Ezra 3:13

KJV

So that the people could not discern the noise of the shout of joy from the noise of the weeping of the people: for the people shouted with a loud shout, and the noise was heard afar off.

KJV (with Strong's)

So that the people {H5971} could not discern {H5234} the noise {H6963} of the shout {H8643} of joy {H8057} from the noise {H6963} of the weeping {H1065} of the people {H5971}: for the people {H5971} shouted {H7321} with a loud {H1419} shout {H8643}, and the noise {H6963} was heard {H8085} afar off {H7350}.

Complete Jewish Bible

so that the people couldn't distinguish the noise of the joyful shouting from the noise of the people's weeping; for the people were shouting so loudly that the noise could be heard at a great distance.

Berean Standard Bible

The people could not distinguish the shouts of joy from the sound of weeping, because the people were making so much noise. And the sound was heard from afar.

American Standard Version

so that the people could not discern the noise of the shout of joy from the noise of the weeping of the people; for the people shouted with a loud shout, and the noise was heard afar off.

Commentary

### SUMMARY
Ezra 3:13 powerfully encapsulates the profound emotional dichotomy experienced by the returned exiles at the laying of the Second Temple's foundation in Jerusalem. The verse vividly describes a scene where the jubilant shouts of joy from the younger generation, celebrating a new beginning and God's faithfulness, merged indistinguishably with the bitter weeping of the elders, who remembered the lost splendor of Solomon's magnificent First Temple. This cacophony created an overwhelming sound that echoed far and wide, symbolizing the complex interplay of triumph and lament, hope and nostalgia, that characterized this pivotal moment of national and spiritual restoration.

### CONTEXT
* **Literary Context:** Ezra 3:13 serves as the climactic summary of the foundational ceremony for the Second Temple, building directly upon the events described in [Ezra 3:10-12](/ezra/3-10-12 "Ezra 3:10-12 - The Laying of the Temple Foundation"). Following the rebuilding of the altar and the resumption of sacrifices, Zerubbabel, Jeshua, and the returned exiles finally commenced the work on the Temple itself. As the foundation stones were laid, priests in their vestments and Levites with cymbals were positioned to praise the Lord according to the ordinances of King David. The people responded with a mighty shout of praise, giving thanks to the Lord for His goodness and enduring mercy. However, this collective exultation was immediately met by a contrasting sound: the loud weeping of the older generation who remembered the glory and grandeur of the First Temple. Verse 13 then synthesizes these two powerful, conflicting emotional expressions, emphasizing their overwhelming and indistinguishable blend.
* **Historical & Cultural Context:** This scene unfolds in the post-exilic period, roughly 70 years after the destruction of Jerusalem and the First Temple by the Babylonians in 586 BC, and following the seventy-year period of captivity prophesied by Jeremiah (cf. [Jeremiah 29:10](/jeremiah/29-10 "Jeremiah 29:10 - Prophecy of the Seventy-Year Exile")). King Cyrus of Persia had issued a decree (recorded in [Ezra 1:1-4](/ezra/1-1-4 "Ezra 1:1-4 - Cyrus's Decree Permitting Return")) allowing the Jewish exiles to return to Judah and rebuild the house of the Lord in Jerusalem. For the returning community, the Temple was not merely a building; it was the spiritual heart of their nation, the dwelling place of God's presence, and a symbol of their covenant relationship with Yahweh. The First Temple, built by Solomon, had been a marvel of ancient architecture and opulence, described in detail in [1 Kings 6](/1_kings/6 "1 Kings 6 - Solomon Builds the Temple"). Its destruction was a national trauma. Therefore, the laying of the new foundation, while a cause for immense joy and a sign of God's faithfulness to His promises, inevitably triggered poignant memories and comparisons to the lost glory, eliciting deep sorrow from those who had witnessed the former edifice.
* **Key Themes:** Ezra 3:13 powerfully encapsulates several central themes within the book of Ezra and the broader post-exilic narrative. Firstly, it highlights the **Complexities of Restoration and New Beginnings**. The verse vividly illustrates that even divinely ordained acts of restoration are often met with a mixed emotional response, blending joy for what is being renewed with sorrow for what was lost. The younger generation, unfamiliar with the First Temple's grandeur, celebrated the tangible sign of God's returning presence and future hope. In stark contrast, the elders, who remembered the former glory, wept in lament. Secondly, it underscores **God's Enduring Faithfulness Amidst Human Imperfection**. Despite the mixed reactions and the humble beginnings of the new Temple compared to the old, the foundation was laid, a concrete manifestation of God fulfilling His promises to bring His people back to their land and restore their worship. This event testifies that God's redemptive work progresses, even through human tears and varying perspectives, demonstrating His unwavering commitment to His covenant. Thirdly, it speaks to the tension of **Remembering the Past While Embracing the Future**, a crucial aspect of navigating significant historical transitions. The verse captures the challenge of honoring the memory of what was lost while simultaneously embracing the new, often less glorious, reality of God's ongoing work, a theme also explored in [Haggai 2:3](/haggai/2-3 "Haggai 2:3 - The Glory of the Latter Temple").

### EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

#### Key Word Analysis
* **Discern (Hebrew, _nâkar'_):** This verb (H5234, נָכַר) means to scrutinize, look intently at, and by extension, to acknowledge, perceive, or distinguish. In this context, the negative "could not discern" emphasizes the inability of the listeners to clearly differentiate between the two distinct sounds. It speaks to an overwhelming auditory experience where the individual qualities of joy and weeping were lost in a unified, intense clamor, highlighting the profound and intermingled emotional state of the community.
* **Weeping (Hebrew, _bᵉkîy'_):** Derived from the root "to weep," this noun (H1065, בְּכִי) denotes deep, emotional lamentation, often accompanied by tears. Its use here signifies the raw grief, sorrow, and nostalgic pain experienced by the elders who remembered the First Temple's glory and the devastating loss and suffering endured during the Babylonian exile. It stands in stark contrast to the celebratory "shout of joy," underscoring the emotional polarity of the scene.
* **Loud (Hebrew, _gâdôwl'_):** This adjective (H1419, גָּדֹol) means "great" in various senses, including magnitude, intensity, or volume. When modifying "shout," it emphasizes the immense, powerful, and resounding nature of the collective acclamation. The "loud shout" was not merely audible but overwhelming, contributing significantly to the indistinguishable blend of sounds that permeated the atmosphere and was heard from afar.

#### Verse Breakdown
* **"So that the people could not discern the noise of the shout of joy from the noise of the weeping of the people:"** This opening clause presents the central paradox and emotional intensity of the scene. The inability to "discern" (distinguish) between the "shout of joy" and the "weeping" highlights the overwhelming volume and intermingling of these two contrasting sounds. It suggests a cacophony where exuberant celebration and profound sorrow merged into an undifferentiated roar, making it impossible for an observer to tell which emotion predominated. This underscores the intense emotional complexity of the moment, where joy and grief were not merely present simultaneously but were so intertwined as to be indistinguishable.
* **"for the people shouted with a loud shout, and the noise was heard afar off."** This concluding clause provides the reason for the indistinguishable sounds and emphasizes the sheer magnitude of the emotional outpouring. The phrase "shouted with a loud shout" (a cognate accusative in Hebrew) reinforces the immense volume and intensity of the collective acclamation, underscoring the powerful expression of emotion. The subsequent declaration that "the noise was heard afar off" serves as a hyperbolic statement, illustrating that the emotional intensity and significance of this event were not confined to the immediate vicinity of the Temple foundation but resonated powerfully, impacting all who heard it and signifying a truly momentous occasion.

#### Literary Devices
Ezra 3:13 is rich in **Contrast**, juxtaposing the "shout of joy" with the "weeping of the people." This stark opposition highlights the dual nature of the human experience of restoration and the varying perspectives within the community. The verse also employs **Hyperbole** with the phrase "the noise was heard afar off," emphasizing the extraordinary volume and far-reaching impact of the combined sounds, suggesting an almost overwhelming sensory experience. Furthermore, the inability to "discern" the sounds serves as a form of **Symbolism**, representing the complex, often contradictory, emotions that accompany significant life transitions and collective historical moments, where hope for the future is intertwined with remembrance of the past. The cacophony itself becomes a **Metaphor** for the mixed emotional landscape of the post-exilic community, a blend of triumph and lament.

### THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Ezra 3:13 offers profound theological insight into the nature of God's work and the human response to it. It reveals that divine restoration, while ultimately good and redemptive, is often experienced within the complexities of human emotion, encompassing both profound joy and deep lament. This tension reflects a biblical realism that acknowledges the "already and not yet" aspect of God's kingdom – the present experience of His grace alongside the lingering effects of a fallen world and past suffering. God's faithfulness is demonstrated not by the absence of tears, but by His presence in the midst of them, bringing forth new beginnings even from the ashes of destruction. The indistinguishable sounds underscore that God's grand narrative of redemption often unfolds in ways that challenge our neat categories, inviting us to trust His sovereign plan even when our hearts are a mix of celebration and sorrow. This passage reminds us that true spiritual maturity embraces the full spectrum of human experience before a sovereign God.

* [Psalm 126:5-6](/psalms/126-5-6 "Psalm 126:5-6 - Sowing in Tears, Reaping in Joy")
* [Zechariah 4:10](/zechariah/4-10 "Zechariah 4:10 - Despise Not Small Beginnings")
* [Nehemiah 8:9-10](/nehemiah/8-9-10 "Nehemiah 8:9-10 - The Joy of the Lord is Your Strength")

### REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Ezra 3:13 serves as a powerful and empathetic reminder that our faith journeys are rarely monochromatic. We frequently encounter situations where joy and sorrow, hope and lament, celebration and grief, coexist and even merge into an indistinguishable experience. This verse grants us profound permission to embrace the full spectrum of our emotions in the presence of God, recognizing that He is intimately present in our tears as much as in our shouts of praise. It encourages us not to dismiss "small beginnings" but to celebrate God's faithfulness in every step of restoration, even if the present reality doesn't perfectly replicate past glories or meet our ideal expectations. Our trust in God's ongoing work should endure, knowing that His sovereign plans unfold even through our complex emotional landscapes. This passage invites us to cultivate a mature faith that can hold both deep gratitude for what God is doing and honest lament for what has been lost, finding strength and hope in His unwavering presence through it all.

#### Questions for Reflection
* **In what areas of your life or community do you currently experience a blend of joy and sorrow, similar to the scene in Ezra 3:13?**
* **How does this passage encourage you to acknowledge and process complex emotions rather than suppressing or compartmentalizing them?**
* **What "small beginnings" in your spiritual journey, family, or community might God be asking you to celebrate, even if they don't yet match your ultimate hopes or past glories?**

### FAQ

**Why was there both joy and weeping at the Temple's foundation?**

Answer: The mixed emotions stemmed from the profoundly different perspectives and experiences of the people gathered. The younger generation, many of whom had grown up in exile or were born after the destruction of the First Temple, saw the laying of the foundation as a monumental act of God's faithfulness and the tangible beginning of a new era of hope and restoration. For them, it was a cause for pure, unadulterated celebration, a sign that God was bringing His people back to their land and rebuilding their spiritual center. In stark contrast, the older generation had vivid and painful memories of the magnificent First Temple built by King Solomon (as described in [1 Kings 6](/1_kings/6 "1 Kings 6 - Solomon Builds the Temple")), which had been a structure of unparalleled grandeur, beauty, and spiritual glory. The new foundation, while significant, appeared humble and modest in comparison to what they remembered. Their weeping was a deep lament for the lost glory, a poignant reminder of the destruction of Jerusalem, the long years of exile, and the suffering they had endured, coupled with a sense of disappointment that the new structure could not immediately rival the former. Thus, the scene was a powerful blend of triumph and tragedy, hope and nostalgia, reflecting the complex human experience of divine restoration.

### CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
The powerful scene of mixed emotions at the Temple's foundation in Ezra 3:13 finds its profound Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and work of Jesus, who is the ultimate Temple and the true source of all lasting restoration. The physical Temple in Jerusalem, though a place where God's presence dwelt and atonement was made, was always a shadow, pointing forward to the greater reality to come. Jesus Himself declared, "[Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up,](/john/2-19 "John 2:19 - Jesus Predicts His Resurrection")" referring to the temple of His own body (as explicitly explained in [John 2:21](/john/2-21 "John 2:21 - Jesus Speaks of His Body as the Temple")). Through His sacrificial death and glorious resurrection, Jesus became the new and living way to God, the perfect and final sacrifice, and the true dwelling place of God among humanity (cf. [Hebrews 10:19-20](/hebrews/10-19-20 "Hebrews 10:19-20 - The New and Living Way to God")). The "shout of joy" in Ezra foreshadows the eternal joy of redemption found in Christ, the triumphant victory over sin, death, and the powers of darkness (as celebrated in [Colossians 2:15](/colossians/2-15 "Colossians 2:15 - Christ's Triumph Over Principalities")). The "weeping" of the elders, lamenting a lost glory and the consequences of sin, points to the profound sorrow over human rebellion and separation from God, which Jesus ultimately bore on the cross as the Suffering Servant (cf. [Isaiah 53:4-5](/isaiah/53-4-5 "Isaiah 53:4-5 - The Suffering Servant Bears Our Griefs")). In Christ, both joy and sorrow are transformed: our godly sorrow over sin leads to repentance and the joy of salvation (as seen in [2 Corinthians 7:10](/2_corinthians/7-10 "2 Corinthians 7:10 - Godly Sorrow Produces Repentance")), and our ultimate hope is no longer in a physical structure but in the spiritual Temple, the Church, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone (cf. [Ephesians 2:20-22](/ephesians/2-20-22 "Ephesians 2:20-22 - The Church as God's Dwelling Place")). Ultimately, the vision of the New Jerusalem in Revelation reveals a city with no need for a temple, "for its temple is the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb" ([Revelation 21:22](/revelation/21-22 "Revelation 21:22 - No Temple in the New Jerusalem")), signifying the complete and perfect restoration where all tears will be wiped away, and only eternal joy in God's glorious presence remains (cf. [Revelation 21:4](/revelation/21-4 "Revelation 21:4 - No More Weeping or Pain")).

Note: Commentary is generated by AI with a directive for Biblical fidelity. Always rely on the Holy Spirit for discernment. The Scripture text and cross-references are from verified, non-AI sources.

Cross-References

1 Samuel 4:5

And when the ark of the covenant of the LORD came into the camp, all Israel shouted with a great shout, so that the earth rang again.

Luke 19:37

And when he was come nigh, even now at the descent of the mount of Olives, the whole multitude of the disciples began to rejoice and praise God with a loud voice for all the mighty works that they had seen;

Luke 19:40

And he answered and said unto them, I tell you that, if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.

Judges 2:5

And they called the name of that place Bochim: and they sacrificed there unto the LORD.

Psalms 100:1

¶ A Psalm of praise. Make a joyful noise unto the LORD, all ye lands.

Psalms 100:2

Serve the LORD with gladness: come before his presence with singing.

Nehemiah 12:43

Also that day they offered great sacrifices, and rejoiced: for God had made them rejoice with great joy: the wives also and the children rejoiced: so that the joy of Jerusalem was heard even afar off.