TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Commentary on Jeremiah 34 verses 8–22
We have here another prophecy upon a particular occasion, the history of which we must take notice of, as necessary to give light to the prophecy.
I. When Jerusalem was closely besieged by the Chaldean army the princes and people agreed upon a reformation in one instance, and that was concerning their servants.
1.The law of God was very express, that those of their own nation should not be held in servitude above seven years, but, after they had served one apprenticeship, they should be discharged and have their liberty; yea, though they had sold themselves into servitude for the payment of their debts, or though they were sold by the judges for the punishment of their crimes. This difference was put between their brethren and strangers, that those of other nations taken in war, or bought with money, might be held in perpetual slavery, they and theirs; but their brethren must serve but for seven years at the longest. This God calls the covenant that he had made with them when he brought them out of the land of Egypt, Jer 34:13, Jer 34:14. This was the first of the judicial laws which God gave them (Exo 21:2), and there was good reason for this law. (1.) God had put honour upon that nation, and he would have them thus to preserve the honour of it themselves and to put a difference between it and other nations. (2.) God had brought them out of slavery in Egypt, and he would have them thus to express their grateful sense of that favour, by letting those go to whom their houses were houses of bondage, as Egypt had been to their forefathers. That deliverance is therefore mentioned here (Jer 34:13) as the ground of that law. Note, God's compassions towards us should engage our compassions towards our brethren; we must release as we are released, forgive as we are forgiven, and relieve as we are relieved. And this is called a covenant; for our performance of the duty required is the condition of the continuance of the favours God has bestowed.
2.This law they and their fathers had broken. Their worldly profit swayed more with them than God's command or covenant. When their servants had lived seven years with them they understood their business, and how to apply themselves to it, better than they did when they first came to them, and therefore they would then by no means part with them, though God himself by his law had made them free: Your fathers hearkened not to me in this matter (Jer 34:14), so that from the days of their fathers they had been in this trespass; and they thought they might do it because their fathers did it, and their servants had by disuse lost the benefit of the provision God made for them; whereas against an express law, especially against an express law of God, no custom, usage, nor prescription, is to be admitted in plea. For this sin of theirs, and their fathers, God now brought them into servitude, and justly.
3.When they were besieged, and closely shut in, by the army of the Chaldeans, they, being told of their fault in this matter, immediately reformed, and let go all their servants that were entitled to their freedom by the law of God, as Pharaoh, who, when the plague was upon him, consented to let the people go, and bound themselves in a covenant to do so. (1.) The prophets faithfully admonished them concerning their sin. From them they heard that they should let their Hebrew servants go free, Jer 34:10. They might have read it themselves in the book of the law, but did not, or did not heed it, therefore the prophets told them what the law was. See what need there is of the preaching of the word; people must hear the word preached because they will not make the use they ought to make of the word written. (2.) All orders and degrees of men concurred in this reformation. The king, and the princes, and all the people, agreed to let go their servants, whatever loss or damage they might sustain by so doing. When the king and princes led in this good work the people could not for shame but follow. The example and influence of great men would go very far towards extirpating the most inveterate corruptions. (3.) They bound themselves by a solemn oath and covenant that they would do this, whereby they engaged themselves to God and one another. Note, What God has bound us to by his precept, it is good for us to bind ourselves to by our promise. This covenant was very solemn: it was made in a sacred place, made before me, in the house which is called by my name (Jer 34:15), in the special presence of God, the tokens of which, in the temple, ought to strike an awe upon them and make them very sincere in their appeals to him. It was ratified by a significant sign; they cut a calf in two, and passed between the parts thereof (Jer 34:18, Jer 34:19) with this dreadful imprecation, "Let us be in like manner cut asunder if we do not perform what we now promise." This calf was probably offered up in sacrifice to God, who was thereby made a party to the covenant. When God covenanted with Abraham, for the ratification of it, a smoking furnace and a burning lamp passed between the pieces of the sacrifice, in allusion to this federal rite, Gen 15:17. Note, In order that we may effectually oblige ourselves to our duty, it is good to alarm ourselves with the apprehensions of the terror of the wrath and curse to which we expose ourselves if we live in the contempt of it, that wrath which will cut sinners asunder (Mat 24:51), and sensible signs may be of use to make the impressions of it deep and durable, as here. (4.) They conformed themselves herein to the command of God and their covenant with him; they did let their servants go, though at this time, when the city was besieged, they could very ill spare them. Thus they did right in God's sight, Jer 34:15. Though it was their trouble that drove them to it, yet he was well pleased with it; and if they had persevered in this act of mercy to the poor, to their poor servants, it might have been a lengthening of their tranquillity, Dan 4:27.
II. When there was some hope that the siege was raised and the danger over they repented of their repentance, undid the good they had done, and forced the servants they had released into their respective services again. 1. The king of Babylon's army had now gone up from them, Jer 34:21. Pharaoh was bringing an army of Egyptians to oppose the progress of the king of Babylon's victories, upon the tidings of which the Chaldeans raised the siege for a time, as we find, Jer 37:5. They departed from Jerusalem. See how ready God was to put a stop to his judgments, upon the first instance of reformation, so slow is he to anger and so swift to show mercy. As soon as ever they let their servants go free God let them go free. 2. When they began to think themselves safe from the besiegers they made their servants come back into subjection to them, Jer 34:11, and again Jer 34:16. This was a great abuse to their servants, to whom servitude would be more irksome, after they had had some taste of the pleasures of liberty. It was a great shame to themselves that they could not keep in a good mind when they were in it. But it was especially an affront to God; in doing this they polluted his name, Jer 34:16. It was a contempt of the command he had given them, as if that were of no force at all, but they might either keep it or break it as they thought fit. It was a contempt of the covenant they had made with him, and of that wrath which they had imprecated upon themselves in case they should break that covenant. It was jesting with God almighty, as if he could be imposed upon by fallacious promises, which, when they had gained their point, they would look upon themselves no longer obliged by. it was lying to God with their mouths and flattering him with their tongues. It was likewise a contempt of the judgments of God and setting them at defiance; as if, when once the course of them was stopped a little and interrupted, they would never proceed again and the judgment would never be revived; whereas reprieves are so far from being pardons that if they be abused thus, and sinners take encouragement from them to return to sin, they are but preparatives for heavier strokes of divine vengeance.
III. For this treacherous dealing with God they are here severely threatened. Be not deceived; God is not mocked. Those that think to put a cheat upon God by a dissembled repentance, a fallacious covenant, and a partial temporary reformation, will prove in the end to have put the greatest cheat upon their own souls; for the Lord, whose name is Jealous, is a jealous God. it is here threatened, with an observable air of displeasure against them, 1. That, since they had not given liberty to their servants to go where they pleased, God would give all his judgments liberty to take their course against them without control (Jer 34:17): You have not proclaimed liberty to your servants. Though they had done it (Jer 34:10), yet they might truly be said not to have done it, because they did not stand to it, but undid it again; and factum non dicitur quod non perseverat - that is not said to be done which does not last. The righteousness that is forsaken and turned away from shall be forgotten, and not mentioned any more than if it had never been, Eze 18:24. "Therefore I will proclaim a liberty for you; I will discharge you from my service, and put you out of my protection, which those forfeit that withdraw from their allegiance. You shall have liberty to choose which of these judgments you will be cut off by, sword, famine, or pestilence;" such a liberty as was offered to David, which put him into a great strait, Sa2 24:14. Note, Those that will not be in subjection to the law of God put themselves into subjection to the wrath and curse of God. But this shows what liberty to sin really - it is but a liberty to the sorest judgments. 2. That, since they had brought their servants back into confinement in their houses, God would make them to be removed into all the kingdoms of the earth, where they should live in servitude, and, being strangers, could not expect the privileges of free-born subjects. 3. That, since they had broken the covenant which they ratified by a solemn imprecation, God would bring on them the evil which they imprecated upon themselves in case they should break it. out of their own mouth will he judge them, and so shall their doom be; the penalty of their bond shall be recovered, because they have not performed the condition; for so some read Jer 34:18, "I will make the men which have transgressed my covenant as the calf which they cut in twain; I will divide them asunder as they divided it asunder." 4. That, since they would not let go their servants out of the hands, God would deliver them into the hands of those that hated them, even the princes and nobles both of Judah and Jerusalem (of the country and of the city), the eunuchs (chamberlains, or great officers of the court), the priests, and all the people, Jer 34:19. They had all dealt treacherously with God, and therefore shall all be involved in the common ruin without exception. They shall all be given unto the hand of their enemies, that seek, not their wealth only, or their service, but their life, and they shall have what they seek; but neither shall that content them: when they have their lives they shall leave their dead bodies unburied, a loathsome spectacle to all mankind and an easy prey to the fowls and beasts, a lasting mark of ignominy being hereby fastened on them, Jer 34:20. 5. That, since they had emboldened themselves in returning to their sin, contrary to their covenant, by the retreat of the Chaldean army from them, God would therefore bring it upon them again: "They have now gone up from you, and your fright is over for the present, but I will command them to face about as they were; they shall return to this city, and take it and burn it," Jer 34:22. Note, (1.) As confidence in God is a hopeful presage of approaching deliverance, so security in sin is a sad omen of approaching destruction. (2.) When judgments are removed from a people before they have done their work, leave them, but leave them unhumbled and unreformed, it is cum animo revertendi - with a design to return; they do but retreat to come on again with so much the greater force; for when God judges he will overcome. (3.) It is just with God to disappoint those expectations of mercy which his providence had given cause for when we disappoint those expectations of duty which our professions, pretensions, and fair promises, had given cause for. If we repent of the good we had purposed, God will repent of the good he had purposed. With the froward thou will show thyself froward.
[Daniel 7:1] "In the first year of Belshazzar, King of Babylon, Daniel beheld a dream. And a vision of his head upon his bed. And when he wrote the dream down, he comprehended it in a few words and gave a brief summary of it, saying..." This section which we now undertake to explain, and also the subsequent section which we are going to discuss, is historically prior to the two previous sections. For this present section and that which follows it are recorded to have taken place in the first and third years of the reign of King Belshazzar (Jeremiah 39) [Jerome's citation of Jeremiah 39 seems quite pointless in this connection]. But the section which we read previously to the one just preceding this, is recorded to have taken place in the last year, indeed on the final day, of Belshaz-zar's reign. And we meet this phenomenon not only in Daniel but also in Jeremiah [cf. Jeremiah 35 and Jeremiah 34] and Ezekiel (Ezekiel 17), as we shall be able to show, if life spares us that long. But in the earlier portion of the book, the historical order has been followed, namely the events which occurred in the time of Nebuchadnezzar, and Belshazzar, and Darius or Cyrus. But in the passages now before us an account is given of various visions which were beheld on particular occasions and of which only the prophet himself was aware, and which therefore lacked any importance as signs or revelations so far as the barbarian nations were concerned. But they were written down only that a record of the things beheld might be preserved for posterity.
Continue studying Jeremiah 34:17 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
SUMMARY
Jeremiah 34:17 powerfully articulates God's severe judgment against the people of Judah and King Zedekiah for their profound hypocrisy and covenant infidelity. After publicly vowing to release their Hebrew slaves in accordance with Mosaic Law, they shamelessly reneged on their promise, re-enslaving those they had just liberated. In response to this blatant disregard for divine command and social justice, the LORD declares an ironic "liberty" for them – not freedom from their oppressors, but a terrifying freedom to face the devastating consequences of the sword, pestilence, and famine, culminating in their forced removal and dispersion into all the nations of the earth. This prophetic declaration underscores God's unwavering justice and the dire repercussions of covenant-breaking and social injustice.
CONTEXT
EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS
Key Word Analysis
Verse Breakdown
Literary Devices
The most striking literary device in Jeremiah 34:17 is Irony. God employs the very word "liberty" (dᵉrôwr) that the people failed to extend to their fellow Israelites, but He redefines it in a terrifyingly punitive manner. Instead of freedom from bondage and oppression, it becomes a freedom to destruction and exile. This sharp and bitter contrast powerfully highlights the severity of their sin and the precise, reciprocal nature of divine retribution. Additionally, there is a clear instance of Anthropomorphism, as God is depicted as actively "proclaiming" liberty, mirroring the human action they were commanded to perform but failed to execute. The listing of "sword, pestilence, and famine" functions as a Tricolon, a rhetorical device using three parallel words or phrases, which emphasizes the comprehensive, inescapable, and multifaceted nature of the impending judgment. These three elements also serve as a form of Metonymy, where the instruments or causes of destruction stand in for the calamities themselves: war, disease, and starvation.
THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Jeremiah 34:17 offers a profound theological insight into the interconnectedness of covenant obedience, social justice, and divine judgment. The people's egregious failure to honor their covenant with God by extending liberty to their enslaved brethren was not merely a social or economic infraction but a direct affront to God's righteous character and His holy law. This passage reveals that God's justice is not arbitrary or disconnected from human actions; rather, it often mirrors the very actions of His people. Their refusal to grant freedom to the vulnerable directly led to their own loss of freedom, security, and national identity. It powerfully underscores the biblical principle that genuine faith is inextricably demonstrated through righteous living and compassionate action towards the vulnerable, and that a persistent disregard for these principles inevitably invites severe divine consequences.
REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Jeremiah 34:17 serves as a stark and challenging reminder that God holds our promises, our covenants, and especially our treatment of others with utmost seriousness. The profound hypocrisy of the people of Judah, who made a solemn covenant under duress only to break it when the immediate threat receded, speaks volumes about the danger of superficial repentance and self-serving obedience. For believers today, this passage compels us to deeply examine the integrity of our own commitments, both to God and to our fellow human beings. Are we truly living out the principles of justice, compassion, and freedom that God calls us to, or are we selectively applying them based on convenience, personal gain, or shifting circumstances? It forces us to confront how our actions, particularly toward the marginalized, the vulnerable, and those in need, truly reflect the condition of our hearts before a righteous God. We are called to recognize that a failure to extend mercy and justice can lead to unintended and severe consequences in our own lives, both spiritually and practically, echoing the divine principle of sowing and reaping.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
What was the "liberty" the people were supposed to proclaim?
Answer: The "liberty" the people were commanded to proclaim referred specifically to the release of their Hebrew slaves, a practice mandated by Mosaic Law. This law, detailed in passages like Deuteronomy 15:12, stipulated that Hebrew servants were to be set free after six years of service. This principle was also intrinsically linked to the broader concept of the Jubilee year, during which all Israelite slaves were to be freed and ancestral lands returned to their original families, as outlined in Leviticus 25:10. Under the immediate threat of the Babylonian siege, King Zedekiah and the people of Judah had made a solemn covenant to implement this law Jeremiah 34:8-10, but then quickly and cynically broke it by re-enslaving those they had just freed Jeremiah 34:11.
How is God's "liberty" to the sword, pestilence, and famine an ironic judgment?
Answer: God's proclamation of "liberty" in Jeremiah 34:17 is profoundly ironic because it employs the very term for a positive, redemptive act (freedom from human bondage) to describe a negative, punitive outcome. The people of Judah refused to grant true liberty to their fellow humans, violating their covenant and God's law. Therefore, God declares a "liberty" for them to experience devastating consequences. This "liberty" is not freedom from suffering or oppression, but rather a terrifying freedom to experience the full force of divine judgment through warfare (the sword), widespread disease (pestilence), and starvation (famine). It powerfully illustrates the principle of divine retribution, where the punishment fittingly corresponds to the crime, turning their desired freedom from obligation into a terrifying freedom to destruction and exile.
CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
Jeremiah 34:17, with its stark portrayal of a broken covenant, human hypocrisy, and ironic divine judgment, finds its ultimate fulfillment and profound reversal in the person and work of Jesus Christ. The people of Judah failed miserably to "proclaim liberty" to their brethren, demonstrating their inherent inability to perfectly uphold God's righteous law and revealing the depth of their sinfulness. This failure led to a "liberty" of judgment, culminating in exile, death, and separation from their land. In stark contrast, Jesus Christ perfectly fulfilled the law and truly proclaimed liberty, not merely from human bondage but from the far greater spiritual bondage of sin and death. He is the one prophesied in Isaiah 61:1, a passage Jesus Himself quoted in Luke 4:18-19 to declare His mission: "to proclaim liberty to the captives." Through His atoning sacrifice on the cross, Christ bore the "sword, pestilence, and famine" of divine judgment that humanity justly deserved, offering Himself as the perfect Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. While Judah's "removal into all the kingdoms of the earth" foreshadowed the spiritual dispersion of humanity due to sin, Christ's resurrection and ascension inaugurate a new, eternal kingdom, gathering people from every tribe, tongue, and nation into one unified body, as envisioned in Revelation 7:9. Thus, where Judah's broken covenant led to a liberty of destruction and separation, Christ's perfect obedience and sacrificial love offer genuine liberty and eternal life to all who believe, bringing them into true fellowship with God and one another, fulfilling the promise of Galatians 5:1.