Skip to content

Micah 2:11

“Silencing the True Prophets”Micah 2:6–11

King James Version
If a man walking in the spirit and falsehood do lie, saying, I will prophesy unto thee of wine and of strong drink; he shall even be the prophet of this people.

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
If H3863 a man H376 walking H1980 in the spirit H7307 and falsehood H8267 do lie H3576, saying, I will prophesy H5197 unto thee of wine H3196 and of strong drink H7941; he shall even be the prophet H5197 of this people H5971.

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
If a man of wind were to come and say falsely, “I will preach to you of wine and strong drink,” he would be just the preacher for this people!

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
If a man walking in a spirit of falsehood do lie, saying, I will prophesy unto thee of wine and of strong drink; he shall even be the prophet of this people.

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
If a man walking in a spirit of falsehood lies: “I will prophesy to you of wine and of strong drink”; he would be the prophet of this people.

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
If a man walke in the Spirit, and would lie falsely, saying, I wil prophecie vnto thee of wine, and of strong drinke, he shall euen be the prophet of this people.

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
If one is going with the wind, And with falsehood hath lied: `I prophesy to thee of wine, and of strong drink,' He hath been the prophet of this people!

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
14 Hebrew words
  1. לוּluifH3863ConjConjunction
  2. אִישׁ'ishanyoneH376N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
  3. הֹלֵךְho·Lekhwalking ofH1980V-Qal-Prtcpl-msVerb Qal Participle Singular Masculine Construct
  4. רוּחַRu·achwindH7307N-fsNoun Singular Feminine Absolute
  5. וָשֶׁקֶרva·She·kerand falsehoodH8267Conj-w ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteוָandשֶׁקֶרfalsehood
  6. כִּזֵּבki·Zevhe told a lieH3576V-Piel-Perf-3msVerb Piel Perfect 3rd Singular Masculine
  7. אַטִּף'a·TifI will prophesyH5197V-Hiphil-Imperf-1csVerb Hiphil Imperfect 1st Singular common gender
  8. לְךָle·Khafor youPrep-l ¦ 2msSuffix Personal 2nd Singular Masculineלְforךָyou
  9. לַיַּיִןlai·Ya·yinof [the] wineH3196Prep-l ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteלַof [the]יַּיִןwine
  10. וְלַשֵּׁכָרve·la·she·Kharand of [the] strong drinkH7941Conj-w ¦ Prep-l ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteוְandלַof [the]שֵּׁכָרstrong drink
  11. וְהָיָהve·ha·Yahand he will beH1961Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecPerf-3msVerb Qal Consecutive Perfect 3rd Singular Masculineוְandהָיָהhe will be
  12. מַטִּיףma·Tif[the] prophesier ofH5197V-Hiphil-Prtcpl-msVerb Hiphil Participle Singular Masculine Construct
  13. הָעָםha·'Amthe peopleH5971Art ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteהָtheעָםpeople
  14. הַזֶּהha·Zeh[the] thisH2088Art ¦ PrtParticle Demonstrativeהַ[the]זֶּהthis
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the original text the KJV's translators worked from — each Hebrew word with its own literal English meaning in this verse, prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences, not word by word, so its wording differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may choose “the LORD” where the gloss reads “Yahweh”. Both are faithful — they answer different questions. For the KJV's own rendering, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
In the KJVVerse 22,607 of 31,102 · 72.7%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

A lying prophet who promised wine and strong drink would be just the prophet these people want, which shows how far they have turned from the truth.

“If a man walking in the spirit and falsehood do lie,”

A man whose whole way of life is deceit, moved by a lying spirit, and his lies are deliberate.

“saying, I will prophesy unto thee of wine and of strong drink;”

His message is plenty and pleasure, a promise of an easy life with no judgment to come.

“he shall even be the prophet of this people.”

The people who silenced the true prophets would gladly take this liar as theirs.

Passage studyMicah 2:6–11

Silencing the True Prophets

6Prophesy ye not, say they to them that prophesy: they shall not prophesy to them, that they shall not take shame. 7O thou that art named the house of Jacob, is the spirit of the LORD straitened? are these his doings? do not my words do good to him that walketh uprightly? 8Even of late my people is risen up as an enemy: ye pull off the robe with the garment from them that pass by securely as men averse from war. 9The women of my people have ye cast out from their pleasant houses; from their children have ye taken away my glory for ever. 10Arise ye, and depart; for this is not your rest: because it is polluted, it shall destroy you, even with a sore destruction. 11If a man walking in the spirit and falsehood do lie, saying, I will prophesy unto thee of wine and of strong drink; he shall even be the prophet of this people.

Summary

Micah has just announced the LORD’s judgment on the powerful men of Judah and Israel who plan evil on their beds and then seize fields and houses (Micah 2:1–5). In these six verses the people answer him with an order: stop prophesying. The LORD replies through Micah with three questions and a list of charges. His Spirit is as strong and patient as ever, and his words do good to everyone who walks uprightly. The trouble lies with a people who have turned on their own neighbours like an invading army, stripping peaceful travellers of their clothes, driving women from their homes and taking God’s glory from their children. So the LORD tells them to get up and go, because the land they have polluted has ceased to be their rest. The passage ends on a bitter note: the prophet these people would gladly welcome is a liar who promises them wine and strong drink.

Why the people told the prophets to be silent

“Prophesy ye not, say they to them that prophesy” is the reply of the people Micah has just rebuked. They have heard that a disaster is coming which they cannot escape, and that their own lands will be shared out to others, and their answer is to command God’s prophets to stop. The order comes from the oppressive rich and from those who follow them, and it shows hearts set hard against repentance. They wanted to keep their comfortable, unjust way of life and the good name that went with it, and the prophets’ message threatened both.

The Hebrew verb for “prophesy” in this verse is nâṭaph, a less common word than the usual nābā. Nâṭaph means to ooze or to fall in drops, and from that it is used of speaking by inspiration. It pictures God’s word coming down on his people like drops of rain or dew, steady and persistent, and the people want even the drops stopped. The word “prophesy” comes back again and again in this short verse, which keeps the quarrel at its centre: the people try to silence the message, and God’s messengers keep bringing it.

To refuse the prophets was to refuse the God who sent them, and Israel did it again and again. Isaiah describes a rebellious people who say to the prophets, “Prophesy not unto us right things, speak unto us smooth things, prophesy deceits” (Isaiah 30:9–11). The priest Amaziah ordered Amos to stop prophesying (Amos 7:12–13). Jeremiah was seized for his prophesying (Jeremiah 26:8), and Pashhur struck him (Jeremiah 20:1–2). Through Jeremiah the LORD said of his people that they “hardened their neck: they did worse than their fathers” (Jeremiah 7:26).

Two ways to hear “they shall not prophesy to them”

The middle of the verse can be heard in two ways. On one reading the people are still speaking, insisting that the prophets must keep their words away from them. On the other, God answers their demand by granting it, and the prophets will stop speaking to such a people. That would be a severe judgment, for God would be giving them over to what they wanted and leaving them in their darkness without the light of his word, and their hearts would grow harder still. On either reading the people end up cut off from God’s word, first by their own choice and then by his verdict on that choice.

Why they feared shame

The last clause gives their motive: “that they shall not take shame.” The word for shame, kᵉlimmâh, means shame, dishonour or disgrace. In Israel honour and shame were bound up with a person’s public standing, so to take shame was to lose one’s reputation and dignity in the community. The verb behind “take”, nâçag, means to retreat, remove or turn away, and the people hoped that silencing the prophets would turn disgrace away from them. Their outward reputation and their comfort mattered more to them than repentance and peace with God.

Their plan defeats itself. Shame dodged by silencing the truth returns greater when God’s judgment falls, as the LORD said through Hosea of a people who sinned against him: “therefore will I change their glory into shame” (Hosea 4:7). Jesus condemned the same care for appearances when he compared the scribes and Pharisees to whited sepulchres, beautiful outside and full of uncleanness within (Matthew 23:27–28).

The Spirit of the LORD and the good his words do

In verse 7 the LORD answers the people through Micah. “O thou that art named the house of Jacob” calls them by their covenant name, the name of God’s chosen people descended from Jacob, and it sets who they are beside how they live. They may have thought that being the house of Jacob kept them safe from judgment, as though the covenant bound God’s Spirit to protect them whatever they did. Three questions follow. The first two expect the answer “No”, and the third expects “Yes”.

“is the spirit of the LORD straitened?” The word rûwach means wind, breath and spirit, and “the spirit of the LORD” is God himself present and at work in power and wisdom. Qâtsar means to be short or to curtail (it is also the word for reaping a harvest), so “straitened” means shortened. The question asks whether the LORD’s power or patience has been cut short, as if he had grown too weak to act or too impatient to bear with his people. The LORD asked Moses the same kind of question in the wilderness: “Is the LORD’S hand waxed short?” (Numbers 11:23).

“are these his doings?” The doings are the coming judgment and the distress the people feel. They blamed God for their trouble, as though he were acting on a whim or unjustly. The disaster is the just result of their own oppression, set out in the verses before, and God’s ways are always right. Moses sang of him, “He is the Rock, his work is perfect: for all his ways are judgment: a God of truth and without iniquity, just and right is he” (Deuteronomy 32:4). The prophets say the same throughout: Amos calls for judgment to run down as waters (Amos 5:24), and Isaiah pronounces woe on those who call evil good and good evil (Isaiah 5:20).

“do not my words do good to him that walketh uprightly?” The word dâbâr means word or speech, and in other places a matter or thing. “My words” are all that God says through his prophets, his law, his commands, his warnings and his promises, and they are given for the good of those who live by them. Yâshâr means straight, just or upright, and hâlak, to walk, describes a whole manner of life. To walk uprightly is to live with integrity and honesty by God’s standards, from the heart as well as in outward practice, acting justly towards others. Micah later gathers it into one sentence: “He hath shewed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the LORD require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?” (Micah 6:8). The psalms say the same of God’s law, which converts the soul and in the keeping of which “there is great reward” (Psalm 19:7–11), and of the righteous man, who is like a tree planted by the rivers of water (Psalm 1:1–3).

Can human sin limit the Spirit of the LORD?

Micah’s question expects the answer that God’s Spirit is as mighty and patient as ever and fully able to carry out his will, whether in judgment or in blessing. The people’s sin brings its own just consequences on them, and the problem lies there. Isaiah puts it plainly: “Behold, the LORD’S hand is not shortened, that it cannot save; neither his ear heavy, that it cannot hear: But your iniquities have separated between you and your God” (Isaiah 59:1–2).

God’s own people rise up as an enemy

Verse 8 turns from the people’s complaint to their crimes. “Even of late” (ʼethmôwl) marks this as a recent thing, and perhaps a growing one. “My people” (ʻam, a people gathered as one) is God’s own name for them, and that is what makes the next words so shocking. They have “risen up” (qûwm, to rise) “as an enemy”. The word ʼôyêb is a form of the verb to be hostile, and it is the ordinary word for an enemy. The people bound to God by covenant and called to uphold justice are treating their own brothers the way foreign invaders would.

“ye pull off the robe with the garment” names the crime. The verb pâshaṭ means to strip or put off, and it is also used of flaying and of a sudden raid, so the word fits the picture of an enemy plundering. The robe, ʼeder, is a mantle, a word that can also mean amplitude or splendour, and here it is a valuable outer cloak. The garment, salmâh, is a person’s dress or clothing. The oppressors take both, leaving their victims stripped of their covering and their dignity.

“from them that pass by securely as men averse from war” names the victims. They pass by (ʻâbar) in safety (beṭach, safety or security, here used as “securely”), travellers and peaceful citizens going about their business and trusting that they are safe. They are “averse from war”, turned back (shûwb) from war (milchâmâh), people unarmed and unready for any fight. To prey on such people is cowardly and cruel.

Why taking a man’s cloak was so serious

A person’s outer garment was often the most valuable thing he owned. It was his clothing by day and, for a poor man, his only blanket at night. The law of Moses said that if a poor man’s garment was taken as a pledge, it had to be given back by sunset: “For that is his covering only, it is his raiment for his skin: wherein shall he sleep?” (Exodus 22:26–27, Deuteronomy 24:12–13). The same law told Israel to open their hand wide to a poor brother (Deuteronomy 15:7–8). To strip a man on the road was robbery, humiliation and plain contempt for God’s commands about the vulnerable.

God is the defender of the poor, the widow and the orphan, and true worship of him shows itself in justice and mercy towards one’s neighbour. Amos condemned Israel for the same oppression of the poor (Amos 2:6–7), and Isaiah told the people to wash themselves and “Learn to do well; seek judgment, relieve the oppressed, judge the fatherless, plead for the widow” (Isaiah 1:16–17).

Women driven from their homes and children robbed of God’s glory

Verse 9 shows where the greed of verses 1 and 2 leads, and who pays for it. “The women of my people” are members of God’s covenant people, perhaps widows or women whose husbands were gone, and such women were among the most exposed in Israel, often with little legal or economic standing of their own. The oppressors have “cast out” these women. The verb gârash means to drive out or expel, and it is also used of divorce. They were driven “from their pleasant houses” (Hebrew mibbeit ta’anugeyha, from the house of her delights), the cherished family homes that gave them shelter, security and a place in their heritage.

Land in Israel was an inheritance from God, meant to keep a family secure from one generation to the next (Leviticus 25). The rich of Micah’s day were gathering up houses and fields through debt, twisted lawsuits and plain seizure, coveting what belonged to others (Micah 2:1–5). Amos speaks of the same men treading upon the poor (Amos 5:11). The law had guarded exactly these people: “Thou shalt not pervert the judgment of the stranger, nor of the fatherless; nor take a widow’s raiment to pledge” (Deuteronomy 24:17). Scripture calls God’s people to open their mouths for those who cannot speak for themselves (Proverbs 31:8–9), and James calls it pure religion to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction (James 1:27).

What is “my glory” that was taken from the children?

“My glory” is the splendour that God himself had put upon his people’s children. The word hâdâr means ornament, splendour or majesty, and Scripture uses it for honour that is put upon someone from outside. For these little ones (‘oleleyha, her children, often used of the youngest) it was their home, their share in the inheritance, a secure future and the chance to grow up under God’s covenant blessing. All of that came from God and showed his faithfulness, so when the oppressors took it, God calls the loss his own. His honour among his people was dimmed as well, because his people’s misery made it look as if he could not or would not protect his own.

“For ever” translates ʻôwlâm, a word for time out of mind or a very long time. A family robbed of its home and land loses it for its children and its children’s children, so the harm of this injustice runs on through the generations.

Arise and depart, for this is not your rest

Verse 10 gives the sentence. “Arise ye, and depart” is a command to get up and go, the announcement of a forced exile. Those who drove women out of their houses are now told that they themselves must leave. The reason follows: “this is not your rest.” The word for rest, mᵉnûwchâh, means rest, quiet and a settled dwelling place. God had promised Israel the land as their rest and inheritance after their wanderings (Deuteronomy 12:9–10). That rest depended on faithfulness to him, and by their deeds these people have forfeited it.

“because it is polluted” gives the reason the land can be their rest no longer. The verb ṭâmêʼ means to be or become unclean, or to defile, and it covers uncleanness by contact as well as by unlawful acts. Their oppression and violence, along with the idolatry of their day, had defiled the land. “it shall destroy you, even with a sore destruction” uses a verb and a noun from the same root together. Châbal means to bind or to destroy, and it is also used of writhing in pain like a woman in labour. Chebel can mean a rope or a measuring line, and also a pang of pain or ruin. Joined together they promise a severe and painful ruin.

How can a land be polluted and destroy its people?

The land belonged to God, and it was bound up with the moral and spiritual life of the people living on it. Sin defiles it. God warned Israel that the nations before them had defiled the land by their sins, “and the land itself vomiteth out her inhabitants” (Leviticus 18:24–28), and that bloodshed pollutes the land where God dwells (Numbers 35:33–34). The land spitting out its people is a picture of God’s judgment, coming as war, famine and exile, which removes a people from their home and their security. Moses had set these consequences before Israel among the blessings and curses of Deuteronomy 28, warning that the LORD would pluck them off the land and scatter them among all people (Deuteronomy 28:63–64).

This came in Micah’s own time and after it. He prophesied in the days of Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah, kings of Judah, while Assyria was rising. Samaria, the capital of the northern kingdom, fell to Assyria in 722 BC, and Jerusalem itself was later besieged.

The prophet this people wanted

Verse 11 shows the kind of prophet the people would welcome. “If a man walking in the spirit and falsehood do lie” describes a man whose whole manner of life is deceit. He walks (hâlak, the same verb as “walketh uprightly” in verse 7), but his walk is in lies. The spirit that moves him is a spirit of deception, and the word is rûwach, the same word used of the Spirit of the LORD in verse 7. Sheqer, falsehood, means a lie, deception or sham, and the word can also mean something vain that disappoints. So the source of his message is a lying spirit, and God’s Spirit has nothing to do with it.

“I will prophesy unto thee of wine and of strong drink” gives his message, and the verb is nâṭaph again. The people who told the true prophets to stop dripping their words will gladly let a liar drip his. Yayin, wine, and shêkâr, strong drink, are fermented drinks, and here they stand for plenty, pleasure and an easy life without trouble or judgment. Where God’s true prophets warned of famine, exile and suffering, this man promises good times and no consequences, which is exactly what the people want to hear.

“he shall even be the prophet of this people.” The liar who promises pleasure is the very man they will accept as their prophet, while they reject the one who speaks God’s hard truth. Jeremiah saw the same thing: “The prophets prophesy falsely, and the priests bear rule by their means; and my people love to have it so” (Jeremiah 5:31). The LORD told him, “The prophets prophesy lies in my name: I sent them not” (Jeremiah 14:14), and the whole of Jeremiah 23 is given over to such prophets. Moses had given Israel a way to tell the true prophet from the false (Deuteronomy 18:20–22).

The New Testament warns that the same thing will happen in the church. Paul says that the time will come when people will heap to themselves teachers “having itching ears”, who tell them what their own desires want to hear (2 Timothy 4:3–4), and Peter says that false teachers will rise among God’s people as false prophets did in Israel (2 Peter 2:1–3).

Christ, the Prophet the world rejected and the rest it lost

Every part of this passage points forward to Jesus. He is the Word of God made flesh (John 1:14), the true Prophet, and like the prophets before him he brought a message many wanted silenced. He exposed the sin of the people and the hypocrisy of their leaders, above all in his woes on the scribes and Pharisees (Matthew 23). The people of Micah’s day silenced the prophets to avoid shame, and the world crucified Jesus, who willingly took shame on himself. He “endured the cross, despising the shame” (Hebrews 12:2), bearing it for our sin, so that “Whosoever believeth on him shall not be ashamed” (Romans 10:11).

In him the Spirit of the LORD was shown to be unshortened, for “God giveth not the Spirit by measure unto him” (John 3:34), and he showed his power over sin, sickness and death in his resurrection. He is the Word who was with God and was God (John 1:1), and his words do good to all who believe in him and walk in the light as he is in the light (1 John 1:7). Through him the Spirit is poured out on all his people (Acts 2:17), so that they walk uprightly by the Spirit’s power.

Where God’s people rose up as an enemy and stripped the defenceless, Christ came to serve and to give his life (Mark 10:45). He is the Lamb of God (John 1:29), who let himself be stripped and crucified, and “though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, that ye through his poverty might be rich” (2 Corinthians 8:9). He counts what is done for the hungry, the stranger and the naked as done for him (Matthew 25:35–40), and he has made his people fellowcitizens with the saints and of the household of God (Ephesians 2:19–22), a community called to the justice and mercy that Micah demanded.

Against those who cast out women and children, Jesus announced good news to the poor and liberty to the oppressed (Luke 4:18–19). He denounced religious leaders who “devour widows’ houses” (Matthew 23:14), and he has gone to prepare a place for his people in his Father’s house, where there are many mansions (John 14:2–3). In him God’s glory is restored to his children.

The rest that the oppressors forfeited is offered anew in him: “Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28–30). A rest still remains for the people of God (Hebrews 4:1–11), in a kingdom which cannot be moved (Hebrews 12:28). The blood of Jesus cleanses the sin that pollutes the heart as well as the land, and where “the wages of sin is death”, God gives eternal life through him (Romans 6:23). The command to arise and depart has its echo for believers in Paul’s words, “Let every one that nameth the name of Christ depart from iniquity” (2 Timothy 2:19).

The false prophet promised wine and strong drink. Jesus is “the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6), and he told his followers plainly that they would take up a cross (Matthew 16:24) and have tribulation in the world, with peace in him because he has overcome the world (John 16:33). What he gives truly satisfies: living water (John 4:10–14) and himself as the bread of life (John 6:35).

The God who keeps speaking

These verses show a God who goes on speaking to people who tell him to be quiet. His Spirit has lost none of its strength, his judgments are right, and his words are meant for the good of those who hear them and walk uprightly. He sees the traveller stripped on the road, the woman put out of her house and the child robbed of a future, and he calls their loss his own. He will remove a people who defile his land, and he holds out a rest that oppression cannot take away.

The passage also shows how comfortable lies win a hearing. The people of Micah’s day wanted smooth words and a prophet of wine, and they got the shame they had tried to avoid. God’s word may wound before it heals, but the truth that convicts is the same truth that leads to repentance and life, and in Christ, who bore our shame, it comes to us with the promise that whoever believes on him shall not be ashamed.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Micah 2:6–11. He set out his notes in a three-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 6 verses
Passage under commentMicah 2:6–11
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

Here are two sins charged upon the people of Israel, and judgments denounced against them for each, such judgments as exactly answer the sin - persecuting God's prophets and oppressing God's poor.

I.Persecuting God's prophets, suppressing and silencing them, is a sin that provokes God as much as anything, for it not only spits in the face of his authority over us, but spurns at the bowels of his mercy to us; for his sending prophets to us is a sure and valuable token of his goodwill. Now observe here,

1.What the obstruction and opposition were which this people gave to God's prophets: They said to those that prophesy, Prophesy ye not, as Isaiah 30:10. They said to the seers, "See not; do not trouble us with accounts of what you have seen, nor bring us any such frightful messages." They must either not prophesy at all or prophesy only what is pleasing. The word for prophesying here signifies dropping, for the words of the prophets dropped from heaven as the dew. Note, Those that hate to be reformed hate to be reproved, and do all they can to silence faithful ministers. Amos was forbidden to prophesy, Amos 7:10, etc. Therefore persecutors stop their breath, because they have no other way to stop their mouths; for, if they live, they will preach and torment those that dwell on the earth, as the two witnesses did, Revelation 11:10. Some read it, Prophesy not; let these prophesy. Let not those prophesy that tell us of our faults, and threaten us, but let those prophesy that will flatter us in our sins, and cry peace to us. They will not say that they will have no ministers at all, but they will have such as will say just what they would have them and go their way. This they are charged with (Micah 2:11), that when they silenced and frowned upon the true prophets they countenanced and encouraged pretenders, and set them up, and made an interest for them, to confront God's faithful prophets: If a man walk in the spirit of falsehood, pretend to have the Spirit of God, while really it is a spirit of error, a spirit of delusion, and he himself knows that he has no commission, no instruction, from God, yet, if he says, I will prophesy unto thee of wine and strong drink, if he will but assure them that they shall have wine and strong drink enough, that they need not fear the judgments of war and famine which the other prophets threatened them with, that they shall always have plenty of the delights of sense and never know the want of them, and if he will but tell them that it is lawful for them to drink as much as they please of their wine and strong drink, and they need not scruple being drunk, that they shall have peace though they go on and add drunkenness to thirst, such a prophet as this is a man after their own heart, who will tell them that there is neither sin nor danger in the wicked course of life they lead: He shall even be the prophet of this people; such a man they would have to be their prophet, that will not only associate with them in their rioting and revellings, but will pretend to consecrate their sensualities by his prophecies and so harden them in their security and sensuality. Note, It is not strange if people that are vicious and debauched covet to have ministers that are altogether such as themselves, for they are willing to believe God is so too, Psalm 50:21. But how are sacred things profaned when they are prostituted to such base purposes, when prophecy itself shall be pressed into the services of a lewd and profane crew! But thus that servant who said, My Lord delays his coming, by the spirit of falsehood, smote his fellow servants and ate and drank with the drunken.

2.How they are here expostulated with upon this matter (Micah 2:7): "O thou that art named the house of Jacob, does it become thee to say and do thus? Wilt thou silence those that prophesy, and forbid them to speak in God's name?" Note, It is an honour and privilege to be named of the house of Jacob. Thou art called a Jew, Romans 2:17. But, when those who are called by that worthy name degenerate, they commonly prove the worst of men themselves and the worst enemies to God's prophets. The Jews who were named of the house of Jacob were the most violent persecutors of the first preachers of the gospel. Upon this the prophet here argues with these oppressors of the word of God, and shows them, (1.) What an affront they hereby put upon God, the God of the holy prophets: "Is the Lord's Spirit straitened? In silencing the Lord's prophets you do what you can to silence his Spirit too; but do you think you can do it? Can you make the Spirit of God your prisoner and your servant? Will you prescribe to him what he shall say, and forbid him to say what is displeasing to you? If you silence the prophets, yet cannot the Spirit of the Lord find out other ways to reach your consciences? Can your unbelief frustrate the divine counsels?" (2.) What a scandal it was to their profession as Jews: "You are named the house of Jacob, and this is your honour; but are these his doings? Are these the doings of your father Jacob? Do you herein tread in his steps? No; if you were indeed his children you would do his works; but now you seek to kill and silence a man that tells you the truth, in God's name; this did not Abraham (John 8:39, John 8:40); this did not Jacob." Or, "Are these God's doings? Are these the doings that will please him? Are these the doings of his people? No, you know they are not, however some may be so strangely blinded and bigoted as to kill God's ministers and think that therein they do him service," John 16:2. (3.) Let them consider how unreasonable and absurd the thing was in itself: Do not my words do good to those that walk uprightly? Yes; certainly they do; it is an appeal to the experiences of the generation of the upright: "Call now if there be any of them that will answer you, and to which of the saints will you turn? Turn to which you will, and you will find they all agree in this, that the word of God does good to those that walk uprightly; and will you then oppose that which does good, so much good as good preaching does? Herein you wrong God, who owns the words of the prophets to be his words (they are my words) and who by them aims and designs to do good to mankind (Psalm 119:68); and will you hinder the great benefactor from doing good? Will you put the light of the world under a bushel: You might as well say to the sun, Shine not, as say to the seers, See not. Herein you wrong the souls of men, and deprive them of the benefit designed them by the word of God." Note, Those are enemies not only to God, but to the world, they are enemies to their country, that silence good ministers, and obstruct the means of knowledge and grace; for it is certainly for the public common good of states and kingdoms that religion should be encouraged. God's words do good to those that walk uprightly. It is the character of good people that they walk uprightly (Psalm 15:2); and it is their comfort that the words of God are good and do good to them; they find comfort in them. God's words are good words to good people, and speak comfortably to them. But those that opposed the words of God, and silenced the prophets, pleaded, in justification of themselves, that God's words were unprofitable and unpleasant to them, and did them no good, nor prophesied any good concerning them, but evil, as Ahab complained of Micaiah, in answer to which the prophet here tells them that it was their own fault; they might thank themselves. They might find it of good use to them if they were but disposed to make a good use of it; if they would but walk uprightly, as they should, and so qualify themselves for comfort, the word of God would speak comfortably to them. Do that which is good, and thou shalt have praise for the same.

3.What they are threatened with for this sin; God also will choose their delusions, and,

(1.)They shall be deprived of the benefit of a faithful ministry. Since they say, Prophesy not, God will take them at their word, and they shall not prophesy to them; their sin shall be their punishment. If men will silence God's ministers, it is just with God to silence them, as he did Ezekiel, and to say, They shall no more be reprovers and monitors to them. Let the physician no longer attend the patient that will not be healed, for he will not be ruled. They shall not prophesy to them, and then they will not take shame. As it is the work of magistrates, so it is also of ministers, to put men to shame when they do amiss (Judges 18:7), that, being made ashamed of their folly, they may not return again to it; but, when God gives men up to be impudent and shameless in sin, he says to his prophets, They are joined to idols; let them alone.

(2.)They shall be given up to the blind guidance of an unfaithful ministry. We may understand Micah 2:11 as a threatening: If a man be found walking in the spirit of falsehood, having such a lying spirit as was in the mouth of Ahab's prophets, that will strengthen their hands in their wicked ways, he shall be the prophet of this people, that is, God will leave them to themselves to hearken to such; since they will be deceived, let them be deceived; since they will not admit the truth in the love of it, God will send them strong delusions to believe a lie, 2 Thessalonians 2:10, 2 Thessalonians 2:11. They shall have prophets that will prophesy to them for wine and strong drink (so some read it), that will give you a cast of their office to your mind for a bottle of wine of a flagon of ale, will soothe sinners in their sins if they will but feed them with the gratifications of their lusts; to have such prophets, and to be ridden by them, is as sad a judgment as any people can be under and as bad a preface of ruin approaching as it is to a particular person to be under the influence of a debauched conscience.

II.Oppressing God's poor is another sin they are charged with, as before (Micah 2:1, Micah 2:2), for it is a sin doubly hateful and provoking to God. Observe,

1.How the sin is described, Micah 2:8, Micah 2:9. When they contemned God's prophets and opposed them they broke out into all other wickedness; what bonds will hold those that have no reverence for God's word? Those who formerly rose up against the enemies of the nation, in defence of their country and therein behaved themselves bravely, now of late rose up as enemies of the nation, and, instead of defending it, destroyed it, and did it more mischief (as usually such vipers in the bowels of a state do) than a foreign enemy could do. They made a prey of men, women, and children,

(1.)Of men, that were travelling on the way, that pass by securely as men averse from war, that were far from any bad designs, but went peaceably about their lawful occasions; those they set upon, as if they had been dangerous obnoxious people, and pulled off the robe with the garment from them, that is, they stripped them both of the upper and the inner garment, took away their cloak, and would have their coat also; thus barbarously did they use those that were quiet in the land, who, being harmless, were fearless, and so the more easily make a prey of.

(2.)Of women, whose sex should have been their protection (Micah 2:9): The women of my people have you cast out from their pleasant houses. They devoured widows' houses (Matthew 23:14), and so turned them out of the possession of them, because they were pleasant houses, and such as they had a mind for. It was inhuman to deal thus barbarously with women; but that which especially aggravated it was that they were the women of God's people, whom they knew to be under his protection.

(3.)Of children, whose age entitles them to a tender usage: From their children have you taken away my glory for ever. It was the glory of the Israelites' children that they were free, but they enslaved them - that they were born in God's house, and had a right to the privileges of it, but they sold them to strangers, sent them into idolatrous countries, where they were deprived for ever of that glory; at least the oppressors designed their captivity should be perpetual. Note, The righteous God will certainly reckon for injuries done to the widows and fatherless, who, being helpless and friendless, cannot otherwise expect to be righted.

2.What the sentence is that is passed upon them for it (Micah 2:10): "Arise ye, and depart; prepare to quit this land, for you shall be forced out of it, as you have forced the women and children of my people out of their possessions; it is not, it shall not, be your rest, as it was intended that Canaan should be, Psalm 95:11. You shall have neither contentment nor continuance in it, because it is polluted by your wickedness." Sin is defiling to a land, and sinners cannot expect to rest in a land which they have polluted, but is will spew them out, as this land spewed out the Canaanites of old when they had polluted it with their abominations, Leviticus 18:27, Leviticus 18:28. "Nay, you shall not only be obliged to depart out of this land, but it shall destroy you even with a sore destruction; you shall either be turned out of it or (which is all one) you shall be ruined in it." We may apply this to our state in this present world; it is polluted; there is a great deal of corruption in the world, through lust, and therefore we should arise, and depart out of it, keep at a distance from the corruption that is in it, and keep ourselves unspotted from it. It is not our rest; it was never intended to be so; it was designed for our passage, but not for our portion - our inn, but not our home. Here we have no continuing city; let us therefore arise and depart; let us sit loose to it and live above it, and think of leaving it and seek a continuing city above.

Historical interpretation

Fourteen Centuries of Reception

3 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

3 quotes · AD 420–1781
Post-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
400500600700800900100011001200130014001500160017001800

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

d. AD 420JeromePost-NiceneSourceCommentary on Micah
(Verse 11, 12.) I wish I were not a man with a spirit, and I spoke lies instead. I will pour for you into wine and into drunkenness, and this people on whom it is poured will be overcome. I will gather Jacob together, I will gather all of you: I will bring the remnants of Israel together.

And in this chapter, the Septuagint interpreters differ greatly from Hebrew. Therefore, let us first explain according to what has been handed down to us by the Hebrews, and then, if the Lord wills, we will discuss their translations. O Jewish people, to whom belong the promises, the covenants, the law, and from whom Christ came according to the flesh (Rom. 9), to whom, facing the imminent Babylonians or Romans, I have said: Rise up and go into captivity, for there is no rest for you in this land, which will be devastated by its own wickedness in the final destruction. Do not think that I am unwilling to speak and preach joyfully, for I see the coming of the Lord. I myself would wish to be accursed for the sake of my brethren, the Israelites (Rom. 9:3). I wish I could speak of my own understanding, and not have the Holy Spirit; and be counted among the false prophets, and perish alone, and not have the things I say be true: and such a multitude would believe in the Son of God, and not be handed over to eternal captivity. But because I speak with the spirit of prophecy, and am sent from divinity (or truth), I proclaim the truth: therefore I will pour out my words to you like bitter wine that intoxicates you and makes you fall. But while I am still dripping, and singing of the evil of the future captivity, this people will receive my rain, whether they want it or not, for it has the capability to endure what I say. And do not think, that I am only a prophet of evils (although great evils indeed), for now the predicted captivity will come; but behold, in me the word speaks, a word that is applicable to all the prophets. For when the prophet is silent, he does not speak, and now he says: I will come, and I will assume a human body, I will be born of a Virgin. Either this: Because I came in the humility of flesh, and you did not believe in me, I will come in the consummation of the world in my majesty with the angels and other powers, and then I will gather you, Jacob, completely. Then I will bring together the remnants of Israel and join them together with the people of the nations in my fold. Then I will surround you with a most strong wall, and there will be such a multitude of believers and such a commotion among the sheepfold that the number of sheep will be overcome by the abundance. Lest you possibly think, because I said, I will place him like a flock in a sheepfold, and like a herd in a stable, that I am speaking of sheep, understand that these sheep are men. For it follows: They will be troubled by the multitude of men. Tumult is the voice of many, and the shout of an excessive multitude equally emitted: let us not think it is the voice of one man, but the common voice of all, praising the good shepherd, who has leveled every difficulty and made it equal with his foot, he himself is the gate of paradise, and says: I am the gate: by which, dividing and preceding the journey, and the gate of the way, the believing flock will pass through him. But this shepherd is a king and Lord. Hence follows: And their king shall pass before them, and the Lord at the head of them. And if we wish to understand all these things about His first coming, and the whole of Jacob and the remnant of Israel as signifying the apostles, and that multitude saved out of the Jews which is recorded in the Acts of the Apostles, we shall not depart from the truth in the interpretation of the expositor. For the Lord has truly gathered these together in His sheepfold, and has placed them in the midst of the folds, and has gone before them, and has brought them into the Church, and has been their king before them, and shall be the Lord at the head of them for ever.


LXX: The spirit establishes a falsehood. It drips into wine and drunkenness, and it will be from the drop of this people, Jacob will be gathered together. Not, as many think, the spirit stood as a liar; but the spirit establishes a falsehood, it is read, which in Greek is called πνεῦμα ἔστησε ψευδὲς, that is, deception. Just as in putrid wounds, so that cancer does not spread and devour the dead flesh, doctors establish and burn the wound with a cautery, or with a caustic powder: in the same way, the spirit of God has set a limit to falsehood, so that the people of God are not overthrown by the voices of false prophets. But the Spirit, wherever it is mentioned without addition, should be understood in a good sense, as we have often said, and now we will partially explain, so that no one should be in doubt. But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace (Galatians 5:22). And: If we live by the Spirit, let us also walk by the Spirit (Galatians 6:25). And elsewhere: But if by the Spirit you put to death the deeds of the body, you will live (Romans 8:13). And in the Old Testament: Giving breath to the people who are in it, and spirit to those who tread on it (Isaiah XLII): without doubt from what comes before that it signifies the earth. For those who trample earthly works and subject them to their feet, certainly deserve to receive not an evil, but a good spirit. On the contrary, an evil spirit is always read with an additional clause, as in this passage: But when the unclean spirit has gone out of a man (Matthew XII, 43). And in another place: He rebuked the unclean spirit (Luke 9:43). And: An evil spirit came upon Saul (1 Samuel 16:14), and similar things to these. Therefore, the Spirit of God, who puts an end to deceit in false prophets, will pour into you wine and drunkenness. Wine that gladdens the heart of man (Psalm 104); and drunkenness with which Noah was intoxicated, and of which it is said: Eat, O friends, and drink until drunk (Song of Solomon 5:1). But all this joy and drunkenness, in comparison to the wisdom of God, is like a heavenly river that waters Jerusalem, it is a drop, and a very small drop. The wisdom of God will not hesitate to call a drop in men, those who have gathered a stone cut from a mountain without hands (Dan. II), and the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the Apostles themselves have known in part, and have prophesied in part (I Cor. XIII, 9). Therefore, concerning this wisdom, that is, concerning the tribe of the Jewish people (for He came only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel), Jacob was gathered: every one who supplants Esau and steals his birthright and blessing, and even before he is born, in his mother's womb, he attacks the heel of his hairy brother.

LXX: When I receive the remnant of Israel with all the Gentiles, and the entire world is brought to my faith, and the fullness of the Gentiles enters, then the remnant of Israel will also be saved, not those remnants about which it is written in the Book of Kings: I have left for myself seven thousand men who have not bowed their knees to Baal (3 Kings 19:18). And concerning them, Paul says: Therefore, even in this present time, the remnants according to the election of grace have been saved (Romans 11:5); concerning whom, the prophet testifies above: And he will gather together the remnant of his people from this drop of water, Jacob will be gathered together. But those remaining, who after all have been received, will be received in the end by God. And concerning them it is now said: 'Gathering the rest of Israel, I will surely receive all, just as it is written: God will conclude all under sin, and have mercy on all.' (Rom. 11:32).

LXX: I will make their destruction like that of sheep in distress. The remaining ones of Israel, whom I will take in after I have taken in all, I will take in: now in the meantime, because they have turned away from me, I will put them in distress, and I will oppress them, and I will make them sit, without priest, without altar, and without prophet: so that those whom they did not perceive through blessings, they may understand through punishments.

LXX: Like a flock in the midst of their fold: it is understood, I will set. Not only, he says, will their aversion, by which they have turned away from me, be set like a flock in tribulation; but after they have been troubled and the time of distress has been completed, they will be set at rest, that is, in their fold. And then (now) they will migrate from men and surpass the state of human condition, and fulfill what follows: They will rise up from among men. Not only they will leap out and go away, but all those to whom the word of God comes, and who, forsaking human vices, imitate the behavior of the divine, and hear: I said, you are gods, and all of you children of the Most High, they will leap out from among men, and be carried as if to heaven.

LXX: Ascend by division. The present passage has a sort of proper beginning and apostrophe of prophetic discourse, speaking to someone who wishes to be saved and commanding them to ascend by division. This will be made clearer if we take an example from Genesis, where twins are born to Tamar, with whom the patriarch Judah had relations: 'And it came to pass, when she travailed, that one put out his hand: and the midwife took and bound upon his hand a scarlet thread, saying, This came out first.' But when he withdrew his hand, his brother came out, and she said, 'Why has the wall been divided because of you?' And she called his name Perez, which means division. And after this his brother came out with the scarlet thread on his hand, and she called his name Zerah, which in our language means seed or east (Gen. XXXVIII, 27, seqq.). Therefore, the elder people showed with their hand, in which there was origin and seed before the Church was born from the nations, and afterwards they withdrew it, hearing the words of Isaiah: For your hands are full of blood (Isai. I, 15). And when he pulled back his hand, and ceased from the works of justice, his brother went out among the nations. And because of him the fence was divided, and the Lord and Saviour destroyed the wall in the middle, and the barrier that separated two peoples: and he made one flock, and in himself he created two, making peace in the new man. Hence the prophetic midwife speaks to the younger people, saying to Phares: Why was the wall divided because of you? If you understand the example from Genesis, ascend to be saved not through the old people who have a contracted hand, but through the new people, in whom is the way of Christ, in whom is the door Jesus, through whom we walk toward the Father, for he himself broke through the middle wall and partition, that is, the darkness of the old prophets, and opened all the sacraments of the ancient Law, and by dispelling the difficulty of walking, revealed the way to the eyes of all: so that whoever wants to proceed is not entangled by any obstacle, nor is he terrified by the darkness of obscurity.


LXX: Before their face they divided and passed through the gate, and went out through it. Their king went out before their face: but the Lord their prince (Heb. shall be) before them. Therefore I said to you: Ascend through the division, you who have risen with Christ, and seek those things that are above: because the Angels, whether the Father and Son, and Holy Spirit, have divided what seemed to obstruct, and have made a way for those who wish to enter, and because they have invaded the path, not only have they entered the gate, but they have also passed through it. But they entered because their king also entered the same gate, and he opened for them the way, so that they could walk without any difficulty. For he himself is the Lord, and king, and shepherd, and the way and the gate, and he says: I am the gate: through me whoever enters will be saved: he will enter and he will go out, and he will find pastures. (John 10:9). Concerning this gate, it is also prophesied elsewhere: This is the gate of the Lord, the righteous shall enter through it. (Psalm 127:20). But whoever enters, should not remain in the state in which they entered; but should go out to the pastures, so that in entering there may be a beginning, in going out and in finding pastures, there may be the perfection of virtues. Whoever enters is still in the world, and through creatures understands the Creator. But whoever goes out, transcends the whole creation, and considering all that can be seen as nothing, will find pastures above the heavens, and will feed on the word of God, and will say: The Lord feeds me, and I shall lack nothing (Psalm 23:1). This is why, in order to understand the Gospel testimony: He will enter and He will go out, and will find pasture; and what is now said through the Prophet: And they passed through the gate, and went out through it: which passage and going out, however, cannot be attributed to our king and Lord Christ, who is king and Lord. For immediately it is connected: But the Lord shall be the Prince.
d. AD 435John CassianPost-NiceneSourceCONFERENCE 9:18
St. Paul wished that he could be accursed if the people of Israel be saved to God’s glory. The man who knows that death is not the end is confident in his readiness to die for Christ. Again, “We rejoice when we are weak, but you are strong.” It is no wonder if St. Paul, for the glory of Christ and the conversion of his brother Jews and of the Gentiles, should be ready to be accursed of Christ. Even the prophet Micah wanted to be a liar and to lose the inspiration of the Holy Spirit if the Jews could escape the punishment and the destruction which he had prophesied: “Would that I were not man that had the Spirit, and that I rather spoke a lie.” And there was the case of the lawgiver, Moses, who did not refuse to perish with his brothers who were doomed to die but said, “I beseech you, O Lord, this people have sinned a heinous sin; either forgive them this trespass, or, if you do not, blot me out of the book which you have written.”
d. AD 1781Richard ChallonerMedieval
Would God: The prophet could have wished, out of his love to his people, that he might be deceived in denouncing to them these evils that were to fall upon them: but by conforming himself to the will of God, he declares to them, that he is sent to prophesy, literally to let drop upon them, the wine of God's indignation, with which they should be made drunk; that is, stupified and cast down.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Micah 2:11 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8