Ecclesiastes 11:3
“Generosity and Investing Wisely”Ecclesiastes 11:1–3
Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain
Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain
Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain
Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain
Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain
Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain
Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain
- אִם'imifH518PrtParticle Conditional
- יִמָּלְאוּyi·mal·'Uthey will be filledH4390V-Niphal-Imperf-3mpVerb Niphal Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculine
- הֶעָבִיםhe·'a·Vimthe cloudsH5645Art ¦ N-mpNoun Plural Masculine Absoluteהֶtheעָבִיםclouds
- גֶּשֶׁםge·shemrainH1653N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
- עַל'alonH5921PrepPreposition
- הָאָרֶץha·'A·retzthe earthH776Art ¦ N-fsNoun Singular Feminine Absoluteהָtheאָרֶץearth
- יָרִיקוּya·Ri·kuthey will pour [it] outH7324V-Hiphil-Imperf-3mpVerb Hiphil Imperfect 3rd Plural Masculine
- וְאִםve·'imand whetherH518Conj-w ¦ PrtParticle Conditionalוְandאִםwhether
- יִפּוֹלyi·Polit fallsH5307V-Qal-Imperf-3msVerb Qal Imperfect 3rd Singular Masculine
- עֵץ'etza treeH6086N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
- בַּדָּרוֹםba·da·Romat the southH1864Prep-b ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteבַּat theדָּרוֹםsouth
- וְאִםve·'Imand orH518Conj-w ¦ PrtParticle Conditionalוְandאִםor
- בַּצָּפוֹןba·tza·Fonat the northH6828Prep-b ¦ N-fsNoun Singular Feminine Absoluteבַּat theצָּפוֹןnorth
- מְקוֹםme·Kom[the] placeH4725N-mscNoun Singular Masculine Construct
- שֶׁיִּפּוֹלshei·yi·Polwhere it fallsH5307Rel-s ¦ V-Qal-Imperf-3msVerb Qal Imperfect 3rd Singular Masculineשֶׁwhereיִּפּוֹלit falls
- הָעֵץha·'Etzthe treeH6086Art ¦ N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absoluteהָtheעֵץtree
- שָׁםshamthereH8033AdvAdverb
- יְהוּאye·Hu'it will beH1933V-Qal-Imperf-3msVerb Qal Imperfect 3rd Singular Masculine
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?
This is the original text the KJV's translators worked from — each Hebrew word with its own literal English meaning in this verse, prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences, not word by word, so its wording differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may choose “the LORD” where the gloss reads “Yahweh”. Both are faithful — they answer different questions. For the KJV's own rendering, switch to the KJV text.
Words in [ ] are added by the English.
Details
Study this verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Ecclesiastes 11:1–6. He set out his notes in a two-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.
Solomon had often, in this book, pressed it upon rich people to take the comfort of their riches themselves; here he presses it upon them to do good to others with them and to abound in liberality to the poor, which will, another day, abound to their account. Observe,
I.How the duty itself is recommended to us, Ecclesiastes 11:1.
1. Cast thy bread upon the waters, thy bread-corn upon the low places (so some understand it), alluding to the husbandman, who goes forth, bearing precious seed, sparing bread-corn from his family for the seedness, knowing that without that he can have no harvest another year; thus the charitable man takes from his bread-corn for seed-corn, abridges himself to supply the poor, that he may sow beside all waters (Isaiah 32:20), because as he sows so he must reap, Galatians 6:7. We read of the harvest of the river, Isaiah 23:3. Waters, in scripture, are put for multitudes (Revelation 16:5), and there are multitudes of poor (we do not want objects of charity); waters are put also for mourners: the poor are men of sorrows. Thou must give bread, the necessary supports of life, not only give good words but good things, Isaiah 58:7. It must be thy bread, that which is honestly got; it is no charity, but injury, to give that which is none of our own to give; first do justly, and then love mercy. "Thy bread, which thou didst design for thyself, let the poor have a share with thee, as they had with Job, Job 31:17. Give freely to the poor, as that which is cast upon the waters. Send it a voyage, send it as a venture, as merchants that trade by sea. Trust it upon the waters; it shall not sink."
2."Give a portion to seven and also to eight, that is, be free and liberal in works of charity." (1.) "Give much if thou hast much to give, not a pittance, but a portion, not a bit or two, but a mess, a meal; give a large dole, not a paltry one; give good measure (Luke 6:38); be generous in giving, as those were when, on festival days, they sent portions to those for whom nothing was prepared (Nehemiah 8:10), worthy portions." (2.) "Give to many, to seven, and also to eight; if thou meet with seven objects of charity, give to them all, and then, if thou meet with an eighth, give to that, and if with eight more, give to them all too. Excuse not thyself with the good thou hast done from the good thou hast further to do, but hold on, and mend. In hard times, when the number of the poor increases, let thy charity be proportionably enlarged." God is rich in mercy to all, to us, though unworthy; he gives liberally, and upbraids not with former gifts, and we must be merciful as our heavenly Father is.
II.The reasons with which it is pressed upon us. Consider,
1.Our reward for well-doing is very certain. "Though thou cast it upon the waters, and it seem lost, thou thinkest thou hast given thy good word with it and art likely never to hear of it again, yet thou shalt find it after many days, as the husbandman finds his seed again in a plentiful harvest and the merchant his venture in a rich return. It is not lost, but well laid out, and well laid up; it brings in full interest in the present gifts of God's providence, and graces and comforts of his Spirit; and the principal is sure, laid up in heaven, for it is lent to the Lord." Seneca, a heathen, could say, Nihil magis possidere me credam, quam bene donata - I possess nothing so completely as that which I have given away. Hochabeo quodcunque dedi; hae sunt divitiae certae in quacunque sortis humanae levitate - Whatever I have imparted I still possess; these riches remain with me through all the vicissitudes of life. "Thou shalt find it, perhaps not quickly, but after many days; the return may be slow, but it is sure and will be so much the more plentiful." Wheat, the most valuable grain, lies longest in the ground. Long voyages make the best returns.
2.Our opportunity for well-doing is very uncertain: "Thou knowest not what evil may be upon the earth, which may deprive thee of thy estate, and put thee out of a capacity to do good, and therefore, while thou hast wherewithal, be liberal with it, improve the present season, as the husbandman in sowing his ground, before the frost comes." We have reason to expect evil upon the earth, for we are born to trouble; what the evil may be we know not, but that we may be ready for it, whatever it is, it is our wisdom, in the day of prosperity, to be in good, to be doing good. Many make use of this as an argument against giving to the poor, because they know not what hard times may come when they may want themselves; whereas we should therefore the rather be charitable, that, when evil days come, we may have the comfort of having done good while we were able; we would then hope to find mercy both with God and man, and therefore should now show mercy. If by charity we trust God with what we have, we put it into good hands against bad times.
III.How he obviates the objections which might be made against this duty and the excuses of the uncharitable.
1.Some will say that what they have is their own and they have it for their own use, and will ask, Why should we cast it thus upon the waters? Why should I take my bread, and my flesh, and give it to I know not whom? So Nabal pleaded, 1 Samuel 25:11. "Look up, man, and consider how soon thou wouldest be starved in a barren ground, if the clouds over thy head should plead thus, that they have their waters for themselves; but thou seest, when they are full of rain, they empty themselves upon the earth, to make it fruitful, till they are wearied and spent with watering it, Job 37:11. Are the heavens thus bountiful to the poor earth, that is so far below them, and wilt thou grudge thy bounty to thy poor brother, who is bone of thy bone? Or thus: some will say, Though we give but little to the poor, yet, thank God, we have as charitable a heart as any." Nay, says Solomon, if the clouds be full of rain, they will empty themselves; if there be charity in the heart, it will show itself, James 2:15, James 2:16. He that draws out his soul to the hungry will reach forth his hand to them, as he has ability.
2.Some will say that their sphere of usefulness is low and narrow; they cannot do the good that they see others can, who are in more public stations, and therefore they will sit still and do nothing. Nay, says he, in the place where the tree falls, or happens to be, there it shall be, for the benefit of those to whom it belongs; every man must labour to be a blessing to that place, whatever it is, where the providence of God casts him; wherever we are we may find good work to do if we have but hearts to do it. Or thus: some will say, "Many present themselves as objects of charity who are unworthy, and I do not know whom it is fit to give it to." "Trouble not thyself about that" (says Solomon); "give as discreetly as thou canst, and then be satisfied that, though the person should prove undeserving of thy charity, yet, if thou give it with an honest heart, thou shalt not lose thy reward; which way soever the charity is directed, north or south, thine shall be the benefit of it." This is commonly applied to death; therefore let us do good, and, as good trees, bring forth the fruits of righteousness, because death will shortly come and cut us down, and we shall then be determined to an unchangeable state of happiness or misery according to what was done in the body. As the tree falls at death, so it is likely to lie to all eternity.
3.Some will object the many discouragements they have met with in their charity. They have been reproached for it as proud and pharisaical; they have but little to give, and they shall be despised if they do not give as others do; they know not but their children may come to want it, and they had better lay it up for them; they have taxes to pay and purchases to make; they know not what use will be made of their charity, nor what construction will be put upon it; these, and a hundred such objections, he answers, in one word (Ecclesiastes 11:4): He that observes the wind shall not sow, which signifies doing good; and he that regards the clouds shall not reap, which signifies getting good. If we stand thus magnifying every little difficulty and making the worst of it, starting objections and fancying hardship and danger where there is none, we shall never go on, much less go through with our work, nor make any thing of it. If the husbandman should decline, or leave off, sowing for the sake of every flying cloud, and reaping for the sake of every blast of wind, he would make but an ill account of his husbandry at the year's end. the duties of religion are as necessary as sowing and reaping, and will turn as much to our own advantage. The discouragements we meet with in these duties are but as winds and clouds, which will do us no harm, and which those that put on a little courage and resolution will despise and easily break through. Note, Those that will be deterred and driven off by small and seeming difficulties from great and real duties will never bring any thing to pass in religion, for there will always arise some wind, some cloud or other, at least in our imagination, to discourage us. Winds and clouds are in God's hands, are designed to try us, and our Christianity obliges us to endure hardness.
4.Some will say, "We do not see in which way what we expend in charity should ever be made up to us; we do not find ourselves ever the richer; why should we depend upon the general promise of a blessing on the charitable, unless we saw which way to expect the operation of it?" To this he answers, "Thou knowest not the work of God, nor is it fit thou shouldst. Thou mayest be sure he will make good his word of promise, though he does not tell thee how, or which way, and though he works in a way by himself, according to the counsels of his unsearchable wisdom. He will work, and none shall hinder; but then he will work and none shall direct or prescribe to him. The blessing shall work insensibly but irresistibly. God's work shall certainly agree with his word, whether we see it or no." Our ignorance of the work of God he shows, in two instances: - (1.) We know not what is the way of the Spirit, of the wind (so some), we know not whence it comes, or whither it goes, or when it will turn; yet the seamen lie ready waiting for it, till it turns about in favour of them; so we must do our duty, in expectation of the time appointed for the blessing. Or it may be understood of the human soul; we know that God made us, and gave us these souls, but how they entered into these bodies, are united to them, animate them, and operate upon them, we know not; the soul is a mystery to itself, no marvel then that the work of God is so to us. (2.) We know not how the bones are fashioned in the womb of her that is with child. We cannot describe the manner either of the formation of the body or of its information with a soul; both, we know, are the work of God, and we acquiesce in his work, but cannot, in either, trace the process of the operation. We doubt not of the birth of the child that is conceived, though we know not how it is formed; nor need we doubt of the performance of the promise, though we perceive not how things work towards it. And we may well trust God to provide for us that which is convenient, without our anxious disquieting cares, and therein to recompense us for our charity, since it was without any knowledge or forecast of ours that our bodies were curiously wrought in secret and our souls found the way into them; and so the argument is the same, and urged to the same intent, with that of our Saviour (Matthew 6:25), The life, the living soul that God has given us, is more than meat; the body, that God has made us, is more than raiment; let him therefore that has done the greater for us be cheerfully depended upon to do the less.
5.Some say, "We have been charitable, have given a great deal to the poor, and never yet saw any return for it; many days are past, and we have not found it again," to which he answers (Ecclesiastes 11:6), "Yet go on, proceed and persevere in well-doing; let slip no opportunity. In the morning sow thy seed upon the objects of charity that offer themselves early, and in the evening do not withhold thy hand, under pretence that thou art weary; as thou hast opportunity, be doing good, some way or other, all the day long, as the husbandman follows his seedness from morning till night. In the morning of youth lay out thyself to do good; give out of the little thou hast to begin the world with; and in the evening of old age yield not to the common temptation old people are in to be penurious; even then withhold not thy hand, and think not to excuse thyself from charitable works by purposing to make a charitable will, but do good to the last, for thou knowest not which work of charity and piety shall prosper, both as to others and as to thyself, this or that, but hast reason to hope that both shall be alike good. Be not weary of well-doing, for in due season, in God's time and that is the best time, you shall reap," Galatians 6:9. This is applicable to spiritual charity, our pious endeavours for the good of the souls of others; let us continue them, for, though we have long laboured in vain, we may at length see the success of them. Let ministers, in the days of their seedness, sow both morning and evening; for who can tell which shall prosper?
Historical interpretation
Fourteen Centuries of Reception
4 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.
Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.
He who needs and apprehends much is filled, he who hath been filled waters others, and therefore Scripture saith, If the clouds be full of rain, they empty themselves upon the earth.
This sentence obviously is meant in a figurative and spiritual sense.…The south is in many ways distinguished from the north geographically, but also in a spiritual sense: The bride in the Song of Songs says, “Awake, O north wind, and come, O south wind!” So she sends the evil power away. The evil power was within her. When the evil was active, that is, the evil regarding faith and vocation, then she had the north wind living within. When she “turned away from evil” and went to the doing of good, she called for the south wind. Pay attention to the occasion: “Blow upon my garden that its fragrance may be wafted abroad,” [she says to the south wind]; the north wind does not do this. She uses the terms in a quite physical sense, since the “cold wind” is called “north wind.” The cold wind closes the openings of the trees, the so-called invisible pores, so that the elements of fragrance are kept inside. But when the warm south wind blows through the garden of the soul, … then the pores are widened.
"If the clouds are full of rain, they empty
themselves upon the earth: and if the tree falls toward the south, or toward
the north, in the place where the tree falls, there it shall be. "Keep the commandments that have been taught to you
above so that the clouds above you will break open in rain. For wherever you have made your home and seat
for the future, whether to the east or facing the north, when you die you will
remain there. Differently: as I have
said above 'send your bread over the water and divide it to all who ask'. Since when the clouds are full they pour
their riches down on mortals, and you are as a tree: however aged you may be,
you will not live forever, but one day suddenly struck by the storm of death
like a storm of winds, there where you fall you will lie forever. The time of your end will come whether you
may be stiff and savage, or mild and merciful.
Differently: God is addressed in the Psalms: "you are truth up to
the clouds" [Ps. 35, 6.],
and in Isaiah God warns the sinner of the vineyard, "I will command the
clouds not to rain down" [Is. 5, 6.]. Therefore the clouds are as prophets or holy
men, who have amassed many talents in their mind, so that he can rain his
teachings of doctrine down on others and say, "their speech should be
awaited just as rain, and they will pour out rain across the earth" [Deut. 32, 2.],
to which is replied, "let the earth hear the words of my mouth" [Deut. 32, 1.]. But this follows: "and if a tree falls
to the east, or to the north, in the place where it falls, there it will
remain." We can take the example of
the book of Hebrews, in which is written, "God will come to Teyma" [Heb. 3,3.],
which some interpreters have taken to mean that God will come from the south,
and when I come to think about it the south is always used in a good
context. This can be seen in Song of
Songs: "arise oh north" that is 'return' and 'go away'; "and
come O south wind" [Cant. 4, 16.]. Therefore a tree, if in this life it falls
and is cut in its state of mortality, either must sin before while it stands
and is then placed in the north afterwards, or if the south winds takes away
all its worthy fruit, it will lie wounded in the south. The text does not mean any tree, but only if
it lies to the north or south. This
means the same as that which is written: "I will say to the north wind,
come, and to the south wind, do not hold back" [Is. 43, 6.]. Nowhere teaches about the south wind and the
east wind together, saying that they blow, since it is fitting for them to be
among those regions, because they are blown afterwards to the south and
east. Therefore it blows from the north
to the south and the south wind blows its inhabitants to the east. And they are not able to blow out if they
remain in their ancient palaces.
If the tree fall: The state of the soul is unchangeable when once she comes to heaven or hell: and a soul that departs this life in the state of grace, shall never fall from grace: as on the other side, a soul that dies out of the state of grace, shall never come to it. But this does not exclude a place of temporal punishments for such souls as die in the state of grace: yet not so as to be entirely pure: and therefore they shall be saved, indeed, yet so as by fire. 1 Cor. 3. 13, 14, 15.
Continue studying Ecclesiastes 11:3 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
- BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
- Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
- ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
- NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
- STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
- BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
- USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
- BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
- StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
- BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
- Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
- Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
- Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
- SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.
This verse
Full clouds pour out their rain and a fallen tree lies where it falls, pictures of what happens outside our control and stays as it happens.
“If the clouds be full of rain,”
A condition drawn from the weather every farmer watched.
“they empty themselves upon the earth:”
Full clouds pour out what they hold, and the rain comes in its own time.
“and if the tree fall toward the south, or toward the north,”
Two directions named to show that the direction is beside the point.
“in the place where the tree falleth, there it shall be.”
The outcome is final, and the fallen tree stays where it lies.
Passage studyEcclesiastes 11:1–3
Cast Thy Bread upon the Waters
Summary
Ecclesiastes 11 opens with two commands and two pictures from nature. The Preacher tells us to cast our bread upon the waters, sending out what we have in generosity and honest venture, with the promise that we shall find it after many days. He tells us to give a portion to seven, and also to eight, sharing widely because the trouble ahead is hidden from us. Then he points to clouds that pour out their rain when they are full, and to a tree that lies where it falls. Rain and falling trees are outside our power to arrange, and the Preacher’s answer to that uncertainty is an open hand and steady work, with the outcome left to God.
What it means to cast thy bread upon the waters
The verb in “Cast thy bread upon the waters” is shâlach, the ordinary word for sending, or for stretching out the hand. The Preacher tells us to send our bread out and let it go from us. Bread, lechem, means bread or food, the staple of every table, and here it stands for what we live on: our goods, our means, our effort and our kindness. The waters, mayim, are wide and unpredictable, a place where whatever you send drifts out of sight. So the picture is of releasing something valuable into a place where you lose sight of it. The Preacher is speaking in a figure, and the bread is whatever we have to give.
Two practices of the ancient world lie close to this picture. The first is trade by sea or river. A merchant loaded grain onto ships and sent it to distant markets, where storms, pirates and changing prices all put the cargo at risk, yet a voyage that came home brought a good return after many days. The second is sowing seed on flooded or marshy ground, where the farmer casts the seed onto the water and trusts the water to nourish it until the harvest. Isaiah speaks a blessing on those who farm this way: “Blessed are ye that sow beside all waters” (Isaiah 32:20). Either way, the image is of putting something precious into an uncertain place and waiting for what comes back.
Is this verse about giving or about investing?
Believers differ on which comes first in this verse, and the two readings sit well together. Many take it chiefly as a call to generosity, to give to people who may be unable to repay you and to trust God to honour it. Proverbs says, “He that hath pity upon the poor lendeth unto the LORD; and that which he hath given will he pay him again” (Proverbs 19:17), and Jesus says, “Give, and it shall be given unto you” (Luke 6:38). Others hear first the counsel of a wise trader, to take sensible risks and do honest work, since a life spent holding everything back yields only what it already has.
The Preacher’s words fit both, and so does the rest of Scripture. Paul writes, “He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully” (2 Corinthians 9:6). The open hand that gives to the poor and the diligent hand that works and ventures belong to the same person, who trusts God for a return still out of sight.
Thou shalt find it after many days
The command comes with a reason, introduced by “for”: “thou shalt find it after many days.” The verb mâtsâʼ means to find or attain, the ordinary word for coming upon something. What was sent away comes back to the one who sent it.
“After many days” sets the time. The return is delayed, sometimes for a long while, and so the verse calls for patience. Paul states the same law of sowing and reaping: “whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap” (Galatians 6:7). What we do now bears fruit later.
People ask whether this promises a return in money. The verse promises that what is given in faith is found again, and it leaves the form and the time of that finding with God. It may come as a material blessing, as a friendship made stronger, as good done to others that spreads further, or as reward from God himself. What we give away for God’s purposes and for the good of others is kept, and he repays it in his own time and his own way.
Give a portion to seven, and also to eight
Verse 2 widens the command. “Give” is nâthan, a very broad word that means to give and is also used for putting, setting and making. A “portion”, chêleq, is an allotment, a share or part, and the same word can mean an inheritance. So the Preacher tells us to divide what we have into shares and hand them out.
“Seven, and also eight” is a Hebrew way of counting that names a number and then one more, to mean many. Proverbs counts the same way in “These six things doth the LORD hate: yea, seven are an abomination unto him” (Proverbs 6:16), and Micah uses the very same seven and eight when he promises “seven shepherds, and eight principal men” (Micah 5:5). Here it means to share with as many as you can, and then with one more. The generosity of this verse is wide, reaching past the few you already help. The same counsel holds for work and enterprise, where spreading your efforts over many ventures means that one loss leaves the rest standing.
Scripture asks that this giving be glad and that it honour God. “God loveth a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7), and “Honour the LORD with thy substance, and with the firstfruits of all thine increase” (Proverbs 3:9).
What evil may come upon the earth?
The reason given is “for thou knowest not what evil shall be upon the earth.” The word raʻ means bad or evil, and it covers harm and misfortune as well as wickedness. Here it is calamity, adversity and distress. Life in Israel was exposed to drought, famine, disease and war, in a world without modern provision for the needy, and anyone could be struck. The Preacher has already said that “time and chance happeneth to them all” (Ecclesiastes 9:11), and James says the same of our plans: “ye know not what shall be on the morrow” (James 4:14).
The hidden future gives two reasons to share now. Trouble may fall on the people you could help today, and your gifts may carry them through it. Trouble may also fall on you, and what has been spread widely among many people and many good works is a safeguard for the day of your own need. Our control over what comes is small, and God’s is complete, so our security lies in trusting him and in wise, open-handed stewardship. The Preacher turns uncertainty away from fear and toward faithful action.
The full clouds and the fallen tree
Verse 3 turns to two scenes every farmer in Israel knew. “If the clouds be full of rain, they empty themselves upon the earth.” Full, mâlêʼ, means filled up, and empty, rûwq, means to pour out or make empty. When the clouds are full, the rain comes down. Israel’s harvests depended on that rain, and it was received as a sign of God’s blessing.
“And if the tree fall toward the south, or toward the north, in the place where the tree falleth, there it shall be.” To fall, nâphal, is a broad word used for falling of every kind, including falling in death. Whatever brought the tree down, age or storm or the axe, it lies where it fell, and there it stays. The direction is beside the point. South or north, the fall itself and the place where it ends are what matter, and both are fixed.
The Preacher draws the lesson in the next verse: “He that observeth the wind shall not sow; and he that regardeth the clouds shall not reap” (Ecclesiastes 11:4). Rain and falling trees are outside our command. God has ordered his world so that they come in their own time, by the laws he set, and the one who waits for perfect conditions before giving or working will wait for ever. So verse 3 sends us back to the commands of verses 1 and 2.
Is verse 3 a counsel of fatalism?
Verse 3 teaches us to act wisely, knowing that some things lie beyond our control and that their results are fixed. The Preacher places it right after his commands to give, venture and work, and right before his warning against waiting on the weather. Knowing which things are fixed frees us to put our strength into the things that are ours to do, and to do them before the tree falls.
Where the tree falleth, there it shall be
The fallen tree is also a picture of death. Once a life has fallen, its place is fixed, and Scripture says, “it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment” (Hebrews 9:27). The Preacher keeps the shortness of life before us: “Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might” (Ecclesiastes 9:10). The choices we make set the course of a life, as Paul says when he warns that we reap what we sow, whether to the flesh or to the Spirit (Galatians 6:7–8). Since tomorrow is uncertain, James teaches us to plan by saying, “If the Lord will” (James 4:13–15). Some opportunities, once missed, are gone for good.
Where these verses stand in Ecclesiastes
For most of the book the Preacher, Koheleth (also written Qoheleth), has weighed the pursuits of life “under the sun”, wisdom, pleasure and wealth, and found them hebel, vanity, when they are made ends in themselves: “Vanity of vanities” (Ecclesiastes 1:2). From about chapter 9, and most clearly in chapters 11 and 12, he gives practical counsel for living well in an uncertain world. He has said, “Live joyfully with the wife whom thou lovest” (Ecclesiastes 9:9), and he will end with “Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man” (Ecclesiastes 12:13).
These three verses begin a run of counsel, through verse 6, that urges hopeful, wide and diligent action while life and strength last, before the decline of old age that he describes in Ecclesiastes 12:1–7. The book comes from Solomon, or from a wisdom teacher in his tradition, and its pictures of ships, fields, rain and trees come from the farming and trading life of Israel.
Christ, who gave himself
Jesus is the fullest picture of bread cast upon the waters. He calls himself the bread of life (John 6:35), and he gave himself into suffering and death, which to human eyes looked like a gift lost in the grave. He taught the principle himself: “Except a corn of wheat fall into the ground and die, it abideth alone: but if it die, it bringeth forth much fruit” (John 12:24). Through his death and resurrection we have found redemption, peace with God and eternal life. He promises that “he that loseth his life for my sake shall find it” (Matthew 10:39), and when he comes again his reward is with him for those who have served him (Revelation 22:12).
He gave without holding back. Paul describes the mind of Christ, who made himself of no reputation, took the form of a servant and became obedient unto death (Philippians 2:5–8), and John calls him “the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world” (John 1:29). Jesus tells his followers, “Take therefore no thought for the morrow”, and to seek the kingdom of God first (Matthew 6:25–34). The Preacher says the coming evil is hidden from us, and Jesus says, “be of good cheer; I have overcome the world” (John 16:33). Our security rests in the one by whom “all things consist” (Colossians 1:17), and our true portion is the inheritance we have in him (Ephesians 1:11). So our giving comes from faith and love, free of the fear of losing control.
The fallen tree points to Christ as well. Death is fixed for every man, and Christ has conquered it, rising as “the firstfruits of them that slept” (1 Corinthians 15:20). His work on the cross is as settled as a fallen tree, and he declared it “finished” (John 19:30). For the one who believes, the place where the tree falls is a place Christ has gone to prepare (John 14:2–3), and “There is therefore now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:1–2).
Living with an open hand
These verses ask us to hold our goods, our time and our gifts loosely. You can give to someone who will be unable to repay you, put your effort into honest work whose return is far off, and share widely, because God sees what you send out and keeps it. The trouble that may come is in his hands too. The rain will fall when the clouds are full and the tree will lie where it falls, and you can leave those things to him and do today the good your hand finds to do.
Ecclesiastes 11:1
“Cast thy bread”
A command, and a personal one. The bread is your own, what you live on.
“upon the waters:”
The wide water where what you send passes out of sight, whether the sea a ship crosses or the flooded field where seed is sown.
“for thou shalt find it”
The reason for the command, given as a sure promise.
“after many days.”
The return comes late, so the one who sends must wait for it.
Ecclesiastes 11:2
“Give a portion to seven,”
A share of what you have, handed out to many.
“and also to eight;”
One more than many, so there is always room for another.
“for thou knowest not what evil shall be upon the earth.”
Calamity of any kind, anywhere on the earth, in a future hidden from us. That hiddenness becomes the reason to give now.
Ecclesiastes 11:3 This verse
“If the clouds be full of rain,”
A condition drawn from the weather every farmer watched.
“they empty themselves upon the earth:”
Full clouds pour out what they hold, and the rain comes in its own time.
“and if the tree fall toward the south, or toward the north,”
Two directions named to show that the direction is beside the point.
“in the place where the tree falleth, there it shall be.”
The outcome is final, and the fallen tree stays where it lies.
Last revised