TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Luke 11:29–36. His three-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.
Christ's discourse in these verses shows two things: -
I.What is the sign we may expect from God for the confirmation of our faith.
The great and most convincing proof of Christ's being sent of God, and which they were yet to wait for, after the many signs that had been given them, was the resurrection of Christ from the dead. Here is,
1.A reproof to the people for demanding other signs than what had already been given them in great plenty: The people were gathered thickly together (Luk 11:29), a vast crowd of them, expecting not so much to have their consciences informed by the doctrine of Christ as to have their curiosity gratified by his miracles. Christ knew what brought such a multitude together; they came seeking a sign, they came to gaze, to have something to talk of when they went home; and it is an evil generation which nothing will awaken and convince, no, not the most sensible demonstrations of divine power and goodness.
2.A promise that yet there should be one sign more given them, different from any that had yet been given them, even the sign of Jonas the prophet, which in Matthew is explained as meaning the resurrection of Christ. As Jonas being cast into the sea, and lying there three days, and then coming up alive and preaching repentance to the Ninevites, was a sign to them, upon which they turned from their evil way, so shall the death and resurrection of Christ, and the preaching of his gospel immediately after to the Gentile world, be the last warning to the Jewish nation. If they be provoked to a holy jealousy by this, well and good; but, if this do not work upon them, let them look for nothing but utter ruin: The Son of Man shall be a sign to this generation (Luk 11:30), a sign speaking to them, though a sign spoken against by them.
3.A warning to them to improve this sign; for it was at their peril if they did not.
(1.)The queen of Sheba would rise up in judgment against them, and condemn their unbelief, Luk 11:31. She was a stranger to the commonwealth of Israel, and yet so readily gave credit to the report she heard of the glories of a king of Israel, that, notwithstanding the prejudices we are apt to conceive against foreigners, she came from the uttermost parts of the earth to hear his wisdom, not only to satisfy her curiosity, but to inform her mind, especially in the knowledge of the true God and his worship, which is upon record, to her honour; and, behold, a greater than Solomon in here, pleion Solomōntos - more than a Solomon is here; that is, says Dr. Hammond, more of wisdom and more heavenly divine doctrine than ever was in all Solomon's words or writings; and yet these wretched Jews will give no manner of regard to what Christ says to them, though he be in the midst of them.
(2.)The Ninevites would rise up in judgment against them, and condemn their impenitency (Luk 11:32): They repented at the preaching of Jonas; but here is preaching which far exceeds that of Jonas, is more powerful and awakening, and threatens a much sorer ruin than that of Nineveh, and yet none are startled by it, to turn from their evil way, as the Ninevites did.
II.What is the sign that God expects from us for the evidencing of our faith, and that is the serious practice of that religion which we profess to believe, and a readiness to entertain all divine truths, when brought to us in their proper evidence. Now observe,
1.They had the light with all the advantage they could desire. For God, having lighted the candle of the gospel, did not put it in a secret place, or under a bushel; Christ did not preach in corners. The apostles were ordered to preach the gospel to every creature; and both Christ and his ministers, Wisdom and her maidens, cry in the chief places of concourse, Luk 11:33. It is a great privilege that the light of the gospel is put on a candlestick, so that all that come in may see it, and may see by it where they are and whither they are going, and what is the true, and sure, and only way to happiness.
2.Having the light, their concern was to have the sight, or else to what purpose had they the light? Be the object ever so clear, if the organ be not right, we are never the better: The light of the body is the eye (Luk 11:34), which receives the light of the candle when it is brought into the room. So the light of the soul is the understanding and judgment, and its power of discerning between good and evil, truth and falsehood. Now, according as this is, so the light of divine revelation is to us, and our benefit by it; it is a savour of life unto life, or of death unto death.
(1.)If this eye of the soul be single, if it see clear, see things as they are, and judge impartially concerning them, if it aim at truth only, and seek it for its own sake, and have not any sinister by - looks and intentions, the whole body, that is, the whole soul, is full of light, it receives and entertains the gospel, which will bring along with it into the soul both knowledge and joy. This denotes the same thing with that of the good ground, receiving the word and understanding it. If our understanding admits the gospel in its full light, it fills the soul, and it has enough to fill it. And if the soul be thus filled with the light of the gospel, having no part dark, - if all its powers and faculties be subjected to the government and influence of the gospel, and none left unsanctified, - then the whole soul shall be full of light, full of holiness and comfort. It was darkness itself, but now light in the Lord, as when the bright shining of a candle doth give thee light, Luk 11:36. Note, The gospel will come into those souls whose doors and windows are thrown open to receive it; and where it comes it will bring light with it. But,
(2.)If the eye of the soul be evil, - if the judgment be bribed and biassed by the corrupt and vicious dispositions of the mind, by pride and envy, by the love of the world and sensual pleasures, - if the understanding be prejudiced against divine truths, and resolved not to admit them, though brought with ever so convincing an evidence, - it is no wonder that the whole body, the whole soul, should be full of darkness, Luk 11:34. How can they have instruction, information, direction, or comfort, from the gospel, that wilfully shut their eyes against it? and what hope is there of such? what remedy for them? The inference hence therefore is, Take heed that the light which is in thee be not darkness, Luk 11:35. Take heed that the eye of the mind be not blinded by partiality, and prejudice, and sinful aims. Be sincere in your enquiries after truth, and ready to receive it in the light, and love, and power of it; and not as the men of this generation to whom Christ preached, who never sincerely desired to know God's will, nor designed to do it, and therefore no wonder that they walked on in darkness, wandered endlessly, and perished eternally.
Historical interpretation
Seven Centuries of Reception
12 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.
Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.
The Queen of the South will condemn it because she is a type of the church. Just as she came to Solomon, so too the church came to our Lord, and just as she condemned this generation, so also will the church. If she, who wished to see wisdom that passes away and a king who was mortal, was judging the synagogue, how much more the church, which desires to see a king who does not pass away and wisdom which does not go astray, will judge? If we suffer with him, we will also be glorified with him.
The sign of Jonah served the Ninevites in two ways. If they would have rejected it, they would have gone down to Sheol alive like Jonah, but they were raised from the dead like him because they repented. Just as in the case of our Lord, who was set for the fall and the rising of many, people either lived through his being killed or died through his death.… They were asking him for a sign from heaven like thunder.… Jonah, after he went up from within the fish, was a negative sign to the Ninevites, because he proclaimed the destruction of their city. The disciples were also this way after the resurrection of our Lord.
(in Esai. 7.) A sign is a thing brought openly to view, containing in itself the manifestation of something hidden, as the sign of Jonas represents the descent to hell, the ascension of Christ, and His resurrection from the dead. Hence it is added, For as Jonas was a sign to the Ninevites, so shall also the Son of man be to this generation. He gives them a sign, not from heaven, because they were unworthy to see it, but from the lowest depths of hell; a sign, namely, of His incarnation, not of His divinity; of His passion, not of His glorification.
(Hom. 7. Cant.) Now as she was queen of the Ethiopians, and in a far distant country, so in the beginning the Church of the Gentiles was in darkness, and far off from the knowledge of God. But when Christ the Prince of peace shone forth, the Jews being still in darkness, thither came the Gentiles, and offered to Christ the frankincense of piety, the gold of divine knowledge, and precious stones, that is, obedience to His commands.
In this also is clearly expressed the mystery of the Church, which is gathered from the ends of the earth, in the penance of the Ninevites, and in the seeking of wisdom by the Queen of the South: so that she may know the peaceful words of Solomon, the Queen, indeed, whose kingdom is indivisible, arising from diverse and distant peoples into one body. Therefore, this is a great Sacrament... of Christ and the Church: but yet this is greater; because that took place in figure before, but now the mystery is fulfilled in truth; for there the type of Solomon, here Christ in His own body. Therefore, the Church consists of two things, so that either you may not know how to sin, or you may cease to sin; for repentance removes the offense, wisdom avoids it.
That you may know that the people of the Synagogue are treated with dishonour, while the blessedness of the Church is increased. But as Jonas was a sign to the Ninevites, so also will the Son of man be to the Jews. Hence it is added, They seek a sign; and there shall no sign be given them but the sign of Jonas the prophet.
Now as the sign of Jonas is a type of our Lord's passion, so also is it a testimony of the grievous sins which the Jews have committed. We may remark at once both the mighty voice of warning, and the declaration of mercy. For by the example of the Ninevites both a punishment is denounced, and a remedy promised. Hence even the Jews ought not to despair of pardon, if they will but practise repentance.
Herein also while condemning the Jewish people, He strongly expresses the mystery of the Church, which in the queen of the South, through the desire of obtaining wisdom, is gathered together from the uttermost parts of the whole earth, to hear the words of the Peacemaking Solomon; a queen plainly whose kingdom is undivided, rising up from different and distant nations into one body.
Now in a mystery, the Church consists of two things, either ignorance of sin, which has reference mainly to the queen of the South, or ceasing to sin, which relates indeed to the repentant Ninevites. For repentance blots out the offence, wisdom guards against it.
(non occ.) The judgment of condemnation comes from men like or unlike to those who are condemned. From like, for instance, as in the parable of the ten virgins, but from unlike, when the Ninevites condemn those who lived at the time of Christ, that so their condemnation might be the more remarkable. (Hom. 43. in Matt.). For the Ninevites indeed were barbarians, but these Jews. The one enjoying the prophetic teaching, the other having never received the divine word. To the former came a servant, to the latter the Master, of whom the one foretold destruction, the other preached the kingdom of heaven. To all men then was it known that the Jews ought rather to have believed, but the contrary happened; therefore he adds, For they repented at the preaching of Jonas, and, behold, a greater than Jonas is here.
(de Cons. Ev. lib. ii. c. 39.) Luke indeed relates this in the same place as Matthew, but in a somewhat different order. But who does not see that it is an idle question, in what order our Lord said those things, seeing that we ought to learn by the most precious authority of the Evangelist, that there is no falsehood. But not every man will repeat another's words in the same order in which they proceeded from his mouth, seeing that the order itself makes no difference with respect to the fact, whether it be so or not.
He will not grant you another sign, so that he may give holy things to dogs or throw pearls before swine.…He said only the sign of Jonah will be given to them. This means the passion on the cross and the resurrection from the dead.
Our Lord had been assailed with two kinds of questions, for some accused Him of casting out devils through Beelzebub, to whom up to this point His answer was addressed; and others tempting Him, sought from Him a sign from heaven, and these He now proceeds to answer. As it follows, And when the people were gathered thick together, he began to say, This is an evil generation, &c.
Not certainly by any authority to judge, but by the contrast of a better deed. As it follows, For she came from the utmost parts of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon; and, behold, a greater than Solomon is here. Hie in this place is not the pronoun, but the adverb of place, that is, "there is one present among you who is incomparably superior to Solomon." He said not, "I am greater than Solomon," that he might teach us to be humble, though fruitful in spiritual graces. As if he said, "The barbarian woman hastened to hear Solomon, taking so long a journey to be instructed in the knowledge of visible living creatures, and the virtues of herbs. But ye when ye stand by and hear Wisdom herself teaching you invisible and heavenly things, and confirming her words with signs and wonders, are strangers to the word, and senselessly disregard the miracles."
But if the queen of the South, who doubtless is of the elect, shall rise up in judgment together with the wicked, we have a proof of the one resurrection of all men, good as well as bad, and that not according to Jewish fables to happen a thousand years before the judgment, but at the judgment itself.
For just as Jonah was a sign to the Ninevites, so will the Son of Man be to this generation. He showed that the Jews, like the Ninevites, were overwhelmed with grave sins and close to destruction if they did not repent. Yet, just as punishment was announced to the Ninevites and a remedy was shown, so too should the Jews not despair of mercy if they are willing to do penance. But see what follows:
Now Jonas after he came forth from the whale's belly converts the men of Nineveh by his preaching, but when Christ rose again, the Jewish nation believed not. So there was a sentence already passed upon them, of which there follows a second example, as it is said, The queen of the south shall rise up in the judgment with the men of this generation, and condemn them.
Or because the South is praised in Scripture as warm and life-giving, therefore the soul reigning in the south, that is, in all spiritual conversation, comes to hear the wisdom of Solomon, the Prince of peace, the Lord our God, (i. e. is raised up to contemplate Him,) to whom no one shall come except he reign in a good life. But He brings next an example from the Ninevites, saying, The men of Nineveh shall rise up in judgment with this generation, and shall condemn it.
Continue studying Luke 11:30 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
CNTR CollationThe earliest Greek manuscripts of this verse, collated letter by letter.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
Luke 11:30 serves as Jesus' direct response to a generation demanding a miraculous sign, asserting that the only sign they will receive is that of Jonah. This declaration profoundly links the prophet Jonah's three days in the belly of the great fish and his subsequent emergence to Jesus' own impending death, burial, and resurrection. It underscores Jesus' identity as the ultimate divine revelation and highlights the spiritual blindness of those who, despite witnessing His unparalleled ministry, refused to believe, contrasting them sharply with the repentant Ninevites.
Context
Literary Context
This verse is embedded within a broader discourse where Jesus confronts a "wicked and adulterous generation" (as described in parallel accounts like Matthew 12:39) that seeks a sign from heaven. Immediately preceding Luke 11:29, Jesus states that no sign will be given except the sign of Jonah. Following this verse, Jesus further elaborates on the judgment that will fall upon "this generation" by referencing the Queen of the South and the Ninevites, both of whom will rise in judgment against them because they responded to lesser revelations than the one present in Jesus (see Luke 11:31-32). This entire section emphasizes the profound spiritual blindness and hardened hearts of many of Jesus' contemporaries, who, despite encountering the very Son of God, remained unrepentant.
Historical & Cultural Context
First-century Judaism was deeply steeped in messianic expectations, often accompanied by a desire for dramatic, heaven-sent signs that would authenticate the Messiah's arrival and power. Many expected a political deliverer who would overthrow Roman rule, and they sought miraculous displays of power to confirm such a figure. The story of Jonah was well-known, a prophet who delivered a message of judgment and repentance to a Gentile city, Nineveh. Nineveh itself was the capital of Assyria, a historical enemy of Israel, making their repentance a remarkable and humbling precedent. Jesus' audience would have been familiar with the concept of prophets performing signs, but His refusal to perform a sign on demand, instead pointing to His own future, was a direct challenge to their preconceived notions and a redefinition of what a true messianic sign entailed.
Key Themes
The central theme is The Sign of Jonah, which Jesus reinterprets as a direct prophecy of His own death, burial, and resurrection. Just as Jonah was in the belly of the great fish for three days and nights before being delivered and preaching to Nineveh (Jonah 1:17-3:5), so Jesus would be in the earth for three days before His triumphant resurrection, which would serve as the ultimate, undeniable sign of His divine authority and messianic identity (Matthew 12:40). This highlights Jesus as the Ultimate Sign, surpassing any prophet or miracle worker who came before Him. Another crucial theme is Repentance vs. Rejection. The Ninevites, despite being Gentiles and receiving a message from a reluctant prophet, repented at Jonah's preaching (Jonah 3:5). In stark contrast, "this generation" of Jews, who had the Son of God Himself ministering among them, performing miracles, and teaching with unparalleled authority, largely rejected Him and refused to repent. This sets up the theme of Divine Judgment and Mercy, where God's mercy is extended to the repentant, but judgment awaits those who harden their hearts against His ultimate revelation in Christ.
Exposition and Analysis
Key Word Analysis
From Hebrew origin (יוֹנָה, meaning "dove"), Jonas refers to the prophet Jonah, whose miraculous survival after being swallowed by a great fish became a prefigurement of Christ's resurrection. His story, particularly his three days and nights in the fish, is the specific event Jesus references as the "sign."
This term denotes an indication, especially one that is ceremonially or supernaturally significant. In this context, it refers to a miraculous event or phenomenon that serves as proof or authentication of divine authority or a divine message. Jesus is not merely offering a sign, but being the sign, embodying the ultimate divine authentication through His resurrection.
This word refers to a generation of people, implying both a period of time and the persons living within that period. Here, it specifically denotes Jesus' contemporary audience, highlighting their unique opportunity to encounter the Messiah directly and their tragic failure to recognize and respond to Him. It carries a connotation of a morally distinct group, characterized by their spiritual blindness and resistance to God's truth.
Verse Breakdown
"For as Jonas was a sign unto the Ninevites,"
This clause establishes a direct analogy. Jonah's unexpected survival from the great fish and his subsequent powerful preaching served as a compelling, undeniable sign to the people of Nineveh, leading them to widespread repentance. The miraculous nature of Jonah's deliverance authenticated his message and God's power.
"so shall also the Son of man be to this generation."
This clause completes the analogy, drawing a parallel between Jonah's experience and Jesus' own future. Just as Jonah's miraculous deliverance was the sign for Nineveh, Jesus' resurrection from the dead, after three days in the tomb, will be the definitive and ultimate sign for "this generation." The title "Son of Man" emphasizes both Jesus' humanity and His unique, divinely appointed messianic authority, particularly as the one who will undergo suffering, death, and resurrection, as prophesied in Daniel. This sign is not merely a display of power, but a profound theological statement about victory over death and the authentication of His entire ministry.
Literary Devices
Luke 11:30 is rich in Analogy and Simile, explicitly comparing Jonah's experience to that of the Son of Man using the structure "as...so." This literary device allows Jesus to explain a profound theological truth (His resurrection) by referencing a well-known historical and prophetic event. The prophet Jonah, and specifically his time in the fish, functions as Symbolism, prefiguring Jesus' death, burial, and resurrection. Jonah's emergence from the fish symbolizes Jesus' victory over the grave. Furthermore, there is a stark Contrast drawn between the Ninevites, who repented at the preaching of a lesser prophet and a less direct sign, and "this generation," who, despite the presence of the Son of God Himself and the promise of the ultimate sign, remained unrepentant. This contrast serves to highlight the spiritual hardness of heart among Jesus' contemporaries and to underscore the gravity of their rejection.
Theological and Thematic Connections
Luke 11:30 is a pivotal statement on the nature of divine revelation and human responsibility. It asserts that God has provided the ultimate sign in Jesus Christ, culminating in His resurrection. This sign is not merely a proof of power, but a call to repentance and faith, demonstrating God's sovereign plan for salvation and judgment. The verse highlights the radical difference between those who respond to God's truth, however inconvenient, and those who harden their hearts, even in the face of overwhelming evidence. It underscores the truth that true faith is not dependent on a continuous stream of sensational miracles, but on a humble response to God's definitive revelation in His Son. The "sign of Jonah" thus becomes the cornerstone of Christian faith, pointing to the empty tomb as the ultimate validation of Jesus' claims and the foundation of the gospel message.
Reflection and Application
Luke 11:30 serves as a profound challenge and comfort for believers today. It reminds us that God has already provided the most compelling evidence for His truth and the Messiah's identity in the person and work of Jesus Christ, especially His resurrection. We are not called to demand new signs or wonders, but to respond in faith and obedience to the revelation already given. For those who have placed their trust in Christ, the "sign of Jonah" is the bedrock of their hope, assuring them of victory over sin and death, and the promise of eternal life. For those who remain skeptical or resistant, this verse stands as a sober warning: to reject the ultimate sign is to invite judgment. It compels us to examine our own hearts: are we truly open to God's truth, even when it challenges our preconceived notions, or are we, like "this generation," seeking signs that conform to our own desires, rather than submitting to God's revealed will? Our response to Jesus, particularly His resurrection, determines our spiritual destiny.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
What exactly is 'the sign of Jonas' that Jesus refers to?
The "sign of Jonas" (or Jonah) refers specifically to the prophet Jonah's miraculous experience of being swallowed by a great fish and remaining in its belly for three days and three nights before being vomited out alive (Jonah 1:17). Jesus explicitly connects this event to His own impending death, burial, and resurrection, stating in Matthew 12:40 that "as Jonah was three days and three nights in the whale's belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth." Thus, the sign is Jesus' resurrection, which authenticates His identity as the Messiah and His victory over death.
Why did Jesus refuse to give other signs to "this generation"?
Jesus had already performed countless miracles—healing the sick, casting out demons, raising the dead, and demonstrating authority over nature—which were abundant signs of His divine power and messianic identity. However, the generation demanding a sign in Luke 11:29 sought a specific, spectacular sign from heaven, often for their own validation or to fit their preconceived notions of a Messiah. Jesus refused because their demand stemmed from a hardened heart and unbelief, not a genuine desire for truth. They had ample evidence but chose to reject it. For such a generation, no amount of signs would suffice; only a sign that addressed their deepest spiritual need—repentance—would be given, and that sign was His resurrection, which would confront them with the reality of His divine authority over life and death.
Who is 'this generation' Jesus refers to, and does it apply to people today?
"This generation" primarily refers to Jesus' contemporaries, particularly those religious leaders and people who witnessed His ministry firsthand but remained unrepentant and rejected His claims. They had the unique privilege of encountering the Son of God yet hardened their hearts. While the immediate context is historical, the principle applies universally. Any "generation" or individual that, despite ample evidence and exposure to the gospel of Jesus Christ, chooses to reject Him and remain in unbelief, stands in a similar position of spiritual blindness and faces the same implicit warning of judgment. The ultimate sign, Jesus' resurrection, remains the definitive proof and call to repentance for all people in every generation.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
Luke 11:30 finds its profound fulfillment in the person and work of Jesus Christ, who is the ultimate "sign" given by God to humanity. The prophecy of Jonah's three days in the fish is not merely a historical parallel but a type that points directly to Christ's death, burial, and glorious resurrection. Jesus, the Son of Man, entered the "heart of the earth" for three days, conquering sin and death, and emerging victorious, just as Jonah emerged from the belly of the great fish. His resurrection is the supreme authentication of His divine identity, His atoning sacrifice, and His victory over the grave (Romans 1:4). It is the definitive proof that He is the promised Messiah, the Son of God, and the only way to salvation (John 14:6). Unlike Jonah, who was a reluctant prophet, Jesus willingly laid down His life and took it up again (John 10:17-18). His resurrection is not just a historical event but the living hope for all who believe, demonstrating that God has indeed provided the ultimate and sufficient sign, calling all people to repentance and faith in the resurrected Lord (Acts 17:30-31).