Skip to content
“Interpretation: Media-Persia, Greece, and the Little Horn”· Daniel 8:20–26
Translation
King James Version
And in the latter time of their kingdom, when the transgressors are come to the full, a king of fierce countenance, and understanding dark sentences, shall stand up.
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
And in the latter time H319 of their kingdom H4438, when the transgressors H6586 are come to the full H8552, a king H4428 of fierce H5794 countenance H6440, and understanding H995 dark sentences H2420, shall stand up H5975.
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
In the latter part of their reign, when the evildoers have become as evil as possible, there will arise an arrogant king skilled in intrigue.
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
In the latter part of their reign, when the rebellion has reached its full measure, an insolent king, skilled in intrigue, will come to the throne.
Ask
American Standard Version
And in the latter time of their kingdom, when the transgressors are come to the full, a king of fierce countenance, and understanding dark sentences, shall stand up.
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
In the latter time of their kingdom, when the transgressors have come to the full, a king of fierce face, and understanding dark sentences, shall stand up.
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
And in the end of their kingdome, when the rebellious shalbe consumed, a King of fierce countenance, and vnderstanding darke sentences, shall stand vp.
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
`And in the latter end of their kingdom, about the perfecting of the transgressors, stand up doth a king, fierce of face, and understanding hidden things;
Ask
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 21,985 of 31,102 · 70.7%

Study This Verse

Summary

Daniel 8:23 prophesies the emergence of a formidable and cunning king who will rise during a period of widespread moral decline and rebellion against God, specifically in the latter days of the four successor kingdoms of Alexander the Great's empire. This figure, historically identified with Antiochus IV Epiphanes, is characterized by his ruthless demeanor and mastery of deceptive schemes, serving as a prophetic type for future tyrannical powers, including the ultimate antichrist.

Context

Literary Context

This verse is a pivotal moment within Daniel's vision in Daniel chapter 8, which symbolically depicts the rise and fall of two major empires. The vision begins with a ram (Medo-Persia) and a goat (Greece). The "great horn" of the goat represents Alexander the Great, whose rapid conquest is vividly portrayed. Following the breaking of this great horn, four notable horns emerge, signifying the division of Alexander's empire into four successor kingdoms (Daniel 8:22). Daniel 8:23 then focuses on a specific tyrannical ruler who will arise "in the latter time of their kingdom," indicating that this king will emerge from one of these four divisions, bringing a period of intense persecution and desecration. The subsequent verses in Daniel 8:24-25 detail this king's destructive actions and his eventual downfall, emphasizing divine intervention.

Historical & Cultural Context

The historical fulfillment of this prophecy is widely understood to be Antiochus IV Epiphanes, a king of the Seleucid Empire (one of the four Hellenistic successor kingdoms) who reigned from 175 to 164 BC. His rule was marked by an aggressive Hellenization policy, which included a severe persecution of the Jews. In 167 BC, Antiochus famously desecrated the Jerusalem Temple by sacrificing a pig on its altar and erecting an idol of Zeus, an event known as the "abomination of desolation" (Daniel 11:31). His actions provoked the Maccabean Revolt, a significant period in Jewish history. The cultural context of the time involved the clash between Hellenistic culture and traditional Jewish practices, with Antiochus representing the extreme imposition of Greek customs and religious practices upon the Jewish people, leading to immense suffering and resistance.

Key Themes

Daniel 8:23 contributes significantly to several major themes found throughout the book of Daniel. Firstly, it powerfully underscores the theme of Divine Sovereignty, demonstrating that God is in ultimate control of human history, even over the rise and fall of powerful, wicked empires and rulers. The prophecy reveals that the emergence of such a king is not random but foreknown and permitted within God's overarching plan. Secondly, the phrase "when the transgressors are come to the full" introduces the theme of Human Depravity and its Consequences, suggesting that the rise of this tyrannical figure is, in part, a judgment or consequence of widespread moral and spiritual rebellion among God's people. Thirdly, the detailed description of the king's character—his "fierce countenance" and "understanding dark sentences"—highlights the theme of The Nature of Evil and Tyranny, portraying it as ruthless, deceptive, and intellectually cunning. Finally, this verse functions as a crucial example of Prophetic Typology, where Antiochus IV Epiphanes serves not only as a historical fulfillment but also as a prototype or foreshadowing of a future, ultimate "man of lawlessness" or antichrist figure, whose characteristics and actions will mirror those of Antiochus on a grander, eschatological scale, as seen in passages like 2 Thessalonians 2:3-4 and Revelation 13:7.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

latter time ʼachărîyth' H319

Meaning "the last or end, hence, the future; also posterity." This term signifies a specific, culminating period within the timeline of the four kingdoms, implying a final stage or the end of their dominion before the rise of this particular king. It points to a decisive moment in the prophetic unfolding.

fierce ʻaz' H5794

Meaning "strong, vehement, harsh." This adjective describes the king's character as intensely powerful, unyielding, and aggressive. When combined with "countenance" (pânîym), it paints a picture of someone whose very presence radiates an intimidating, ruthless, and uncompassionate disposition.

dark sentences chîydâh' H2420

Meaning "a puzzle, hence, a trick, conundrum, sententious maxim; dark saying (sentence, speech), hard question, proverb, riddle." This word highlights the king's intellectual capacity for deception, intrigue, and complex, often misleading, schemes. He is not merely powerful but also cunning, a master of subtle manipulation and hidden agendas, rather than straightforward communication.

Verse Breakdown

"And in the latter time of their kingdom"

This phrase establishes the chronological setting for the king's emergence. "Their kingdom" refers to the four successor kingdoms that arose from Alexander the Great's empire. The "latter time" indicates that this king will appear towards the end of the period dominated by these Hellenistic dynasties, specifically the Seleucid line, which aligns with the historical timing of Antiochus IV Epiphanes.

"when the transgressors are come to the full"

This clause provides a crucial spiritual and moral context. It suggests that the king's rise is correlated with a peak in widespread sin, apostasy, and rebellion against God among the people. This "fullness" of transgression implies a state of moral decay that, in divine providence, sets the stage for judgment or the allowance of oppressive rule. It highlights a connection between human unrighteousness and the emergence of tyrannical figures.

"a king of fierce countenance, and understanding dark sentences, shall stand up"

This describes the nature and character of the prophesied ruler. "A king of fierce countenance" portrays him as bold, insolent, ruthless, and without pity—his very face reflecting his cruel and defiant nature. "Understanding dark sentences" reveals his intellectual prowess in cunning, deception, and intricate, often malicious, plots. He is not just a brute but a master strategist of evil, skilled in riddles, enigmas, and obscure, deceptive communication. The phrase "shall stand up" denotes his emergence, his taking a prominent and active role on the world stage.

Literary Devices

The verse employs several potent literary devices to convey its prophetic message. Typology is central, as the figure of the "king of fierce countenance" serves not only as a specific historical individual (Antiochus IV Epiphanes) but also as a type or foreshadowing of future, ultimate adversaries of God's people, particularly the antichrist figure in end-time prophecy. The description "fierce countenance" uses Metonymy or Synecdoche, where the physical attribute (countenance) represents the entire character and disposition of the king—his ruthlessness, boldness, and lack of compassion. Similarly, "understanding dark sentences" employs Metaphor to describe his cunning and deceptive intelligence, likening his schemes to complex riddles or enigmas. The phrase "when the transgressors are come to the full" uses Hyperbole to emphasize the extreme degree of moral corruption that precedes the king's rise, underscoring the severity of the spiritual climate.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Daniel 8:23 deeply enriches our understanding of God's sovereign control over history and the nature of evil. It reveals that even the most oppressive and cunning rulers operate within the confines of God's foreknowledge and ultimate plan. The rise of such a "fierce" and "dark" king, occurring when "transgressors are come to the full," underscores a profound theological principle: human rebellion and moral decay often precede or coincide with periods of divine judgment or the allowance of tyrannical forces. This does not imply that God causes evil, but that He permits it to run its course, often as a consequence of widespread sin, ultimately for His greater purposes, which include bringing about repentance or demonstrating His power to overcome all opposition. The prophecy also serves as a stark reminder of the spiritual battle between good and evil, and the constant need for discernment and faithfulness in the face of deceptive powers.

Daniel 7:23-26Prophesies a terrifying fourth beast and a "little horn" that speaks against the Most High and persecutes the saints, setting times and law, until judgment is given to the saints.
2 Thessalonians 2:3-4Describes the "man of lawlessness" who will oppose and exalt himself above everything called God, even sitting in God's temple and proclaiming himself to be God.
Revelation 13:1-8Portrays a beast rising from the sea, given power by the dragon, speaking blasphemies, and making war on the saints, with all the world worshipping it.

Reflection and Application

Daniel 8:23 offers timeless insights for believers navigating a world often marked by injustice and oppression. It calls us to cultivate spiritual discernment, enabling us to recognize the characteristics of tyrannical power, whether manifested in political systems, ideologies, or individual leaders. The "fierce countenance" and "understanding dark sentences" serve as a warning against overt cruelty and subtle deception. This prophecy reminds us that periods of widespread moral decline can create fertile ground for such figures to emerge, prompting us to examine our own lives and societies for signs of transgression "coming to the full." Crucially, it anchors our hope in God's unwavering sovereignty; despite the rise of wicked powers, they are ultimately subject to His divine timetable and purpose. This should inspire steadfast faith and courage, knowing that evil will not ultimately prevail. It also challenges us to be counter-cultural witnesses, living righteously and speaking truth in a world that may be increasingly embracing "dark sentences."

Questions for Reflection

  1. How does understanding the "latter time of their kingdom" help us interpret current global events and the rise of certain leaders?
  2. In what ways might "transgressors coming to the full" manifest in our society today, and what is our responsibility in such times?
  3. What does it mean to have a "fierce countenance" or "understand dark sentences" in a contemporary context, and how can we discern such characteristics?
  4. How does the sovereignty of God, as demonstrated in this prophecy, provide comfort and strength when faced with seemingly overwhelming evil?

FAQ

Is Daniel 8:23 exclusively about Antiochus IV Epiphanes, or does it have a broader fulfillment?

While Daniel 8:23 finds its primary historical fulfillment in Antiochus IV Epiphanes, a king of the Seleucid Empire who severely persecuted the Jews in the 2nd century BC, biblical scholars widely understand him to be a type or foreshadowing of a greater, eschatological figure. The characteristics described—a fierce demeanor, cunning intellect, and opposition to God's people—are so pronounced that they point beyond a single historical individual to a pattern of evil that culminates in the ultimate antichrist. Therefore, it has both a specific historical fulfillment and a broader prophetic application, serving as a prototype for the "man of lawlessness" described in 2 Thessalonians 2 and the beast in Revelation 13.

What does "when the transgressors are come to the full" imply about the timing of this king's appearance?

This phrase suggests a direct correlation between the moral and spiritual state of humanity and the emergence of this tyrannical ruler. "Come to the full" implies a culmination or saturation point of rebellion, apostasy, and sin against God. The timing indicates that this king arises not randomly, but during a period when human wickedness has reached an extreme measure, perhaps signaling a time of divine judgment or the allowance of evil to fully manifest itself. It serves as a sobering warning that societal moral decay can create the conditions for oppressive powers to gain ascendancy.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

While Daniel 8:23 describes a formidable human adversary, its ultimate Christ-centered fulfillment lies in the stark contrast between this "king of fierce countenance" and the true King, Jesus Christ, and in Christ's decisive victory over all such evil. The "fierce countenance" of the earthly king is met by the unyielding, righteous gaze of the Lion of the tribe of Judah, who perfectly understands not "dark sentences" but the profound mysteries of God's kingdom. The temporary reign of the oppressive king, whose power is given by the dragon, stands in stark opposition to the eternal, righteous dominion of Christ, who has all authority in heaven and on earth. The "transgressors coming to the full" sets the stage for the rise of the human tyrant, but Christ's first coming was precisely to take away the sin of the world, offering redemption and a path out of transgression. Ultimately, the prophetic type of the oppressive king in Daniel 8:23 is definitively vanquished by Christ. Just as the vision in Daniel points to the cutting off of the "little horn" without human hand (Daniel 8:25), so too will Christ, at His second coming, destroy the man of lawlessness with the breath of His mouth and establish His eternal kingdom, which shall never be destroyed (Daniel 7:14). Thus, Daniel 8:23, while describing a dark period, ultimately magnifies the light and triumph of Christ over all forces of evil and deception.

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Daniel 8:15–27. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 13 verses
Passage under commentDaniel 8:15–27
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

Here we have,

I.Daniel's earnest desire to have this vision explained to him (Dan 8:15):

I sought the meaning. Note, Those that rightly know the things of God cannot but desire to know more and more of them, and to be led further into the mystery of them; and those that would find the meaning of what they have seen or heard from God must seek it, and seek it diligently. Seek and you shall find. Daniel considered the thing, compared it with the former discoveries, to try if he could understand it; but especially he sought by prayer (as he had done Dan 2:18), and he did not seek in vain.

II.Orders given to the angel Gabriel to inform him concerning this vision.

One in the appearance of a man (who, some think, was Christ himself, for who besides could command angels?) orders Gabriel to make Daniel understand this vision. Sometimes God is pleased to make use of the ministration of angels, not only to protect his children, but to instruct them, to serve the kind intentions, not only of his providence, but of his grace.

III.The consternation that Daniel was in upon the approach of his instructor (Dan 8:17):

When he came near I was afraid. Though Daniel was a man of great prudence and courage, and had been conversant with the visions of the Almighty, yet the approach of an extraordinary messenger from heaven put him into this fright. He fell upon his face, not to worship the angel, but because he could no longer bear the dazzling lustre of his glory. Nay, being prostrate upon the ground, he fell into a deep sleep, (Dan 8:18), which came not from any neglect of the vision, or indifference towards it, but was an effect of his faintness and the oppression of spirit he was under, through the abundance of revelations. The disciples in the garden slept for sorrow; and, as there, so here, the spirit was willing, but the flesh was weak. Daniel would have kept awake, and could not.

IV.The relief which the angel gave to Daniel, with great encouragement to him to expect a satisfactory discovery of the meaning of this vision.

1.He touched him, and set him upon his feet, Dan 8:18. Thus when John, in a similar case, was in similar consternation, Christ laid his right hand upon him, Rev 1:17. It was a gentle touch that the angel here gave to Daniel, to show that he came not to hurt him, not to plead against him with his great power, or with a hand heavy upon him, but to help him, to put strength into him (Job 23:6), which God can do with a touch. When we are slumbering and grovelling on this earth we are very unfit to hear from God, and to converse with him. But, if God design instruction for us, he will be his grace awaken us out of our slumber, raise us from things below, and set us upright.

2.He promised to inform him: "Understand, O son of man! Dan 8:17. Thou shalt understand, if thou wilt but apply thy mind to understand." He calls him son of man to intimate that he would consider his frame, and would deal tenderly with him, accommodating himself to his capacity as a man. Or thus he preaches humility to him; though he be admitted to converse with angels, he must not be puffed up with it, but must remember that he is a son of man. Or perhaps this title puts honour upon him: the Messiah was lately called the Son of man (Dan 7:13), and Daniel is akin to him, and is a figure of him as a prophet and one greatly beloved. He assures him that he shall be made to know what shall be in the last end of the indignation, Dan 8:19. Let it be laid up for a comfort to those who shall live to see these calamitous times that there shall be an end of them; the indignation shall cease (Isa 10:25); it shall be overpast, Isa 26:20. It may intermit and return again, but the last end shall be glorious; good will follow it, nay, and good will be brought out of it. He tells him (Dan 8:17), "At the time of the end shall be the vision; when the last end of the indignation comes, when the course of this providence is completed, then the vision shall be made plain and intelligible by the event, as the event shall be made plain and intelligible by the vision." Or, "At the time of the end of the Jewish church, in the latter days of it, shall this vision be accomplished, 300 or 400 years hence; understand it therefore, that thou mayest leave it on record for the generations to come." But is he ask more particularly, "When is the time of the end? And how long will it be before it arrive?" let this answer suffice (Dan 8:19): At the time appointed the end shall be; it is fixed in the divine counsel, which cannot be altered and which must not be pried into.

V.The exposition which he gave him of the vision.

1.Concerning the two monarchies of Persia and Greece, Dan 8:20-22. The ram signified the succession of the kings of Media and Persia; the rough goat signified the kings of Greece; the great horn was Alexander; the four horns that rose in his room were the four kingdoms into which his conquests were cantoned, of which before, Dan 8:8. They are said to stand up out of the nations, but not in his power; none of them ever made the figure that Alexander did. Josephus relates that when Alexander had taken Tyre, and subdued Palestine, and was upon his march to Jerusalem, Jaddas, who was them high priest (Nehemiah mentions one of his name, Neh 12:11), fearing his rage, had recourse to God by prayer and sacrifice for the common safety, and was by him warned in a dream that upon Alexander's approach he should throw open the gates of the city, and that he and the rest of the priests should go forth to meet him in their habits, and all the people in white. Alexander, seeing this company at a distance, went himself alone to the high priest, and, having prostrated himself before that God whose name was engraven in the golden plate of his mitre, he first saluted him; and, being asked by one of his own captains why he did so, he said that while he was yet in Macedon, musing on the conquest of Asia, there appeared to him a man like unto this, and thus attired, who invited him into Asia, and assured him of success in the conquest of it. The priests led him to the temple, where he offered sacrifice to the God of Israel as they directed him; and there they showed him this book of the prophet Daniel, that it was there foretold that a Grecian should come and destroy the Persians, which animated him very much in the expedition he was now meditating against Darius. Hereupon he took the Jews and their religion under his protection, promised to be kind to those of their religion in Babylon and Media, whither he was now marching, and in honour of him all the priests that had sons born that year called them Alexander. Joseph. lib. 11.

2.Concerning Antiochus, and his oppression of the Jews. This is said to be in the latter time of the kingdom of the Greeks, when the transgressors are come to the full (Dan 8:23); that is, when the degenerate Jews have filled up the measure of their iniquity, and are ripe for this destruction, so that God cannot in honour bear with them any longer then shall stand up this king, to be flagellum Dei - the rod in God's hand for the chastising of the Jews. Now observe here,

(1.)His character: He shall be a king of fierce countenance, insolent and furious, neither fearing God nor regarding man, understanding dark sentences, or (rather) versed in dark practices, the hidden things of dishonesty; he was master of all the arts of dissimulation and deceit, and knew the depths of Satan as well as any man. He was wise to do evil.

(2.)His success. He shall make dreadful havoc of the nations about him: His power shall be mighty, bear down all before it, but not by his own power (Dan 8:24), but partly by the assistance of his allies, Eumenes and Attalus, partly by the baseness and treachery of many of the Jews, even of the priests that came into his interests, and especially by the divine permission. it was not by his own power, but by a power given him from above, that he destroyed wonderfully, and thought he made himself a great man by being a great destroyer. He destroys wonderfully indeed, for he destroys,

[1.]The mighty people, and they cannot resist him by their power. The princes of Egypt cannot stand before him with all their forces, but he practises against them and prospers. Note, The mighty ones of the earth commonly meet with those at length that are too hard for them, that are more mighty than they. Let not the strong man then glory in his strength, be it ever so great, unless he could be sure that there were none stronger than he.

[2.]He destroys the holy people, or the people of the holy ones; and their sacred character does neither deter him from destroying them nor defend them from being destroyed. All things come alike to all, and there is one event to the mighty and to the holy in this world.

[3.]The methods by which he will gain this success, not by true courage, wisdom, or justice, but by his policy and craft (Dan 8:25), by fraud and deceit, and serpentine subtlety: He shall cause craft to prosper; so cunningly shall he carry on his projects that he shall gain his point by the art of wheedling. By peace he shall destroy many, as others do by war; under the pretence of treaties, leagues, and alliances, with them, he shall encroach on their rights, and trick them into a subjection to him. Thus sometimes what a nation truly brave has gained in a righteous war a nation truly base has regained in a treacherous peace, and craft has been caused to prosper.

[4.]The mischief that he shall do to religion: He shall magnify himself in his heart, and think himself fit to prescribe and give law to every body, so that he shall stand up against the Prince of princes, that is, against God himself. He will profane his temple and altar, prohibit his worship, and persecute his worshippers. See what a height of impudence some men's impiety brings them to; they openly bid defiance to God himself though he is the Kings of kings.

[5.]The ruin that he shall be brought to at last: He shall be broken without hand, that is, without the hand of man. He shall not be slain in war, nor shall he be assassinated, as tyrants commonly were, but he shall fall into the hand of the living God and die by an immediate stroke of his vengeance. He, hearing that the Jews had cast the image of Jupiter Olympius out of the temple, where he had placed it, was so enraged at the Jews that he vowed he would make Jerusalem a common burial-place, and determined to march thither immediately; but no sooner had he spoken these proud words than he was struck with an incurable plague in his bowels; worms bred so fast in his body that whole flakes of flesh sometimes dropped from him; his torments were violent, and the stench of his disease such that none could endure to come near him. He continued in this misery very long. At first he persisted in his menaces against the Jews; but at length, despairing of his recovery, he called his friends together, and acknowledged all those miseries to have fallen upon him for the injuries he had done to the Jews and his profaning the temple at Jerusalem. Then he wrote courteous letters to the Jews, and vowed that if he recovered he would let them have the free exercise of their religion. But, finding his disease grow upon him, when he could no longer endure his own smell, he said, It is meet to submit to God, and for man who is mortal not to set himself in competition with God, and so died miserably in a strange land, on the mountains of Pacata near Babylon: so Ussher's Annals, A.M. 3840, about 160 years before the birth of Christ.

3.As to the time fixed for the continuance of the cessation of the daily sacrifice, it is not explained here, but only confirmed (Dan 8:26). That vision of the evening and morning is true, in the proper sense of the words, and needs no explication. How unlikely soever it might be that God should suffer his own sanctuary to be thus profaned, yet it is true, it is too true, so it shall be.

VI.Here is the conclusion of this vision, and here,

1.The charge given to Daniel to keep it private for the present: Shut thou up the vision; let it not be publicly know among the Chaldeans, lest the Persians, who were now shortly to possess the kingdom, should be incensed against the Jews by it, because the downfall of their kingdom was foretold by it, which would be unseasonable now that the edict for their release was expected from the king of Persia. Shut it up, for it shall be for many days. It was about 300 years from the time of this vision to the time of the accomplishment of it; therefore he must shut it up for the present, even from the people of the Jews, lest it should amaze and perplex them, but let it be kept safely for the generations to come, that should live about the time of the accomplishment of it, for to them it would be both most intelligible and most serviceable. Note, What we know of the things of God should be carefully laid up, that hereafter, when there is occasion, it may be faithfully laid out; and what we have not now any use for, yet we may have another time. Divine truths should be sealed up among our treasures, that we may find them again after many days.

2.The care he took to keep it private, having received such a charge, Dan 8:27. He fainted, and was sick, with the multitude of his thoughts within him occasioned by this vision, which oppressed and overwhelmed him the more because he was forbidden to publish what he had seen, so that his belly was as wine which has no vent, he was ready to burst like new bottles, Job 32:19. However, he kept it to himself, stifled and smothered the concern he was in; so that those he conversed with could not perceive it, but he did the king's business according to the duty of his place, whatever it was. Note, As long as we live in this world we must have something to do in it; and even those whom God has most dignified with his favours must not think themselves above their business; nor must the pleasure of communion with God take us off from the duties of our particular callings, but still we must in them abide with God. Those especially that are entrusted with public business must see to it that they conscientiously discharge their trust.

Copy as

Historical interpretation

Historical Reception

One surviving comment on this verse from the historical church.

1 quote · AD 373
AD 373Ephrem the SyrianPost-NiceneSourceCOMMENTARY ON DANIEL 8:23
When the Jews begin to abandon the law and faith of God and to estrange themselves, the grandchildren of Seleucus Nicator will invade the last part of their kingdom. “A king of bold countenance shall arise”: this is Antiochus, who is able to understand riddles, is cunning and is ready to weave intrigues and to prepare his domination by means of his intelligence.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Daniel 8:23 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.