the old were not past it, and the young had soon come up to it. Either they had no magistrates to keep the peace, and protect the peaceable, or their magistrates were themselves aiding and abetting. Note, When the disease of sin has become epidemical, it is fatal to any place, Isa 1:5-7.
II.That they had arrived at the highest pitch of wickedness; they were sinners before the Lord exceedingly (Gen 13:13); for,
1.It was the most unnatural and abominable wickedness that they were now set upon, a sin that still bears their name, and is called Sodomy. They were carried headlong by those vile affections (Rom 1:26, Rom 1:27), which are worse than brutish, and the eternal reproach of the human nature, and which cannot be thought of without horror by those that have the least spark of virtue and any remains of natural light and conscience. Note, Those that allow themselves in unnatural uncleanness are marked for the vengeance of eternal fire. See Jde 1:7.
2.They were not ashamed to own it, and to prosecute their design by force and arms. The practice would have been bad enough if it had been carried on by intrigue and wheedling; but they proclaimed war with virtue, and bade open defiance to it. Hence daring sinners are said to declare their sin as Sodom, Isa 3:9. Note, Those that have become impudent in sin generally prove impenitent in sin; and it will be their ruin. Those have hard hearts indeed that sin with a high hand, Jer 6:15.
3.When Lot interposed, with all the mildness imaginable, to check the rage and fury of their lust, they were most insolently rude and abusive to him. He ventured himself among them, Jer 6:6. He spoke civilly to them, called them brethren (Gen 19:7), and begged of them not to do so wickedly; and, being greatly disturbed at their vile attempt, he unadvisedly and unjustifiably offered to prostitute his two daughters to them, Gen 19:8. It is true, of two evils we must choose the less; but of two sins we must choose neither, nor ever do evil that good may come of it. He reasoned with them, pleaded the laws of hospitality and the protection of his house which his guests were entitled to; but he might as well have offered reason to a roaring lion and a raging bear as to these head-strong sinners, who were governed only by lust and passion. Lot's arguing with them does but exasperate them; and, to complete their wickedness, and fill up the measure of it, they fall foul upon him.
(1.)They ridicule him, charge him with the absurdity of pretending to be a magistrate, when he was not so much as a free-man of their city, Gen 19:9. Note, It is common for a reprover to be unjustly upbraided as a usurper; and, while offering the kindness of a friend, to be charged with assuming the authority of a judge: as if a man might not speak reason without taking too much upon him.
(2.)They threaten him, and lay violent hands upon him; and the good man is in danger of being pulled in pieces by this outrageous rabble. Note,
[1.]Those that hate to be reformed hate those that reprove them, though with ever so much tenderness. Presumptuous sinners do by their consciences as the Sodomites did by Lot, baffle their checks, stifle their accusations, press hard upon them, till they have seared them and quite stopped their mouths, and so made themselves ripe for ruin.
[2.]Abuses offered to God's messengers and to faithful reprovers soon fill the measure of a people's wickedness, and bring destruction without remedy. See Pro 29:1, and Ch2 36:16. If reproofs remedy not, there is no remedy. See Ch2 25:16.
III.That nothing less than the power of an angel could save a good man out of their wicked hands.
It was now past dispute what Sodom's character was and what course must be taken with it, and therefore the angels immediately give a specimen of what they further intended.
1.They rescue Lot, Ch2 25:10. Note, He that watereth shall be watered also himself. Lot was solicitous to protect them, and now they take effectual care for his safety, in return for his kindness. Note further, Angels are employed for the special preservation of those that expose themselves to danger by well-doing. The saints, at death, are pulled like Lot into a house of perfect safety, and the door shut for ever against those that pursue them.
2.They chastise the insolence of the Sodomites: They smote them with blindness, Gen 19:11. This was designed,
(1.)To put an end to their attempt, and disable them from pursuing it. Justly were those struck blind who had been deaf to reason. Violent persecutors are often infatuated so that they cannot push on their malicious designs against God's messengers, Job 5:14, Job 5:15. Yet these Sodomites, after they were struck blind, continued seeking the door, to break it down, till they were tired. No judgments will, of themselves, change the corrupt natures and purposes of wicked men. If their minds had not been blinded as well as their bodies, they would have said, as the magicians, This is the finger of God, and would have submitted.
(2.)It was to be an earnest of their utter ruin, the next day. When God, in a way of righteous judgment, blinds men, their condition is already desperate, Rom 11:8, Rom 11:9.
Historical interpretation
Historical Reception
One surviving comment on this verse from the historical church.
Indeed, when they [the men of Sodom] were raging to commit such a crime, Lot says among other things: "I have two daughters who have not yet known a man. I will bring them out to you, and you may abuse them as it pleases you, provided that you do nothing evil to these men." Because he wanted to offer his daughters as a form of compensation so that his male guests would not suffer such an outrage from the Sodomites, it is rightly questioned whether such a compensation of crimes or any sins should be admitted, that we might do something evil in order to prevent another from doing a greater evil, or whether it should rather be attributed to the disturbance of Lot’s mind rather than his intention, since he said this; indeed, this compensation is most perilously admitted; but if it is attributed to human disturbance and a mind disturbed by such great evil, it should in no way be imitated.
Continue studying Genesis 19:8 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
Genesis 19:8 vividly portrays Lot's desperate and morally abhorrent offer to the men of Sodom, who were aggressively demanding access to his angelic guests. In a profound moment of ethical compromise, driven by the ancient duty of hospitality and extreme duress, Lot presented his virgin daughters to the depraved mob. This act not only underscores the pervasive wickedness of Sodom, which necessitated such a horrific proposal, but also reveals the extent to which Lot's own moral judgment had been tragically skewed by his prolonged immersion in a corrupt society.
Context
Literary Context
This verse is situated at a pivotal and intensely dramatic point in the narrative of Sodom and Gomorrah, immediately preceding their catastrophic divine judgment. The preceding verses establish the arrival of two angelic messengers, appearing as men, who are welcomed into Lot's home after finding no other hospitable dwelling in the city. As night descends, the entire male population of Sodom, from young to old, surrounds Lot's house with a singular, perverse demand: "Bring them out to us, that we may know them" (Genesis 19:5). This demand, a euphemism for sexual assault, represents the apex of Sodom's spiritual and moral depravity. Lot's emergence from his house and his subsequent shocking proposal in Genesis 19:8 is a direct, desperate, and ultimately indefensible response to this aggressive threat, highlighting the extreme pressure he faced to protect his guests, even at an unimaginable cost. The narrative here serves as a grim prelude to the city's destruction, justifying God's impending judgment.
Historical & Cultural Context
In the ancient Near East, hospitality was a sacred and inviolable social covenant. A host was bound by honor and custom to protect guests under their roof, even at personal risk. This "guest-right" was paramount, and its violation was considered a grave offense. Lot's offer, while morally repugnant by any standard, must be understood against this backdrop of extreme pressure to uphold his duty as a host. The wickedness of Sodom, as depicted here, was not merely sexual immorality but a profound breakdown of social order, including a complete disregard for guest-right, justice, and compassion (Ezekiel 16:49-50). The city's inhabitants were characterized by arrogance, gluttony, and a refusal to aid the poor and needy, culminating in overt, aggressive sexual violence and a complete lack of moral restraint. Lot, though described as "righteous" in 2 Peter 2:7, had evidently absorbed some of the moral decay of his environment, leading to this horrific compromise.
Key Themes
Genesis 19:8 contributes to several overarching themes within Genesis and the broader biblical narrative. Firstly, it powerfully underscores the theme of human depravity and the escalating nature of sin, demonstrating how a society can descend into utter moral corruption, demanding sexual violence against strangers. Secondly, it highlights the sacred duty of hospitality in the ancient world, even as Lot's actions tragically distort this virtue. Thirdly, the passage vividly illustrates the dangers of moral compromise and the corrupting influence of ungodly environments, particularly seen in Lot's flawed judgment despite his righteous standing. Finally, it sets the stage for the theme of divine judgment against unrepentant wickedness, affirming God's justice and holiness in responding to such egregious sin, while simultaneously foreshadowing His grace and deliverance for the righteous, even those who are deeply flawed, as Lot and his daughters are ultimately rescued from the impending destruction (Genesis 19:15-16).
Exposition and Analysis
Key Word Analysis
Derived from a root meaning "to build," this term refers to a female child. In this context, it specifically denotes Lot's two unmarried, virgin daughters. The mention of their virginity ("which have not known man") intensifies the horror of Lot's offer, as it proposes the violation of their purity and future prospects, highlighting the extreme nature of his desperation and the depth of the moral crisis.
A primitive root meaning "to know" in a wide variety of senses, including intellectual understanding, experiential knowledge, and intimate, carnal knowledge. In this verse, as in Genesis 4:1, it is used euphemistically to refer to sexual intercourse. The Sodomites' demand to "know" Lot's guests was a demand for homosexual rape, and Lot's offer to let them "do ye to them" implies the same intent for his daughters, making the word choice chillingly explicit in its euphemism.
This adjective describes something as "good" in the widest sense, encompassing beauty, favor, pleasantness, and moral uprightness. In Lot's phrase, "do ye to them as is good in your eyes," the term is used ironically or tragically. What the Sodomites considered "good" (i.e., sexually gratifying and violent) was morally reprehensible and evil in the eyes of God and any righteous standard. This stark contrast highlights the perversion of moral values within Sodom, where evil was perceived as good.
Verse Breakdown
"Behold now, I have two daughters which have not known man"
Lot begins by drawing the attention of the mob ("Behold now"), a desperate attempt to divert their focus. His immediate offering is his two daughters, explicitly stating their virginity. This detail is crucial; it underscores the profound moral depravity of his offer, as he proposes to sacrifice the purity and future of his own children, rather than allowing harm to come to his guests. It reveals the extreme pressure and the warped sense of duty he felt.
"let me, I pray you, bring them out unto you, and do ye to them as [is] good in your eyes"
This is the core of Lot's horrific proposition. The phrase "I pray you" indicates a plea, a desperate entreaty to the mob. He offers to personally facilitate the assault, inviting them to commit sexual violence against his daughters, allowing them to do "as is good in your eyes." This phrase demonstrates the complete breakdown of moral order in Sodom, where what was "good" to the mob was utterly evil, and Lot, in his desperation, was willing to concede to their perverted desires.
"only unto these men do nothing; for therefore came they under the shadow of my roof"
This final clause reveals Lot's primary, albeit tragically misdirected, motivation: to protect his guests at all costs. The phrase "under the shadow of my roof" is a powerful ancient Near Eastern idiom signifying the inviolable sanctuary and protection a host was obligated to provide to those under their care. Lot's desperate attempt to uphold this sacred duty of hospitality, even by offering his daughters, starkly contrasts with the Sodomites' utter disregard for this fundamental social and moral norm, highlighting their extreme wickedness and the dire situation Lot faced.
Literary Devices
The passage employs several potent literary devices. Euphemism is evident in the phrase "have not known man," which, while literally true of their virginity, also subtly alludes to the sexual nature of the threat, amplified by the Sodomites' demand to "know" the angels. Irony pervades Lot's offer: in his desperate attempt to uphold the sacred duty of hospitality, he proposes an act that is itself a profound violation of familial duty and moral law, turning a virtue into a vehicle for sin. There is also a stark Contrast between Lot's flawed but genuine attempt at protection and the unbridled, aggressive depravity of the Sodomite mob. Finally, the phrase "under the shadow of my roof" serves as powerful Symbolism, representing the ancient concept of sanctuary and inviolable guest-right, emphasizing the gravity of the Sodomites' transgression against this sacred custom and Lot's desperate, albeit misguided, attempt to uphold it.
Theological and Thematic Connections
This harrowing account in Genesis 19:8 serves as a profound theological statement on the depths of human sin and the necessity of divine judgment. It exposes the utter moral corruption that can permeate a society when it abandons righteousness, leading to a complete perversion of natural law and social order. Lot's tragic compromise, while born of a desperate attempt to uphold a sacred cultural duty, underscores the corrupting influence of ungodly environments and the danger of allowing one's moral compass to be skewed by surrounding wickedness. Ultimately, the passage reinforces the biblical truth that God's justice will prevail against pervasive evil, even as it highlights His grace in delivering the righteous, however flawed, from impending destruction.
Reflection and Application
Lot's agonizing offer in Genesis 19:8 stands as a chilling testament to the corrupting power of ungodly environments and the perilous nature of moral compromise when faced with extreme pressure. While Lot's initial desire to protect his guests stemmed from a deeply ingrained cultural value, his method was an egregious violation of his paternal duty and divine law, revealing the tragic extent to which his moral judgment had been compromised by living in Sodom. This passage compels believers to critically examine the subtle and overt influences of the surrounding culture on their own moral compass. It challenges us to maintain unwavering moral integrity, even in the face of hostility or perceived crisis, trusting in God's sovereign protection and provision rather than resorting to sinful or desperate measures. The narrative powerfully underscores the importance of seeking divine wisdom and upholding righteousness, even when it seems to come at a great cost, reminding us that true safety and integrity are found only in adherence to God's unchanging standards, not in appeasing the demands of a fallen world.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Was Lot justified in offering his daughters to the men of Sodom?
No. While Lot was undoubtedly under extreme duress and attempting to uphold the sacred ancient Near Eastern duty of hospitality, his offer to sacrifice his daughters' purity to the depraved mob was a grave moral transgression and utterly indefensible from a divine and ethical standpoint. The Bible presents it not as a justifiable act, but as a desperate, sinful compromise that tragically highlights the depth of Sodom's evil and the extent of Lot's own compromised moral state due to his prolonged exposure to such wickedness. It serves as a stark warning, not an example to emulate.
What does "under the shadow of my roof" signify in this context?
The phrase "under the shadow of my roof" is a powerful ancient Near Eastern idiom that signifies the sacred custom of guest-right, or hospitality. It implies that once a guest entered a host's dwelling, they were considered to be under the host's inviolable protection and sanctuary. The host was honor-bound to defend their guests from any harm, even at personal risk. Lot's desperate plea, "for therefore came they under the shadow of my roof," underscores his attempt to invoke this sacred custom, highlighting the Sodomites' profound violation of this fundamental societal norm and the extreme pressure Lot faced in trying to fulfill his duty as a host.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
The harrowing narrative of Lot's desperate and morally compromised attempt to protect his guests, even at the cost of his own daughters' purity, powerfully illuminates humanity's profound need for a perfect protector and deliverer. Unlike Lot, whose efforts were tragically tainted by human weakness and moral failure, Christ offers true, unblemished, and ultimate sanctuary. He is the perfect Host who, rather than sacrificing others, willingly laid down His own life as the ultimate sacrifice to provide complete protection and deliverance from sin, judgment, and the power of darkness (John 10:11). The insatiable depravity of Sodom, demanding a sacrifice from Lot, foreshadows humanity's desperate spiritual condition and its inherent need for a Savior. In Christ, we find the Lamb of God who perfectly fulfills righteousness and offers Himself as the spotless sacrifice (John 1:29), providing a refuge and a covering that Lot, in his flawed humanity, could never truly offer. Through His perfect sacrifice, Christ shelters us "under the shadow of His wings" (Psalm 91:4), offering eternal security and a moral purity that transforms us, unlike the corrupting influence of Sodom.