TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Commentary on Mark 8 verses 10–21
Still Christ is upon motion; now he visits the parts of Dalmanutha, that no corner of the land of Israel might say that they had not had his presence with them. He came thither by ship (Mar 8:10); but, meeting with occasions of dispute there, and not with opportunities of doing good, he entered into the ship again (Mar 8:13), and came back. In these verses, we are told,
I. How he refused to gratify the Pharisees, who challenged him to give them a sign from heaven. They came forth on purpose to question with him; not to propose questions to him, that they might learn of him, but to cross question with him, that they might ensnare him.
1.They demanded of him a sign from heaven, as if the signs he gave them on earth, which were more familiar to them, and were more capable of being examined and enquired into, were not sufficient. There was a sign from heaven at his baptism, in the descent of the dove, and the voice (Mat 3:16, Mat 3:17); it was public enough; and if they had attended John's baptism as they ought to have done, they might themselves have seen it. Afterward, when he was nailed to the cross, they prescribed a new sign; Let him come down from the cross, and we will believe him; thus obstinate infidelity will still have something to say, though ever so unreasonable. They demanded this sign, tempting him; not in hopes that he would give it them, that they might be satisfied, but in hopes that he would not, that they might imagine themselves to have a pretence for their infidelity.
2.He denied them their demand; He sighed deeply in his spirit, Mar 8:12. He groaned (so some), being grieved for the hardness of their hearts, and the little influence that his preaching and miracles had had upon them. The infidelity of those that have long enjoyed the means of conviction, is a great grief to the Lord Jesus; it troubles him, that sinners should thus stand in their own light, and put a bar in their own door. (1.) He expostulates with them upon this demand; "Why doth this generation seek after a sign; this generation, that is so unworthy to have the gospel brought to it, and to have any sign accompanying it; this generation, that so greedily swallows the traditions of the elders, without the confirmation of any sign at all; this generation, into which, by the calculating of the times prefixed in the Old Testament, they might easily perceive that the coming of the Messiah must fall; this generation, that has had such plenty of sensible and merciful signs given them in the cure of their sick? What an absurdity is it for them to desire a sign!" (2.) He refuses to answer their demand; Verily, I say unto you, there shall no sign, no such sign, be given to this generation. When God spoke to particular persons in a particular case, out of the road of his common dispensation, they were encouraged to ask a sign, as Gideon and Ahaz; but when he speaks in general to all, as in the law and the gospel, sending each with their own evidence, it is presumption to prescribe other signs than what he has given. Shall any teach God knowledge? He denied them, and then left them, as men not fit to be talked with; if they will not be convinced, they shall not; leave them to their strong delusions.
II. How he warned his disciples against the leaven of the Pharisees and of Herod. Observe here,
1.What the caution was (Mar 8:15); "Take heed, beware, lest ye partake of the leaven of the Pharisees, lest ye embrace the tradition of the elders, which they are so wedded to, lest ye be proud, and hypocritical, and ceremonious, like them." Matthew adds, and of the Sadducees; Mark adds, and of Herod: whence some gather, that Herod, and his courtiers were generally Sadducees, that is, deists, men of no religion. Others give this sense, The Pharisees demanded a sign from heaven; and Herod was long desirous to see some miracle wrought by Christ (Luk 23:8); such as he should prescribe, so that the leaven of both was the same; they were unsatisfied with the signs they had, and would have others of their own devising; "Take heed of this leaven" (saith Christ), "be convinced by the miracles ye have seen, and covet not to see more."
2.How they misunderstood this caution. It seems, at their putting to sea this time, they had forgotten to take bread, and had not in their ship more than one loaf, Mar 8:14. When therefore Christ bid them beware of the leaven of the Pharisees, they understood it as an intimation to them, not to apply themselves to any of the Pharisees for relief, when they came to the other side, for they had lately been offended at them for eating with unwashen hands. They reasoned among themselves, what should be the meaning of this caution, and concluded, "It is because we have no bread; he saith this, to reproach us for being so careless as to go to sea, and go among strangers, with but one loaf of bread; he doth, in effect, tell us, we must be brought to short allowance, and must eat our bread by weight." They reasoned it - dielogizonto, they disputed about it; one said, "It was owing to you;" and the other said, "It was owing to you, that we are so ill provided for this voyage." Thus distrust of God makes Christ's disciples quarrel among themselves.
3.The reproof Christ gave them for their uneasiness in this matter, as it argued a disbelief of his power to supply them, notwithstanding the abundant experience they had had of it. The reproof is given with some warmth, for he knew their hearts, and knew they needed to be thus soundly chidden; "Perceive ye not yet, neither understand, that which you have had so many demonstrations of? Have ye your hearts yet hardened, so as that nothing will make any impression upon them, or bring them to compliance with your Master's designs? Having eyes, see ye not that which is plain before your eyes? Having ears, hear ye not that which you have been so often told? How strangely stupid and senseless are ye! Do ye not remember that which was done but the other day, when I broke the five loaves among the five thousand, and soon after, the seven loaves among the four thousand? Do ye not remember how many baskets full ye took up of the fragments?" Yes, they did remember, and could tell that they took up twelve baskets full one time, and seven another; "Why then," said he, "how is it that ye do not understand? As if he that multiplied five loaves, and seven, could not multiply one." They seemed to suspect that the one was not matter enough to work upon, if he should have a mind to entertain his hearers a third time: and if that was their thought, it was indeed a very senseless one, as if it were not all alike to the Lord, to save by many or few, and as easy to make one loaf to feed five thousand as five. It was therefore proper to remind them, not only of the sufficiency, but of the overplus, of the former meals; and justly were they chidden for not understanding what Christ therein designed, and what they from thence might have learned. Note, (1.) The experiences we have had of God's goodness to us in the way of duty, greatly aggravate our distrust of him, which is therefore very provoking to the Lord Jesus. (2.) Our not understanding of the true intent and meaning of God's favours to us, is equivalent to our not remembering of them. (3.) We are therefore overwhelmed with present cares and distrusts, because we do not understand, and remember, what we have known and seen of the power and goodness of our Lord Jesus. It would be a great support to us, to consider the days of old, and we are wanting both to God and ourselves if we do not. (4.) When we thus forgot the works of God, and distrust him, we should chide ourselves severely for it, as Christ doth his disciples here; "Am I thus without understanding? How is it that my heart is thus hardened?"
But for what sign from heaven were they asking? Maybe that he should hold back the sun, or curb the moon, or bring down thunderbolts, or change the direction of the wind, or something like that?… In Pharaoh’s time there was an enemy from whom deliverance was needed. But for one who comes among friends, there should be no need of such signs.
Let no one, however, be perplexed that the answer which Mark says was given to them, when they sought a sign from heaven, is not the same as that which Matthew relates, namely, that concerning Jonah. He says that the Lord's answer was, that no sign should be given to it; by which we must understand such an one as they asked for, that is, one from heaven; but he has omitted to say, what Matthew has related.
(Vict. Ant. e Cat. in Marc.) Matthew says, of the leaven of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees; Luke, however, of the Pharisees only. All three, therefore, name the Pharisees, as being the most important of them, but Matthew and Mark have each mentioned one of the secondary sects; and fitly has Mark added of Herod, as a supplement to Matthew's narrative, in which they were left out. But in saying this, He by degrees brings the disciples to understanding and faith.
(in Marc. 2, 33) The Pharisees, then, seek a sign from heaven, that He, Who had for the second time fed many thousands of men with a few loaves of bread, should now, after the example of Moses, refresh the whole nation in the last time with manna sent down from heaven, and dispersed amongst them all.
(ubi sup.) When, as related above, He was about to refresh the believing multitude, He gave thanks, so now, on account of the foolish petition of the Pharisees, He groans; because, bearing about with Him the feelings of human nature, as He rejoices over the salvation of men, so He grieves over their errors. Wherefore it goes on, And he groaned in spirit, and saith, Why doth this generation seek after a sign? Verily I say unto you, If a sign shall be given to this generation. That is, no sign shall be given; as it is written in the Psalms, (Ps. 89:36) I have sworn once by my holiness, if I shall fail David, that is, I will not fail David.
(ubi sup.) For a sign from heaven was not to be given to a generation of men, who tempted the Lord; but to a generation of men seeking the Lord, He shows a sign from heaven, when in the sight of the Apostles He ascended into heaven. It goes on, And he left them, and entering into a ship again, he departed to the other side.
(ubi sup.) Some may ask, how they had no bread, when they had filled seven baskets just before they embarked in the ship. But Scripture relates that they had forgotten to take them with them, which is a proof how little care they had for the flesh in other things, since in their eagerness to follow the Lord, even the necessity of refreshing their bodies had escaped from their mind.
(ubi sup.) Or, the leaven of the Pharisees is making the decrees of the divine law inferior to the traditions of men, preaching the law in word, attacking it in deed, tempting the Lord, and disbelieving His doctrine and His works; but the leaven of Herod is adultery, murder, rash swearing, a pretence of religion, hatred to Christ and His forerunner.
(ubi sup.) Taking occasion then from the precept, which He had commanded, saying, Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and of the leaven of Herod, our Saviour teaches them what was the meaning of the five and the seven loaves, concerning which He adds, And do ye not remember, when I brake the five loaves amongst five thousand, and how many baskets full of fragments ye took up? For if the leaven mentioned above means perverse traditions, of course the food, with which the people of God was nourished, means the true doctrine.
And sighing deeply in spirit, he said, "Why does this generation seek a sign? Truly, I say to you, if a sign will be given to this generation." He, who above thanked the crowd believing for heavenly benefit to be restored, now sighed and was saddened over the foolish petition of the Pharisees who did not believe and tempted, because truly bearing the nature of man, with real feelings of human nature, just as he rejoices over the salvation of men, so too he grieves and sighs over their errors. Hence also elsewhere, when many were led to salvation through the preaching of the apostles, it is written about him: "In that very hour he rejoiced in the Holy Spirit, and said: 'I thank you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that you have hidden these things from the wise and prudent, and have revealed them to little children'" (Luke 10). And when he was about to rebuke Judas' deed, he was troubled in spirit, as John writes, and he testified, and said: "Truly, truly, I say to you, that one of you will betray me" (John 13). But what he says, "If a sign will be given to this generation," means it will not be given, according to that in the Psalm: "Once I have sworn by my holiness; I will not lie to David" (Psalm 89), that is, I will not lie to David. Hence Saint Augustine, speaking of the harmony of the evangelists, bears witness that it is thus written in Mark: "And no sign will be given to it." Therefore, no sign will be given to that generation, that is, to those tempting the Lord and rejecting his words. Certainly a sign such as the tempters were seeking, this is to say, from heaven. Nevertheless, many heavenly signs he gave them on earth. Besides, to the generation seeking the gift, requiring the face of the God of Jacob, he showed a sign from heaven, when, with the apostles watching, he ascended into heaven, when, with the Spirit sent from above, he filled the primitive Church, when at the imposition of the hands of the apostles in Samaria, Caesarea, Ephesus, and many other cities and places, he ministered the grace of the Holy Spirit to the believers from heaven.
After that our Lord had worked the miracle of the loaves, He immediately retires into another spot, lest on account of the miracle, the multitudes should take Him to make Him a king; wherefore it is said, And straightway he entered into a ship with his disciples, and came into the parts of Dalmanutha.
Or they seek for a sign from heaven, that is, they wish Him to make the sun and moon stand still, to bring down hail, and change the atmosphere; for they thought that He could not perform miracles from heaven, but could only in Beelzebub perform a sign on earth.
Now the reason why the Lord did not listen to them was, that the time of signs from heaven had not arrived, that is, the time of the second Advent, when the powers of the heaven shall be shaken, and the moon shall not give her light. But in the time of the first Advent, all things are full of mercy, and such things do not take place.
The Lord indeed quits the Pharisees, as men uncorrected; for where there is a hope of correction, there it is right to remain; but where the evil is incorrigible, we should go away. There follows: Now they had forgotten to take bread, neither had they in the ship with them more than one loaf.
By a special providence1 also the disciples forgot to take bread, that they might be blamed by Christ, and thus become better, and arrive at a knowledge of Christ's power. For it goes on, And he charged them, saying, Take heed, and beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and of the leaven of Herod.
He means by leaven their hurtful and corrupt doctrine, full of the old malice, for the Herodians were the teachers, who said that Herod was the Christ.
But the disciples themselves thought that the Lord spoke of the leaven of bread. Wherefore it goes on, And they reasoned amongst themselves, saying, it is because we have no bread; and this they said, as not understanding the power of Christ, who could make bread out of nothing; wherefore the Lord reproves them; for there follows, And when Jesus knew it, he said unto them, Why reason ye because ye have no bread?
Continue studying Mark 8:12 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
CNTR CollationThe earliest Greek manuscripts of this verse, collated letter by letter.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
SUMMARY
In Mark 8:12, Jesus responds with profound sorrow and indignation to the Pharisees' demand for a sign from heaven, a request born of skepticism rather than genuine faith. His deep sigh reveals His grief over their spiritual blindness and persistent unbelief, culminating in His emphatic declaration that no sign will be given to such a generation, underscoring the futility of seeking external proof when the heart remains hardened to God's clear revelation.
CONTEXT
Literary Context: This verse immediately follows a pivotal moment in Jesus' ministry: the feeding of the four thousand in Mark 8:1-9, a miracle that mirrored the earlier feeding of the five thousand and demonstrated His divine power and compassion. Despite such overwhelming evidence of His authority and identity, the Pharisees, along with some Herodians, arrive in Mark 8:11 to question Him, "seeking of him a sign from heaven, tempting him." This demand is not an honest inquiry but a challenge, an attempt to trap Jesus and discredit His ministry. Jesus' response in Mark 8:12 highlights the spiritual chasm between His divine revelation and their hardened hearts, setting the stage for His subsequent warning to His disciples about the "leaven of the Pharisees and the leaven of Herod" in Mark 8:15.
Historical & Cultural Context: The Pharisees were a prominent Jewish religious sect known for their strict adherence to the Mosaic Law and oral traditions. They often clashed with Jesus, viewing Him as a threat to their authority and interpretations of the Law. In the first century, many Jews, including the Pharisees, anticipated a Messiah who would perform dramatic signs, particularly "signs from heaven," to authenticate His divine mission and liberate Israel from Roman rule. This expectation was rooted in biblical precedents like Moses' miracles or Elijah's calling down fire from heaven. However, their demand for a sign from Jesus was not a sincere search for truth but a test, a desire for a particular kind of proof that fit their preconceived notions, rather than recognizing the divine power already manifest in His teachings, healings, and provisions. Their skepticism was deeply ingrained, reflecting a broader spiritual malaise within segments of the Jewish leadership.
Key Themes: The passage powerfully articulates the theme of unbelief versus true faith. The Pharisees' demand for a sign, despite Jesus' numerous public miracles, exemplifies a profound spiritual blindness and a refusal to acknowledge God's work right before their eyes. This highlights the nature of divine revelation—that God reveals Himself not solely through spectacular displays on demand, but through consistent, life-transforming acts and teachings, culminating in the person of Jesus Himself. Jesus' refusal to perform on demand underscores His sovereign authority and His unwillingness to be manipulated or to validate Himself to those with hardened hearts. It also implicitly points to the cost of discipleship, as true faith requires a heart open to God's truth, not a constant need for external validation. This echoes the broader biblical narrative where God often operates through quiet faithfulness rather than sensationalism, challenging humanity to trust in His character and revealed Word, as seen in the later discussion of the "sign of Jonah" in Matthew 12:39-40.
EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS
Key Word Analysis
Verse Breakdown
Literary Devices
Mark 8:12 is rich with literary devices that amplify its theological message. The phrase "he sighed deeply in his spirit" is a powerful example of Pathos, evoking a strong sense of Jesus' profound sorrow, grief, and exasperation over the spiritual hardness and unbelief of the people. It's a deeply human and divine expression of lament. The question, "Why doth this generation seek after a sign?" functions as a Rhetorical Question, not requiring an answer but serving to highlight the utter futility and spiritual blindness of the Pharisees' demand. It underscores the irrationality of their persistent unbelief in the face of abundant evidence. Finally, Jesus' declaration, "There shall no sign be given unto this generation," employs Strong Negation or an absolute refusal. This definitive statement emphasizes the finality of His decision and the consequence of their hardened hearts, leaving no room for negotiation or further attempts to manipulate Him into performing on demand.
THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Mark 8:12 profoundly underscores the biblical truth that true faith is not predicated on a continuous demand for miraculous signs or supernatural phenomena, nor does God perform on demand for skeptical hearts. Jesus' deep sigh and subsequent refusal reveal His sorrow over humanity's spiritual blindness and its tendency to prioritize external validation over genuine receptivity to divine truth. This passage challenges the notion that more evidence will automatically lead to belief; rather, it suggests that a hardened heart will always find reasons to doubt, regardless of the signs presented. The ultimate revelation of God's power and love is not found in a spectacle to satisfy curiosity, but in the person and work of Jesus Christ, which demands a response of faith.
REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Mark 8:12 serves as a poignant mirror for self-reflection, urging us to examine the foundation of our own faith. Are we genuinely seeking to know and follow God, or are we, like the Pharisees, constantly demanding more proof, more signs, more validation before we fully commit? True faith, as demonstrated throughout Scripture, is not built on a continuous barrage of new miracles but on a trusting heart response to God's revealed character, His Word, and the overwhelming evidence already provided through Jesus Christ. This verse calls us to move beyond a transactional view of faith, where God must perform to earn our belief, towards a relational one, where our trust is rooted in His faithfulness and love. Jesus' deep sigh reminds us of His compassion and sorrow over human unbelief, prompting us to cultivate a spirit of humility, receptiveness, and trust in what God has already provided, rather than demanding what He has chosen not to give. Our faith should be resilient, grounded in the person of Christ, even when immediate or dramatic "signs" are not evident.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Why did Jesus sigh deeply in His spirit?
Answer: Jesus sighed deeply in His spirit (Greek: anastenázō) out of profound spiritual grief, exasperation, and sorrow. This was not a sigh of mere annoyance, but a visceral lament over the spiritual blindness and persistent unbelief of the Pharisees and the generation they represented. Despite having witnessed numerous miracles, heard His authoritative teaching, and experienced His compassion, they remained hardened, demanding a sign from heaven as if to test or trap Him. His sigh was a divine expression of anguish over their unwillingness to recognize God's work right before their eyes, revealing the depth of His emotional connection to humanity's spiritual state.
What does "this generation" mean in this context?
Answer: In this context, "this generation" (Greek: geneá) refers not merely to a chronological age group of people living at that specific time, but more significantly to a particular moral and spiritual disposition. It describes a type of people characterized by their unbelief, spiritual hardness, and a consistent refusal to acknowledge or respond to God's revelation. It is a spiritual indictment of those who, despite ample evidence, remain resistant to the truth and demand further, often manipulative, proof. Jesus uses the term to highlight the spiritual condition of those who sought a sign from Him without a genuine desire to believe.
Does Jesus' statement "There shall no sign be given unto this generation" mean God never gives signs?
Answer: No, this statement does not mean God never gives signs. Throughout biblical history, God has indeed given signs to confirm His word, His messengers, and His redemptive plan (e.g., the plagues in Egypt, the parting of the Red Sea, prophecies, and the miracles of Jesus). However, Jesus' refusal here is specific: He would not perform a sign on demand for those whose hearts were hardened and whose request was born of skepticism, malice, or a desire to manipulate Him, rather than genuine inquiry or faith. The ultimate and definitive sign given to "this generation" and all generations was not a spectacle on demand, but the resurrection of Jesus Christ, which He often referred to as "the sign of Jonah." This ultimate sign calls for faith, not further, insincere demands for proof.
CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
While Jesus emphatically declared that no sign would be given to "this generation" on their terms, His refusal itself points to the ultimate and most profound sign God would provide: the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead. This is the "sign of Jonah" that Jesus spoke of elsewhere (Matthew 12:39-40), where His burial for three days and subsequent rising would be the definitive proof of His divine identity and authority. The Pharisees sought a spectacle from heaven, but God's greatest sign was given through the cross and the empty tomb, an event that was both a stumbling block to the Jews and foolishness to the Gentiles, yet the power and wisdom of God (1 Corinthians 1:23-24). Jesus' deep sigh foreshadows His ultimate suffering and rejection, which paradoxically became the means of humanity's salvation. His refusal to perform a sign on demand highlights that true faith is not based on continuous miraculous displays but on the finished work of Christ, His death, and His glorious resurrection, which powerfully declared Him to be the Son of God (Romans 1:4). The call to "this generation" and all generations is to believe in the resurrected Christ, the ultimate sign of God's love and power, rather than to perpetually seek further proofs. This definitive act of God provides the foundation for all who would believe, inviting a faith that trusts in what has been revealed, not what is continually demanded.