Skip to content
Share this page

Genesis 3:2

“The Serpent Tempts the Woman”Genesis 3:1–5

King James Version
And the woman said unto the serpent, We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden:

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
And the woman H802 said H559 unto the serpent H5175, We may eat H398 of the fruit H6529 of the trees H6086 of the garden H1588:

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
The woman answered the serpent, “We may eat the fruit of the trees of the garden,

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
And the woman said unto the serpent, Of the fruit of the trees of the garden we may eat:

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
The woman said to the serpent, “We may eat fruit from the trees of the garden,

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
And the woman said vnto the serpent, We eate of the fruite of the trees of the garden,

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
And the woman saith unto the serpent, `Of the fruit of the trees of the garden we do eat,

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
8 Hebrew words
  1. וַתֹּאמֶרva·To·merand she saidH559Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecImperf-3fsVerb Qal Consecutive Imperfect 3rd Singular Feminineוַandתֹּאמֶרshe said
  2. הָאִשָּׁהha·'i·Shahthe womanH802Art ¦ N-fsNoun Singular Feminine Absoluteהָtheאִשָּׁהwoman
  3. אֶל'eltoH413PrepPreposition
  4. הַנָּחָשׁha·na·Chashthe snakeH5175Art ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteהַtheנָּחָשׁsnake
  5. מִפְּרִיmi·pe·Rifrom [the] fruit ofH6529Prep-m ¦ N-mscNoun Singular Masculine Constructמִfromפְּרִי[the] fruit of
  6. עֵץ'etz[the] tree[s] ofH6086N-mscNoun Singular Masculine Construct
  7. הַגָּןha·Ganthe gardenH1588Art ¦ N-csNoun Singular common gender Absoluteהַtheגָּןgarden
  8. נֹאכֵלno·Khelwe will eatH398V-Qal-Imperf-1cpVerb Qal Imperfect 1st Plural common gender
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Hebrew Masoretic text, the same tradition the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “the LORD” where the word-by-word meaning reads “Yahweh”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Hebrew. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
See on the biblical-era maps
All Genesis Sites (Canaan)
All Genesis Sites (Canaan) View full PDF
All Genesis Sites (Middle East)
All Genesis Sites (Middle East) View full PDF

Map © Biblica Open Bible Maps · CC BY-SA 4.0

In the KJVVerse 58 of 31,102 · 0.2%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

The woman answers truly that God has given them the fruit of the garden’s trees to eat, which corrects the serpent’s picture of a stingy God.

“And the woman said unto the serpent,”

The first words a human being speaks to the tempter. She enters the conversation he started.

“We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden:”

True and generous. God had given them every tree but one (Genesis 2:16–17), and her answer corrects the serpent’s “every tree”.

Passage studyGenesis 3:1–5

The Serpent Questions God’s Word

1Now the serpent was more subtil than any beast of the field which the LORD God had made. And he said unto the woman, Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden? 2And the woman said unto the serpent, We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden: 3But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die. 4And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die: 5For God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil.

Summary

In the garden God planted, a serpent more subtle than any other creature speaks to the woman. He opens with a question that twists God’s command. She answers with God’s generous permission and his one prohibition, but she adds to the prohibition and states its warning less firmly. The serpent then contradicts God outright and accuses him of keeping back what would make them like him. In five verses we see how the first temptation came: a question about what God said, a flat denial of it, and a slander against God’s goodness. Scripture names the serpent as the devil, and the rest of the Bible tells how Christ came to destroy his work.

Who the serpent is

Genesis 3 follows straight on from God’s good creation in Genesis 1 and Genesis 2. God had placed the man in a garden of plenty (Genesis 2:8), made the woman from one of his ribs (Genesis 2:21–23), and given one command about the tree of the knowledge of good and evil (Genesis 2:17). Into that scene comes the serpent. The Hebrew word, nâchâsh, simply means a snake or serpent, and Strong’s traces it to the idea of hissing.

Verse 1 calls it a “beast of the field which the LORD God had made”. The serpent is a creature, made by the same LORD God whose name is introduced in Genesis 2:4, and it stands within his creation even while it speaks against him. Among Israel’s neighbours, the Egyptians and Canaanites, serpents could stand for wisdom, fertility, or chaos and evil. Genesis counts this serpent among the animals God made, and it sets one created thing against the word of the supreme God.

What sets it apart from the other animals is that it is “more subtil” than any of them. The word is ʻârûwm, from the verb ʻâram, and it means crafty or cunning, usually in a bad sense, though it can also mean prudent. Proverbs uses it in that good sense for the prudent man (Proverbs 12:16). Here it is cleverness put to work for deceit, as the serpent’s first words show. Paul remembers this moment when he fears for the church at Corinth, “lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtilty, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ” (2 Corinthians 11:3).

Who is speaking through the serpent?

A snake that reasons and talks points to someone behind it, and Scripture names him: “And the great dragon was cast out, that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world” (Revelation 12:9). The serpent in Eden is a real creature and the instrument of Satan, the enemy of God and of mankind. Jesus says of the devil that “he was a murderer from the beginning” and that “he is a liar, and the father of it” (John 8:44), and the first lie in Scripture is told in this passage. So evil comes into human life from outside God’s good creation, through a deceiver who works behind the scenes and through the choice the man and woman make.

“Yea, hath God said?”

The serpent begins with a question. Its first word, ʼaph, can mean “indeed” or “surely”, and it gives what follows the sound of someone only checking a fact: “Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden?” God had said nearly the opposite. He had given them every tree of the garden but one (Genesis 2:16–17). The serpent’s question stretches the one forbidden tree into a ban on all of them, so that God looks stingy and his command looks like a burden.

The question is rhetorical. It asks for no information and is meant to plant doubt about God’s generosity and about his word. The verb for “said”, ʼâmar, is the ordinary word for saying, telling or commanding, and the poison lies in the words it introduces. The serpent uses persuasion and conversation, and temptation in the Bible begins here, with a question about what God said and why he said it, well before any fruit is taken.

The woman’s answer

The woman (ʼishshâh) answers, and her first words are true: “We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden.” She knows that God has given them the garden’s trees for food, and her reply corrects the serpent on the very point he twisted. The verb ʼâkal means to eat, and figuratively to devour or consume. God’s care for what he has made runs through Scripture. A psalm says of every living creature, “These wait all upon thee; that thou mayest give them their meat in due season” (Psalm 104:27–28).

Then she names the exception, “the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden”. She knows which tree it is, and she knows the command came from God, for she says “God hath said”. The name she uses, ʼĕlôhîym, is the name of God in Genesis 1, plural in form and read as a plural of majesty, usually with a singular verb. “Ye shall not eat of it” is exactly what God commanded. Two other things in her reply differ from God’s words in Genesis 2:17.

Neither shall ye touch it

God forbade eating from the tree. The woman adds “neither shall ye touch it”. The verb nâgaʻ means to touch or lay the hand on, and by implication to reach. Her reason is left unstated. She may have wanted a fence around the command for extra safety, or the words may have grown as the command was passed on, since God first gave it to the man. Either way, the addition blurred the exact boundary God had set.

Lest ye die

God’s warning was emphatic: “thou shalt surely die”. In Hebrew the verb mûwth, “die”, is doubled for certainty, môt tāmût. The woman says “lest ye die” (pen temuthun), which names the danger without that doubled certainty and makes a sure result sound like a risk. This weakened the weight of the warning in her own mind, and it gave the serpent his opening to deny it outright in the next verse.

So she has made the command stricter and its penalty less sure. Scripture warns against both: “Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you, neither shall ye diminish ought from it” (Deuteronomy 4:2). Proverbs adds, “Add thou not unto his words, lest he reprove thee, and thou be found a liar” (Proverbs 30:5–6), and the Bible closes with the same warning (Revelation 22:18–19).

Was the woman lying?

Her words read as a mistake, a loose hold on the exact form of what God had said, and nothing in the passage points to a wish to deceive. That is the sobering part. An honest blur in our grasp of God’s word still gives the deceiver room to work, and in the next verse he uses it.

“Ye shall not surely die”

Now the serpent stops asking and contradicts God. God had said “thou shalt surely die” (Genesis 2:17), and the serpent takes God’s own emphatic words and puts “not” (lōʼ) in front of them: “Ye shall not surely die.” It is the first plain lie in Scripture, a lie about God’s word and about what sin brings. He speaks it to the woman, though the command was first given to the man, and he holds out the promise of life where God had warned of certain death.

Death came as God said. Disobedience cut the man and woman off from the fellowship with God they had known, and in time their bodies returned to the dust, as God told the man: “for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return” (Genesis 3:19). Paul traces all human death to this moment: “by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin” (Romans 5:12). The serpent promised that disobedience would cost them nothing, and it cost them everything.

The promise of opened eyes

The serpent’s last words go behind the command to God’s motive. “For God doth know” hints that God forbade the tree to protect himself, to keep the man and woman from rising to his level. That attacks God’s goodness and his truthfulness at once, and it is the foundation of the whole temptation.

He then makes three promises. The first is “your eyes shall be opened”. The verb pâqach is used of opening the senses, especially the eyes. This promise was partly true, which made it all the more dangerous. Their eyes were opened when they ate (Genesis 3:7), and what they saw was their own nakedness, with shame and guilt in place of the insight they were promised.

The second is “ye shall be as gods”. The word is ʼĕlôhîym (elohim), the same word used for God in this very verse and in verses 1 and 3. Its plural form lets it mean divine beings, as the KJV’s “gods”, or God himself. On either rendering the serpent is offering them a place that belongs to God alone.

The third is “knowing good and evil”. The verb yâdaʻ often means knowing by experience, closely and personally. The serpent offers a knowledge of good and evil gained by doing evil, and with it the right to decide for themselves what is good and what is evil. God made them to know good by obeying him and to know evil by turning away from it. True wisdom begins elsewhere: “The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge” (Proverbs 1:7).

What does “ye shall be as gods” mean?

It is an offer of self-rule: to rise above the limits of a creature and to judge right and wrong in God’s place. The serpent holds out what looks like divinity, and what it delivers is pride and rebellion. This is the pride that Isaiah 14:12–15 pictures in one who said in his heart that he would ascend above the stars of God and was brought down to the pit, the pride that brought Satan down. The same pull to define reality and morality for ourselves runs through the rest of the Bible, and the whole of Genesis 3 shows where it leads.

Did God hold back something good?

God’s command was an act of love and protection, a boundary set for their good and flourishing. The serpent’s hint that God was jealous of what they might gain was a lie meant to make God look grudging and restrictive. Their good lay in living with God in trust and obedience, and the knowledge they gained by rebelling brought shame. God’s commands are given for our welfare, and man lives “by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the LORD” (Deuteronomy 8:3).

How the first temptation worked

Read together, the five verses show the enemy’s method. He starts with a question that makes God’s word sound harsh and God sound stingy. He waits while the hearer’s hold on the word slips, then denies God’s warning flatly. Last, he questions God’s motive and promises a gain, blending a partial truth (“your eyes shall be opened”) with outright lies. He uses words throughout, and the choice remains the woman’s, which is why Scripture holds the man and woman responsible.

The weakness he worked on is in us too. Jeremiah says, “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked” (Jeremiah 17:9). Paul’s fear for the Corinthians is that the same subtlety will lead them away from simple devotion to Christ, so this scene is a picture of how deception still comes: through doubt about God’s goodness, and through a shift of our attention from all that he has given to the one thing he has withheld.

Christ and the serpent

This dark beginning carries a promise in the same chapter. God tells the serpent that the woman’s seed “shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel” (Genesis 3:15), the first announcement of the gospel. Jesus is that seed, “made of a woman” (Galatians 4:4). He took on flesh “that through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil” (Hebrews 2:14–15), and “for this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil” (1 John 3:8).

Where the woman’s conversation with the serpent ended in a blurred word and disobedience, Jesus met the tempter in the wilderness and answered each temptation with God’s exact word (Matthew 4:1–11). He is the last Adam (1 Corinthians 15:45), and “by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous” (Romans 5:19). The first man and woman reached to be as God. Christ, who is God, humbled himself, took the form of a servant, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross (Philippians 2:6–8).

The serpent lied, and Christ is the truth (John 14:6), the Word who was with God and was God (John 1:1) and was made flesh (John 1:14). The serpent said they would not die, and death came. Christ rose from the dead, and “as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive” (1 Corinthians 15:20–22). The serpent promised opened eyes and gave shame. Christ gives “the eyes of your understanding being enlightened” (Ephesians 1:18), for he is “the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24), and through him we come to know God, or rather to be known of God (Galatians 4:9). The tree that brought death is answered by the tree of life he gives to those who overcome (Revelation 2:7), by the bread of life who satisfies (John 6:35), and by the fulness from which we receive “grace for grace” (John 1:16).

Standing on what God has said

The serpent’s first move was to ask what God had said, and the woman’s footing slipped on the exact words. The answer for us is to know God’s word well, closely enough to notice when it is being stretched, softened or added to, and to test every voice against it.

It also matters what we remember about God when a boundary feels restrictive. The garden was full of trees he had given freely, and there was one he withheld. When God’s “no” looms larger than all his gifts, the serpent’s picture of God is gaining ground. God’s commands come from the same love that planted the garden, and he can be trusted with what he keeps back.

And when the old promise of being our own judge of good and evil comes around again, we can answer it as Jesus did, with what is written, knowing that the serpent’s head has been bruised by the woman’s seed.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Genesis 3:1–5. He set out his notes in a four-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 5 verses
Passage under commentGenesis 3:1–5
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

We have here an account of the temptation with which Satan assaulted our first parents, to draw them into sin, and which proved fatal to them. Here observe,

I.The tempter, and that was the devil, in the shape and likeness of a serpent.

1.It is certain it was the devil that beguiled Eve. The devil and Satan is the old serpent (Revelation 12:9), a malignant spirit, by creation an angel of light and an immediate attendant upon God's throne, but by sin become an apostate from his first state and a rebel against God's crown and dignity. Multitudes of the angels fell; but this that attacked our first parents was surely the prince of the devils, the ring-leader in the rebellion: no sooner was he a sinner than he was a Satan, no sooner a traitor than a tempter, as one enraged against God and his glory and envious of man and his happiness. He knew he could not destroy man but by debauching him. Balaam could not curse Israel, but he could tempt Israel, Revelation 2:14. The game therefore which Satan had to play was to draw our first parents to sin, and so to separate between them and their God. Thus the devil was, from the beginning, a murderer, and the great mischief-maker. The whole race of mankind had here, as it were, but one neck, and at that Satan struck. The adversary and enemy is that wicked one.

2.It was the devil in the likeness of a serpent. Whether it was only the visible shape and appearance of a serpent (as some think those were of which we read, Exodus 7:12), or whether it was a real living serpent, actuated and possessed by the devil, is not certain: by God's permission it might be either. The devil chose to act his part in a serpent,

(1.)Because it is a specious creature, has a spotted dappled skin, and then went erect. Perhaps it was a flying serpent, which seemed to come from on high as a messenger from the upper world, one of the seraphim; for the fiery serpents were flying, Isaiah 14:29. Many a dangerous temptation comes to us in gay fine colours that are but skin-deep, and seems to come from above; for Satan can seem an angel of light. And,

(2.)Because it is a subtle creature; this is here taken notice of. Many instances are given of the subtlety of the serpent, both to do mischief and to secure himself in it when it is done. We are directed to be wise as serpents. But this serpent, as actuated by the devil, was no doubt more subtle than any other; for the devil, though he has lost the sanctity, retains the sagacity of an angel, and is wise to do evil. He knew of more advantage by making use of the serpent than we are aware of. Observe, There is not any thing by which the devil serves himself and his own interest more than by unsanctified subtlety. What Eve thought of this serpent speaking to her we are not likely to tell, when I believe she herself did not know what to think of it. At first, perhaps, she supposed it might be a good angel, and yet, afterwards, she might suspect something amiss. It is remarkable that the Gentile idolaters did many of them worship the devil in the shape and form of a serpent, thereby avowing their adherence to that apostate spirit, and wearing his colours.

II.The person tempted was the woman, now alone, and at a distance from her husband, but near the forbidden tree. It was the devil's subtlety,

1.To assault the weaker vessel with his temptations. Though perfect in her kind, yet we may suppose her inferior to Adam in knowledge, and strength, and presence of mind. Some think Eve received the command, not immediately from God, but at second hand by her husband, and therefore might the more easily be persuaded to discredit it.

2.It was his policy to enter into discourse with her when she was alone. Had she kept close to the side out of which she was lately taken, she would not have been so much exposed. There are many temptations, to which solitude gives great advantage; but the communion of saints contributes much tot heir strength and safety.

3.He took advantage by finding her near the forbidden tree, and probably gazing upon the fruit of it, only to satisfy her curiosity. Those that would not eat the forbidden fruit must not come near the forbidden tree. Avoid it, pass not by it, Proverbs 4:15.

4.Satan tempted Eve, that by her he might tempt Adam; so he tempted Job by his wife, and Christ by Peter. It is his policy to send temptations by unsuspected hands, and theirs that have most interest in us and influence upon us.

III.The temptation itself, and the artificial management of it.

We are often, in scripture, told of our danger by the temptations of Satan, his devices (2 Corinthians 2:11), his depths (Revelation 2:24), his wiles, Ephesians 6:11. The greatest instances we have of them are in his tempting of the two Adams, here, and Mt. 4. In this he prevailed, but in that he was baffled. What he spoke to them, of whom he had no hold by any corruption in them, he speaks in us by our own deceitful hearts and their carnal reasonings; this makes his assaults on us less discernible, but not less dangerous. That which the devil aimed at was to persuade Eve to cut forbidden fruit; and, to do this, he took the same method that he does still. He questioned whether it was a sin or no, Genesis 3:1. He denied that there was any danger in it, Genesis 3:4. He suggested much advantage by it, Genesis 3:5. And these are his common topics.

1.He questioned whether it was a sin or no to eat of this tree, and whether really the fruit of it was forbidden. Observe,

(1.)He said to the woman, Yea, hath God said, You shall not eat? The first word intimated something said before, introducing this, and with which it is connected, perhaps some discourse Eve had with herself, which Satan took hold of, and grafted this question upon. In the chain of thoughts one thing strangely brings in another, and perhaps something bad at last. Observe here,

[1.]He does not discover his design at first, but puts a question which seemed innocent: "I hear a piece of news, pray is it true? has God forbidden you to eat of this tree?" Thus he would begin a discourse, and draw her into a parley. Those that would be safe have need to be suspicious, and shy of talking with the tempter.

[2.]He quotes the command fallaciously, as if it were a prohibition, not only of that tree, but of all. God had said, Of every tree you may eat, except one. He, by aggravating the exception, endeavours to invalidate the concession: Hath God said, You shall not eat of every tree? The divine law cannot be reproached unless it be first misrepresented.

[3.]He seems to speak it tauntingly, upbraiding the woman with her shyness of meddling with that tree; as if he had said, "You are so nice and cautious, and so very precise, because God has said, 'You shall not eat." The devil, as he is a liar, so he is a scoffer, from the beginning: and the scoffers of the last days are his children.

[4.]That which he aimed at in the first onset was to take off her sense of the obligation of the command. "Surely you are mistaken, it cannot be that God should tie you out from this tree; he would not do so unreasonable a thing." See here, That it is the subtlety of Satan to blemish the reputation of the divine law as uncertain or unreasonable, and so to draw people to sin; and that it is therefore our wisdom to keep up a firm belief of, and a high respect for, the command of God. Has God said, "You shall not lie, nor take his name in vain, nor be drunk," etc.? "Yes, I am sure he has, and it is well said, and by his grace I will abide by it, whatever the tempter suggests to the contrary."

(2.)In answer to this question the woman gives him a plain and full account of the law they were under, Genesis 3:2, Genesis 3:3. Here observe,

[1.]It was her weakness to enter into discourse with the serpent. She might have perceived by his question that he had no good design, and should therefore have started back with a Get thee behind me, Satan, thou art an offence to me. But her curiosity, and perhaps her surprise, to hear a serpent speak, led her into further talk with him. Note, It is a dangerous thing to treat with a temptation, which ought at first to be rejected with disdain and abhorrence. The garrison that sounds a parley is not far from being surrendered. Those that would be kept from harm must keep out of harm's way. See Proverbs 14:7; Proverbs 19:27.

[2.]It was her wisdom to take notice of the liberty God had granted them, in answer to his sly insinuation, as if God has put them into paradise only to tantalize them with the sight of fair but forbidden fruits. "Yea," says she, "we may eat of the fruit of the trees, thanks to our Maker, we have plenty and variety enough allowed us." Note, To prevent our being uneasy at the restraints of religion, it is good often to take a view of the liberties and comforts of it.

[3.]It was an instance of her resolution that she adhered to the command, and faithfully repeated it, as of unquestionable certainty: "God hath said, I am confident he hath said it, You shall not eat of the fruit of this tree;" and that which she adds, Neither shall you touch it, seems to have been with a good intention, not (as some think) tacitly to reflect upon the command as too strict (Touch not, taste not and handle not), but to make a fence about it: "We must not eat, therefore we will not touch. It is forbidden in the highest degree, and the authority of the prohibition is sacred to us." [4.] She seems a little to waver about the threatening, and is not so particular and faithful in the repetition of that as of the precept. God has said, In the day thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die; all she makes of that is, Lest you die. Note, Wavering faith and wavering resolutions give great advantage to the tempter.

2.He denies that there was any danger in it, insisting that, though it might be the transgressing of a precept, yet it would not be the incurring of a penalty: You shall not surely die, Genesis 3:4. "You shall not dying die," so the word is, in direct contradiction to what God had said. Either, (1.) "It is not certain that you shall die," so some. "It is not so sure as you are made to believe it is." Thus Satan endeavours to shake that which he cannot overthrow, and invalidates the force of divine threatenings by questioning the certainty of them; and, when once it is supposed possible that there may be falsehood or fallacy in any word of God, a door is then opened to downright infidelity. Satan teaches men first to doubt and then to deny; he makes them sceptics first, and so by degrees makes them atheists. Or, (2.) "It is certain you shall not die," so others. He avers his contradiction with the same phrase of assurance that God had used in ratifying the threatening. He began to call the precept in question (Genesis 3:1), but, finding that the woman adhered to that, he quitted that battery, and made his second onset upon the threatening, where he perceived her to waver; for he is quick to spy all advantages, and to attack the wall where it is weakest: You shall not surely die. This was a lie, a downright lie; for, [1.] It was contrary to the word of God, which we are sure is true. See 1 John 2:21, 1 John 2:27. It was such a lie as gave the lie to God himself. [2.] It was contrary to his own knowledge. When he told them there was no danger in disobedience and rebellion he said that which he knew, by woeful experience, to be false. He had broken the law of his creation, and had found, to his cost, that he could not prosper in it; and yet he tells our first parents they shall not die. He concealed his own misery, that he might draw them into the like: thus he still deceives sinners into their own ruin. He tells them that, though they sin, they shall not die; and gains credit rather than God, who tells them, The wages of sin is death. Note, Hope of impunity is a great support to all iniquity, and impenitency in it. I shall have peace, though I walk in the imagination of my heart, Deuteronomy 29:19.

3.He promises them advantage by it, Genesis 3:5. Here he follows his blow, and it was a blow at the root, a fatal blow to the tree we are branches of. He not only would undertake that they should be no losers by it, thus binding himself to save them from harm; but (if they would be such fools as to venture upon the security of one that had himself become a bankrupt) he undertakes they shall be gainers by it, unspeakable gainers. He could not have persuaded them to run the hazard of ruining themselves if he had not suggested to them a great probability of bettering themselves.

(1.)He insinuates to them the great improvements they would make by eating of this fruit. And he suits the temptation to the pure state they were now in, proposing to them, not any carnal pleasures or gratifications, but intellectual delights and satisfactions. These were the baits with which he covered his hook. [1.] "Your eyes shall be opened; you shall have much more of the power and pleasure of contemplation than now you have; you shall fetch a larger compass in your intellectual views, and see further into things than now you do." He speaks as if now they were but dim-sighted, and short-sighted, in comparison of what they would be then. [2.] "You shall be as gods, as Elohim, mighty gods; not only omniscient, but omnipotent too;" or, "You shall be as God himself, equal to him, rivals with him; you shall be sovereigns and no longer subjects, self-sufficient and no longer dependent." A most absurd suggestion! As if it were possible for creatures of yesterday to be like their Creator that was from eternity. [3.] "You shall know good and evil, that is, every thing that is desirable to be known." To support this part of the temptation, he abuses the name given to this tree: it was intended to teach the practical knowledge of good and evil, that is, of duty and disobedience; and it would prove the experimental knowledge of good and evil, that is, of happiness and misery. In these senses, the name of the tree was a warning to them not to eat of it; but he perverts the sense of it, and wrests it to their destruction, as if this tree would give them a speculative notional knowledge of the natures, kinds, and originals, of good and evil. And, [4.] All this presently: "In the day you eat thereof you will find a sudden and immediate change for the better." Now in all these insinuations he aims to beget in them, First, Discontent with their present state, as if it were not so good as it might be, and should be. Note, No condition will of itself bring contentment, unless the mind be brought to it. Adam was not easy, no, not in paradise, nor the angels in their first state, Jude 1:6. Secondly, Ambition of preferment, as if they were fit to be gods. Satan had ruined himself by desiring to be like the Most High (Isaiah 14:14), and therefore seeks to infect our first parents with the same desire, that he might ruin them too.

(2.)He insinuates to them that God had no good design upon them, in forbidding them this fruit: "For God doth know how much it will advance you; and therefore, in envy and ill-will to you, he hath forbidden it:" as if he durst not let them eat of that tree because then they would know their own strength, and would not continue in an inferior state, but be able to cope with him; or as if he grudged them the honour and happiness to which their eating of that tree would prefer them. Now,

[1.]This was a great affront to God, and the highest indignity that could be done him, a reproach to his power, as if he feared his creatures, and much more a reproach to his goodness, as if he hated the work of his own hands and would not have those whom he has made to be made happy. Shall the best of men think it strange to be misrepresented and evil spoken of, when God himself is so? Satan, as he is the accuser of the brethren before God, so he accuses God before the brethren; thus he sows discord, and is the father of those that do so.

[2.]It was a most dangerous snare to our first parents, as it tended to alienate their affections from God, and so to withdraw them from their allegiance to him. Thus still the devil draws people into his interest by suggesting to them hard thoughts of God, and false hopes of benefit and advantage by sin. Let us therefore, in opposition to him, always think well of God as the best good, and think ill of sin as the worst of evils: thus let us resist the devil, and he will flee from us.

Historical interpretation

Seven Centuries of Reception

15 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

15 quotes · AD 50–749
Ante-NicenePost-NiceneEarly Medieval
100200300400500600700

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

(32) Did the serpent speak with a human voice? [Gen 3:2] In the first place, it may be the fact that at the beginning of the world even the other animals besides man were not entirely destitute of the power of articulate speech, but only that man excelled them in a greater fluency and perspicuity of speech and language. In the second place, when anything very marvellous requires to be done, God changes the subject natures by which he means to operate. Thirdly, because our soul is entirely filled with many errors, and rendered deaf to all words except in one or two languages to which it is accustomed; but the souls of those who were first created were rendered acute to thoroughly understand every voice of every kind, in order that they might be pure from evil and wholly unpolluted. Since we indeed are not endowed with senses in such perfection, for those which we have received are in some degree depraved, just as the construction of our bodies too is small; but the first created men, as they received bodies of vast size reaching to a gigantic height, must also of necessity have received more accurate senses, and, what is more excellent still, a power of examining into and hearing things in a philosophical manner. For some people think, and perhaps with some reason, that they were endowed with such eyes as enabled them to behold even those natures, and essences, and operations, which exist in heaven, as also ears by which they could comprehend every kind of voice and language.
(33) Why did the serpent accost the woman, and not the man? [Gen 3:2] The serpent, having formed his estimate of virtue, devised a treacherous stratagem against them, for the sake of bringing mortality on them. But the woman was more accustomed to be deceived than the man. For his counsels as well as his body are of a masculine sort, and competent to disentangle the notions of seduction; but the mind of the woman is more effeminate, so that through her softness she easily yields and is easily caught by the persuasions of falsehood, which imitate the resemblance of truth. Since therefore, in his old age, the Serpent{5}{the ancients believed that the serpent became young again by casting his skin. Ovid says--Anguibus exuitur tenui cum pelle vetustas.} strips himself of his scales from the top of his head to his tail, he, by his nakedness, reproaches man because he has exchanged death for immortality. His nature is renewed by the beast, and made to resemble every time. The woman, when she sees this, is deceived; when she ought rather to have looked upon him as an example, who, while showing his ingenuity towards her, was full of devices, but she was led to desire to acquire a life which should be free from old age, and from all decay.
d. AD 373Ephrem the SyrianPost-NiceneSourceCOMMENTARY ON GENESIS 2.16.1
As for the serpent’s speech, either Adam understood the serpent’s own mode of communication, or Satan spoke through it, or the serpent posed the question in his mind and speech was given to it, or Satan sought from God that speech be given to the serpent for a short time.
d. AD 373Ephrem the SyrianPost-NiceneSourceHYMNS ON PARADISE 3.4-5
The serpent could not
enter paradise,
for neither animal
nor bird
was permitted to approach
the outer region of paradise,
and Adam had to go out
to meet them;
so the serpent cunningly learned,
through questioning Eve,
the character of paradise,
what it was and how it was ordered.
When the accursed one learned
how the glory of that inner tabernacle,
as if in a sanctuary,
was hidden from them,
and that the Tree of Knowledge,
clothed with an injunction,
served as the veil
for the sanctuary,
he realized that its fruit
was the key of justice
that would open the eyes of the bold
and cause them great remorse.
d. AD 373Ephrem the SyrianPost-NiceneSourceCOMMENTARY ON GENESIS 2.15.1
Although the serpent was cunning, it was only more cunning than the dumb animals that were governed by Adam. It is not true that because the serpent surpassed the level of animals in cleverness, it was immediately raised up to the level of human rationality. It was only more clever than those animals that lack reason and was only more crafty than the animals that had no mind. For it is clear that the serpent, which did not have the mind of man, did not possess the wisdom of mankind. Adam was also greater than the serpent by the way he was formed, by his soul, by his mind, by his glory and by his place. Therefore it is evident that in cunning also Adam was infinitely greater than the serpent.
d. AD 373Ephrem the SyrianPost-NiceneSourceCOMMENTARY ON GENESIS 2.20.1
The tempter then turned its mind to the commandment of the One who had set down the commandment. Adam and Eve were commanded not only to not eat from the tree, but they were not even to draw near to it. The serpent then realized that God had forewarned them about even looking at it lest they become entrapped by its beauty. With this in mind, the serpent enticed Eve to look upon it.
d. AD 397Ambrose of MilanPost-NiceneSourceLetter 45.10
But since all creatures are subject to passions, lust, with the stealth of a serpent, has crept over man's affections: well therefore has holy Moses represented lust under the similitude of a serpent; for it creeps upon its belly like a serpent, not walking on foot, nor raised up on legs, gliding along by the sinuous contortions, as it were, of its whole body. Its food, as that of the serpent, is earthly, for it knows not heavenly food, but feeds on carnal things, and changes itself into various kinds of desire, and bends to and fro in tortuous wreaths. It has poison in its fangs, whereby the belly of every luxurious man is ripped up, the glutton is slain, the licker up of dishes perishes.
d. AD 397Ambrose of MilanPost-NiceneSourceOn Paradise, 12.56-60
Although you are aware that the serpent is wiser than all creatures, his cunning is especially noticeable here. As he sets his snares, he pretends to give utterance to the words of God, for God had already said: 'From every tree of the garden you may eat, but from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you must not eat, for the day you eat of it you must die. [ Gen 2:16 ] The serpent inserted a falsehood in questioning the woman thus: 'Did God say, you shall not eat of any tree?' Whereas God had actually said: 'From every tree of the garden you may eat, but from one tree you must not eat,' meaning, by that, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil which was not to be tasted. We need not wonder at the manner of deception. Deceit accompanies any effort at ensnaring an individual. The serpent's question was not without its purpose. But the woman's reply will indicate that there was nothing questionable in the command of God: 'Of the fruit of all the trees in the garden we may eat, but of the fruit of the tree in the middle of the garden, God said, you shall not eat of it neither shall you touch it, lest you die.' There was nothing inexact about the command itself. The error lay in the report of the command. The Scriptural passage under discussion is self-explanatory. We realize that we ought not to make any addition to a command even by way of instruction. Any addition or qualification of a command is in the nature of a falsification. The simple, original form of a command should be preserved or the facts should be duly set before us. It frequently happens that a witness adds something of himself to a relation of facts. In this way, by the injection of an untruth, confidence in his testimony is wholly shattered. No addition therefore--not even a good one--is called for. What is, therefore, at first sight objectionable in the addition made by the woman: 'Neither shall you touch anything of it'? God did not say this, but, rather: 'you must not eat.' Still, we have here something which leads to error. There are two possibilities to the addition she made: Either it is superfluous or because of this personal contribution she has made God's command only partly intelligible. John in his writings has made this clear: 'If anyone shall add to them, God will add unto him the plagues that are written in this book. And if anyone shall take away from these words of the book of this prophecy, God will take away his portion from the tree of life.' [ Rev 22:18,19 ] If this is true in this case, how much truer is it that nothing should be taken away from the commands laid down by God! From this springs the primary violation of the command. And many believe that this was Adam's fault-not the woman's. They reason that Adam in his desire to make her more cautious had said to the woman that God had given the additional instruction: 'Neither shall you touch it.' We know that it was not Eve, but Adam, who received the command from God, because the woman had not yet been created. Scripture does not reveal the exact words that Adam used when he disclosed to her the nature and content of the command. At all events, we understand that the substance of the command was given to the woman by the man. What opinions others have offered on this subject should be taken into consideration. It seems to me, however, that the initial violation and deceit was due to the woman. Although there may appear to be an element of uncertainty in deciding which of the two was guilty, we can discern the sex which was liable first to do wrong. Add to this the fact that she stands convicted in court whose previous error is afterward revealed. The woman is responsible for the man's error and not vice-versa. Hence Paul says: 'Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and was in sin.' [ 1 Tim 2:14 ]
Now let us examine another question relative to the addition which was made to the command. Does this addition in itself seem to be objectionable? If the words, 'neither shall you touch it,' are actually advantageous and tend to put one on his guard, why did not God expressly forbid this even to the point of seemingly permitting it by not forbidding it? Wherefore, both points must be examined; namely, the reasons why He neither permitted it nor forbade it. Some raise the question: Why did He not order that the object which He had made should be seen and touched? But, when you realize that there was in that tree the knowledge of good and evil, you can understand that He did not wish you to touch what is evil. Sufficient is it for us, using the words of the Lord, 'to watch Satan fall as lightning from heaven,' [ Luke 10:18 ] and giving to his sons not the meat of life, but that of night and darkness, as it is written: 'He gave him to be meat for the people of the Ethiopians.' [ Ps 73:14 ] Thus far on the subject of the reason why He did not command the tree to be touched. Here are the reasons, as I understand them, why God did not prohibit this act. There are many things which do us harm, if we make up our minds to touch them before we know what they are. We often learn, in fact, by experience to be resigned if we know beforehand that a certain food or drink is bitter. You learn to be tolerant if you believe that what is bitter is beneficial, lest your sudden realization of its bitterness may offend you and cause you to reject what may prove to be salutary. It is advantageous, therefore, first to have knowledge of this bitter quality, so that you may not be squeamish and that you may realize what is good for you. These are examples of what may harm us just to a slight degree. From the discussion which now follows, take warning of what may cause us more serious damage unless we make provision against it.
Take the case of the Gentile who is eager for the faith. He becomes a catechumen and desires a greater fullness of doctrine to strengthen his faith. See to it that in his willingness to learn he is not exposed to false doctrine. Take care that he does not learn from Photinus or from Arius or from Sabellius. See that he does not hand himself over to teachers of this sort who would attract him by their airs of authority, so that his untrained mind, impressed by the weight of such august prestige, will be unable to discriminate the right from the wrong. He should first, therefore, determine with the eyes of his mind what are the logical sequences. Let him note where life exists by touching the life-giving qualities of holy Scripture, so that no interpreter will stand in his way. Sabellius reads for him: 'I am in the Father and the Father in me,' [ John 14:10 ] and says that means one Person. Photinus reads that 'there is one Mediator between God and men, himself man, Christ Jesus.' [ 1 Tim 2:5 ] And elsewhere: 'Why do you wish to kill me, a man?' [ John 8:40 ] Arius, too, read the following: 'For the Father is greater than I.' [ John 14:28 ] The reading is clear, but the catechumen first ought to reflect on the matter in his own mind, so as to discover the real meaning of these passages. He is influenced by the prestige of his teachers. It would have been more to his advantage if he had not investigated at all rather than have come upon such an instructor. But the Gentile, too, if he takes up the Scriptures, reads: 'Eye for eye, tooth for tooth.' [ Lev 24:20 ] Again: 'If thy right hand is an occasion of sin to thee, cut it off.' [ Matt 5:30 ] He does not understand the sense of this. He is not aware of the secret meaning of the divine words. He is worse off than if he had not read at all. Hence he has furnished a lesson to these men on how they should have investigated the meaning of the Word of God. A careful, not a superficial, examination of the context of the passage should be made. It is written: 'What was from the beginning, what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes, what we have looked upon and our hands have investigated: of the Word of Life. And we have seen and now testify and announce to you.' [ John 1:1,2 ] You see how he investigated, so to speak, with his hands the Word of God and afterward announced it. Hence, the Word would not perhaps have caused injury to Adam and Eve if they had first touched and handled it, as it were, with the hands of the mind. Those who are infirm can by careful examination and handling investigate the nature of each and every object which they do not understand. Certainly, those weak first parents of ours should have studied beforehand the problem presented to them: How were they to touch the tree in which they knew there was knowledge of evil? The knowledge of evil, in fact, can frequently be of advantage to us. Wherefore we read in the oracular words of Scripture of the wiles of the Devil, so that we learn how we can escape his arts. We should be aware of his temptations, not that we may follow his lead, but that by instruction we may avoid these pitfalls.
At this point there are some who doubt whether God meant that the fruit of every tree should be eaten-this injunction to include every tree, inclusive of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil-or whether, in fact, He referred to every tree, but excluded only the tree of knowledge of good and evil? These people are of the opinion that this matter is not without significance, because, although the fruit of this tree is harmful in itself, still, if it were combined with that of the other trees, it could not be injurious. They cite as example of this fact the belief that an antidote can be obtained from the body of a serpent which, being poisonous since it is extracted from a serpent, is harmful when taken alone, but when mixed with other drugs has medicinal properties. The knowledge of good and evil, also, if one possesses wisdom that is ever an aid toward survival and if one reaches out after the other types of virtue, is considered to be of no inconsiderable value. On that account, therefore, many hold that we can even understand the reason why God made this prohibition. He did not wish that tree of the knowledge of good and evil should be eaten alone and not in combination with the fruit of the others. He did not prohibit this if the other trees are taken into consideration at the same time. Wherefore what God said to Adam is cited: 'Who told you that you were naked? You have eaten, then, of the tree which alone I commanded you not to eat.' [ Gen 3:11 ] This would seem to offer an occasion for disputation. In the preceding passage the woman might well have not made any reply to the serpent's question: 'Did God say, you shall not eat of any tree of the garden?' But she answered: 'Of the tree in the middle of the garden, God said, you shall not eat of it.' In this incident, as she was on the point of sinning, the woman's faith may appear to have been weak. Moreover, I shall not despoil Adam of all the virtues, so that he would appear to have attained no virtue in Paradise and would seem to have eaten nothing from the other trees, but had fallen into sin before he had obtained any fruit. I shall, therefore, not despoil Adam lest I may despoil the whole human race, which is innocent before it acquires the capacity to know good and evil. Not without reason was it said: 'Unless you turn and become like this child, you shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven.' [ Matt 18:3 ] The child, when he is scolded, does not retaliate. When he is struck, he does not strike back. He is not conscious of the allurements of ambition and self-seeking.
The truth seems to be, then, that He commanded the tree not to be eaten, not even along with the fruit of the other trees. Knowledge of good, in fact, although of no use to a perfect man, is, on the other hand, of no value to a man who is imperfect. Paul speaks of himself as imperfect: 'Not that I have already obtained this or already have been made perfect, but I press on hoping that I may lay hold of it already.' [ Phil 3:12 ] Hence the Lord says to the imperfect: 'Do not judge that you may not be judged.' [ Matt 7:1 ] Knowledge is, therefore, of no use to the imperfect. Hence we read: 'I did not know sin unless the Law had said, thou shalt not lust.' And further on we read: 'For without the Law sin is dead.' [ Rom 7:7,8 ] What advantage is it to me to know what I cannot avoid? What avails it for me to know that the law of my flesh assails me? Paul is assailed and sees 'the law of his flesh warring against that of his mind and making him prisoner to the law of sin.' He does not rely on himself, but by the grace of Christ is confident of his 'deliverance from the body of death.' [ Rom 7:23:24 ] Do you think that anyone with knowledge of sin can avoid it? Paul says: 'For I do not the good that I wish, but the evil that I do not wish.' [ Rom 7:19 ] Do you consider that this knowledge which adds to the reproach of sin can be of help to man? Granted, however, that the perfect man is unable to sin. God foresaw all men in the person of Adam. Hence it was not fitting that the human race in general should have a knowledge of good and evil-a knowledge which he could not utilize because of the weakness of the flesh.
d. AD 397Ambrose of MilanPost-NiceneSourceOn Paradise, 12.54
The cause of envy was the happiness of man placed in paradise, because the devil could not brook the favors received by man. His envy was aroused because man, though formed in slime, was chosen to be an inhabitant of paradise. The devil began to reflect that man was an inferior creature yet had hopes of an eternal life, whereas he, a creature of superior nature, had fallen and had become part of this mundane existence.
d. AD 397Ambrose of MilanPost-NiceneSourceOn Paradise, 12.54
[The Devil] aimed to circumvent Adam by means of the woman. He did not accost the man who had in his presence received the heavenly command. He accosted her who had learned of it from her husband and who had not received from God the command which was to be observed. There is no statement that God spoke to the woman. We know that he spoke to Adam. Hence we must conclude that the command was communicated through Adam to the woman.
d. AD 407John ChrysostomPost-Nicene
Let us, however, listen to what she says to him in reply. That is, when he said, "'Why is it that God said, Do not eat of any tree of the garden?'" the woman replied to the serpent, "'We do eat of every tree of the garden; but of the fruit of the tree in the middle of the garden God said, Do not eat or even touch it in case you die.'" [ Gen 3:2, Gen 3:3 ] Do you see his malice? He said what was not the case so as to entice her into conversation with him and thus learn what was the case. The woman, you see, is evidently encouraged as though he were kindly disposed to her, and she reveals the whole of the instruction, tells him all in detail, and by her reply deprives herself of any excuse. I mean, what could you say in your defense, woman? "God said, Do not eat of any tree in the garden." You ought to have turned away from the speaker and said to him, Be off, you are a cheat, you do not know the force of the direction given us, nor the extent of the enjoyment we have, nor the abundance of good things given us. For your part you said God has told us to taste nothing of any tree, whereas out of his great goodness the Lord and Creator has permitted us enjoyment and control of them all, bidding us keep away only from one, and this likewise out of great care for us lest we taste it and die. You should, had you been in your right mind, have ad dressed these words to him, turned away from him utterly, and have had nothing to do with him nor listened to anything said by him
d. AD 425Severian of GabalaPost-NiceneSourceON THE CREATION OF THE WORLD 6.2
Do not think of the snake the way he currently is, since we now run from him and are disgusted by him. It was not this way in the beginning; the snake was a friend of humanity, even the closest of servants. What, then, made him our enemy? The declaration of God: “You are more cursed than all the cattle, and more than every wild animal. I will place hostility between you and the woman.” This hostility destroyed the friendship. I say “friendship,” but I do not mean an intellectual relationship, it was instead one which mindless creatures are capable of having. The snake used to serve humans in the same way the dog displaces friendship—not with word but by body language. Since it was a creature who held such great closeness to humanity, the snake was a convenient tool for the devil.…So the devil spoke through the snake in order to deceive Adam. Please hear me in love and do not receive my words carelessly. My question is not easy to take. Many scoff, “how did the snake speak, with a human’s voice or with a snake’s hiss?” or “how did Eve understand him?” Before the fall, Adam was filled with wisdom, discernment and prophecy.… When the devil noticed the snake’s intelligence and Adam’s high opinion of it (Adam considered the snake very wise), the devil spoke through the snake so that Adam would think that the snake, being intelligent, was able to imitate even human speech.
d. AD 735BedeEarly MedievalSourceCommentary on Genesis (Hexaemeron)
He then said to the woman: "Did God really command you not to eat from any tree in the Garden?" To which the woman replied: "We may eat the fruit of the trees in the garden, but from the fruit of the tree which is in the middle of the garden, God commanded us not to eat, nor to touch it, lest perhaps we die." "Therefore, first the serpent asked and the woman answered this so that the transgression would be inexcusable, and it could not in any way be said that the woman had forgotten what God had commanded."
d. AD 749John DamasceneEarly MedievalSourceORTHODOX FAITH 2.10
Before the fall, all things were subject to the control of man, because God had made him ruler over all the things on the earth and in the water. And the serpent was on intimate terms with man, associating with him more than all the rest and conversing agreeably with him. For that reason it was through this relation that the devil, who is the source of evil, made that most evil suggestion to our first parents.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Genesis 3:2 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8