Skip to content
Share this page

Luke 23:10

“Jesus Interrogated by Herod”Luke 23:6–12

King James Version
And the chief priests and scribes stood and vehemently accused him.

Bible text: King James Version (1769 Blayney text) · Public domain

KJV (with Strong's)
And G1161 the chief priests G749 and G2532 scribes G1122 stood G2476 and vehemently G2159 accused G2723 him G846.

Bible text: King James Version with Strong's numbers · Public domain

Berean Standard Bible
Meanwhile, the chief priests and scribes stood there, vehemently accusing Him.

Bible text: Berean Standard Bible · Public domain

American Standard Version
And the chief priests and the scribes stood, vehemently accusing him.

Bible text: American Standard Version (1901) · Public domain

World English Bible Messianic
The chief priests and the scribes stood, vehemently accusing him.

Bible text: World English Bible, Messianic edition · Public domain

Geneva Bible (1599)
The hie Priests also and Scribes stood forth, and accused him vehemently.

Bible text: Geneva Bible (1599) · Public domain

Young's Literal Translation
And the chief priests and the scribes stood vehemently accusing him,

Bible text: Young's Literal Translation · Public domain

King James Version — Interlinear
10 Greek words
  1. εἱστήκεισανheistēkeisanHad been standing byG2476V-LAI-3PVerb Pluperfect Active Indicative 3rd Plural
  2. δὲdenowG1161CONJConjunction
  3. οἱhoitheG3588T-NPMDefinite article Nominative Plural Masculine
  4. ἀρχιερεῖςarchiereischief priestsG749N-NPMNoun Nominative Plural Masculine
  5. καὶkaiandG2532CONJConjunction
  6. οἱhoitheG3588T-NPMDefinite article Nominative Plural Masculine
  7. γραμματεῖςgrammateisscribesG1122N-NPMNoun Nominative Plural Masculine
  8. εὐτόνωςeutonōsvehementlyG2159ADVAdverb
  9. κατηγοροῦντεςkatēgorountesaccusingG2723V-PAP-NPMVerb Present Active Participle Nominative Plural Masculine
  10. αὐτοῦautouHimG846P-GSMPersonal pronoun Genitive Singular Masculine
English is a literal word-by-word gloss of the Greek, not the KJV's wording. Why?

This is the Greek text the KJV’s translators worked from, with each word given its own literal English meaning in this verse. The word-by-word meanings were prepared by scholars at Tyndale House, Cambridge. The KJV translates whole sentences rather than single words, so its wording often differs: one Greek word can become several English words, and the KJV may say “charity” where the word-by-word meaning reads “love”. The two are made for different purposes, and both are faithful to the Greek. To read the KJV’s own wording, switch to the KJV text.

Words in [ ] are added by the English.

Translation
Details
See on the biblical-era maps
All Luke Sites (Jerusalem)
All Luke Sites (Jerusalem) View full PDF
All Luke Sites (Levant)
All Luke Sites (Levant) View full PDF
All Luke Sites (Eastern Mediterranean)
All Luke Sites (Eastern Mediterranean) View full PDF

Map © Biblica Open Bible Maps · CC BY-SA 4.0

In the KJVVerse 25,946 of 31,102 · 83.4%

Study this verse

Written with AI assistance. Always check it against Scripture.

This verse

The chief priests and scribes stand before Herod and press their charges against Jesus with all their strength.

“And the chief priests and scribes stood”

The leading priests and the experts in the law had followed Jesus to Herod’s court to press their charge.

“and vehemently accused him.”

They argued their case with all their strength, a flood of words against his silence.

Passage studyLuke 23:6–12

Jesus Stands Silent Before Herod

6When Pilate heard of Galilee, he asked whether the man were a Galilaean. 7And as soon as he knew that he belonged unto Herod’s jurisdiction, he sent him to Herod, who himself also was at Jerusalem at that time. 8And when Herod saw Jesus, he was exceeding glad: for he was desirous to see him of a long season, because he had heard many things of him; and he hoped to have seen some miracle done by him. 9Then he questioned with him in many words; but he answered him nothing. 10And the chief priests and scribes stood and vehemently accused him. 11And Herod with his men of war set him at nought, and mocked him, and arrayed him in a gorgeous robe, and sent him again to Pilate. 12And the same day Pilate and Herod were made friends together: for before they were at enmity between themselves.

Summary

Pilate has just said of Jesus, “I find no fault in this man,” and the accusers answer that Jesus has stirred up the people “beginning from Galilee to this place.” At the word Galilee, Pilate sees a way out. Galilee belongs to Herod Antipas, who is in Jerusalem at the time, so Pilate sends Jesus to him. Herod is delighted, because he has wanted for a long while to see Jesus work a miracle. He questions him at length while the chief priests and scribes accuse him fiercely, and Jesus keeps silent through all of it. Herod and his soldiers then treat him with contempt, dress him in a gorgeous robe as a mock king and send him back to Pilate, and the two rulers, enemies until then, become friends that same day.

Luke alone tells this scene. In it the innocent Son of God is passed from one ruler to another and holds his peace before them all, while God carries out through their scheming what his hand and his counsel had determined before.

Why Pilate sent Jesus to Herod

The council had already examined Jesus (Luke 22:66–71) and brought him to Pilate, the Roman governor, because they lacked the power to put him to death. Before Pilate they framed their charges in political terms, accusing him of stirring up rebellion and claiming to be a king in opposition to Caesar (Luke 23:1–2). Pilate questioned him and declared, “I find no fault in this man,” but the accusers pressed harder, saying that he stirred up the people “beginning from Galilee to this place” (Luke 23:4–5).

Pilate governed the Roman province of Judea from AD 26 to 36. Galilee, Jesus’ home region and the place where much of his public ministry was done (Luke 4:14–15), lay outside Pilate’s rule. With Perea it belonged to Herod Antipas, a son of Herod the Great, who governed it as tetrarch under Rome.

So when Pilate heard the name of Galilee, he asked whether the man were a Galilean. The verb for heard, akoúō, is the ordinary word for hearing, and the verb for asked, eperōtáō, is the plain word for asking or questioning someone. A Galilaîos is simply a Galilean, a native of Galilee. Pilate’s question was about jurisdiction. If Jesus came from Galilee, he fell under Herod’s authority, and Pilate could hand the case to him. Galilee was known for fervent Jewish nationalism and for outbreaks of rebellion, and leaders in Judea often looked down on it, so to a Roman ear a Galilean accused of stirring up the people sounded dangerous.

“As soon as he knew” translates epiginṓskō, which means to recognize something by a mark, or to become fully acquainted with it. Pilate recognized the opening and acted on it at once. The word behind “jurisdiction” is exousía, which covers both authority and plain power. Here it is Herod’s authority over his own territory, and Pilate deferred to it. The verb for sent, anapémpō, means to send up or send back, and Luke uses the same verb in verse 11 when Herod sends Jesus back to Pilate.

Herod was in Jerusalem “at that time” for the Passover, when rulers came up to the city along with the crowds of pilgrims. That allowed the transfer to happen on the spot, the same day.

What Pilate hoped to gain

Pilate had found Jesus innocent and wanted to release him, yet he feared the leaders who demanded his death. Sending Jesus to Herod promised several things at once. It moved a dangerous case out of his hands, it spared him a direct clash with the accusers, and it paid Herod a courtesy by deferring to his rule, which mattered because the two men were on bad terms (Luke 23:12). This was the first of Pilate’s attempts to rid himself of the decision. He went on seeking to release Jesus amid threats (John 19:12), and in Matthew’s account he finally washed his hands before the people (Matthew 27:24), a scene Luke leaves out.

Why Herod was glad to see Jesus

The Herod of this scene is Herod Antipas, and his name, Hērṓdēs, means “heroic”. His life gave the name little honour. He had made an unlawful marriage with Herodias, had imprisoned John the Baptist (Luke 3:19–20) and had then put him to death (Mark 6:17–29).

When Herod saw Jesus, “he was exceeding glad”. The verb for saw, eídō, is the common word for seeing, and chaírō, glad, is the ordinary word for rejoicing or being glad. Scripture uses it of the world’s rejoicing as well as the joy of believers, and the rest of the verse shows which kind this was.

Herod had wanted to see Jesus “of a long season”. The word behind “long” is hikanós, which says how great or how many a thing is, here a considerable time. The same word stands behind “many” in the next verse, so the long wait ends in a long run of questions. He “had heard many things of him”, with akoúō again, the verb of Pilate’s hearing in verse 6. Reports of Jesus’ teaching and above all of his miracles had reached the ruler of Galilee. And “he hoped to have seen some miracle done by him.” The word for miracle, sēmeîon, means a sign, mark or token, an indication of something, and here it is a supernatural sign done by Jesus’ own hand.

Herod wanted to watch a wonder for his own satisfaction. He had a ruler’s curiosity about a famous man and hoped for a display of power. Those who came to Jesus in real need met him very differently. The woman with the issue of blood (Luke 8:43–48) and Zacchaeus the tax collector (Luke 19:1–10) went away changed. Herod stands closer to the crowds who sought Jesus for the food he gave (John 6:26–27) and to the Athenians, who loved to hear some new thing (Acts 17:21).

Why did Jesus give Herod no sign?

Jesus worked signs to show God’s glory, to show compassion and to call people to faith and repentance, and he refused to perform them on demand for people who wanted a show. When the scribes and Pharisees asked him for a sign, he told them they would be given only the sign of the prophet Jonah (Matthew 12:38–40), and he said the same again later (Matthew 16:4). The sign he did give was his own death and resurrection, which Peter proclaimed to the men of Israel (Acts 2:22–24).

Why did Jesus answer Herod nothing?

Jesus chose silence, in full command of himself, before a man who wanted only to be entertained. “Then he questioned with him in many words”. The verb is eperōtáō, the same verb as Pilate’s asking in verse 6, and Luke’s tense pictures questioning that went on and on. The “many words” are hikanós lógos, a considerable number of words, lógos being anything said. Herod may have asked who he was, what he claimed and whether he would work a sign. The answer Luke records is “he answered him nothing”. The word oudeís means “not even one”, and every one of Herod’s questions met the same silence.

Scripture gives several reasons for this silence, and they belong together.

  • Herod’s motive. He wanted a spectacle, and Jesus had taught, “neither cast ye your pearls before swine” (Matthew 7:6). Sacred truth is withheld from those who would only profane it.
  • Prophecy. Isaiah wrote of the Servant that “he opened not his mouth” (Isaiah 53:7), and the afflicted sufferer of Psalm 38:13–14 is silent before his enemies. Jesus kept the same silence before the chief priests and before Pilate (Matthew 27:12–14, Mark 15:5).
  • Submission to the Father. Jesus told Pilate, “My kingdom is not of this world” (John 18:36), and Herod’s power held no sway over him. The Word of God chose to remain silent, emptying himself and humbling himself to the death of the cross (Philippians 2:7–11), and he endured it “for the joy that was set before him” (Hebrews 12:2).

The scene is full of irony. Herod sits as ruler and Jesus stands as a bound prisoner, yet the prisoner keeps command of his own words, and all Herod’s authority cannot draw one from him.

Why the chief priests and scribes accused him so fiercely

The accusers had followed Jesus from Pilate’s court to Herod’s, and verse 10 finds them before Herod pressing their case. The chief priests, archiereús, the word for the high priest and by extension the leading priests, came from the powerful priestly families, most of them Sadducees. The scribes, grammateús, literally writers, were the trained experts in the law of Moses, many of them Pharisees. Together they made up the religious and learned leadership of the nation.

They “stood”, hístēmi, as accusers stand up to press a charge, and they “vehemently accused him”. Katēgoréō means to act as plaintiff, to charge someone with an offence, and eutónōs means “in a well-strung manner”, that is, intensely. Their storm of words stands against the silence of Jesus in the verse before.

Their fury had more than one root. They counted him a blasphemer for his claims and a threat to their understanding of the law and the temple. They feared that if he were taken for a rebel king, Rome would come and take away their place and their nation (John 11:48). His public rebukes of their hypocrisy (Matthew 23) had wounded their pride, and envy drove them on. David’s complaint, “False witnesses did rise up” (Psalm 35:11), comes true here in the Son of David, and Stephen later laid the same resistance to God at the council’s door (Acts 7:51–53).

How Herod and his soldiers mocked the King

“Herod with his men of war” names stráteuma, a body of troops, here most likely his personal guard. They “set him at nought”, exouthenéō, which means to despise, to count as worthless, and they “mocked him”, empaízō, to jeer at and deride. Contempt turned into open ridicule.

Then they “arrayed him in a gorgeous robe”. Lamprós means radiant, bright, magnificent in appearance, and esthḗs is simply a garment. Luke gives the robe no colour, and it may have been white. It was a costume to ridicule his kingship, a splendid robe on a silent prisoner. Later Pilate’s soldiers put a purple robe on him (John 19:2), a different garment carrying the same scorn.

“And sent him again to Pilate” uses anapémpō, the verb of verse 7. Herod declined to condemn him, and Pilate later told the leaders that Herod, like himself, had found in Jesus nothing worthy of death (Luke 23:14–15). So two rulers, each with power to judge him, found him innocent, and both still avoided the duty of setting him free.

Scripture foretold this treatment. Isaiah’s Servant is despised and rejected (Isaiah 53:3), and the sufferer of Psalm 22 calls himself a worm, despised by the people (Psalm 22:6–7). The man dressed up as a mock king is the King of kings and Lord of lords (Revelation 19:16). Peter writes of him that “when he was reviled, reviled not again; when he suffered, he threatened not; but committed himself to him that judgeth righteously” (1 Peter 2:23).

How Pilate and Herod became friends

“The same day Pilate and Herod were made friends together”. Gínomai means to become, and phílos is the ordinary word for a friend, one held dear, an associate. Before this they were at “enmity”, échthra, which means hostility.

Luke leaves the cause of their quarrel unnamed. Their authority overlapped, and Pilate was known for harsh rule and for disregard of Jewish customs. He had also killed Galileans, Herod’s own subjects (Luke 13:1), which may well have been a source of friction. What healed the quarrel is clearer. Pilate honoured Herod by sending him a prisoner from his own territory, and Herod returned the courtesy by sending Jesus back and leaving the verdict with Pilate. Their friendship grew out of a shared problem and a shared wish to escape the blame for it.

There is deep irony here. Two rulers are reconciled over the rejection of the one who came to reconcile. The psalm had said, “The kings of the earth set themselves, and the rulers take counsel together, against the LORD, and against his anointed” (Psalm 2:1–2), and the world that is divided against itself still finds common cause against Christ, as Jesus warned his disciples it would hate them as it hated him (John 15:18–19). Their peace was a truce of convenience. The peace Christ made on the cross breaks down the wall of hostility between divided peoples (Ephesians 2:14–16) and reconciles all things to God (Colossians 1:19–20).

God’s purpose as Jesus was passed between rulers

Every hand in this scene acted from its own motive. Pilate wanted to escape a decision, Herod wanted a show, and the priests wanted a death. Over all of them God was working his plan. The church later prayed, “For of a truth against thy holy child Jesus, whom thou hast anointed, both Herod, and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles, and the people of Israel, were gathered together, For to do whatsoever thy hand and thy counsel determined before to be done” (Acts 4:27–28). Peter preached the same truth, that Jesus was delivered up by God’s own counsel and raised by him (Acts 2:22–24).

A Roman governor and a Jewish ruler both had a part in his trial, so the sin Christ bore is the whole world’s and the salvation he gives reaches to all. Through their evasion and mockery God brought his Son to the cross, where he bore the sins of many as the Servant who was wounded for our transgressions (Isaiah 53:4–6). This day is the suffering Servant of Isaiah 53 coming to pass, and the rest of Luke 23 carries it on to Golgotha.

Jesus walked through these courts while holding all authority (John 19:10–11), and on the cross he triumphed over principalities and powers (Colossians 2:13–15). God commends his love toward us in that while we were yet sinners Christ died for us (Romans 5:8), and he gave his Son so that whoever believes in him should have everlasting life (John 3:16).

The King who held his peace

These seven verses set Jesus among the powers of the world and show who he is. He stands before a governor, a king and the leaders of his own nation, and he is the calmest person in the room. The gorgeous robe was meant as a joke, yet it was put on the true King, and the silence Herod took for weakness was the Servant’s obedience to his Father.

The passage also shows how close a person can come to Christ and leave unchanged. Herod had wanted to see Jesus for a long time, and when he stood before him he wanted only a wonder. Pilate and Herod gained a friendship that day, and the One they passed between them was going to the cross to make a peace that lasts.

Above it all stands God. He ruled over Pilate’s evasion, Herod’s scorn and the priests’ fury, and he turned each of them to the saving purpose he had determined before. When you are mocked for Christ’s sake, Peter points to this very scene, where Jesus committed himself to the One who judges righteously.

Last revised

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry wrote on whole passages, and this entry covers Luke 23:1–12. He set out his notes in a three-level outline, kept here as he numbered it.

1662–1714 · 12 verses
Passage under commentLuke 23:1–12
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

Our Lord Jesus was condemned as a blasphemer in the spiritual court, but it was the most impotent malice that could be that this court was actuated by; for, when they had condemned him, they knew they could not put him to death, and therefore took another course.

I.They accused him before Pilate.

The whole multitude of them arose, when they saw they could go no further with him in their court, and led him unto Pilate, though it was no judgment day, no assizes or sessions; and they demanded justice against him, not as a blasphemer (that was no crime that he took cognizance of), but as one disaffected to the Roman government, which they in their hearts did not look upon as any crime at all, or, if it was one, they themselves were much more chargeable with it than he was; only it would serve the turn and answer the purpose of their malice: and it is observable that that which was the pretended crime, for which they employed the Roman powers to destroy Christ, was the real crime for which the Roman powers not long after destroyed them.

1.Here is the indictment drawn up against him (Luke 23:2), in which they pretended a zeal for Caesar, only to ingratiate themselves with Pilate, but it was all malice against Christ, and nothing else. They misrepresented him,

(1.)As making the people rebel against Caesar. It was true, and Pilate knew it, that there was a general uneasiness in the people under the Roman yoke, and they wanted nothing but an opportunity to shake it off; now they would have Pilate believe that this Jesus was active to foment that general discontent, which, if the truth was known, they themselves were the aiders and abettors of: We have found him perverting the nation; as if converting them to God's government were perverting them from the civil government; whereas nothing tends more to make men good subjects than making them Christ's faithful followers. Christ had particularly taught that they ought to give tribute to Caesar, though he knew there were those that would be offended at him for it; and yet he is here falsely accused as forbidding to give tribute to Caesar. Innocency is no fence against calumny.

(2.)As making himself a rival with Caesar, though the very reason why they rejected him, and would not own him to be the Messiah, was because he did not appear in worldly pomp and power, and did not set up for a temporal prince, nor offer to do any thing against Caesar; yet this is what they charged him with, that he said, he himself is Christ a king. He did say that he was Christ, and, if so, then a king, but not such a king as was ever likely to give disturbance to Caesar. When his followers would have made him a king (John 6:15), he declined it, though by the many miracles he wrought he made it appear that if he would have set up in competition with Caesar he would have been too hard for him.

2.His pleading to the indictment: Pilate asked him, Art thou the king of the Jews? Luke 23:3. To which he answered, Thou sayest it; that is, "It is as thou sayest, that I am entitled to the government of the Jewish nation; but in rivalship with the scribes and Pharisees, who tyrannize over them in matters of religion, not in rivalship with Caesar, whose government relates only to their civil interests." Christ's kingdom is wholly spiritual, and will not interfere with Caesar's jurisdiction. Or, "Thou sayest it; but canst thou prove it? What evidence hast thou for it?" All that knew him knew the contrary, that he never pretended to be the king of the Jews, in opposition to Caesar as supreme, or to the governors that were sent by him, but the contrary.

3.Pilate's declaration of his innocency (Luke 23:4): He said to the chief priests, and the people that seemed to join with them in the prosecution, "I find no fault in this man. What breaches of your law he may have been guilty of I am not concerned to enquire, but I find nothing proved upon him that makes him obnoxious to our court."

4.The continued fury and outrage of the prosecutors, Luke 23:5. Instead of being moderated by Pilate's declaration of his innocency, and considering, as they ought to have done, whether they were not bringing the guilt of innocent blood upon themselves, they were the more exasperated, more exceedingly fierce. We do not find that they have any particular fact to produce, much less any evidence to prove it; but they resolve to carry it with noise and confidence, and say it, though they cannot prove it: He stirs up the people to rebel against Caesar, teaching throughout all Judea, beginning from Galilee to this place. He did stir up the people, but it was not to any thing factious or seditious, but to every thing that was virtuous and praiseworthy. He did teach, but they could not charge him with teaching any doctrine that tended to disturb the public peace, or make the government uneasy or jealous.

II.They accused him before Herod.

1.Pilate removed him and his cause to Herod's court. The accusers mentioned Galilee, the northern part of Canaan. "Why," saith Pilate, "is he of that country? Is he a Galilean?" Luke 23:6. "Yes," said they, "that is his head-quarters; there he was spent most of his time." "Let us send him to Herod then," saith Pilate, "for Herod is now in town, and it is but fit he should have cognizance of his cause, since he belongs to Herod's jurisdiction." Pilate was already sick of the cause, and desirous to rid his hands of it, which seems to have been the true reason for sending him to Herod. But God ordered it so for the more evident fulfilling of the scripture, as appears Acts 4:26, Acts 4:27, where that of David (Psalm 2:2), The kings of the earth and the rulers set themselves against the Lord and his Anointed, is expressly said to be fulfilled in Herod and Pontius Pilate.

2.Herod was very willing to have the examining of him (Luke 23:8): When he saw Jesus he was exceedingly glad, and perhaps the more glad because he saw him a prisoner, saw him in bonds. He had heard many things of him in Galilee, where his miracles had for a great while been all the talk of the country; and he longed to see him, not for any affection he had for him or his doctrine, but purely out of curiosity; and it was only to gratify this that he hoped to have seen some miracle done by him, which would serve him to talk of as long as he lived. In order to this, he questioned with him in many things, that at length he might bring him to something in which he might show his power. Perhaps he pumped him concerning things secret, or things to come, or concerning his curing diseases. But Jesus answered him nothing; nor would he gratify him so much as with the performance of one miracle. The poorest beggar, that asked a miracle for the relief of his necessity, was never denied; but this proud prince, that asked a miracle merely for the gratifying of his curiosity, is denied. He might have seen Christ and his wondrous works many a time in Galilee, and would not, and therefore it is justly said, Now he would see them, and shall not; they are hidden from his eyes, because he knew not the day of his visitation. Herod thought, now that he had him in bonds, he might command a miracle, but miracles must not be made cheap, nor Omnipotence be at the beck of the greatest potentate.

3.His prosecutors appeared against him before Herod, for they were restless in the prosecution: They stood, and vehemently accused him (Luke 23:10), impudently and boldly, so the word signifies. They would make Herod believe that he had poisoned Galilee too with his seditious notions. Note, It is no new thing for good men and good ministers, that are real and useful friends to the civil government, to be falsely accused as factious and seditious, and enemies to government.

4.Herod was very abusive to him: He, with his men of war, his attendants, and officers, and great men, set him at nought. They made nothing of him; so the word is. Horrid wickedness! To make nothing of him who made all things. They laughed at him as a fool; for they knew he had wrought many miracles to befriend others, and why would he not now work one to befriend himself? Or, they laughed at him as one that had lost his power, and was become weak as other men. Herod, who had been acquainted with John Baptist, and had more knowledge of Christ too than Pilate had, was more abusive to Christ than Pilate was; for knowledge without grace does but make men the more ingeniously wicked. Herod arrayed Christ in a gorgeous robe, some gaudy painted clothes, as a mock-king; and so he taught Pilate's soldiers afterwards to do him the same indignity. He was ringleader in that abuse.

5.Herod sent him back to Pilate, and it proved an occasion of the making of them friends, they having been for some time before at variance. Herod could not get sight of a miracle, but would not condemn him neither as a malefactor, and therefore sent him again to Pilate (Luke 23:11), and so returned Pilate's civility and respect in sending the prisoner to him; and this mutual obligation, with the messages that passed between them on this occasion, brought them to a better understanding one of another than there had been of late between them, Luke 23:12. They had been at enmity between themselves, probably upon Pilate's killing of the Galileans, who were Herod's subjects (Luke 13:1), or some other such matter of controversy as usually occurs among princes and great men. Observe how those that quarrelled with one another yet could unite against Christ; as Gebal, and Ammon, and Amalek, though divided among themselves, were confederate against the Israel of God, Psalm 83:7. Christ is the great peace-maker; both Pilate and Herod owned his innocency, and their agreeing in this cured their disagreeing in other things.

Historical interpretation

Seven Centuries of Reception

8 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

8 quotes · AD 386–1107
Post-NiceneEarly MedievalMedieval
40050060070080090010001100

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

Having been bound, Christ went from Caiaphas to Pilate; is this also written? Yes: “And having bound him, they led him away as a present to the King of Jarim.” But some keen listener will object: “Pilate was not a king.” (Let us pass over for the time the main points of the inquiry.) “How then, having bound him, did they lead him as a present to the king?” But read the Gospel: “Pilate, hearing that he was from Galilee, sent him to Herod; for Herod was then king and was present in Jerusalem.” Notice the exactness of the prophet, for he says that he was sent as a present. For “Herod and Pilate became friends that very day; whereas previously they had been at enmity with each other.” It was fitting that he, who was to restore peace between earth and heaven, should first put at peace the very men who condemned him, for the Lord himself was there present, “who reconciles the hearts of the princes of the earth.” Mark the exactness of the prophets and their truthful testimony.
d. AD 397Ambrose of Milanas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Post-NiceneSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
He was silent and did nothing, for Herod's unbelief deserved not to see Him, and the Lord shunned display. And perhaps typically in Herod are represented all the ungodly, who if they have not believed the Law and the Prophets, cannot see Christ's wonderful works in the Gospel.

It is not without reason that He is arrayed by Herod in a white robe, as bearing a sign of His immaculate Passion, that the Lamb of God without spot would take upon Himself the sins of the world.

Under the type also of Herod and Pilate, who from enemies were made friends by Jesus Christ, is preserved the figure of the people of Israel and the Gentile nation; that through our Lord's Passion should come to pass the future concord of both, yet so that the people of the Gentiles should receive the word of God first, and then transmit it by the devotion of their faith to the Jewish people; that they too may with the glory of their majesty clothe the body of Christ, which before they had despised.
There follows an admirable place, where the patience to bear moral harm is poured into the human breast. The Lord is accused, and he is silent: and he is right to be silent, who does not need to defend himself. Let those who fear to be conquered, roam around seeking to be defended. Therefore, he does not confirm the accusation by fearing it, but he despises it by not refuting it. For what would he fear, who does not seek salvation? He betrayed his own salvation for the salvation of all, that it may be acquired by all. And here Pilate absolves: but he absolves by judgment, he crucifies by mystery. But this is specific to Christ: the human aspect, that with unjust judges it seemed more a matter of unwillingness than inability to be defended. But why did the Lord remain silent? He himself gave the answer, saying: If I tell you, you will not believe me; if I ask you, you will not answer me. However, the most remarkable thing is that he preferred to prove himself as a king rather than to speak; so that those who accuse him could not have a reason to condemn him, as they confess what they object to. But Herod, desiring to see some miracles done by him, kept silent and did nothing; for neither did his cruelty deserve to see divine things, nor did the Lord desire to indulge in boasting. And perhaps in Herod all the wicked are symbolized: who, if they do not believe in the Law and the prophets, are unable to see the miracles of Christ's works even in the Gospel.
It is not idle that he is dressed in a white robe by Herod, giving clear indications of his passion; for the great God, without spot, with glory, received the sins of the world. In the figure of Herod and Pilate also, who became friends from enemies through Jesus Christ, the figure of the people of Israel and the Gentile people is preserved, so that through the passion of the Lord there will be future harmony between them both: in such a way, however, that the pious people of the nations receive the word of God and transmit their faith to the Jewish people with their devotion; so that they too may clothe the body of Christ with the glory of their majesty, whom they had previously despised.
d. AD 604Gregory the Dialogistas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Early MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
(Mor. 10. c. 31.) Now Herod wished to make proof of Christ's fame, desiring to witness His miracles; for it follows, And when Herod saw Jesus, he was glad, &c.

(Mor. 22. c. 16.) From these words we ought to derive a lesson, that whenever our hearers wish as if by praising us to gain knowledge from us, but not to change their own wicked course, we must be altogether silent, lest if from love of ostentation we speak God's word, both they who were guilty cease not to be so, and we who were not become so. And there are many things which betray the motive of a hearer, but one in particular, when they always praise what they hear, yet never follow what they praise.

(Mor. 10. c. 31.) The Redeemer therefore though questioned held His peace, though expected disdained to work miracles. And keeping Himself secretly within Himself, left those who were satisfied to seek for outward things, to remain thankless without, preferring to be openly set at nought by the proud, than be praised by the hollow voices of unbelievers. Hence it follows, And the chief priests and scribes stood and vehemently accused him. And Herod with his men of war set him at nought, and mocked him, and arrayed him in a white robe.
d. AD 735Bedeas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274Early MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
Pilate having determined not to question our Lord concerning the above-mentioned accusation, is the rather glad now that an opportunity offers to escape from passing judgment upon Him. Hence it is said, When Pilate heard of Galilee, he asked whether the man were a Galilæan. And lest he should be compelled to pass sentence against one whom he knew to be innocent, and delivered for envy, sends Him to be heard by Herod, preferring that he who was the Tetrarch of our Lord's country might be the person either to acquit or punish Him; for it follows, And as soon as he knew that he belonged to Herod's jurisdiction.

Or this alliance between Herod and Pilate signifies that the Gentiles and Jews, though differing in race, religion, and character, agree together in persecuting Christians.
d. AD 735BedeEarly MedievalSourceOn the Gospel of Luke
The chief priests and the scribes also stood, vehemently accusing him. With the chief priests and scribes accusing him, the Lord responded little to Pilate, and answered nothing to Herod, lest by refuting the accusation he might be released by the governor, and the benefit of the cross be delayed. For it was indeed just that he should respond in part to Pilate, who reluctantly delivered the sentence: but Herod and the other Jewish leaders whom he regarded as wholly unworthy of his words, since they condemned the innocent against the decrees of their own law. Because of these things, although he refused to answer, the likeness of the Lamb was given so that in his silence he might be considered not guilty, but innocent. For when he remained silent, he displayed the patience of a lamb about to be slaughtered for the whole flock; but when he answered, he fought like a good shepherd against the threats of wolves and robbers for the sheep entrusted to him.
d. AD 1107Theophylact of Ohridas quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274MedievalSourceCatena Aurea by Aquinas
Wherein he follows the Roman law, which provided that every man should be judged by the governor of his own jurisdiction.

Not as though he was about to gain any benefit from the sight, but seized with curiosity he thought he should see that extraordinary man, of whose wisdom and wonderful works he had heard so much. He also wished to hear from His mouth what He could say. Accordingly he asks Him questions, making a sport of Him, and ridiculing Him. But Jesus, who performed all things prudently, and who, as David testifies, ordereth His words with discretion, (Ps. 112:5.) thought it right in such a case to be silent. For a word uttered to one whom it profiteth nothing becomes the cause of his condemnation. Therefore it follows, But he answered him nothing.

Nevertheless, observe how the Devil is thwarted by the thing which He does. He heaps up scorn and reproaches against Christ, whereby it is made manifest that the Lord is not seditious. Otherwise He would not have been derided, when so great a danger was afloat, and that too from a people who were held in suspicion, and so given to change. But the sending of Christ by Pilate to Herod, becomes the commencement of a mutual friendship, Pilate not receiving those who were subject to Herod's authority, as it is added, And they were made friends, &c. Observe the Devil every where uniting together things separate, that he may compass the death of Christ. Let us blush then, if for the sake of our salvation we keep not even our friends in union with us.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.

Continue studying Luke 23:10 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and does not control their content.

Related study articles8