Skip to content
Share this page

Malachi 1:2

“The Lord's Love Questioned”Malachi 1:1–5

King James Version
I have loved you, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? Was not Esau Jacob's brother? saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob,

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
I have loved H157 you, saith H559 the LORD H3068. Yet ye say H559, Wherein hast thou loved H157 us? Was not Esau H6215 Jacob's H3290 brother H251? saith H5002 the LORD H3068: yet I loved H157 Jacob H3290,

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
“I have loved you,” says the LORD. But you ask, “How have You loved us?” “Was not Esau Jacob’s brother?” declares the LORD. “Yet Jacob I have loved,

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
I have loved you, saith Jehovah. Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? Was not Esau Jacob’s brother? saith Jehovah: yet I loved Jacob;

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
“I have loved you,” says the LORD. Yet you say, “How have you loved us?” “Wasn’t Esau Jacob’s brother?” says the LORD, “Yet I loved Jacob;

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
I haue loued you, sayth the Lord: yet yee say, Wherein hast thou loued vs? Was not Esau Iaakobs brother, saith the Lord? yet I loued Iaakob,

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
I have loved you, said Jehovah, And ye have said, `In what hast Thou loved us?'

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
16 Hebrew words
  1. אָהַבְתִּי'a·Hav·tiI have lovedH157V-Qal-Perf-1csVerb Qal Perfect 1st Singular common gender
  2. אֶתְכֶם'et·Khem[obj.] youH853DirObjM ¦ 2mpParticle Object Indicatorאֶתְ[obj.]כֶםyou
  3. אָמַר'a·Marhe saysH559V-Qal-Perf-3msVerb Qal Perfect 3rd Singular Masculine
  4. יְהוָהYah·wehYahwehH3068N-properNoun Proper Title
  5. וַאֲמַרְתֶּםva·'a·mar·Temand you sayH559Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecPerf-2mpVerb Qal Consecutive Perfect 2nd Plural Masculineוַandאֲמַרְתֶּםyou say
  6. בַּמָּהba·Mah[in] how?H4100Prep-b ¦ InterrogPronoun Interrogativeבַּ[in]מָּהhow?
  7. אֲהַבְתָּנוּ'a·hav·Ta·nuhave you loved usH157V-Qal-Perf-2ms ¦ 1cpVerb Qal Perfect 2nd Singular Masculineאֲהַבְתָּhave you lovedנוּus
  8. הֲלוֹאha·lo'¿ notH3808Interrog ¦ NegParticle Negativeהֲ¿לוֹאnot
  9. אָח'ach[did] a brotherH251N-msNoun Singular Masculine Absolute
  10. עֵשָׂו'e·SavEsauH6215N-proper-mNoun Proper Masculine
  11. לְיַעֲקֹבle·ya·'a·Ko[belong] to JacobH3290Prep-l ¦ N-proper-mNoun Proper Masculineלְ[belong] toיַעֲקֹבJacob
  12. נְאֻםne·'um[the] utterance ofH5002N-mscNoun Singular Masculine Construct
  13. יְהוָהYah·wehYahwehH3068N-properNoun Proper Title
  14. וָאֹהַבva·'o·Havand I lovedH157Conj-w ¦ V-Qal-ConsecImperf-1csVerb Qal Consecutive Imperfect 1st Singular common genderוָandאֹהַבI loved
  15. אֶת'et[obj.]H853DirObjMParticle Object Indicator
  16. יַעֲקֹבya·'a·KoJacobH3290N-proper-mNoun Proper Masculine
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Hebrew, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Hebrew Masoretic text, the same tradition the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Hebrew word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “the LORD” where the word-by-word meaning reads “Yahweh”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Hebrew. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
In the KJVVerse 23,092 of 31,102 · 74.2%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

The LORD tells his people he has loved them, and when they ask how, he points to his choice of Jacob, though Esau was Jacob’s own brother.

“I have loved you, saith the LORD.”

The book opens with love before any rebuke, and the LORD himself makes the declaration.

“Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us?”

The first of the people’s challenging questions in this book. They ask for proof, and the LORD gives it.

“Was not Esau Jacob’s brother?”

Esau’s name, ʻÊsâv, is taken to mean “rough”, and Jacob’s, Yaʻăqôb, means heel-catcher or supplanter. As twins they began life on equal footing.

“saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob,”

God’s choice of Jacob is his whole answer. Jacob here stands for the nation descended from him as well as the man.

Passage studyMalachi 1:1–5

I Have Loved You, Saith the LORD

1The burden of the word of the LORD to Israel by Malachi. 2I have loved you, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? Was not Esau Jacob’s brother? saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob, 3And I hated Esau, and laid his mountains and his heritage waste for the dragons of the wilderness. 4Whereas Edom saith, We are impoverished, but we will return and build the desolate places; thus saith the LORD of hosts, They shall build, but I will throw down; and they shall call them, The border of wickedness, and, The people against whom the LORD hath indignation for ever. 5And your eyes shall see, and ye shall say, The LORD will be magnified from the border of Israel.

Summary

Malachi’s book opens with a heavy word from the LORD to a people back from exile, and its first words are “I have loved you.” The people answer with a doubting question, “Wherein hast thou loved us?”, and the LORD points them to two brothers. He chose Jacob, the father of Israel, and he set himself against Esau and laid Edom’s land waste. Edom vows to rebuild, and the LORD says he will throw down whatever they build. Israel will see it with their own eyes and say that the LORD is great. In five verses we learn that God’s love for his people rests on his own choice, that he holds to it while they doubt it, and that he rules the nations around them.

“I Have Loved You”: The LORD Answers a Doubting People

Malachi spoke to the Jews who had come back to Judah from exile in Babylon, most likely in the middle or later part of the fifth century before Christ, around the time of Ezra and Nehemiah (Nehemiah 13). The temple had been rebuilt and the sacrifices had started again, yet the hopes of the return had faded. The people were poor, the glory the prophets had spoken of had yet to come, and many felt that God was far away. Their disappointment showed in their worship and their homes. Priests offered blemished sacrifices, tithes went unpaid, men married foreign wives, and the weak were oppressed. “Israel” in this book means this community, the covenant people living in Judah.

The LORD’s first word to them is love. “I have loved you, saith the LORD.” The verb is ʼâhab, to love, to have affection for, and “loved” stands three times in this verse, each time for that word. Before he names a single sin, God tells them that he has loved them. The second “saith” is nᵉʼum, a word for an utterance or declaration, used of a prophetic statement, so the line comes as the LORD’s own solemn word. Earlier in the verse “saith the LORD” translates ʼâmar, the ordinary verb for saying, which is also the word behind “ye say”.

Then comes the people’s reply: “Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us?” Their question is a challenge. They want proof, because hard times have persuaded them that his love has gone. It is the first of six times in the book that the LORD makes a statement, the people throw it back at him with a question, and he answers them in full. Israel had questioned the LORD in the same way in the wilderness (Numbers 14:11), and the rest of Malachi 1 shows where this doubt leads: contempt for his name and careless worship at his altar.

“Was not Esau Jacob’s brother?”

The LORD answers with their own history. Esau and Jacob were twins, born of the same parents into the same home, and the word for brother, ʼâch, covers kinship of every kind. “Yet I loved Jacob.” Before the boys were born, God had already spoken of the two nations they would become (Genesis 25:23). His choice came before either brother had done anything, so it rested on God’s own will and purpose.

Israel’s whole story rests on love of this kind. God called Abraham and promised to bless him and make of him a great nation (Genesis 12:1–3). Moses told Israel that the LORD chose them to be his own people because he loved them, few as they were (Deuteronomy 7:6–8). So the LORD’s answer to “Wherein hast thou loved us?” is simple: you are my people because I chose your father Jacob. The proof of his love was written into their history long before they doubted it.

Why Did God Love Jacob and Hate Esau?

In this verse “hated” describes God’s settled choice against Esau and the people who came from him, and it stands beside “I loved Jacob” to show how differently the two brothers stood in God’s purpose. The word is sânêʼ, to hate, and it is a strong word. Set beside love for a brother, it often speaks of choosing one over the other. Jesus uses the word hate in this way when he says that a disciple must hate father and mother (Luke 14:26), meaning that he must love them less than he loves Christ. On this reading, God’s love for Jacob and his hatred of Esau describe a choice. Jacob’s line would carry God’s covenant and bring the Messiah, and Esau’s descendants, Edom, were passed over for that purpose.

Edom’s own deeds belong to the answer as well. Esau’s descendants treated Israel with hostility again and again. They refused Israel passage on the way from Egypt (Numbers 20:14–21), and when Babylon destroyed Jerusalem in 586 BC they joined in and rejoiced over its fall (Psalm 137:7, Obadiah 1:10–14). Verse 4 calls their land “the border of wickedness”. God’s hatred of Esau therefore includes his just judgment on a people who set themselves against him and against their brother nation, and it is the act of a holy God.

Paul quotes these words of Malachi in Romans 9:10–13, where he teaches that God’s choice rests on his grace and his call, apart from works. Believers differ on how far Paul’s use of it reaches. Some hold that it speaks of God’s choice of a nation and a line, the one through which his promise would come into the world. Others hold that it also shows God’s free choice of the people he saves, made in Christ before the foundation of the world (Ephesians 1:4–5). On either reading, God’s love is a gift he gives freely, and his choices are just and purposeful even where we cannot see all his reasons.

Edom’s Mountains Left to the Jackals

The second half of verse 3 shows God’s word against Esau carried out in history. “His mountains” are the rugged hill country of Seir, southeast of Judah, where Esau’s descendants lived among strongholds they thought were safe. “His heritage” is nachălâh, something inherited, the land they held as their ancestral portion. God says he has “laid” it waste. The verb sûwm simply means to put or set, and here God sets Edom’s land down as a ruin. The word for waste, shᵉmâmâh, means devastation or desolation, and also horror, a ruin that appals those who see it.

The “dragons of the wilderness” are jackals. The word tannâh is the female jackal, and older English used “dragons” for the creatures of waste places. The wilderness, midbâr, is open country where cattle were driven to pasture, and so the desert. A land given over to jackals is a land empty of people, and that is the picture of Edom’s homeland.

By Malachi’s day Edom had already suffered this ruin, possibly at the hands of Arab peoples such as the Nabataeans, who later took over its old territory south of the Dead Sea, and in time Edom passed away as a separate nation. Israel had suffered too, yet Israel was still there, back in its land with its temple rebuilt. That difference was the LORD’s answer, plain to see. The whole of Obadiah’s short prophecy is a word against Edom (Obadiah 1), and Isaiah also announces the LORD’s judgment on Edom (Isaiah 34:5–6).

“They Shall Build, but I Will Throw Down”

Edom answers its ruin with a vow: “We are impoverished, but we will return and build the desolate places.” The word for impoverished, râshash, means to demolish, so Edom is saying that it has been beaten down. To return, shûwb, is to turn back, and the desolate places, chorbâh, are ruins, dry and decayed. To build, bânâh, also means to repair or set up, and Edom means to restore what it had. Nations often rebuilt in this way after a defeat, but Edom speaks of its ruin as a setback it can repair by its own strength, and leaves out the hand that brought it.

The LORD answers as “the LORD of hosts”. The word tsâbâʼ is a body of people organised for war, an army, so the name shows the LORD as the commander of armies, with all power to carry out what he decrees. His reply takes up Edom’s own word: “They shall build, but I will throw down.” The verb hâraç means to tear down, throw down or overthrow, the opposite of building. Whatever Edom raises, he will pull down. When the LORD of hosts has purposed a thing, it stands (Isaiah 14:27). He frustrates the plans of the nations while his own counsel stands for ever (Psalm 33:10–11), and “There are many devices in a man’s heart; nevertheless the counsel of the LORD, that shall stand” (Proverbs 19:21).

Others will then name Edom by what it is: “The border of wickedness, and, The people against whom the LORD hath indignation for ever.” To call, qârâʼ, is to call out or to name. The border, gᵉbûwl, is a border or boundary and by extension the territory inside it, so the name covers Edom’s whole land. Wickedness, rishʻâh, is wrong, especially moral wrong. Edom’s people, ʻam, will be known as the ones against whom the LORD has indignation. The verb zâʻam properly means to foam at the mouth, to be enraged, and it is a word for fierce anger. “For ever” is ʻad ʻôwlâm, as far as time out of mind, to the vanishing point. Edom’s judgment is what its own wickedness earned, from the God to whom vengeance belongs (Deuteronomy 32:35).

Why does Malachi begin with Edom?

Malachi begins with Edom because Edom’s ruin was the plainest proof Israel had of the LORD’s love, and it was also a warning to them. Both brother nations had been laid low, but Israel came back and rebuilt, while the LORD gave his word that Edom’s rebuilding would fail. The same God who judges Edom’s sin is about to name Israel’s own. The rest of the book confronts their careless priests, their blemished offerings and their broken faith. He judges sin wherever he finds it, among his enemies or among his own people.

“The LORD Will Be Magnified”

Verse 5 looks ahead. In “your eyes shall see”, ʻayin is the eye and râʼâh is to see, both with the eye and with understanding. Israel would watch the LORD’s word against Edom come true, and the people who had asked “Wherein hast thou loved us?” would say instead, “The LORD will be magnified.” The doubting words of verse 2 become words of praise in verse 5.

The verb gâdal means to be great or large, to grow, and in some forms to make great. To magnify the LORD is to see how great he already is and to say so, so that his greatness is known and declared by others. The psalmist calls others to do this with him: “O magnify the LORD with me, and let us exalt his name together” (Psalm 34:3). God acts in history so that people will “know that I am God” (Psalm 46:10), so that he is known far and wide as the only God (Isaiah 45:6), and all things are from him and for his glory (Romans 11:36).

“From the border of Israel” uses gᵉbûwl again, the word behind “the border of wickedness” in verse 4. Edom’s land would be called the border of wickedness, and from Israel’s border the LORD would be called great. Israel would praise him from inside their own land as they looked across at the ruin beside them, and his greatness would also reach out past that border to the lands beyond. In both senses, what God did at Israel’s border showed his greatness.

The Burden of the Word of the LORD by Malachi

The book’s first verse names its message, its source, its hearers and its messenger. “Burden”, massâʼ, is a load, something carried, and in the prophets it is used for an utterance, chiefly a message of doom. It is a heavy word from God that calls people to account, and it is the term used for Isaiah’s word against Babylon (Isaiah 13:1) and Nahum’s against Nineveh (Nahum 1:1). Here the burden is for Israel, and it opens with “I have loved you”.

The word, dâbâr, means speech and also a matter or thing. “The word of the LORD” is the LORD’s own speech, so the book claims his authority from its first line, as other prophets’ books open with a title naming the prophet (Isaiah 1:1, Jeremiah 1:1). The name LORD, Yᵉhôvâh, is God’s covenant name, the self-existent and eternal One, and it tells Israel that the God who bound himself to them is the one speaking. Israel, Yisrâʼêl, is the name given to Jacob and carried by his descendants, which already points to the Jacob of verse 2.

The word came “by Malachi”, literally by the hand, yâd, of Malachi. With a preposition this word marks anyone through whom something is done, and here it marks Malachi as the one through whom God sent his word. God has always spoken through people he sends. He promised to raise up a prophet and put his words in his mouth (Deuteronomy 18:18), he called Jeremiah (Jeremiah 1), and he showed Ezekiel his visions (Ezekiel 1). The name Malʼâkîy means “my messenger”, which fits his work. The same idea returns in the book’s own promise that the LORD will send his messenger to prepare the way before him (Malachi 3:1), a promise the Gospel of Mark applies to John the Baptist (Mark 1:2–3). God, who spoke by the prophets, has in these last days spoken to us by his Son (Hebrews 1:1–2), and his word accomplishes what he sends it to do (Isaiah 55:11).

Christ and the Love God Chose to Give

The question “Wherein hast thou loved us?” has its fullest answer at the cross. God commends his love toward us in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us (Romans 5:8), and God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son (John 3:16). The free love that chose Jacob is the love that chose believers in Christ (Ephesians 1:4–5). Every promise of God is yes in Christ (2 Corinthians 1:20), and all who belong to Christ are Abraham’s seed and heirs according to the promise (Galatians 3:29).

God’s Word became flesh and dwelt among us, “and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth” (John 1:14), so the LORD is magnified most of all in Jesus. That praise now reaches far past the border of Israel, until every tongue confesses that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father (Philippians 2:11). Christ has triumphed over the principalities and powers (Colossians 2:15), and so the LORD’s word that he will throw down all that stands against him is carried out in Christ. Edom’s ruin is a picture of the wrath of God that abides on those who reject the Son (John 3:36), while those justified by his blood are saved from wrath through him (Romans 5:9). The burden of God’s word presses hard on sinners, and Jesus calls all who labour and are heavy laden to come to him for rest (Matthew 11:28–30).

The LORD Whose Love Comes First

This passage shows a God who meets doubt with love. His people had grown tired and cynical, and he spoke of his love before he spoke of their sins. He gave them evidence they could see, in the story of their father Jacob and in the ruins across their border. His love rests on his own choice, so it holds firm while the people who receive it are weak and doubting, and it had lasted through all their hard times. The God who judged Edom is the same God who keeps his people. When we ask with Israel, “Wherein hast thou loved us?”, the passage points us to what he has already done, in Jacob and, for us, in the cross of Christ. And it ends where Israel’s doubt was meant to end, with eyes that see and lips that say, “The LORD will be magnified.”

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Malachi 1:1–5. He set out his notes in a four-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 5 verses
Passage under commentMalachi 1:1–5
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

The prophecy of this book is entitled, The burden of the word of the Lord (Malachi 1:1), which intimates, 1. That it was of great weight and importance; what the false prophets said was light as the chaff, what the true prophets said was ponderous as the wheat, Jeremiah 23:28. 2. That it ought to be often repeated to them and by them, as the burden of a song. 3. That there were those to whom it was a burden and a reproach; they were weary of it, and found themselves so aggrieved by it that they were not able to bear it. 4. That to them it would prove a burden indeed, to sink them to the lowest hell, unless they repented. 5. That to those who loved it and embraced it, and bade it welcome, though it was a light burden, as our Saviour calls it (Matthew 11:30), yet it was a burden.

This burden of the word of the Lord was sent, 1. To Israel, for to them pertained the lively oracles of prophecy as well as those of the written word. Many prophets God had sent to Israel, and now he will try them with one more. 2. By Malachi, by the hand of Malachi, as if it were not a message by word of mouth, but a letter put into his hand, for the greater certainty.

In these verses, they are charged with ingratitude, in that they were not duly sensible of God's distinguishing goodness to them; and such a charge as this may well be called a burden, for it is a heavy one.

I.God asserts the great kindness he had, and had often expressed, for them (Malachi 1:2):

I have loved you, saith the Lord. Thus abruptly does the sermon begin, as if God intended, whatever reproofs should be given them, to reconcile them to his love, and to take care that they should still have good thoughts of him. As many as I love I rebuke and chasten. Thus kindly does the sermon begin. God will have his people satisfied that he loves them and is ever mindful of his love. This is the same with what he said of old to the virgin of Israel, that he might engage her affections to himself (Jeremiah 31:3, Jeremiah 31:4): Yea I have loved thee with an everlasting love. In this one word God sums up all his gracious dealings with them; love was the spring of all; he loved them because he would love them (Deuteronomy 7:7, Deuteronomy 7:8), loved them in their childhood, Hosea 11:1. His delight was in them, Isaiah 62:4. "I have loved you, but you have not loved me, nor made any suitable returns for my love." Note, God's people need to be often reminded of his love to them.

II.They question his love, and diminish the instances of it, and seem to quarrel with him for telling them of it:

Yet you say, Wherein hast thou loved us? As God traces up all his favours to them to the fountain, which was his love, so he traces up all their sins against him to the fountain, which was their contempt of his love. Instead of acknowledging his kindness, and studying what they shall render, they scorn to own that they have been beholden to him, challenge him to produce proofs of his love that are material, and think and speak very slightly of the instances they have had of his kindness, as if they were so few, so small, as not to be worth taking notice of, and no more than what they had sufficiently made returns for, or at least than he had sufficiently balanced with instances of his wrath. "Have we not been wasted, impoverished, and carried captive; and wherein then hast thou loved us?" Note, God justly takes it very ill to have his favours slighted, as not worth speaking of; and it is very absurd for us to ask wherein he has loved us, when, which way soever we look, we meet with the proofs and instances of his love to us.

III.He makes it out, beyond contradiction, that he has loved them, loved them in a distinguishing way, which was in a special manner obliging.

For proof of this he shows the difference he had made, and would still make, between Jacob and Esau, between Israelites and Edomites. Some read their question, Wherefore hast thou loved us? as if they did indeed own that he had loved them, but withal insinuate that there was a reason for it - that he loved them because their father Abraham had loved him, so that it was not a free love, but a love of debt, to which he replies, "Was not Esau as near akin to Abraham as you are? Was he not Jacob's own brother, his elder brother? And therefore, if there were any right to a recompence for Abraham's love, Esau had it, and yet I hated Esau and loved Jacob."

1.Let them see what a difference God had made between Jacob and Esau. Esau was Jacob's brother, his twin-brother: "Yet I loved Jacob and I hated Esau, that is, took Jacob into covenant, and entailed the blessing on him and his, but refused and rejected Esau." Note, Those that are taken into covenant with God, that have the lively oracles and the means of grace committed to them, have reason to look upon these as tokens of his love. Jacob is loved, for he has these, Esau hated, for he has not. The apostle quotes this (Romans 9:13), and compares it with what the oracle said to Rebecca concerning her twins (Genesis 25:23), The elder shall serve the younger, to illustrate the doctrine of God's sovereignty in dispensing his favours; for may he not do what he will with his own? Esau was justly hated, but Jacob freely loved; even so, Father, because it seemed good in thy eyes, and it is not for us to ask why or wherefore.

2.Let them see what he was now doing and would do with them, pursuant to this original difference.

(1.)The Edomites shall be made the monuments of God's justice, and he will be glorified in their utter destruction: For Esau have I hated; I laid his mountains waste, the mountains of Seir, which were his heritage. When all that part of the world was ravaged by the Chaldean army the country of Edom was, among the rest, laid in ruins, and became a habitation for the dragons of the wilderness, so perfectly desolate was it; as was foretold, Isaiah 34:6, Isaiah 34:11. The Edomites had triumphed in Jerusalem's overthrow (Psalm 137:7), and therefore it was just with God to put the same cup of trembling into their hands. And, though Edom's ruins were last, yet they were lasting, and the desolation perpetual; and in this the difference was made between Jacob and Esau, and is made between the righteous and the wicked, to whom otherwise all things come alike, and there seems to be one event. Jacob's cities are laid waste, but they are rebuilt; Edom's are laid waste, and never rebuilt. The sufferings of the righteous will have an end and will end well; all their grievances will be redressed, and their sorrow turned into joy; but the sufferings of the wicked will be endless and remediless, as Edom's desolations, Malachi 1:4. Observe here,

[1.]The vain hopes of the Edomites, that they shall have their ruins repaired as well as Israel, though they had no promise to build their hope upon. They say, "It is true, we are impoverished; it is the common chance, and there is no remedy; but we will return and build the desolate places; we are resolved we will" (not so much as asking God leave); "we will whether he will or no; nay, we will do it in defiance of God's curse, and that sentence pronounced upon Edom (Isaiah 34:10), From generation to generation it shall lie waste." They build presumptuously, as Hiel built Jericho in direct contradiction to the word of God (1 Kings 16:34), and it shall speed accordingly. Note, It is common for those whose hearts are unhumbled under humbling providences to think to make their part good against God himself, and to build, and plant, and flourish again as much as ever, though God has said that they shall be impoverished. But see,

[2.]The dashing of these hopes and the disappointment of them: They say, We will build; but what says the Lord of hosts? For we are sure his word shall stand, and not theirs; and he says, First, Their attempts shall be baffled: They shall build, but I will throw down. Note, Those that walk contrary to God will find that he will walk contrary to them; for who ever hardened his heart against God and prospered? When the Jews had rejected Christ and his gospel they became Edomites, and this word was fulfilled in them; for when, in the time of the emperor Adrian, they attempted to rebuild Jerusalem, God by earthquakes and eruptions of fire threw down what they built, so that they were forced to quit the enterprise. Secondly, They shall be looked upon by all as abandoned to utter ruin. All that see them shall call them the border of wickedness, a sinful nation, incurably so, and therefore the people against whom the Lord has indignation for ever. Since their wickedness is such as will never be reformed, their desolations shall be such as are never to be repaired. Against Israel God was a little displeased (Zechariah 1:15), but against Edom he has indignation, and will have for ever, for they are the people of his curse, Isaiah 34:5.

(2.)The Israelites shall be made the monuments of his mercy, and he will be glorified in their salvation, Malachi 1:5. "The Edomites shall be stigmatized as a people hated of God, but your eyes shall see your doubts concerning his love to you for ever silenced; for you shall say, and have cause to say, The Lord is and will be magnified from the border of Israel, from every part and border of the land of Israel." The border of Edom is a border of wickedness, and therefore the Lord will have indignation against it for ever; but the border of Israel is a border of holiness, the border of the sanctuary (Psalm 78:54), and therefore God will make it to appear (though it may for a time lie desolate) that he has mercy in store for it, and thence he will be magnified; he will give his people Israel both cause, and hearts, to praise him. When the border of Edom still remains desolate, and the border of Israel is repaired and replenished, then it will appear that God has loved Jacob. Note, [1.] Those who doubt of God's love to his people shall, sooner or later, have convincing and undeniable proofs given them of it: "your own eyes shall see what you will not believe." [2.] Deliverances out of trouble are to be reckoned proofs of God's good-will to his people, though they may be suffered to fall into trouble, Psalm 34:19. [3.] Distinguishing favours are very obliging. If God rear up again the border of Israel, but leave the border of Edom in ruins, let no Israelite ask, for shame, Wherein hast thou loved us? [4.] The dignifying of Israel is the magnifying of the God of Israel, and, one way or other, God will have honour from his professing people. [5.] God's goodness being his glory, when he does us good we must proclaim him great, for that is magnifying him. It is an instance of his goodness that he has pleasure in the prosperity of his servants, and for this those that love his salvation say, The Lord be magnified, Psalm 35:27.

Historical interpretation

Seventeen Centuries of Reception

5 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

5 quotes · AD 56–1781
Ante-NicenePost-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
0100200300400500600700800900100011001200130014001500160017001800

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

d. AD 56Romanson 9:1-18Ante-Nicene
I say the truth in Christ, I lie not, my conscience also bearing me witness in the Holy Ghost, That I have great heaviness and continual sorrow in my heart. For I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh: Who are Israelites; to whom pertaineth the adoption, and the glory, and the covenants, and the giving of the law, and the service of God, and the promises; Whose are the fathers, and of whom as concerning the flesh Christ came, who is over all, God blessed for ever. Amen. Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect. For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel: Neither, because they are the seed of Abraham, are they all children: but, In Isaac shall thy seed be called. That is, They which are the children of the flesh, these are not the children of God: but the children of the promise are counted for the seed. For this is the word of promise, At this time will I come, and Sara shall have a son. And not only this; but when Rebecca also had conceived by one, even by our father Isaac; (For the children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, that the purpose of God according to election might stand, not of works, but of him that calleth;) It was said unto her, The elder shall serve the younger. As it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated. [Malachi 1:2-3] What shall we say then? Is there unrighteousness with God? God forbid. For he saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. So then it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that showeth mercy. For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might show my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth. Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth.
d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceEnchiridion 25:98
Furthermore, who would be so impiously foolish as to say that God cannot turn the evil wills of people—as he wills, when he wills and where he wills—toward the good? But when he acts, he acts through mercy; when he does not act, it is through justice. For “he has mercy on whom he wills, and whom he wills, he hardens.” Now when the apostle said this, he was commending grace, of which he had just spoken in connection with the twin children in Rebecca’s womb: “Before they had yet been born or had done anything good or bad, in order that the electing purpose of God might continue, it was said of them, ‘The elder shall serve the younger.’ ” Accordingly he refers to another prophetic witness, where it is written, “Jacob I loved, but Esau I have hated.” Then, realizing how what he said could disturb those whose understanding could not penetrate to this depth of grace, he adds, “What therefore shall we say to this? Is there unrighteousness in God? God forbid!” Yet it does seem unfair that, without any merit derived from good works or bad, God should love the one and hate the other. Now if the apostle had wished us to understand that there were future good deeds of the other—which God, of course, foreknew—he never would have said “not of good works” but rather “of future works.” Thus he would have solved the difficulty; or rather he would have left no difficulty to be solved. As it is, however, when he went on to exclaim, “God forbid!” he proceeds immediately to add (to prove that no unfairness in God is involved here), “For he says to Moses, ‘I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will show pity to whom I will show pity.’ ” Now who but a fool would think God unfair either when he imposes penal judgment on the deserving or when he shows mercy to the undeserving? Finally, the apostle concludes and says, “Therefore it is not a question of him who wills nor of him who runs but of God’s showing mercy.”
d. AD 430Augustine of HippoPost-NiceneSourceLETTER 194
Who are these that reply to God, who speaks to Rebecca? She had twin sons of one conception of Isaac our father. “The children were not yet born nor had done any good or evil (that the purpose of God according to election might stand).” The election was of grace, not of merit. It is the election by which he does not find but makes elect—“that it was not of works but of him that calls, that the elder should serve the younger.” To this sentence the blessed apostle adds the testimony of a prophet who came along afterward: “Jacob I have loved, but Esau I have hated” to give us to understand plainly by the later utterance what was hidden in the predestination of God by grace before they were born. For what did he love but the free gift of his mercy in Jacob, who had done nothing good before his birth? And what did he hate but original sin in Esau, who had done nothing evil before his birth? Surely he would not have loved in the former a goodness which he had not practiced, nor would he have hated in the latter a nature which he himself had created good.
d. AD 542Caesarius of ArlesPost-NiceneSourceSERMON 104:1
At the very beginning of the world, of those two sons who were born of Adam, Abel the younger is chosen, while as a figure of the unfaithful Jews, Cain the older one is condemned. Afterward, in the time of Abraham, the same figure is fulfilled in Sarah and Hagar. Sarah was sterile for a long time as a type of the church, while Hagar as a figure of the synagogue bore a son at once. Hence it is that the younger son Isaac is received into the inheritance, but Ishmael, who was older, is driven away. This fact also seems to have been fulfilled in those two: Jacob the younger was loved by God, while Esau was rejected according to what is written: “I have loved Jacob but hated Esau.” This figure is also known to have been fulfilled in those two sisters whom blessed Jacob had as his wives: Rachel, who was the younger, was loved more than Leah the older. In fact, of the former was born Joseph, who was to be sold in Egypt as a type of our Lord and Savior. That Leah was bleary-eyed while Rachel was beautiful in countenance is also significant: in Leah is understood the synagogue; the church is indicated in Rachel. A man whose bodily eyes are afflicted with inflammation cannot look at the brightness of the sun. Similarly the synagogue, which had had the eyes of its heart filled with jealousy and envy against our Lord and Savior as with poisonous floods, could not gaze upon the splendor of Christ, who is “the Sun of justice.”
d. AD 1781Richard ChallonerMedieval
I have loved Jacob: I have preferred his posterity, to make them my chosen people, and to lead them with my blessings, without any merit on their part, and though they have been always ungrateful; whilst I have rejected Esau, and executed severe judgments upon his posterity. Not that God punished Esau, or his posterity, beyond their desert: but that by his free election and grace he loved Jacob, and favoured his posterity above their deserts.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Malachi 1:2 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8