John 18:15
“Peter Denies Jesus”John 18:15–27
Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain
Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain
Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain
Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain
Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain
Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain
Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain
- ἨκολούθειĒkoloutheiWere followingG190V-IAI-3SVerb Imperfect Active Indicative 3rd Singular
- δὲdenowG1161CONJConjunction
- τῷtō[the]G3588T-DSMDefinite article Dative Singular Masculine
- ἸησοῦIēsouafter JesusG2424N-DSM-PNoun Dative Singular Masculine Individual
- ΣίμωνSimōnSimonG4613N-NSM-PNoun Nominative Singular Masculine Individual
- ΠέτροςPetrosPeterG4074N-NSM-PNoun Nominative Singular Masculine Individual
- καὶkaiandG2532CONJConjunction
- ὁhotheG3588T-NSMDefinite article Nominative Singular Masculine
- ἄλλοςallosotherG243A-NSMAdjective Nominative Singular Masculine
- μαθητήςmathētēsdiscipleG3101N-NSMNoun Nominative Singular Masculine
- ὁhotheG3588T-NSMDefinite article Nominative Singular Masculine
- δὲdeNowG1161CONJConjunction
- μαθητὴςmathētēsdiscipleG3101N-NSMNoun Nominative Singular Masculine
- ἐκεῖνοςekeinosthat [one]G1565D-NSMDemonstrative pronoun Nominative Singular Masculine
- ἦνēnwasG1510V-IAI-3SVerb Imperfect Active Indicative 3rd Singular
- γνωστὸςgnōstosknownG1110A-NSMAdjective Nominative Singular Masculine
- τῷtōto theG3588T-DSMDefinite article Dative Singular Masculine
- ἀρχιερεῖarchiereihigh priestG749N-DSMNoun Dative Singular Masculine
- καὶkaialsoG2532CONJConjunction
- συνεισῆλθενsuneisēlthenhe entered withG4897V-2AAI-3SVerb 2nd Aorist Active Indicative 3rd Singular
- τῷtō[the]G3588T-DSMDefinite article Dative Singular Masculine
- ἸησοῦIēsouJesusG2424N-DSM-PNoun Dative Singular Masculine Individual
- εἰςeisintoG1519PREPPreposition
- τὴνtēntheG3588T-ASFDefinite article Accusative Singular Feminine
- αὐλὴνaulēncourtG833N-ASFNoun Accusative Singular Feminine
- τοῦtouof theG3588T-GSMDefinite article Genitive Singular Masculine
- ἀρχιερέωςarchiereōshigh priestG749N-GSMNoun Genitive Singular Masculine
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Greek, not the KJV's wording. Why?
This is the Greek text the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Greek word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “charity” where the word-by-word meaning reads “love”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Greek. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.
Words in [ ] are added by the English.
Details
See on the biblical-era maps



Study this verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers John 18:13–27. He set out his notes in a four-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.
We have here an account of Christ's arraignment before the high priest, and some circumstances that occurred therein which were omitted by the other evangelists; and Peter's denying him, which the other evangelists had given the story of entire by itself, is interwoven with the other passages. The crime laid to his charge having relation to religion, the judges of the spiritual court took it to fall directly under their cognizance. Both Jews and Gentiles seized him, and so both Jews and Gentiles tried and condemned him, for he died for the sins of both. Let us go over the story in order.
I.Having seized him, they led him away to Annas first, before they brought him to the court that was sat, expecting him, in the house of Caiaphas, v. 13. 1. They led him away, led him in triumph, as a trophy of their victory; led him as a lamb to the slaughter, and they led him through the sheep-gate spoken of Neh. iii. 1. For through that they went from the mount of Olives into Jerusalem. They hurried him away with violence, as if he had been the worst and vilest of malefactors. We had been led away of our own impetuous lusts, and led captive by Satan at his will, and, that we might be rescued, Christ was led away, led captive by Satan's agents and instruments. 2. They led him away to their masters that sent them. It was now about midnight, and one would think they should have put him in ward (Lev. xxiv. 12), should have led him to some prison, till it was a proper time to call a court; but he is hurried away immediately, not to the justices of peace, to be committed, but to the judges to be condemned; so extremely violent was the prosecution, partly because they feared a rescue, which they would thus not only leave no time for, but give a terror to; partly because they greedily thirsted after Christ's blood, as the eagle that hasteth to the prey. 3. They led him to Annas first. Probably his house lay in the way, and was convenient for them to call at to refresh themselves, and, as some think, to be paid for their service. I suppose Annas was old and infirm, and could not be present in council with the rest at that time of night, and yet earnestly desired to see the prey. To gratify him therefore with the assurance of their success, that the old man might sleep the better, and to receive his blessing for it, they produce their prisoner before him. It is sad to see those that are old and sickly, when they cannot commit sin as formerly, taking pleasure in those that do. Dr. Lightfoot thinks Annas was not present, because he had to attend early that morning in the temple, to examine the sacrifices which were that day to be offered, whether they were without blemish; if so, there was a significancy in it, that Christ, the great sacrifice, was presented to him, and sent away bound, as approved and ready for the altar. 4. This Annas was father-in-law to Caiaphas the high priest; this kindred by marriage between them comes in as a reason either why Caiaphas ordered that this piece of respect should be done to Annas, to favour him with the first sight of the prisoner, or why Annas was willing to countenance Caiaphas in a matter his heart was so much upon. Note, Acquaintance and alliance with wicked people are a great confirmation to many in their wicked ways.
II.Annas did not long detain them, being as willing as any of them to have the prosecution pushed on, and therefore sent him bound to Caiaphas, to his house, which was appointed for the rendezvous of the sanhedrim upon this occasion, or to the usual place in the temple where the high priest kept his court; this is mentioned, v. 24. But our translators intimate in the margin that it should come in here, and, accordingly, read it there, Annas had sent him. Observe here,
1.The power of Caiaphas intimated (v. 13). He was high priest that same year. The high priest's commission was during life; but there were now such frequent changes, by the Simoniacal artifices of aspiring men with the government, that it was become almost an annual office, a presage of its final period approaching; while they were undermining one another. God was overturning them all, that he might come whose right it was. Caiaphas was high priest that same year when Messiah was to be cut off, which intimates,
(1.)That when a bad thing was to be done by a high priest, according to the foreknowledge of God, Providence so ordered it that a bad man should be in the chair to do it.
(2.)That, when God would make it to appear what corruption there was in the heart of a bad man, he put him into a place of power, where he had temptation and opportunity to exert it. It was the ruin of Caiaphas that he was high priest that year, and so became a ringleader in the putting of Christ to death. Many a man's advancement has lost him his reputation, and he had not been dishonoured if he had not been preferred.
2.The malice of Caiaphas, which is intimated (v. 14) by the repeating of what he had said some time before, that, right or wrong, guilty or innocent, it was expedient that one man should die for the people, which refers to the story ch. xi. 50. This comes in here to show,
(1.)What a bad man he was; this was that Caiaphas that governed himself and the church by rules of policy, in defiance of the rules of equity.
(2.)What ill usage Christ was likely to meet with in his court, when his case was adjudged before it was heard, and they were already resolved what to do with him; he must die; so that his trial was a jest. Thus the enemies of Christ's gospel are resolved, true or false, to run it down.
(3.)It is a testimony to the innocency of our Lord Jesus, from the mouth of one of his worst enemies, who owned that he fell a sacrifice to the public good, and that it was not just he should die, but expedient only.
3.The concurrence of Annas in the prosecution of Christ. He made himself a partaker in guilt,
(1.)With the captain and officers, that without law or mercy had bound him; for he approved it by continuing him bound when he should have loosed him, he not being convicted of any crime, nor having attempted an escape. If we do not what we can to undo what others have ill done, we are accessaries ex post facto—after the fact. It was more excusable in the rude soldiers to bind him than in Annas, who should have known better, to continue him bound.
(2.)With the chief priest and council that condemned him, and prosecuted him to death. This Annas was not present with them, yet thus he wished them good speed, and became a partaker of their evil deeds.
III.In the house of Caiaphas, Simon Peter began to deny his Master, v. 15-18.
1.It was with much ado that Peter got into the hall where the court was sitting, an account of which we have v. 15, 16. Here we may observe,
(1.)Peter's kindness to Christ, which (though it proved no kindness) appeared in two things:—[1.] That he followed Jesus when he was led away; though at first he fled with the rest, yet afterwards he took heart a little, and followed at some distance, calling to mind the promises he had made to adhere to him, whatever it should cost him. Those that had followed Christ in the midst of his honours, and shared with him in those honours, when the people cried Hosanna to him, ought to have followed him now in the midst of his reproaches, and to have shared with him in these. Those that truly love and value Christ will follow him all weathers and all ways. [2.] When he could not get in where Jesus was in the midst of his enemies, he stood at the door without, willing to be as near him as he could, and waiting for an opportunity to get nearer. Thus when we meet with opposition in following Christ we must show our good-will. But yet this kindness of Peter's was no kindness, because he had not strength and courage enough to persevere in it, and so, as it proved, he did but run himself into a snare: and even his following Christ, considering all things, was to be blamed, because Christ, who knew him better than he knew himself, had expressly told him (ch. xiii. 36), Whither I go thou canst not follow me now, and had told him again and again that he would deny him; and he had lately had experience of his own weakness in forsaking him. Note, We must take heed of tempting God by running upon difficulties beyond our strength, and venturing too far in a way of suffering. If our call be clear to expose ourselves, we may hope that God will enable us to honour him; but, if it be not, we may fear that God will leave us to shame ourselves.
(2.)The other disciple's kindness to Peter, which yet, as it proved, was no kindness neither. St. John several times in this gospel speaking of himself as another disciple, many interpreters have been led by this to fancy that this other disciple here was John; and many conjectures they have how he should come to be known to the high-priest; propter generis nobilitatem—being of superior birth, saith Jerome, Epitaph. Marcel., as if he were a better gentleman born than his brother James, when they were both the sons of Zebedee the fisherman; some will tell you that he had sold his estate to the high priest, others that he supplied his family with fish, both which are very improbable. But I see no reason to think that this other disciple was John, or one of the twelve; other sheep Christ had, which were not of the fold; and this might be, as the Syriac read it, unus ex discipulis aliis—one of those other disciples that believe in Christ, but resided at Jerusalem, and kept their places there; perhaps Joseph of Arimathea, or Nicodemus, known to the high priest, but not known to him to be disciples of Christ. Note, As there are many who seem disciples and are not so, so there are many who are disciples and seem not so. There are good people hid in courts, even in Nero's, as well as hid in crowds. We must not conclude a man to be no friend to Christ merely because he has acquaintance and conversation with those that were his known enemies. Now,
[1.]This other disciple, whoever he was, showed a respect to Peter, in introducing him, not only to gratify his curiosity and affection, but to give him an opportunity of being serviceable to his Master upon his trial, if there were occasion. Those that have a real kindness for Christ and his ways, though their temper may be reserved and their circumstances may lead them to be cautious and retired, yet, if their faith be sincere, they will discover, when they are called to it, which way their inclination lies, by being ready to do a professed disciple a good turn. Peter perhaps had formerly introduced this disciple into conversation with Christ, and now he requites his kindness, and is not ashamed to own him, though, it should seem, he had at this time but a poor downcast appearance.
[2.]But this kindness proved no kindness, nay a great diskindness; by letting him into the high priest's hall, he let him into temptation, and the consequence was bad. Note, The courtesies of our friends often prove a snare to us, through a misguided affection.
2.Peter, having got in, was immediately assaulted with the temptation, and foiled by it, v. 17. Observe here,
(1.)How slight the attack was. It was but a silly maid, of so small account that she was set to keep the door, that challenged him, and she only asked him carelessly, Art not thou one of this man's disciples? probably suspecting it by his sheepish look, and coming in timorously. We should many a time better maintain a good cause if we had a good heart on it, and could put a good face on it. Peter would have had some reason to take the alarm if Malchus had set upon him, and had said, "This is he that cut off my ear, and I will have his head for it;" but when a maid only asked him, Art not thou one of them? he might without danger have answered, And what if I am? Suppose the servants had ridiculed him, and insulted over him, upon it, those can bear but little for Christ that cannot bear this; this is but running with the footmen.
(2.)How speedy the surrender was. Without taking time to recollect himself, he suddenly answered, I am not. If he had had the boldness of the lion, he would have said, "It is my honour that I am so;" or, if he had had the wisdom of the serpent, he would have kept silence at this time, for it was an evil time. But, all his care being for his own safety, he thought he could not secure this but by a peremptory denial: I am not; he not only denies it, but even disdains it, and scorns her words.
(3.)Yet he goes further into the temptation: And the servants and officers stood there, and Peter with them v. 18.
[1.]See how the servants made much of themselves; the night being cold, they made a fire in the hall, not for their masters (they were so eager in persecuting Christ that they forgot cold), but for themselves to refresh themselves. They cared not what became of Christ; all their care was to sit and warm themselves, Amos vi. 6.
[2.]See how Peter herded himself with them, and made one among them. He sat and warmed himself. First, It was a fault bad enough that he did not attend his Master, and appear for him at the upper end of the hall, where he was now under examination. He might have been a witness for him, and have confronted the false witnesses that swore against him, if his Master had called him; at least, he might have been a witness to him, might have taken an exact notice of what passed, that he might relate it to the other disciples, who could none of them get in to hear the trial; he might have learned by his Master's example how to carry himself when it should come to his turn to suffer thus; yet neither his conscience nor his curiosity could bring him into the court, but he sits by, as if, like Gallio, he cared for none of these things. And yet at the same time we have reason to think his heart was as full of grief and concern as it could hold, but he had not the courage to own it. Lord, lead us not into temptation. Secondly, It was much worse that he joined himself with those that were his Master's enemies: He stood with them, and warmed himself; this was a poor excuse for joining with them. A little thing will draw those into bad company that will be drawn to it by the love of a good fire. If Peter's zeal for his Master had not frozen, but had continued in the heat it seemed to be of but a few hours before, he had not had occasion to warm himself now. Peter was much to be blamed, 1. Because he associated with these wicked men, and kept company with them. Doubtless they were diverting themselves with this night's expedition, scoffing at Christ, at what he had said, at what he had done, and triumphing in their victory over him; and what sort of entertainment would this give to Peter? If he said as they said, or by silence gave consent, he involved himself in sin; if not, he exposed himself to danger. If Peter had not so much courage as to appear publicly for his Master, yet he might have had so much devotion as to retire into a corner, and weep in secret for his Master's sufferings, and his own sin in forsaking him; if he could not have done good, he might have kept out of the way of doing hurt. It is better to abscond than appear to no purpose, or bad purpose. 2. Because he desired to be thought one of them, that he might not be suspected to be a disciple of Christ. Is this Peter? What a contradiction is this to the prayer of every good man, Gather not my soul with sinners! Saul among the prophets is not so absurd as David among the Philistines. Those that deprecate the lot of the scornful hereafter should dread the seat of the scornful now. It is ill warming ourselves with those with whom we are in danger of burning ourselves, Ps. cxli. 4.
IV.Peter, Christ's friend, having begun to deny him, the high priest, his enemy, begins to accuse him, or rather urges him to accuse himself, v. 19-21. It should seem, the first attempt was to prove him a seducer, and a teacher of false doctrine, which this evangelist relates; and, when they failed in the proof of this, then they charged him with blasphemy, which is related by the other evangelists, and therefore omitted here. Observe,
1.The articles or heads upon which Christ was examined (v. 19): concerning his disciples and his doctrine. Observe,
(1.)The irregularity of the process; it was against all law and equity. They seize him as a criminal, and now that he is their prisoner they have nothing to lay to his charge; no libel, no prosecutor; but the judge himself must be the prosecutor, and the prisoner himself the witness, and, against all reason and justice, he is put on to be his own accuser.
(2.)The intention. The high priest then (oun—therefore, which seems to refer to v. 14), because he had resolved that Christ must be sacrificed to their private malice under colour of the public good, examined him upon those interrogatories which would touch his life. He examined him,
[1.]Concerning his disciples, that he might charge him with sedition, and represent him as dangerous to the Roman government, as well as to the Jewish church. He asked him who were his disciples—what number they were—of what country—what were their names and characters, insinuating that his scholars were designed for soldiers, and would in time become a formidable body. Some think his question concerning his disciples was, "What is now become of them all? Where are they? Why do they not appear?" upbraiding him with their cowardice in deserting him, and thus adding to the affliction of it. There was something significant in this, that Christ's calling and owning his disciples was the first thing laid to his charge, for it was for their sakes that he sanctified himself and suffered.
[2.]Concerning his doctrine, that they might charge him with heresy, and bring him under the penalty of the law against false prophets, Deut. xiii. 9, 10. This was a matter properly cognizable in that court (Deut. xvii. 12), therefore a prophet could not perish but at Jerusalem, where that court sat. They could not prove any false doctrine upon him; but they hoped to extort something from him which they might distort to his prejudice, and to make him an offender for some word or other, Isa. xxix. 21. They said nothing to him concerning his miracles, by which he had done so much good, and proved his doctrine beyond contradiction, because of these they were sure they could take no hold. Thus the adversaries of Christ while they are industriously quarrelling with his truth, willfully shut their eyes against the evidences of it, and take no notice of them.
2.The appeal Christ made, in answer to these interrogatories. (1.) As to his disciples, he said nothing, because it was an impertinent question; if his doctrine was sound and good, his having disciples to whom to communicate it was no more than what was practised and allowed by their own doctors. If Caiaphas, in asking him concerning his disciples, designed to ensnare them, and bring them into trouble, it was in kindness to them that Christ said nothing of them, for he had said, Let these go their way. If he meant to upbraid him with their cowardice, no wonder that he said nothing, for
he would say nothing to condemn them, and could say nothing to justify them. (2.) As to his doctrine, he said nothing in particular, but in general referred himself to those that heard him, being not only made manifest to God, but made manifest also in their consciences, v. 20, 21.
[1.]He tacitly charges his judges with illegal proceedings. He does not indeed speak evil of the rulers of the people, nor say now to these princes, You are wicked; but he appeals to the settled rules of their own court, whether they dealt fairly by him. Do you indeed judge righteously? Ps. lviii. 1. So here, Why ask you me? Which implies two absurdities in judgment: First, "Why ask you me now concerning my doctrine, when you have already condemned it?" They had made an order of court for excommunicating all that owned him (ch. ix. 22), had issued out a proclamation for apprehending him; and now they come to ask what his doctrine is! Thus was he condemned, as his doctrine and cause commonly are, unheard. Secondly, "Why ask you me? Must I accuse myself, when you have no evidence against me?"
[2.]He insists upon his fair and open dealing with them in the publication of his doctrine, and justifies himself with this. The crime which the sanhedrim by the law was to enquire after was the clandestine spreading of dangerous doctrines, enticing secretly, Deut. xiii. 6. As to this, therefore, Christ clears himself very fully. First, As to the manner of his preaching. He spoke openly, parresia—with freedom and plainness of speech; he did not deliver things ambiguously, as Apollo did his oracles. Those that would undermine the truth, and spread corrupt notions, seek to accomplish their purpose by sly insinuation, putting queries, starting difficulties, and asserting nothing; but Christ explained himself fully, with, Verily, verily, I say unto you; his reproofs were free and bold, and his testimonies express against the corruptions of the age. Secondly, As to the persons he preached to: He spoke to the world, to all that had ears to hear, and were willing to hear him, high or low, learned or unlearned, Jew or Gentile, friend or foe. His doctrine feared not the censure of a mixed multitude; nor did he grudge the knowledge of it to any (as the masters of some rare invention commonly do), but freely communicated it, as the sun does his beams. Thirdly, As to the places he preached in. When he was in the country, he preached ordinarily in the synagogues—the places of meeting for worship, and on the sabbath-day-the time of meeting; when he came up to Jerusalem, he preached the same doctrine in the temple at the time of the solemn feasts, when the Jews from all parts assembled there; and though he often preached in private houses, and on mountains, and by the sea-side, to show that his word and worship were not to be confined to temples and synagogues, yet what he preached in private was the very same with what he delivered publicly. Note, The doctrine of Christ, purely and plainly preached, needs not be ashamed to appear in the most numerous assembly, for it carries its own strength and beauty along with it. What Christ's faithful ministers say they would be willing all the world should hear. Wisdom cries in the places of concourse, Prov. i. 21; viii. 3; ix. 3. Fourthly, As to the doctrine itself. He said nothing in secret contrary to what he said in public, but only by way of repetition and explication: In secret have I said nothing; as if he had been either suspicious of the truth of it, or conscious of any ill design in it. He sought no corners, for he feared no colours, nor said any thing that he needed to be ashamed of; what he did speak in private to his disciples he ordered them to proclaim on the house-tops, Matt. x. 27. God saith of himself (Isa. xlv. 19), I have not spoken in secret; his commandment is not hidden, Deut. xxx. 11. And the righteousness of faith speaks in like manner, Rom. x. 6. Veritas nihil metuit nisi abscondi—truth fears nothing but concealment.—Tertullian.
[3.]He appeals to those that had heard him, and desires that they might be examined what doctrine he had preached, and whether it had that dangerous tendency that was surmised: "Ask those that heard me what I said unto them; some of them may be in court, or may be sent for out of their beds." He means not his friends and followers, who might be presumed to speak in his favour, but, Ask any impartial hearer; ask your own officers. Some think he pointed to them, when he said, Behold, they know what I said, referring to the report which they had made of his preaching (ch. vii. 46), Never man spoke like this man. Nay, you may ask some upon the bench; for it is probable that some of them had heard him, and had been put to silence by him. Note, The doctrine of Christ may safely appeal to all that know it, and has so much right and reason on its side that those who will judge impartially cannot but witness to it.
V.While the judges were examining him, the servants that stood by were abusing him, v. 22, 23.
1.It was a base affront which one of the officers gave him; though he spoke with so much calmness and convincing evidence, this insolent fellow struck him with the palm of his hand, probably on the side of his head or face, saying, Answerest thou the high priest so? as if he had behaved himself rudely to the court.
(1.)He struck him, edoke rhapisma—he gave him a blow. Some think it signifies a blow with a rod or wand, from rhabdos, or with the staff which was the badge of his office. Now the scripture was fulfilled (Isa. l. 6), I gave my cheeks, eis rhapismata (so the LXX.) to blows, the word here used. And Mic. v. 1, They shall smite the judge of Israel with a rod upon the cheek; and the type answered (Job xvi. 10), They have smitten me upon the cheek reproachfully. It was unjust to strike one that neither said nor did amiss; it was insolent for a mean servant to strike one that was confessedly a person of account; it was cowardly to strike one that had his hands tied; and barbarous to strike a prisoner at the bar. Here was a breach of the peace in the face of the court, and yet the judges countenanced it. Confusion of face was our due; but Christ here took it to himself: "Upon me be the curse, the shame."
(2.)He checked him in a haughty imperious manner: Answerest thou the high priest so? As if the blessed Jesus were not good enough to speak to his master, or not wise enough to know how to speak to him, but, like a rude and ignorant prisoner, must be controlled by the jailor, and taught how to behave. Some of the ancients suggest that this officer was Malchus, who owed to Christ the healing of his ear, and the saving of his head, and yet made him this ill return. But, whoever it was, it was done to please the high priest, and to curry favour with him; for what he said implied a jealousy for the dignity of the high priest. Wicked rulers will not want wicked servants, who will help forward the affliction of those whom their masters persecute. There was a successor of this high priest that commanded the bystanders to smite Paul thus on the mouth, Acts xxiii. 2. Some think this officer took himself to be affronted by Christ's appeal to those about him concerning his doctrine, as if he would have vouched him to be a witness; and perhaps he was one of those officers that had spoken honourably of him (ch. vii. 46), and, lest he should now be thought a secret friend to him, he thus appears a bitter enemy.
2.Christ bore this affront with wonderful meekness and patience (v. 23): "If I have spoken evil, in what I have now said, bear witness of the evil. Observe it to the court, and let them judge of it, who are the proper judges; but if well, and as it did become me, why smitest thou me?" Christ could have answered him with a miracle of wrath, could have struck him dumb or dead, or have withered the hand that was lifted up against him. But this was the day of his patience and suffering, and he answered him with the meekness of wisdom, to teach us not to avenge ourselves, not to render railing for railing, but with the innocency of the dove to bear injuries, even when with the wisdom of the serpent, as our Saviour, we show the injustice of them, and appeal to the magistrate concerning them. Christ did not here turn the other cheek, by which it appears that that rule, Matt. v. 39, is not to be understood literally; a man may possibly turn the other cheek, and yet have his heart full of malice; but, comparing Christ's precept with his pattern, we learn,
(1.)That in such cases we must not be our own avengers, nor judges in our own cause. We must rather receive than give the second blow, which makes the quarrel; we are allowed to defend ourselves, but not to avenge ourselves: the magistrate (if it be necessary for the preserving of the public peace, and the restraining and terrifying of evil-doers) is to be the avenger, Rom. xiii. 4.
(2.)Our resentment of injuries done us must always be rational, and never passionate; such Christ's here was; when he suffered, he reasoned, but threatened not. He fairly expostulated with him that did him the injury, and so may we.
(3.)When we are called out to suffering, we must accommodate ourselves to the inconveniences of a suffering state, with patience, and by one indignity done us be prepared to receive another, and to make the best of it.
VI.While the servants were thus abusing him, Peter was proceeding to deny him, v. 25-27. It is a sad story, and none of the least of Christ's sufferings.
1.He repeated the sin the second time, v. 25. While he was warming himself with the servants, as one of them, they asked him, Art not thou one of his disciples? What dost thou here among us? He, perhaps, hearing that Christ was examined about his disciples, and fearing he should be seized, or at least smitten, as his Master was, if he should own it, flatly denied it, and said, I am not.
(1.)It was his great folly to thrust himself into the temptation, by continuing in the company of those that were unsuitable for him, and that he had nothing to do with. He staid to warm himself; but those that warm themselves with evil doers grow cold towards good people and good things, and those that are fond of the devil's fire-side are in danger of the devil's fire. Peter might have stood by his Master at the bar, and have warmed himself better than here, at the fire of his Master's love, which many waters could not quench, Cant. viii. 6, 7. He might there have warmed himself with zeal for his Master, and indignation at his persecutors; but he chose rather to warm with them than to warm against them. But how could one (one disciple) be warm alone? Eccl. iv. 11.
(2.)It was his great unhappiness that he was again assaulted by the temptation; and no other could be expected, for this was a place, this an hour, of temptation. When the judge asked Christ about his disciples, probably the servants took the hint, and challenged Peter for one of them, "Answer to thy name." See here,
[1.]The subtlety of the tempter in running down one whom he saw falling, and mustering a greater force against him; not a maid now, but all the servants. Note, Yielding to one temptation invites another, and perhaps a stronger. Satan redoubles his attacks when we give ground.
[2.]The danger of bad company. We commonly study to approve ourselves to those with whom we choose to associate; we value ourselves upon their good word and covet to stand right in their opinion. As we choose our people we choose our praise, and govern ourselves accordingly; we are therefore concerned to make the first choice well, and not to mingle with those whom we cannot please without displeasing God.
(3.)It was his great weakness, nay, it was his great wickedness, to yield to the temptation, and to say, I am not one of his disciples, as one ashamed of that which was his honour, and afraid of suffering for it, which would have been yet more his honour. See how the fear of man brings a snare. When Christ was admired, and caressed, and treated with respect, Peter pleased himself, and perhaps prided himself, in this, that he was a disciple of Christ, and so put in for a share in the honours done to his Master. Thus many who seem fond of the reputation of religion when it is in fashion are ashamed of the reproach of it; but we must take it for better and worse.
2.He repeated the sin the third time, v. 26, 27. Here he was attacked by one of the servants, who was kinsman to Malchus, who, when he heard Peter deny himself to be a disciple of Christ, gave him the lie with great assurance: "Did not I see thee in the garden with him? Witness my kinsman's ear." Peter then denied again, as if he knew nothing of Christ, nothing of the garden, nothing of all this matter.
(1.)This third assault of the temptation was more close than the former: before his relation to Christ was only suspected, here it is proved upon him by one that saw him with Jesus, and saw him draw his sword in his defence. Note, Those who by sin think to help themselves out of trouble do but entangle and embarrass themselves the more. Dare to be brave, for truth will out. A bird of the air may perhaps tell the matter which we seek to conceal with a lie. Notice is taken of this servant's being akin to Malchus, because this circumstance would make it the more a terror to Peter. "Now," thinks he, "I am gone, my business is done, there needs no other witness nor prosecutor." We should not make any man in particular our enemy if we can help it, because the time may come when either he or some of his relations may have us at their mercy. He that may need a friend should not make a foe. But observe, though here was sufficient evidence against Peter, and sufficient provocation given by his denial to have prosecuted him, yet he escapes, has no harm done him nor attempted to be done. Note, We are often drawn into sin by groundless causeless fears, which there is no occasion for, and which a small degree of wisdom and resolution would make nothing of.
(2.)His yielding to it was no less base than the former: He denied again. See here,
[1.]The nature of sin in general: the heart is hardened by the deceitfulness of it, Heb. iii. 13. It was a strange degree of effrontery that Peter had arrived to on a sudden, that he could with such assurance stand in a lie against so clear a disproof; but the beginning of sin is as the letting forth of water, when once the fence is broken men easily go from bad to worse.
[2.]Of the sin of lying in particular; it is a fruitful sin, and upon this account exceedingly sinful: one lie needs another to support it, and that another. It is a rule in the devil's politics Male facta male factis tegere, ne perpluant—To cover sin with sin, in order to escape detection.
Historical interpretation
Four Centuries of Reception
11 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.
Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.
His coming thither was caused by love, his not entering within by distress and fear. For the Evangelist hath recorded these things, to clear a way for excusing his denial; with regard to himself, he doth not set it down as any great matter that he was known to the high priest, but since he had said that he alone with Jesus went in, lest thou shouldest suppose that the action proceeded from any exalted feelings, he puts also the cause. And that Peter would have also entered had he been permitted, he shows by the sequel; for when he went out, and bade the damsel who kept the door bring in Peter, he straightway came in. But why did he not bring him in himself? He clung to Christ, and followed Him; on this account he bade the woman bring him in.
"And Simon Peter followed Jesus, and so did another disciple." Who is that other disciple? It is the writer himself. "And wherefore doth he not name himself? When he lay on the bosom of Jesus, he with reason concealed his name; but now why doth he this?" For the same reason, for here too he mentions a great good deed, that when all had started away, he followed. Therefore he conceals himself, and puts Peter before him. He was obliged to mention himself, that thou mightest understand that he narrates more exactly than the rest what took place in the hall, as having been himself within. But observe how he detracts from his own praise; for, lest any one should ask, "How, when all had retreated, did this man enter in farther than Simon?" he saith, that he "was known to the high priest." So that no one should wonder that he followed, or cry him up for his manliness. But the wonder was that matter of Peter, that being in such fear, he came even as far as the hall, when the others had retreated.
(Hom. lxxxiii) That no one however might be disturbed at the sound of the chains, the Evangelist reminds them of the prophecy that His death would be the salvation of the world: Now Caiaphas was he which gave counsel to the Jews, that it was expedient that one man should die for the people. Such is the overpowering force of truth, that even its enemies echo it.
He omits his own name out of humility: though he is relating an act of great virtue, how that he followed when the rest fled. He puts Peter before himself, and then mentions himself, in order to show that he was inside the hall, and therefore related what took place there with more certainty than the other Evangelists could. That disciple was known unto the high priest, and went in with Jesus into the palace of the high priest. This he mentions not as a boast, but in order to diminish his own merit, in having been the only one who entered with Jesus. It is accounting for the act in another way, than merely by greatness of mind. Peter's love took him as far as the palace, but his fear prevented him entering in: But Peter stood at the door without.
(Hom. lxxxiii) But that Peter would have entered the palace, if he had been permitted, appears by what immediately follows: Then went out that other disciple who was known to the high priest, and spake unto her who kept the doors, and brought in Peter. He did not bring him in himself, because he kept near Christ. It follows: Then saith the damsel that kept the door unto Peter, Art not thou also one of this Man's disciples? He saith, I am not. What sayest thou, O Peter? Didst thou not say before, I will lay down my life for thy sake? (Mat. 26:35) What then had happened, that thou givest way even when the damsel asks thee? It was not a soldier who asked thee, but a mean porteress. Nor said she, Art thou this Deceiver's disciple, but, this Man's: an expression of pity. Art not thou also, she says, because John was inside.
(Serm. de Petro et Elia.) Therefore did Divine Providence permit Peter first to fall, in order that he might be less severe to sinners from the remembrance of his own fall. Peter, the teacher and master of the whole world, sinned, and obtained pardon, that judges might thereafter have that rule to go by in dispensing pardon. For this reason I suppose the priesthood was not given to Angels; because, being without sin themselves, they would punish sinners without pity. Passible man is placed over man, in order that remembering his own weakness, he may be merciful to others.
The temptation of Peter, which took place during the time that the Lord was enduring these injuries, is not placed by all Evangelists in the same order. Matthew and Mark first narrate the injuries inflicted on the Lord and then this temptation of Peter. Luke first describes Peter’s temptation, and only after this does he record the reproaches borne by the Lord. John begins with Peter’s temptation but then introduces some verses that record what the Lord had to bear, appending the statement that the Lord was sent away from Annas to Caiaphas the high priest, and then at this point he resumes and sums up what he had been relating about Peter’s temptation in the house to which Jesus was first conducted. He then gives a full account of that incident and thereafter reverts to the succession of events that happened to the Lord, telling us how Jesus was brought to Caiaphas.
"But Jesus was followed," he says, "by Simon Peter, and another disciple." Who that other disciple is, we cannot affirm with confidence, because it is left unnoticed here. But it is in this way that John usually refers to himself, with the addition, "whom Jesus loved." Perhaps, therefore, it is he also in the present case; but whoever it is, let us look at what follows. "And that disciple," he says, "was known unto the high priest, and went in with Jesus into the palace of the high priest; but Peter stood at the door without. Then went out that other disciple, who was known unto the high priest, and spake unto her that kept the door, and brought in Peter. Then saith the damsel that kept the door unto Peter, Art thou also one of this man's disciples? He saith, I am not." Lo, the pillar of greatest strength has at a single breath of air trembled to its foundations. Where is now all that boldness of the promiser, and his overweening confidence in himself beforehand? What now of those words, when he said, "Why cannot I follow Thee now? I will lay down my life for Thy sake." Is this the way to follow the Master, to deny his own discipleship? is it thus that one's life is laid down for the Lord, when one is frightened at a maid-servant's voice, lest it should compel us to the sacrifice? But what wonder, if God foretold what was true, and man presumptuously imagined what was false? Assuredly in this denial of the Apostle Peter, which had now entered on its first stage, we ought to take notice that not only is Christ denied by one who says that He is not Christ, but by him also who, while really a Christian, himself denies that he is so. For the Lord said not to Peter, Thou shall deny that thou art my disciple; but, "Thou shall deny me." Him, therefore, he denied, when he denied that he was His disciple. And what else did such a form of denial imply, but that of his own Christianity?
(de Con. Evang. iii. vi) The temptation of Peter, which took place in the midst of the contumelies offered to our Lord, is not placed by all in the same order. Matthew and Mark put the contumelies first, the temptation of Peter afterwards; Luke the temptation first, the contumelies after. John begins with the temptation: And Simon Peter followed Jesus, and so did another disciple.
(Tr. cxiii) Who that other disciple was we cannot hastily decide, as his name is not told us. John however is wont to signify himself by this expression, with the addition of, whom Jesus loved. Perhaps therefore he is the one.
(Tr. cxiii) But what wonder, if God foretold truly, man presumed falsely. Respecting this denial of Peter we should remark, that Christ is not only denied by him, who denies that He is Christ, but by him also who denies himself to be a Christian. For the Lord did not say to Peter, Thou shalt deny that thou art My disciple, but, Thou shalt deny Me. (Luke 22:34) He denied Him then, when he denied that he was His disciple. And what was this but to deny that he was a Christian? How many afterwards, even boys and girls, were able to despise death, confess Christ, and enter courageously into the kingdom of heaven; which he who received the keys of the kingdom, was now unable to do? Wherein we see the reason for His saying above, Let these go their way, for of those which Thou hast given Me, have I lost none. If Peter had gone out of this world immediately after denying Christ, He must have been lost.
For although the disciples of Christ were not yet called by such a name,-because it was after His ascension, in Antioch, first that the disciples began to be called Christians,-yet the thing itself, that afterwards assumed such a name, already existed, those who were afterwards called Christians were already disciples; and this common name, like the common faith, they transmitted to their posterity. He, therefore, who denied that he was Christ's disciple, denied the reality of the thing, of which the being called a Christian was only the name. How many afterwards, not to speak of old men and women, whose satiated feelings as regards the present life might more easily enable them to brave death for the confession of Christ; and not merely the youth of both sexes, when of an age at which the exercise of fortitude seems to be fairly required; but even boys and girls could do-even as an innumerable company of holy martyrs with brave hearts and by a violent death entered the kingdom of heaven-what at that moment he was unable to do, who received the keys of that kingdom. It is here we see why it was said, "Let these go their way," when He, who hath redeemed us by His own blood, gave Himself for us; that the saying which He spake might be fulfilled, "Of those whom Thou hast given me I have lost none." For assuredly, had Peter gone hence after denying the Christ, what else would have awaited him but destruction?
And Simon Peter followed Jesus, and so did the other disciple.
While the other disciples, it seems, were panic-stricken, and fled from the present wrath of the murderers, Peter, who was always moved thereto by more fervent passion, clings to his love for Christ, and follows Him at the peril of his life, and watches the issue of events; the other disciple accompanying him, and, with like courage, sustaining a similar resolution. This was John, the truly pious writer of this Divine work. For he calls himself that other disciple, without giving himself a definite name, fearing to seem boastful, and abhorring the appearance of being better than the rest. For the crowning achievements of virtue, if manifested by any of the righteous, yet are never blazoned forth to the world by their own mouth. For it very ill beseems a man to win praise rather out of his own mouth than the conversation of other men. In the Book of Proverbs it is written: Let another man praise thee, and not thine own mouth; a stranger, and not thine own lips.
Now that disciple was known unto the high priest, and entered in with Jesus into the court of the high priest.
The Apostle shows great forethought in condescending to mention this fact, and does not scruple to enter into detail where it is profitable for us. For, as he was about to set down in order in his book what was done and said in the palace of the high priest, he was, as it were, compelled to show us how he was able to enter there with Christ; for, he says, he was known unto the high priest. He enters, therefore, without hindrance, his knowledge of the leader of the people----for he has not thought proper to say friendship----allowing him free entrance within the doors. In order, then, that he might convince us that he did not compile his account of what took place in the palace from information drawn from others, but that he himself saw and heard what passed, he has given us this most useful explanation of his knowledge of the high priest.
He followed his Master out of devotion, though afar off, on account of fear.
Let’s begin with some things that we ought to know about John, but which we usually don’t. John was very likely the Lord’s first cousin on their mothers’ side. John was a son of Zebedee, and his mother’s name was Salome, which we can find out by comparing Mark 16:1 and Matt.27:56. Mark says that the third woman who went to the tomb was Salome and Matthew said it was the mother of Zebedee’s children. And then in John 19:25, it says that four women were present at the crucifixion—two Marys from Mark and Matthew, the Lord’s mother, and the Lord’s aunt. This helps make sense of how the Lord would entrust the care of His mother to John, which on this reading would be her nephew. It also helps explain the particular closeness of Jesus and John (John 21:7).
John was also from a well-to-do family with respectable connections. His father had hired servants (Mark 1:20), and Salome was one of the women who was a financial patroness of the Lord’s ministry (Luke 8:3; Mark 15:40). John was known to the high priest (John 18:15-16), and was able to get Peter into the place where the Lord was being tried.
We also know a great deal about John’s giftedness and related challenges. Jesus named him, together with his brother, a son of thunder (Mark 3:17). He was a fire-eater, and sometimes succumbed to the temptations that come with that—which would be misdirected zeal and ambition. He was one of the disciples who wanted Jesus to torch a Samaritan village (Luke 9:54), and it was Salome who made the request for James and John to sit at Christ’s left and right hand (Matt. 20:20; Mark 10:37). John was not formally trained (Acts 4:13), but was nonetheless a staggering genius. He was a tender and humble man as revealed by all his writings, but it is very plain that this was the result of the Spirit taming a lot of horsepower.
He remained in Jerusalem for a number of years—at least 14 (Gal. 2:9), but then moved to Ephesus, where he wrote his gospel (according to Irenaeus. That was the time during which he was exiled to Patmos. According to early reports, he lived until the reign of Trajan (which started in 98 A.D.)
Continue studying John 18:15 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
- BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
- Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
- ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
- NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
- STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
- BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
- USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
- BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
- StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
- BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
- Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
- Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
- Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
- CNTR CollationThe earliest Greek manuscripts of this verse, collated letter by letter.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.
Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.
This verse
Simon Peter and another disciple follow the arrested Jesus, and the other disciple, who is known to the high priest, goes in with Jesus into the high priest’s court.
“And Simon Peter followed Jesus,”
He follows a bound prisoner, after the other disciples have fled.
“and so did another disciple:”
Unnamed, as the writer of this Gospel leaves himself unnamed elsewhere, most likely John.
“that disciple was known unto the high priest,”
His acquaintance with the household is what opens the way in, first for himself and then for Peter.
“and went in with Jesus into the palace of the high priest.”
He goes in alongside the prisoner and his guards, into the courtyard where the rest of the scene takes place.
Passage studyJohn 18:15–27
Peter Denies Jesus as Jesus Stands Trial
Summary
While Jesus is questioned inside the high priest’s house, Peter stands in the courtyard and three times disowns being his disciple. John tells the two scenes side by side. Peter gets in with the help of another disciple who is known to the high priest, denies Jesus to the girl at the door, and warms himself at a fire of coals among the servants and officers who arrested his Master. Inside, Jesus tells the high priest that he taught openly and said nothing in secret, takes a blow from an officer without striking back, asks for honest witness, and is sent bound to Caiaphas. Peter then denies him twice more, and the cock crows at once, just as Jesus had said. The disciple fails and the Lord stays faithful, and the same Gospel goes on to tell how Jesus restored Peter beside another fire of coals.
Peter and the Other Disciple Follow Jesus In
After the arrest in the garden, Jesus was bound and led first to Annas (John 18:12–14). The disciples had scattered, as Jesus had said they would (John 16:32), but Simon Peter “followed Jesus, and so did another disciple.” The verb akolouthéō means to go the same way with someone, to accompany, and it is the word for following a teacher as his disciple. Only a little earlier Peter had drawn a sword in the garden (John 18:1–12), and his love for his Master still draws him after him, into the house of the men who had seized him. Both men are called by the plain word for a disciple, mathētḗs, a learner or pupil.
The “palace of the high priest” is the aulē, a word for a yard open to the sky and, by extension, the house built around it. The KJV renders it court, fold, hall or palace in different places. Here it is the high priest’s residence, an enclosed compound with an open central court where servants, guards and visitors gathered, a private house where the rulers could do their business.
The other disciple “was known unto the high priest”. The word is gnōstós, well known, an acquaintance. He had standing in that household, enough to walk in with Jesus and the guards, and that is the detail that lets the whole scene in the courtyard happen. How he came to be known there is left untold. One suggestion is that his family’s fishing trade had brought them into dealings with households in Jerusalem.
Who was the other disciple?
The other disciple is most likely John himself, who wrote this Gospel. He keeps his own name out of the story throughout, and calls himself “the disciple whom Jesus loved” (John 13:23, John 19:26–27, John 20:2, John 21:7). At the end of the book that disciple is named as the one who testified of these things and wrote them (John 21:20–24). This is why the Gospel can tell what happened at the door and by the fire, and what was said in the high priest’s presence: the man who wrote it was there, and he puts Christ at the centre and himself in the background.
Peter at the Door
Peter got only as far as the door. He “stood at the door without”, and the verb is hístēmi, simply to stand. Then the other disciple came out, spoke to the woman who kept the door, and “brought in Peter”, eiságō, to lead someone in. Large households kept a doorkeeper to control who came and went, and the word of a man the household knew was enough to get Peter past her.
It was a kind act, and it brought Peter straight into the place where he would be tested. Jesus had already told him plainly what would happen (John 13:36–38), and Luke records that he had prayed for Peter, that his faith would hold (Luke 22:31–34).
Peter needed a friend and a doorkeeper to get through that door. Jesus calls himself the door through which his sheep come in to God (John 10:7–9), and by his death he opened “a new and living way” into God’s own presence (Hebrews 10:19–20).
“I Am Not”: The First Denial
The doorkeeper is a paidískē, a girl, and in particular a female slave or servant, the KJV’s “damsel”. She asks Peter, “Art not thou also one of this man’s disciples?” The word “also” may show that she knew the other disciple was one of them, and guessed that Peter, who came in on his word, was another. Her question and Peter’s reply are both brought in with légō, the everyday verb for saying something.
Peter answers, “I am not.” Her question uses mḗ, which Strong’s describes as a particle of qualified negation, and Peter’s answer uses ou, the absolute negative, so his reply is flat and complete. The man who had told Jesus, “I will lay down my life for thy sake” (John 13:37), and who had swung a sword in the garden, gives way before a question from a servant girl at a door.
Peter’s “I am not”, ouk eimi, stands against the “I am” sayings of Jesus in this Gospel, such as “Before Abraham was, I am” (John 8:58). Jesus owns who he is, though it will cost him his life, and Peter disowns who he is to save his own.
Why did Peter deny Jesus?
Peter denied Jesus because he was afraid. He loved Jesus, and he had shown it by following when the others fled. But he was standing in the house of the men who had just arrested his Master, and to be known as the prisoner’s disciple could bring arrest, punishment or disgrace on him too. His promise to die for Jesus was sincere, and it was made in his own strength, and his own strength gave out. Matthew records how firmly Peter had insisted that he would die with Jesus sooner than deny him (Matthew 26:33–35). Jesus knew Peter’s weakness better than Peter did, and he foretold the denials before they came.
Scripture tells this failure plainly, about the man who would become a leader of the church. That honesty about its own heroes is part of what makes its witness so trustworthy.
Warming Himself at the Fire of Coals
“It was cold.” Passover came in the spring, when nights in Jerusalem can still be chilly, and the servants and officers had made a fire. The servants are slaves or bondservants, doûlos. The officers are hypērétēs, a word Strong’s traces to an under-oarsman in a ship, and so any subordinate or assistant, here the temple police who served the high priest and had taken part in the arrest. Peter “stood with them, and warmed himself”. The verb thermaínō means to warm oneself, and the act was an ordinary one. Where he did it is what matters. It put Jesus’ disciple shoulder to shoulder with Jesus’ captors, in the light of their fire, where he could be seen and questioned.
The “fire of coals” is anthrakiá, a bed of burning coals, a charcoal fire. In the New Testament the word is used only here and in John 21, where the disciples come ashore after a night’s fishing and find a fire of coals with fish laid on it, and where the risen Jesus restores Peter (John 21:9–19). Peter disowned his Lord beside one charcoal fire and was given back his calling beside another. John’s choice of the word ties the place of failure to the place of grace.
Jesus Before Annas
Who was the high priest who questioned Jesus?
The high priest who questions Jesus in verses 19 to 23 is Annas, the father-in-law of Caiaphas, to whom Jesus was taken first (John 18:13). Annas had been high priest himself, from about AD 6 until the Roman governor Valerius Gratus removed him in AD 15. He kept great power after that as head of a priestly family. Five of his sons held the office in turn, and so did his son-in-law Caiaphas, who was high priest that year. Men still gave Annas the title, and the Gospel calls him “the high priest” here. The word archiereús means the high priest, and by extension any of the chief priests.
This was an informal hearing before the council met under Caiaphas, a way to draw something out of Jesus or to put pressure on him first. It was badly out of order. It was held at night, in a private house, and it began by questioning the prisoner before any witness had been brought against him. The Jewish rules for capital trials called for hearings by day and for the testimony of witnesses, and a conviction had to rest on witnesses besides the accused himself.
What the high priest asked
Annas asked Jesus “of his disciples, and of his doctrine.” The verb erōtáō is the ordinary word for asking a question or making a request. “Doctrine” is didachḗ, teaching, both the act of teaching and what is taught. Both subjects worried the rulers. A teacher with a large following could look to them like the start of a revolt, and they feared the Romans would come and take away both their place and their nation (John 11:48). A teaching that went against their reading of the Law could be branded heresy or blasphemy. So the two questions probe whether Jesus is a rebel or a false teacher.
Jesus had already said where his teaching came from: “My doctrine is not mine, but his that sent me” (John 7:16–17). The crowds had been astonished at his teaching, because he taught them as one having authority (Matthew 7:28–29), and later the same council would forbid the apostles to teach in his name (Acts 5:28). Before Pilate, Jesus would say that his kingdom was “not of this world” (John 18:36), a kingdom of changed hearts and no army.
“I spake openly to the world”
Jesus answers by pointing to his whole ministry. “I spake openly to the world” uses parrhesía, all out-spokenness, frankness, publicity, and by implication confidence. He “ever taught in the synagogue, and in the temple, whither the Jews always resort”. The synagogue was the meeting place in each town for prayer and teaching, and the temple courts in Jerusalem were the nation’s centre of worship, crowded at the feasts. The word behind “ever” and “always” is the same, pántote, at all times: he always taught where the people always gathered. “Taught” is didáskō, to teach. Luke tells how he taught in their synagogues (Luke 4:15), the people of Jerusalem said, “he speaketh boldly” (John 7:26), and he sat in the temple at dawn teaching all who came (John 8:2).
“And in secret have I said nothing.” Kryptós means concealed or private. Everything Jesus taught, he taught in the open, to anyone who came to hear, and his message was for the whole world that God loved (John 3:16). The accused man had done everything in daylight, while his accusers arrested him by night and questioned him behind closed doors. He speaks as the LORD speaks in Isaiah: “I have not spoken in secret, in a dark place of the earth” (Isaiah 45:19). He is the truth itself (John 14:6), the Word made flesh, full of grace and truth (John 1:14), and the light of the world (John 8:12, John 12:46).
“Ask them which heard me”
“Why askest thou me? ask them which heard me”. The verb behind both “askest” and “ask” is eperōtáō, to ask, question or inquire of, a word also used for questioning in a court. Jesus sends the inquiry where an honest one would begin, to those who had heard him (akoúō, to hear). “Behold, they know what I said.” Íde, “behold”, is an interjection that calls for attention and puts weight on what follows. “Know” is eídō, a verb whose proper sense is to see, and which here means to know. Crowds had heard him, and they could say what he taught.
Was Jesus refusing to answer?
Jesus was answering, and his answer was a point of justice. A fair inquiry gathers evidence from witnesses, and here the prisoner was being pressed, in private and at night, to supply the case against himself. By sending Annas to those who had heard him, Jesus affirmed that his teaching was public and his conduct blameless, and he showed the hearing for what it was. He bore the same kind of witness before Pilate: “To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth” (John 18:37).
Truth is at home in the light. Jesus had said that those who do evil hate the light, while those who do truth come to it (John 3:19–21). He warned that what is whispered in closets will be proclaimed upon the housetops (Luke 12:3), and Paul could say of the gospel before King Agrippa, “this thing was not done in a corner” (Acts 26:26).
The officer’s blow
At these words “one of the officers which stood by struck Jesus with the palm of his hand”, demanding, “Answerest thou the high priest so?” The KJV phrase stands for dídōmi, to give, with rhápisma, a slap: he gave Jesus a slap. A slap in the face was an insult, meant to shame more than to wound, and the officer meant it to put Jesus in his place and to enforce respect for the high priest. He took Jesus’ calm, truthful answer for insolence. The man whose task was to keep order is the one who breaks it, against a prisoner who has just spoken the truth.
This was the first of many blows. Before the council they spat in his face and struck him (Matthew 26:67–68), and soon he would be scourged and crucified. Isaiah had written of the Servant of the LORD, “I gave my back to the smiters, and my cheeks to them that plucked off the hair: I hid not my face from shame and spitting” (Isaiah 50:6).
“If I have spoken evil, bear witness of the evil”
Jesus answers the officer with a plain question of justice. “If I have spoken evil” uses kakōs, badly or wrongly, and “bear witness” is martyréō, to be a witness, to testify. If he has said something wrong, let it be shown by testimony. “But if well, why smitest thou me?” The verb is dérō, which Strong’s gives as properly to flay, and so to beat or thrash, and the KJV renders it “smite”. Either way the blow stands condemned, because wrong words call for witnesses and right words call for a hearing. Jesus, the innocent prisoner, asks the officers of the law to keep the law.
Did Jesus turn the other cheek?
Jesus did what he taught. He took the blow without striking back or cursing the man who struck him, which is the heart of his word in Matthew 5:39: “whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.” He also spoke, calmly and without anger, to ask for justice and to name the wrong. Peter later wrote of him, “when he was reviled, reviled not again; when he suffered, he threatened not; but committed himself to him that judgeth righteously” (1 Peter 2:23).
Isaiah says of the Servant, “he openeth not his mouth” (Isaiah 53:7), and before his accusers later that day Jesus kept silent (Matthew 27:12–14). Here he speaks to expose injustice, and his whole bearing is still that of the lamb who submits and never retaliates.
Sent bound to Caiaphas
“Now Annas had sent him bound unto Caiaphas the high priest.” The verb apostéllō means to send out, and déō means to tie or bind. Jesus had been bound in the garden, and he stays bound, handled as a criminal, as Annas passes him on to the reigning high priest. The informal hearing ends, the formal proceedings begin, and from Caiaphas the road leads to Pilate (John 18:28–40). The two men charged with guarding God’s law are bending it against God’s Son, and the one who came to set captives free is himself in bonds.
None of this was outside God’s purpose. Peter would preach that Jesus was delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God (Acts 2:23), and Jesus had said of his life, “No man taketh it from me, but I lay it down of myself” (John 10:18). He went as one obedient unto death (Philippians 2:8).
The Second and Third Denials
John turns back to the courtyard with the same words as before: “Simon Peter stood and warmed himself”, again hístēmi and thermaínō. While Jesus stood before the high priest and spoke the truth, Peter stood by the fire. The people around it asked, “Art not thou also one of his disciples?”, almost the girl’s question, now from a group. “He denied it, and said, I am not.” “Denied” is arnéomai, to deny, refuse, disown or say no, and his words are the same “I am not” he gave at the door.
Then came the hardest question. One of the high priest’s servants (doûlos again) was a kinsman of the man whose ear Peter had cut off, Malchus (John 18:10). Syngenḗs means a relative by blood, and by extension a fellow countryman. “Did not I see thee in the garden with him?” This man had been in the garden, he had seen Peter there, and he had a family reason to remember him. Peter’s own rash stroke with the sword now pointed him out. The verb is eídō again, here in its plain sense of seeing.
“Peter then denied again”. The verb is arnéomai once more, and John gives none of Peter’s words this time, only the fact. Peter denied Jesus three times, as Jesus had said: to the girl at the door, to the group at the fire, and to the kinsman who had seen him in the garden. Each challenge came from someone who knew more than the one before.
Why the cock crew at that moment
“And immediately the cock crew.” Euthéōs means immediately, at once. Phōnéō means to sound, cry out or call, and it is used of a cock’s crow as well as of a person calling. At the supper Jesus had said, “The cock shall not crow, till thou hast denied me thrice” (John 13:38), and the other Gospels record the same warning (Mark 14:30, Luke 22:34). The crow came at the very moment of the third denial, and so Jesus’ word was kept to the letter, by a common farmyard sound in the hands of God. The cockcrow was also the name of a watch of the night, the third, in the small hours before dawn.
For Peter the sound brought the weight of what he had done, and the truth of Jesus’ words, home to him at once. Matthew tells the scene too (Matthew 26:69–75), and Luke ends it with Peter, who “went out, and wept bitterly” (Luke 22:54–62). The sound that marked his fall was also a mercy, because it led him to repentance.
The Faithful Lord and His Failing Disciple
John places Peter’s denials around the questioning of Jesus, and the two scenes explain each other. Inside, Jesus speaks the truth and suffers for it. Outside, Peter hides the truth to escape suffering. The difference shows how little our own resolve can bear under pressure, and how fully Jesus can be trusted. Paul puts it in one sentence: “If we believe not, yet he abideth faithful: he cannot deny himself” (2 Timothy 2:13).
He is the great high priest who understands weakness, “in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin” (Hebrews 4:14–15). He prayed for Peter before the fall, and he still lives to intercede for his people (Romans 8:34, Hebrews 7:25). He is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29), and he bore the sins of the failing, Peter’s denials among them. Isaiah says, “he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities” (Isaiah 53:4–6), and Paul says that God commended his love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us (Romans 5:8). The gospel he left rests on things done openly, a death and resurrection seen by many witnesses (1 Corinthians 15:3–8).
Peter’s story goes on in John 21, at another fire of coals. There the risen Jesus asks him three times whether he loves him, and gives him again the work of an apostle (John 21:15–19). The Lord who foretold Peter’s fall had already prayed for him, and the disciple who denied him was the one he sent back to feed his flock. His grace is sufficient for the weakest of his people, because his strength is made perfect in weakness (2 Corinthians 12:9).
John 18:15 This verse
“And Simon Peter followed Jesus,”
He follows a bound prisoner, after the other disciples have fled.
“and so did another disciple:”
Unnamed, as the writer of this Gospel leaves himself unnamed elsewhere, most likely John.
“that disciple was known unto the high priest,”
His acquaintance with the household is what opens the way in, first for himself and then for Peter.
“and went in with Jesus into the palace of the high priest.”
He goes in alongside the prisoner and his guards, into the courtyard where the rest of the scene takes place.
John 18:16
“But Peter stood at the door without.”
Peter is stopped at the entrance, on the outside, unable to get in by himself.
“Then went out that other disciple, which was known unto the high priest,”
The Gospel repeats the reason he could come and go freely.
“and spake unto her that kept the door,”
The doorkeeper is a woman, the same servant who questions Peter in the next verse.
“and brought in Peter.”
A friend’s help brings Peter into the courtyard where he will be tested.
John 18:17
“Then saith the damsel that kept the door unto Peter,”
The first challenge comes from a servant girl, a person of low standing in the house.
“Art not thou also one of this man’s disciples?”
“This man” is the prisoner just led inside. To say yes is to stand with him.
“He saith, I am not.”
Peter disowns the very thing he had been since Jesus called him, a disciple.
John 18:18
“And the servants and officers stood there,”
The men in the courtyard include those who had made the arrest.
“who had made a fire of coals;”
A charcoal fire, the kind John mentions again on the shore in John 21.
“for it was cold:”
A spring night in Jerusalem at Passover, chilly enough for a fire.
“and they warmed themselves:”
The servants and officers gather round the warmth together.
“and Peter stood with them, and warmed himself.”
Peter joins the circle and becomes one face among Jesus’ captors.
John 18:19
“The high priest then asked Jesus”
Annas, the former high priest, questions the prisoner himself before any witness is called.
“of his disciples,”
Who his followers were, and whether they could be a threat.
“and of his doctrine.”
What he taught, and whether it could be called heresy.
John 18:20
“Jesus answered him,”
He answers the man who claims to judge him, calmly and directly.
“I spake openly to the world;”
“The world” is kósmos. His words were for everyone.
“I ever taught in the synagogue, and in the temple,”
The two most public places in Jewish life, one in every town and one at the heart of the nation.
“whither the Jews always resort;”
Where the people regularly came together, so that anyone could hear him.
“and in secret have I said nothing.”
His teaching and his conduct had been open from the start.
John 18:21
“Why askest thou me?”
A question that challenges the hearing itself, where the accused is pressed to supply the case against himself.
“ask them which heard me, what I have said unto them:”
The witnesses are many and easy to find.
“behold, they know what I said.”
“Behold” calls the high priest to look at what is plain.
John 18:22
“And when he had thus spoken,”
The blow answers his words, which were true.
“one of the officers which stood by”
One of the temple police guarding the prisoner.
“struck Jesus with the palm of his hand,”
A slap, a blow of contempt meant to humiliate.
“saying, Answerest thou the high priest so?”
The officer treats Jesus’ plain answer as disrespect to Annas.
John 18:23
“Jesus answered him,”
He answers the officer, with neither silence nor a blow in return.
“If I have spoken evil, bear witness of the evil:”
Wrong words should be proved by testimony.
“but if well, why smitest thou me?”
Right words deserve a hearing, and the officer is left to account for his blow.
John 18:24
“Now Annas had sent him bound”
The prisoner is still in the bonds put on him at the arrest.
“unto Caiaphas the high priest.”
The high priest of that year, Annas’s son-in-law, before whom the formal proceedings take place.
John 18:25
“And Simon Peter stood and warmed himself.”
John returns to Peter where he left him, at the fire.
“They said therefore unto him, Art not thou also one of his disciples?”
The question now comes from the group around the fire.
“He denied it, and said, I am not.”
The second denial, in the same words as the first.
John 18:26
“One of the servants of the high priest,”
A member of the household, who had been in the garden.
“being his kinsman whose ear Peter cut off,”
A relative of Malchus, with good reason to remember the man with the sword.
“saith, Did not I see thee in the garden with him?”
Eyewitness memory, tied to a time and a place, and much harder to brush aside.
John 18:27
“Peter then denied again:”
The third denial, given without any recorded words.
“and immediately the cock crew.”
At that very moment, exactly as Jesus had said at the supper (John 13:38).
Last revised