Skip to content

Joshua 7:11

“God Reveals the Sin and Commands Action”· Joshua 7:10–15Read in context
King James Version
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
KJV (with Strong's)
Israel H3478 hath sinned H2398, and they have also transgressed H5674 my covenant H1285 which I commanded H6680 them: for they have even taken H3947 of the accursed thing H2764, and have also stolen H1589, and dissembled H3584 also, and they have put H7760 it even among their own stuff H3627.
Complete Jewish Bible
Isra'el has sinned. Yes, they have violated my covenant, which I commanded them. They have taken some of what was to have been set aside for destruction. They have stolen it, lied about it and put it with their own things.
Berean Standard Bible
Israel has sinned; they have transgressed My covenant that I commanded them, and they have taken some of what was devoted to destruction. Indeed, they have stolen and lied, and they have put these things with their own possessions.
American Standard Version
Israel hath sinned; yea, they have even transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: yea, they have even taken of the devoted thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also; and they have even put it among their own stuff.
World English Bible Messianic
Israel has sinned. Yes, they have even transgressed my covenant which I commanded them. Yes, they have even taken of the devoted things, and have also stolen, and also deceived. They have even put it among their own stuff.
Geneva Bible (1599)
Israel hath sinned, and they haue transgressed my couenant, which I commanded them: for they haue euen taken of the excommunicate thing, and haue also stollen, and dissembled also, and haue put it euen with their owne stuffe.
Young's Literal Translation
Israel hath sinned, and also they have transgressed My covenant which I commanded them, and also taken of the devoted thing, and also stolen, and also deceived, and also put it among their vessels,
Translation
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 5,988 of 31,102 · 19.3%

Study this verse

Summary

Joshua 7:11 serves as God's direct and profound revelation, articulating the precise reason for Israel's unexpected and humiliating defeat at Ai. Following their miraculous and divinely empowered victory at Jericho, the Israelites suffered a significant setback against a seemingly inferior foe, leading Joshua to deep distress and questioning. This pivotal verse clarifies that the military failure was not due to God's abandonment or lack of power, but rather a direct and severe consequence of corporate disobedience and a breach of the covenant within the Israelite camp, specifically through the taking of forbidden spoils.

Context

Literary Context

This verse immediately follows Israel's demoralizing defeat at Ai, a stark and perplexing contrast to their recent, miraculous triumph at Jericho. In the preceding chapter, God had given explicit and stringent instructions regarding the spoils of Jericho: all precious metals were to be consecrated to the Lord's treasury, while everything else was to be utterly destroyed as "the accursed thing" (Hebrew: ḥērem). Taking anything from these devoted items was strictly forbidden, as clearly commanded in Joshua 6:18. The narrative of Joshua 7 opens with Israel's inexplicable defeat at Ai, causing Joshua and the elders to prostrate themselves before the Ark, lamenting and questioning God's presence and purpose (Joshua 7:6-9). God abruptly interrupts Joshua's prayer with this blunt declaration in Joshua 7:10-11, revealing the hidden sin that had provoked divine wrath, compromised their holiness, and led to their weakness before their enemies. The subsequent verses detail the identification and punishment of Achan, the perpetrator of the sin, and the restoration of God's favor to Israel.

Historical & Cultural Context

The concept of ḥērem (the "accursed thing" or "devoted thing") is absolutely central to understanding this passage. In the ancient Near East, ḥērem referred to something set apart, often for destruction, to a deity. For Israel, it signified items or people utterly devoted to Yahweh, usually in the context of holy war, where spoils were either destroyed or dedicated to the sanctuary, never for personal gain. This practice underscored God's absolute sovereignty over the land and its inhabitants, and Israel's role as His instrument of judgment. To take from the ḥērem was not merely theft but profound sacrilege—a direct affront to God's holiness and His rightful claim. Furthermore, Israel's identity and success were intrinsically tied to the Mosaic Covenant, a conditional agreement where obedience brought blessing and protection, as outlined in Deuteronomy 28:1-14, while disobedience invoked curses and divine judgment, as warned in Deuteronomy 28:15-68. The incident at Ai dramatically illustrates the immediate and severe consequences of violating this foundational covenant.

Key Themes

Joshua 7:11 powerfully articulates several foundational themes crucial to the book of Joshua and the broader Old Testament narrative. Firstly, it highlights Corporate Responsibility or corporate solidarity, where the sin of one individual (Achan, though unnamed in this verse) is attributed to the entire nation ("Israel hath sinned"). This underscores the interconnectedness of the covenant community, where the actions of a single member, especially regarding covenant faithfulness, can profoundly affect the entire group, bringing judgment or hindering blessing. Secondly, the verse explicitly states Covenant Transgression, emphasizing that taking the forbidden items was a direct violation of God's covenant commands. God's relationship with Israel was predicated on obedience, and this act was a clear breach, leading to the withdrawal of divine favor and protection. Thirdly, it reveals the Seriousness of Disobedience and the multifaceted nature of sin. God categorizes Achan's actions not merely as taking, but also as "stolen" and "dissembled" (deceived/lied), indicating a deliberate, deceitful, and calculated act of rebellion against God's explicit command, not a simple oversight. Finally, the presence of "the accursed thing" among Israel's possessions speaks to the Holiness of God and the defilement of the camp. A holy God cannot fully dwell among or fight for a people harboring such defilement, which compromised their sacred relationship and spiritual purity.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Accursed thing chêrem' H2764

This term (H2764) refers to something "devoted" or "set apart" to God, often for complete destruction, especially in the context of holy war. At Jericho, it designated spoils that were forbidden for human use or personal gain, as they were consecrated to the Lord as the "firstfruits" of conquest. To take from the ḥērem was an act of profound sacrilege, directly defying God's absolute claim over all things and violating divine ownership and holiness, bringing defilement and judgment upon the perpetrator and, by extension, the entire community.

Transgressed ʿâbar' H5674

The verb ʿâbar (H5674) literally means "to pass over" or "to cross a boundary." In a moral or legal sense, it signifies violating a command, breaking a law, or crossing a forbidden line. Here, it denotes a deliberate breach of the covenant stipulations that God "commanded them," indicating a conscious and intentional act of defiance against divine authority and the established terms of their sacred relationship with Yahweh. It highlights a crossing of a clear moral and spiritual boundary.

Dissembled kâchash' H3584

This verb (H3584) implies denying, deceiving, or hiding. It suggests more than simply taking and concealing the forbidden items; it points to a deliberate act of deceit, an attempt to hide the transgression from both God and fellow Israelites. This adds a layer of premeditation and moral culpability to Achan's sin, highlighting not only the act of theft but also the accompanying dishonesty, feigned innocence, and lack of repentance.

Verse Breakdown

"Israel hath sinned"

This opening declaration immediately establishes the principle of corporate solidarity. Although only one individual (Achan) committed the act, God attributes the sin to the entire nation. This reflects the Old Testament understanding that the covenant community functions as a unified body, and the sin of a member, particularly one that violates the covenant, affects the purity and standing of the whole. It signifies that the entire camp was defiled and therefore under divine displeasure, leading to the withdrawal of God's protective presence.

"and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them"

This clause specifies the nature of the sin: it is a direct breach of the covenant God had established with Israel. The phrase "which I commanded them" underscores the explicit nature of the divine instruction regarding the spoils of Jericho, making the transgression a deliberate act of disobedience against a known and clear divine will. This covenantal breach is the fundamental root cause of God's wrath and Israel's vulnerability.

"for they have even taken of the accursed thing"

This identifies the specific forbidden act. The "accursed thing" (ḥērem) was consecrated to God and forbidden for personal gain. Taking it constituted sacrilege, a direct theft from God, and a defilement of the sacred. This act was not merely a violation of a rule but an assault on God's holiness and His rightful claim over the firstfruits of their conquest, demonstrating a profound disrespect for divine authority.

"and have also stolen, and dissembled also"

These phrases further characterize the nature and severity of the transgression. "Stolen" explicitly labels the act as theft, not just a casual taking, emphasizing the illicit acquisition of property that belonged to God. "Dissembled" (or "deceived/lied") adds the element of deceit and concealment. Achan not only took what was forbidden but also actively hid it, attempting to evade detection and accountability, compounding his sin with dishonesty and a lack of remorse.

"and they have put [it] even among their own stuff"

This final clause highlights the consequence of the act: the accursed thing was integrated into the camp's possessions. This act of mixing the holy/forbidden with the common/personal defiled the entire community. The presence of the ḥērem within their midst compromised Israel's purity and broke the covenant, leading to the withdrawal of God's protective presence and power, and ultimately, to their defeat.

Literary Devices

Joshua 7:11 employs several powerful literary devices to convey its urgent message and underscore the gravity of the situation. The most prominent is Corporate Representation (often understood as a form of Metonymy or Synecdoche), where "Israel" stands in for Achan, the individual perpetrator. This emphasizes the profound impact of individual sin on the entire covenant community, making the nation corporately responsible for the actions of one of its members and highlighting the interconnectedness of God's people. The verse also utilizes Repetition and Emphasis through the repeated use of "and also" ("and they have also transgressed... and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put [it] even among their own stuff"). This cumulative listing underscores the multifaceted nature of the transgression, highlighting the layers of disobedience, theft, and deceit involved, building a sense of the sin's comprehensive nature. Furthermore, the direct, declarative nature of God's speech functions as a Divine Oracle, delivering an authoritative and unambiguous pronouncement of judgment and the precise reason for Israel's defeat, thereby establishing divine accountability for human actions. There is also an implicit Contrast with the preceding chapter, where Israel's obedience led to miraculous victory at Jericho, setting up the stark reality that disobedience, even by one, can lead to defeat and divine disfavor.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Joshua 7:11 is a foundational text for understanding the interconnectedness of sin, holiness, and divine judgment within the covenant community. It powerfully illustrates the principle of corporate solidarity, where the purity and standing of the entire group are affected by the actions of its individual members, especially when those actions constitute a direct breach of divine command. This passage underscores God's absolute holiness and His intolerance for sin within His consecrated people. It teaches that unconfessed and unaddressed sin creates a barrier between God and His people, hindering His blessing and protection. The severity of the consequences for Achan's sin, and its impact on the entire nation, highlights the gravity of disobedience and the necessity of maintaining covenant faithfulness for the well-being and success of the community. This incident serves as a stark warning against covetousness and the deceptive nature of hidden sin, emphasizing that nothing is truly hidden from God and that His justice demands a response to unholiness.

Reflection and Application

Joshua 7:11 offers timeless and profound lessons for believers and communities today. It serves as a potent reminder that sin, even when committed by one person and concealed, can have far-reaching and detrimental consequences that impact an entire community, family, or organization. This passage challenges us to consider the pervasive nature of sin and its potential to hinder God's work and blessing among us. It calls for a deep commitment to personal and corporate integrity, recognizing that our actions, both visible and hidden, contribute to the spiritual health of the collective body. Just as God required Israel to deal decisively with the "accursed thing," so too are we called to identify and confess sin, both individually and corporately, to restore fellowship with God and experience His unhindered presence and power. This demands transparency, humility, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths for the sake of purity and spiritual vitality, ensuring that our lives and communities are truly set apart for God's holy purposes.

Questions for Reflection

  1. In what ways might hidden sin in one individual or group impact the broader community today, even if not in the same direct, punitive manner as in ancient Israel?
  2. How does this passage challenge our understanding of personal responsibility versus corporate solidarity within the church or other communities?
  3. What "accursed things"—whether materialism, pride, unforgiveness, or other forms of disobedience—might we be tempted to harbor in our lives or communities that hinder God's blessing and presence?
  4. How can we cultivate a culture of transparency, confession, and accountability within our spiritual communities that honors God's holiness and promotes corporate purity?

FAQ

Why did God punish all of Israel for Achan's sin?

God's judgment on all of Israel for Achan's sin highlights the Old Testament principle of corporate solidarity. In the covenant community, the actions of one member, particularly a significant breach of covenant like taking the ḥērem, were seen as defiling the entire camp and compromising its relationship with a holy God. Israel was a unified body, and Achan's sin was not merely a private act but a corporate transgression against the covenant that affected the entire nation's standing before God. His sin brought "trouble" (Achor means "trouble") upon the whole community, leading to the withdrawal of divine protection and the defeat at Ai. This demonstrated the seriousness of covenant obedience and God's demand for holiness from His people, emphasizing that the purity of the collective was paramount for their success in the Promised Land.

What was the "accursed thing" and why was it so serious?

The "accursed thing" (Hebrew: ḥērem) refers to something "devoted" or "set apart" to God, often for complete destruction, especially in the context of holy war. At Jericho, God commanded that all spoils, except precious metals for the treasury, be utterly destroyed. Taking from the ḥērem was a grave act of sacrilege because it defied God's explicit command, stole what was consecrated to Him, and violated His holiness and ownership. It was not merely theft but a profound act of rebellion against divine authority, defiling the perpetrator and, by extension, the entire community, thus breaking the covenant and incurring divine wrath. It represented a direct challenge to God's sovereignty and His right to the firstfruits of their conquest.

Does God still punish communities for individual sins today in the same way He did Israel?

While the New Covenant emphasizes individual salvation and responsibility before God, the principle that sin has relational and communal consequences remains. The church, as the body of Christ, is called to holiness, and unaddressed sin within the community can still grieve the Holy Spirit, hinder corporate blessing, damage witness, and sow discord. While God does not typically bring military defeat upon nations today in the same direct, immediate, and physical manner as He did Israel, the New Testament warns about the "leaven" of sin that can spread (1 Corinthians 5:6) and the need for purity within the church (Ephesians 5:27). The consequences of sin, whether individual or corporate, still manifest as broken fellowship, loss of spiritual power, and a compromised testimony, emphasizing the ongoing need for confession, repentance, and church discipline to maintain the purity and effectiveness of the body of Christ.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

Joshua 7:11, with its stark revelation of corporate sin and its devastating consequences, finds profound Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and work of Jesus. The "accursed thing" that brought defilement and judgment upon Israel ultimately points to the universal problem of sin, which separates humanity from a holy God. Humanity, corporately and individually, has "transgressed God's covenant" through disobedience, incurring the curse of the law. However, Christ became the ultimate "accursed thing" for us, taking upon Himself the full weight of God's wrath and the curse of sin. As Galatians 3:13 declares, "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us—for it is written, 'Cursed is everyone who is hanged on a tree.'" He, who knew no sin, was made "to be sin for us" (2 Corinthians 5:21), bearing the defilement and judgment that was rightfully ours. Through His perfect obedience, Christ fulfilled the covenant's demands, and through His sacrificial death, He cleansed us from all unrighteousness, making it possible for a new covenant community—the Church—to be established, purified by His blood (Hebrews 9:14). Unlike Old Testament Israel, whose corporate purity depended on the obedience of all its members and resulted in immediate temporal judgment for sin, the Church's purity is grounded in Christ's finished work, and believers are called to confess their sins to a faithful God who forgives and cleanses (1 John 1:9). Thus, what Achan's sin exposed—the devastating power of sin and the necessity of divine intervention—is ultimately and perfectly addressed in the redemptive work of Christ, who enables us to live as a holy people, no longer harboring the "accursed thing" of sin, but rather walking in the light of His grace and righteousness.

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Joshua 7:10–15. His three-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 6 verses
Passage under commentJoshua 7:10–15
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

We have here God's answer to Joshua's address, which, we may suppose, came from the oracle over the ark, before which Joshua had prostrated himself, v. 6. Those that desire to know the will of God must attend with their desires upon the lively oracles, and wait at wisdom's gates for wisdom's dictates, Pro 8:34. And let those that find themselves under the tokens of God's displeasure never complain of him, but complain to him, and they shall receive an answer of peace. The answer came immediately, while he was yet speaking (Isa 65:24), as that to Daniel, Dan 9:20, etc.

I.God encourages Joshua against his present despondencies, and the black and melancholy apprehensions he had of the present posture of Israel's affairs (Jos 7:10): "Get thee up, suffer not thy spirits to droop and sink thus; wherefore liest thou thus upon thy face?" No doubt Joshua did well to humble himself before God, and mourn as he did, under the tokens of his displeasure; but now God told him it was enough, he would not have him continue any longer in that melancholy posture, for God delights not in the grief of penitents when they afflict their souls further than as it qualifies them for pardon and peace; the days even of that mourning must be ended. Arise, shake thyself from the dust, Isa 53:2. Joshua continued his mourning till eventide (Jos 7:6), so late that they could do nothing that night towards the discovery of the criminal, but were forced to put it off till next morning. Daniel (Dan 9:21), and Ezra (Ezr 9:5, Ezr 9:6), continued their mourning only till the time of the evening sacrifice; that revived them both: but Joshua went past that time, and therefore is thus roused: "Get thee up, do not lie all night there." Yet we find that Moses fell down before the Lord forty days and forty nights, to make intercession for Israel, Deu 9:18. Joshua must get up because he has other work to do than to lie there; the accursed thing must be discovered and cast out, and the sooner the better; Joshua is the man that must do it, and therefore it is time for him to lay aside his mourning weeds, and put on his judge's robes, and clothe himself with zeal as a cloak. Weeping must not hinder sowing, nor one duty of religion jostle out another. Every thing is beautiful in its season. Shechaniah perhaps had an eye to this in what he said to Ezra upon a like occasion. See Ezr 10:2-4.

II.He informs him of the true and only cause of this disaster, and shows him wherefore he contended with them (Jos 7:11):

Israel hath sinned. "Think not that God's mind is changed, his arm shortened, or his promise about to fail; no, it is sin, it is sin, that great mischief-maker, that has stopped the current of divine favours and has made this breach upon you." The sinner is not named, though the sin is described, but it is spoken of as the act of Israel in general, till they have fastened it upon the particular person, and their godly sorrow have so wrought a clearing of themselves, as theirs did, Co2 7:11. Observe how the sin is here made to appear exceedingly sinful.

1.They have transgressed my covenant, an express precept with a penalty annexed to it. It was agreed that God should have all the spoil of Jericho, and they should have the spoil of the rest of the cities of Canaan; but, in robbing God of his part, they transgressed this covenant.

2.They have even taken of the devoted thing, in contempt of the curse which was so solemnly denounced against him that should dare to break in upon God's property, as if that curse had nothing in it formidable.

3.They have also stolen; they did it clandestinely, as if they could conceal it from the divine omniscience, and they were ready to say, The Lord shall not see, or will not miss so small a matter out of so great a spoil. Thus thou thoughtest I was altogether such a one as thyself.

4.They have dissembled also. Probably, when the action was over, Joshua called all the tribes, and asked them whether they had faithfully disposed of the spoil according to the divine command, and charged them, if they knew of any transgression, that they should discover it, but Achan joined with the rest in a general protestation of innocency, and kept his countenance, like the adulterous woman that eats and wipes her mouth, and says, I have done no wickedness. Nay,

5.They have put the accursed thing among their own goods, as if they had as good a title to that as to any thing they have, never expecting to be called to an account, nor designing to make restitution. All this Joshua, though a wise and vigilant ruler, knew nothing of, till God told him, who knows all the secret wickedness that is in the world, which men know nothing of God could at this time have told him who the person was that had done this thing, but he does not,

(1.)To exercise the zeal of Joshua and Israel, in searching out the criminal.

(2.)To give the sinner himself space to repent and make confession. Joshua no doubt proclaimed it immediately throughout the camp that there was such a transgression committed, upon which, if Achan had surrendered himself, and penitently owned his guilt, and prevented the scrutiny, who knows but he might have had the benefit of that law which accepted of a trespass-offering, with restitution, from those that had sinned through ignorance in the holy things of the law? Lev 5:15, Lev 5:16. But Achan never discovering himself till the lot discovered him evidenced the hardness of his heart, and therefore he found no mercy.

III.He awakens him to enquire further into it, by telling him,

1.That this was the only ground for the controversy God had with them, this, and nothing else; so that when this accursed thing was put away he needed not fear, all would be well, the stream of their successes, when this one obstruction was removed, would run as strong as ever.

2.That if this accursed thing were not destroyed they could not expect the return of God's gracious presence; in plain terms, neither will I be with you any more as I have been, except you destroy the accursed, that is, the accursed person, who is made so by the accursed thing. That which is accursed will be destroyed; and those whom God has entrusted to bear the sword bear it in vain if they make it not a terror to that wickedness which brings these judgments of God on a land. By personal repentance and reformation, we destroy the accursed thing in our own hearts, and, unless we do this, we must never expect the favour of the blessed God. Let all men know that it is nothing but sin that separates between them and God, and, if it be not sincerely repented of and forsaken, it will separate eternally.

IV.He directs him in what method to make this enquiry and prosecution.

1.He must sanctify the people, now over-night, that is, as it is explained, he must command them to sanctify themselves, Jos 7:13. And what can either magistrates or ministers do more towards sanctification? They must put themselves into a suitable frame to appear before God and submit to the divine scrutiny, must examine themselves, now that God was coming to examine them, must prepare to meet their God. They were called to sanctify themselves when they were to receive the divine law (Ex. 19), and now also when they were to come under the divine judgment; for in both God is to be attended with the utmost reverence. "There is an accursed thing in the midst of you, and therefore sanctify yourselves," that is, Let all that are innocent be able to clear themselves, and be the more careful to cleanse themselves. The sin of others may be improved by us as furtherances of our sanctification, as the scandal of the incestuous Corinthian occasioned a blessed reformation in that church, Co2 7:11.

2.He must bring them all under the scrutiny of the lot (Jos 7:14); the tribe which the guilty person was of should first be discovered by lot, then the family, then the household, and last of all the person. The conviction came upon him thus gradually that he might have some space given him to come in and surrender himself; for God is not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. Observe, The Lord is said to take the tribe, and family, and household, on which the lot fell, because the disposal of the lot is of the Lord, and, however casual it seems, is under the direction of infinite wisdom and justice; and to show that when the sin of sinners finds them out God is to be acknowledged in it; it is he that seizes them, and the arrests are in his name. God hath found out the iniquity of thy servants, Gen 44:16. It is also intimated with what a certain and unerring judgment the righteous God does and will distinguish between the innocent and the guilty, so that though for a time they seem involved in the same condemnation, as the whole tribe did when it was first taken by the lot, yet he who has his fan in his hand will effectually provide for the taking out of the precious from the vile; so that though the righteous be of the same tribe, and family, and household, with the wicked, yet they shall never be treated as the wicked, Gen 18:25.

3.When the criminal was found out he must be put to death without mercy (Heb 10:28), and with all the expressions of a holy detestation, Jos 7:15. He and all that he has must be burnt with fire, that there might be no remainders of the accursed thing among them; and the reason given for this severe sentence is because the criminal has,

(1.)Given a great affront to God: He has transgressed the covenant of the Lord, who is jealous particularly for the honour of the holy covenant.

(2.)He has done a great injury to the church of God: He has wrought folly in Israel, has shamed that nation which is looked upon by all its neighbours to be a wise and understanding people, has infected that nation which is sanctified to God, and troubled that nation of which he is the protector. These being crimes so heinous in their nature, and of such pernicious consequence and example, the execution, which otherwise would have come under the imputation of cruelty, is to be applauded as a piece of necessary justice. It was sacrilege; it was invading God's rights, alienating his property, and converting to a private use that which was devoted to his glory and appropriated to the service of his sanctuary - this was the crime to be thus severely punished, for warning to all people in all ages to take heed how they rob God.

Copy as
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Joshua 7:11 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8