Skip to content
Share this page

John 8:21

“Warning: You Shall Die in Your Sins”John 8:21–30

King James Version
Then said Jesus again unto them, I go my way, and ye shall seek me, and shall die in your sins: whither I go, ye cannot come.

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
Then G3767 said G2036 Jesus G2424 again G3825 unto them G846, I G1473 go my way G5217, and G2532 ye shall seek G2212 me G3165, and G2532 shall die G599 in G1722 your G5216 sins G266: whither G3699 I G1473 go G5217, ye G5210 cannot G3756 G1410 come G2064.

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
Again He said to them, “I am going away, and you will look for Me, but you will die in your sin. Where I am going, you cannot come.”

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
He said therefore again unto them, I go away, and ye shall seek me, and shall die in your sin: whither I go, ye cannot come.

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
Yeshua said therefore again to them, “I am going away, and you will seek me, and you will die in your sins. Where I go, you can’t come.”

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
Then saide Iesus againe vnto them, I goe my way, and ye shall seeke me, and shall die in your sinnes, Whither I goe, can ye not come.

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
therefore said Jesus again to them, `I go away, and ye will seek me, and in your sin ye shall die; whither I go away, ye are not able to come.'

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
24 Greek words
  1. ΕἶπενEipenHe saidG2036V-2AAI-3SVerb 2nd Aorist Active Indicative 3rd Singular
  2. οὖνounthenG3767CONJConjunction
  3. πάλινpalinagainG3825ADVAdverb
  4. αὐτοῖςautoisto themG846P-DPMPersonal pronoun Dative Plural Masculine
  5. ὁho[the]G3588T-NSMDefinite article Nominative Singular Masculine
  6. Ἰησοῦς·IēsousJesusG2424N-NSM-PNoun Nominative Singular Masculine Individual
  7. ἐγὼegōI myselfG1473P-1NSPersonal pronoun Nominative 1st Singular
  8. ὑπάγωhupagōam going awayG5217V-PAI-1SVerb Present Active Indicative 1st Singular
  9. καὶkaiandG2532CONJConjunction
  10. ζητήσετέzētēseteyou will seekG2212V-FAI-2PVerb Future Active Indicative 2nd Plural
  11. μεmeMeG3165P-1ASPersonal pronoun Accusative 1st Singular
  12. καὶkaiandG2532CONJConjunction
  13. ἐνeninG1722PREPPreposition
  14. τῇtēatheG3588T-DSFDefinite article Dative Singular Feminine
  15. ἁμαρτίᾳhamartiasinG266N-DSFNoun Dative Singular Feminine
  16. ὑμῶνhumōnof youG4771P-2GPPersonal pronoun Genitive 2nd Plural
  17. ἀποθανεῖσθε·apothaneistheyou will dieG599V-FDI-2PVerb Future Middle Deponent Indicative 2nd Plural
  18. ὅπουhopouwhereG3699CONJConjunction
  19. ἐγὼegōI myselfG1473P-1NSPersonal pronoun Nominative 1st Singular
  20. ὑπάγωhupagōgoG5217V-PAI-1SVerb Present Active Indicative 1st Singular
  21. ὑμεῖςhumeisyou yourselvesG4771P-2NPPersonal pronoun Nominative 2nd Plural
  22. οὐounotG3756PRT-NNegative Particle Negative
  23. δύνασθεdunastheare ableG1410V-PNI-2PVerb Present Middle Or Passive Deponent Indicative 2nd Plural
  24. ἐλθεῖνeltheinto comeG2064V-2AANVerb 2nd Aorist Active Infinitive
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Greek, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Greek text the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Greek word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “charity” where the word-by-word meaning reads “love”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Greek. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
See on the biblical-era maps
All John Sites (Jerusalem)
All John Sites (Jerusalem) View full PDF
Jesus' Third Journey from Galilee to Jerusalem
Jesus' Third Journey from Galilee to Jerusalem View full PDF
All John Sites (Levant)
All John Sites (Levant) View full PDF

Map © Biblica Open Bible Maps · CC BY-SA 4.0

In the KJVVerse 26,403 of 31,102 · 84.9%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

Jesus warns his opponents that he is going away to the Father, that they will seek him too late and die in their sins, and that they cannot come where he goes.

“Then said Jesus again unto them,”

He has given this warning before (John 7:33–34), and he repeats it now to the same opponents.

“I go my way,”

Hypágō, to go away. He means his return to the Father through his death, resurrection and ascension.

“and ye shall seek me,”

A seeking that comes too late, perhaps in distress, and without faith.

“and shall die in your sins:”

To die unforgiven, with sins still charged against them, and so to face God’s judgment.

“whither I go, ye cannot come.”

Ou with dýnamai, “not able”. Their unbelief bars them from the Father’s presence, where he is going.

Passage studyJohn 8:21–30

Believe That I Am He, or Die in Your Sins

21Then said Jesus again unto them, I go my way, and ye shall seek me, and shall die in your sins: whither I go, ye cannot come. 22Then said the Jews, Will he kill himself? because he saith, Whither I go, ye cannot come. 23And he said unto them, Ye are from beneath; I am from above: ye are of this world; I am not of this world. 24I said therefore unto you, that ye shall die in your sins: for if ye believe not that I am he, ye shall die in your sins. 25Then said they unto him, Who art thou? And Jesus saith unto them, Even the same that I said unto you from the beginning. 26I have many things to say and to judge of you: but he that sent me is true; and I speak to the world those things which I have heard of him. 27They understood not that he spake to them of the Father. 28Then said Jesus unto them, When ye have lifted up the Son of man, then shall ye know that I am he, and that I do nothing of myself; but as my Father hath taught me, I speak these things. 29And he that sent me is with me: the Father hath not left me alone; for I do always those things that please him. 30As he spake these words, many believed on him.

Summary

During the Feast of Tabernacles, in the temple at Jerusalem, Jesus gives the men who oppose him a solemn warning. He is going away, they will seek him, and they will die in their sins, because where he goes they cannot come. They turn his words into a sneer about suicide. He answers that they are from beneath and he is from above, and that the one way out of their sins is to believe that “I am he”. When they ask who he is, he points to all he has told them from the beginning, to the true Father who sent him, and to the day when they will lift him up and then know him. The Father is with him, because he always does what pleases the Father. As he speaks, many believe on him. The passage holds both the warning and its answer, for the Son of man who would be lifted up is the one in whom sinners believe and live.

Jesus Warns That He Goes Where They Cannot Come

These words belong to the Feast of Tabernacles (John 7:2), one of Israel’s three great pilgrimage feasts, when Jerusalem was crowded with worshippers. The feast remembered God’s care for Israel in the wilderness and looked ahead to the age of the Messiah. Its ceremonies of poured water and great lamps lit in the temple stand behind Jesus’ offer of living water (John 7:37–38) and his claim to be the light of the world (John 8:12). The Pharisees answered that claim by calling his witness untrue (John 8:13), and the argument that followed about his witness and his Father (John 8:14–19) runs straight into this passage, spoken in the temple treasury.

“Then said Jesus again unto them” looks back to an earlier day of the feast, when he had already told them that he would go away and that they would look for him and be unable to come where he is (John 7:33–34). He says it again now, and more sharply, because their unbelief has set hard. “I go my way” is hypágō, which Strong’s gives as to go away or withdraw, “as if sinking out of sight”. Jesus means his return to the Father who sent him, by way of the cross, the resurrection and the ascension. That departure was also the step by which the Holy Spirit would come to his people (John 16:7), so the going that brings his enemies loss brings his disciples gain.

“Ye shall seek me” points to a time when these men will look for him too late, perhaps in distress or under judgment, a search for relief made without faith or repentance. “Ye cannot come” joins two Greek words, ou, the plain word for “not”, and dýnamai, “to be able”. The barrier lies in them. Jesus is returning to the presence of God, and he himself is the one way there: “I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me” (John 14:6). He is the door (John 10:9) and the one mediator between God and men (1 Timothy 2:5), so those who refuse him shut themselves out of the place he is going. Later in the chapter he tells these same hearers that they are unable to hear his word, because “ye are not of God” (John 8:43–47).

What does it mean to die in your sins?

To die in your sins is to die with your sins still upon you, unforgiven, and so to come under God’s judgment for them. The verb is apothnḗskō, “to die”, the ordinary word for death, and the noun is hamartía, “sin”, which Strong’s marks as properly abstract. The plural, “your sins”, gathers up all that these men had done against God, and the state of rebellion behind it. Jesus speaks of bodily death, but the weight of the warning lies in what follows it: “it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment” (Hebrews 9:27). The state a person is in at death settles where they will spend eternity.

Scripture says the same in many places. “For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord” (Romans 6:23). Sin separates people from God (Isaiah 59:2), and its final end is the second death (Revelation 20:14–15). John puts both sides in one verse: “He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him” (John 3:36).

The other side of the warning is the promise. God gave his Son so that whoever believes in him should have everlasting life (John 3:16), and for those who are in Christ Jesus there is “no condemnation” (Romans 8:1). By the blood of Jesus believers have “a new and living way” into the holiest (Hebrews 10:19–20). Jesus speaks this warning while these men can still hear him and believe, and verse 30 shows that many did.

The Leaders Ask Whether He Will Kill Himself

“The Jews” in John’s Gospel often means the religious authorities in Jerusalem who opposed Jesus, and they are the ones speaking here. “Said” is légō, which Strong’s describes as laying forth or relating in words, and their question is a pointed one. They take his words about going away at the level of the earth, repeating them back to him: “Whither I go, ye cannot come.” If a man goes where others are unable to follow, they reason, he must mean to end his own life. The verb for “kill” is apokteínō, the ordinary word to kill, and “himself” turns it back on the speaker.

In that day suicide was counted a grave sin and a shameful death. Those who took their own lives were often denied full burial and mourning, and were thought to be shut out of the community and of the life to come. So the question carries contempt along with confusion. It mocks Jesus and tries to make his words sound like the talk of a desperate man.

The irony runs deep. Jesus will die, and he will go where they are unable to follow, but his death will come at their hands, as he tells them in verse 28, and it will be the very means of salvation. His going leads through the cross and the resurrection to his ascension (Acts 1:9–11) and to the glory of the Father (John 17:5), where he is our great High Priest (Hebrews 4:14–16). Those who believe are joined to him even now. God has seated us with him in heavenly places (Ephesians 2:6), and in him we have access to the Father (Ephesians 3:12), so the place they “cannot come” lies open to faith.

The leaders missed all this because, as Paul writes, “the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned” (1 Corinthians 2:14). Jesus had said the same to Nicodemus: “Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God” (John 3:3).

Jesus Is From Above, and They Are From Beneath

Jesus answers the mockery by naming the gulf between them: “Ye are from beneath; I am from above: ye are of this world; I am not of this world.” All four phrases rest on the one preposition ek, “from” or “out of”, and the KJV’s “from” and “of” both render it with the same sense. The verse is about where each side comes from. Kátō means downward or beneath, and ánō means up or above. The beneath and the above here are spiritual and moral, earthly origin set against heavenly.

To be from beneath is to be rooted in the earthly order, with an outlook shaped by human wisdom and by sin, and so to be unable to grasp what comes from heaven. Jesus is from above. He came down from heaven to do the will of the one who sent him (John 6:38), and he who comes from above is above all (John 3:31). He is the Word who was with God in the beginning and through whom all things were made (John 1:1–3). Because he comes from the Father, he alone has the truth and the authority to make the Father known.

Kósmos, “world”, has the root sense of an orderly arrangement or adornment, and by extension the world. In John it often means the world of people turned away from God, the darkness into which the light shines (John 1:5). To be “of this world” is to belong to that order and take one’s values from it. Jesus stands apart from it in purity, and that fits him to be the spotless Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29).

The verse also holds out hope. The one from above came so that those from beneath could be born again, or born from above (John 3:3–7). They then become, as Jesus said of his disciples, “not of the world”, and he prayed for them as people who remain in the world and carry his truth into it (John 17:15–18). Paul says of believers, “our conversation is in heaven” (Philippians 3:20), calls them to set their affection on things above (Colossians 3:1–2), and names them fellowcitizens with the saints (Ephesians 2:19).

“If Ye Believe Not That I Am He”

Verse 24 repeats the warning and gives its condition. “Ye shall die in your sins” stands twice in this verse, at its beginning and its end, with the condition between them: “if ye believe not that I am he”. The repetition makes the stakes plain. What a person believes about Jesus divides life from death.

The words “I am he” are egṓ eimí in Greek, “I am”, and the KJV supplies “he” to make smooth English. Egṓ is the pronoun “I”, which Greek usually adds only for emphasis, and eimí is the everyday verb “to be”. The weight lies in the phrase standing on its own. Spoken this way, “I am” echoes the name God gave to Moses: “I AM THAT I AM” (Exodus 3:14). Jesus uses it the same way later in this chapter, “Before Abraham was, I am” (John 8:58), and claims like these are why his opponents later took up stones and charged him with blasphemy (John 10:33). He is claiming to be the eternal God, the self-existent One.

To believe, pisteúō, is to credit what someone says and to trust the one who says it. To believe “that I am he” is to accept that Jesus is who he says he is and to rest on him. John writes, “He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God” (John 3:18). Hebrews says the same of faith in God: “he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him” (Hebrews 11:6).

The verse also points to the cure. The very sins in which these men would die are what Jesus came to carry. God “made him to be sin for us” (2 Corinthians 5:21), so that those who believe in the I AM are freed from dying in their own.

Who Art Thou?

Jesus answers that he is the one he has been telling them he is from the very start. Their question, with the word tís, “who”, is a demand and a challenge, pressing him for a plain statement they can use against him. It also shows how little they had taken in, after all his signs and teaching. “Said they” is légō again, and “saith” for Jesus is épō, another common verb for speaking. “I said” in his reply is laléō, the general verb to talk or utter words.

The Greek of his answer, tēn archēn ho ti kai lalō hymin, is hard, and believers translate it in more than one way. The KJV takes it as “Even the same that I said unto you from the beginning”, supplying “the same”, so that Jesus’ claims now are those he made at the start of his ministry and the fault lies in their hearing. Some render it as a question, “Why do I speak to you at all?”, a word of weariness at their unbelief. Others read it as “I am the Beginning”, linking it to “In the beginning was the Word” (John 1:1) and to Christ as the Alpha and Omega (Revelation 22:13). The word archḗ means “beginning”, and in other uses “origin” or “first cause”, or “ruler” or “power”.

On every reading Jesus stands unchanged. God, who spoke in times past by the prophets, “hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son” (Hebrews 1:1–3), the Son through whom all things were created (Colossians 1:15–17). Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today and for ever (Hebrews 13:8), and the truth he told about himself at the start is the truth he tells at the end.

The One Who Sent Him Is True

“I have many things to say and to judge of you” uses échō, to have or hold. Jesus has much he could say about these men, and his words already expose their unbelief and their blindness. “To judge” here is an assessment of their hearts, and it brings every hearer to a point of decision, toward life or toward condemnation, as John 3:18 says.

“But he that sent me is true” turns, with allá, “but”, from what he could say against them to the one whose word he speaks. The word for “true” is alēthḗs, which Strong’s explains as true “as not concealing”, and so reliable and truthful. It is set beside alēthinós, which stresses what is genuine or real. Jesus had said the same of the one who sent him earlier at the feast (John 7:28). “Sent” is pémpō, the ordinary verb to send. Since the Father is true, everything the Son speaks from him is true, and to reject the Son’s words is to reject the truth of God himself.

“I speak to the world those things which I have heard of him.” To hear, akoúō, describes how the Son receives the Father’s words, and “to the world” is eis, “to” or “into”, with kósmos, the same word as in verse 23. His message is for all people. He speaks what he hears and does what he sees the Father do (John 5:19), and the Father gave him commandment what he should say (John 12:49–50). He is the Word made flesh, “full of grace and truth” (John 1:14), the one Peter confessed had the words of eternal life (John 6:68), and the truth itself in person (John 14:6).

Blind to the Father of Whom He Spoke

John adds a short note: “They understood not that he spake to them of the Father.” To understand, ginṓskō, is to know, perceive or come to understand. “Spake” is légō, and “Father” is patḗr, the ordinary word for a father. Jesus had been speaking of the Father plainly through the whole exchange, so the fault lay in their hearing.

Jews of the day called God the Father of the nation, or Creator of all. Jesus spoke of God as his own Father in a way that belonged to him alone, and when he did so his opponents said he was making himself equal with God (John 5:18). Their failure here belongs to a wider pattern: “He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and the world knew him not. He came unto his own, and his own received him not” (John 1:10–11).

The Son came to make the Father known. He is in the bosom of the Father and has declared him (John 1:18), and he is the express image of God’s person (Hebrews 1:3). Jesus later told his disciples, “If ye had known me, ye should have known my Father also” (John 14:7), and whoever has seen him has seen the Father (John 14:9). The men in the temple stood before that very revelation and missed it.

When the Son of Man Is Lifted Up

“When ye have lifted up the Son of man” is Jesus’ prophecy of his crucifixion. The verb hypsóō means to raise up or exalt, and in John it carries both senses at once. Jesus would be raised up on the cross, a death of shame that the law counted as accursed (Deuteronomy 21:23), and in that same lifting up he would be exalted. He had told Nicodemus that the Son of man must be lifted up as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness (John 3:14), and later he says that when he is lifted up from the earth he will draw all men to himself (John 12:32–33). “Son of man” was Jesus’ own name for himself, and it reaches back to the one like the Son of man in Daniel who receives an everlasting kingdom (Daniel 7:13–14). It speaks of his true humanity and of his authority.

“Ye have lifted up” lays the act at their door. These very men would bring about his death, and God would use it to carry out his plan. The cross bore the sins of his people, “with his stripes we are healed” (Isaiah 53:5–6). Christ humbled himself and became obedient to death, and God has highly exalted him (Philippians 2:8–9). At Pentecost Peter proclaimed that the crucified Jesus, exalted at God’s right hand, had been made both Lord and Christ (Acts 2:33–36).

“Then shall ye know that I am he.” The verb “know” is ginṓskō, the same verb as “they understood not” in verse 27. What they missed while he stood before them would become clear after they lifted him up. Here again “I am he” is egṓ eimí, the words of verse 24. The cross, the resurrection and the ascension would show beyond question who he is, and the One they rejected would be known as the I AM, God come in the flesh (John 1:14).

“I do nothing of myself; but as my Father hath taught me, I speak these things.” People ask whether this makes the Son less than the Father. It shows the Father and the Son perfectly one in will, with the Son carrying out all the Father’s purpose and speaking all the Father’s words, as he says elsewhere that the Father dwells in him and does the works (John 14:10). It also answers the charge that he spoke on his own authority or against God. He speaks what the Father taught him, and his whole ministry rests on the Father’s authority.

The Father Has Not Left Him Alone

“And he that sent me is with me” uses pémpō, the verb for “sent” in verse 26. The one who sent him has stayed beside him, and “the Father hath not left me alone” says it a second time. Mónos means alone, sole or single, and the Father has never left the Son on his own. Surrounded by men who doubted and mocked him, Jesus rests in that unbroken fellowship.

“For I do always those things that please him.” The word for “please” is arestós, what is agreeable or fitting, and the Son does these things always. His food was to do the will of him who sent him (John 4:34), he came down from heaven to do it (John 6:38), and he and the Father are one (John 10:30). At his baptism the Father declared his pleasure in his beloved Son (Matthew 3:17). Every word and deed of Jesus pleased the Father, and that perfect obedience made him the spotless sacrifice for sin.

That obedience is also our hope. By one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, and by the obedience of one many are made righteous (Romans 5:19). Christ’s obedience held all the way to the cross (Philippians 2:8), and those who believe are clothed in the righteousness of the One who always pleased the Father (2 Corinthians 5:21), so that the Father is pleased with us in him.

Many Believed on Him

“As he spake these words, many believed on him.” “Spake” is laléō, and it was the very words he had just spoken, about the Father who sent him, about being lifted up, about the Father’s presence, that brought hearers to faith. “Many” is polýs, and it tells us that his message found a real welcome among the crowd while the leaders went on resisting.

“Believed on him” joins pisteúō with eis, which means “into” or “to”. Pisteúō can mean to credit what someone says, and it can mean to trust and rely on a person, and believing on Jesus is how this Gospel speaks of the faith that receives him. To all who received him he gave power to become the sons of God (John 1:12). “Faith cometh by hearing” (Romans 10:17), and here it came by hearing Jesus himself. There is one name given for salvation: “there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved” (Acts 4:12).

Jesus turns at once to those who believed and speaks to them of continuing in his word and of the freedom the truth brings (John 8:31–36). The faith that begins as he speaks is called to go on in his word.

The Warning and the Cross That Answers It

Jesus warns these men plainly, to their faces, while they are mocking him, because their sins will hold them in death unless they believe. The same passage shows that the warning need be no one’s end. The one who says “ye shall die in your sins” is the Son of man who would be lifted up, who carried sin on the cross so that those who believe in him are set free from theirs.

The passage shows us God the Father, who is true, who sent his Son and stayed beside him, and who was pleased with all he did. It shows us the Son, who came from above, spoke what he heard from the Father, and went to the cross in that same obedience. The cross these men meant as his end became the place where “I am” was made known, and the place where they “cannot come” now stands open to everyone who believes on him.

For those who already believe, the warning measures what we have been spared, and it stirs compassion for all who are still in their sins. Verse 30 shows that his words brought many of his hearers to faith that very day.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers John 8:21–30. He set out his notes in a four-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 10 verses
Passage under commentJohn 8:21–30
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

Christ here gives fair warning to the careless unbelieving Jews to consider what would be the consequence of their infidelity, that they might prevent it before it was too late; for he spoke words of terror as well as words of grace. Observe here,

I.The wrath threatened (John 8:21):

Jesus said again unto them that which might be likely to do them good. He continued to teach, in kindness to those few who received his doctrine, though there were many that resisted it, which is an example to ministers to go on with their work, notwithstanding opposition, because a remnant shall be saved. Here Christ changes his voice; he had piped to them in the offers of his grace, and they had not danced; now he mourns to them in the denunciations of his wrath, to try if they would lament. He said, I go my way, and you shall seek me, and shall die in your sins. Whither I go you cannot come. Every word is terrible, and bespeaks spiritual judgments, which are the sorest of all judgments; worse than war, pestilence, and captivity, which the Old Testament prophets denounced. Four things are here threatened against the Jews.

1.Christ's departure from them: I go my way, that is, "It shall not be long before I go; you need not take so much pains to drive me from you, I shall go of myself." They said to him, Depart from us, we desire not the knowledge of thy ways; and he takes them at their word; but woe to those from whom Christ departs. Ichabod, the glory is gone, our defence is departed, when Christ goes. Christ frequently warned them of his departure before he left them: he bade often farewell, as one loth to depart, and willing to be invited, and that would have them stir up themselves to take hold on him.

2.Their enmity to the true Messiah, and their fruitless and infatuated enquiries after another Messiah when he was gone away, which were both their sin and their punishment: You shall seek me, which intimates either,

(1.)Their enmity to the true Christ: "You shall seek to ruin my interest, by persecuting my doctrine and followers, with a fruitless design to root them out." This was a continual vexation and torment to themselves, made them incurably ill-natured, and brought wrath upon them (God's and their own) to the uttermost. Or,

(2.)Their enquiries after false Christs: "You shall continue your expectations of the Messiah, and be the self-perplexing seekers of a Christ to come, when he is already come;" like the Sodomites, who, being struck with blindness, wearied themselves to find the door. See Romans 9:31, Romans 9:32.

3.Their final impenitency: You shall die in your sins. Here is an error in all our English Bibles, even the old bishops' translation, and that of Geneva (the Rhemists only excepted), for all the Greek copies have it in the singular number, en tē hamartia humōn - in your sin, so all the Latin versions; and Calvin has a note upon the difference between this and John 8:24, where it is plural, tais hamartiais, that here it is meant especially of the sin of unbelief, in hoc peccato vestro - in this sin of yours. Note, Those that live in unbelief are for ever undone if they die in unbelief. Or, it may be understood in general, You shall die in your iniquity, as Ezekiel 3:19, and Ezekiel 33:9. Many that have long lived in sin are, through grace, saved by a timely repentance from dying in sin; but for those who go out of this world of probation into that of retribution under the guilt of sin unpardoned, and the power of sin unbroken, there remaineth no relief: salvation itself cannot save them, Job 20:11; Ezekiel 32:27.

4.Their eternal separation from Christ and all happiness in him: Whither I go you cannot come. When Christ left the world, he went to a state of perfect happiness; he went to paradise. Thither he took the penitent thief with him, that did not die in his sins; but the impenitent not only shall not come to him, but they cannot; it is morally impossible, for heaven would not be heaven to those that die unsanctified and unmeet for it. You cannot come, because you have no right to enter into that Jerusalem, Revelation 22:14. Whither I go you cannot come, to fetch me thence, so Dr. Whitby; and the same is the comfort of all good Christians, that, when they get to heaven, they will be out of the reach of their enemies' malice.

II.The jest they made of this threatening.

Instead of trembling at this word, they bantered it, and turned it into ridicule (John 8:22): Will he kill himself? See here,

1.What slight thoughts they had of Christ's threatenings; they could make themselves and one another merry with them, as those that mocked the messengers of the Lord, and turned the burden of the word of the Lord into a by-word, and precept upon precept, line upon line, into a merry song, Isaiah 28:13. But be ye not mockers, lest your bands be made strong.

2.What ill thoughts they had of Christ's meaning, as if he had an inhuman design upon his own life, to avoid the indignities done him, like Saul. This is indeed (say they) to go whither we cannot follow him, for we will never kill ourselves. Thus they make him not only such a one as themselves, but worse; yet in the calamities brought by the Romans upon the Jews many of them in discontent and despair did kill themselves. They had put a much more favourable construction upon this word of his (John 7:34, John 7:35): Will he go to the dispersed among the Gentiles? But see how indulged malice grows more and more malicious.

III.The confirmation of what he had said.

1.He had said, Whither I go you cannot come, and here he gives the reason for this (John 8:23): You are from beneath, I am from above; you are of this world, I am not of this world. You are ek tōn katō - of those things which are beneath; noting, not so much their rise from beneath as their affection to these lower things: "You are in with these things, as those that belong to them; how can you come where I go, when your spirit and disposition are so directly contrary to mine?" See here,

(1.)What the spirit of the Lord Jesus was - not of this world, but from above. He was perfectly dead to the wealth of the world, the ease of the body, and the praise of men, and was wholly taken up with divine and heavenly things; and none shall be with him but those who are born from above and have their conversation in heaven.

(2.)How contrary to this their spirit was: "You are from beneath, and of this world." The Pharisees were of a carnal worldly spirit; and what communion could Christ have with them?

2.He had said, You shall die in your sins, and here he stand to it: "Therefore I said, You shall die in your sins, because you are from beneath;" and he gives this further reason for it, If you believe not that I am he, you shall die in your sins, John 8:24. See here,

(1.)What we are required to believe: that I am he, hoti egō eimi - that I am, which is one of God's names, Exodus 3:14. It was the Son of God that there said, Ehejeh asher Ehejeh - I will be what I will be; for the deliverance of Israel was but a figure of good things to come, but now he saith, "I am he; he that should come, he that you expect the Messias to be, that you would have me to be to you. I am more than the bare name of the Messiah; I do not only call myself so, but I am he." True faith does not amuse the soul with an empty sound of words, but affects it with the doctrine of Christ's mediation, as a real thing that has real effects.

(2.)How necessary it is that we believe this. If we have not this faith, we shall die in our sins; for the matter is so settled that without this faith,

[1.]We cannot be saved from the power of sin while we live, and therefore shall certainly continue in it to the last. Nothing but the doctrine of Christ's grace will be an argument powerful enough, and none but the Spirit of Christ's grace will be an agent powerful enough, to turn us from sin to God; and that Spirit is given, and that doctrine given, to be effectual to those only who believe in Christ: so that, if Satan be not by faith dispossessed, he has a lease of the soul for its life; if Christ do not cure us, our case is desperate, and we shall die in our sins.

[2.]Without faith we cannot be saved from the punishment of sin when we die, for the wrath of God remains upon them that believe not, Mark 16:16. Unbelief is the damning sin; it is a sin against the remedy. Now this implies the great gospel promise: If we believe that Christ is he, and receive him accordingly, we shall not die in our sins. The law saith absolutely to all, as Christ said (John 8:21), You shall die in your sins, for we are all guilty before God; but the gospel is a defeasance of the obligation upon condition of believing. The curse of the law is vacated and annulled to all that submit to the grace of the gospel. Believers die in Christ, in his love, in his arms, and so are saved from dying in their sins.

IV.Here is a further discourse concerning himself, occasioned by his requiring faith in himself as the condition of salvation, John 8:25-29. Observe,

1.The question which the Jews put to him (John 8:25): Who art thou? This they asked tauntingly, and not with any desire to be instructed. he had said, You must believe that I am he. By his not saying expressly who he was, he plainly intimated that in his person he was such a one as could not be described by any, and in his office such a one as was expected by all that looked for redemption in Israel; yet this awful manner of speaking, which had so much significancy in it, they turned to his reproach, as if he knew not what to say of himself: "Who art thou, that we must with an implicit faith believe in thee, that thou art some mighty HE, we know not who or what, nor are worthy to know?"

2.His answer to this question, wherein he directs them three ways for information: -

(1.)He refers them to what he had said all along: "Do you ask who I am? Even the same that I said unto you from the beginning." The original here is a little intricate, tēn archēn ho ti kai lalō humin which some read thus: I am the beginning, which also I speak unto you. So Austin takes it. Christ is called Archē - the beginning (Colossians 1:18; Revelation 1:8; Revelation 21:6; Revelation 3:14), and so it agrees with John 8:24, I am he. Compare Isaiah 41:4 : I am the first, I am he. Those who object that it is the accusative case, and therefore not properly answering to tis ei, must undertake to construe by grammar rules that parallel expression, Revelation 1:8, ho ēn. But most interpreters agree with our version, Do you ask who I am?

[1.]I am the same that I said to you from the beginning of time in the scriptures of the Old Testament, the same that from the beginning was said to be the Seed of the woman, that should break the serpent's head, the same that in all the ages of the church was the Mediator of the covenant, and the faith of the patriarchs.

[2.]From the beginning of my public ministry. The account he had already given of himself he resolved to abide by; he had declared himself to be the Son of God (John 5:17), to be the Christ (John 4:26), and the bread of life, and had proposed himself as the object of that faith which is necessary to salvation, and to this he refers them for an answer to their question. Christ is one with himself; what he had said from the beginning, he saith still. His is an everlasting gospel.

(2.)He refers them to his Father's judgment, and the instructions he had from him (John 8:26): "I have many things, more than you think of, to say, and in them to judge of you. But why should I trouble myself any further with you? I know very well that he who sent me is true, and will stand by me, and bear me out, for I speak to the world (to which I am sent as an ambassador) those things, all those and those only, which I have heard of him." Here,

[1.]He suppresses his accusation of them. He had many things to charge them with, and many evidences to produce against them; but for the present he had said enough. Note, Whatever discoveries of sin are made to us, he that searches the heart has still more to judge of us, 1 John 3:20. How much soever God reckons with sinners in this world there is still a further reckoning yet behind, Deuteronomy 32:34. Let us learn hence not to be forward to say all we can say, even against the worst of men; we may have many things to say, by way of censure, which yet it is better to leave unsaid, for what is it to us?

[2.]He enters his appeal against them to his Father: He that sent me. Here two things comfort him: - First, That he had been true to his Father, and to the trust reposed in him: I speak to the world (for his gospel was to be preached to every creature) those things which I have heard of him. Being given for a witness to the people (Isaiah 55:4), he was Amen, a faithful witness, Revelation 3:14. He did not conceal his doctrine, but spoke it to the world (being of common concern, it was to be of common notice); nor did he change or alter it, nor vary from the instructions he received from him that sent him. Secondly, That his Father would be true to him; true to the promise that he would make his mouth like a sharp sword; true to his purpose concerning him, which was a decree (Psalm 2:7); true to the threatenings of his wrath against those that should reject him. Though he should not accuse them to his Father, yet the Father, who sent him, would undoubtedly reckon with them, and would be true to what he had said (Deuteronomy 18:19), that whosoever would not hearken to that prophet whom God would raise up he would require it of him. Christ would not accuse them; "for," saith he, "he that sent me is true, and will pass judgment on them, though I should not demand judgment against them." Thus, when he lets fall the present prosecution, he binds them over to the judgment-day, when it will be too late to dispute what they will not now be persuaded to believe. I, as a deaf man, heard not; for thou wilt hear, Psalm 38:13, Psalm 38:15. Upon this part of our Saviour's discourse the evangelist has a melancholy remark (John 8:27): They understood not that he spoke to them of the Father. See here, 1. The power of Satan to blind the minds of those who believe not. Though Christ spoke so plainly of God as his Father in heaven, yet they did not understand whom he meant, but thought he spoke of some father he had in Galilee. Thus the plainest things are riddles and parables to those who are resolved to hold fast their prejudices; day and night are alike to the blind. 2. The reason why the threatenings of the word make so little impression upon the minds of sinners; it is because they understand not whose the wrath is that is revealed in them. When Christ told them of the truth of him that sent him, as a warning to them to prepare for his judgment, which is according to truth, they slighted the warning, because they understood not to whose judgment it was that they made themselves obnoxious.

(3.)He refers them to their own convictions hereafter, John 8:28, John 8:29. He finds they will not understand him, and therefore adjourns the trial till further evidence should come in; they that will not see shall see, Isaiah 26:11. Now observe here,

[1.]What they should ere long be convinced of: "You shall know that I am he, that Jesus is the true Messiah. Whether you will own it or no before men, you shall be made to know it in your own consciences, the convictions of which, though you may stifle, yet you cannot baffle: that I am he, not that you represent me to be, but he that I preach myself to be, he that should come!" Two things they should be convinced of, in order to this: - First, That he did nothing of himself, not of himself as man, of himself alone, of himself without the Father, with whom he was one. He does not hereby derogate from his own inherent power, but only denies their charge against him as a false prophet; for of false prophets it is said that they prophesied out of their own hearts, and followed their own spirits. Secondly, That as his Father taught him so he spoke these things, that he was not autodidaktos - selftaught, but Theodidaktos - taught of God. The doctrine he preached was the counterpart of the counsels of God, with which he was intimately acquainted; kathōs edidaxe, tauta lalō - I speak those things, not only which he taught me, but as he taught me, with the same divine power and authority.

[2.]When they should be convinced of this: When you have lifted up the Son of man, lifted him up upon the cross, as the brazen serpent upon the pole (John 3:14), as the sacrifices under the law (for Christ is the great sacrifice), which, when they were offered, were said to be elevated, or lifted up; hence the burnt-offerings, the most ancient and honourable of all, were called elevations (Gnoloth from Gnolah, asendit - he ascended), and in many other offerings they used the significant ceremony of heaving the sacrifice up, and moving it before the Lord; thus was Christ lifted up. Or the expression denotes that his death was his exaltation. They that put him to death thought thereby for ever to have sunk him and his interest, but it proved to be the advancement of both, John 12:24. When the Son of man was crucified, the Son of man was glorified. Christ had called his dying his going away; here he calls it his being lifted up; thus the death of the saints, as it is their departure out of this world, so it is their advancement to a better. Observe, He speaks of those he is now talking with as the instruments of his death: when you have lifted up the Son of man; not that they were to be the priests to offer him up (no, that was his own act, he offered up himself), but they would be his betrayers and murderers; see Acts 2:23. They lifted him up to the cross, but then he lifted up himself to his Father. Observe with what tenderness and mildness Christ here speaks to those who he certainly knew would put him to death, to teach us not to hate or seek the hurt of any, though we may have reason to think they hate us and seek our hurt. Now, Christ speaks of his death as that which would be a powerful conviction of the infidelity of the Jews. When you have lifted up the Son of man, then shall you know this. And why then? First, Because careless and unthinking people are often taught the worth of mercies by the want of them, Luke 17:22. Secondly, The guilt of their sin in putting Christ to death would so awaken their consciences that they would be put upon serious enquiries after a Saviour, and then would know that Jesus was he who alone could save them. And so it proved, when, being told that with wicked hands they had crucified and slain the Son of God, they cried out, What shall we do? and were made to know assuredly that this Jesus was Lord and Christ, Acts 2:36. Thirdly, There would be such signs and wonders attending his death, and the lifting of him up from death in his resurrection, as would give a stronger proof of his being the Messiah than any that had been yet given: and multitudes were hereby brought to believe that Jesus is the Christ, who had before contradicted and opposed him. Fourthly, By the death of Christ the pouring out of the Spirit was purchased, who would convince the world that Jesus is he, John 16:7, John 16:8. Fifthly, The judgments which the Jews brought upon themselves, by putting Christ to death, which filled up the measure of their iniquity, were a sensible conviction to the most hardened among them that Jesus was he. Christ had often foretold that desolation as the just punishment of their invincible unbelief, and when it came to pass (lo, it did come) they could not but know that the great prophet had been among them, Ezekiel 33:33.

[3.]What supported our Lord Jesus in the mean time (John 8:29): He that sent me is with me, in my whole undertaking; for the Father (the fountain and first spring of this affair, from whom as its great cause and author it is derived) hath not left me alone, to manage it myself, hath not deserted the business nor me in the prosecution of it, for do I always those things that please him. Here is,

First, The assurance which Christ had of his Father's presence with him, which includes both a divine power going along with him to enable him for his work, and a divine favour manifested to him to encourage him in it. He that sent me is with me, Isaiah 42:1; Psalm 89:21. This greatly emboldens our faith in Christ and our reliance upon his word that he had, and knew he had, his Father with him, to confirm the word of his servant, Isaiah 44:26. The King of kings accompanied his own ambassador, to attest his mission and assist his management, and never left him alone, either solitary or weak; it also aggravated the wickedness of those that opposed him, and was an intimation to them of the premunire they ran themselves into by resisting him, for thereby they were found fighters against God. How easily soever they might think to crush him and run him down, let them know he had one to back him with whom it is the greatest madness that can be to contend.

Secondly, The ground of this assurance: For I do always those things that please him. That is, 1. That great affair in which our Lord Jesus was continually engaged was an affair which the Father that sent him was highly well pleased with. His whole undertaking is called the pleasure of the Lord (Isaiah 53:10), because of the counsels of the eternal mind about it, and the complacency of the eternal mind in it. 2. His management of that affair was in nothing displeasing to his Father; in executing his commission he punctually observed all his instructions, and did in nothing vary from them. No mere man since the fall could say such a word as this (for in many things we offend all) but our Lord Jesus never offended his Father in any thing, but, as became him, he fulfilled all righteousness. This was necessary to the validity and value of the sacrifice he was to offer up; for if he had in any thing displeased the Father himself, and so had had any sin of his own to answer for, the Father could not have been pleased with him as a propitiation for our sins; but such a priest and such a sacrifice became us as was perfectly pure and spotless. We may likewise learn hence that God's servants may then expect God's presence with them when they choose and do those things that please him, Isaiah 66:4, Isaiah 66:5.

V.Here is the good effect which this discourse of Christ's had upon some of his hearers (John 8:30): As he spoke these words many believed on him. Note,

1.Though multitudes perish in their unbelief, yet there is a remnant according to the election of grace, who believe to the saving of the soul. If Israel, the whole body of the people, be not gathered, yet there are those of them in whom Christ will be glorious, Isaiah 49:5. This the apostle insists upon, to reconcile the Jews' rejection with the promises made unto their fathers. There is a remnant, Romans 11:5.

2.The words of Christ, and particularly his threatening words, are made effectual by the grace of God to bring in poor souls to believe in him. When Christ told them that if they believed not they should die in their sins, and never get to heaven, they thought it was time to look about them, Romans 1:16, Romans 1:18.

3.Sometimes there is a wide door opened, and an effectual one, even where they are many adversaries. Christ will carry on his work, though the heathen rage. The gospel sometimes gains great victories where it meets with great opposition. Let this encourage God's ministers to preach the gospel, though it be with much contention, for they shall not labour in vain. Many may be secretly brought home to God by those endeavours which are openly contradicted and cavilled at by men of corrupt minds. Austin has an affectionate ejaculation in his lecture upon these words: Utinam et, me loquenti, multi credant; non in me, sed mecum in eo - I wish that when I speak, many may believe, not on me, but with me on him.

Historical interpretation

Nine Centuries of Reception

10 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

10 quotes · AD 253–1107
Ante-NicenePost-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
30040050060070080090010001100

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

If the Word is not received when present, he threatens to go.…As long as we preserve the seeds and principles of truth that have been sown in our souls, the Word has not yet departed from us. But if we utterly destroy them with a flood of wickedness, he will say to us, "I go." And then, even if we seek him, we will not find him but will die in our sin, overtaken in our sin and swept away by it.…
And we must not pass over without noticing the expression "you will die in your sins." If it is taken in the ordinary sense, it is clear that sinners will die in their sin and the righteous in their righteousness. But if "you will die" is taken in relation to death, the enemy of Christ, since the one who dies has committed a sin that leads to death, then it is clear that those to whom this is spoken have not yet died.…
Those to whom the Word had not yet come had not committed sin that leads to death. Still, they were spiritually sick, a sickness tending toward death. The Physician, seeing that they were deadly ill, after he had despaired of healing them, said, "I go, and you will seek me, and you will die in your sin." …
Perhaps the statement "where I go you cannot come," attached to "you will die in your sin," will be clearer. For whenever someone dies in his sin, he cannot go where Jesus goes, for no one who is dead can follow Jesus: "For the dead do not praise you, O Lord."
"Then said Jesus unto them, I go My way, and ye shall seek Me."

Why saith He this continually? To shame and terrify their souls; for observe what fear this saying caused in them. Although they desired to kill Him that they might be rid of Him, they yet ask, "whither He goeth," such great things did they imagine from the matter. He desired also to show them another thing, that the deed would not be effected through their force; but He showed it to them in a figure beforehand, and already foretold the Resurrection by these words.

"Then said the Jews, Will he kill himself?"

What then doth Christ? To remove their suspicion, and to show that such an act is sin, He saith,

"Ye are from beneath."

What He saith, is of this kind: "It is no wonder that ye imagine such things, ye who are carnal men, and have no spiritual thoughts, but I shall not do anything of the kind, for,

"I am from above; ye are of the world."

Here again He speaketh of their worldly and carnal imaginations, whence it is clear that the, "I am not of this world," doth not mean that He had not taken upon Him flesh, but that He was far removed from their wickedness. For He even saith, that His disciples were "not of the world", yet they had flesh. As then Paul, when he saith, "Ye are not in the flesh" doth not mean that they are incorporeal, so Christ when He saith, that His disciples are "not of the world," doth nothing else than testify to their heavenly wisdom.

"I said therefore unto you that...if ye believe not that I am He, ye shall die in your sins."

For if He came to take away the sin of the world, and if it is impossible for men to put that off in any other way except by the washing, it needs must be that he that believeth not must depart hence, having the old man; since he that will not by faith slay and bury that old man, shall die in him, and shall go away to that place to suffer the punishment of His former sins. Wherefore He said, "He that believeth not is judged already"; not merely through his not believing, but because he departeth hence having his former sins upon him.
d. AD 407John Chrysostomas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
(Hom. liii. 1) As if to say, No wonder that ye think as ye do, seeing ye are carnal, and understand nothing spiritually. I am from above.

(Hom. liii. 1) Or He says, I am not of this world, with reference to worldly and vain thoughts.

(Hom. liii. 1) For if He came in order to take away sin, and a man cannot put that off, except by washing, and cannot be baptized except he believe; it follows, that he who believes not must pass out of this life, with the old man, i. e. sin, within him: not only because he believes not, but because he departs hence, with his former sins upon him.
d. AD 430Augustine of Hippoas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
(Tract. xxxviii. 2) In accordance with what was just, He said that no man laid hands on Him, because His hour was not yet come; He now speaks to the Jews of His passion, as a free, and not a compulsory sacrifice on His part: Then said Jesus again unto them, I go My way. Death to our Lord was a return to the place whence He had come.

(Tract. xxxviii. 2) Ye shall seek Me, then, He says, not from compassionate regret, but from hatred: for after He had departed from the eyes of men, He was sought for both by those who hated, and those who loved Him: the one wanting to persecute, the other to have His presence. And that ye may not think that ye shall seek Me in a good sense, I tell you, Ye shall die in your sin. (ἁμαρτίᾳ plural in our Transl.) This is to seek Christ amiss, to die in one's sin: this is to hate Him, from Whom alone cometh salvation. He pronounces sentence on them prophetically, that they shall die in their sins.

(Tract. xxviii. s. 2) This He tells His disciples in another place; without saying to them, however, Ye shall die in your sin, He only says, Whither I go, ye cannot follow Me now; not preventing, but only delaying their coming.
d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceTractates on John 38
But of His own passion itself, which lay not in any necessity He was under, but in His own power, all that He said in His discourse to the Jews was, "I go away." For to Christ the Lord's death was His proceeding to the place whence He had come, and from which He had never departed. "I go away," said He, "and ye shall seek me," not from any longing for me, but in hatred. For after His removal from human sight, He was sought for both by those who hated Him and those who loved Him; by the former in a spirit of persecution, by the latter with the desire of having Him. In the Psalms the Lord Himself says by the prophet, "A place of refuge hath failed me, and there is none that seeketh after my life;" and again He says in another place in the Psalms, "Let them be confounded and ashamed who seek after my life." He blamed the former for not seeking, He condemned the latter because they did. For it is wrong not to seek the life of Christ, that is, in the way the disciples sought it; and it is wrong to seek the life of Christ, that is, in the way the Jews sought it: for the former sought to possess it, these latter to destroy it.

Accordingly, because these men sought it thus in a wrong way, with a perverted heart, what next did He add? "Ye shall seek me, and"-not to let you suppose that ye will seek me for good-"ye shall die in your sin." This comes of seeking Christ wrongly, to die in one's sin; this of hating Him, through whom alone salvation could be found. For, while men whose hope is in God ought not to render evil even for evil, these men were rendering evil for good. The Lord therefore announced to them beforehand, and in His foreknowledge uttered the sentence, that they should die in their sin.
d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceTractates on John 38
And then He adds, "Whither I go, ye cannot come." He said the same to the disciples also in another place; and yet He said not to them, "Ye shall die in your sin." But what did He say? The same as to these men: "Whither I go, ye cannot come." He did not take away hope, but foretold delay. For at the time when the Lord spake this to the disciples, they were not able to come whither He was going, yet were they to come afterwards; but these men never, to whom in His foreknowledge He said, "Ye shall die in your sin."
He said therefore unto them again, I go My way, and ye shall seek Me and shall die in your sins.

That we must needs take hold of the present time for whatever one may receive profit from to oneself, does Christ herein well declare unto us. For to be too late in what is good and to take after-counsel for what is profitable, clearly brings no gain but ministers wailing befitting the neglect. Our Lord therefore being good and gracious, as it is written, both bears with those who dishonour Him and aids those who insult Him and is found as God superior to all the littleness of man. Yet does He for their good threaten to depart from them, and says plainly I go My way, that He may implant in them a more resolved mind, and that they considering that they ought not to leave their Redeemer when present frustrate of His work, He may whet them to pass on to the faith and may make them now at length more ready unto obedience. And having cried out, I go My way, and threatened departure from the whole nation, He subjoined economically the damage therefrom ensuing unto them. For (He says) Ye shall die in your sins; and we shall see the nature of the thing bringing in the truth of what is said. For they who did not at all receive Him Who came to us from Heaven that He might justify all through faith, how shall they not beyond all contradiction die in their sins, and not receiving Him Who can cleanse them, how will they not have lasting defilement from their impiety? For to die unredeemed, yet laden with the weight of sin, to whom is it any doubt where this will conduct the soul of man? For deep Hades will, I deem, receive such an one, and he will continue in great darkness, yea he will inhabit fire and flames, with reason numbered among those of whom it has been said by Prophet's voice, Their worm shall not die neither shall their fire be quenched, and they shall be for a sight to all flesh. Whereof that they may escape the trial, Christ kept manifoldly calling them to a speedy turning away from their wonted unbelief, saying not only that He should leave them and go away, but also of necessity putting before them how great misfortune they will thence undergo. For ye shall die (He says) in your sins. But since He put in between, And ye shall seek Me, and hitherto we do not find the Jews seeking Him, we shall reasonably go to some other meaning: for He must needs be True. For even though they now in the body and yet in full enjoyment of the pleasures of the flesh, for their exceeding senselessness seek not their Redeemer, yet when they wretched fall into hell and have their abode in the place of punishments, when they are in the ill itself, then, then will they seek even against their will. For there (He says) is weeping and gnashing of teeth, each (it is likely) of those there wailing his carelessness in what was good, and well-nigh saying what is in the Book of Proverbs, I have not obeyed the voice of him that instructed me and taught me. Therefore as Paul saith, Let us therefore fear lest, a promise being left us of entering into His Rest, any of you should seem to come short of it. For we must run, that we may obtain, and not by our disbelief insult Him Who draws us out of bitter bondage, but submit ourselves and with upturned hands lay hold on the grace.
and whither I go, YE cannot come.

Not only does He say that they shall die in their sins, but declares clearly that, ascending not to the mansions above, they will remain outside of the good things of the kingdom: for they who received not Him Who came from above, how could they also follow Him ascending up? Double therefore is the punishment to them who believe not, and not in any single thing their loss. For just as they who have fallen into bodily loss of health must needs suffer and endure the trials of the suffering and besides be deprived of the pleasures of health; so and not otherwise do they who have departed into Hades, and there undergo punishment proportionate to the sins, both endure the state of punishment and lose the enjoyment of the hope of the saints. Most excellently then does our Lord Jesus Christ say not only that they shall die in their sins, but also that they shall not mount up to the mansions above: for binding them as by a twofold cord, does He haste to draw them away from their inherent ill-counsel. From all sides saving that which was lost and binding up the broken and raising up that which was broken down (for these are the ways of a Good Shepherd and One Who readily gives His Life for the salvation of the sheep) does He tell His own disciples, I will go and prepare a place for you, and will come again and receive you with Myself, showing that the very heaven will be accessible to the saints and teaching that the mansions above have been prepared for them that love Him, but to those who have chosen to disbelieve Him, rightly and needs does He say, Whither I go YE cannot come. For who at all will follow the All-holy Christ, if he love not the cleansing that is through faith? or how shall he that is yet defiled and that has not cleared off the filth from his passions be with our Lord Who loves us? What communion hath light with darkness, as Paul saith? For I deem that they ought to be holy who would say to the All-Pure God, My soul cleaveth after Thee.

I think that this meaning has now too not amiss been put on the words before us, but if one must go about and view it differently, and say yet something else besides, we will not shrink from doing this too. Whither I go, YE cannot come. Being Very God, I am absent from no one, I fill all things, and being with all, I dwell specially in Heaven, gladly having abode with holy spirits. But since I am the human-loving Framer of all things, I deemed intolerable the loss of My creation, I beheld man going away to utter destruction, I viewed him falling from sin unto death, I must needs reach forth an helping Hand to him as he lay, I must needs in every way aid him overcome and falling. How then was it meet to save that which was lost? it needed that the Physician should be with those in peril, it needed that Life should be there present with the dying, it needed that Light should have its abode with those in darkness. But it were not possible that ye being men by nature should take wing to Heaven and have your abode with the Saviour. Therefore have I Myself come to you, I heard the Saints oftentimes crying aloud, Bow Thy Heavens o Lord and come down; I bowed the Heavens therefore and have come down; for in no other way could ye look to come hither. Yet do I endure to remain with you, do ye more resolutely lay hold of life, purify yourselves through faith while He is with you Who knows to, and can, compassionate with authority. For I shall go, yea shall return again whither YE cannot come; even though ye should seek the Giver of salvation by an untimely after-counsel, ye shall not find Him: what follows ye may see. For ye shall surely die in your sins, and weighed down by your own transgressions, shall go mourning to the prison-house of death, there to pay the penalty of your lengthened unbelief. The Saviour then being good and exceeding loving to man, compels the Jews by fears of future punishment even against their will to be saved.
d. AD 735Bedeas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Early MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
The connection of these words is such, that they might have been spoken at one place and one time, or at another place and another time: as either nothing at all, or some things, or many may have intervened.

Note: sin is in the singular number, your in the plural; to express one and the same wickedness in all.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying John 8:21 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8