Skip to content
Translation
King James Version
O LORD, are not thine eyes upon the truth? thou hast stricken them, but they have not grieved; thou hast consumed them, but they have refused to receive correction: they have made their faces harder than a rock; they have refused to return.
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
O LORD H3068, are not thine eyes H5869 upon the truth H530? thou hast stricken H5221 them, but they have not grieved H2342; thou hast consumed H3615 them, but they have refused H3985 to receive H3947 correction H4148: they have made their faces H6440 harder H2388 than a rock H5553; they have refused H3985 to return H7725.
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
ADONAI, your eyes look for truth. You struck them, but they weren't affected; you [nearly] destroyed them, but they refused correction. They made their faces harder than rock, refusing to repent.
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
O LORD, do not Your eyes look for truth? You struck them, but they felt no pain. You finished them off, but they refused to accept discipline. They have made their faces harder than stone and refused to repent.
Ask
American Standard Version
O Jehovah, do not thine eyes look upon truth? thou hast stricken them, but they were not grieved; thou hast consumed them, but they have refused to receive correction: they have made their faces harder than a rock; they have refused to return.
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
O LORD, don’t your eyes look on truth? You have stricken them, but they were not grieved. You have consumed them, but they have refused to receive correction. They have made their faces harder than a rock. They have refused to return.
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
O Lord, are not thine eyes vpon the trueth? thou hast striken them, but they haue not sorowed: thou hast consumed them, but they haue refused to receiue correction: they haue made their faces harder then a stone, and haue refused to returne.
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
Jehovah, Thine eyes, are they not on stedfastness? Thou hast smitten them, and they have not grieved, Thou hast consumed them, They have refused to receive instruction, They made their faces harder than a rock, They have refused to turn back.
Ask

Study This Verse

SUMMARY

Jeremiah 5:3 serves as a poignant divine lament, powerfully articulating the profound spiritual obstinacy of the people of Judah in the face of God's unwavering truth and corrective discipline. The verse opens with a rhetorical question affirming the Lord's perfect discernment, then details how His severe judgments—striking and consuming—failed to elicit genuine grief, repentance, or a willingness to receive instruction. It vividly portrays their hardened hearts, likening their defiant refusal to change course to faces made harder than rock, ultimately sealing their tragic and persistent refusal to return to God.

CONTEXT

  • Literary Context: Jeremiah 5:3 is strategically placed within a broader prophetic indictment against Judah and Jerusalem, immediately following the Lord's challenge to find even one righteous person in the city (Jeremiah 5:1-2). The preceding verses establish the pervasive moral decay and absence of truth, even among those who claim to know God. Verse 5:3 then provides the divine explanation for the impending judgment: the people's deep-seated impenitence and active resistance to God's disciplinary measures. This verse is pivotal, demonstrating that God's judgment is not arbitrary but a necessary consequence of their unyielding rebellion, thus setting the stage for the escalating pronouncements of destruction and exile that dominate the remainder of the chapter and the book. It underscores the severity of their spiritual condition, which necessitates the drastic divine actions that follow.
  • Historical & Cultural Context: Jeremiah's prophetic ministry unfolded during the tumultuous twilight of the Kingdom of Judah (late 7th to early 6th centuries BC), a period characterized by profound political instability, widespread spiritual apostasy, and the escalating threat of the Neo-Babylonian Empire. Despite King Josiah's earlier reforms, the nation rapidly reverted to rampant idolatry, social injustice, and covenant unfaithfulness after his death. The "striking" and "consuming" mentioned in the verse refer to various forms of divine chastisement already experienced—including droughts, famines, plagues, and military defeats at the hands of regional powers—all intended as merciful, corrective measures to recall His covenant people to faithfulness. Culturally, the idiom of "hardening the face" or "stiffening the neck" was a well-understood expression for deliberate stubbornness, defiance, and an unyielding refusal to submit to authority or truth. This imagery powerfully conveys Judah's intentional and deep-seated spiritual rebellion against the covenant Lord, indicating a conscious choice to resist divine influence.
  • Key Themes: Jeremiah 5:3 significantly contributes to several core themes woven throughout the book of Jeremiah. Firstly, it highlights God's unwavering righteousness and omniscience, as His "eyes are upon the truth," contrasting sharply with the people's self-deception and moral blindness. This divine gaze ensures that judgment is always just and perfectly informed. Secondly, it powerfully illustrates the pervasive theme of human impenitence and spiritual rebellion, demonstrating Judah's profound and active unwillingness to respond to God's repeated warnings and discipline. This stubbornness is a recurring motif, also seen in the prophet's laments over their unyielding hearts in passages like Jeremiah 7:26. Thirdly, the verse speaks to the purpose and tragic failure of divine discipline, revealing that God's chastisements were not arbitrary acts of destruction but merciful attempts to bring His people to repentance, a purpose tragically thwarted by their hardened hearts. This aligns with the broader biblical principle that God disciplines those He loves, as articulated in Hebrews 12:6. Finally, the repeated "refused to return" emphasizes the critical theme of repentance—its necessity for restoration and the dire consequences of its absence—a central message woven throughout Jeremiah's prophetic ministry and a call echoed throughout the Old Testament (e.g., Hosea 14:1-2).

EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

Key Word Analysis

  • truth (Hebrew, ʼĕmûwnâh', H530): This word, derived from a root meaning firmness, signifies security, fidelity, and morally, faithfulness or truth. When the Lord's "eyes are upon the truth," it implies His unwavering commitment to what is real, righteous, and faithful. He perceives the unvarnished reality of Judah's spiritual condition, their unfaithfulness, and His judgment is based on this unshakeable standard of divine fidelity and righteousness. It stands in stark contrast to the people's profound lack of faithfulness and their embrace of falsehood.
  • grieved (Hebrew, chûwl', H2342): This primitive root primarily means "to twist or whirl," often referring to writhing in pain, especially the intense pain of childbirth or fear. In this context, "they have not grieved" means they did not writhe in pain or sorrow over their sin in response to God's chastisements. The expected, natural response of deep anguish and remorse, which should lead to repentance and a turning back to God, was conspicuously absent, indicating a profound spiritual deadness and insensitivity to their own transgression and God's holiness.
  • harder (Hebrew, châzaq', H2388): This root means "to fasten upon," "to seize," "to be strong," or "to be obstinate." When their faces are made "harder" than a rock, it conveys an active, deliberate, and unyielding resolve to be stubborn. It's not merely a passive state of insensitivity but an intentional stiffening of their will against God's attempts to correct them. This signifies a conscious and defiant choice to remain impervious to divine influence, the consequences of their actions, or any sense of shame or conviction.

Verse Breakdown

  • "O LORD, [are] not thine eyes upon the truth?": This is a powerful rhetorical question, serving both as an impassioned plea from the prophet and a profound affirmation of God's character. Jeremiah appeals to God's very nature, acknowledging His perfect knowledge, righteousness, and unwavering commitment to reality. It implies that God sees everything as it truly is, without deception or illusion, including the full depth of Judah's sin and impenitence, and that His judgment is perfectly just and informed by this unassailable truth.
  • "thou hast stricken them, but they have not grieved;": This clause highlights God's active, yet merciful, intervention. "Striken" refers to various forms of divine discipline—hardships, calamities, or judgments—sent to bring His people to their senses and back to the covenant. However, the expected outcome, a deep sorrow or remorse ("grieved") over their sin, was conspicuously absent. This reveals their spiritual insensitivity and the tragic failure of God's corrective measures to penetrate their hardened hearts and elicit a repentant response.
  • "thou hast consumed them, [but] they have refused to receive correction:": Escalating the previous point, "consumed" refers to the devastating effects of God's judgment or discipline, perhaps even more severely or thoroughly. Yet, despite experiencing these severe consequences, they actively "refused to receive correction." This indicates a deliberate and conscious rejection of God's instruction, discipline, or warning, demonstrating a defiant unwillingness to learn from their mistakes, acknowledge their need for change, or submit to His righteous will.
  • "they have made their faces harder than a rock;": This powerful simile describes the extreme obduracy and impenitence of the people. Their "faces," often a reflection of inner emotion, shame, or responsiveness, became unyielding, unashamed, and impervious to any sense of remorse or conviction. It signifies a deliberate act of stiffening their resolve against God, making themselves unmovable and unchangeable in their rebellion, exhibiting a brazen defiance that rejects all attempts at softening.
  • "they have refused to return.": This final clause encapsulates the ultimate failure of Judah's spiritual journey. "To return" (Hebrew, shûwb) is a quintessential biblical term for repentance—a turning away from sin and a turning back to God, both in action and heart. Despite all of God's patient efforts and severe discipline, their hardened hearts led to a categorical refusal to repent, to change their ways, or to re-establish their covenant relationship with the Lord. This persistent refusal sealed their fate and necessitated further, more severe judgment.

Literary Devices

Jeremiah 5:3 employs several powerful literary devices to convey the prophet's lament and God's righteous indignation. The opening "O LORD, [are] not thine eyes upon the truth?" is a potent rhetorical question, not seeking an answer but emphatically affirming God's omniscience, unwavering justice, and perfect discernment, thereby highlighting the stark contrast with Judah's moral blindness and self-deception. The verse then uses parallelism and antithesis in the repeated structure: "thou hast stricken them, but they have not grieved; thou hast consumed them, [but] they have refused to receive correction." This structural repetition emphasizes the consistent pattern of God's disciplinary action met with the people's equally consistent, defiant impenitence. The most striking device is the simile and metaphorical language found in "they have made their faces harder than a rock." This vivid imagery powerfully communicates the extreme, unyielding stubbornness and spiritual insensitivity of the people, presenting a tangible picture of their defiance. The "face" here also serves as a synecdoche for their entire being or disposition, emphasizing their complete lack of shame, remorse, or receptiveness to God's will.

THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS

Jeremiah 5:3 is a profound theological statement on the nature of God's justice, the depth of human depravity, and the purpose of divine discipline. It reveals a God who is intimately aware of truth and righteousness, whose disciplinary actions are not arbitrary acts of wrath but are purposeful attempts to bring His people to repentance and restoration. The tragic reality is that even in the face of such divine intervention, the human heart can become so hardened by sin and rebellion that it actively resists correction and defiantly refuses to turn back to its Creator. This verse underscores the critical importance of a responsive heart to God's voice and discipline, for persistent impenitence ultimately leads to inevitable and severe consequences. It serves as a stark reminder that while God is patient and longs for His people to repent, His patience is not infinite, and His justice will ultimately prevail against unrepentant rebellion, ensuring that truth is upheld and righteousness is vindicated.

REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

Jeremiah 5:3 stands as a timeless and sobering mirror for individuals and communities alike, challenging us to honestly assess the condition of our hearts in response to God's dealings. It forces us to ask whether we are truly receptive to divine truth and correction, or if we have allowed complacency, pride, and self-will to harden our spiritual sensitivities. When faced with difficulties, setbacks, internal conviction from the Holy Spirit, or even the natural consequences of our choices, our natural inclination might be to resist, blame others, or grow resentful. However, this verse calls us to a radical humility: to grieve over our sins, to receive God's discipline as an act of love and a pathway to growth, and to actively choose the path of repentance. It warns against the perilous progression from unresponsiveness to outright refusal, a path that culminates in a heart "harder than a rock," impervious to grace and truth. Therefore, we are urged to cultivate a soft and pliable heart, ever ready to turn back to the Lord, recognizing that His "eyes are upon the truth" and His desire is always for our restoration, not our destruction.

Questions for Reflection

  • In what areas of my life might I be resisting God's correction or warnings, either subtly or overtly, perhaps through rationalization or deflection?
  • How do I typically respond to hardship, criticism, or divine discipline? Do I allow it to lead me to godly sorrow and repentance, or do I become resentful, stubborn, or defensive?
  • What practical steps can I take to cultivate a "soft heart" that is more responsive to God's Word, the conviction of the Holy Spirit, and the lessons learned from life's challenges?

FAQ

What does it mean that God's "eyes are upon the truth"?

Answer: This rhetorical question emphasizes God's omniscience, His perfect discernment, and His unwavering commitment to reality and righteousness. It means that God sees things exactly as they are, without deception, illusion, or partiality. He perceives the true spiritual condition of humanity, the hidden motives of the heart, and the unvarnished facts of sin and faithfulness. His judgments and actions are always based on this perfect, unchangeable standard of truth, contrasting sharply with human attempts to hide or rationalize their wrongdoing. It assures us that God is fully aware of every detail of our lives and the world, and His justice is perfectly informed and executed according to His righteous character.

Why did the people refuse to "receive correction" and "return"?

Answer: The text indicates a profound spiritual stubbornness and impenitence rooted in a rebellious will. Despite experiencing God's disciplinary actions (being "stricken" and "consumed" through various calamities), their hearts were so hardened by sin and a deliberate choice to defy God that they actively resisted the intended purpose of these trials. "Receiving correction" implies a willingness to learn from mistakes, acknowledge wrongdoing, and adjust one's behavior according to divine instruction. Their refusal stemmed from a conscious decision to defy God's will, prioritize their own sinful desires, and maintain their chosen path of unfaithfulness. This deep-seated resistance to change, vividly described as making their "faces harder than a rock," prevented them from the act of "returning" (repentance), which involves a fundamental change of mind and direction back to God. This persistent unwillingness to turn from evil ways is a recurring and tragic theme throughout prophetic literature, where God consistently laments His people's refusal to turn from their evil ways.

CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT

Jeremiah 5:3, with its lament over a people whose faces are "harder than a rock" and who stubbornly refuse to return, finds its ultimate fulfillment and profound reversal in the person and work of Jesus Christ. While ancient Israel consistently resisted God's discipline and refused to repent, Jesus perfectly embodied the responsive and obedient heart, always submitting to the Father's will, even to the point of death on the cross (Philippians 2:8). He is the very Truth upon whom the Father's eyes are always set (John 14:6), and through His atoning sacrifice, He offers the transformative power to soften even the hardest of hearts. The New Covenant, inaugurated by Christ's blood, promises a new heart and a new spirit, replacing the "heart of stone" with a "heart of flesh" (Ezekiel 36:26). Where Israel refused to grieve or receive correction, Christ bore the ultimate striking and consumption of divine judgment, not for His own sin, but for ours, so that we might be grieved by sin and willingly return to God through repentance and faith in Him (Romans 2:4). His call is not one of condemnation for hardened hearts, but an invitation to find rest for weary souls (Matthew 11:28-30). Thus, the tragedy of Jeremiah 5:3 highlights the desperate need for the Savior who alone can break the power of stubborn rebellion and enable true repentance, leading us into a living relationship with the God of truth.

Copy as

Commentary on Jeremiah 5 verses 1–9

I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points

Here is, I. A challenge to produce any one right honest man, or at least any considerable number of such, in Jerusalem, Jer 5:1. Jerusalem had become like the old world, in which all flesh had corrupted their way. There were some perhaps who flattered themselves with hopes that there were yet many good men in Jerusalem, who would stand in the gap to turn away the wrath of God; and there might be others who boasted of its being the holy city and thought that this would save it. But God bids them search the town, and intimates that they should scarcely find a man in it who executed judgment and made conscience of what he said and did: "Look in the streets, where they make their appearance and converse together, and in the broad places, where they keep their markets; see if you can find a man, a magistrate (so some), that executes judgment, and administers justice impartially, that will put the laws in execution against vice and profaneness." When the faithful thus cease and fail it is time to cry Woe is me! (Mic 7:1, Mic 7:2), high time to cry, Help Lord, Psa 12:1. "If there be here and there a man that is truly conscientious, and does at least speak the truth, yet you shall not find him in the streets and broad places; he dares not appear publicly, lest he should be abused and run down. Truth has fallen in the street (Isa 59:14), and is forced to seek for corners." So pleasing would it be to God to find any such that for their sake he would pardon the city; if there were but ten righteous men in Sodom, if but one of a thousand, of ten thousand, in Jerusalem, it should be spared. See how ready God is to forgive, how swift to show mercy. But it might be said, "What do you make of those in Jerusalem that continue to make profession of religion and relation to God? Are not they men for whose sakes Jerusalem may be spared?" No, for they are not sincere in their profession (Jer 5:2): They say, The Lord liveth, and will swear by his name only, but they swear falsely, that is, 1. They are not sincere in the profession they make of respect to God, but are false to him; they honour him with their lips, but their hearts are far from him. 2. Though they appeal to God only, they make no conscience of calling him to witness to a lie. Though they do not swear by idols, they forswear themselves, which is no less an affront to God, as the God of truth, than the other is as the only true God.

II. A complaint which the prophet makes to God of the obstinacy and wilfulness of these people. God had appealed to their eyes (Jer 5:1); but here the prophet appeals to his eyes (Jer 5:3): "Are not thy eyes upon the truth? Dost thou not see every man's true character? And is not this the truth of their character, that they have made their faces harder than a rock?" Or, "Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward part; but where is it to be found among the men of this generation? For though they say, The Lord liveth, yet they never regard him; thou hast stricken them with one affliction after another, but they have not grieved for the affliction, they have been as stocks and stones under it, much less have they grieved for the sin by which they have brought it upon themselves. Thou hast gone further yet, hast consumed them, hast corrected them yet more severely; but they have refused to receive correction, to accommodate themselves to thy design in correcting them and to answer to it. They would not receive instruction by the correction. The have set themselves to outface the divine sentence and to outbrave the execution of it, for they have made their faces harder than a rock; they cannot change countenance, neither blush for shame nor look pale for fear, cannot be beaten back from the pursuit of their lusts, whatever check is given them; for, though often called to it, they have refused to return, and would go forward, right or wrong, as the horse into the battle."

III. The trial made both of rich and poor, and the bad character given of both.

1.The poor were ignorant, and therefore they were wicked. He found many that refused to return, for whom he was willing to make the best excuse their case would bear, and it was this (Jer 5:4): "Surely, these are poor, they are foolish. They never had the advantage of a good education, nor have they wherewithal to help themselves now with the means of instruction. They are forced to work hard for their living, and have no time nor capacity for reading or hearing, so that they know not the way of the Lord, nor the judgments of their God; they understand neither the way in which God by his precepts will have them to walk towards him nor the way in which he by his providence is walking towards them." Note, (1.) Prevailing ignorance is the lamentable cause of abounding impiety and iniquity. What can one expect but works of darkness from brutish sottish people that know nothing of God and religion, but choose to sit in darkness? (2.) This is commonly a reigning sin among poor people. There are the devil's poor as well as God's, who, notwithstanding their poverty, might know the way of the Lord, so as to walk in it and do their duty, without being book-learned; but they are willingly ignorant, and therefore their ignorance will not be their excuse.

2.The rich were insolent and haughty, and therefore they were wicked (Jer 5:5): "I will get me to the great men, and see if I can find them more pliable to the word and providence of God. I will speak to them, preach at court, in hopes to make some impression upon men of polite literature. But all in vain; for, though they know the way of the Lord and the judgment of their God, yet they are too stiff to stoop to his government: These have altogether broken the yoke and burst the bonds. They know their Master's will, but are resolved to have their own will, to walk in the way of their heart and in the sight of their eyes. They think themselves too goodly to be controlled, too big to be corrected, even by the sovereign Lord of all himself. They are for breaking even his bands asunder, Psa 2:3. The poor are weak, the rich are wilful, and so neither do their duty."

IV. Some particular sins specified, which they were notoriously guilty of, and which cried most loudly to heaven for vengeance. Their transgressions indeed were many, of many kinds and often repeated, and their backslidings were increased; they added to the number of them and grew more and more impudent in them, Jer 5:6. But two sins especially were justly to be looked upon as unpardonable crimes: - 1. Their spiritual whoredom, giving that honour to idols which is due to God only. "Thy children have forsaken me, to whom they were born and dedicated and under whom they have been brought up, and they have sworn by those that are no gods, have made their appeal to them as if they had been omniscient and their proper judges." This is here put for all acts of religious worship due to God only, but with which they had honoured their idols. They have sworn to them (so it may be read), have joined themselves to them and covenanted with them. Those that forsake God make a bad change for those that are no gods. 2. Their corporal whoredom. Because they had forsaken God and served idols, he gave them up to vile affections; and those that dishonoured him were left to dishonour themselves and their own families. They committed adultery most scandalously, without sense of shame or fear of punishment, for they assembled themselves by troops in the harlots' houses and did not blush to be seen by one another in the most scandalous places. So impudent and violent was their lust, so impatient of check, and so eager to be gratified, that they became perfect beasts (Jer 5:8); like high-fed horses, they neighed every one after his neighbour's wife, Jer 5:8. Unbridled lusts make men like natural brute beasts, such monstrous odious things are they. And that which aggravated their sin was that it was the abuse of God's favours to them: When they were fed to the full, then their lusts grew thus furious. Fulness of bread was fuel to the fire of Sodom's lusts. Sine Cerere et Bacchio friget Venu - Luxurious living feeds the flames of lust. Fasting would help to tame the unruly evil that is so full of deadly poison, and bring the body into subjection.

V. A threatening of God's wrath against them for their wickedness and the universal debauchery of their land.

1.The particular judgment that is threatened, Jer 5:6. A foreign enemy shall break in upon them, get dominion over them, and shall lay waste: their country shall be as if it were overrun and perfectly mastered by wild beasts. This enemy shall be, (1.) Like a lion of the forest; so strong, so furious, so irresistible; and he shall slay them. (2.) Like a wolf of the evening, which comes out at night, when he is hungry, to seek his prey, and is very fierce and ravenous; and the noise both of the lions' roaring and of the wolves' howling is very hideous. (3.) Like a leopard, which is very swift and very cruel, and withal careful not to miss his prey. The army of the enemy shall watch over their cities so strictly as to put the inhabitants to this sad dilemma - if they stay in, they are starved; if they stir out, they are stabbed; Every one that goeth out thence shall be torn in pieces, which intimates that in many places the enemy gave no quarter. And all this bloody work is owing to the multitude of their transgressions. It is sin that makes the great slaughter.

2.An appeal to themselves concerning the equity of it (Jer 5:9); "Shall I not visit for these things? Can you yourselves think that the God whose name is Jealous will let such idolatries go unpunished, or that a God of infinite purity will connive at such abominable uncleanness?" These are things that must be reckoned for, else the honour of God's government cannot be maintained, nor his laws saved from contempt; but sinners will be tempted to think him altogether such a one as themselves, contrary to that conviction of their own consciences concerning the judgment of God which is necessary to be supported, That those who do such things are worthy of death, Rom 1:32. Observe, when God punishes sin, he is said to visit for it, or enquire into it; for he weighs the cause before he passes sentence. Sinners have reason to expect punishment upon the account of God's holiness, to which sin is highly offensive, as well as upon the account of his justice, to which it renders us obnoxious; this is intimated in that, Shall not my soul be avenged on such a nation as this? It is not only the word of God, but his soul, that takes vengeance. And he has national judgments wherewith to take vengeance for national sins. Such nations as this was cannot long go unpunished. How shall I pardon thee for this? Jer 5:7. Not but that those who have been guilty of these sins have found mercy with God, as to their eternal state (Manasseh himself did, though so much accessory to the iniquity of these times); but nations, as such, being rewardable and punishable only in this life, it would not be for the glory of God to let a nation so very wicked as this pass without some manifest tokens of his displeasure.

Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Commentary on the Whole Bible. This section covers verses 1–9. Public domain.
Copy as
JeromeAD 420
Commentary on Jeremiah
(Verse 3) Lord, your eyes look upon faith: you struck them, and they did not hurt; you crushed them, and they refused to accept discipline. They hardened their faces like rock, and they refused to turn back. After the words of the Lord, in which he commanded, saying: Go around the streets of Jerusalem, etc., the Prophet speaks to the Lord: Lord, your eyes look upon faith, which in Hebrew is called Emuna: not the works of the Jews, in which they rejoiced according to the ceremonies of the Law; but the faith of the Christians, through which we have been saved by grace. In this chapter, we learn that punishments are inflicted in order to correct vices. Finally, it says, 'You have struck them, and they have not felt pain; you have crushed them, and they have refused to accept discipline.' Through all the torments and whips, Jerusalem is corrected, and yet they did not even have shame for their vices; but like a stone hardening their foreheads, they refused to be converted to better things.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Jeremiah 5:3 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.