Deuteronomy 17
Blemished Offerings and the Punishment for Idolatry 1–7
The Central Judicial Authority 8–13
Laws Governing the King 14–20
Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain
Study Notes for Deuteronomy 17
Verse 1
blemish, or any evilfavouredness — The Hebrew for 'evilfavouredness' is 'evil thing', a flaw of any kind. The rule was given for firstlings in 15:21, 'lame, or blind, or… any ill blemish', and is called here an 'abomination' (to'ebah). Malachi charges priests who offered 'the blind for sacrifice' and 'the lame and sick' with the same fault (Mal 1:8).
Verse 2
in transgressing his covenant — 'Transgressing' is abar, to pass over, as a boundary is crossed. The charge is set before the offence is named: verse 3 says he 'hath gone and served other gods, and worshipped them, either the sun, or moon, or any of the host of heaven'. 'Man or woman' (v.5) are equally liable. Hos 8:1 speaks of those who 'have transgressed my covenant'.
Verse 5
stone them with stones — The condemned is taken 'unto thy gates', the town gates of 16:18, and stoned there. Stoning (saqal) is also the penalty in 13:10 for the one who enticed to other gods. When Achan was stoned, 'all Israel stoned him with stones, and burned them with fire' (Josh 7:25).
Verse 6
two witnesses, or three witnesses — A death sentence needs the 'mouth of two witnesses, or three', and 'one witness' is not enough. The rule is given for murder in Num 35:30 and generally in Deut 19:15. Christ repeats it for settling a dispute (Matt 18:16), and Hebrews recalls that under Moses a man 'died without mercy under two or three witnesses' (Heb 10:28).
Verse 7
The hands of the witnesses shall be first upon him — Those who testified carry out the sentence first, then 'the hands of all the people'. The order is that of 13:9. Christ's words to the accusers of the woman, 'let him first cast a stone at her' (John 8:7), use the same order. The closing line, 'So thou shalt put the evil away from among you', is echoed in 1 Cor 5:13.
Verse 8
between blood and blood, between plea and plea, and between stroke and stroke — Three pairs name the hard cases: bloodshed, lawsuits (din) and injuries (nega, a blow or plague). Such a matter goes up 'into the place which the LORD thy God shall choose'. Jehoshaphat set Levites, priests and chief fathers in Jerusalem 'for the judgment of the LORD, and for controversies' (2 Chr 19:8).
Verse 9
the priests the Levites, and… the judge — The case goes to the priests and to 'the judge that shall be in those days'. 'Enquire' is darash, the verb of 12:5 and 13:14. The priests are consulted because 'the priest's lips should keep knowledge, and they should seek the law at his mouth' (Mal 2:7), and Moses had delivered the law to them (Deut 31:9).
Verse 12
do presumptuously — Zadon is pride, the word of Prov 11:2, 'When pride cometh, then cometh shame'. The man who refuses the verdict of the priest and the judge dies, and 'thou shalt put away the evil from Israel'. Num 15:30 gives the same ground for the sin 'presumptuously': 'the same reproacheth the LORD'.
Verse 14
I will set a king over me, like as all the nations — Moses speaks of the request long before it was made. In 1 Sam 8:5 the elders say, 'make us a king to judge us like all the nations', and again in 8:20, 'that we also may be like all the nations'. The law of the king shows he was permitted, with conditions from the LORD.
Verse 15
whom the LORD thy God shall choose — The king is chosen by the LORD, and he is to come 'from among thy brethren'. Samuel said of Saul, 'See ye him whom the LORD hath chosen' (1 Sam 10:24). A 'stranger' (nokri, the foreigner of 15:3) is excluded. Jeremiah promises that 'their governor shall proceed from the midst of them' (Jer 30:21).
Verse 16
he shall not multiply horses — The verb rabah, to make many, occurs four times in vv.16–17 for horses, wives and silver and gold. Horses are tied to Egypt, from which the LORD said, 'Ye shall henceforth return no more that way'. Solomon 'had horses brought out of Egypt' (1 Kings 10:28), and Isaiah pronounces woe on those who 'stay on horses' (Isa 31:1).
Verse 17
neither shall he multiply wives to himself — The reason is given in the verse: 'that his heart turn not away'. Of Solomon it is said that 'his wives turned away his heart after other gods' (1 Kings 11:4), and Nehemiah asks, 'Did not Solomon king of Israel sin by these things?' (Neh 13:26). The same verb limits his silver and gold.
Verse 18
a copy of this law in a book — 'Copy' is mishneh, a duplicate or second, the same word as the 'double' hired servant in 15:18. Joshua wrote 'a copy of the law of Moses' on stones at Mount Ebal (Josh 8:32). The king writes his from the book 'before the priests the Levites', the keepers of the original.
Verse 19
he shall read therein all the days of his life — The king reads (qara) 'that he may learn to fear the LORD his God', the aim given to all the people in 4:10 and 31:12. It is the same charge as Joshua's: 'This book of the law shall not depart out of thy mouth; but thou shalt meditate therein day and night' (Josh 1:8).
Verse 20
to the right hand, or to the left — The king's heart is not to be 'lifted up above his brethren', the same word as in v.15, 'from among thy brethren'. Turning 'to the right hand, or to the left' is the phrase of Deut 5:32 and Josh 1:7. The reward is long days 'in his kingdom, he, and his children, in the midst of Israel'.