Skip to content

Deuteronomy 12:8

“Worship Only at the Chosen Place”· Deuteronomy 12:5–14Read in context
King James Version
Ye shall not do after all the things that we do here this day, every man whatsoever is right in his own eyes.
KJV (with Strong's)
Ye shall not do H6213 after all the things that we do H6213 here this day H3117, every man H376 whatsoever is right H3477 in his own eyes H5869.
Complete Jewish Bible
You will not do things the way we do them here today, where everyone does whatever in his own opinion seems right;
Berean Standard Bible
You are not to do as we are doing here today, where everyone does what seems right in his own eyes.
American Standard Version
Ye shall not do after all the things that we do here this day, every man whatsoever is right in his own eyes;
World English Bible Messianic
You shall not do after all the things that we do here this day, every man whatever is right in his own eyes;
Geneva Bible (1599)
Ye shall not doe after all these things that we doe here this day: that is, euery man whatsoeuer seemeth him good in his owne eyes.
Young's Literal Translation
`Ye do not do according to all that we are doing here to-day, each anything that is right in his own eyes,
Translation
In the KJVVerse 5,249 of 31,102 · 16.9%

Study this verse

Summary

Deuteronomy 12:8 delivers a crucial prophetic warning to the Israelites on the precipice of entering the Promised Land, explicitly forbidding them from perpetuating the decentralized, self-determined worship and lifestyle practices that characterized their wilderness wandering. Moses commands a radical departure from the principle of "every man whatsoever is right in his own eyes" in matters of divine service and communal living, signaling a mandatory shift towards a divinely ordained, centralized, and unified system of obedience and worship once they are settled in Canaan. This verse fundamentally asserts that God's people are to live by His revealed will and objective standards, not by subjective human preferences, convenience, or cultural relativism.

Context

Literary Context

Deuteronomy 12:8 is strategically placed within Moses' second major discourse, specifically at the outset of the legal section (Deuteronomy 12-26) that details the statutes and ordinances for life in the Promised Land. Chapter 12 itself is foundational, establishing the paramount command for a single, central place of worship (see Deuteronomy 12:5), a stark contrast to the provisional, decentralized altars and practices common during their nomadic wilderness journey (compare Deuteronomy 12:13-14). Verse 8 directly precedes the imperative to seek the Lord at this chosen place (as outlined in Deuteronomy 12:9-10) and to bring all prescribed offerings there. This emphasizes that their future worship must be in strict accordance with God's detailed instructions, marking a definitive transition from a temporary, adaptable system to a permanent, divinely prescribed one.

Historical & Cultural Context

The Israelites stood on the threshold of a momentous transition from a nomadic existence, where their worship often involved portable altars and localized sacrifices necessitated by their movements, to a settled agricultural life in Canaan. This new environment presented profound spiritual perils, particularly the pervasive idolatry, syncretism, and morally depraved practices of the Canaanite nations. The command in Deuteronomy 12:8, therefore, functioned as a vital preventative measure, designed to safeguard Israel from adopting these pagan customs and from the spiritual chaos that inevitably arises when each individual determines their own religious and ethical standards. The phrase "here this day" refers to the wilderness period, where, out of practical necessity, worship was less rigidly regulated and more decentralized. God's overarching intention was to establish a distinct, holy nation whose worship and ethics were meticulously set apart from the surrounding cultures, thereby ensuring the purity and integrity of their unique covenant relationship with Him.

Key Themes

This verse profoundly contributes to several overarching themes woven throughout Deuteronomy and the broader Old Testament narrative. Firstly, it powerfully reinforces the centralization of worship, a dominant theme in Deuteronomy 12, underscoring God's sovereign prerogative to choose the specific place for His name to dwell. This command was crucial for preventing the proliferation of unauthorized altars and the insidious adoption of pagan practices (as explicitly warned against in Deuteronomy 12:2-4). Secondly, it highlights the profound and enduring tension between divine authority and human autonomy. The phrase "whatsoever is right in his own eyes" serves as a direct and unequivocal rejection of subjective morality and self-determined religion, asserting that God's revealed will is the sole, immutable standard for His people's conduct and worship. This critical theme resonates throughout Israel's history, most poignantly illustrated in the chaotic period of the Judges, where the absence of a king led to widespread moral relativism, famously encapsulated by the recurring refrain that "everyone did what was right in his own eyes" (found in Judges 17:6 and Judges 21:25). Finally, the verse speaks directly to the vital themes of order, unity, and holiness. By prescribing a singular standard and a central place of worship, God aimed to foster tribal unity, prevent spiritual fragmentation, and meticulously maintain the holiness required of a people in covenant with a holy God.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Do ʿâsâh' H6213

From the primitive root H6213, meaning "to do or make, in the broadest sense and widest application." In Deuteronomy 12:8, this verb signifies not merely performing an action, but engaging in a consistent pattern of behavior or practice. The repetition of "do" (first as "ye shall not do," then "that we do") emphasizes the ingrained nature of the wilderness practices that are now to be abandoned. It refers to the manner of their religious and ethical conduct.

Right yâshâr' H3477

Meaning "straight (literally or figuratively); convenient, equity, just, upright." When used in the phrase "right in his own eyes," it denotes a self-referential standard of rectitude. It describes what an individual perceives as correct, good, or proper, based solely on their internal judgment or preference, rather than an external, objective, or divine standard. This highlights a dangerous subjectivity that undermines accountability to God's law.

Eyes ʿayin' H5869

Meaning "an eye (literally or figuratively); by analogy, a fountain (as the eye of the landscape)." In this idiomatic expression, "eyes" (often plural) represents perception, judgment, and perspective. To do something "in one's own eyes" means to act according to one's own subjective understanding, desires, or convictions, without reference to an external, objective standard. It points to the internal, personal source of moral or religious decision-making, which is precisely what God forbids here as a basis for covenant living.

Verse Breakdown

"Ye shall not do after all [the things] that we do here this day"

This opening clause functions as a direct and emphatic prohibition against the prevailing, temporary mode of worship and living that characterized their wilderness sojourn. "Here this day" specifically refers to the nomadic period, during which, due to their transient state and the absence of a permanent sanctuary, certain practices (such as offering sacrifices at various localized altars) were permitted out of practical necessity. Moses is unequivocally declaring that this era of flexible, decentralized practices is drawing to a close. The Israelites are commanded to abandon these ad-hoc methods, as they are no longer suitable for the structured, settled life God intends for them in the Promised Land, which demands a more disciplined and unified approach to obedience.

"every man whatsoever [is] right in his own eyes"

This pivotal phrase clarifies the precise nature of the "things" they are no longer permitted to do. It serves as a profound condemnation of the principle of subjective autonomy in matters of faith and obedience. It means acting solely according to one's personal judgment, preferences, or desires, without any regard for God's revealed will or the communal standards He meticulously establishes. This is not a trivial matter of personal freedom in minor affairs, but addresses the profound spiritual danger of self-determination in core religious and ethical practices, which, as Israel's history would repeatedly demonstrate, inevitably leads to idolatry, syncretism, moral chaos, and a departure from covenant faithfulness.

Literary Devices

Deuteronomy 12:8 masterfully employs several potent literary devices to convey its urgent and foundational message. The most prominent device is Contrast, which establishes a stark distinction between the past and the future, specifically between the wilderness experience and the anticipated life in the Promised Land. The phrase "here this day" (representing the wilderness's temporary, decentralized, and self-determined practices) is sharply contrasted with the implied "there" (the chosen place, permanent, centralized, and divinely prescribed worship) that God will soon establish. This contrast powerfully underscores the radical shift in obedience and spiritual discipline that God now demands. Furthermore, the phrase "whatsoever is right in his own eyes" functions as a powerful Idiom, a common Hebrew expression (yāšār bəʿênāw) that succinctly encapsulates the concept of subjective morality and self-rule. This idiom carries deeply negative connotations throughout the Old Testament, frequently preceding or describing periods of moral decline, spiritual apostasy, and societal breakdown. The verse also implicitly uses Foreshadowing, as this solemn warning against self-determined righteousness tragically anticipates the devastating consequences of such behavior, most vividly illustrated in the Book of Judges, where the absence of a central authority and the adherence to individualistic standards lead to widespread societal and spiritual chaos precisely because "everyone did what was right in his own eyes."

Theological and Thematic Connections

Deuteronomy 12:8 lays down a foundational theological principle: the absolute and unyielding supremacy of God's revealed will over human inclination and subjective judgment. It teaches that genuine worship and authentic obedience are not matters of personal preference, cultural adaptation, or individual convenience, but rather a strict and joyful adherence to divine command. This principle directly confronts and counters the inherent human tendency towards autonomy and self-determination, which, when applied to spiritual matters, invariably leads to idolatry, syncretism, and moral decay. God's desire for a centralized sanctuary and meticulously prescribed worship was not arbitrary or burdensome; it was a loving design intended to protect Israel's unique identity as His covenant people, to prevent them from succumbing to the abominations of the surrounding nations, and to ensure the purity and integrity of their devotion. This verse powerfully underscores that true freedom, flourishing, and spiritual integrity are found not in doing "what is right in one's own eyes," but in humble, joyful, and unwavering submission to the wise, holy, and loving commands of the Almighty.

Reflection and Application

Deuteronomy 12:8 speaks with profound and enduring relevance to contemporary believers, living in an age increasingly characterized by radical individualism, moral relativism, and a pervasive distrust of external authority. The stern warning against doing "what is right in his own eyes" challenges us to critically and honestly examine the ultimate sources of our beliefs, our behaviors, and our ethical frameworks. Are we genuinely submitting to the unchanging, objective authority of God's inspired Word, or are we subtly, perhaps even unconsciously, allowing personal preferences, prevailing cultural trends, subjective feelings, or even our own limited reason to dictate our spiritual walk, our expressions of worship, and our ethical choices? This verse calls us to cultivate a humble posture of obedience, acknowledging that God's ways are infinitely higher than our ways, and His wisdom immeasurably surpasses our own finite understanding. It serves as a vital reminder to the Church that genuine unity, purity, and spiritual health are maintained not by accommodating every individual's "right" way of doing things, but by collectively submitting to the clear, non-negotiable teachings of Scripture and the unified leadership of the Holy Spirit. In a world that often celebrates self-expression and personal truth above all else, Deuteronomy 12:8 stands as a timeless and counter-cultural declaration that true freedom, abundant life, and spiritual flourishing come from aligning our entire lives with God's perfect, revealed will, rather than our own imperfect, often flawed, perceptions.

Questions for Reflection

  1. In what specific areas of my life or faith might I be subtly doing "what is right in my own eyes" rather than humbly submitting to God's revealed will?
  2. How can I actively cultivate a deeper reverence for biblical authority and objective truth in a culture that increasingly prioritizes personal autonomy and subjective experience?
  3. What are the practical implications of this verse for fostering genuine unity and maintaining spiritual purity within my local church community today?

FAQ

Why was it permissible for the Israelites to do "what was right in their own eyes" in the wilderness, but not in the Promised Land?

The phrase "what we do here this day" refers to the temporary, nomadic conditions of the wilderness journey. During this provisional period, a centralized sanctuary was not yet established, and the Israelites lived in a state of constant movement. Therefore, certain worship practices, such as building altars in various locations, were permitted out of practical necessity, adapting to their transient lifestyle. However, this was explicitly a provisional arrangement, not God's ultimate and ideal design for His people. Upon entering the Promised Land, God intended to establish a permanent, central place of worship (as meticulously detailed in Deuteronomy 12:5), and a unified, divinely prescribed system of worship and communal living. The prohibition in Deuteronomy 12:8 signifies the definitive end of the provisional period and the commencement of a new era where strict adherence to God's specific commands, rather than individual discretion, would be absolutely required to maintain holiness, prevent syncretism with pagan practices, and preserve Israel's distinct identity as God's covenant people.

What are the dangers of doing "what is right in one's own eyes" for individuals and communities?

The primary and most profound danger of doing "what is right in one's own eyes" is that it fundamentally substitutes human judgment and preference for divine authority, inevitably leading to moral relativism, spiritual chaos, and ultimately, apostasy. For individuals, this self-referential standard can lead to self-deception, the justification of sin, and a gradual but profound straying from God's righteous path, because one's own desires or perceptions become the ultimate arbiter of truth and conduct (as powerfully warned in Proverbs 16:25). For communities, especially the people of God, it fosters disunity, division, and the insidious erosion of shared truth, ethical standards, and covenant faithfulness. The historical narrative of the book of Judges vividly illustrates this societal and spiritual breakdown, repeatedly noting that "in those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did what was right in his own eyes" (Judges 21:25). This subjective approach inevitably leads to spiritual compromise, the adoption of foreign and idolatrous practices, and a catastrophic departure from the covenant relationship with the one true God.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

Deuteronomy 12:8, with its stern warning against the perils of self-determined righteousness and its call for adherence to God's prescribed will, finds its ultimate fulfillment and profound resolution in the person and work of Jesus Christ. The Old Covenant's emphasis on a divinely chosen standard and a central place of worship perfectly foreshadowed the perfect obedience of Christ and the new, spiritual reality of worship in the New Covenant. Jesus Himself perfectly embodied the rejection of "doing what is right in his own eyes," declaring, "I can do nothing on my own. As I hear, I judge; and my judgment is just, because I seek not my own will but the will of him who sent me" (John 5:30). He is the true and ultimate temple, the ultimate "place the Lord will choose," where God's presence truly dwells among His people (John 2:19-21). Under the New Covenant, the physical centralization of worship gives way to a profound spiritual reality, where true worshipers worship the Father in spirit and truth, no longer bound by a specific geographical location, but by the indwelling Holy Spirit of God (John 4:23-24). Christ's perfect obedience to the Father's will and His atoning sacrifice on the cross fulfill the righteous demands of the law, liberating believers from the futility and condemnation of self-righteousness. Through His Spirit, believers are now empowered to truly live according to God's will, no longer conformed to the patterns of this fallen world but transformed by the renewing of their minds (Romans 12:2). In Christ, we discover the ultimate, objective standard for what is truly "right," not in our own fallible eyes, but in the perfect eyes of God, revealed and embodied in His Son.

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Deuteronomy 12:5–32. His three-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 28 verses
Passage under commentDeuteronomy 12:5–32
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

There is not any one particular precept (as I remember) in all the law of Moses so largely pressed and inculcated as this, by which they are all tied to bring their sacrifices to that one altar which was set up in the court of the tabernacle, and there to perform all the rituals of their religion; for, as to moral services, then, no doubt, as now, men might pray every where, as they did in their synagogues. The command to do this, and the prohibition of the contrary, are here repeated again and again, as we teach children: and yet we are sure that there is in scripture no vain repetition; but all this stress is laid upon it, 1. Because of the strange proneness there was in the hearts of the people to idolatry and superstition, and the danger of their being seduced by the many temptations which they would be surrounded with. 2. Because of the great use which the observance of this appointment would be of to them, both to prevent the introducing of corrupt customs into their worship and to preserve among them unity and brotherly love, that, meeting all in one place, they might continue both of one way and of one heart. 3. Because of the significancy of this appointment. They must keep to one place, in token of their belief of those two great truths, which we find together (Ti1 2:5), That there is one God, and one Mediator between God and man. It not only served to keep up the notion of the unity of the Godhead, but was an intimation to them (though they could not stedfastly discern it) of the one only way of approach to God and communion with him, in and by the Messiah.

Let us now reduce this long charge to its proper heads.

I.It is here promised that when they were settled in Canaan, when they had rest from their enemies, and dwelt in safety, God would choose a certain place, which he would appoint to be the centre of their unity, to which they should bring all their offerings, Deu 12:10, Deu 12:11. Observe,

1.If they just be tied to one place, they should not be left in doubt concerning it, but should certainly know what place it was. Had Christ intended, under the gospel, to make any one place such a seat of power as Rome pretends to be, we should not have been left so destitute of instruction as we are concerning the appointed place.

2.God does not leave it to them to choose the place, lest the tribes should have quarrelled about it, each striving, for their secular advantage, to have it among them; but he reserves the choice to himself, as he does the designation of the Redeemer and the institution of holy ordinances.

3.He does not appoint the place now, as he had appointed mounts Gerizim and Ebal, for the pronouncing of the blessings and curses (Deu 11:29), but reserves the doing of it till hereafter, that hereby they might be made to expect further directions from heaven, and a divine conduct, after Moses should be removed. The place which God would choose is said to be the place where he would put his name, that is, which he would have to be called his, where his honour should dwell, where he would manifest himself to his people, and make himself known, as men do by their names, and where he would receive addresses, by which his name is both praised and called upon. It was to be his habitation, where, as King of Israel, he would keep court, and be found by all those that reverently sought him. The ark was the token of God's presence, and where that was put there God put his name, and that was his habitation. It contained the tables of the law; for none must expect to receive favours from God's hand but those that are willing to receive the law from his mouth. The place which God first chose for the ark to reside in was Shiloh; and, after that place had sinned away its honours, we find the ark at Kirjath-jearim and other places; but at length, in David's time, it was fixed at Jerusalem, and God said concerning Solomon's temple, more expressly than ever he had said concerning any other place, This I have chosen for a house of sacrifice, Ch2 7:12. Compare Ch2 6:5. Now, under the gospel, we have no temple that sanctifies the gold, no altar that sanctifies the gift, but Christ only; and, as to the places of worship, the prophets foretold that in every place the spiritual incense should be offered, Mal 1:11. And our Saviour has declared that those are accepted as true worshippers who worship God in sincerity and truth, without regard either to this mountain or Jerusalem, Joh 4:23.

II.They are commanded to bring all their burnt-offerings and sacrifices to this place that God would choose (Deu 12:6 and again Deu 12:11):

Thither shall you bring all that I command you; and (Deu 12:14), There thou shalt offer thy burnt offerings; and (Deu 12:27), The flesh and the blood must be offered upon the altar of the Lord thy God. And of their peace-offerings, here called their sacrifices, though they were to eat the flesh, yet the blood was to be poured out upon the altar. By this they were taught that sacrifices and offerings God did not desire, nor accept, for their own sake, nor for any intrinsic worth in them, as natural expressions of homage and adoration; but that they received their virtue purely from that altar on which they were offered, as it typified Christ; whereas prayers and praises, as much more necessary and valuable, were to be offered every day by the people of God wherever they were. A devout Israelite might honour God, and keep up communion with him, and obtain mercy from him, though he had not an opportunity, perhaps, for many months together, of bringing a sacrifice to his altar. But this signified the obligation we Christians are under to offer up all our spiritual sacrifices to God in the name of Jesus Christ, hoping for acceptance only upon the score of his mediation, Pe1 2:5.

III.They are commanded to feast upon their hallowed things before the Lord, with holy joy.

They must not only bring to the altar the sacrifices which were to be offered to God, but hey must bring to the place of the altar all those things which they were appointed by the law to eat and drink, to the honour of God, in token of their communion with him, Deu 12:6. Their, tithes, and heave-offerings of their hand, that is, their first-fruits, their vows, and free-will-offerings, and firstlings, all those things which were to be religiously made use of either by themselves or by the priests and Levites, must be brought to the place which God would choose; as all the revenues of the crown, from all parts of the kingdom, are brought into the exchequer. And (Deu 12:7): There you shall eat before the Lord, and rejoice in all that you put your hands unto; and again (Deu 12:12), You shall rejoice before the Lord, you, and your sons, and your daughters. Observe here,

1.That what we do in the service of God and to his glory redounds to our benefit, if it be not our own fault. Those that sacrifice to God are welcome to eat before him, and to feast upon their sacrifices: he sups with us, and we with him, Rev 3:20. If we glorify God, we edify ourselves, and cultivate our own minds, through the grace of God, by the increase of our knowledge and faith, the enlivening of devout affections, and the confirming of gracious habits and resolutions: thus is the soul nourished.

2.That work for God should be done with holy joy and cheerfulness. You shall eat and rejoice, Deu 12:7, and again, Deu 12:12 and Deu 12:18.

(1.)Now while they were before the Lord they must rejoice, Deu 12:12. It is the will of God that we should serve him with gladness; none displeased him more than those that covered his altar with tears. Mal 2:13. See what a good Master we serve, who has made it our duty to sing at our work. Even the children and servants must rejoice with them before God, that the services of religion might be a pleasure to them, and not a task or drudgery.

(2.)They must carry away with them the grateful relish of that delight which they found in communion with God; they must rejoice in all that they put their hands unto, Deu 12:7. Some of the comfort which they must take with them into their common employments; and, being thus strengthened in soul, whatever they did they must do it heartily and cheerfully. And this holy pious joy in God and his goodness, with which we are to rejoice evermore, would be the best preservative against the sin and snare of vain and carnal mirth and a relief against the sorrows of the world.

IV.They are commanded to be kind to the Levites.

Did they feast with joy? The Levites must feast with them, and rejoice with them, Deu 12:12, and again, Deu 12:18; and a general caution (Deu 12:19), Take heed that thou forsake not the Levite as long as thou livest. There were Levites that attended the altar as assistants to the priests, and these must not be forsaken, that is, the service they performed must be constantly adhered to; no other altar must be set up than that which God appointed; for that would be to forsake the Levites. But this seems to be spoken of the Levites that were dispersed in the country to instruct the people in the law of God, and to assist them in their devotions; for it is the Levite within their gates that they are here commanded to make much of. It is a great mercy to have Levites near us, within our gates, that we may ask the law at their mouth, and at our feasts to be a check upon us, to restrain excesses. And it is the duty of people to be kind to their ministers that give them good instructions and set them good examples. As long as we live we shall need their assistance, till we come to that world where ordinances will be superseded; and therefore as long as we live we must not forsake the Levites. The reason given (Deu 12:12) is because the Levite has no part nor inheritance with you, so that he cannot grow rich by husbandry or trade; let him therefore share with you in the comfort of your riches. They must give the Levites their tithes and offerings, settled on them by the law, because they had no other maintenance.

V.They are allowed to eat common flesh, but not the flesh of their offerings, in their own houses, wherever they dwelt.

What was any way devoted to God they must not eat at home, Deu 12:13, Deu 12:17. But what was not so devoted they might kill and eat of at their pleasure, Deu 12:15. And this permission is again repeated, Deu 12:20-22. It should seem that while they were in the wilderness they did not eat the flesh of any of those kinds of beasts that were used in sacrifice, but what was killed at the door of the tabernacle, and part of it presented to God as a peace-offering, Lev 17:3, Lev 17:4. But when they came to Canaan, where they must live at a great distance from the tabernacle, they might kill what they pleased for their own use of their flocks and herds, without bringing part to the altar. This allowance is very express, and repeated, lest Satan should take occasion from that law which forbade the eating of their sacrifices at their own houses to suggest to them, as he did to our first parents, hard thoughts of God, as if he grudged them: Thou mayest eat whatsoever thy soul lusteth after. There is a natural regular appetite, which it is lawful to gratify with temperance and sobriety, not taking too great a pleasure in the gratification, nor being uneasy if it be crossed. The unclean, who might not eat of the holy things, yet might eat of the same sort of flesh when it was only used as common food. The distinction between clean persons and unclean was sacred, and designed for the preserving of the honour of their holy feasts, and therefore must not be brought into their ordinary meals. This permission has a double restriction: - 1. They must eat according to the blessing which God had given them, Deu 12:15. Note, It is not only our wisdom, but our duty, to live according to our estates, and not to spend above what we have. As it is unjust on the one hand to hoard what should be laid out, so it is much more unjust to lay out more than we have; for what is not our own must needs be another's, who is thereby robbed and defrauded. And this, I say, is much more unjust, because it is easier afterwards to distribute what has been unduly spared, and so to make a sort of restitution for the wrong, than it is to repay to wife, and children, and creditors, what has been unduly spent. Between these two extremes let wisdom find the mean, and then let watchfulness and resolution keep it. 2. They must not eat blood (Deu 12:16, and again, Deu 12:23): Only be sure that thou eat not the blood (Deu 12:24), Thou shalt not eat it; and (Deu 12:25), Thou shalt not eat it, that it may go well with thee. When they could not bring the blood to the altar, to pour it out there before the Lord, as belonging to him, they must pour it out upon the earth, as not belonging to them, because it was the life, and therefore, as an acknowledgment, belonged to him who gives life, and, as an atonement, belonged to him to whom life is forfeited. Bishop Patrick thinks one reason why they were forbidden thus strictly the eating of blood was to prevent the superstitions of the old idolaters about the blood of their sacrifices, which they thought their demons delighted in, and by eating of which they imagined that they had communion with them.

VI.They are forbidden to keep up either their own corrupt usages in the wilderness or the corrupt usages of their predecessors in the land of Canaan.

1.They must not keep up those improper customs which they had got into in the wilderness, and which were connived at in consideration of the present unsettledness of their condition (Deu 12:8, Deu 12:9): You shall not do after all the things that we do here this day. Never was there a better governor than Moses, and one would think never a better opportunity of keeping up good order and discipline than now among the people of Israel, when they lay so closely encamped under the eye of their governor; and yet it seems there was much amiss and many irregularities had crept in among them. We must never expect to see any society perfectly pure and right, and as it should be till we come to the heavenly Canaan. They had sacrifices and religious worship, courts of justice and civil government, and, by the stoning of the man that gathered sticks on the sabbath day, it appears there was great strictness used in guarding the most weighty matters of the law; but being frequently upon the remove, and always at uncertainty,

(1.)They could none of them observe the solemn feasts, and the rites of cleansing, with the exactness that the law required. And,

(2.)Those among them that were disposed to do amiss had opportunity given them to do it unobserved by the frequent interruptions which their removals gave to the administration of justice. But (says Moses) when you come to Canaan, you shall not do as we do here. Note, When the people of God are in an unsettled condition, that may be tolerated and dispensed with which would by no means be allowed at another time. Cases of necessity are to be considered while the necessity continues; but that must not be done in Canaan which was done in the wilderness. While a house is in the building a great deal of dirt and rubbish are suffered to lie by it, which must all be taken away when the house is built. Moses was now about to lay down his life and government, and it was a comfort to him to foresee that Israel would be better in the next reign than they had been in his.

2.They must not worship the Lord by any of those rites or ceremonies which the notions of Canaan had made use of in the service of their gods, Deu 12:29-32. They must not so much as enquire into the modes and forms of idolatrous worship. What good would it do to them to know those depths of Satan? Rev 2:24. It is best to be ignorant of that which there is danger of being infected by. They must not introduce the customs of idolaters,

(1.)Because it would be absurd to make those their patterns whom God had made their slaves and captives, cut off, and destroyed from before them. The Canaanites had not flourished and prospered so much in the service of their gods as that the Israelites should be invited to take up their customs. Those are wretchedly besotted indeed who will walk in the way of sinners, after they have seen their end.

(2.)Because some of their customs were most barbarous and inhuman, and such as trampled, not only upon the light and law of nature, but upon natural affection itself, as burning their sons and their daughters in the fire to their gods (Deu 12:31), the very mention of which is sufficient to make it odious, and possess us with a horror of it.

(3.)Because their idolatrous customs were an abomination to the Lord, and the translating of them into his worship would make even that an abomination and an affront to him by which they should give him honour, and by which they hoped to obtain his favour. The case is bad indeed when the sacrifice itself has become an abomination, Pro 15:8. He therefore concludes (Deu 12:32) with the same caution concerning the worship of God which he had before given concerning the word of God (Deu 4:2): "You shall not add thereto any inventions of your own, under pretence of making the ordinance either more significant or more magnificent, nor diminish from it, under pretence of making it more easy and practicable, or of setting aside that which may be spared; but observe to do all that, and that only, which God has commanded." We may then hope in our religious worship to obtain the divine acceptance when we observe the divine appointment. God will have his own work done in his own way.

Copy as
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Deuteronomy 12:8 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8