Skip to content

Joshua 4:6

“The Command to Build a Memorial”· Joshua 4:1–9Read in context
King James Version
That this may be a sign among you, that when your children ask their fathers in time to come, saying, What mean ye by these stones?
KJV (with Strong's)
That this may be a sign H226 among H7130 you, that when your children H1121 ask H7592 their fathers in time to come H4279, saying H559, What mean ye by these stones H68?
Complete Jewish Bible
This will be a sign for you. In the future, when your children ask, 'What do you mean by these stones?'
Berean Standard Bible
to serve as a sign among you. In the future, when your children ask, ‘What do these stones mean to you?’
American Standard Version
that this may be a sign among you, that, when your children ask in time to come, saying, What mean ye by these stones?
World English Bible Messianic
that this may be a sign among you, that when your children ask in time to come, saying, ‘What do you mean by these stones?’
Geneva Bible (1599)
That this may bee a signe among you, that whe your children shall aske their fathers in time to come, saying, What meane you by these stones?
Young's Literal Translation
so that this is a sign in your midst, when your children ask hereafter, saying, What are these stones to you?
Translation
See on the biblical-era map
Crossing the Jordan and the Fall of Jericho
Crossing the Jordan and the Fall of Jericho View full PDF

Map © Biblica Open Bible Maps · CC BY-SA 4.0

In the KJVVerse 5,917 of 31,102 · 19.0%

Study this verse

Summary

Joshua 4:6 serves as a profound divine mandate for intergenerational remembrance, establishing the twelve stones taken from the miraculously parted Jordan River as a perpetual memorial. This verse anticipates future inquiries from children, prompting parents to recount God's powerful intervention in bringing Israel into the Promised Land, thereby ensuring that the nation's foundational faith and identity are continually rooted in the miraculous acts of their faithful God and passed down through active instruction.

Context

Literary Context

Joshua 4:6 is situated immediately after the dramatic and miraculous crossing of the Jordan River by the entire Israelite nation, an event orchestrated by God and led by the priests bearing the Ark of the Covenant. The preceding verses (Joshua 4:1-5) detail God's explicit command to Joshua to select twelve men, one from each tribe, to take a stone from the very spot in the middle of the Jordan where the priests' feet had stood firm. These twelve stones were then to be carried and set up as a memorial at Gilgal, their first encampment in the Promised Land. This specific verse provides the explicit divine rationale and pedagogical purpose for this physical monument: to serve as an enduring "sign" and a catalyst for future instruction. It flows directly from the command to erect the stones, explaining their profound purpose and anticipating the crucial opportunity they would create for the transmission of faith across generations.

Historical & Cultural Context

The crossing of the Jordan River marked a pivotal and climactic moment in Israelite history, signifying the definitive end of their forty years of wilderness wandering and their long-awaited entrance into the land promised to their ancestors. This event, occurring during the Jordan's flood stage (often in the spring harvest season, making the miracle even more impressive), powerfully mirrored the earlier miraculous parting of the Red Sea, thus reaffirming God's unwavering covenant faithfulness and His continued, active presence with His people. In ancient Near Eastern cultures, the erection of stone monuments (such as stelae or cairns) was a common and widely understood practice used to commemorate significant events, military victories, or solemn treaties. These physical markers served as tangible reminders and often as official historical or legal records. The command to erect these specific stones at Gilgal, the Israelites' inaugural camp in Canaan, aligns with this established cultural practice but profoundly elevates it with a unique theological purpose: not merely to record history, but to facilitate the ongoing narrative of God's redemptive acts within the family unit and the national consciousness of Israel.

Key Themes

This verse powerfully contributes to several overarching themes that are foundational within the book of Joshua and resonate throughout the broader Pentateuch. Firstly, it underscores Divine Faithfulness and Power, demonstrating God's absolute ability to fulfill His promises to Israel by miraculously clearing their path into the Promised Land, just as He had done when leading them out of Egypt. This act solidifies His reputation as a covenant-keeping God. Secondly, it highlights the critical theme of Remembrance and Memorialization, emphasizing the vital importance of not forgetting God's mighty deeds. The stones are explicitly designated as a tangible "sign" (Hebrew: 'owth) designed to provoke memory and testimony. Thirdly, and perhaps most prominently, it establishes the profound theme of Intergenerational Teaching and Discipleship. The explicit mention of children asking about the stones reveals God's intentional design for faith to be actively transmitted from one generation to the next, fulfilling the foundational mandate articulated in Deuteronomy 6:7. This ensures the continuity of Israel's unique covenant identity and their ongoing understanding of God's active and redemptive work among them, preventing spiritual amnesia and fostering a living faith.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Sign ʼôwth' H226

This term (H226) denotes a signal, mark, token, or miraculous sign that serves as a reminder or a pledge. Here, the twelve stones are an ʼôwth, a clear, visible marker designed by God to prompt questions and provide an opportunity to recount His powerful intervention at the Jordan. It implies a tangible, physical representation of an invisible, divine reality or event, specifically intended to evoke memory, understanding, and faith in God's character and actions. It is not merely a historical marker but a profound theological one.

Children bên' H1121

This word (H1121) refers to a son, but in the widest sense, encompassing offspring or descendants. The explicit mention of "children" (plural) highlights God's long-term vision for the perpetuation of faith. It emphasizes that the memorial is designed with future generations in mind, anticipating their natural curiosity and establishing a divine pattern for parents to actively engage in the spiritual formation of their offspring, ensuring the continuity of the covenant community.

Ask shâʼal' H7592

This verb (H7592) means "to inquire, request, or demand." The use of shâʼal here is crucial as it implies a natural, proactive curiosity and a seeking of understanding from the children. God orchestrates the situation so that the memorial stones will inherently provoke questions, creating an open door for the parents to teach. This highlights the pedagogical intent behind the memorial, emphasizing active engagement and dialogue rather than passive observation or rote memorization.

Verse Breakdown

"That this may be a sign among you"

This opening clause immediately establishes the divine purpose for the twelve stones taken from the Jordan. They are not merely an arbitrary collection of rocks but a divinely ordained "sign" (ʼôwth), a visible emblem of God's invisible power, faithfulness, and covenant presence. The phrase "among you" indicates its public, communal presence within the Israelite community, constantly visible and accessible, serving as a perpetual, tangible reminder of the miraculous Jordan crossing and God's active involvement in their history.

"[that] when your children ask [their fathers] in time to come"

This clause reveals the specific, intergenerational mechanism through which the sign is intended to function. God, with divine foresight, anticipates future generations, particularly children, who, upon encountering the unusual and prominent monument, will naturally inquire about its meaning. The phrase "in time to come" (Hebrew: mâchâr, literally "tomorrow" or "afterwards") emphasizes the enduring nature of this memorial and God's long-term vision for His people's spiritual formation. The responsibility of answering these crucial questions falls to "their fathers," highlighting the patriarchal role in transmitting faith and covenant identity.

"saying, What [mean] ye by these stones?"

This direct question, put into the mouths of future children, is the intended trigger for intergenerational instruction. It is a question of purpose, significance, and personal relevance, not just mere identification of objects. The children's innocent curiosity becomes the divine opportunity for parents to recount the mighty works of God, explaining the historical event of the Jordan crossing and its profound theological implications for Israel's identity as God's chosen people, ensuring that the memory of God's faithfulness is perpetually renewed.

Literary Devices

Joshua 4:6 employs several impactful literary devices that enhance its message and pedagogical intent. Anticipation is central, as the verse projects into the future, foreseeing the natural questions of future generations. This literary foresight underscores the enduring relevance of God's acts and the intentionality of His plan for intergenerational faith transmission. The stones themselves function as powerful Symbolism, representing God's miraculous power, His unwavering covenant faithfulness, and the nation's new beginning in the Promised Land. They are a tangible, physical manifestation of an extraordinary divine intervention, designed to evoke memory and understanding. Furthermore, the entire passage is deeply Didactic, designed explicitly to teach and instruct. The very purpose of the stones, as explained in this verse, is to serve as a teaching aid, creating a natural pedagogical moment for parents to impart foundational truths about God to their children. This didacticism is reinforced by the direct quotation of the children's anticipated question, framing the narrative as an ongoing, living lesson.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Joshua 4:6 profoundly articulates God's unwavering commitment to ensuring that His redemptive acts are remembered and faithfully passed down through the generations. It underscores the vital principle that faith is not merely a personal conviction but a communal heritage, deeply rooted in historical events where God has powerfully revealed His character, power, and faithfulness. The memorial stones serve as a tangible link between past divine intervention and future spiritual formation, demonstrating that God desires His people to continually reflect on His mighty works as the foundational basis for their trust, obedience, and identity. This act of remembering is absolutely crucial for maintaining national identity, preventing spiritual amnesia, and ensuring that each successive generation understands its unique place within God's unfolding story of salvation and covenant relationship.

Reflection and Application

Joshua 4:6 offers a timeless and profoundly relevant blueprint for spiritual formation within families and communities today. It calls us to cultivate a posture of active remembrance, diligently recalling and celebrating God's faithfulness in our personal lives and in the broader history of redemption. Just as the stones at Gilgal were a physical prompt for inquiry and instruction, we are encouraged to identify and intentionally create our own "spiritual markers"—whether through family traditions, personal testimonies, journaling, regular recounting of God's goodness, or even physical mementos—that serve as tangible reminders of His work. This verse also places a profound emphasis on the sacred duty and privilege of intergenerational teaching. It's not enough for us to merely know God's story; we are commissioned to tell it, to anticipate the spiritual questions of the next generation, and to patiently, joyfully, and faithfully articulate the meaning and implications of God's interventions. In a world increasingly prone to historical and spiritual forgetfulness, this passage challenges us to be intentional, compelling storytellers of God's grace, ensuring that the legacy of faith endures and flourishes for generations to come.

Questions for Reflection

  1. What "stones" or significant moments of God's faithfulness have you experienced in your own life that you need to intentionally remember and recount?
  2. How are you actively creating "memorials" or establishing practices in your family or community to pass on the story of God's work to the next generation?
  3. In what specific ways can you better anticipate and respond to the spiritual questions of children or younger believers in your life, fostering genuine curiosity?
  4. What is the profound "meaning" of God's past actions for your present faith, your daily walk, and your future hope?

FAQ

What was the significance of the Jordan River crossing for the Israelites?

The Jordan River crossing was immensely significant for the Israelites for several profound reasons. Theologically, it served as a powerful demonstration of God's continued faithfulness to His covenant promises, mirroring the earlier Red Sea crossing and affirming that the same omnipotent God who delivered them from Egyptian bondage was now actively leading them into the Promised Land. It was a clear sign that God was indeed with Joshua, just as He had been with Moses (Joshua 3:7), thus legitimizing Joshua's leadership. Strategically, it marked their definitive and miraculous entry into Canaan, ending their forty years of wilderness wanderings and initiating the conquest of the land God had sworn to their ancestors. Furthermore, it was a clear, undeniable miracle that would have instilled both awe and renewed faith in Israel and profound fear in the inhabitants of Canaan (Joshua 5:1), preparing the way for future victories.

Why were "fathers" specifically mentioned as the ones to answer the children's questions?

The specific mention of "fathers" reflects the patriarchal structure of ancient Israelite society, where the father was typically the head of the household and bore primary responsibility for the religious instruction and moral upbringing of his children. This aligns with broader biblical mandates, such as those found in Deuteronomy 6:6-7, which instruct parents (implicitly, the father as the head) to diligently teach God's commands and mighty acts to their children. While mothers also played a vital role in education within the home, the father's role in public and formal instruction, especially concerning national history, covenant identity, and theological truths, was particularly emphasized. This highlights the divine intention for faith to be transmitted robustly within the family unit, with the father serving as a key spiritual leader, storyteller, and guardian of the covenant narrative.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

The memorial stones of Joshua 4:6, designed to provoke questions and facilitate the recounting of God's mighty acts, find their ultimate fulfillment and deepest meaning in Jesus Christ, who is the supreme "sign" and the very embodiment of God's faithfulness and redemptive power. Just as the Jordan crossing signaled Israel's entry into their promised inheritance, Christ's sacrificial death and glorious resurrection open the way for believers to enter into the new covenant inheritance—eternal life, reconciliation with God, and participation in His glorious kingdom. The stones pointed to a historical act of salvation, but Christ Himself is the living memorial of God's ultimate salvation, the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Our "children," both physical and spiritual, now ask not merely "What mean ye by these stones?" but "What mean ye by the cross?" or "Who is this Jesus?" And our answer, empowered by the Holy Spirit, is the Gospel: that God, in Christ, has perfectly fulfilled all His promises, parted the waters of sin and death, and brought us into His glorious and eternal kingdom. The New Covenant's primary "memorial" is the Lord's Supper, where we "proclaim the Lord's death until he comes" (1 Corinthians 11:26), ensuring that the central, most pivotal act of God's redemptive history—Christ's atoning sacrifice—is continually remembered, celebrated, and passed on to every generation. He is the ultimate sign, the living Word, and the one through whom all God's promises are "Yes" and "Amen" (2 Corinthians 1:20).

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Joshua 4:1–9. His two-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 9 verses
Passage under commentJoshua 4:1–9
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points

We may well imagine how busy Joshua and all the men of war were while they were passing over Jordan, when besides their own marching into an enemy's country, and in the face of the enemy, which could not but occasion them many thoughts of hear, they had their wives, and children, and families, their cattle, and tents, and all their effects, bag and baggage, to convey by this strange and untrodden path, which we must suppose either very muddy or very stony, troublesome to the weak and frightful to the timorous, the descent to the bottom of the river and the ascent out of it steep, so that every man must needs have his head full of care and his hands full of business, and Joshua more than any of them. And yet, in the midst of all his hurry, care must be taken to perpetuate the memorial of this wonderous work of God, and this care might not be adjourned to a time of greater leisure. Note, How much soever we have to do of business for ourselves and our families, we must not neglect nor omit what we have to do for the glory of God and the serving of his honour, for that is our best business. Now,

I.God gave orders for the preparing of this memorial.

Had Joshua done it without divine direction, it might have looked like a design to perpetuate his own name and honour, nor would it have commanded so sacred and venerable a regard from posterity as now, when god himself appointed it. Note, God's works of wonder ought to be kept in everlasting remembrance, and means devise for the preserving of the memorial of them. Some of the Israelites that passed over Jordan perhaps were so stupid, and so little affected with this great favour of God to them, that they felt no concern to have it remembered; while others, it may be, were so much affected with it, and had such deep impressions made upon them by it, that they thought there needed no memorial of it to be erected, the heart and tongue of every Israelite in every age would be a living lasting monument of it. But God, knowing their frame, and how apt they had been soon to forget his works, ordered an expedient for the keeping of this in remembrance to all generations, that those who could not, or would not, read the record of it in the sacred history, might come to the knowledge of it by the monument set up in remembrance of it, of which the common tradition of the country would be an explication; it would likewise serve to corroborate the proof of the matter of fact, and would remain a standing evidence of it to those who in after-ages might question the truth of it. A monument is to be erected, and,

1.Joshua, as chief captain, must five direction about it (v. 1): When all the people had clean passed over Jordan, not even the feeble, that were the hindmost of them, left behind, so that God had done his work completely, and every Israelite got safe into Canaan, then God spoke unto Joshua to provide materials for this monument. It is the pious conjecture of the learned bishop Patrick that Joshua had gone into some place of retirement to return thanks immediately for this wonderful mercy, and then god met him, and spoke thus to him. Or, perhaps, it was by Eleazar the priest that God gave these and other instructions to Joshua; for, though he is not mentioned here, yet, when Joshua was ordained by the imposition of hands to this great trust, god appointed that Eleazar should ask counsel for him after the judgment of Urim, and at his word Joshua and all the children of Israel must go out and come in, Num 27:21.

2.One man out of each tribe, and he a chosen man, must be employed to prepare materials for this monument, that each tribe might have the story told them by one of themselves, and each tribe might contribute something to the glory of God thereby (Jos 4:2, Jos 4:4): Out of ever tribe a man. Not the Levites only, but every Israelite must, in his place, help to make known to the sons of men God's mighty acts, Psa 145:12. The two tribes, though seated already in their possession, yet, sharing in the mercy, must lend a hand to the memorial of it.

3.The stones that must be set up for this memorial are ordered to be taken out of the midst of the cannel (where, probably, there lay abundance of great stones), and as near as might be from the very place where the priests stood with the ark, Jos 4:3, Jos 4:5. This intended monument deserved to be made of stones curiously cut with the finest and most exquisite art, but these stones out of the bottom of the river were more natural and more apt indications of the miracle. let posterity know by this that Jordan was driven back, for these very stones were then fetched out of it. In the institution of signs, God always chose that which was most proper and significant, rather than that which is pompous or curious; for God hath chosen the foolish things of the world. These twelve men, after they got over Jordan, must be sent back to the place where the ark stood, being permitted to come near it (which others might not) for this service: "Pass over before the ark (Jos 4:5), that is, into the presence of the ark, which now stands in the midst of Jordan, and thence fetch these stones." 4. the use of these stones is here appointed for a sign (Jos 4:6), a memorial, Jos 4:7. They would give occasion to the children to ask their parents in time to come, How came these stones hither? (probably the land about not being stony), and then the parents would inform them, as they themselves had been informed, that in this place Jordan was divided by the almighty power of God, to give Israel passage into Canaan, as Joshua enlarges on this head, v. 22, etc.

II.According to these orders the thing was done.

1. Twelve stones were taken up out of the midst of Jordan, and carried in the sight of the people to the place where they had their head-quarters that night, v. 8. It is probable that the stones they took were as big as they could well carry, and as near as might be of a size and shape. But whether they went away with them immediately to the place, of whether they staid to attend the ark, and kept pace with the solemn procession of that, to grace its triumphant entry in to Canaan, is not certain. By these stones which they were ordered to take up God did, as it were, give them livery and seisin of this good land; it is all their own, let them enter and take possession; therefore what these twelve did the children of Israel are said to do (v. 8), because they were the representatives of their respective tribes. In allusion to this, we may observe that when the Lord Jesus, our Joshua, having overcome the sharpness of death and dried up that Jordan, had opened the kingdom of heaven to all believers, he appointed his twelve apostles according to the number of the tribes of Israel, by the memorial of the gospel to transmit the knowledge of this to remote places and future ages. 2. Other twelve stones (probably much larger than the other, for we read not that they were each of them one man's load) were set up in the midst of Jordan (v. 9), piled up so high in a heap or pillar as that the top of it might be seen above the water when the river was low, or seen in the water when it was clear, or at least the noise of commotion of the water passing over it would be observable, and the bargemen would avoid it, as they do a rock. Some way or other, it is likely, it was discernible, so as to notify the very place where the ark stood, and to serve for a duplicate to the other monument, which was to set up on dry land in Gilgal, for the confirming of its testimony and the preserving of its tradition. The sign being doubled, no doubt the thing was certain.

Copy as

Historical interpretation

Historical Reception

2 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

2 quotes · AD 749
AD 749John DamasceneEarly MedievalSourceON DIVINE IMAGES 3.23
Images are of two kinds: either they are words written in a book … or else they are material images such as the twelve stones which he commanded to be taken from the Jordan for a second memorial (such a mystery, truly the greatest ever to befall the faithful people!) of the carrying of the ark and the parting of the waters. Therefore we now set up images in remembrance of valiant men, that we may zealously desire to follow their example. Either remove these images altogether, and reject the authority of him who commanded them to be made, or else accept them in the manner and with the esteem which they deserve.
AD 749John DamasceneEarly MedievalSourceON DIVINE IMAGES 1.18
God ordered twelve stones to be taken from the Jordan, and specified why, for he says, “When your children ask their fathers in time to come, what do these stones mean? Then you shall let your children know, Israel passed over this Jordan on dry ground, for the Lord your God dried up the waters of the Jordan for you until you passed over,” and thus the ark was saved and all the people. Shall we not then record with images the saving passion and miracles of Christ our God, so that when my son asks me, “What is this?” I may say that God the Word became man, and that through him not only Israel passed through the Jordan, but the whole human race regained its original happiness? Through him, human nature rose from the lowest depths to the most exalted heights, and in him sat on the Father’s throne.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Joshua 4:6 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8