TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Romans 7:7–13. His two-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.
To what he had said in the former paragraph, the apostle here raises an objection, which he answers very fully: What shall we say then? Is the law sin? When he had been speaking of the dominion of sin, he had said so much of the influence of the law as a covenant upon that dominion that it might easily be misinterpreted as a reflection upon the law, to prevent which he shows from his own experience the great excellency and usefulness of the law, not as a covenant, but as a guide; and further discovers how sin took occasion by the commandment. Observe in particular,
I.The great excellency of the law in itself. Far be it from Paul to reflect upon the law; no, he speaks honourably of it.
1.It is holy, just, and good, Rom 7:12. The law in general is so, and every particular commandment is so. Laws are as the law-makers are. God, the great lawgiver, is holy, just, and good, therefore his law must needs be so. The matter of it is holy: it commands holiness, encourages holiness; it is holy, for it is agreeable to the holy will of God, the original of holiness. It is just, for it is consonant to the rules of equity and right reason: the ways of the Lord are right. It is good in the design of it; it was given for the good of mankind, for the conservation of peace and order in the world. It makes the observers of it good; the intention of it was to better and reform mankind. Wherever there is true grace there is an assent to this - that the law is holy, just, and good.
2.The law is spiritual (Rom 7:14), not only in regard to the effect of it, as it is a means of making us spiritual, but in regard to the extent of it; it reaches our spirits, it lays a restraint upon, and gives a direction to, the motions of the inward man; it is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart, Heb 4:12. It forbids spiritual wickedness, heart-murder, and heart-adultery. It commands spiritual service, requires the heart, obliges us to worship God in the spirit. It is a spiritual law, for it is given by God, who is a Spirit and the Father of spirits; it is given to man, whose principal part is spiritual; the soul is the best part, and the leading part of the man, and therefore the law to the man must needs be a law to the soul. Herein the law of God is above all other laws, that it is a spiritual law. Other laws may forbid compassing and imagining, etc., which are treason in the heart, but cannot take cognizance thereof, unless there be some overt act; but the law of God takes notice of the iniquity regarded in the heart, though it go no further. Wash thy heart from wickedness, Jer 4:14. We know this: Wherever there is true grace there is an experimental knowledge of the spirituality of the law of God.
II.The great advantage that he had found by the law.
1.It was discovering: I had not known sin but by the law, Rom 7:7. As that which is straight discovers that which is crooked, as the looking-glass shows us our natural face with all its spots and deformities, so there is no way of coming to that knowledge of sin which is necessary to repentance, and consequently to peace and pardon, but by comparing our hearts and lives with the law. Particularly he came to the knowledge of the sinfulness of lust by the law of the tenth commandment. By lust he means sin dwelling in us, sin in its first motions and workings, the corrupt principle. This he came to know when the law said, Thou shalt not covet. The law spoke in other language than the scribes and Pharisees made it to speak in; it spoke in the spiritual sense and meaning of it. By this he knew that lust was sin and a very sinful sin, that those motions and desires of the heart towards sin which never came into act were sinful, exceedingly sinful. Paul had a very quick and piercing judgment, all the advantages and improvements of education, and yet never attained the right knowledge of indwelling sin till the Spirit by the law made it known to him. There is nothing about which the natural man is more blind than about original corruption, concerning which the understanding is altogether in the dark till the Spirit by the law reveal it, and make it known. Thus the law is a schoolmaster, to bring us to Christ, opens and searches the wound, and so prepares it for healing. Thus sin by the commandment does appear sin (Rom 7:13); it appears in its own colours, appears to be what it is, and you cannot call it by a worse name than its own. Thus by the commandment it becomes exceedingly sinful; that is, it appears to be so. We never see the desperate venom or malignity there is in sin, till we come to compare it with the law, and the spiritual nature of the law, and then we see it to be an evil and a bitter thing.
2.It was humbling (Rom 7:9): I was alive. He thought himself in a very good condition; he was alive in his own opinion and apprehension, very secure and confident of the goodness of his state. Thus he was once, pote - in times past, when he was a Pharisee; for it was the common temper of that generation of men that they had a very good conceit of themselves; and Paul was then like the rest of them, and the reason was he was then without the law. Though brought up at the feet of Gamaliel, a doctor of the law, though himself a great student in the law, a strict observer of it, and a zealous stickler for it, yet without the law. He had the letter of the law, but he had not the spiritual meaning of it - the shell, but not the kernel. He had the law in his hand and in his head, but he had it not in his heart; the notion of it, but not the power of it. There are a great many who are spiritually dead in sin, that yet are alive in their own opinion of themselves, and it is their strangeness to the law that is the cause of the mistake. But when the commandment came, came in the power of it (not to his eyes only, but to his heart), sin revived, as the dust in a room rises (that is, appears) when the sun-shine is let into it. Paul then saw that in sin which he had never seen before; he then saw sin in its causes, the bitter root, the corrupt bias, the bent to backslide, - sin in its colours, deforming, defiling, breaking a righteous law, affronting an awful Majesty, profaning a sovereign crown by casting it to the ground, - sin in its consequences, sin with death at the heels of it, sin and the curse entailed upon it. "Thus sin revived, and then I died; I lost that good opinion which I had had of myself, and came to be of another mind. Sin revived, and I died; that is, the Spirit, but the commandment, convinced me that I was in a state of sin, and in a state of death because of sin." Of this excellent use is the law; it is a lamp and a light; it converts the soul, opens the eyes, prepares the way of the Lord in the desert, rends the rocks, levels the mountains, makes ready a people prepared for the Lord.
III.The ill use that his corrupt nature made of the law notwithstanding.
1.Sin, taking occasion by the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence, Rom 7:8. Observe, Paul had in him all manner of concupiscence, though one of the best unregenerate men that ever was; as touching the righteousness of the law, blameless, and yet sensible of all manner of concupiscence. And it was sin that wrought it, indwelling sin, his corrupt nature (he speaks of a sin that did work sin), and it took occasion by the commandment. The corrupt nature would not have swelled and raged so much if it had not been for the restraints of the law; as the peccant humours in the body are raised, and more inflamed, by a purge that is not strong enough to carry them off. It is incident to corrupt nature, in vetitum niti - to lean towards what is forbidden. Ever since Adam ate forbidden fruit, we have all been fond of forbidden paths; the diseased appetite is carried out most strongly towards that which is hurtful and prohibited. Without the law sin was dead, as a snake in winter, which the sunbeams of the law quicken and irritate.
2.It deceived men. Sin puts a cheat upon the sinner, and it is a fatal cheat, Rom 7:11. By it (by the commandment) slew me. There being in the law no such express threatening against sinful lustings, sin, that is, his won corrupt nature, took occasion thence to promise him impunity, and to say, as the serpent to our first parents, You shall not surely die. Thus it deceived and slew him.
3.It wrought death in me by that which is good, Rom 7:13. That which works concupiscence works death, for sin bringeth forth death. Nothing so good but a corrupt and vicious nature will pervert it, and make it an occasion of ins; no flower so sweet by sin will such poison out of it. Now in this sin appears sin. The worst thing that sin does, and most like itself, is the perverting of the law, and taking occasion from it to be so much the more malignant. Thus the commandment, which was ordained to life, was intended as a guide in the way to comfort and happiness, proved unto death, through the corruption of nature, Rom 7:10. Many a precious soul splits upon the rock of salvation; and the same word which to some is an occasion of life unto life is to others an occasion of death unto death. The same sun that makes the garden of flowers more fragrant makes the dunghill more noisome; the same heat that softens wax hardens clay; and the same child was set for the fall and rising again of many in Israel. The way to prevent this mischief is to bow our souls to the commanding authority of the word and law of God, not striving against, but submitting to it.
Historical interpretation
Two Centuries of Reception
13 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.
Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.
But how high an encomium of the law (do we obtain) from this fact, that by it there comes to light the latent presence of sin! It was not the law, therefore, which led me astray, but "sin, taking occasion by the commandment." Why then do you, (O Marcion, ) impute to the God of the law what His apostle dares not impute even to the law itself? Nay, he adds a climax: "The law is holy, and its commandment just and good.
I do not know why it is, but things which are forbidden are desired all the more. Thus it happened that although the commandment is holy and just and good, since because it forbids evil it must be good, yet in forbidding covetousness it provoked and inflamed it all the more, with the result that something good wrought death in me.
For when the law was given, the devil had it in his power to work lust in me; "for without the law, sin was dead; "
By “all kinds of covetousness” Paul means every sin. [In the last verse] he mentioned covetousness according to the law, and now by adding other sins he shows that all covetousness works in man by the impulse of the devil, whom he calls “sin,” so that the law was given to man to promote the opposite. For when the devil saw the help provided by the law for man, whom he was delighted to have snared as much by his own sin as by the sin of Adam, he realized that this was done against him. For when he saw man placed under the law he knew that he would escape from his control, for now man knew how to escape the punishment of hell. For this reason his wrath was kindled against man, in order to turn him away from the law and get him to do what was forbidden, so that he would again offend God and fall back into the devil’s power.“Apart from the law sin lies dead.” This is to be understood in two ways. First, you should realize that the devil is meant when the word sin is used and that it also refers here to sin itself. The devil is said to have died because before the law came he did not conspire to deceive man and was quiet, as if unable to possess him. But, second, “sin was also dead,” because it was thought that it would not be reckoned by God. For that reason it was dead as far as natural man was concerned, as if he could sin without being punished. In fact sin was not absent, as I have already indicated, but this was not realized until it became clear by the giving of the law, i.e., that sin would revive. But how could it revive unless it had previously been alive and after the fall of man was thought to be dead when in fact it was still living? People thought that sin was not being reckoned to them, when in fact it was. Thus something which was alive was assumed to be dead.
By “sin,” Paul presumably means the devil. For just as Scripture sometimes calls the Savior “life” and “righteousness” because he is the source of life and righteousness, so it calls the opposing power by what it causes—sometimes “sin,” sometimes “lie,” sometimes “death.”
So, then, brethren, having received no small occasion to repent, while we have opportunity, let us turn to God who called us, while yet we have One to receive us. For if we renounce these indulgences and conquer the soul by not fulfilling its wicked desires, we shall be partakers of the mercy of Jesus.
Do you see how he has cleared it of all blame? For "sin," he says, "taking occasion by the commandment," it was, and not the Law, that increased the concupiscence, and the reverse of the Law's intent was brought about. This came of weakness, and not of any badness. For when we desire a thing, and then are hindered of it, the flame of the desire is but increased. Now this came not of the Law; for it hindered us (endeavored) of itself to keep us off from it; but sin, that is, thy own listlessness and bad disposition, used what was good for the reverse. But this is no fault in the physician, but in the patient who applies the medicine wrongly. For the reason of the Law being given was, not to inflame concupiscence, but to extinguish it, though the reverse came of it. Yet the blame attaches not to it, but to us. Since if a person had a fever, and wanted to take cold drink when it was not good for him, and one were not to let him take his fill of it, and so increase his lust after this ruinous pleasure, one could not deservedly be found fault with. For the physician's business is simply prohibiting it, but the restraining himself is the patient's. And what if sin did take occasion from it? Surely there are many bad men who by good precepts grow in their own wickedness. For this was the way in which the devil ruined Judas, by plunging him into avarice, and making him steal what belonged to the poor. However it was not the being entrusted with the bag that brought this to pass, but the wickedness of his own spirit. And Eve, by bringing Adam to eat from the tree, threw him out of Paradise. But neither in that case was the tree the cause, even if it was through it that the occasion took place.
It is not reasonable to condemn completely someone who has sinned in ignorance. But when the law was given and revealed sin, it gave sin power. This was not a condemnation of the law but a punishment of the contempt shown by those who did not keep it. For if it is true that without the law sin lies dead, it is also true that sin is dead when the law is kept.
Paul says that without the law to define it sin would not be effective. Why? Because it is not the deed by itself which is sin but rather doing something when you know that it is wrong.
Not every sort of lust existed before the prohibition increased it. For since the prohibition increases lust when the Deliverer’s grace is missing, it is clear that not all lust existed beforehand. But when, in the absence of grace, lust was forbidden, it grew so much that it reached its own kind of completeness, to the point that it appeared in opposition to the law and added criminal offense to the transgression. When Paul says: “Apart from the law sin lies dead,” he does not mean that it does not exist but rather that it lies hidden. He makes this clear [in verse 13]. The law is therefore good, but without grace it only reveals sins; it does not take them away.
By “sin lies dead,” Paul means that it is “latent” in us.
By “sin is dead” the apostle means that it is not “imputed” to us.
I think that what Paul means here is something like this: Even though the person who sins in ignorance is guilty, there will be a harsher punishment for the one who sins knowingly.
Continue studying Romans 7:8 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
CNTR CollationThe earliest Greek manuscripts of this verse, collated letter by letter.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
In Romans 7:8, the Apostle Paul profoundly articulates how the Mosaic Law, though holy and good, paradoxically served to expose and even intensify the sinful nature within him. He explains that sin, leveraging the very prohibitions of the commandment, actively worked to produce all manner of illicit desires, demonstrating its deceptive power. Paul concludes that without the explicit standard of the Law, sin's true nature and its destructive force remained dormant or "dead," unable to fully manifest its condemning power.
Context
Literary Context
Romans 7:8 is a pivotal verse within Paul's extended argument in Romans 7 concerning the relationship between the Law, sin, and the believer's experience. It immediately follows Paul's declaration in Romans 7:7 that he would not have known sin apart from the Law, specifically citing the commandment "You shall not covet." This verse elaborates on how the Law revealed sin, portraying sin as an active, malicious agent that exploits the Law's prohibitions. It sets the stage for Paul's subsequent lament about his internal struggle in Romans 7:14-25, ultimately leading to the triumphant declaration of freedom in Christ found in Romans 8.
Historical & Cultural Context
Paul, a former Pharisee, was deeply steeped in the Jewish understanding of the Torah (Law) as God's divine revelation and guide for life. For Jews, the Law was a source of national identity and a means of righteousness. However, Paul's experience, as articulated here, challenges the notion that mere adherence to the Law could bring salvation or eradicate sin. This perspective would have been revolutionary and potentially controversial to his Jewish audience, who revered the Law. Culturally, the concept of "law" (Greek: nomos) was also present in Greco-Roman thought, but Paul's theological use of it, particularly in relation to sin and grace, was distinctively Christian, drawing heavily on Old Testament themes while reinterpreting them through the lens of Christ.
Key Themes
This verse contributes significantly to several key themes in Romans. Firstly, it underscores the Law's revelatory purpose, showing that its primary function is not to justify but to expose the depth of human sinfulness, acting as a mirror to our fallen condition (Romans 3:20). Secondly, it highlights the active and deceptive power of sin, personifying it as an entity that "takes occasion" and "wrought" evil, demonstrating its dominion over humanity apart from Christ. Thirdly, it implicitly points to human inability to overcome sin through personal effort or adherence to external commands, thereby building a compelling case for the necessity of divine grace and the righteousness that comes through faith in Jesus Christ, a major theme throughout the book of Romans.
Exposition and Analysis
Key Word Analysis
From hamartánō, meaning "to miss the mark." In this context, it refers to the abstract principle of sin, the inherent fallen nature, rather than specific acts of transgression. Paul personifies this principle, portraying it as an active, malevolent force operating within humanity.
Literally "a starting-point" or "base of operations." This term vividly illustrates how sin leverages the good Law of God as a strategic platform or opportunity to exert its power and manifest its destructive influence within the human heart. The Law, by defining sin, inadvertently provided sin with the means to become more clearly recognized and active.
From katá (down, against) and ergázomai (to work). It means "to work fully," "accomplish," or "produce." This word emphasizes the active, effective, and complete way sin operates. It's not a passive presence but an energetic force that fully produces its desired outcome—in this case, "all manner of concupiscence."
A longing, especially for what is forbidden. While epithymía can denote any strong desire, in this context, it specifically refers to illicit, sinful cravings or lusts. It encompasses a wide range of covetous desires that are contrary to God's will, which the Law, particularly the tenth commandment, brought to light.
Verse Breakdown
"But sin, taking occasion by the commandment"
Paul introduces a contrast ("But") to his previous statement. He personifies "sin" as an active agent, demonstrating its cunning. Sin seizes an "occasion" or opportunity (aphormē) from "the commandment" (likely referring to the Mosaic Law in general, or specifically the prohibition against coveting from Romans 7:7). The Law, intended to guide righteousness, inadvertently provides sin with a platform to reveal its power.
"wrought in me all manner of concupiscence."
Sin, having taken its opportunity, actively "wrought" or produced (katergázomai) its effects. The phrase "in me" refers to Paul's own experience, representing the universal human condition. Sin produced "all manner of concupiscence" (epithymía), meaning every kind of illicit desire, craving, or lust. This indicates that the Law, by forbidding certain actions, paradoxically stirred up the very desires it sought to suppress in the fallen human heart, making the individual acutely aware of their pervasive sinfulness.
"For without the law sin [was] dead."
This clause explains the preceding statement. "Without the law" means in the absence of God's explicit divine standard. "Sin was dead" does not imply that sin did not exist or that people were not sinful before the Law. Rather, it means sin was dormant, inactive in its full condemning power, or not fully recognized as transgression. The Law gave sin its definition, its power to condemn, and its clear manifestation as rebellion against God's revealed will. Without the Law, sin's true nature and its ability to bring spiritual death (Romans 6:23) were not fully evident or charged.
Literary Devices
Paul masterfully employs Personification in this verse, portraying "sin" not as an abstract concept but as an active, cunning, and malevolent entity. Sin "takes occasion" and "wrought" (or "produced"), giving it agency and intent. This literary device vividly conveys the powerful and insidious nature of sin, which operates almost independently, exploiting even good things (like the Law) for its destructive purposes. Furthermore, the phrase "sin was dead" functions as a Metaphor, illustrating that without the Law's clear prohibitions, sin lacked its full vitality, definition, and condemning power, akin to something lifeless or dormant. It was not truly "dead" in the sense of non-existence, but "dead" in its inability to be fully recognized or to bring about its full legal consequence.
Theological and Thematic Connections
Romans 7:8 is crucial for understanding the Law's role in God's redemptive plan. It clarifies that the Law's purpose is not to grant righteousness, for it cannot overcome the power of indwelling sin. Instead, the Law serves as a divine magnifying glass, exposing the pervasive nature of sin and driving humanity to recognize its utter helplessness and desperate need for a Savior. This profound theological insight sets the stage for Paul's glorious exposition of justification by faith in Christ, where the power of sin is broken not by legal adherence but by the liberating power of the Holy Spirit. The Law reveals the disease; Christ provides the cure.
Reflection and Application
This verse offers profound insights into the human condition and the nature of temptation. It teaches us that merely knowing God's commands is insufficient to overcome sin; in fact, the very act of prohibition can sometimes awaken dormant desires in our fallen nature. This highlights the ongoing spiritual battle within every believer, a struggle between the flesh and the Spirit. For us, the Law serves as a mirror, not a ladder. It shows us our spiritual brokenness and our inability to achieve righteousness on our own, thereby cultivating humility and a deeper reliance on God's grace. Understanding this dynamic helps us to cease striving in our own strength and instead to lean fully on the empowering work of the Holy Spirit, who enables us to walk in newness of life, fulfilling the righteous requirements of the Law not by compulsion but by love.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Does Romans 7:8 mean the Law is bad or causes sin?
No, Romans 7:8 does not mean the Law is bad or causes sin. Paul explicitly states in Romans 7:12 that "the law is holy, and the commandment holy and just and good." The problem lies not with the Law, but with indwelling sin and the fallen human nature. The Law, by defining sin and its prohibitions, provides sin with an "occasion" or opportunity to manifest its power. It's like a spotlight that reveals dirt; the spotlight doesn't create the dirt, but it makes it visible. The Law exposes the sin that is already present in the human heart, making us aware of our transgressions and our inability to perfectly obey God's righteous standards.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
Romans 7:8, by exposing the Law's inability to conquer indwelling sin and its paradoxical effect of stirring up illicit desires, powerfully underscores humanity's desperate need for a Savior. The "deadness" of sin without the Law, and its subsequent "life" through the Law's revelation, highlights the inescapable reality of human depravity under the Law's condemning power. This sets the stage for the glorious truth of Christ's work. Jesus Christ, through His perfect obedience and sacrificial death, fulfilled the Law's righteous demands on our behalf and broke the power of sin that once held us captive (Romans 8:3-4). Where the Law could only expose and condemn, Christ provides liberation and empowerment. The "concupiscence" that the Law revealed is now confronted by the transforming power of the Holy Spirit, who indwells believers, enabling them to walk not according to the flesh but according to the Spirit (Romans 8:9-11). Thus, Christ is the ultimate answer to the dilemma posed in Romans 7, offering freedom from the dominion of sin and the curse of the Law, leading to a life of righteousness by faith (Romans 8:1-2).