TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Judges 1:9–20.
We have here a further account of that glorious and successful campaign which Judah and Simeon made. 1. The lot of Judah was pretty well cleared of the Canaanites, yet not thoroughly. Those that dwelt in the mountain (the mountains that were round about Jerusalem) were driven out (Jdg 1:9, Jdg 1:19), but those in the valley kept their ground against them, having chariots of iron, such as we read of, Jos 17:16. Here the men of Judah failed, and thereby spoiled the influence which otherwise their example hitherto might have had on the rest of the tribes, who followed them in this instance of their cowardice, rather than in all the other instances of their courage. They had iron chariots, and therefore it was thought not safe to attack them: but had not Israel God on their side, whose chariots are thousands of angels (Psa 68:17), before whom these iron chariots would be but as stubble to the fire? Had not God expressly promised by the oracle (Jdg 1:2) to give them success against the Canaanites in this very expedition, without excepting those that had iron chariots? Yet they suffered their fears to prevail against their faith, they could not trust God under any disadvantages, and therefore durst not face the iron chariots, but meanly withdrew their forces, when with one bold stroke they might have completed their victories; and it proved of pernicious consequence. They did run well, what hindered them? Gal 5:7. 2. Caleb was put in possession of Hebron, which, though given him by Joshua ten or twelve years before (as Dr. Lightfoot computes), yet being employed in public service, for the settling of the tribes, which he preferred before his own private interests, it seems he did not till now make himself master of; so well content was that good man to serve others, while he left himself to be served last; few are like-minded, for all seek their own, Phi 2:20, Phi 2:21. Yet now the men of Judah all came in to his assistance for the reducing of Hebron (Jdg 1:10), slew the sons of Anak, and put him in possession of it, Jdg 1:20. They gave Hebron unto Caleb. And now Caleb, that he might return the kindness of his countrymen, is impatient to see Debir reduced and put into the hands of the men of Judah, to expedite which he proffers his daughter to the person that will undertake to command in the siege of that important place, Jdg 1:11, Jdg 1:12. Othniel bravely undertakes it, and wins the town and the lady (Jdg 1:13), and by his wife's interest and management with her father gains a very good inheritance for himself and his family, Jdg 1:14, Jdg 1:15. We had this passage before, Jos 15:16-19, where it was largely explained and improved. 3. Simeon got ground of the Canaanites in his border, Jdg 1:17, Jdg 1:18. In the eastern part of Simeon's lot, they destroyed the Canaanites in Zephath, and called it Hormah - destruction, adding this to some other devoted cities not far off, which they had some time ago, with good reason, called by that name, Num 21:2, Num 21:3. And this perhaps was the complete performance of the vow they them made that they would utterly destroy these cities of the Canaanites in the south. In the western part they took Gaza, Askelon, and Ekron, cities of the Philistines; they gained present possession of the cities, but, not destroying the inhabitants, the Philistines in process of time recovered the cities, and proved inveterate enemies to the Israel of God, and no better could come of doing their work by the halves. 4. The Kenites gained a settlement in the tribe of Judah, choosing it there rather than in any other tribe, because it was the strongest, and there they hoped to be safe and quiet, Jdg 1:16. These were the posterity of Jethro, who either went with Israel when Moses invited them (Num 10:29) or met them about the same place when they came up from their wanderings in the wilderness thirty-eight years after, and went with them then to Canaan, Moses having promised them that they should fare as Israel fared, Num 10:32. They had at first seated themselves in the city of palm-trees, that is, Jericho, a city which never was to be rebuilt, and therefore the fitter for those who dwelt in tents, and did not mind building. But afterwards they removed into the wilderness of Judah, either out of their affection to that place, because solitary and retired, or out of their affection to that tribe, which perhaps had been in a particular manner kind to them. Yet we find the tent of Jael, who was of that family, far north, in the lot of Naphtali, when Sisera took shelter there, Jdg 4:17. This respect Israel showed them, to let them fix where they pleased, being a quiet people, who, wherever they were, were content with a little. Those that molested none were molested by none. Blessed are the meek, for thus they shall inherit the earth.
Continue studying Judges 1:9 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
Judges 1:9 details the ongoing military campaign of the tribe of Judah following their initial successes after Joshua's death. It specifically describes their efforts to dispossess the remaining Canaanite inhabitants from distinct geographical regions within their allotted territory: the rugged mountain areas, the arid southern Negeb, and the fertile lowlands or valleys. This verse underscores the persistent and challenging nature of the conquest, highlighting Judah's active and widespread role in securing the land promised by God.
Context
Literary Context
Judges 1 serves as a crucial prologue to the entire book, setting the stage for the cycles of disobedience, oppression, and deliverance that characterize the period of the Judges. Following the death of Joshua, the Israelites seek divine guidance on who should lead the charge against the remaining Canaanites, as depicted in Judges 1:1-2. Judah, with the assistance of Simeon, takes the lead, achieving significant initial victories, including the defeat of Adoni-Bezek in Judges 1:4-7 and the capture of Jerusalem in Judges 1:8. Verse 9 continues this narrative, shifting from these general successes to specify the types of challenging terrain Judah still had to conquer. It transitions the reader from initial triumphs to the persistent, geographically diverse struggle that would ultimately define the incomplete nature of Israel's conquest, foreshadowing the failures detailed later in the chapter and throughout the book.
Historical & Cultural Context
The period described in Judges 1 falls into the early Iron Age I (roughly 1200-1000 BCE), a time of significant transition for the Israelite tribes. After the unified campaigns under Joshua, the tribes were now largely decentralized, operating with varying degrees of cooperation. The Canaanites were not a monolithic entity but comprised various city-states and peoples, often possessing superior military technology, including iron chariots (mentioned in Judges 1:19). The geographical terms "mountain," "south," and "valley" are critical. The "mountain" refers to the central highlands of Judah, characterized by rocky, defensible terrain. The "south" (Hebrew: Negeb) denotes the semi-arid, often desolate region stretching towards the wilderness. The "valley" (Hebrew: Shephelah) refers to the fertile lowlands and foothills situated between the central highlands and the coastal plain, often home to strong Canaanite cities. Judah's "going down" implies movement from their higher, more secure mountain strongholds into these different, often more challenging, regions.
Key Themes
This verse contributes significantly to several overarching themes in Judges. Firstly, it highlights the Incomplete Conquest, a pervasive theme throughout the book. Despite God's promise to give them the land, Israel's possession was not immediate or effortless; it required persistent, often difficult, military engagement, and ultimately, they failed to fully dispossess the inhabitants, leading to ongoing spiritual and social challenges (e.g., Judges 2:2-3). Secondly, it emphasizes Tribal Responsibility, particularly Judah's leadership role. Having been designated to go first, as seen in Judges 1:1-2, Judah actively pursued its mandate, showcasing a degree of initial obedience and commitment that contrasts with the later failures of other tribes. Thirdly, it illustrates the interplay between Divine Promise and Human Effort. God had promised the land to Israel, as affirmed in Joshua 1:3, but this promise did not negate the necessity of human action and warfare. The verse demonstrates that divine sovereignty works in conjunction with human responsibility and obedience. Finally, the verse underscores the Persistent Opposition faced by Israel, revealing that the Canaanites were deeply entrenched across diverse terrains, necessitating sustained and varied military approaches.
Exposition and Analysis
Key Word Analysis
From יָדָה, meaning "celebrated," this refers to Jehudah, the name of a prominent Israelite and the tribe descended from him, encompassing its territory. In Judges 1, Judah is specifically chosen by God to lead the initial phase of the conquest, demonstrating their prominence and responsibility. Their active participation in fighting across diverse terrains highlights their commitment to the divine mandate, at least in this early stage.
A patrial term from כְּנַעַן, denoting a Kenaanite or inhabitant of Kenaan. By implication, it can also refer to a pedlar, as the Canaanites were known for mercantile caravans. These indigenous peoples represented the primary antagonists and the spiritual and physical obstacles Israel was commanded to dispossess. Their continued presence in the "mountain," "south," and "valley" underscores the formidable challenge they posed and the incomplete nature of Israel's initial victories.
These three terms precisely delineate the primary geographical zones within Judah's tribal inheritance, emphasizing the diverse and challenging nature of the conquest. Har, a shortened form of הָרָר, refers to a "mountain or range of hills," often used figuratively, denoting the rugged central highlands. Negeb, from an unused root meaning "to be parched," signifies "the south" (from its drought), specifically the semi-arid southern district of Judah. Shᵉphêlâh, from שָׁפֵL, means "Lowland," referring to the maritime slope of Palestine, or the fertile lowlands and foothills between the central mountains and the coastal plain. The mention of these distinct terrains highlights that the fighting was not confined to one type of landscape but required varied military strategies and persistent effort across the entirety of their promised land.
Verse Breakdown
"And afterward the children of Judah went down to fight"
This phrase indicates a continuation of military operations, following the initial victories described in the preceding verses (e.g., the capture of Jerusalem in Judges 1:8). The verb "went down" (Hebrew: yarad) implies a geographical descent, likely from the higher central highlands where many Israelite settlements were located, into the lower-lying or more distant regions of the Negeb and Shephelah. This signifies a proactive and strategic movement to expand their control.
"against the Canaanites, that dwelt in the mountain"
This clause specifies the first area of engagement. Despite Judah's initial successes in the highlands, pockets of Canaanite resistance remained even in the mountainous regions. This indicates that the conquest was not a clean sweep, but a piecemeal and challenging process, requiring ongoing efforts to secure even their immediate surroundings.
"and in the south"
This refers to the Negeb, the semi-arid southern region of Judah. Fighting here would have presented different challenges than in the mountains, potentially involving more open skirmishes or the securing of water sources and trade routes. It highlights the vastness and diversity of the territory Judah was tasked with conquering.
"and in the valley"
This refers to the Shephelah, the lowlands and foothills between the Judean mountains and the Philistine plain. These valleys were often fertile and strategically important, frequently containing stronger Canaanite cities, some of which possessed chariots (as later implied in Judges 1:19). Securing these areas was crucial for full control of their inheritance but also presented significant military obstacles.
Literary Devices
Judges 1:9 employs several literary techniques that enhance its meaning. The most prominent is Repetition through the listing of the three geographical regions: "mountain," "south," and "valley." This repetition emphasizes the comprehensive scope of Judah's military endeavors, indicating that the fight was not localized but encompassed diverse and challenging terrains across their entire allotted inheritance. This also creates a sense of Merism, where the listing of distinct parts (mountain, south, valley) is used to represent the whole territory of Judah. By mentioning these varied landscapes, the text implicitly highlights the multifaceted nature of the conquest and the different military tactics required. Furthermore, the verse contributes to the overall Narrative Progression of Judges 1, moving from the initial, more general victories to the specific, ongoing challenges. This progression subtly Foreshadows the incomplete nature of the conquest that will become a dominant theme, setting up the subsequent accounts of Israel's failures to fully dispossess the inhabitants.
Theological and Thematic Connections
Judges 1:9 powerfully illustrates that the fulfillment of God's promises often requires persistent human effort and engagement with formidable challenges. Just as Judah had to actively fight to possess the land promised by God, believers today are called to a life of active faith, engaging in spiritual warfare and persevering through trials to "take hold" of the spiritual inheritance and promises given in Christ. The physical conquest of Canaan serves as a tangible metaphor for the ongoing spiritual battle against sin, self, and the forces of evil. God's strength is always available, but it is often manifested through our obedient and diligent participation. The incomplete nature of Judah's conquest also subtly reminds us that human effort, apart from complete reliance on God, will always fall short, highlighting the need for divine intervention and a perfect deliverer.
Reflection and Application
Judges 1:9 offers a profound lesson on the nature of spiritual progress and the Christian walk. Just as the children of Judah faced a protracted and diverse struggle to possess their physical inheritance, so too does the believer encounter an ongoing spiritual battle to fully live out their new identity in Christ and experience the fullness of His promises. This verse reminds us that faith is not a one-time decision but a lifelong journey of active engagement. We must be prepared to fight for holiness in the "mountains" of our pride, the "valleys" of our despair, and the "south" (Negeb) of our spiritual barrenness. The presence of Canaanites in these areas signifies the persistent temptations, sinful habits, and worldly influences that seek to hinder our spiritual growth. Our call is to persevere, relying not on our own strength, but on the power of the Holy Spirit, understanding that securing spiritual ground requires continuous effort, vigilance, and unwavering trust in God's faithfulness.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Why did Judah have to "go down" to fight in these specific areas?
Geographically, the central highlands of Judah, where many Israelite settlements were established, were at a higher elevation. To campaign in the Negeb (the southern arid region) or the Shephelah (the lowlands/valleys to the west), Judah's forces would naturally descend from their mountain strongholds. This "going down" (Hebrew: yarad) signifies a strategic movement from their more secure, elevated positions into different, often more challenging, terrains where the Canaanites were entrenched. It indicates a proactive and necessary expansion of their military efforts to secure their full inheritance, building upon their initial successes like the capture of Jerusalem described in Judges 1:8.
What does this verse tell us about the nature of the conquest of Canaan?
Judges 1:9 vividly illustrates that the conquest of Canaan was far from a swift or singular event. Instead, it was a protracted, difficult, and ongoing process. Despite God's promise and earlier victories under Joshua, the land was not simply handed over. It required sustained military campaigns against entrenched enemies across diverse and challenging terrains—from rugged mountains to arid deserts and fertile valleys. This verse highlights the reality of persistent Canaanite resistance and the need for continuous Israelite effort, foreshadowing the incomplete nature of the conquest that would have profound theological and historical implications for Israel, as further detailed throughout the book of Judges.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
While Judges 1:9 describes Judah's physical conquest of Canaan, it ultimately points to the greater spiritual conquest achieved by Jesus Christ. Just as Judah "went down" from their mountain strongholds to fight, Christ, the ultimate warrior, "came down" from heaven, humbling Himself to take on human flesh (Philippians 2:6-8). He engaged in a decisive battle not against flesh and blood, but against sin, death, and the spiritual forces of evil, triumphing over them on the cross (Colossians 2:15). His victory on the cross and resurrection was the ultimate "dispossession" of the enemy, securing for us a spiritual inheritance far greater than any earthly land (Ephesians 1:3). While His victory is complete, believers are called to participate in the ongoing spiritual battle, empowered by His finished work. The "mountains, south, and valleys" of Judah's struggle can be seen as types of the diverse spiritual challenges we face, which are overcome not by our own might, but by the power of the Spirit working through us as we walk in obedience to our conquering King (Romans 8:37). The incomplete conquest of Judah underscores humanity's inability to fully secure God's promises without a perfect deliverer, a role perfectly fulfilled by Christ, who will ultimately establish His kingdom in its fullness, bringing about the new heavens and new earth where righteousness dwells (Revelation 21:1-4).