Skip to content
Share this page

Romans 2:28

“The Failure of the Privileged Jew”Romans 2:17–29

King James Version
For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
For G1063 he is G2076 not G3756 a Jew G2453, which is one outwardly G1722 G5318; neither G3761 is that circumcision G4061, which is outward G1722 G5318 in G1722 the flesh G4561:

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
A man is not a Jew because he is one outwardly, nor is circumcision only outward and physical.

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
For he is not a Jew who is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision which is outward in the flesh:

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
For he is not a Jew who is one outwardly, neither is that circumcision which is outward in the flesh;

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
For hee is not a Iewe, which is one outwarde: neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
For he is not a Jew who is so outwardly, neither is circumcision that which is outward in flesh;

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
16 Greek words
  1. οὐouNotG3756PRT-NNegative Particle Negative
  2. γὰρgarforG1063CONJConjunction
  3. ὁhothe [one]G3588T-NSMDefinite article Nominative Singular Masculine
  4. ἐνenonG1722PREPPreposition
  5. τῷtōtheG3588T-DSNDefinite article Dative Singular Neuter
  6. φανερῷphanerōoutwardG5318A-DSNAdjective Dative Singular Neuter
  7. ἸουδαῖόςIoudaiosa JewG2453N-NSM-PGNoun Nominative Singular Masculine Person Gentilic
  8. ἐστινestinisG1510V-PAI-3SVerb Present Active Indicative 3rd Singular
  9. οὐδὲoudeneitherG3761CONJ-NConjunction Negative
  10. ἡhēthe [one]G3588T-NSFDefinite article Nominative Singular Feminine
  11. ἐνenoutwardlyG1722PREPPreposition
  12. τῷtōtheG3588T-DSNDefinite article Dative Singular Neuter
  13. φανερῷphanerōoutwardG5318A-DSNAdjective Dative Singular Neuter
  14. ἐνeninG1722PREPPreposition
  15. σαρκὶsarkifleshG4561N-DSFNoun Dative Singular Feminine
  16. περιτομήperitomē[is] circumcisionG4061N-NSFNoun Nominative Singular Feminine
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Greek, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Greek text the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Greek word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “charity” where the word-by-word meaning reads “love”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Greek. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
See on the biblical-era maps
In the KJVVerse 27,991 of 31,102 · 90.0%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

Outward descent and a mark in the flesh fall short of what makes a person a Jew, and a circumcision, in God’s sight.

“For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly;”

Descent and outward identity, which people can see, fall short of what God means by a Jew.

“neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:”

The mark in the body alone falls short of the circumcision God asks for.

Passage studyRomans 2:17–29

A Jew Inwardly, Circumcised in Heart

Summary

Paul now speaks straight to the Jew. He lists what the Jew has been given: an honoured name, the law, a clear knowledge of God’s will, and a calling to be a guide and a light to those in darkness. Then he asks whether the teacher keeps what he teaches, naming stealing, adultery and sacrilege. Breaking the law dishonours God, and the prophets had already said that his name was blasphemed among the Gentiles because of his people. Circumcision profits the one who keeps the law, and an uncircumcised man who keeps it will be counted as circumcised and will judge the lawbreaker. Paul closes with the line the whole passage leads to: the true Jew is one inwardly, his circumcision is of the heart, by the Spirit, and his praise comes from God. These verses belong to the long argument of Romans 1–3, which shows every person in need of God’s grace.

Paul Speaks to the Jew Who Rests in the Law

Paul has described the Gentile world, which knew God from what he had made and held down the truth (Romans 1:18–32). He has spoken to the one who judges others while doing the same things, and he has shown that God renders to every man according to his deeds and has no respect of persons (Romans 2:1–16). In verse 17 he names the one he has had in view, so that Jew and Gentile alike stand under sin (Romans 3:9–20).

“Behold” is íde, an interjection meaning “lo” or “see”. It calls for attention and puts weight on what follows. Paul speaks to “thou”, one person who stands for his people, and that makes every line personal. The name he gives him is Ioudaîos, a Judaean, one who belongs to Judah, a name that goes back to Judah the son of Jacob. Paul grants the name its full honour. To be called a Jew was to belong to the people God had chosen, to whom he had given his covenant and his law.

The Jew “restest in the law”. The verb epanapaúomai means to settle on something and rely on it. The law was God’s gift, and this man has made his possession of it the ground of his security before God, so that leaning on it has become a settled ease. He also “makest thy boast of God”. Kaucháomai means to boast or glory, and it can be used in a good sense or a bad one. A psalm says, “My soul shall make her boast in the LORD” (Psalm 34:2), and Paul himself teaches believers to glory in the Lord, who has made Christ our wisdom, righteousness, sanctification and redemption (1 Corinthians 1:30–31). The boast in this verse rests on the privilege of being God’s people, while the life that should honour him is missing, as the next verses show. Later in the letter Paul says that boasting is shut out once we see that a man is justified by faith (Romans 3:27–28), and he counts his own former grounds for confidence in the flesh as loss, so that he may be found in Christ with the righteousness that is of God by faith (Philippians 3:4–9).

What the Law Had Given Him

Verse 18 lists what the law gave him. He “knowest his will”. Ginṓskō is the ordinary word for knowing or understanding, and thélēma is what God has determined and chosen, his purpose for how his people should live. The Gentiles knew of God from creation, and the Jew had God’s will spelled out in words. Moses told Israel that keeping these statutes would be their wisdom and understanding in the sight of the nations (Deuteronomy 4:5–6), and a psalm calls God’s word a lamp to the feet (Psalm 119:105).

He also “approvest the things that are more excellent”. Dokimázō means to test or examine something, and so to approve it once it has proved true. Diaphérō, behind “the things that are more excellent”, speaks of what stands apart from the rest and above it. With the law as his measure, the Jew could weigh choices and prefer what God counts best. Paul prays for this same discernment of what is excellent for the believers at Philippi (Philippians 1:9–10), and he gives them a list of excellent things to fill their thoughts (Philippians 4:8).

All this came from “being instructed out of the law”. Katēchéō means to sound something down into the ears, to teach by word of mouth, and it is the word behind our “catechize”. The law was read and taught in the synagogue, and the Jew had been thoroughly taught it.

A guide of the blind and a light in darkness

Verse 19 moves from what he knows to what he is sure he is. “Art confident” is peíthō, to persuade or convince, and in this form to be convinced and to rely on something. He is persuaded that he himself (seautoû, “thyself”) is “a guide of the blind”. A hodēgós is one who leads the way, a guide or teacher, and typhlós means blind, in the eyes or in understanding. He is also “a light of them which are in darkness”, with phōs, light, set against skótos, darkness.

These are good callings. God had spoken of a light to the Gentiles (Isaiah 49:6), and Israel saw itself as appointed to carry God’s truth to nations sunk in idolatry. Paul’s question is whether the guide can see. Jesus called the Pharisees blind guides who strain at a gnat and swallow a camel (Matthew 23:24), and he said that he had come so that the blind might see and those who claim to see might be shown to be blind (John 9:39–41).

The form of knowledge and of the truth

Verse 20 adds two more titles. “An instructor of the foolish” uses paideutḗs, a trainer, one who teaches and corrects, and áphrōn, one without understanding. “A teacher of babes” uses nḗpios, an infant who cannot yet speak, and so anyone simple or immature in the things of God. These are the Gentiles and the less taught, whom he means to bring along.

The ground of all this confidence is that he “hast the form of knowledge and of the truth in the law”. Mórphōsis means a formation or shape, the outline of something, and it can mean a formula. Gnōsis is knowledge. The law truly holds knowledge and truth, set out in words, and this man holds their outline in his mind. The next verses show that it has left his life unchanged. Paul warns Timothy of people who have a form of godliness (2 Timothy 3:5), and Jesus compared the scribes and Pharisees to whitewashed tombs, fair outside and corrupt within (Matthew 23:27–28). God’s answer was the promise of his law written on the heart (Jeremiah 31:33).

Teachest Thou Not Thyself?

From verse 21 the list of privileges becomes a list of questions. “Thou therefore which teachest another, teachest thou not thyself?” Didáskō, to teach, stands on both sides of the question, and the reflexive seautoû turns it back on the teacher. Each question that follows sets what he says against what he does.

“Thou that preachest a man should not steal, dost thou steal?” Kērýssō is to herald, to proclaim as a public crier, the word the New Testament chiefly uses for preaching the gospel. Kléptō is to steal, and the command he proclaims is the eighth commandment (Exodus 20:15).

“Thou that sayest a man should not commit adultery, dost thou commit adultery?” “Sayest” is légō, to speak or set out in words, here to lay down a moral rule. The command is the seventh (Exodus 20:14).

“Thou that abhorrest idols, dost thou commit sacrilege?” Bdelýssō means to find something disgusting and so to detest it, and it is used especially of idolatry. Eídōlon is an image made for worship, and so a heathen god. The commandments against other gods and graven images (Exodus 20:3–5) had taught Israel to loathe them. Hierosyléō means to be a temple-robber, to commit sacrilege.

How could a man who abhors idols commit sacrilege?

The word speaks of robbing a temple, laying hands on what is holy, and Paul leaves the deed unnamed. It may have been dishonesty with temple money or offerings, a light handling of sacred vows, or a general irreverence for God’s holy things. Whatever form it took, the man who stood firmly against one way of dishonouring God was guilty of another, profaning what belonged to God himself.

Boasting in the law and breaking it

Verse 23 gathers the charges into one. “Thou that makest thy boast of the law, through breaking the law dishonourest thou God?” Kaucháomai is the same verb as “makest thy boast of God” in verse 17. Parábasis is a violation or transgression, the breaking of a command. Diá, “through”, marks the means: it is by breaking the law that he dishonours God. Atimázō means to dishonour, to treat with contempt or bring to shame. The question expects the answer yes. The law is the source of his pride, and his conduct shames the God who gave it.

The law itself remains good. Paul says later, “the law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good” (Romans 7:12). The fault lies with the one who knows it, teaches it and breaks it. The LORD said through Isaiah that his people drew near with their lips while their hearts were far from him (Isaiah 29:13). Jesus told the crowds to do what the scribes and Pharisees taught and to leave their works alone (Matthew 23:3). He said, “Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven” (Matthew 7:21), and he warned against judging the mote in a brother’s eye while the beam is in our own (Matthew 7:3–5). The apostles say the same. Paul writes of those who profess to know God and deny him in their works (Titus 1:16), John calls the man who claims to know God and disobeys his commandments a liar (1 John 2:4), and James tells us to be “doers of the word, and not hearers only” (James 1:22), because “faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone” (James 2:14–18).

God’s Name Blasphemed Among the Gentiles

Verse 24 gives the reason this matters so much. “For the name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles through you, as it is written.” A name, ónoma, stands for the one who bears it, with his authority, character and reputation. To blaspheme, blasphēméō, is to speak evil of someone, to revile or defame him. Éthnos means a nation or people, and so the Gentiles. God set his people among the nations to be a light, and when they broke the law he gave them, the nations spoke evil of him because of them.

“As it is written” points back to the prophets, most likely to Isaiah 52:5, where the LORD says that his name is despised, or to Ezekiel 36:20–23, where Israel profaned God’s holy name among the nations to which they went. Paul is pointing to an old failure that the Scriptures had already exposed. Nathan told David that his sin had given the enemies of the LORD great occasion to blaspheme (2 Samuel 12:14). Paul later gives believers instructions with this very aim, that the word of God and his name should be kept from reproach (Titus 2:5, 1 Timothy 6:1). The same truth works the other way as well. Jesus tells his disciples to let their light shine before men, so that they may see their good works and glorify their Father in heaven (Matthew 5:14–16).

When Circumcision Is Made Uncircumcision

Verse 25 turns to the sign the Jew carried in his body. Peritomḗ is circumcision, the rite itself, the state of being circumcised, or the circumcised people. God gave it to Abraham as the sign of his covenant (Genesis 17:9–14), and it marked Israel off from the nations.

“For circumcision verily profiteth, if thou keep the law.” “Verily” is mén, a particle that affirms or concedes a point, and Paul grants that circumcision has real value. Ōpheléō means to be of use, to benefit. That benefit belongs to the one who keeps the law, the nómos, because the sign marked a covenant that called for a faithful life.

“But if thou be a breaker of the law” turns the other way with dé, “but”. A parabátēs is a transgressor, one who breaks the law. Then comes the conclusion: “thy circumcision is made uncircumcision.” Gínomai means to become, and akrobystía is the foreskin, and by extension the uncircumcised state and the uncircumcised people, the Gentiles. In God’s sight the lawbreaker who bears the mark stands where the Gentile stands, and the sign has lost the meaning it was given to carry. Paul says elsewhere that what counts is keeping the commandments of God (1 Corinthians 7:19) and, in Christ, faith working by love (Galatians 5:6).

The Uncircumcised Man Who Keeps the Law

Verse 26 draws the conclusion with “Therefore”. “If the uncircumcision keep the righteousness of the law, shall not his uncircumcision be counted for circumcision?” “The uncircumcision” is akrobystía again, here the Gentile. To keep is phylássō, to watch, guard and keep. “The righteousness of the law” is the law’s just requirements. To be “counted” is logízomai, to count or reckon, the verb Paul uses when he speaks of righteousness counted to a person. If such a man kept what the law requires, God would reckon him as circumcised, giving him the standing the sign was meant to mark.

The prophets had spoken this way long before. Moses told Israel, “Circumcise therefore the foreskin of your heart” (Deuteronomy 10:16). Jeremiah called Judah to circumcise their hearts (Jeremiah 4:4), and he warned that God would punish the circumcised together with the uncircumcised, because Israel was uncircumcised in heart (Jeremiah 9:25–26).

Verse 27 presses further. “Uncircumcision which is by nature” is the man uncircumcised by birth, phýsis being nature, what a person is by birth and descent. If he “fulfil the law”, teléō, carrying it through to the end, he will “judge” the circumcised lawbreaker. Krínō means to decide and so to condemn. This judgment is the witness of his life: his obedience makes plain the guilt of the one who had far more light. Paul has already spoken of Gentiles who do by nature the things contained in the law and show the work of the law written in their hearts (Romans 2:14–15).

The lawbreaker has “the letter and circumcision”. The letter is grámma, a writing, here the law in its written form. He has the written law and the sign, and he transgresses all the same. “Dost transgress” renders the noun parabátēs again, so Paul names the man for what he is, a transgressor of the law.

Can a Gentile be saved by keeping the law?

Paul’s letter answers this plainly: “by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight: for by the law is the knowledge of sin” (Romans 3:20). All have sinned and come short of the glory of God, and the righteousness of God comes by faith in Jesus Christ to all who believe (Romans 3:21–26).

Believers differ on who the law-keeping Gentile of these verses is. Some hold that Paul is putting a case in order to strip away the Jew’s trust in his sign: if an uncircumcised man did keep the law, God would honour that obedience above circumcision without it, and the rest of the argument shows that every person, Jew and Gentile, falls short. Others hold that Paul is describing Gentiles who have believed in Christ, whose hearts the Spirit has circumcised and in whom the righteous requirement of the law is fulfilled as they walk after the Spirit (Romans 8:2–14), the people of the new covenant who have God’s law written in their hearts (Hebrews 8:10). On both readings God looks for obedience that comes from the heart, and the sign in the flesh holds no merit of its own.

A Jew Inwardly, Circumcised in Heart

The passage ends with Paul’s own conclusion. “For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh: but he is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit, and not in the letter; whose praise is not of men, but of God.”

“Outwardly” and “outward” both render en with phanerós, “in what is visible”, what lies open to sight. “In the flesh” is sárx, the body. “Inwardly” renders en with kryptós, “in what is hidden”, the secret inner life. So Paul sets what everyone can see beside what only God sees. Descent from Abraham and the mark in the body can be seen. The Jew God counts as his own is the one whose heart God has dealt with.

What is the circumcision of the heart?

Circumcision of the heart is God’s work on the inner person, cutting away its stubbornness and rebellion and giving it wholly to him. The heart, kardía, is the inner life of thought and feeling. Moses promised that the LORD would circumcise the heart of his people and of their children, so that they would love him with all their heart (Deuteronomy 30:6). Paul tells the Colossians that in Christ they were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands (Colossians 2:11–12), and he tells the Philippians that those who worship God in the spirit, rejoice in Christ Jesus and put no confidence in the flesh are the true circumcision (Philippians 3:3).

This circumcision is “in the spirit, and not in the letter”. Pneûma means breath or wind, and by extension a spirit, and here it speaks of the Spirit of God, who does the work the written code could only command. The letter, grámma, is the same word as in verse 27, the law written down. Paul draws the same line in 2 Corinthians 3:6: “the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” Jesus spoke of worship “in spirit and in truth” (John 4:23–24). In Christ the new creature is what counts, and Paul speaks of “the Israel of God” (Galatians 6:15–16), where Jew and Gentile who believe stand together.

Praise that comes from God

“Whose praise is not of men, but of God.” Épainos is praise or commendation, and ánthrōpos here is people in general. The man who is a Jew outwardly can win the praise of other people, who see outward things. The man who is a Jew inwardly receives his praise from God, who sees the hidden heart and knows what his Spirit has done there.

Christ Kept the Law and Gives the Spirit

This passage leaves every one of us without a boast, and so it points to Christ. The law shows sin, and it was a schoolmaster to bring us to Christ (Galatians 3:24). Jesus came to fulfil the law (Matthew 5:17), he lived without sin (Hebrews 4:15), and at the end he could tell the Father that he had glorified him on the earth (John 17:4). He is the Word made flesh (John 1:14), “in whom are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge” (Colossians 2:3), the light of the world (John 8:12) and the way, the truth and the life (John 14:6). The teacher of verse 20 held the form of knowledge, and Christ lived every word he taught.

The law could never give the power to keep it, and God sent his Son so that the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in those who walk after the Spirit (Romans 8:2–14). Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believes (Romans 10:4). God made him to be sin for us so that we might be made the righteousness of God in him (2 Corinthians 5:21), and anyone in Christ is a new creature (2 Corinthians 5:17). Jesus himself was full of the Holy Ghost (Luke 4:1), and his Spirit now lives in those who belong to him, as God works in them (Philippians 2:13). In him Jew and Gentile, circumcised and uncircumcised, are made one new people, and he is their peace (Ephesians 2:11–22).

The name that was blasphemed among the Gentiles is the name God has exalted in Christ, so that every tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father (Philippians 2:9–11), and those who trust in Christ live to the praise of his glory (Ephesians 1:11–12). To the one who rested in the law, Jesus offers a better rest: “Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28).

Hearts God Himself Circumcises

Paul’s questions reach every one of us who knows the truth well, as they reached the teacher in Rome. The warning holds for anyone who leans on an outward mark of belonging, whether baptism, church membership, a Christian upbringing or a good knowledge of the Bible, while the heart stays as it was. It falls with special weight on those who teach, lead or bring up others, and it reaches everyone who claims the name of Christ, because the world still judges God by his people.

The passage also carries good news. The circumcision God asks for is one he performs himself, by his Spirit, as he promised through Moses. The praise he gives is his own, given to hearts he has made new. The God whose name was spoken against through his people’s sin has made that name glorious in Christ, and he looks with favour on the hidden work of his Spirit in us.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Romans 2:17–29. He set out his notes in a three-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 13 verses
Passage under commentRomans 2:17–29
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

In the latter part of the chapter the apostle directs his discourse more closely to the Jews, and shows what sins they were guilty of, notwithstanding their profession and vain pretensions. He had said (Romans 2:13) that not the hearers but the doers of the law are justified; and he here applies that great truth to the Jews. Observe,

I.He allows their profession (Romans 2:17-20) and specifies their particular pretensions and privileges in which they prided themselves, that they might see he did not condemn them out of ignorance of what they had to say for themselves; no, he knew the best of their cause.

1.They were a peculiar people, separated and distinguished from all others by their having the written law and the special presence of God among them.

(1.)Thou art called a Jew; not so much in parentage as profession. It was a very honourable title. Salvation was of the Jews; and this they were very proud of, to be a people by themselves; and yet many that were so called were the vilest of men. It is no new thing for the worst practices to be shrouded under the best names, for many of the synagogue of Satan to say they are Jews (Revelation 2:9), for a generation of vipers to boast they have Abraham to their father, Matthew 3:7-9.

(2.)And restest in the law; that is, they took a pride in this, that they had the law among them, had it in their books, read it in their synagogues. They were mightily puffed up with this privilege, and thought this enough to bring them to heaven, though they did not live, up to the law. To rest in the law, with a rest of complacency and acquiescence, is good; but to rest in it with a rest of pride, and slothfulness, and carnal security, is the ruin of souls. The temple of the Lord, Jeremiah 7:4. Bethel their confidence, Jeremiah 48:13. Haughty because of the holy mountain, Zephaniah 3:11. It is a dangerous thing to rest in external privileges, and not to improve them.

(3.)And makest thy boast of God. See how the best things may be perverted and abused. A believing, humble, thankful glorying in God, is the root and summary of all religion, Psalm 34:2; Isaiah 45:15; 1 Corinthians 1:31. But a proud vainglorious boasting in God, and in the outward profession of his name, is the root and summary of all hypocrisy. Spiritual pride is of all kinds of pride the most dangerous.

2.They were a knowing to people (Romans 2:18): and knowest his will, thelēma - the will. God's will is the will, the sovereign, absolute, irresistible will. The world will then, and not till then, be set to rights, when God's will is the only will, and all other wills are melted into it. They did not only know the truth of God, but the will of God, that which he would have them to do. It is possible for a hypocrite to have a great deal of knowledge in the will of God. - And approvest the things that are more excellent - dokimazeis ta diapheronta. Paul prays for it for his friends as a very great attainment, Philippians 1:10. Eis to dokemazein humas ta diapheronta. Understand it,

(1.)Of a good apprehension in the things of God, reading it thus, Thou discernest things that differ, knowest how to distinguish between good and evil, to separate between the precious and the vile (Jeremiah 15:19), to make a difference between the unclean and the clean, Leviticus 11:47. Good and bad lie sometimes so near together that it is not easy to distinguish them; but the Jews, having the touchstone of the law ready at hand, were, or at least thought they were, able to distinguish, to cleave the hair in doubtful cases. A man may be a good casuist and yet a bad Christian - accurate in the notion, but loose and careless in the application. Or, we may, with De Dieu, understand controversies by the ta diapheronta. A man may be well skilled in the controversies of religion, and yet a stranger to the power of godliness.

(2.)Of a warm affection to the things of God, as we read it, Approvest the things that are excellent. There are excellences in religion which a hypocrite may approve of: there may be a consent of the practical judgment to the law, that it is good, and yet that consent overpowerd by the lusts of the flesh, and of the mind: -

- Video meliora proboque

Deteriora sequor.

I see the better, but pursue the worse.

and it is common for sinners to make that approbation an excuse which is really a very great aggravation of a sinful course. They got this acquaintance with, and affection to, that which is good, but being instructed out of the law, katēchoumenos - being catechised. The word signifies an early instruction in childhood. It is a great privilege and advantage to be well catechised betimes. It was the custom of the Jews to take a great deal of pains in teaching their children when they were young, and all their lessons were out of the law; it were well if Christians were but as industrious to teach their children out of the gospel. Now this is called (Romans 2:20), The form of knowledge, and of the truth in the law, that is, the show and appearance of it. Those whose knowledge rests in an empty notion, and does not make an impression on their hearts, have only the form of it, like a picture well drawn and in good colours, but which wants life. A form of knowledge produces but a form of godliness, 2 Timothy 3:5. A form of knowledge may deceive men, but cannot impose upon the piercing eye of the heart-searching God. A form may be the vehicle of the power; but he that takes up with that only is like sounding brass and a tinkling cymbal.

3.They were a teaching people, or at least thought themselves so (Romans 2:19, Romans 2:20): And art confident that thou thyself art a guide of the blind. Apply it,

(1.)To the Jews in general. They thought themselves guides to the poor blind Gentiles that sat in darkness, were very proud of this, that whoever would have the knowledge of God must be beholden to them for it. All other nations must come to school to them, to learn what is good, and what the Lord requires; for they had the lively oracles.

(2.)To their rabbis, and doctors, and leading men among them, who were especially those that judged others, Romans 2:1. These prided themselves much in the possession they had got of Moses's chair, and the deference which the vulgar paid to their dictates; and the apostle expresses this in several terms, a guide of the blind, a light of those who are in darkness, an instructor of the foolish, a teacher of babes, the better to set forth their proud conceit of themselves, and contempt of others. This was a string they loved to be harping upon, heaping up titles of honour upon themselves. The best work, when it is prided in, is unacceptable to God. It is good to instruct the foolish, and to teach the babes: but considering our own ignorance, and folly, and inability to make these teachings successful without God, there is nothing in it to be proud of.

II.He aggravates their provocations (Romans 2:21-24) from two things: -

1.That they sinned against their knowledge and profession, did that themselves which they taught others to avoid: Thou that teachest another, teachest thou not thyself? Teaching is a piece of that charity which begins at home, though it must not end there. It was the hypocrisy of the Pharisees that they did not do as they taught (Matthew 23:3), but pulled down with their lives what they built up with their preaching; for who will believe those who do not believe themselves? Examples will govern more than rules. The greatest obstructors of the success of the word are those whose bad lives contradict their good doctrine, who in the pulpit preach so well that it is a pity they should ever come out, and out of the pulpit live so ill that it is a pity they should ever come in. He specifies three particular sins that abound among the Jews: - (1.) Stealing. This is charged upon some that declared God's statutes (Psalm 50:16, Psalm 50:18), When thou sawest a thief, then thou consentedst with him. The Pharisees are charged with devouring widows' houses (Matthew 23:14), and that is the worst of robberies. (2.) Adultery, Romans 2:22. This is likewise charged upon that sinner (Psalm 50:18), Thou hast been partaker with adulterers. Many of the Jewish rabbin are said to have been notorious for this sin. (3.) Sacrilege - robbing in holy things, which were then by special laws dedicated and devoted to God; and this is charged upon those that professed to abhor idols. So the Jews did remarkably, after their captivity in Babylon; that furnace separated them for ever from the dross of their idolatry, but they dealt very treacherously in the worship of God. It was in the latter days of the Old Testament church that they were charged with robbing God in tithes and offerings (Malachi 3:8, Malachi 3:9), converting that to their own use, and to the service of their lusts, which was, in a special manner, set apart for God. And this is almost equivalent to idolatry, though this sacrilege was cloaked with the abhorrence of idols. Those will be severely reckoned with another day who, while they condemn sin in others, do the same, or as bad, or worse, themselves.

2.That they dishonoured God by their sin, Romans 2:23, Romans 2:24. While God and his law were an honour to them, which they boasted of and prided themselves in, they were a dishonour to God and his law, by giving occasion to those that were without to reflect upon their religion, as if that did countenance and allow of such things, which, as it is their sin who draw such inferences (for the faults of professors are not to be laid upon professions), so it is their sin who give occasion for those inferences, and will greatly aggravate their miscarriages. This was the condemnation in David's case, that he had given great occasion to the enemies of the Lord to blaspheme, 2 Samuel 12:14. And the apostle here refers to the same charge against their forefathers: As it is written, Romans 2:24. He does not mention the place, because he wrote this to those that were instructed in the law (in labouring to convince, it is some advantage to deal with those that have knowledge and are acquainted with the scripture), but he seems to point at Isaiah 52:5; Ezekiel 36:22, Ezekiel 36:23; and 2 Samuel 12:14. It is a lamentation that those who were made to be to God for a name and for a praise should be to him a shame and dishonour. The great evil of the sins of professors is the dishonour done to God and religion by their profession. "Blasphemed through you; that is, you give the occasion for it, it is through your folly and carelessness. The reproaches you bring upon yourselves reflect upon your God, and religion is wounded through your sides." A good caution to professors to walk circumspectly. See 1 Timothy 6:1.

III.He asserts the utter insufficiency of their profession to clear them from the guilt of these provocations (Romans 2:25-29):

Circumcision verily profiteth, if thou keep the law; that is, obedient Jews shall not lose the reward of their obedience, but will gain this by their being Jews, that they have a clearer rule of obedience than the Gentiles have. God did not give the law nor appoint circumcision in vain. This must be referred to the state of the Jews before the ceremonial polity was abolished, otherwise circumcision to one that professed faith in Christ was forbidden, Galatians 5:1. But he is here speaking to the Jews, whose Judaism would benefit them, if they would but live up to the rules and laws of it; but if not "thy circumcision is made uncircumcision; that is, thy profession will do thee no good; thou wilt be no more justified than the uncircumcised Gentiles, but more condemned for sinning against greater light." The uncircumcised are in scripture branded as unclean (Isaiah 52:1), as out of the covenant, (Ephesians 2:11, Ephesians 2:12) and wicked Jews will be dealt with as such. See Jeremiah 9:25, Jeremiah 9:26. Further to illustrate this,

1.He shows that the uncircumcised Gentiles, if they live up to the light they have, stand upon the same level with the Jews; if they keep the righteousness of the law (Romans 2:26), fulfil the law (Romans 2:27); that is, by submitting sincerely to the conduct of natural light, perform the matter of the law. Some understand it as putting the case of a perfect obedience to the law: "If the Gentiles could perfectly keep the law, they would be justified by it as well as the Jews." But it seems rather to be meant of such an obedience as some of the Gentiles did attain to. The case of Cornelius will clear it. Though he was a Gentile, and uncircumcised, yet, being a devout man, and one that feared God with all his house (Acts 10:2), he was accepted, Romans 2:4. Doubtless, there were many such instances: and they were the uncircumcision, that kept the righteousness of the law; and of such he says,

(1.)That they were accepted with God, as if they had been circumcised. Their uncircumcision was counted for circumcision. Circumcision was indeed to the Jews a commanded duty, but it was not to all the world a necessary condition of justification and salvation.

(2.)That their obedience was a great aggravation of the disobedience of the Jews, who had the letter of the law, Romans 2:27. Judge thee, that is, help to add to thy condemnation, who by the letter and circumcision dost transgress. Observe, To carnal professors the law is but the letter; they read it as a bare writing, but are not ruled by it as a law. They did transgress, not only notwithstanding the letter and circumcision, but by it, that is, they thereby hardened themselves in sin. External privileges, if they do not do us good, do us hurt. The obedience of those that enjoy less means, and make a less profession, will help to condemn those that enjoy greater means, and make a greater profession, but do not live up to it.

2.He describes the true circumcision, Romans 2:28, Romans 2:29.

(1.)It is not that which is outward in the flesh and in the letter. This is not to drive us off from the observance of external institutions (they are good in their place), but from trusting to them and resting in them as sufficient to bring us to heaven, taking up with a name to live, without being alive indeed. He is not a Jew, that is, shall not be accepted of God as the seed of believing Abraham, nor owned as having answered the intention of the law. To be Abraham's children is to do the works of Abraham, John 8:39, John 8:40.

(2.)It is that which is inward, of the heart, and in the spirit. It is the heart that God looks at, the circumcising of the heart that renders us acceptable to him. See Deuteronomy 30:6. This is the circumcision that is not made with hands, Colossians 2:11, Colossians 2:12. Casting away the body of sin. So it is in the spirit, in our spirit as the subject, and wrought by God's Spirit as the author of it.

(3.)The praise thereof, though it be not of men, who judge according to outward appearance, yet it is of God, that is, God himself will own and accept and crown this sincerity; for he seeth not as man seeth. Fair pretences and a plausible profession may deceive men: but God cannot be so deceived; he sees through shows to realities. This is alike true of Christianity. He is not a Christian that is one outwardly, nor is that baptism which is outward in the flesh; but he is a Christian that is one inwardly, and baptism is that of the heart, in the spirit, and not in the letter, whose praise is not of men but of God.

Historical interpretation

Two Centuries of Reception

5 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

5 quotes · AD 220–418
Ante-NicenePost-Nicene
200300400

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

d. AD 220TertullianAnte-NiceneSourceAgainst Marcion Book V
Since this is the circumcision recommended by Jeremiah: "Circumcise (yourselves to the Lord, and take away) the foreskins of your heart; " and even of Moses: "Circumcise, therefore, the hardness of your heart," -the Spirit which circumcises the heart will proceed from Him who prescribed the letter also which clips the flesh; and "the Jew which is one inwardly" will be a subject of the self-same God as he also is who is "a Jew outwardly; " because the apostle would have preferred not to have mentioned a Jew at all, unless he were a servant of the God of the Jews.
d. AD 220TertullianAnte-NiceneSourceTo His Wife Book I
And so to the Law presently had to succeed the Word of God introducing the spiritual circumcision. Therefore, by means of the wide licence of those days, materials for subsequent emendations were furnished beforehand, of which materials the Lord by His Gospel, and then the apostle in the last days of the (Jewish) age, either cut off the redundancies or regulated the disorders.
On exactly the same principle, they consider the special soil of Judµa to be that very holy land, which ought rather to be interpreted of the Lord's flesh, which, in all those who put on Christ, is thenceforward the holy land; holy indeed by the indwelling of the Holy Ghost, truly flowing with milk and honey by the sweetness of His assurance, truly Judµan by reason of the friendship of God. For "he is not a Jew which is one outwardly, but he who is one inwardly." In the same way it is that both God's temple and Jerusalem (must be understood) when it is said by Isaiah: "Awake, awake, O Jerusalem! put on the strength of thine arm; awake, as in thine earliest time," that is to say, in that innocence which preceded the fall into sin.
d. AD 418PelagiusPost-NiceneSourcePELAGIUS’S COMMENTARY ON ROMANS
This is the true Jew, for everything which was previously done externally was but an image of what was meant to happen internally.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Romans 2:28 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8