James 2
Warning Against Favoritism and Partiality 1–13
Faith Without Works Is Dead 14–26
Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain
Study Notes for James 2
Verse 1
respect of persons — Prosopolepsia, literally the taking of a face, occurs in Rom 2:11, Eph 6:9, Col 3:25 and here. The law is Lev 19:15, 'thou shalt not respect the person of the poor, nor honour the person of the mighty'. 'The Lord of glory' is the title of 1 Cor 2:8, 'they would not have crucified the Lord of glory'.
Verse 4
partial in yourselves — Diakrino, to make a distinction, is 'wavering' in 1:6 and 'put no difference' in Acts 15:9. 'Evil thoughts' (dialogismos) are the reasonings of the heart, as in Matt 15:19. The corrective is John 7:24, 'Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment.'
Verse 5
Hath not God chosen the poor — 'Chosen' (eklegomai) is the verb of 1 Cor 1:27, 'God hath chosen the foolish things of the world'. 'Heirs of the kingdom' is joined to the promise of 1:12, 'the crown of life, which the Lord hath promised to them that love him'. Christ said 'Blessed be ye poor' (Luke 6:20).
Verse 8
the royal law — Basilikos means belonging to a king; the law is the King's and goes with the 'kingdom' of v.5. It is quoted from Lev 19:18, ranked second by Christ (Matt 22:39), and summed up by Paul, 'all the law is fulfilled in one word' (Gal 5:14).
Verse 9
have respect to persons — The verb prosopolepteo occurs only here; the noun is in v.1. 'Convinced' (elencho) is 'convicted' in John 8:9. 'Transgressors' (parabates), those who step across a line, is used again in v.11. The law is Lev 19:15, which forbids honouring the person of the mighty.
Verse 10
offend in one point — 'Offend' (ptaio), to stumble, is the verb of 3:2, 'in many things we offend all'. 'Guilty of all' (enochos) is held under the whole law, as with the curse of Deut 27:26 on whoever 'confirmeth not all the words of this law' (cf. Gal 3:10). Verse 11 gives the reason, one Lawgiver.
Verse 12
the law of liberty — This is the 'perfect law of liberty' of 1:25, joined to the royal law of v.8. 'Liberty' (eleutheria) is not licence: 'use not liberty for an occasion to the flesh, but by love serve one another' (Gal 5:13). 'Shall be judged' looks ahead to the judgment of v.13.
Verse 13
mercy rejoiceth against judgment — 'Without mercy' is one word, anileos, found only here. 'Rejoiceth against' (katakauchaomai) is 'boast' in Rom 11:18, 'boast not against the branches'. The principle is that of Matt 5:7, 'Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy', and of the unforgiving servant (Matt 18:33).
Verse 14
What doth it profit — Ophelos, profit, occurs here, in v.16 and in 1 Cor 15:32. The case is of a man who 'say he hath faith' without works, as 1:22 distinguishes doers from hearers only. Christ's own test is 'he that doeth the will of my Father' (Matt 7:21).
Verse 17
is dead, being alone — 'Dead' (nekros) is said of faith three times, in vv.17, 20 and 26. 'Being alone' is literally 'by itself', faith taken apart from works. The faith in view is the one claimed in v.14, and the figure in v.26 is the body without the spirit.
Verse 18
shew me thy faith — 'Shew' (deiknymi) is the verb of 3:13, 'let him shew out of a good conversation his works'. The speaker offers to show faith 'by my works', out of them, since it cannot be displayed without them. Christ gives the same rule for fruit: 'by their fruits ye shall know them' (Matt 7:20).
Verse 19
the devils also believe, and tremble — Phrisso, to shudder, occurs only here. 'One God' is the creed of Deut 6:4, 'The LORD our God is one LORD'. The evil spirits confess more: 'I know thee who thou art, the Holy One of God' (Mark 1:24), and 'Jesus, thou Son of God' (Matt 8:29).
Verse 21
justified by works — The event is Gen 22, where the LORD says 'now I know that thou fearest God, seeing thou hast not withheld thy son' (22:12). Heb 11:17 calls it faith: 'By faith Abraham… offered up Isaac'. It came after the belief recorded in Gen 15:6, which James cites in v.23.
Verse 23
the Friend of God — The title is in 2 Chr 20:7, 'Abraham thy friend for ever', and Isa 41:8. 'Imputed' (logizomai), counted, is the verb of Gen 15:6 and of Rom 4:3. The Scripture 'was fulfilled' in the sense that the offering of v.21 showed what kind of belief it was.
Verse 24
not by faith only — The 'faith only' denied is the idle faith of v.14. V.22 says 'faith wrought with his works', and Gal 5:6 has 'faith which worketh by love'. Paul's 'justified by faith without the deeds of the law' (Rom 3:28) concerns works of the law, and the same Abraham stands in both (Rom 4:3; v.23).
Verse 25
Rahab the harlot — The 'messengers' (angelos, usually 'angels') are the two spies of Josh 2. She let them down by a cord and sent them to the mountain (Josh 2:15–16), which James calls 'another way'. Heb 11:31 names it faith. 'Rachab' stands in the line of Christ (Matt 1:5), and Josh 6:25 records that she was saved alive.
Verse 26
the body without the spirit — 'Without' (choris) is the same word in both halves of the comparison, as in v.20. 'Spirit' (pneuma) is the breath of life that God gave (Gen 2:7) and to which it returns (Eccl 12:7). The verse is the third statement of faith that is 'dead' (vv.17, 20, 26).