1 Samuel15

Samuel commanded King Saul to utterly destroy the Amalekites and all their possessions as divine judgment. However, Saul spared King Agag and the best of the livestock, claiming they were for sacrifice. Samuel rebuked Saul, declaring that obedience is superior to sacrifice and that God had rejected Saul as king for his disobedience. Samuel then personally executed Agag.

Saul Commanded to Utterly Destroy Amalek

Sh'mu'el said to Sha'ul, "ADONAI sent me to anoint you king over his people, over Isra'el. Now listen to what ADONAI has to say.

Here is what ADONAI-Tzva'ot says: 'I remember what 'Amalek did to Isra'el, how they fought against Isra'el when they were coming up from Egypt.

Now go and attack 'Amalek, and completely destroy everything they have. Don't spare them, but kill men and women, children and babies, cows and sheep, camels and donkeys.'"

Sha'ul summoned the people and reviewed them in T'la'im - 200,000 foot soldiers, with another 10,000 men from Y'hudah.

Sha'ul arrived at the city of 'Amalek and lay in wait in the valley.

Sha'ul said to the Keni, "Go away, withdraw, leave your homes there with the 'Amaleki. Otherwise, I might destroy you along with them, even though you were kind to all the people of Isra'el when they came out of Egypt. So the Keni went away from among the 'Amaleki.

Then Sha'ul attacked 'Amalek, starting at Havilah and continuing toward Shur, at the border of Egypt.

He took Agag the king of 'Amalek alive; but he completely destroyed the people, putting them to the sword.

However, Sha'ul and the people spared Agag, along with the best of the sheep and cattle, and even the second best, also the lambs, and everything that was good - they weren't inclined to destroy these things. But everything that was worthless or weak they completely destroyed.

God Rejects Saul for Disobedience

Then the word of ADONAI came to Sh'mu'el:

"I regret setting up Sha'ul as king, because he has turned back from following me and hasn't obeyed my orders."This made Sh'mu'el very sad, so that he cried to ADONAI all night.

Sh'mu'el got up early in the morning to meet Sha'ul; however, Sh'mu'el was told, "Sha'ul came to Karmel to set up a monument for himself there, but now he has left and is on his way down to Gilgal."

Sh'mu'el went to Sha'ul; Sha'ul said to him, "May ADONAI bless you! I have done what ADONAI ordered."

But Sh'mu'el answered, "If so, why do I hear sheep bleating and cows mooing?"

Sha'ul said, "They brought them from the 'Amaleki, because the people spared the best of the sheep and cattle to sacrifice to ADONAI your God. But we completely destroyed the rest."

Then Sh'mu'el said to Sha'ul, "Stop! I'm going to tell you what ADONAI said to me last night." He said, "Speak."

Obedience Is Better Than Sacrifice

Sh'mu'el then said, "You may be small in your own sight, but you are head of the tribes of Isra'el -ADONAI anointed you king over Isra'el!

Now ADONAI sent you on a mission and told you, 'Go and completely destroy 'Amalek, those sinners; keep making war on them until they have been exterminated.

Why did you seize the spoil instead of paying attention to what ADONAI said? From ADONAI's viewpoint, you have done an evil thing."

Sha'ul said to Sh'mu'el, "I did too pay attention to what ADONAI said, and I carried out the mission on which ADONAI sent me. I brought back Agag the king of 'Amalek, and I completely destroyed 'Amalek.

But the people took some of the spoil, the best of the sheep and cattle set aside for destruction, to sacrifice to ADONAI your God in Gilgal."

Sh'mu'el said, "Does ADONAI take as much pleasure in burnt offerings and sacrifices as in obeying what ADONAI says? Surely obeying is better than sacrifice, and heeding orders than the fat of rams.

"For rebellion is like the sin of sorcery, stubbornness like the crime of idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of ADONAI, he too has rejected you as king."

Saul's Partial Confession and Appeal

Sha'ul said to Sh'mu'el, "I have sinned. I violated the order of ADONAI and your words too, because I was afraid of the people and listened to what they said.

Now, please, pardon my sin; and come back with me, so that I can worship ADONAI."

But Sh'mu'el said to Sha'ul, "I will not go back with you, because you have rejected the word of ADONAI, and ADONAI has rejected you as king over Isra'el."

As Sh'mu'el was turning around to leave, he took hold of the hem of his cloak, and it tore.

Sh'mu'el said to him, "ADONAI has torn the kingdom of Isra'el away from you today and given it to a fellow countryman of yours who is better than you.

Moreover, the Eternal One of Isra'el will not lie or change his mind, because he isn't a mere human being subject to changing his mind."

Then Sha'ul said, "I have sinned; but in spite of that, please show me respect now before the leaders of my people and before Isra'el by coming back with me, so that I can worship ADONAI your God."

So Sh'mu'el followed Sha'ul back, and Sha'ul worshipped ADONAI.

Samuel Executes Agag; Final Separation

Then Sh'mu'el said, "Bring Agag the king of 'Amalek here to me. Agag came to him in chains and said, "Without doubt, mine will be a bitter death."

Sh'mu'el said, "Just as your sword has left women childless, so will your mother be left childless among women." Then Sh'mu'el cut Agag in pieces before ADONAI in Gilgal.

Sh'mu'el returned to Ramah, and Sha'ul went up to his house in Giv'at-Sha'ul.

Never again did Sh'mu'el see Sha'ul, until the day he died. But Sh'mu'el grieved over Sha'ul, and ADONAI regretted that he had made Sha'ul king over Isra'el.

Study Notes for 1 Samuel 15

Verse 1

A reminder to Saul that his kingship depends entirely on obedience to the prophetic word, setting the stage for the crucial test of his reign.

Verse 2

The Amalekites were Israel’s first major enemy after leaving Egypt (Exod. 17:8-16), attacking the weak and stragglers. This command is an act of delayed divine judgment (Deut. 25:17-19).

Verse 3

The command for 'utter destruction' (Hebrew: *herem*) signifies that the objects and people were devoted entirely to God, usually meaning total annihilation, leaving no spoil. This was often reserved for notoriously wicked nations.

Verse 4

The inclusion of a separate count for the ten thousand men of Judah foreshadows the future geopolitical division between the northern tribes and the tribe of Judah.

Verse 6

The Kenites, a nomadic group often associated with Moses' father-in-law (Jethro), are spared because of their historical loyalty and kindness shown to Israel during the Exodus journey.

Verse 8

Saul's decision to spare King Agag was a direct violation of the *herem* command (v. 3). Taking a royal captive was often done for triumphal display, indicating Saul prioritized his own glory over God's instructions.

Verse 9

Saul and the people rationalize their disobedience by only destroying what was 'vile and refuse.' By sparing the best livestock, they sought personal gain, violating the principle that all spoil belonged to God.

Verse 10

The failure of Saul's kingship is now established. God's judgment is based on the king's willful failure to obey the clear divine command.

Verse 11

The phrase 'It repenteth me' (Hebrew *niham*) expresses divine grief and sorrow over the consequences of Saul’s actions and the resulting change in relationship, not an error in divine planning. Samuel’s grief highlights the seriousness of the rejection.

Verse 12

Setting up a monument (a 'place' or 'trophy') in Carmel before reporting to Samuel shows Saul’s vanity and self-aggrandizement, contrasting his behavior with the expectation of humble obedience.

Verse 13

Saul immediately boasts of full obedience, demonstrating either self-deception or a deliberate attempt to minimize the significance of sparing Agag and the livestock.

Verse 15

Saul attempts to shift blame from himself to 'the people' and justifies the disobedience by claiming the animals were saved for religious sacrifice. This pattern of excusing sin through piety is a major theme of the chapter.

Verse 17

Samuel reminds Saul that he was chosen when he was humble ('little in thine own sight'). His current arrogance and desire for spoil betray his initial character.

Verse 19

'Didst fly upon the spoil' suggests greed and eagerness for forbidden gain, showing that the motive for sparing the animals was selfish, despite the later claim of religious intent.

Verse 22

This is a key theological statement. It establishes the priority of moral obedience and submission over ritualistic performance and religious ceremony, a theme echoed throughout the prophets.

Verse 23

Rebellion is equated with divination (witchcraft) and stubbornness with idolatry—sins that directly usurp God's authority. Saul's rejection is final because he rejected the authoritative word of the LORD.

Verse 24

Saul admits sin but immediately attributes his failure to 'fear of the people,' demonstrating that he valued popular approval more than divine command, confirming his unsuitability as king.

Verse 26

Samuel’s refusal to return emphasizes the finality of the divine rejection. The relationship between the prophet and the king is irrevocably broken.

Verse 27

The tearing of Samuel’s mantle serves as a dramatic, non-verbal prophetic sign, symbolizing the tearing away of the kingdom from Saul (v. 28).

Verse 29

'The Strength of Israel' (a title for God) emphasizes God's reliability and immutability. God's rejection decree, unlike human decisions, is irreversible.

Verse 30

Saul’s request for public honor even after judgment shows his continued focus on reputation and appearance rather than true repentance before God.

Verse 32

Agag approaches 'delicately' or 'cheerfully,' assuming the danger had passed since Saul spared him. This provides a stark contrast to the swift justice administered by Samuel.

Verse 33

Samuel carries out the *herem* command that Saul failed to execute, thereby fulfilling God's judgment and demonstrating that the prophetic authority remains supreme over the kingship.

Verse 35

While Samuel ceased formal visits and counsel, he continued to mourn for Saul, indicating personal sorrow over the failed kingship despite acknowledging the righteousness of God’s judgment.

Use ← → arrow keys to navigate

1 Samuel15

Saul Commanded to Utterly Destroy Amalek

God Rejects Saul for Disobedience

Obedience Is Better Than Sacrifice

Saul's Partial Confession and Appeal

Samuel Executes Agag; Final Separation

Reading Style

Typeface

Font Size 19px

Reading Width 45 chars

Options