1 Samuel 24
David Pleads His Case to Saul 8–15
Saul Acknowledges David's Righteousness 16–22
Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain
Study Notes for 1 Samuel 24
Verse 1
the wilderness of Engedi — En Gedi means 'fountain of a kid'. It is one of the cities 'in the wilderness' of Judah (Josh 15:61–62), and v.1 follows 23:29, where David 'dwelt in strong holds at Engedi'. Saul has 'returned from following the Philistines' (23:27–28), and the pursuit resumes as soon as he is told where David is.
Verse 2
three thousand chosen men — The number of the force Saul chose at the start of his reign (13:2), and the number he brings again against David in 26:2. 'Chosen' is bachar. They go 'upon the rocks of the wild goats' (ya'el), the high hills that are 'a refuge for the wild goats' (Ps 104:18).
Verse 3
to cover his feet — A Hebrew idiom for relieving oneself, the same words as in the servants' guess about Eglon in his summer chamber, 'Surely he covereth his feet' (Judg 3:24). Saul goes into a cave by the sheepcotes, and David and his men 'remained in the sides of the cave'.
Verse 4
the day of which the LORD said unto thee — David's men quote a word, 'I will deliver thine enemy into thine hand', which the history has not recorded; 'deliver' is nathan, as in 23:4 and 23:14. David cuts off 'the skirt of Saul's robe' (kanaph and me'il), the two words used of the skirt of Samuel's mantle that tore in 15:27.
Verse 5
David's heart smote him — The same words are used at 2 Sam 24:10, 'David's heart smote him after that he had numbered the people', where he says at once, 'I have sinned greatly'. Here the cause is that 'he had cut off Saul's skirt'. In v.11 he holds up the same skirt as the evidence of what he had not done.
Verse 6
the LORD'S anointed — Mashiach, 'anointed', is David's title for Saul here, in v.10, at 26:9, 11, 16 and 23, and at 2 Sam 1:14 and 16. 'The LORD forbid' is chalilah, the word of Ahimelech's 'be it far from me' in 22:15. David himself had been anointed by Samuel (16:13) and still refuses to 'stretch forth' his hand.
Verse 8
My lord the king — David 'cried after Saul', then 'stooped with his face to the earth, and bowed himself'. To his men he had said 'my master, the LORD'S anointed' (v.6). The same bowing is recorded of David before Jonathan (20:41) and of Abigail before David (25:23). In 26:17 Saul's question is again 'Is this thy voice, my son David?'
Verse 10
the LORD had delivered thee to day into mine hand — David describes the event with the verb his men used in v.4, 'deliver… into thine hand' (nathan). 'Some bade me kill thee' refers to those men. 'Mine eye spared thee' uses chus, to have pity, and the reason he gives is 'for he is the LORD'S anointed'.
Verse 12
The LORD judge between me and thee — Shaphat, to judge, and naqam, to avenge. David leaves both with the LORD and adds 'mine hand shall not be upon thee', repeating it in v.13 and the appeal in v.15. Jephthah appealed in similar words, 'the LORD the Judge be judge' (Judg 11:27), and Paul cites 'Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord' (Rom 12:19).
Verse 14
a dead dog, after a flea — The questions ask whom 'the king of Israel' has come out after. Par'osh, 'flea', is found only here and at 26:20. Mephibosheth calls himself 'such a dead dog as I am' before David (2 Sam 9:8). David's words describe himself as having no power to threaten a king.
Verse 16
Is this thy voice, my son David? — The same question is asked in the same words at 26:17. David had called Saul 'my father' (v.11), and Saul now says 'my son'. He 'lifted up his voice, and wept' (bakah); in 26:21 he says again 'return, my son David'.
Verse 20
I know well that thou shalt surely be king — Saul says as something he knows what Samuel had told him (15:28) and what Jonathan told David (23:17). Earlier he had asked of the women's song, 'what can he have more but the kingdom?' (18:8). The kingdom 'shall be established in thine hand' (qum, to stand).
Verse 21
Swear now therefore unto me by the LORD — Saul asks what Jonathan had asked of David, that he would not 'cut off' kindness from his house (20:15); the verb 'cut off' is the same (karath). The request is for his 'seed' and 'name'. David swears in v.22, and his kindness to Saul's house follows at 2 Sam 9:1, 'for Jonathan's sake'.