Exodus 22:9

KJV

For all manner of trespass, [whether it be] for ox, for ass, for sheep, for raiment, [or] for any manner of lost thing, which [another] challengeth to be his, the cause of both parties shall come before the judges; [and] whom the judges shall condemn, he shall pay double unto his neighbour.

KJV (with Strong's)

For all manner {H1697} of trespass {H6588}, whether it be for ox {H7794}, for ass {H2543}, for sheep {H7716}, for raiment {H8008}, or for any manner of lost thing {H9}, which another challengeth {H559} to be his, the cause {H1697} of both parties {H8147} shall come {H935} before the judges {H430}; and whom the judges {H430} shall condemn {H7561}, he shall pay {H7999} double {H8147} unto his neighbour {H7453}.

Complete Jewish Bible

In every case of dispute over ownership, whether of an ox, a donkey, a sheep, clothing, or any missing property, where one person says, 'This is mine,' both parties are to come before God; and the one whom God condemns must pay the other one double.

Berean Standard Bible

In all cases of illegal possession of an ox, a donkey, a sheep, a garment, or any lost item that someone claims, ‘This is mine,’ both parties shall bring their cases before the judges. The one whom the judges find guilty must pay back double to his neighbor.

American Standard Version

For every matter of trespass, whether it be for ox, for ass, for sheep, for raiment, or for any manner of lost thing, whereof one saith, This is it, the cause of both parties shall come before God; he whom God shall condemn shall pay double unto his neighbor.

Commentary

### SUMMARY
Exodus 22:9 delineates a critical legal principle within the Mosaic covenant, addressing disputes over property where ownership is contested, whether due to alleged theft or the finding of lost items. This statute mandates that such cases be brought before the designated judicial authorities, ensuring a fair and impartial hearing. The verse further prescribes a specific penalty: the party found guilty of wrongful possession or false accusation must pay double the value of the disputed item to their neighbor, thereby upholding justice, deterring dishonesty, and providing comprehensive restitution for the wronged party within the Israelite community.

### CONTEXT
* **Literary Context:** Exodus 22:9 is strategically placed within the "Book of the Covenant" ([Exodus 20:22-23:33](/exodus/20-22-23-33 "The Book of the Covenant - Laws and Ordinances")), which immediately follows the giving of the Ten Commandments. This section serves as a practical application and elaboration of the Decalogue's foundational moral principles, particularly those concerning property rights and interpersonal relationships (e.g., "You shall not steal" in [Exodus 20:15](/exodus/20-15 "Exodus 20:15 - You Shall Not Steal")). Chapters 21 and 22 specifically detail civil laws, covering various scenarios from personal injury to property damage and theft. While earlier verses in Exodus 22 (like [Exodus 22:1-4](/exodus/22-1-4 "Exodus 22:1-4 - Laws Concerning Theft")) address clear-cut cases of theft and the required restitution, verse 9 extends these principles to more ambiguous situations where ownership is disputed or a lost item is found, necessitating formal judicial arbitration rather than direct accusation. This progression demonstrates a comprehensive legal framework designed to cover a wide array of communal interactions and potential conflicts, ensuring justice even in complex circumstances.
* **Historical & Cultural Context:** The legal framework presented in Exodus, including verse 9, reflects a blend of unique divine revelation and adaptations of ancient Near Eastern legal traditions. Unlike some surrounding cultures that might have allowed for self-redress or arbitrary punishment, the Mosaic Law consistently emphasizes a structured, impartial judicial process. The concept of "judges" (often referred to as *ʾĕlōhîm*, implying divine authority or representatives) was fundamental to maintaining order and justice within the tribal society of early Israel. These judges, often elders or appointed leaders, were responsible for discerning truth and applying God's statutes. The emphasis on restitution, particularly the "double" payment, was a common legal principle in the ancient world, serving both as a punitive measure and a means of full restoration to the wronged party. This system aimed to prevent cycles of vengeance, promote social stability, and reinforce the community's commitment to righteousness and justice, as frequently called for in the Law (e.g., [Deuteronomy 16:18-20](/deuteronomy/16-18-20 "Deuteronomy 16:18-20 - Appointment and Duty of Judges")).
* **Key Themes:** Exodus 22:9 contributes significantly to several overarching themes within the Book of Exodus and the Pentateuch. Foremost is the theme of **Divine Justice and Righteousness**, demonstrating God's meticulous concern for equity and fairness among His people. The law underscores that justice is not merely a human construct but a reflection of God's own character. Another key theme is **Community Order and Stability**, as the detailed legal codes provide a framework for resolving disputes peacefully and maintaining social harmony, preventing chaos and vigilantism. The emphasis on restitution highlights the theme of **Restoration and Reconciliation**, showing that God's laws aim not only to punish wrongdoing but also to heal broken relationships and restore what was lost. Finally, the role of the "judges" points to the theme of **Delegated Authority and Accountability**, where human leaders are entrusted with the sacred task of administering God's justice, underscoring their responsibility to act with integrity and impartiality. This verse, therefore, is a practical outworking of God's desire for a holy and just society.

### EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS
#### Key Word Analysis
* **Trespass (Hebrew, _peshaʻ'_):** The Hebrew word פֶּשַׁע (_peshaʻ'_) is a strong term, often translated as "transgression," "rebellion," or "offense." It implies a deliberate breaking away from an established order or covenant relationship. In the context of Exodus 22:9, it signifies a wrongful act against another's property rights, whether through theft, wrongful retention of lost property, or a false accusation regarding ownership. It highlights that such an act is not merely a civil wrong but a violation of the divine order and the covenant relationship established for Israelite society, carrying moral and spiritual weight.
* **Judges (Hebrew, _ʼĕlôhîym'_):** The word אֱלֹהִים (_ʼĕlôhîym'_) typically refers to God, but in specific legal contexts, as here, it can refer to human judges who are seen as acting on God's behalf or possessing a divinely delegated authority in dispensing justice. This usage profoundly underscores the sacred nature of the judicial process in Israel; decisions rendered by these judges were considered to be divinely sanctioned, reflecting God's own judgment and righteousness. Their role was not merely administrative but sacerdotal, embodying God's concern for justice and truth within the community.
* **Double (Hebrew, _shᵉnayim'_):** The term שְׁנַיִם (_shᵉnayim'_) signifies "two" or "twofold," indicating a doubling. This prescribed penalty of paying double was a common form of restitution and punishment in ancient Near Eastern law and is frequently found in the Mosaic Law (e.g., [Exodus 22:4](/exodus/22-4 "Exodus 22:4 - Restitution for Stolen Livestock")). It served multiple purposes: it fully compensated the wronged party for their loss, acted as a significant deterrent against false claims or wrongful possession, and imposed a punitive measure on the condemned party, ensuring that dishonesty carried a substantial cost. This penalty went beyond mere replacement, aiming to restore the victim and deter the offender.

#### Verse Breakdown
* **"For all manner of trespass, [whether it be] for ox, for ass, for sheep, for raiment, [or] for any manner of lost thing, which [another] challengeth to be his":** This opening clause broadly defines the extensive scope of the law. It encompasses any type of property dispute, from valuable livestock (ox, ass, sheep) to personal items like clothing, or any other "lost thing" whose ownership is contested. The phrase "which another challengeth to be his" specifically addresses situations where there is a dispute over who rightfully owns the item, implying either an accusation of wrongful possession (e.g., theft or finding and not returning) or a counter-claim of ownership. This highlights the law's application to ambiguous or disputed cases rather than clear-cut theft.
* **"the cause of both parties shall come before the judges":** This clause mandates the formal legal process. It dictates that such disputes are not to be settled privately through vigilantism, personal vendettas, or arbitrary means, but must be brought before the designated judicial authority. This ensures impartiality, due process, and a public resolution according to the established laws, reinforcing the principle that justice is a communal responsibility overseen by divinely appointed arbiters who act on God's behalf.
* **"[and] whom the judges shall condemn, he shall pay double unto his neighbour":** This final clause specifies the outcome and penalty. Once the judges have heard the evidence, discerned the truth, and rendered a verdict, the party found guilty (whether of wrongful possession, theft, or a false claim that could not be substantiated) is required to pay double the value of the disputed item to the innocent party. This "double" payment is a comprehensive form of justice, encompassing full restitution for the loss, a punitive fine for the transgression, and a strong deterrent against future dishonest actions, thereby restoring equilibrium and deterring further wrongdoing within the community.

#### Literary Devices
Exodus 22:9 employs several literary devices characteristic of biblical law, designed for clarity, comprehensiveness, and impact. It is a prime example of **Casuistic Law**, which presents specific cases and their corresponding legal outcomes. Although the "if...then" structure is implied rather than explicit ("For all manner of trespass... the cause... shall come... and whom... shall condemn, he shall pay..."), the verse clearly outlines a scenario and its prescribed legal consequence. The verse also utilizes **Enumeration** by listing specific types of property ("ox, ass, sheep, raiment, or any manner of lost thing"). This detailed listing emphasizes the comprehensive nature of the law, ensuring that a wide range of common possessions are covered under its jurisdiction, thereby preventing loopholes and ensuring broad applicability. Furthermore, the phrase "the cause of both parties shall come before the judges" functions as a **Legal Formula**, signifying the formal, binding, and authoritative nature of the judicial process. The prescribed "double" payment embodies a principle of **Retributive Justice** combined with **Restitution**, aiming not only to punish the offender for their transgression but primarily to restore the wronged party to a state better than, or at least equal to, their original condition, while also serving as a powerful deterrent against future dishonesty.

### THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Exodus 22:9 reveals profound theological truths about God's character and His design for human society. It underscores God's meticulous concern for justice, order, and the sanctity of private property within the covenant community. The requirement for disputes to be brought before "judges" (ʾĕlôhîm) highlights that human justice is to reflect divine justice, with judges acting as God's representatives. This principle asserts that even seemingly mundane property disputes are matters of divine concern, impacting the overall righteousness and well-being of the community. The law's emphasis on restitution, specifically the double payment, demonstrates that God's justice is not merely punitive but restorative, aiming to heal broken relationships and re-establish equilibrium. It teaches that transgression against one's neighbor's property is ultimately a transgression against God's established order and His covenant, emphasizing the interconnectedness of human actions with divine principles.

This verse connects with broader biblical themes of justice and restitution:
* [Leviticus 6:1-5](/leviticus/6-1-5 "Leviticus 6:1-5 - Guilt Offering for Trespass and Restitution")
* [Numbers 5:6-7](/numbers/5-6-7 "Numbers 5:6-7 - Confession and Restitution for Wrongdoing")
* [Proverbs 6:30-31](/proverbs/6-30-31 "Proverbs 6:30-31 - Consequences of Theft")

### REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Exodus 22:9, though an ancient civil law, holds enduring relevance for contemporary life, speaking profoundly to our understanding of justice, accountability, and community. It challenges us to consider how we handle disputes, emphasizing the importance of impartial processes rather than personal vengeance or arbitrary decisions. The principle of restitution reminds us that true justice seeks not only to punish wrongdoing but also to restore what was lost and, ideally, to heal relationships. In a world often marked by self-interest, a casual disregard for others' property, and a tendency to avoid accountability, this verse calls believers to uphold high standards of integrity, respect for possessions, and a commitment to fair and just resolution when conflicts arise. It encourages us to be people who actively seek reconciliation and stand for what is right, knowing that God Himself is concerned with every detail of our interactions and desires for His people to live in righteousness and peace. This ancient statute serves as a timeless reminder that our conduct in seemingly small matters of property reflects our commitment to God's larger kingdom principles of justice and love.

#### Questions for Reflection
* **In what ways does this passage challenge modern notions of justice, particularly regarding its emphasis on comprehensive restitution over mere punishment or incarceration?**
* **How does the concept of "judges" acting as God's representatives inform our view of civil authority and the pursuit of justice in society today, especially in legal and judicial systems?**
* **What practical steps can we take in our personal lives, families, or communities to ensure that disputes are handled with fairness, impartiality, and a focus on restoration, as modeled in this verse?**

### FAQ
**What does "trespass" mean in the context of Exodus 22:9?**

Answer: In Exodus 22:9, "trespass" (Hebrew: _peshaʻ'_) refers to a serious transgression or offense specifically related to property rights. It encompasses situations where someone wrongfully possesses another's property, whether through outright theft, finding a lost item and not returning it, or making a false claim of ownership over an item that belongs to someone else. It highlights a violation of the established order and the rights of a neighbor within the covenant community, signifying a breach of trust and a moral wrong.

**Why is the penalty "double" payment, and what is its significance?**

Answer: The "double" payment (Hebrew: _shᵉnayim'_) is a significant and recurring penalty in ancient Near Eastern law and the Mosaic Law. Its significance is multifaceted:
1. **Full Restitution and More:** It ensures that the wronged party is not only fully compensated for their loss but receives an additional amount, often to cover inconvenience, distress, or the time spent pursuing justice.
2. **Punitive Measure:** It serves as a substantial punishment for the offender, making the cost of dishonesty or wrongful possession significant and memorable.
3. **Strong Deterrent:** It acts as a powerful deterrent against future similar offenses, discouraging theft, false claims, and the wrongful retention of property by making such actions economically disadvantageous. This principle is also seen in other parts of the law, such as in [Exodus 22:7](/exodus/22-7 "Exodus 22:7 - Penalty for Breach of Trust"), where a similar penalty applies to a breach of trust involving money or goods.

**Who are the "judges" mentioned in this verse?**

Answer: The "judges" (Hebrew: _ʾĕlôhîym'_) in this context refer to human arbiters or magistrates within the Israelite community, often elders or appointed leaders. The use of _ʾĕlôhîym'_, a term usually referring to God, underscores that these judges were considered to be acting as God's representatives. They were divinely appointed or sanctioned to administer justice and discern truth according to God's laws, highlighting the sacred and authoritative nature of their role in resolving disputes and maintaining social order. Their decisions were viewed as reflecting God's own judgment.

### CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
Exodus 22:9, with its emphasis on restitution for trespass and the role of impartial judges, finds profound Christ-centered fulfillment. While the law addresses property disputes among humans, it speaks to the deeper reality of humanity's ultimate "trespass" against God. Our sin is a rebellion against God's holy character and His divine order, resulting in an infinite spiritual debt and a broken relationship that we could never repay on our own. Yet, Jesus Christ, the ultimate righteous Judge and faithful Son, stepped in to pay the "double" for our transgressions. He bore the full penalty of our sin on the cross, offering not just restitution but complete redemption and reconciliation with God ([2 Corinthians 5:18-19](/2-corinthians/5-18-19 "2 Corinthians 5:18-19 - The Ministry of Reconciliation")). He is the "Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!" ([John 1:29](/john/1-29 "John 1:29 - Jesus, the Lamb of God")), making full and perfect payment for our spiritual debt, thereby satisfying divine justice and restoring us to fellowship with God. Moreover, Christ embodies the perfect judge, whose judgment is always true and just, and to whom all judgment has been committed ([John 5:22](/john/5-22 "John 5:22 - Jesus, the Judge")). In His kingdom, the principles of justice, righteousness, and restoration, foreshadowed in this ancient law, are fully realized, not merely through legal statutes but through the transformative power of His Spirit in the hearts of His people, enabling them to live righteously and pursue justice in their own relationships ([Romans 14:17](/romans/14-17 "The Kingdom of God is Righteousness, Peace, and Joy")).

Note: Commentary is generated by AI with a directive for Biblical fidelity. Always rely on the Holy Spirit for discernment. The Scripture text and cross-references are from verified, non-AI sources.

Cross-References

Deuteronomy 25:1

¶ If there be a controversy between men, and they come unto judgment, that [the judges] may judge them; then they shall justify the righteous, and condemn the wicked.

Numbers 5:6

Speak unto the children of Israel, When a man or woman shall commit any sin that men commit, to do a trespass against the LORD, and that person be guilty;

Numbers 5:7

Then they shall confess their sin which they have done: and he shall recompense his trespass with the principal thereof, and add unto it the fifth [part] thereof, and give [it] unto [him] against whom he hath trespassed.

Exodus 23:6

Thou shalt not wrest the judgment of thy poor in his cause.

Exodus 23:8

And thou shalt take no gift: for the gift blindeth the wise, and perverteth the words of the righteous.

Exodus 22:4

If the theft be certainly found in his hand alive, whether it be ox, or ass, or sheep; he shall restore double.

Matthew 18:35

So likewise shall my heavenly Father do also unto you, if ye from your hearts forgive not every one his brother their trespasses.