TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Exodus 5:15–23. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.
It was a great strait that the head-workmen were in, when they must either abuse those that were under them or be abused by those that were over them; yet, it should seem, rather than they would tyrannize, they would be tyrannized over; and they were so. In this evil case (Exo 5:19), observe,
I.How justly they complained to Pharaoh:
They came and cried unto Pharaoh, Exo 5:15. Whither should they go with a remonstrance of their grievances but to the supreme power, which is ordained for the protection of the injured? As bad as Pharaoh was his oppressed subjects had liberty to complain to him; there was no law against petitioning: it was a very modest, but moving, representation that they made of their condition (Exo 5:16): Thy servants are beaten (severely enough, no doubt, when things were in such a ferment), and yet the fault is in thy own people, the task-masters, who deny us what is necessary for carrying on our work. Note, It is common for those to be most rigorous in blaming others who are most blameworthy themselves. But what did they get by this complaint? It did but make bad worse.
1.Pharaoh taunted them (Exo 5:17); when they were almost killed with working, he told them they were idle: they underwent the fatigue of industry, and yet lay under the imputation of slothfulness, while nothing appeared to ground the charge upon but this, that they said, Let us go and do sacrifice. Note, It is common for the best actions to be mentioned under the worst names; holy diligence in the best business is censured by many as a culpable carelessness in the business of the world. It is well for us that men are not to be our judges, but a God who knows what the principles are on which we act. Those that are diligent in doing sacrifice to the Lord will, with God, escape the doom of the slothful servant, though, with men, they do not.
2.He bound on their burdens: Go now and work. Exo 5:18. Note, Wickedness proceedeth from the wicked; what can be expected from unrighteous men but more unrighteousness?
II.How unjustly they complained of Moses and Aaron:
The Lord look upon you, and judge, Exo 5:21. This was not fair. Moses and Aaron had given sufficient evidence of their hearty good-will to the liberties of Israel; and yet, because things succeed not immediately as they hoped, they are reproached as accessaries to their slavery. They should have humbled themselves before God, and taken to themselves the shame of their sin, which turned away good things from them; but, instead of this, they fly in the face of their best friends, and quarrel with the instruments of their deliverance, because of some little difficulties and obstructions they met with in effecting it. Note, Those that are called out to public service for God and their generation must expect to be tried, not only by the malicious threats of proud enemies, but by the unjust and unkind censures of unthinking friends, who judge only by outward appearance and look but a little way before them. Now what did Moses do in this strait? It grieved him to the heart that the event did not answer, but rather contradict, his expectation; and their upbraidings were very cutting, and like a sword in his bones; but,
1.He returned to the Lord (Exo 5:22), to acquaint him with it, and to represent the case to him: he knew that what he had said and done was by divine direction; and therefore what blame is laid upon him for it he considers as reflecting upon God, and, like Hezekiah, spreads it before him as interested in the cause, and appeals to him. Compare this with Jer 20:7-9. Note, When we find ourselves, at any time, perplexed and embarrassed in the way of our duty, we ought to have recourse to God, and lay open our case before him by faithful and fervent prayer. If we retreat, let us retreat to him, and no further.
2.He expostulated with him, Exo 5:22, Exo 5:23. He knew not how to reconcile the providence with the promise and the commission which he had received. "Is this God's coming down to deliver Israel? Must I, who hoped to be a blessing to them, become a scourge to them? By this attempt to get them out of the pit, they are but sunk the deeper into it." Now he asks,
(1.)Wherefore hast thou so evil entreated this people? Note, Even when God is coming towards his people in ways of mercy, he sometimes takes such methods as that they may think themselves but ill treated. The instruments of deliverance, when they aim to help, are found to hinder, and that becomes a trap which, it was hoped, would have been for their welfare, God suffering it to be so that we may learn to cease from man, and may come off from a dependence upon second causes. Note, further, When the people of God think themselves ill treated, they should go to God by prayer, and plead with him, and that is the way to have better treatment in God's good time.
(2.)Why is it thou hast sent me? Thus,
[1.]He complains of his ill success: "Pharaoh has done evil to this people, and not one step seems to be taken towards their deliverance." Note, It cannot but sit very heavily upon the spirits of those whom God employs for him to see that their labour does no good, and much more to see that it does hurt eventually, though not designedly. It is uncomfortable to a good minister to perceive that his endeavours for men's conviction and conversion do but exasperate their corruptions, confirm their prejudices, harden their hearts, and seal them up under unbelief. This makes them go in the bitterness of their souls, as the prophet, Eze 3:14. Or,
[2.]He enquires what was further to be done: Why hast thou sent me? that is, "What other method shall I take in pursuance of my commission?" Note, Disappointments in our work must not drive us from our God, but still we must consider why we are sent.
Continue studying Exodus 5:19 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
Exodus 5:19 vividly portrays the grim realization of the Israelite officers, who, as foremen under Egyptian taskmasters, were held directly accountable for the brick production quotas. Having just endured a beating for failing to meet impossible demands after Pharaoh withheld straw, they acutely recognized the truly dire and inescapable "evil case" they were in, facing unachievable tasks and relentless punishment without any human recourse.
Context
Literary Context
This verse is situated immediately after the Israelite officers have been severely beaten by Pharaoh's taskmasters for failing to meet the daily brick quota, despite the new, impossible condition of having to gather their own straw (Exodus 5:14). It follows Moses and Aaron's initial, unsuccessful appeal to Pharaoh for the Israelites' release to worship God (Exodus 5:1-3). Pharaoh's response was not only a defiant refusal but a deliberate intensification of the Israelites' forced labor, designed to crush any hope of freedom (Exodus 5:4-9). Verse 19 captures the officers' dawning, painful understanding of the full extent of their predicament, marking a low point of despair before the narrative shifts towards God's more direct and powerful interventions.
Historical & Cultural Context
In ancient Egypt, the production of bricks was a fundamental component of large-scale construction projects, often fueled by slave labor. Straw was a crucial binding agent for sun-dried mud bricks, providing tensile strength and preventing cracking. Withholding straw while maintaining the quota was a deliberate act of extreme cruelty and oppression, designed to make the task literally impossible and to break the spirit of the laborers. The "officers of the children of Israel" were likely Israelite foremen appointed by the Egyptian overseers, serving as intermediaries. This system placed them in an unenviable and dangerous position: they were responsible for their kinsmen's output, yet powerless to change the conditions, making them direct targets for Pharaoh's wrath and a conduit for his oppression. Their beatings and subsequent realization reflect the brutal realities of slavery and the systemic nature of Pharaoh's tyranny.
Key Themes
This verse contributes significantly to several overarching themes in Exodus. It underscores the theme of Increased Oppression, demonstrating Pharaoh's escalating cruelty and his determination to tighten his grip on the Israelites in response to God's demand for their release, rather than loosening it. This intensified suffering directly highlights the Impossible Demands placed upon the Israelites, where the expectation to produce the same number of bricks with fewer resources and more labor emphasizes the unjust and unachievable burdens designed to break their spirit. The officers' realization of their "evil case" powerfully conveys the theme of Despair and Helplessness that permeated the Israelite community, setting the stage for God's miraculous intervention. Furthermore, it exemplifies the Cost of Obedience, as Moses and Aaron's initial, divinely-commissioned appeal paradoxically led to greater suffering for their people, testing their faith and the people's resolve before ultimate deliverance would come, as promised in Exodus 6:6-7.
Exposition and Analysis
Exodus 5:19 starkly reveals the Israelite officers' grim reality: "And the officers of the children of Israel did see [that] they [were] in evil [case], after it was said, Ye shall not minish [ought] from your bricks of your daily task." This verse follows their brutal beating at the hands of Pharaoh's taskmasters for failing to meet the brick quotas, despite the impossible new conditions. Their "seeing" implies a profound and painful realization of the depth of their predicament, a recognition that their situation was not merely difficult, but truly calamitous and without human remedy. The phrase "Ye shall not minish [ought] from your bricks of your daily task" reiterates Pharaoh's unyielding and cruel decree, cementing their hopeless position.
Key Word Analysis
From a primitive root meaning "to scrape off; by implication, to shave, remove, lessen, withhold; abate, clip, (di-) minish, do (take) away, keep back, restrain, make small, withdraw." In this context, it emphasizes Pharaoh's absolute refusal to reduce the brick quota, highlighting the unyielding nature of the demand and the impossibility of the task. The Israelites were forbidden from reducing anything from their required output, regardless of the lack of straw.
From a root meaning "bad or (as noun) evil (natural or moral); adversity, affliction, bad, calamity, [phrase] displease(-ure), distress, evil((-favouredness), man, thing), [phrase] exceedingly, [idiom] great, grief(-vous), harm, heavy, hurt(-ful), ill (favoured), [phrase] mark, mischief(-vous), misery, naught(-ty), noisome, [phrase] not please, sad(-ly), sore, sorrow, trouble, vex, wicked(-ly, -ness, one), worse(-st), wretchedness, wrong." Here, "evil case" (literally "evil to them") signifies a deeply distressing, harmful, and grievous situation. It is not merely an inconvenience but a profoundly difficult and dangerous state of affairs, emphasizing the severity of their plight and the wickedness of Pharaoh's decree.
From a root meaning "a word; by implication, a matter (as spoken of) or thing; adverbially, a cause; act, advice, affair, answer, [idiom] any such (thing), because of, book, business, care, case, cause, certain rate, [phrase] chronicles, commandment, [idiom] commune(-ication), [phrase] concern(-ing), [phrase] confer, counsel, [phrase] dearth, decree, deed, [idiom] disease, due, duty, effect, [phrase] eloquent, errand, (evil favoured-) ness, [phrase] glory, [phrase] harm, hurt, [phrase] iniquity, [phrase] judgment, language, [phrase] lying, manner, matter, message, (no) thing, oracle, [idiom] ought, [idiom] parts, [phrase] pertaining, [phrase] please, portion, [phrase] power, promise, provision, purpose, question, rate, reason, report, request, [idiom] (as hast) said, sake, saying, sentence, [phrase] sign, [phrase] so, some (uncleanness), somewhat to say, [phrase] song, speech, [idiom] spoken, talk, task, [phrase] that, [idiom] there done, thing (concerning), thought, [phrase] thus, tidings, what(-soever), [phrase] wherewith, which, word, work." In this context, "daily task" refers to the specific, mandated amount of work or production required each day. It emphasizes the concrete, inescapable burden placed upon the Israelites, a "word" or "matter" that had become a crushing reality.
Verse Breakdown
"And the officers of the children of Israel did see"
This opening clause highlights the moment of profound realization. The Israelite foremen, who were directly responsible and had just suffered physical violence, gained a clear, painful understanding of their situation. Their "seeing" is not merely visual but intellectual and emotional, signifying a dawning awareness of the full scope of their predicament.
"[that] they [were] in evil [case],"
This phrase describes the nature of their realization. The situation they faced was not just difficult or inconvenient, but profoundly "evil" or calamitous. It was a state of severe distress, harm, and injustice, from which there appeared to be no human escape.
"after it was said, Ye shall not minish [ought] from your bricks of your daily task."
This final clause explains why they perceived their case as evil. Pharaoh's decree, reiterated and enforced, made it clear that despite the withdrawal of straw, the brick quota would remain undiminished. This absolute, unyielding demand, coupled with the lack of resources, rendered their task utterly impossible and guaranteed continued suffering and punishment.
Literary Devices
The verse employs several literary devices to convey the depth of the Israelites' despair. The phrase "evil case" functions as a form of understatement or euphemism, as the situation was far more than merely "evil"; it was a brutal, hopeless, and life-threatening predicament. There is significant irony in the narrative: Moses and Aaron's divine commission to liberate the people initially leads to an intensification of their suffering, a paradoxical outcome that tests faith. The "bricks" themselves become a symbol of their bondage and the crushing weight of Egyptian oppression, while the "daily task" represents the relentless, dehumanizing cycle of slavery. The officers' "seeing" is a moment of profound anagnorisis (recognition), where they fully grasp the tragic reality of their impossible situation, evoking pathos and emphasizing their utter helplessness before divine intervention.
Theological and Thematic Connections
The officers' despair in Exodus 5:19 serves as a crucial pivot point, highlighting the depth of human helplessness and setting the stage for God's mighty acts of deliverance. This moment underscores the biblical principle that God often allows circumstances to become utterly impossible for human solutions to fail, so that His power and faithfulness can be unmistakably demonstrated. The intensified suffering was part of God's sovereign plan to harden Pharaoh's heart further, preparing the way for the plagues and the ultimate Red Sea deliverance, which would magnify His glory and reveal His covenant faithfulness to Israel.
Reflection and Application
The profound despair experienced by the Israelite officers in Exodus 5:19 resonates deeply with the human condition across all ages. We, too, often find ourselves in "evil cases"—situations where demands seem impossible, resources are scarce, and the path forward appears blocked by unyielding forces or systemic oppression. This verse serves as a poignant reminder to cultivate empathy for those trapped in such seemingly hopeless circumstances, whether due to injustice, illness, or overwhelming life burdens. It compels us to recognize that true liberation, whether personal or corporate, often begins precisely when human efforts utterly fail, and our self-reliance is completely exhausted. This moment of profound helplessness is not an end but a prelude, preparing the way for God's power to be fully revealed. It calls us to trust that even in our darkest moments, when our "case" seems utterly hopeless, the sovereign God is attentive to our cries and is orchestrating a greater deliverance, working all things for His ultimate purpose and glory.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Why did the Israelite officers bear the brunt of Pharaoh's cruelty?
The Israelite officers, or foremen, were appointed by the Egyptian taskmasters to oversee their own people. This made them crucial intermediaries, directly responsible for meeting the quotas set by Pharaoh. When the quotas became impossible to meet due to the withholding of straw, the Egyptian taskmasters beat the Israelite officers as a means of enforcing compliance and punishing perceived failure, as clearly depicted in Exodus 5:14. They were caught in an impossible and agonizing position, suffering from Pharaoh's wrath while also being responsible for the suffering of their kinsmen, embodying the cruel efficiency of the oppressive system.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
The "evil case" of the Israelite officers in Exodus 5:19 powerfully foreshadows humanity's own "evil case" under the pervasive bondage of sin and the impossible demands of the Law. Just as the Israelites were trapped in an unachievable task of brick-making, humanity is trapped in the impossible task of earning righteousness or salvation through works, for "by the works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight, since through the law comes knowledge of sin" (Romans 3:20). Jesus Christ, the ultimate Deliverer, steps into this very "evil case" of humanity. He perfectly fulfilled the Law's righteous demands on our behalf (Matthew 5:17) and, through His perfect obedience and sacrificial death on the cross, He met the ultimate impossible demand of God's justice. By bearing our sin and its penalty, Christ delivered us from the greater bondage of sin and death, offering a freedom and rest that no human effort or "daily task" could ever achieve (Galatians 5:1). He is the true Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29), providing the ultimate rescue from our impossible plight.