Skip to content
“Dispute Over Greatness”· Luke 22:24–30
Translation
King James Version
Ye are they which have continued with me in my temptations.
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
G1161 Ye G5210 are G2075 they which have continued G1265 with G3326 me G1700 in G1722 my G3450 temptations G3986.
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
“You are the ones who have stayed with me throughout my trials.
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
You are the ones who have stood by Me in My trials.
Ask
American Standard Version
But ye are they that have continued with me in my temptations;
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
But you are those who have continued with me in my trials.
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
And yee are they which haue continued with me in my tentations.
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
`And ye--ye are those who have remained with me in my temptations,
Ask
See on the biblical-era map
All Luke Sites (Jerusalem)
All Luke Sites (Jerusalem) View full PDF
All Luke Sites (Levant)
All Luke Sites (Levant) View full PDF
All Luke Sites (Eastern Mediterranean)
All Luke Sites (Eastern Mediterranean) View full PDF

Map © Biblica Open Bible Maps · CC BY-SA 4.0

In the KJVVerse 25,893 of 31,102 · 83.3%

Study This Verse

Summary

In Luke 22:28, Jesus offers a profound and tender affirmation to His disciples during the Last Supper, acknowledging their steadfast perseverance and loyalty in the face of the numerous trials and adversities He Himself endured throughout His earthly ministry. This commendation comes at a pivotal moment, just before His betrayal and crucifixion, highlighting the unique bond He shared with His closest followers despite their human frailties and recent disputes, setting the stage for their future roles in His kingdom.

Context

Literary Context

This verse is situated within the highly charged narrative of Jesus' final hours before His crucifixion. It immediately follows the institution of the Lord's Supper (Luke 22:14-20) and, significantly, a dispute among the disciples about who among them was the greatest (Luke 22:24). In stark contrast to their self-serving argument, Jesus shifts the focus from their imperfection to their past faithfulness, commending their consistent presence. This affirmation then leads directly into Jesus' promise of a kingdom and authority to them (Luke 22:29-30), underscoring that true greatness in His kingdom is tied to humble service and enduring loyalty, not earthly status.

Historical & Cultural Context

The setting is the Passover meal, a deeply significant event for Jewish people, commemorating their liberation from slavery in Egypt. This backdrop imbues Jesus' words with profound covenantal weight. Discipleship in the ancient world involved a close, often lifelong, commitment to a teacher, following them, learning from them, and adopting their way of life. Jesus' ministry was marked by constant opposition from religious authorities, political pressures from the Roman occupation, and the general hardships of itinerant preaching. His "temptations" were not merely internal struggles against sin but encompassed the relentless external pressures, threats, and attempts to derail His mission, including the wilderness temptations (Luke 4:1-13) and ongoing hostility. The disciples' decision to remain with Him, despite these dangers and the social ostracization that often accompanied association with Jesus, was a significant act of loyalty.

Key Themes

This verse powerfully contributes to several overarching themes in Luke's Gospel and the broader biblical narrative. It highlights the faithfulness and perseverance of true discipleship, demonstrating that despite human flaws (as seen in their recent argument), consistent presence and loyalty are highly valued by Christ. It also underscores Christ's own suffering and trials, revealing His profound empathy as one who was "tempted in every respect as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15). The commendation serves as a divine affirmation of His chosen ones, a powerful word of encouragement that would be crucial for them as they faced the impending trauma of His crucifixion and the challenging mission ahead. Furthermore, it subtly connects their present faithfulness to their future reward and authority in the kingdom, a theme explicitly developed in the subsequent verses of Luke 22.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

continued diaménō' G1265

Derived from dia (through) and menō (to remain, abide), this word signifies staying constantly, enduring, or persevering without deviation. It implies a sustained presence and unwavering commitment over time, emphasizing the disciples' steadfastness throughout the entirety of Jesus' challenging ministry rather than just isolated moments.

with metá' G3326

This preposition denotes accompaniment or association. In this context, it highlights the intimate and participatory nature of the disciples' relationship with Jesus. They were not merely observers but active companions, sharing in His journey, His experiences, and implicitly, His burdens.

temptations peirasmós' G3986

From peirazō (to test, try), this term refers to a putting to proof, often through adversity, trials, or solicitations. While it can mean enticement to sin, in the context of Jesus' experience, it primarily denotes the intense external pressures, severe testings, and profound sufferings He endured throughout His ministry, all designed to challenge His resolve and deter Him from His divine mission.

Verse Breakdown

"Ye are they which have continued with me"

Jesus directly addresses His disciples, affirming their unique status and role. The phrase "have continued with me" uses the perfect tense in Greek, emphasizing a completed action with ongoing results—their loyalty was not a one-time event but a consistent pattern throughout His public ministry. This highlights their enduring companionship and steadfastness, even when others abandoned Him or when circumstances were difficult. It underscores a personal, intimate relationship of shared experience.

"in my temptations"

This crucial phrase specifies the context of their faithfulness. Jesus is not referring to His disciples' temptations, but His own. These "temptations" (or trials/testings) encompass the full spectrum of opposition, suffering, and pressure Jesus faced: from the wilderness temptations by Satan, through the constant scrutiny and hostility of religious leaders, the misunderstanding of the crowds, the burden of His mission, and the looming shadow of the cross. The disciples' "continuing with Him" meant sharing in the reproach, the danger, and the hardship that accompanied His ministry, demonstrating a loyalty that transcended mere curiosity or fleeting enthusiasm.

Literary Devices

Luke's rendering of Jesus' words employs several powerful literary devices. Affirmation is central, as Jesus directly commends His disciples, validating their commitment despite their recent failings. There is a strong element of Contrast between the disciples' petty dispute over greatness in Luke 22:24 and Jesus' magnanimous recognition of their enduring loyalty in Luke 22:28. This contrast highlights the divine perspective that values faithfulness over self-promotion. The phrase "my temptations" uses Understatement or Litotes (a form of ironic understatement), as it refers to the immense suffering and opposition Jesus endured, which were far more than mere "temptations" in the common sense. It also functions as a form of Empathy, as Jesus, the suffering Messiah, acknowledges the shared burden with His followers. Finally, the verse serves as a subtle Foreshadowing, hinting at the greater trials Jesus is about to face (Gethsemane, arrest, crucifixion) and implicitly inviting His disciples to maintain their steadfastness through those ultimate tests, even though many would falter temporarily.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Luke 22:28 offers profound theological insights into the nature of discipleship and the character of Christ. It reveals that true faithfulness is not about perfection, but about perseverance and consistent presence, even amidst personal flaws and challenging circumstances. Jesus, in His divine wisdom and grace, looks beyond the immediate failings of His disciples to affirm their deeper commitment. This verse also underscores the reality of Christ's own suffering and testing, establishing Him as a High Priest who can truly sympathize with our weaknesses because He has been "tempted in every respect as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15). His commendation of the disciples' loyalty in His trials foreshadows the call for all believers to share in Christ's sufferings (Philippians 3:10) and to endure to the end for the sake of the kingdom.

Reflection and Application

Luke 22:28 serves as a powerful reminder that our journey of faith is not always smooth or without blemish, yet our steadfastness in following Christ, particularly through difficult seasons, is deeply valued by our Lord. Just as Jesus saw past the disciples' recent argument to commend their enduring loyalty, God sees our hearts and recognizes our faithful presence, even when we feel imperfect or our efforts seem small. This verse calls us to a radical commitment to "continue with" Christ, not just in times of ease, but especially "in His temptations"—that is, by standing with His truth, His values, and His mission even when it brings us into conflict with the world, or when we face personal trials for His name's sake. Our willingness to remain by His side, to bear reproach for Him, and to persevere in our faith demonstrates a love and loyalty that reflects His own enduring faithfulness to us. It offers profound encouragement to the weary, assuring us that our fidelity is seen and will be honored by the One who endured the ultimate test for our salvation.

Questions for Reflection

  1. In what specific ways have you "continued with" Christ during your own "temptations" or trials?
  2. How does knowing that Jesus Himself endured "temptations" deepen your empathy for Him and strengthen your resolve to follow Him?
  3. What areas of your life might God be calling you to greater perseverance or steadfastness in your commitment to Him?

FAQ

What does Jesus mean by "my temptations" in this verse?

When Jesus speaks of "my temptations" (Greek: peirasmós), He is referring to the continuous and intense trials, testings, and adversities He faced throughout His earthly ministry. These were not temptations to sin in the way humans experience them, but rather external pressures and internal struggles designed to challenge His resolve, deflect Him from His divine mission, or cause Him to deviate from the Father's will. This includes the wilderness temptations by Satan (Luke 4:1-13), the constant opposition and hostility from religious leaders, the misunderstanding of the crowds, the burden of His impending suffering and death, and the spiritual agony He would soon experience in Gethsemane. The disciples "continued with Him" by remaining loyal companions through these challenging circumstances.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

Luke 22:28, while a commendation of the disciples, ultimately points to the greater faithfulness of Christ Himself. Jesus' "temptations" were not merely personal struggles but the very means by which He perfectly fulfilled His redemptive mission. He alone "continued" in absolute obedience to the Father, even unto death on the cross (Philippians 2:8). His endurance through every trial, from the wilderness to Gethsemane, qualified Him as the perfect High Priest, one who can "sympathize with our weaknesses, for we have not a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15). The disciples' limited perseverance foreshadows the call for all believers to share in Christ's sufferings (Romans 8:17), but it is Christ's perfect, unwavering steadfastness that ultimately secures our salvation. He is the true embodiment of faithfulness, whose victory over all temptations and trials enables us, by His grace, to also "continue with Him" and ultimately inherit the kingdom He has prepared (Revelation 3:21).

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Luke 22:21–38. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 18 verses
Passage under commentLuke 22:21–38
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

We have here Christ's discourse with his disciples after supper, much of which is new here; and in St. John's gospel we shall find other additions. We should take example from him to entertain and edify our family and friends with such discourse at table as is good and to the use of edifying, which may minister grace to the hearers; but especially after we have been at the Lord's table, by Christian conference to keep one another in a suitable frame. The matters Christ here discoursed of were of weight, and to the present purpose.

I.He discoursed with them concerning him that should betray him, who was now present.

1.He signifies to them that the traitor was now among them, and one of them, Luk 22:21. By placing this after the institution of the Lord's supper, though in Matthew and Mark it is placed before it, it seems plain that Judas did receive the Lord's supper, did eat of that bread and drink of that cup; for, after the solemnity was over, Christ said, Behold, the hand of him that betrayeth me is with me on the table. There have been those that have eaten bread with Christ and yet have betrayed him.

2.He foretels that the treason would take effect (Luk 22:22): Truly the Son of man goes as it was determined, goes to the place where he will be betrayed; for he is delivered up by the counsel and foreknowledge of God, else Judas could not have delivered him up. Christ was not driven to his sufferings, but cheerfully went to them. He said, Lo, I come.

3.He threatens the traitor: Woe to that man by whom he is betrayed. Note, Neither the patience of the saints under their sufferings, nor the counsel of God concerning their sufferings, will be any excuse for those that have any hand in their sufferings, or that persecute them. Though God has determined that Christ shall be betrayed and he himself has cheerfully submitted to it, yet Judas's sin or punishment is not at all the less.

4.He frightens the rest of the disciples into a suspicion of themselves, by saying that it was one of them, and not naming which (Luk 22:23): They began to enquire among themselves, to interrogate themselves, to put the question to themselves, who it was that should do this thing, that could be so base to so good a Master. The enquiry was not, Is it you? or, Is it such a one? but, Is it I?

II.Concerning the strife that was among them for precedency or supremacy.

1.See what the dispute was: Which of them should be accounted the greatest. Such and so many contests among the disciples for dignity and dominion, before the Spirit was poured upon them, were a sad presage of the like strifes for, and affections of, supremacy in the churches, after the Spirit should be provoked to depart from them. How inconsistent is this with that in the verse before! There they were enquiring which would be the traitor, and here which should be the prince. Could such an instance of humility, and such an instance of pride and vanity, be found in the same men, so near together? This is like sweet waters and bitter proceeding at the same time out of the same fountain. What a self-contradiction is the deceitful heart of man!

2.See what Christ said to this dispute. He was not sharp upon them, as might have been expected (he having so often reproved them for this very thing), but mildly showed them the sin and folly of it.

(1.)This was to make themselves like the kings of the Gentiles, who affect worldly pomp, and worldly power, Luk 22:25. They exercise lordship over their subjects, and are ever and anon striving to exercise lordship too over the princes that are about them, though as good as themselves, if they think them not so strong as themselves. Note, The exercising of lordship better becomes the kings of the Gentiles than the ministers of Christ. But observe, They that exercise authority, and take upon themselves to bear sway, and give law, they are called Benefactors - Euergetas, they call themselves so, and so their flatterers call them, and those that set themselves to serve their interests. It is pretended that they have been benefactors, and upon that account they should be admitted to have rule; nay, that in exercising authority they are benefactors. However they may really serve themselves, they would be thought to serve their country. One of the Ptolemies was surnamed Euergetes - The Benefactor. Now our Saviour, by taking notice of this, intimates,

[1.]That to do good is much more honourable than to look great; for these princes that were the terror of the mighty would not be called so, but rather the benefactors of the needy; so that, by their own confession, a benefactor to his country is much more valued than a ruler of his country.

[2.]That to do good is the surest way to be great, else they that aimed to be rulers would not have been so solicitous to be called Benefactors. This therefore he would have his disciples believe, that their greatest honour would be to do all the good they could in the world. They would indeed be benefactors to the world, by bringing the gospel to it. Let them value themselves upon that title, which they would indeed be entitled to, and then they need not strive which should be the greatest, for they would all be greater - greater blessings to mankind than the kings of the earth, that exercise lordship over them. If they have that which is confessedly the greater honour, of being benefactors, let them despise the less, of being rulers.

(2.)It was to make themselves unlike the disciples of Christ, and unlike Christ himself: "You shall not be so," Luk 22:26, Luk 22:27. "It was never intended that you should rule any otherwise than by the power of truth and grace, but that you should serve." When church-rulers affect external pomp and power, and bear up themselves by secular interests and influences, they debase their office, and it is an instance of degeneracy like that of Israel when they would have a king like the nations that were round about them, whereas the Lord was their King. See here,

[1.]What is the rule Christ gave to his disciples: He that is greater among you, that is senior, to whom precedency is due upon the account of his age, let him be as the younger, both in point of lowness of place (let him condescend to sit with the younger, and be free and familiar with them) and in point of labour and work. We say, Juniores ad labores, seniores ad honores - Let the young work, and the aged receive their honours. But let the elder take pains as well as the younger; their age and honour, instead of warranting them to take their ease, bind them to double work. And he that is chief, ho hēgoumenos - the president of the college or assembly, let him be as he that serves, hōs ho diakonōn - as the deacon; let him stoop to the meanest and most toilsome services for the public good, if there be occasion.

[2.]What was the example which he himself gave to this rule: Whether is greater, he that sitteth at meat or he that serveth? he that attendeth or he that is attended on? Now Christ was among his disciples just like one that waited at table. He was so far from taking state, or taking his ease, by commanding their attendance upon him, that he was ready to do any office of kindness and service for them; witness his washing their feet. Shall those take upon them the form of princes who call themselves followers of him that took upon him the form of a servant?

(3.)They ought not to strive for worldly honour and grandeur, because he had better honours in reserve for them, of another nature, a kingdom, a feast, a throne, for each of them, wherein they should all share alike, and should have no occasion to strive for precedency, Luk 22:28-30. Where observe,

[1.]Christ's commendation of his disciples for their faithfulness to him; and this was honour enough for them, they needed not to strive for any greater. It is spoken with an air of encomium and applause: "You are they who have continued with me in my temptations, you are they who have stood by me and stuck to me when others have deserted me and turned their backs upon me." Christ had his temptations; he was despised and rejected of men, reproached and reviled, and endured the contradiction of sinners. But his disciples continued with him, and were afflicted in all his afflictions. It was but little help that they could give him, or service that they could do him; nevertheless, he took it kindly that they continued with him, and he here owns their kindness, though it was by the assistance of his own grace that they did continue. Christ's disciples had been very defective in their duty. We find them guilty of many mistakes and weaknesses: they were very dull and very forgetful, and often blundered, yet their Master passes all by and forgets it; he does not upbraid them with their infirmities, but gives them this memorable testimonial, You are they who have continued with me. Thus does he praise at parting, to show how willing he is to make the best of those whose hearts he knows to be upright with him.

[2.]The recompence he designed them for their fidelity: I appoint, diatithemai, I bequeath, unto you a kingdom. Or thus, I appoint to you, as my Father has appointed a kingdom to me, that you may eat and drink at my table. Understand it, First, Of what should be done for them in this world. God gave his Son a kingdom among men, the gospel church, of which he is the living, quickening, ruling, Head. This kingdom he appointed to his apostles and their successors in the ministry of the gospel, that they should enjoy the comforts and privileges of the gospel, help to communicate them to others by gospel ordinances, sit on thrones as officers of the church, not only declaratively, but exhortatively judging the tribes of Israel that persist in their infidelity, and denouncing the wrath of God against them, and ruling the gospel Israel, the spiritual Israel, by the instituted discipline of the church, administered with gentleness and love. This is the honour reserved for you. Or, Secondly, Of what should be done for them in the other world, which I take to be chiefly meant. Let them go on in their services in this world; their preferments shall be in the other world. God will give them the kingdom, in which they shall be sure to have, 1. The richest dainties; for they shall eat and drink at Christ's table in his kingdom, of which he had spoken, Luk 22:16, Luk 22:18. They shall partake of those joys and pleasures which were the recompence of his services and sufferings. They shall have a full satisfaction of soul in the vision and fruition of God; and herein they shall have the best society, as at a feast, in the perfection of love. 2. The highest dignities: "You shall not only be provided for at the royal table, as Mephibosheth at David's, but you shall be preferred to the royal throne; shall sit down with me on my throne, Rev 3:21. In the great day you shall sit on thrones, as assessors with Christ, to approve of and applaud his judgment of the twelve tribes of Israel." If the saints shall judge the world (Co1 6:2), much more the church.

III.Concerning Peter's denying him. And in this part of the discourse we may observe,

1.The general notice Christ gives to Peter of the devil's design upon him and the rest of the apostles (Luk 22:31): The Lord said, Simon, Simon, observe what I say; Satan hath desired to have you, to have you all in his hands, that he may sift you as wheat. Peter, who used to be the mouth of the rest in speaking to Christ, is here made the ear of the rest; and what is designed for warning to them all (all you shall be offended, because of me) is directed to Peter, because he was principally concerned, being in particular manner struck at by the tempter: Satan has desired to have you. Probably Satan had accused the disciples to God as mercenary in following Christ, and aiming at nothing else therein but enriching and advancing themselves in this world, as he accused Job. "No," saith God, "they are honest men, and men of integrity." "Give me leave to try them," saith Satan, "and Peter particularly." He desired to have them, that he might sift them, that he might show them to be chaff, and not wheat. The troubles that were now coming upon them were sifting, would try what there was in them: but this was not all; Satan desired to sift them by his temptations, and endeavoured by those troubles to draw them into sin, to put them into a loss and hurry, as corn when it is sifted to bring the chaff uppermost, or rather to shake out the wheat and leave nothing but the chaff. Observe, Satan could not sift them unless God gave him leave: He desired to have them, as he begged of God a permission to try and tempt Job. Exētēsato - "He has challenged you, has undertaken to prove you a company of hypocrites, and Peter especially, the forwardest of you." Some suggest that Satan demanded leave to sift them as their punishment for striving who should be greatest, in which contest Peter perhaps was very warm: "Leave them to me, to sift them for it."

2.The particular encouragement he gave to Peter, in reference to this trial: "I have prayed for thee, because, though he desires to have them all, he is permitted to make his strongest onset upon thee only: thou wilt be most violently assaulted, but I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not, that it may not totally and finally fail." Note,

(1.)If faith be kept up in an hour of temptation, though we may fall, yet we shall not be utterly cast down. Faith will quench Satan's fiery darts.

(2.)Though there may be many failings in the faith of true believers, yet there shall not be a total and final failure of their faith. It is their seed, their root, remaining in them.

(3.)It is owing to the mediation and intercession of Jesus Christ that the faith of his disciples, though sometimes sadly shaken, yet is not sunk. If they were left to themselves, they would fail; but they are kept by the power of God and the prayer of Christ. The intercession of Christ is not only general, for all that believe, but for particular believers (I have prayed for thee), which is an encouragement for us to pray for ourselves, and an engagement upon us to pray for others too.

3.The charge he gives to Peter to help others as he should himself be helped of God: "When thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren; when thou art recovered by the grace of God, and brought to repentance, do what thou canst to recover others; when thou hast found they faith kept from failing, labour to confirm the faith of others, and to establish them; when thou hast found mercy with God thyself, encourage others to hope that they also shall find mercy." Note,

(1.)Those that have fallen into sin must be converted from it; those that have turned aside must return; those that have left their first love must do their first works.

(2.)Those that through grace are converted from sin must do what they can to strengthen their brethren that stand, and to prevent their falling; see Psa 51:11-13; Ti1 1:13.

4.Peter's declared resolution to cleave to Christ, whatever it cost him (Luk 22:33): Lord, I am ready to go with thee, both into prison and to death. This was a great word, and yet I believe no more than he meant at this time, and thought he should make good too. Judas never protested thus against denying Christ, though often warned of it; for his heart was as fully set in him to the evil as Peter's was against it. Note, All the true disciples of Christ sincerely desire and design to follow him, whithersoever he goes, and whithersoever he leads them, though into a prison, though out of the world.

5.Christ's express prediction of his denying him thrice (Luk 22:34): "I tell thee, Peter (thou dost not know thine own heart, but must be left to thyself a little, that thou mayest know it, and mayest never trust to it again), the cock shall not crow this day before thou even deny that thou knowest me." Note, Christ knows us better than we know ourselves, and knows the evil that is in us, and will be done by us, which we ourselves do not suspect. It is well for us that Christ knows where we are weak better than we do, and therefore where to come in with grace sufficient; that he knows how far a temptation will prevail, and therefore when to say, Hitherto shall it come, and no further.

IV.Concerning the condition of all the disciples.

1.He appeals to them concerning what had been, Luk 22:35. He had owned that they had been faithful servants to him, Luk 22:28. Now he expects, at parting, that they should acknowledge that he had been a kind and careful Master to them ever since they left all to follow him: When I sent you without purse, lacked you any thing?

(1.)He owns that he had sent them out in a very poor and bare condition, barefoot, and with no money in their purses, because they were not to go far, nor be out long; and he would thus teach them to depend upon the providence of God, and, under that, upon the kindness of their friends. If God thus send us out into the world, let us remember that better than we have thus begun low.

(2.)Yet ye will have them own that, notwithstanding this, they had lacked nothing; they then lived as plentifully and comfortably as ever; and they readily acknowledged it: "Nothing, Lord; I have all, and abound." Note,

[1.]It is good for us often to review the providences of God that have been concerning us all our days, and to observe how we have got through the straits and difficulties we have met with.

[2.]Christ is a good Master, and his service a good service; for though his servants may sometimes be brought low, yet he will help them; and though he try them, yet will he not leave them. Jehovah-jireh.

[3.]We must reckon ourselves well done by, and must not complain, but be thankful, if we have had the necessary supports of life, though we have had neither dainties nor superfluities, though we have lived from hand to mouth, and lived upon the kindness of our friends. The disciples lived upon contribution, and yet did not complain that their maintenance was precarious, but owned, to their Master's honour, that it was sufficient; they had wanted nothing.

2.He gives them notice of a very great change of their circumstances now approaching. For,

(1.)He that was their Master was now entering upon his sufferings, which he had often foretold (Luk 22:37): "Now that which is written must be fulfilled in me, and this among the rest, He was numbered among the transgressors - he must suffer and die as a malefactor, and in company with some of the vilest of malefactors. This is that which is yet to be accomplished, after all the rest, and then the things concerning me, the things written concerning me, will have an end; then I shall say, It is finished." Note, It may be the comfort of suffering Christians, as it was of a suffering Christ, that their sufferings were foretold, and determined in the counsels of heaven, and will shortly determine in the joys of heaven. They were written concerning them, and they will have an end, and will end well, everlastingly well.

(2.)They must therefore expect troubles, and must not think now to have such an easy and comfortable life as they had had; no, the scene will alter. They must now in some degree suffer with their Master; and, when he is gone, they must expect to suffer like him. The servant is not better than his Lord.

[1.]They must not now expect that their friends would be so kind and generous to them as they had been; and therefore, He that has a purse, let him take it, for he may have occasion for it, and for all the good husbandry he can use.

[2.]They must now expect that their enemies would be more fierce upon them than they had been, and they would need magazines as well as stores: He that has no sword wherewith to defend himself against robbers and assassins (Co2 11:26) will find a great want of it, and will be ready to wish, some time or other, that he had sold his garment and bought one. This is intended only to show that the times would be very perilous, so that no man would think himself safe if he had not a sword by his side. But the sword of the Spirit is the sword which the disciples of Christ must furnish themselves with. Christ having suffered for us, we must arm ourselves with the same mind (Pe1 4:1), arm ourselves with an expectation of trouble, that it may not be a surprise to us, and with a holy resignation to the will of God in it, that there may be no opposition in us to it: and then we are better prepared than if we had sold a coat to buy a sword. The disciples hereupon enquire what strength they had, and find they had among them two swords (Luk 22:38), of which one was Peter's. The Galileans generally travelled with swords. Christ wore none himself, but he was not against his disciples' wearing them. But he intimates how little he would have them depend upon this when he saith, It is enough, which some think is spoken ironically: "Two swords among twelve men! you are bravely armed indeed when our enemies are now coming out against us in great multitudes, and every one with a sword!" Yet two swords are sufficient for those who need none, having God himself to be the shield of their help and the sword of their excellency, Deu 33:29.

Copy as

Historical interpretation

Nine Centuries of Reception

10 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

10 quotes · AD 220–1107
Ante-NicenePost-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
20030040050060070080090010001100

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

AD 220TertullianAnte-NiceneSourceOn Baptism
And the reason, I believe, why they were tempted was, that they fell asleep; so that they deserted the Lord when apprehended, and he who continued to stand by Him, and used the sword, even denied Him thrice: for withal the word had gone before, that "no one untempted should attain the celestial kingdoms." The Lord Himself forthwith after baptism temptations surrounded, when in forty days He had kept fast.
AD 220TertullianAnte-NiceneSourceOn Idolatry
For avoiding it, remedies cannot be lacking; since, even if they be lacking, there remains that one by which you will be made a happier magistrate, not in the earth, but in the heavens.
The kingdom of God is not of this world. Therefore, the equality of man to God is not possible, but rather an emulation of similarity. For only Christ is the perfect image of God, because of the unity of the expressed glory of the Father in Him. But a just man is in the image of God, if, for the purpose of imitating the likeness of divine conduct, he despises this world through knowledge of God and looks down upon earthly pleasures through the perception of the word of God, by which we are nourished unto life. And so we partake of the body of Christ, that we may be partakers of eternal life. For it is not food and drink that are promised to us as rewards and honors, but the sharing of heavenly grace and life. And the twelve thrones, as described, are not physical receptacles for sitting, but because just as Christ, according to his divine likeness, judges by the knowledge of hearts and not by questioning deeds, rewarding virtue and condemning impiety, so too the apostles are formed in spiritual judgment by the reward of faith and the condemnation of perfidy, refuting error with their power and pursuing sacrilege with hatred.
AD 397Ambrose of Milanas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
The kingdom of God is not of this world, But it is not equality with God, but likeness to Him, unto which man must aspire. For Christ alone is the full image of God, on account of the unity of His Father's glory expressed in Him. But the righteous man is after the image of God, if for the sake of imitating the likeness of the Divine conversation, He through the knowledge of God despises the world. Therefore also we eat the Body and Blood of Christ, that we may be partakers of eternal life. Whence it follows, That ye may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom. For the reward promised to us is not food and drink, but the communication of heavenly grace and life.

But the twelve thrones are not as it were any resting-places for the bodily posture, but because since Christ judges after the Divine likeness by knowledge of the hearts, not by examination of the actions, rewarding virtue, condemning iniquity; so the Apostles are appointed to a spiritual judgment, for the rewarding of faith, the condemnation of unbelief, repelling error with virtue, inflicting vengeance on the sacrilegious.
AD 407John Chrysostomas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
(Hom. 64. in Matt.) What then will Judas also sit there? Observe what the law was which God gave by Jeremiah, If I have promised any good, and thou art counted unworthy of it, I will punish you. (Jerem. 18:10.) Therefore speaking to His disciples He did not make a general promise, but added, Ye who have continued with me in my temptations.
AD 444Cyril of Alexandriaas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
By means of the things of our present life He describes spiritual things. For they exercise a high privilege with earthly kings, who sit at their table as guests. So then by man's estimation He shows who shall be rewarded by Him with the greatest honours.
AD 444Cyril of AlexandriaPost-NiceneSourceCOMMENTARY ON LUKE, HOMILY 143
The Savior therefore drives away from the holy apostles the affliction of pride. They might perhaps think among themselves and even say, “What will be the reward of faithfulness? What advantage shall we, who have waited on Christ, receive when temptations happen from time to time?” Confirmed by the hope of the blessings that are in store, they throw away from their minds all laziness in virtuous pursuits. They rather choose with an eager mind to follow him and take pleasure in labor for his sake. They also count the doing it a cause of gain, the pathway of joy, and the means of eternal glory.
AD 735Bedeas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Early MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
For not the first effort of patience, but long-continued perseverance, is rewarded with the glory of the heavenly kingdom, for perseverance, (which is called constancy or fortitude of mind,) is, so to say, the pillar and prop of all virtues. The Son of God then conducts those who abide with Him in His temptations to the everlasting kingdom. For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection. (Rom. 6:5.) Hence it follows, And I give to you a kingdom, &c.

Or the table offered to all saints richly to enjoy is the glory of a heavenly life, wherewith they who hunger and thirst after righteousness shall be filled, resting in the long-desired enjoyment of the true God. (Matt. 5:6.)

This then is the exchange to the right hand of the Most High, (Ps. 118:15.) that those who now in lowliness rejoice to minister to their fellow-servants, shall then at our Lord's table on high be fed with the banquet of everlasting life, and they who here in temptations abide with the Lord being unjustly judged, shall then come with Him as just judges upon their tempters. Hence it follows, And sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel.

From the high excellence of this promise Judas is excluded. For before the Lord said this, Judas must be supposed to have gone out. They also are excluded whoever having heard the words of the incomprehensible Sacrament, have gone backwards. (John 6:67.)
AD 735BedeEarly MedievalSourceOn the Gospel of Luke
You are those who have remained with me in my trials, and I appoint to you, as my Father appointed to me, a kingdom. Not the beginning of patience, but perseverance is granted the glory of the heavenly kingdom. Because, indeed, perseverance, which is called constancy by another name, is a certain strength and fortitude of mind, and (so to speak) the pillar of all virtues. When it stands well upright and firm, nothing is more certain, nothing safer for good morals. But if it is thrown down by any storm, it does not fall alone; for indeed, all the goods of the soul collapse together. Therefore, as the Father appointed to the Son the kingdom, who was made obedient to death, even the death of the cross, exalted him, and gave him a name that is above every name (Philippians 2), so also the Son will lead those who remain with him in the trials to the eternal kingdom. For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall also be in the likeness of his resurrection (Romans 6). From the height of whose promise the unhappy Judas is excluded. For even before the Lord spoke these things, he is believed to have gone out. He not only spurned to remain with Him in the trials but also helped the authors of his trials. Those who, having heard the words of the incomprehensible sacrament, went back and no longer walked with Him, are also excluded. For there are none who have departed from the Lord, except those who returned repenting, who could be saved.
AD 1107Theophylact of Ohridas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
As the Lord had denounced woe to the traitor, so on the other hand to the rest of the disciples He promises blessings, saying, Ye are they which have continued with me, &c.

He said this not as if they would have there bodily food, or as if His kingdom were to be a sensible one. For their life then shall be the life of angels, as He before told the Sadducees. (Mat. 22:30, Luke 20:36) But Paul also says that the kingdom of God is not meat and drink. (Rom. 14:17.)

That is, the unbelievers condemned out of the twelve tribes.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Luke 22:28 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.