Genesis 38
Judah Settles in Canaan 1–5
Er and Onan Die 6–11
Tamar Deceives Judah 12–23
Judah Judges and Acknowledges 24–26
The Birth of Pharez and Zarah 27–30
Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain
Study Notes for Genesis 38
Verse 1
Judah went down from his brethren — The chapter stops the story of Joseph (ch. 37; 39) to follow Judah, from whom the promise runs: 'The sceptre shall not depart from Judah… until Shiloh come' (Gen 49:10). Judah settles with 'a certain Adullamite, whose name was Hirah', who appears again in vv.12, 20.
Verse 2
a daughter of a certain Canaanite — The verbs are plain: Judah 'saw', 'took', and 'went in unto her'. Abraham had made his servant swear not to take a wife for Isaac 'of the daughters of the Canaanites, among whom I dwell' (Gen 24:3), and Isaac gave Jacob the same charge (Gen 28:1).
Verse 7
wicked in the sight of the LORD — No sin is named. The Hebrew is ra' ('evil') in the eyes of the LORD, and the verb 'slew' is the same in v.10. Er and Onan are remembered in the family lists as the sons of Judah who 'died in the land of Canaan' (Gen 46:12).
Verse 8
raise up seed to thy brother — The duty of a husband's brother, given in the Law: 'her husband's brother shall go in unto her… and the firstborn which she beareth shall succeed in the name of his brother which is dead' (Deut 25:5–6). The Sadducees quote it to Christ (Matt 22:24).
Verse 9
he spilled it on the ground — The verse states the motive: 'lest that he should give seed to his brother'. Under the duty of v.8 the firstborn son would 'succeed in the name of his brother which is dead' (Deut 25:6), so the child would be counted Er's. The verb shachath means to ruin or waste.
Verse 10
displeased the LORD — Literally 'was evil in the eyes of the LORD', the expression used of Er in v.7, and the judgment is the same: 'he slew him also'. The verse gives the LORD's own verdict on 'the thing which he did', the refusal of the duty in v.8.
Verse 11
Remain a widow at thy father's house — Judah's reason is his own fear: 'Lest peradventure he die also, as his brethren did.' Shelah is the third son (v.5). Tamar's return to her father's house leaves the duty unmet, and v.14 says she 'was not given unto him to wife'.
Verse 12
Judah was comforted — The verb nacham is the one used of Jacob, who 'refused to be comforted' for Joseph (Gen 37:35). Judah then 'went up' to the sheepshearers at Timnath. Shearing was an occasion for gathering and feasting: Nabal 'held a feast in his house, like the feast of a king' (1 Sam 25:36).
Verse 14
covered her with a vail — The word tsa'iph is used in Genesis only here (vv.14, 19) and of Rebekah, who 'took a vail, and covered herself' when she met Isaac (Gen 24:65). Tamar puts off the garments of her widowhood because Shelah 'was grown' and she had not been given to him.
Verse 15
he thought her to be an harlot — The verse gives Judah's reason: 'because she had covered her face.' He judges from the veil alone, and v.16 says he 'knew not that she was his daughter in law'. What proves who she is, and who he is, is not her face but the pledge (vv.25–26).
Verse 16
he knew not that she was his daughter in law — The parenthesis tells the reader what Judah does not know. She asks 'What wilt thou give me', which leads to the pledge in vv.17–18. His not knowing is answered in v.26, where he 'acknowledged them'.
Verse 18
Thy signet, and thy bracelets, and thy staff — 'Pledge' is arabon, found in Genesis only in vv.17, 18 and 20. The signet (chotham) is a seal, 'bracelets' is pethil, a cord or thread, and the staff (matteh) is the one in his hand. Together they identify the man 'whose these are' (v.25).
Verse 24
let her be burnt — Judah gives the sentence himself, as soon as he is told. The Law later names burning for a priest's daughter who 'profane herself by playing the whore' (Lev 21:9) and for certain unlawful unions (Lev 20:14). Tamar had been left unmarried by Judah's own promise (v.11).
Verse 25
Discern, I pray thee — Nakar, to look closely and recognise. It is the word of Gen 37:32–33: Judah's brothers sent Jacob the coat with 'know now whether it be thy son's coat or no', and Jacob 'knew it'. The same verb now falls on Judah as it fell on his father.
Verse 26
She hath been more righteous than I — Judah 'acknowledged' (nakar, v.25) the pledge. Tsadeq means to be in the right, and the reason is stated: 'because that I gave her not to Shelah my son.' Judah later says of Benjamin, 'I will be surety for him' (Gen 43:9).
Verse 29
Pharez — Perets, 'breach': 'How hast thou broken forth? this breach be upon thee'. Pharez is in the line to David and Christ (Ruth 4:18–22; Matt 1:3), and the people of Bethlehem blessed Ruth: 'let thy house be like the house of Pharez, whom Tamar bare unto Judah' (Ruth 4:12).