Skip to content
Translation
King James Version
And they came unto their brethren to Zorah and Eshtaol: and their brethren said unto them, What say ye?
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
And they came H935 unto their brethren H251 to Zorah H6881 and Eshtaol H847: and their brethren H251 said H559 unto them, What say ye?
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
When they returned to their kinsmen in Tzor'ah and Eshta'ol, they asked them what they had to report.
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
When the men returned to Zorah and Eshtaol, their brothers asked them, “What did you find?”
Ask
American Standard Version
And they came unto their brethren to Zorah and Eshtaol: and their brethren said unto them, What say ye?
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
They came to their brothers to Zorah and Eshtaol: and their brothers said to them, “What do you say?”
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
So they came againe vnto their brethren to Zorah and Eshtaol: and their brethren saide vnto them, What haue ye done?
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
And they come in unto their brethren, at Zorah and Eshtaol, and their brethren say to them, `What--ye?'
Ask
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 7,002 of 31,102

Study This Verse

SUMMARY

Judges 18:8 marks a pivotal moment in the Danite narrative, capturing the intense anticipation and urgent inquiry of a tribe facing an existential crisis. After dispatching five spies to scout new territory, this verse records their return to the waiting community in Zorah and Eshtaol, setting the stage for a fateful decision that would lead a significant portion of the Danite people to abandon their God-given inheritance, embark on a violent conquest, and establish a deeply compromised, idolatrous cult center in the north.

CONTEXT

  • Literary Context: Judges 18:8 is situated within a crucial transitional phase of the Danite migration narrative, following the initial dispatch of the spies (Judges 18:1-2) and their encounter with Micah's idolatrous household and renegade Levite priest, Jonathan (Judges 18:3-7). The verse serves as the narrative hinge, signaling the culmination of the reconnaissance mission and the imminent reporting of the spies' findings to the anxious Danite community. This report, detailed in the subsequent verses (Judges 18:9-10), will directly catalyze the tribe's decision to relocate en masse to Laish, a move that tragically culminates in the violent conquest of an unsuspecting people and the establishment of a rival, idolatrous religious center, profoundly shaping the moral and spiritual landscape of Israel during the period of the Judges.
  • Historical & Cultural Context: The era of the Judges was marked by a fragmented, decentralized tribal society, famously characterized by the principle that "every man did that which was right in his own eyes" (Judges 17:6; 21:25). The tribe of Dan was originally allotted territory in the fertile Shephelah, bordering the Philistine plain (Joshua 19:40-48). However, as explicitly stated in Judges 1:34-35, they failed to dispossess the Amorites and were confined to the hill country, unable to fully expand into their designated inheritance. This historical pressure, coupled with their inability to secure their original land, propelled their desperate search for new territory. The communal inquiry in verse 8 authentically reflects the tribal structure of the time, where collective decisions, often predicated on scouting reports, were paramount for tribal survival, expansion, and the allocation of resources.
  • Key Themes: This verse encapsulates several profound themes prevalent throughout the Book of Judges. Firstly, it powerfully illustrates the theme of dispossession and the failure to inherit, a recurring motif for numerous tribes who, due to a lack of faith and obedience, did not fully conquer their allotted land, leading to ongoing conflict and compromise, as vividly depicted in Judges 1. Secondly, it underscores the critical role of communal decision-making and the tribe's reliance on shared intelligence for their collective future, even when those decisions ultimately steer them towards morally questionable actions. Thirdly, the urgent question, "What [say] ye?", profoundly reflects the anticipation of a solution to a pressing existential problem, setting the stage for the Danites' desperate, yet morally flawed, pursuit of a new home. This pursuit tragically leads to the establishment of a rival religious center, directly contradicting the Mosaic covenant's call to worship Yahweh alone at a central sanctuary, thereby highlighting the pervasive theme of religious syncretism and apostasy that permeates the latter half of the book, particularly in Judges 17-18.

EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

Key Word Analysis

  • came (Hebrew, bôwʼ', H935): This verb signifies the physical arrival of the five Danite spies back at their home cities. Beyond mere movement, it implies the culmination of their mission and the initiation of the next crucial phase: the delivery of their intelligence. The act of "coming" here is charged with anticipation, as it directly precedes the revelation of information that will determine the tribe's future.
  • brethren (Hebrew, ʼâch', H251): This term emphasizes the familial and communal bond within the tribe of Dan. It highlights the collective nature of their struggle and decision-making. The spies are returning not to strangers, but to their own kin, underscoring the shared destiny and mutual dependence that characterized tribal life in ancient Israel. The inquiry that follows is from a unified body, deeply invested in the outcome.
  • said (Hebrew, ʼâmar', H559): This primitive root verb is used with great latitude, but here it denotes a direct and eager verbal inquiry. The "saying" of the brethren is not a casual greeting but an urgent demand for information, reflecting their precarious situation and their hope for a viable solution to their inability to fully inhabit their original inheritance. It sets the immediate tone of high expectation and dependence on the spies' findings.

Verse Breakdown

  • "And they came unto their brethren to Zorah and Eshtaol": This clause marks the successful completion of the spies' reconnaissance mission and their return to the heart of their tribal community. Their arrival back at Zorah and Eshtaol, key Danite strongholds, signifies the central gathering point where the collective decision-making process for the tribe's future would unfold, underscoring the communal nature of the Danite struggle and their shared anticipation.
  • "and their brethren said unto them": This phrase introduces the direct and immediate interaction between the returning spies and the waiting Danite community. The "brethren" represent the collective tribal body, eagerly poised to receive the news that would determine their destiny. This moment is charged with high tension and expectation, as the future of the entire tribe hinges on the report about to be delivered.
  • "What [say] ye?": This succinct and direct question encapsulates the urgency, dependency, and collective anxiety of the Danite people regarding the spies' findings. It is a concise demand for an immediate report, reflecting their precarious situation and their desperate hope for a viable solution to their inability to fully inhabit their original inheritance. The implied verb "say" accurately conveys the intent of the Hebrew, which is a succinct and eager inquiry for the anticipated verbal report.

Literary Devices

Judges 18:8 effectively employs Dialogue to convey the immediate and urgent nature of the interaction between the returning spies and their waiting brethren. The direct question, "What [say] ye?", functions as a powerful example of Epithet, a concise and pointed inquiry that cuts directly to the core issue, reflecting the tribe's collective anxiety and profound anticipation. The specific mention of "Zorah and Eshtaol" serves as a crucial element of Geographical Specificity, firmly grounding the narrative in the Danites' existing, albeit constrained, territory and emphasizing their origins before their significant migration. The entire scene masterfully builds Suspense, as the reader, alongside the Danite brethren, eagerly awaits the crucial report that will determine the tribe's next, and ultimately tragic, course of action.

THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS

Judges 18:8, though brief, serves as a critical juncture in the Danite narrative, powerfully illustrating the profound consequences of Israel's failure to fully obey God's command to dispossess the inhabitants of the land. The Danites' inability to secure their inheritance, stemming from a discernible lack of faith and courage, propelled them to seek an alternative solution outside of God's original provision and covenantal promises. This proactive, yet ultimately unrighteous, search for new territory highlights a pervasive theme throughout the Book of Judges: the people's persistent tendency to rely on their own wisdom, strength, and pragmatic solutions rather than faithfully trusting in God for their deliverance and prosperity. This self-reliance inevitably led to a cyclical pattern of sin, oppression, and temporary, often compromised, deliverance. The communal inquiry underscores the shared responsibility of the tribe in this fateful decision, which would tragically lead them not only to a new land but also into the depths of idolatry and spiritual apostasy.

REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

Judges 18:8 stands as a poignant and enduring reminder of the human tendency to seek our own solutions when confronted with significant challenges, especially when we perceive God's promises as unfulfilled or His path as overly arduous. The Danites, unable to fully possess their divinely promised land, opted for what appeared to be an easier, more pragmatic path—a "new normal" that ultimately led them further away from God's intended design and into spiritual compromise. This narrative compels us to engage in profound self-examination: when we encounter obstacles, feel constrained by circumstances, or face seemingly insurmountable difficulties, do we diligently seek God's will, patiently wait on His timing, and trust in His sovereign power to overcome? Or do we, like the Danites, hastily devise our own plans, even if they lead us down paths of compromise, unrighteousness, or a departure from God's revealed truth? True faith calls us to persevere steadfastly in the path He has set, rather than abandoning it for what appears to be a more convenient or immediately gratifying alternative, recognizing that God's ways are always ultimately for our good and His glory.

Questions for Reflection

  • How do I typically respond when God's promises or my current circumstances feel difficult, delayed, or unfulfilled?
  • In what specific areas of my life might I be tempted to seek "easier" or self-devised solutions rather than patiently trusting God's process and provision?
  • What practical steps can I take to better discern God's will and commit wholeheartedly to His path, even when it requires significant perseverance, faith, and patience?

FAQ

What was the significance of the Danites sending out spies?

Answer: The act of sending out spies, as meticulously described in Judges 18:1-2, was a desperate and ultimately misguided measure by the tribe of Dan. Unlike many other Israelite tribes who largely secured their inheritance through divine assistance and military conquest, the Danites had conspicuously failed to dispossess the Amorites from their divinely allotted territory in the fertile Shephelah (Judges 1:34-35). This meant they were confined, unable to expand, and faced constant pressure from surrounding peoples. Sending spies was a proactive, yet ultimately faithless, attempt to find new, unpossessed land where they could settle and thrive without relying on God's power to conquer their original inheritance. It profoundly highlights their struggle for survival and their perceived need to take matters into their own hands in a period characterized by spiritual and political disarray in Israel, where "every man did that which was right in his own eyes" (Judges 21:25).

CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT

The narrative of the Danites' struggle for an inheritance, their unrighteous pursuit of a new dwelling, and their tragic descent into idolatry stands in stark contrast to the perfect inheritance and righteous leadership found in Jesus Christ. The Danites sought a physical land and security through their own strength and flawed, self-serving decisions, which led them to a deeply compromised spiritual state. In profound contrast, Jesus Christ is the true and ultimate "inheritance" for believers, providing not merely a physical land but eternal life, spiritual security, and an incorruptible dwelling in the presence of God (Ephesians 1:11; Colossians 1:12). While the Danites were driven by the urgent question, "What [say] ye?" concerning a new earthly dwelling, Christ offers a heavenly dwelling and a new identity, calling us to "follow me" (Matthew 4:19). He is the Good Shepherd who truly leads His sheep to abundant pastures and living water, unlike the Danite spies who led their tribe to a place of idolatry and spiritual barrenness (John 10:9-11). The Danites' failure to fully dispossess their enemies foreshadows humanity's inherent inability to overcome the spiritual enemies of sin and death on its own; only through Christ's ultimate victory on the cross can we truly inherit the promises of God and find eternal rest in Him (Hebrews 4:9-10). He is the one who secures our true and lasting inheritance, not through human effort or compromised means, but through His perfect obedience, sacrificial love, and glorious resurrection (1 Peter 1:3-5).

Copy as

Commentary on Judges 18 verses 7–13

I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points

Here is, I. The observation which the spies made upon the city of Laish, and the posture of its inhabitants, Jdg 18:7. Never was place so ill governed and so ill guarded, which would make it a very easy prey to the invader.

1.It was ill governed, for every man might be as bad as he would, and there was no magistrate, no heir of restraint (as the word is), that might so much as put them to shame in any thing, much less put them to death, so that by the most impudent immoralities they provoked God's wrath, and by all manner of mutual mischiefs weakened and consumed one another. See here, (1.) What the office of magistrates is. They are to be heirs of restraint, that is, to preserve a constant entail of power, as heirs to an inheritance, in the places where they are, for the restraining of that which is evil. They are possessors of restraint, entrusted with their authority for this end, that they may check and suppress every thing that is vicious and be a terror to evil doers. It is only God's grace that can renew men's depraved minds and turn their hearts; but the magistrate's power may restrain their bad practices and tie their hands, so that the wickedness of the wicked may not be either so injurious or so infectious as otherwise it would be. Though the sword of justice cannot cut up the root of bitterness, it may cut off its branches and hinder its growth and spreading, that vice may not go without a check, for then it becomes daring and dangerous, and the community shares in the guilt. (2.) See what method must be used for the restraint of wickedness. Sinners must be put to shame, that those who will not be restrained by the shamefulness of the sin before God and their own consciences may be restrained by the shamefulness of the punishment before men. All ways must be tried to dash sin out of countenance and cover it with contempt, to make people ashamed of their idleness, drunkenness, cheating, lying, and other sins, by making reputation always appear on virtue's side. (3.) See how miserable, and how near to ruin, those places are that either have no magistrates or none that bear the sword to any purpose; the wicked then walk on every side, Psa 12:8. And how happy we are in good laws and a good government.

2.It was ill guarded. The people of Laish were careless, quiet, and secure, their gates left open, their walls out of repair, because under no apprehension of danger in any way, though their wickedness was so great that they had reason to fear divine vengeance every day. It was a sign that the Israelites, through their sloth and cowardice, were not now such a terror to the Canaanites as they were when they first came among them, else the city of Laish, which probably knew itself to be assigned to them, would not have been so very secure. Though they were an open and inland town, they lived secure, like the Zidonians (who were surrounded with the sea and were well fortified both by art and nature), but were far from the Zidonians, who therefore could not come in to their assistance, nor help to defend them from the danger which, by debauching their manners, they had helped to bring them into. And, lastly, they had no business with any man, which bespeaks either the idleness they affected (they followed no trade, and so grew lazy and luxurious, and utterly unable to defend themselves) or the independency they affected: they scorned to be either in subjection to or alliance with any of their neighbours, and so they had none to protect them nor bring in any aid to them. They cared for nobody and therefore nobody cared for them. Such as these were the men of Laish.

II. The encouragement which they consequently gave to their countrymen that sent them to prosecute their design upon this city, Jdg 18:8-10. Probably the Danites had formed notions of the insuperable difficulties of the enterprise, thought it impossible ever to make themselves masters of Laish, and therefore had kept themselves so long out of the possession of it, perhaps suggesting likewise to one another, in their unbelief, that it was not a country worth going so far and running such a risk for, which jealousies the spies (and they were not, in this, evil spies) had an eye to in their report. 1. They represent the place as desirable: "If you will trust our judgments, we have seen the land, and we are agreed in our verdict upon the view, that, behold, it is very good (Jdg 18:9), better than this mountainous country into which we are here crowded by the Philistines. You need not doubt of living comfortably in it, for it is a place where there is no want of any thing," Jdg 18:10. See what a good land Canaan was, that this city which lay furthest of all northward, in the utmost corner of the country, stood on such a fruitful spot. 2. They represent it as attainable. They do not at all question but, with God's blessing, they may soon get possession of it; for the people are secure, Jdg 18:10. And the more secure always the less safe. "God has given it into your hands, and you may have it for the taking." They stir them up to the undertaking: "Arise, that we may go up against them, let us go about it speedily and resolutely." They expostulate with them for their delays, and chide them out of their sluggishness: Are you still? Be not slothful to go. Men need to be thus stirred up to mind even their interest. Heaven is a very good land, where there is no want of any thing; our God has, by the promise, given it into our hands; let us not then be slothful in making it sure, and laying hold on eternal life, but strive to enter.

III. The Danites' expedition against Laish. This particular family of them, to whose lot that city fell, now at length make towards it, Jdg 18:11-13. The military men were but 600 in all, not a hundredth part of that tribe, for when they entered Canaan the Danites were above 64,000, Num 26:43. It was strange that none of their brethren of their own tribe, much less of any other, came in to their assistance; but it was long after Israel came to Canaan before there appeared among them any thing of a public spirit, or concern for a common interest, which was the reason why they seldom united in a common head, and this kept them low and inconsiderable. It appears (by Jdg 18:21) that these 600 were the whole number that went to settle there, for they had their families and effects with them, their little ones and cattle, so confident were they of success. The other tribes gave them a free passage through their country. Their first day's march brought them to Kirjath-jearim (Jdg 18:12), and such rare things had military encampments now become in Israel that the place where they rested that night was thence called Mahaneh-dan, the camp of Dan, and probably the place whence they began their march between Zorah and Eshtaol was called by the same name, and is meant, Jdg 13:25. The second day's march brought them to Mount Ephraim, near Micah's house (Jdg 18:13), and there we must pause awhile.

Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Commentary on the Whole Bible. This section covers verses 7–13. Public domain.
Copy as
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Judges 18:8 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.