Joshua 19:1

KJV

¶ And the second lot came forth to Simeon, [even] for the tribe of the children of Simeon according to their families: and their inheritance was within the inheritance of the children of Judah.

KJV (with Strong's)

And the second {H8145} lot {H1486} came forth {H3318} to Simeon {H8095}, even for the tribe {H4294} of the children {H1121} of Simeon {H8095} according to their families {H4940}: and their inheritance {H5159} was within {H8432} the inheritance {H5159} of the children {H1121} of Judah {H3063}.

Complete Jewish Bible

The second lot came out for Shim'on, for the tribe of the descendants of Shim'on according to their families. Their inheritance was inside the inheritance of the descendants of Y'hudah.

Berean Standard Bible

The second lot came out for the clans of the tribe of Simeon:

American Standard Version

And the second lot came out for Simeon, even for the tribe of the children of Simeon according to their families: and their inheritance was in the midst of the inheritance of the children of Judah.

Commentary

### SUMMARY
Joshua 19:1 marks the commencement of the land distribution for the remaining seven tribes of Israel, specifically detailing the inheritance allocated to the tribe of Simeon. This verse reveals a distinctive arrangement: Simeon's portion was not a contiguous, independent territory but was instead situated entirely "within" the expansive inheritance already designated to the tribe of Judah. This unique geographical placement underscores a significant departure from the typical tribal allocations, hinting at Simeon's future trajectory and its deep interconnectedness with, and eventual absorption into, its more dominant southern neighbor.

### CONTEXT
* **Literary Context:** Joshua 19:1 is strategically placed within the latter half of the Book of Joshua (chapters 13-21), which meticulously chronicles the division of the Promised Land among the twelve tribes of Israel. Following the initial major allocations to Reuben, Gad, the half-tribe of Manasseh, Judah, Ephraim, and the other half-tribe of Manasseh (Joshua 13-18), this verse initiates the distribution for the remaining seven tribes. The preceding chapters describe the establishment of the central sanctuary at Shiloh and the meticulous process of surveying the land and casting lots under Joshua's supervision. Thus, Joshua 19:1 serves as a pivotal transition, shifting the narrative focus from the larger, more prominent tribal inheritances to the specific, often more intricate, portions of the remaining tribes, with Simeon being the first among them to receive its lot. This systematic approach highlights the orderly fulfillment of God's promises.
* **Historical & Cultural Context:** The division of the land by lot was a profoundly significant act in ancient Israel, understood not as a random chance but as a divinely guided process for discerning God's will and ensuring a just and equitable distribution. This method underscored God's sovereign hand in fulfilling His ancient covenant promises to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob that their descendants would indeed inherit the land of Canaan, as articulated in [Proverbs 16:33](/proverbs/16-33 "Proverbs 16:33 - The Lord Directs the Lot"). For an Israelite tribe, land ownership was absolutely foundational to their identity, economic security, and the perpetuation of their covenant relationship with Yahweh. Simeon's unique placement "within" Judah's territory was highly unusual and carried profound implications for its future. This arrangement suggests a degree of dependence rather than independent tribal strength, reflecting not only divine decree but also the historical realities of tribal power dynamics, demographic size, and alliances in the nascent Israelite nation.
* **Key Themes:** Joshua 19:1 powerfully contributes to several overarching themes woven throughout the Book of Joshua and the broader Pentateuch. Foremost among these is **Divine Faithfulness**, demonstrating God's unwavering commitment to His ancient covenant promises to provide a land for His people, a promise reiterated from the call of Abraham (e.g., [Genesis 12:7](/genesis/12-7 "Genesis 12:7 - God's Promise to Abraham")). The casting of the lot emphatically highlights **Divine Sovereignty**, illustrating that God, not human strategy or military might, determined the precise boundaries, relationships, and destinies of the tribes, even in seemingly unconventional arrangements like Simeon's. Furthermore, Simeon's specific inheritance within Judah's territory serves as a remarkable **Fulfillment of Prophecy**, particularly Jacob's ancient pronouncement in [Genesis 49:7](/genesis/49-7 "Genesis 49:7 - Jacob's Prophecy Regarding Simeon and Levi"), where he declared that Simeon and Levi would be "divided in Jacob and scattered in Israel." While Levi was scattered as the priestly tribe without a contiguous land inheritance, Simeon's land absorption into Judah's territory directly led to its eventual diminishment and integration, showcasing God's intricate and precise working of His prophetic word across generations.

### EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

#### Key Word Analysis
* **Lot (Hebrew, _gôwrâl'_):** This term refers to a small object, typically a pebble or stone, cast or drawn to determine a decision or outcome. In the biblical context, especially concerning the division of the land, the "lot" was understood not as a random chance but as a divinely guided mechanism through which God's will was revealed and His sovereign plan executed. It underscored that the land distribution was divinely ordained, not based on human negotiation, military conquest, or tribal preference, thus emphasizing God's ultimate authority over the land and its allocation.
* **Inheritance (Hebrew, _nachălâh'_):** More than mere property or possession, _nachălâh_ signifies a divinely given possession, a legacy, or an enduring portion passed down. For the tribes of Israel, their inheritance in the land of Canaan represented the tangible fulfillment of God's covenant promises to their forefathers. It was considered a permanent, inalienable gift from God, symbolizing their identity, security, and their unique covenant relationship with Him. The concept extends beyond the physical land to encompass a spiritual legacy.
* **Within (Hebrew, _tâvek'_):** This preposition is critically important in Joshua 19:1, indicating inclusion, enclosure, or the center of something. The phrase "within the inheritance of the children of Judah" is highly significant because it denotes that Simeon's territory was not merely contiguous or adjacent to Judah's but was geographically embedded or enclosed within Judah's much larger boundaries. This unique arrangement points to Simeon's lesser status, its lack of independent territorial integrity, and foreshadows its eventual absorption into the dominant tribe of Judah, rather than maintaining a distinct and separate tribal identity.

#### Verse Breakdown
* **"And the second lot came forth to Simeon":** This initial clause immediately establishes the divine nature of the land allocation process. The "lot" signifies God's sovereign choice and direct involvement in assigning territory to each tribe. Simeon is identified as the recipient of the "second" lot among the group of seven remaining tribes, highlighting its turn in the systematic and orderly fulfillment of God's promise to provide land for His people. This underscores the intentionality behind the distribution.
* **"[even] for the tribe of the children of Simeon according to their families":** This specification clarifies that the allocation was for the entire tribe of Simeon, meticulously delineated by its constituent families. This detail emphasizes the equitable and thorough nature of the land division, ensuring that each family unit within the tribe received its rightful portion. It reflects the profound importance of familial lineage and tribal structure in Israelite society and the principle of inherited land tenure.
* **"and their inheritance was within the inheritance of the children of Judah":** This is the most distinctive and impactful part of the verse, revealing the extraordinary geographical arrangement for Simeon. Unlike other tribes that received their own distinct, contiguous territories, Simeon's land was not separate but was enclosed by or embedded within the much larger territory of Judah. This unique placement was highly unusual and foreshadowed Simeon's future historical trajectory, characterized by a lack of independent strength, eventual integration, or even absorption into its more powerful neighbor, Judah.

#### Literary Devices
The verse employs **Foreshadowing** by subtly hinting at Simeon's future. The placement of Simeon's inheritance "within" Judah's territory is not merely a geographical detail but a prophetic indicator of Simeon's eventual decline, diminishment, and absorption. This arrangement directly fulfills Jacob's ancient and somewhat ominous prophecy concerning Simeon in [Genesis 49:7](/genesis/49-7 "Genesis 49:7 - Jacob's Prophecy Regarding Simeon and Levi"). This geographical detail also functions as **Symbolism**, where the physical land allocation symbolizes the spiritual and historical destiny of the tribe. The land, a tangible representation of God's promise and covenant faithfulness, here also symbolizes the inter-tribal dynamics and the consequences of past actions. Furthermore, the casting of the lot itself is a profound literary and theological device demonstrating **Divine Sovereignty**, emphasizing that God is the ultimate director of events, meticulously orchestrating even the seemingly mundane act of land distribution to accomplish His overarching purposes.

### THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Joshua 19:1 profoundly illustrates the intricate outworking of God's sovereign plan and His unwavering faithfulness to His covenant promises. The precise, divinely ordained placement of Simeon's inheritance, even within the territory of Judah, underscores that no detail of God's will is arbitrary or left to chance. It highlights how God orchestrates circumstances, even those seemingly disadvantageous or unconventional from a human perspective, to fulfill His ancient prophetic declarations and to shape the destiny of His people. This verse reminds us that God's promises are not only broad in scope but also meticulously detailed, impacting individual tribal identities and inter-tribal relationships within the larger tapestry of Israel's history, all according to His perfect wisdom.

* [Genesis 49:7](/genesis/49-7 "Jacob's Prophecy Regarding Simeon and Levi") - Jacob's prophetic words concerning Simeon and Levi, foretelling their dispersion and scattering, find a remarkable and direct fulfillment in Simeon's unique land allocation within Judah's territory.
* [Numbers 26:14](/numbers/26-14 "Simeon's Diminished Numbers in the Census") - The census taken after the plague reveals Simeon as the smallest tribe in terms of fighting men, providing a demographic context that helps explain its eventual absorption into Judah.
* [Judges 1:3](/judges/1-3 "Judah and Simeon's Alliance in Conquest") - This verse records Judah inviting Simeon to join them in battle, indicating their close cooperation and Simeon's reliance on Judah, further illustrating their intertwined destinies and the beginning of Simeon's integration.

### REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Joshua 19:1 offers a powerful and counter-intuitive lesson in trusting God's sovereign plan, especially when our "inheritance" or life circumstances appear unexpected, unconventional, or less prominent than what we might envision for ourselves or others. Simeon's story reminds us that God works out His purposes not always through independent strength or expansive autonomy, but sometimes through interdependence, integration, and even a degree of diminishment for a greater, overarching divine design. It challenges us to embrace our unique place within God's larger community, recognizing that our individual journeys are often intricately intertwined with others, and that God's faithfulness extends to every detail of our lives, fulfilling His promises in ways we may not initially comprehend. Just as Simeon found its place within the greater inheritance of Israel, we are called to find our ultimate purpose, security, and identity within the body of Christ, trusting that our true and eternal inheritance is securely found in Him, regardless of our earthly circumstances.

#### Questions for Reflection
* **How does Simeon's unique inheritance challenge our assumptions about what a "blessing" or "inheritance" from God should look like in our own lives?**
* **In what ways might God be calling us to find our "inheritance" or purpose in a way that is intertwined with or dependent on others, rather than standing alone in independent strength?**
* **How does the precise fulfillment of Jacob's ancient prophecy through Simeon's land allocation deepen your trust in God's meticulous faithfulness to His word, even across generations?**
* **What does it mean to trust God's "lot" for your life, even when His plan seems unconventional, requires integration with others, or involves a perceived diminishment of your own independent identity?**

### FAQ

**Why was Simeon's inheritance placed within Judah's territory?**

Answer: Simeon's unique placement within Judah's territory is widely understood as a direct and remarkable fulfillment of Jacob's ancient prophecy in [Genesis 49:7](/genesis/49-7 "Jacob's Prophecy Regarding Simeon and Levi"), where he declared that Simeon and Levi would be "divided in Jacob and scattered in Israel." While Levi was scattered throughout Israel as the priestly tribe without a distinct land inheritance, Simeon's land was absorbed into Judah's, leading to its eventual diminishment and integration. Historically, Simeon was a smaller tribe, as evidenced by the census of [Numbers 26:14](/numbers/26-14 "Simeon's Diminished Numbers in the Census"), and likely lacked the military and demographic strength to secure and maintain a fully independent territory. Its placement within Judah's larger, more powerful domain provided a measure of protection and resources, but ultimately led to its loss of distinct tribal identity over time, aligning perfectly with the prophetic word.

**What happened to the tribe of Simeon later in Israel's history?**

Answer: Following the initial land allocation described in Joshua, the tribe of Simeon gradually lost its distinct identity and was largely absorbed into the more dominant tribe of Judah. While they initially cooperated with Judah in some conquests (e.g., [Judges 1:3-4](/judges/1-3 "Judah and Simeon's Alliance in Conquest")), Simeon is rarely mentioned as an independent entity in later biblical narratives. Their territory effectively became part of Judah's, and the Simeonites are often simply counted with Judah or disappear from the historical record as a separate tribal force. This historical trajectory, marked by a lack of independent political and military power, aligns perfectly with the prophetic implications of their initial land inheritance being "within" Judah, foreshadowing their eventual integration and loss of unique tribal prominence.

### CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
The inheritance of the land in Joshua, culminating in verses like Joshua 19:1, serves as a powerful type pointing forward to the ultimate and eternal inheritance found in Jesus Christ. Just as the physical land was a tangible fulfillment of God's promise to Israel, Christ Himself is the true and ultimate inheritance for all believers, a spiritual reality far surpassing any earthly territory or tribal portion. Simeon's unique placement within Judah's inheritance foreshadows the profound truth that all who are "in Christ" are spiritually grafted into the lineage of Judah, the royal tribe from which the Messiah came. Our spiritual inheritance is not a separate parcel, but is found entirely "within" Christ, who is our peace, our righteousness, our wisdom, and our complete portion (cf. [Ephesians 1:3-14](/ephesians/1-3 "Ephesians 1:3-14 - Spiritual Blessings in Christ") and [Colossians 1:12](/colossians/1-12 "Colossians 1:12 - Sharing in the Inheritance of the Saints")). The fragmented, often diminished, and temporary earthly inheritances of the tribes find their glorious and secure fulfillment in the indivisible and eternal kingdom of God, inaugurated by the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world ([John 1:29](/john/1-29 "John 1:29 - Jesus, the Lamb of God")). In Christ, all God's promises find their "Yes" and "Amen" ([2 Corinthians 1:20](/2_corinthians/1-20 "2 Corinthians 1:20 - God's Promises are Yes in Christ")), providing a secure and eternal dwelling place for all who believe, not based on tribal lot or earthly lineage, but on divine grace and perfect redemption.

Note: Commentary is generated by AI with a directive for Biblical fidelity. Always rely on the Holy Spirit for discernment. The Scripture text and cross-references are from verified, non-AI sources.

Cross-References

Joshua 19:9

Out of the portion of the children of Judah [was] the inheritance of the children of Simeon: for the part of the children of Judah was too much for them: therefore the children of Simeon had their inheritance within the inheritance of them.

Genesis 49:5

¶ Simeon and Levi [are] brethren; instruments of cruelty [are in] their habitations.

Genesis 49:7

Cursed [be] their anger, for [it was] fierce; and their wrath, for it was cruel: I will divide them in Jacob, and scatter them in Israel.

Joshua 18:6

Ye shall therefore describe the land [into] seven parts, and bring [the description] hither to me, that I may cast lots for you here before the LORD our God.

Joshua 18:11

¶ And the lot of the tribe of the children of Benjamin came up according to their families: and the coast of their lot came forth between the children of Judah and the children of Joseph.