Skip to content

Psalms 73:15

“Doubt and Despair”· Psalms 73:13–16Read in context
King James Version
¶ If I say, I will speak thus; behold, I should offend against the generation of thy children.
KJV (with Strong's)
If I say H559 H8804, I will speak H5608 H8762 thus H3644; behold, I should offend H898 H8804 against the generation H1755 of thy children H1121.
Complete Jewish Bible
If I had said, "I will talk like them,"I would have betrayed a generation of your children.
Berean Standard Bible
If I had said, “I will speak this way,” then I would have betrayed Your children.
American Standard Version
If I had said, I will speak thus; Behold, I had dealt treacherously with the generation of thy children.
World English Bible Messianic
If I had said, “I will speak thus”; behold, I would have betrayed the generation of your children.
Geneva Bible (1599)
If I say, I will iudge thus, beholde the generation of thy children: I haue trespassed.
Young's Literal Translation
If I have said, `I recount thus,' Lo, a generation of Thy sons I have deceived.
Translation
In the KJVVerse 15,036 of 31,102 · 48.3%

Study this verse

Summary

Psalms 73:15 captures a pivotal moment in Asaph's spiritual journey where, after wrestling with the apparent injustice of the wicked's prosperity, he contemplates voicing his profound doubts. However, he immediately recoils from this impulse, recognizing that such public expression of unrefined skepticism would not merely be unhelpful but would actively "offend" or betray "the generation of thy children"—God's covenant people, particularly the vulnerable and less mature in faith. This verse highlights Asaph's deep pastoral concern and his discerning wisdom to protect the spiritual well-being of the community over the immediate gratification of airing his personal frustrations.

Context

Literary Context

Psalms 73 is a wisdom psalm, a deeply personal lament that ultimately transitions into a profound affirmation of faith. It belongs to the "Psalms of Asaph" (Psalms 73-83), characterized by their theological depth and often wrestling with issues of divine justice and human suffering. The psalm opens with Asaph's honest confession of envy and near spiritual collapse as he observes the apparent ease and prosperity of the wicked, admitting his feet had almost stumbled and his steps had nearly slipped as he saw the prosperity of the wicked (Psalms 73:2-3). He vividly describes their pride, violence, and seeming immunity from hardship, noting that they are always at ease and increase in wealth (Psalms 73:6-12). This internal turmoil leads him to question the value of his own purity and righteous living, wondering if he had cleansed his heart in vain and washed his hands in innocence for nothing (Psalms 73:13-14). Verse 15 serves as a critical turning point, a moment of profound self-correction and discernment, immediately preceding his entry into the sanctuary where he gains clarity regarding the wicked's end (Psalms 73:17). It marks the crucial shift from outward observation and internal complaint to an inward, protective posture towards God's people.

Historical & Cultural Context

Asaph was a prominent Levite, a chief musician, and a seer during the reigns of David and Solomon, playing a significant role in leading worship and prophecy, as seen in 1 Chronicles 16:4-7. His position meant he held significant spiritual authority and influence within the Israelite community. In ancient Israel, the community was tightly knit, and the words and actions of leaders carried immense weight, directly impacting the faith and morale of the entire congregation. The concept of "the generation of thy children" refers to the covenant people of God, Israel, emphasizing their collective identity and shared spiritual heritage as God's chosen family. Causing a fellow Israelite to stumble, especially one less mature or struggling, was a serious offense within the covenant community, reflecting a deep responsibility to uphold one another in faith and obedience to God.

Key Themes

This verse contributes significantly to several key themes within Psalms 73 and the broader biblical narrative. Firstly, it underscores the weight and responsibility of our words, particularly for those in positions of spiritual influence. Asaph recognizes that unbridled expression of doubt, even if personally felt, can have devastating consequences for the faith of others. This resonates with the wisdom found in Proverbs 18:21, which states that "death and life are in the power of the tongue." Secondly, it highlights the theme of pastoral care and protection of the vulnerable within the community of faith. Asaph's concern for "the generation of thy children" demonstrates a profound sense of duty to safeguard the spiritual well-being of God's people, especially those who might be easily discouraged or led astray by a respected leader's public struggles. This resonates strongly with later New Testament teachings on not causing a brother or sister to stumble, as articulated in Romans 14:13. Finally, the verse subtly introduces the theme of discretion in doubt, suggesting that while internal wrestling with faith questions is a natural part of spiritual growth, the manner and context in which those doubts are processed and expressed are critical for the health of the individual and the community, leading to a deeper understanding as Asaph found in the sanctuary.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Say ʼâmar' H559

The Hebrew verb אָמַר (ʼâmar) is a primitive root meaning "to say" or "to speak," used with great latitude to include answering, appointing, commanding, declaring, or even thinking. In this context, it refers to Asaph's internal contemplation and the potential outward articulation of his doubts and grievances that he has been harboring. It highlights the power and intentionality behind his potential words.

Offend bâgad' H898

The KJV translation "offend" here carries a much stronger meaning than merely causing annoyance. The Hebrew verb בָּגַד (bâgad) means "to cover (with a garment)," and figuratively, "to act covertly," "to deal deceitfully," "treacherously," or "unfaithfully." It implies a serious breach of trust or loyalty, a violation of a covenant. Asaph understands that publicly voicing his doubts about God's justice would be tantamount to a spiritual betrayal of God's people, potentially leading them into doubt, despair, or even apostasy, thus violating his pastoral responsibility and the communal covenant.

Generation dôwr' H1755

The Hebrew word דּוֹר (dôwr) refers to "a revolution of time," an "age," or a "generation," and can also refer to a "dwelling." In this context, "the generation of thy children" refers to the contemporary community of God's people, those living at that time who are part of His covenant family. It emphasizes the collective identity and shared spiritual journey of believers who are living through the same period.

Children bên' H1121

The term בֵּן (bên), meaning "son" or "child," is a tender and intimate descriptor for God's people, emphasizing their special relationship as His beloved offspring. It underscores the vulnerability and preciousness of those whom Asaph is concerned about, highlighting their dependence on God's faithfulness and the guidance of their spiritual leaders.

Verse Breakdown

"If I say, I will speak thus; behold, I should offend"

This clause reveals Asaph's internal monologue and the hypothetical nature of his potential action. He is contemplating the very act of articulating his bitter observations and doubts about divine justice, particularly the prosperity of the wicked and the apparent futility of his own righteous living, as expressed in Psalms 73:13-14. The phrase "I will speak thus" refers to the grievances and questions he has just articulated. The immediate recognition, "behold, I should offend," demonstrates a moment of profound self-correction and spiritual discernment. He perceives the severe negative consequence of such speech, understanding it as a betrayal.

"[against] the generation of thy children."

This specifies the object of Asaph's potential "offense" or betrayal. It is not merely a general public, but specifically "the generation of thy children"—God's covenant community, His beloved people. This highlights Asaph's pastoral heart and his understanding of his responsibility to protect and nurture the faith of those who look to God, particularly those who might be less mature, weaker in faith, or susceptible to discouragement. His words, if spoken publicly and without discernment, could cause them to stumble, doubt God's goodness, or even abandon their faith, thus betraying their trust and their relationship with God.

Literary Devices

Psalms 73:15 employs several significant literary devices. The primary device is a Hypothetical Statement ("If I say..."), which allows Asaph to explore the potential consequences of a contemplated action without actually performing it. This creates a moment of dramatic tension and internal conflict, revealing the depth of his ethical and spiritual consideration. The psalm itself is largely an Internal Monologue, and this verse is a crucial turning point within that monologue, marking a shift from complaint to discernment. The phrase "behold, I should offend" functions as an Exclamatory Realization, emphasizing the sudden and impactful understanding Asaph has of the gravity of his potential words. Finally, the word "offend" (Hebrew bagad) functions as a powerful Metaphor for spiritual betrayal or causing a severe stumbling block, far beyond a simple slight, underscoring the profound responsibility of speech within the covenant community.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Psalms 73:15 profoundly underscores the biblical emphasis on the power of speech and the sacred responsibility of those who influence others. Asaph's moment of self-correction reveals a deep theological truth: our words, especially when spoken by those in leadership or with spiritual authority, have the capacity to either build up or tear down the faith of others. The concept of "offending" or causing others to stumble is a recurring theme throughout Scripture, highlighting God's tender care for His vulnerable children and the severe consequences for those who lead them astray. This verse serves as a powerful reminder that while honest wrestling with doubt is permissible before God, the public dissemination of unrefined spiritual struggles can be spiritually destructive to the community, particularly to those who are young in faith or experiencing their own trials. It calls believers to a high standard of discernment and pastoral sensitivity in all their communication, prioritizing the edification and protection of God's flock.

Reflection and Application

Asaph's profound moment of self-correction in Psalms 73:15 offers invaluable lessons for believers today. It challenges us to consider the immense power of our words and the responsibility we bear, not just for what we say, but for how and to whom we say it. While it is natural and even healthy to wrestle with doubts, frustrations, and questions about God's ways, Asaph demonstrates the wisdom of processing these struggles privately before God or with trusted, mature spiritual mentors, rather than broadcasting them in ways that could undermine the faith of others. This verse calls us to cultivate a pastoral heart, recognizing that our speech can either be a source of encouragement and stability or a stumbling block to those who might be less mature in their faith, new believers, or those navigating their own seasons of doubt. It encourages us to discern carefully when and how to articulate our internal struggles, always prioritizing the spiritual well-being of "the generation of thy children" and seeking to build up, rather than tear down, the body of Christ.

Questions for Reflection

  1. What internal struggles or doubts am I currently wrestling with, and where am I processing them?
  2. How do my words, both spoken and written (e.g., on social media), impact the faith of others, particularly those who might be vulnerable or less mature?
  3. In what ways can I exercise greater discernment and pastoral sensitivity in sharing my personal spiritual journey with others?
  4. Who are "the generation of thy children" in my life or community whom I am called to protect and encourage with my words?

FAQ

What does "offend" mean in Psalms 73:15, and why is it so significant?

The KJV word "offend" translates the Hebrew בָּגַד (bâgad), which is a much stronger term than simply causing annoyance. It means "to deal treacherously," "to betray," or "to act faithlessly." In this context, Asaph realizes that publicly voicing his unrefined doubts about God's justice would be a spiritual betrayal of "the generation of thy children"—God's covenant people. It would not just annoy them, but potentially cause them to stumble in their faith, doubt God's faithfulness, or even lead them into despair or apostasy. This highlights the severe spiritual harm that can come from irresponsible speech, especially from someone in a position of spiritual influence.

Who are "the generation of thy children" that Asaph is concerned about?

"The generation of thy children" refers to God's covenant people, the community of Israel, particularly those who are sincere in their faith but might be spiritually vulnerable, less mature, or struggling with their own doubts. Asaph, as a worship leader and seer, felt a deep pastoral responsibility for the spiritual well-being of this community. His concern reflects the biblical principle of protecting the "little ones" or weaker brethren from anything that might cause them to stumble, as Jesus himself warned in Matthew 18:6.

Is it wrong for believers to have doubts or questions about God?

No, it is not inherently wrong to have doubts or questions about God; in fact, they can often be a catalyst for deeper faith. Psalms 73 itself is a testament to Asaph's honest wrestling with profound theological questions. The issue in Psalms 73:15 is not the existence of doubt, but the public expression of unrefined, potentially destructive doubt to a vulnerable audience. Asaph wisely discerns that some struggles are best processed privately before God or with trusted, mature spiritual mentors, rather than being broadcast in a way that could undermine the faith of others. His journey ultimately leads him to clarity and renewed faith in God's sanctuary (Psalms 73:17), demonstrating that honest wrestling can lead to spiritual growth when handled discerningly.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

Psalms 73:15, with Asaph's discerning choice to protect "the generation of thy children" from his unrefined doubts, finds its ultimate fulfillment in the person and ministry of Jesus Christ. Jesus, the Good Shepherd, perfectly embodies the pastoral heart that Asaph only began to grasp. He consistently guarded His "little ones" and warned severely against causing any of them to stumble, declaring that it would be better for one to have a millstone tied around his neck and be cast into the sea than to cause one of His "little ones" to sin (Matthew 18:6-7). Unlike Asaph, who wrestled with the temptation to speak faithless words, Jesus's words were always pure, always true, and always life-giving, designed to build up and never to betray or cause offense to God's children. He is the ultimate Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world, never wavering in His trust in the Father, even in the face of unimaginable suffering and cosmic injustice, as prophesied and fulfilled in His atoning work (John 1:29). Through His perfect life, atoning death, and resurrection, Jesus brings into being the new "generation of thy children"—those who are adopted into God's family by faith in Him, becoming a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people for God's own possession (1 Peter 2:9). His Spirit now empowers believers to speak words that edify and build up the body of Christ, reflecting His own perfect example of speech that is always gracious and seasoned with salt (Ephesians 4:29).

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Psalms 73:15–20. His three-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 6 verses
Passage under commentPsalms 73:15–20
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

We have seen what a strong temptation the psalmist was in to envy prospering profaneness; now here we are told how he kept his footing and got the victory.

I.He kept up a respect for God's people, and with that he restrained himself from speaking what he had thought amiss, Psa 73:15.

He got the victory by degrees, and this was the first point he gained; he was ready to say, Verily, I have cleansed my heart in vain, and thought he had reason to say it, but he kept his mouth with this consideration, "If I say, I will speak thus, behold, I should myself revolt and apostatize from, and so give the greatest offence imaginable to, the generation of thy children." Observe here,

1.Though he thought amiss, he took care not to utter that evil thought which he had conceived. Note, It is bad to think ill, but it is worse to speak it, for that is giving the evil thought an imprimatur - a sanction; it is allowing it, giving consent to it, and publishing it for the infection of others. But it is a good sign that we repent of the evil imagination of the heart if we suppress it, and the error remains with ourselves. If therefore thou hast been so foolish as to think evil, be so wise as to lay thy hand upon thy mouth, and let it go no further, Pro 30:32. If I say, I will speak thus. Observe, Though his corrupt heart made this inference from the prosperity of the wicked, yet he did not mention it to those whether it were fit to be mentioned or no. Note, We must think twice before we speak once, both because some things may be thought which yet may not be spoken and because the second thoughts may correct the mistakes of the first.

2.The reason why he would not speak it was for fear of giving offence to those whom God owned for his children. Note,

(1.)There are a people in the world that are the generation of God's children, a set of men that hear and love God as their Father.

(2.)We must be very careful not to say or do any thing which may justly offend any of these little ones (Mat 18:6), especially which may offend the generation of them, may sadden their hearts, or weaken their hands, or shake their interest.

(3.)There is nothing that can give more general offence to the generation of God's children than to say that we have cleansed our heart in vain or that it is vain to serve God; for there is nothing more contrary to their universal sentiment and experience nor any thing that grieves them more than to hear God thus reflected on.

(4.)Those that wish themselves in the condition of the wicked do in effect quit the tents of God's children.

II.He foresaw the ruin of wicked people.

By this he baffled the temptation, as by the former he gave some check to it. Because he durst not speak what he had thought, for fear of giving offence, he began to consider whether he had any good reason for that thought (Psa 73:16): "I endeavoured to understand the meaning of this unaccountable dispensation of Providence; but it was too painful for me. I could not conquer it by the strength of my own reasoning." It is a problem, not to be solved by the mere light of nature, for, if there were not another life after this, we could not fully reconcile the prosperity of the wicked with the justice of God. But (Psa 73:17) he went into the sanctuary of God; he applied to his devotions, meditated upon the attributes of God, and the things revealed, which belong to us and to our children; he consulted the scriptures, and the lips of the priests who attended the sanctuary; he prayed to God to make this matter plain to him and to help him over this difficulty; and, at length, he understood the wretched end of wicked people, which he plainly foresaw to be such that even in the height of their prosperity they were rather to be pitied than envied, for they were but ripening for ruin. Note, There are many great things, and things needful to be known, which will not be known otherwise than by going into the sanctuary of God, by the word and prayer. The sanctuary must therefore be the resort of a tempted soul. Note, further, We must judge of persons and things as they appear by the light of divine revelation, and then we shall judge righteous judgment; particularly we must judge by the end. All is well that ends well, everlastingly well; but nothing well that ends ill, everlastingly ill. The righteous man's afflictions end in peace, and therefore he is happy; the wicked man's enjoyments end in destruction, and therefore he is miserable.

1.The prosperity of the wicked is short and uncertain. The high places in which Providence sets them are slippery places (Psa 73:18), where they cannot long keep footing; but, when they offer to climb higher, that very attempt will be the occasion of their sliding and falling. Their prosperity has no firm ground; it is not built upon God's favour or his promise; and they have not the satisfaction of feeling that it rests on firm ground.

2.Their destruction is sure, and sudden, and very great. This cannot be meant of any temporal destruction; for they were supposed to spend all their days in wealth and their death itself had no bands in it: In a moment they go down to the grace, so that even that could scarcely be called their destruction; it must therefore be meant of eternal destruction on the other side death - hell and destruction. They flourish for a time, but are undone for ever.

(1.)Their ruin is sure and inevitable. He speaks of it as a thing done - They are cast down; for their destruction is as certain as if it were already accomplished. He speaks of it as God's doing, and therefore it cannot be resisted: Thou castest them down. It is destruction from the Almighty (Joe 1:15), from the glory of his power, Th2 1:9. Who can support those whom God will cast down, on whom God will lay burdens?

(2.)It is swift and sudden; their damnation slumbers not; for how are they brought into desolation as in a moment! Psa 73:19. It is easily effected, and will be a great surprise to themselves and all about them.

(3.)It is severe and very dreadful. It is a total and final ruin: They are utterly consumed with terrors, It is the misery of the damned that the terrors of the Almighty, whom they have made their enemy, fasten upon their guilty consciences, which can neither shelter themselves from them nor strengthen themselves under them; and therefore not their being, but their bliss, must needs be utterly consumed by them; not the least degree of comfort or hope remains to them; the higher they were lifted up in their prosperity the sorer will their fall be when they are cast down into destructions (for the word is plural) and suddenly brought into desolation.

3.Their prosperity is therefore not to be envied at all, but despised rather, quod erat demonstrandum - which was the point to be established, Psa 73:20. As a dream when one awaketh, so, O Lord! when thou awakest, or when they awake (as some read it), thou shalt despise their image, their shadow, and make it to vanish. In the day of the great judgment (so the Chaldee paraphrase reads it), when they are awaked out of their graves, thou shalt, in wrath, despise their image; for they shall rise to shame and everlasting contempt. See here,

(1.)What their prosperity now is; it is but an image, a vain show, a fashion of the world that passes away; it is not real, but imaginary, and it is only a corrupt imagination that makes it a happiness; it is not substance, but a mere shadow; it is not what it seems to be, nor will it prove what we promise ourselves from it; it is as a dream, which may please us a little, while we are asleep, yet even then it disturbs our repose; but, how pleasing soever it is, it is all but a cheat, all false; when we awake we find it so. A hungry man dreams that he eats, but he awakes and his soul is empty, Isa 29:8. A man is never the more rich or honourable for dreaming he is so. Who therefore will envy a man the pleasure of a dream?

(2.)What will be the issue of it; God will awake to judgment, to plead his own and his people's injured cause; they shall be made to awake out of the sleep of their carnal security, and then God shall despise their image; he shall make it appear to all the world how despicable it is; so that the righteous shall laugh at them, Psa 52:6, Psa 52:7. How did God despise that rich man's image when he said, Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee! Luk 12:19, Luk 12:20. We ought to be of God's mind, for his judgment is according to truth, and not to admire and envy that which he despises and will despise; for, sooner or later, he will bring all the world to be of his mind.

Copy as

Historical interpretation

Historical Reception

5 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

5 quotes · AD 397–430
Post-Nicene
400

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

Subsequent events also go to show how the image of such a person is not found but perishes, since his image is not found in the city of the Lord, that Jerusalem which is above. For the Lord has painted us in his image and likeness, even as he teaches us, saying, “Behold, O Jerusalem, I have painted your walls.” If we have acted well, that heavenly image continues in us; if anyone acts badly, this image is destroyed in him that is the image of him who came down from heaven, and there is in him the image of the earthly. On this account also the apostle says, “Even as we have borne the image of the one that is earthly, let us bear also the image of the other that is heavenly.” Therefore, the images of good continue to shine forth in that city of God. But if anyone has turned aside to graver sins and has not done penance, his image is destroyed or else cast out even as Adam was cast out and excluded from paradise. But whoever has conducted himself in a holy and honorable fashion enters into that city of God15 and brings in his own image so that it may shine in that city of God. “O Lord, in your city you shall reduce their images to nothing,” because those who have clothed themselves with the works of darkness cannot shine in the light. Let us adduce an example from the world. See how the images of good rulers continue in cities, whereas the images of tyrants are destroyed.
Such, then, is the first supposition of true knowledge, that things in the world happen by chance. The second is that “on account of the subterfuges you have placed before them” prodigious success, worldly profits and an abundance of riches. Otherwise, they might plead by way of excuse that they had been less devout by reason of want or of some bitter pain or grief and had been driven to the guilt of robbery and to the desire to plunder under compulsion of poverty. For they were enriched with wealth and exalted with honors, not for tranquility of life or the enjoyment of delight but that complaining might be foreclosed and distress piled up.
Therefore, in regard to the latter, David also says, “They have ceased to be and have perished by reason of their iniquity as the dream of one that wakes up.” This means: The wicked cease to be, and they disappear as a dream does when one first wakes up from sleep, “because they are in darkness and have walked in darkness”;7 not a trace of their good work remains, but they are like those who see a dream. Now one who dreams, dreams at night, whereas night is in darkness. The children of darkness are deprived of the Sun of justice and the splendor of virtue, for they sleep always and do not keep watch, and of them it is appropriately said, “They have slept their sleep and have found nothing.” For indeed, when their souls are separated from the body, and they are, as it were, released from the sleep of the body, they will find nothing, they will possess nothing, and they will lose what they thought they possessed. For although the unwise and foolish person may overflow with riches, he will leave his riches to strangers, and the glory of his house will not descend to hell together with him.
And therefore I conferred with my heart and I said to myself, “if I will speak thus, that I have justified my heart in vain,” and the voice of God replied to me and said, “Behold the generation of your children, to which I have made distribution.” This means: Behold, you find in the Scriptures, O you son of Adam, that I have made distribution to the generation of your children, that wealth may be granted to the wicked simply by chance and not from some merit. Neither are the rewards of virtue the profits of a treasury, just as poverty … is not a punishment for sin. But such things come without distinction, for they roll along on a kind of flow of life that is like a river.
"If I said, I shall declare thus; behold, the generation of Your sons I have reprobated" [Psalm 73:15]: that is, I will teach thus. How will you teach? That there is no knowledge in the Most High, that God does not know? Will you propound this opinion, that without cause men live justly who do live justly; that a just man has lost his service, because God does more show favour to evil men, or else He does care for no one? Will you tell this, declare this? He does restrain himself by an authority repressing him. What authority? A man wishes some time to break out in this sentiment: but he is recalled by the Scriptures directing us always to live well, saying, that God does care for things human, that He makes a distinction between a godly man and an ungodly man. Therefore this man also wishing to put forth this sentiment, does recollect himself. And what says he? "I have reprobated the generation of Your sons." If I shall declare thus, the generation of just men I shall reprobate. As also some copies have it, "Behold, the generation of your sons with which I have been in concert:" that is, with which consisting of Your sons I have been in concert; that is, with which I have agreed, to which I have been conformed: I have been out of time with all, if so I teach. For he does sing in concert who gives the tune together; but he that gives not the tune together does not sing in concert. Am I to say something different from that which Abraham said, from that which Isaac said, from that which Jacob said, from that which the Prophets said? For all they said that God does care for things human, am I to say that He cares not? Is there greater wisdom in me than in them? Greater understanding in me than in them? A most wholesome authority has called back his thought from ungodliness.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Psalms 73:15 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8