TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Commentary on 1 Samuel 1 verses 9–18
Elkanah had gently reproved Hannah for her inordinate grief, and here we find the good effect of the reproof.
I. It brought her to her meat. She ate and drank, Sa1 1:9. She did not harden herself in sorrow, nor grow sullen when she was reproved for it; but, when she perceived her husband uneasy that she did not come and eat with them, she cheered up her own spirits as well as she could, and came to table. it is as great a piece of self-denial to control our passions as it is to control our appetites.
II. It brought her to her prayers. It put her upon considering, "Do I well to be angry? Do I well to fret? What good does it do me? Instead of binding the burden thus upon my shoulders, had I not better easy myself of it, and cast it upon the Lord by prayer?" Elkanah had said, Am not I better to thee than ten sons? which perhaps occasioned her to think within herself, "Whether he be so or no, God is, and therefore to him will I apply, and before him will I pour out my complaint, and try what relief that will give me." If ever she will make a more solemn address than ordinary to the throne of grace upon this errand, now is the time. They are at Shiloh, at the door of the tabernacle, where God had promised to meet his people, and which was the house of prayer. They had recently offered their peace-offerings, to obtain the favour of God and all good and in token of their communion with him; and, taking the comfort of their being accepted of him, they had feasted upon the sacrifice; and now it was proper to put up her prayer in virtue of that sacrifice, for the peace-offerings, for by it not only atonement is made for sin, but the audience and acceptance of our prayers and an answer of peace to them are obtained for us: to that sacrifice, in all our supplications, we must have an eye. Now concerning Hannah's prayer we may observe,
1.The warm and lively devotion there was in it, which appeared in several instances, for our direction in prayer. (1.) She improved the present grief and trouble of her spirit for the exciting and quickening of her pious affections in prayer: Being in bitterness of soul, she prayed, Sa1 1:10. This good use we should make of our afflictions, they should make us the more lively in our addresses to God. Our blessed Saviour himself, being in an agony, prayed more earnestly, Luk 22:44. (2.) She mingled tears with her prayers. It was not a dry prayer: she wept sore. Like a true Israelite, she wept and made supplication (Hos 12:4), with an eye to the tender mercy of our God, who knows the troubled soul. The prayer came from her heart, as the tears from her eyes. (3.) She was very particular, and yet very modest, in her petition. She begged a child, a man-child, that it might be fit to serve in the tabernacle. God gives us leave, in prayer, not only to ask good things in general, but to mention that special good thing which we most need and desire. Yet she says not, as Rachel, Give me children, Gen 30:1. She will be very thankful for one. (4.) She made a solemn vow, or promise, that if God would give her a son she would give him up to God, Sa1 1:11. He would be by birth a Levite, and so devoted to the service of God, but he should be by her vow a Nazarite, and his very childhood should be sacred. It is probable she had acquainted Elkanah with her purpose before, and had had his consent and approbation. Note, Parents have a right to dedicate their children to God, as living sacrifices and spiritual priests; and an obligation is thereby laid upon them to serve God faithfully all the days of their life. Note further, It is very proper, when we are in pursuit of any mercy, to bind our own souls with a bond, that, if God give it us, we will devote it to his honour and cheerfully use it in his service. Not that hereby we can pretend to merit the gift, but thus we are qualified for it and for the comfort of it. In hope of mercy, let us promise duty. (5.) She spoke all this so softly that none could hear her. Her lips moved, but her voice was not heard, Sa1 1:13. Hereby she testified her belief of God's knowledge of the heart and its desires. Thoughts are words to him, nor is he one of those gods that must be cried aloud to, Kg1 18:27. It was likewise an instance of her humility and holy shamefacedness in her approach to God. She was none of those that made her voice to be heard on high, Isa 58:4. It was a secret prayer, and therefore, though made in a public place, yet was thus made secretly, and not, as the Pharisees prayed, to be seen of men. It is true prayer is not a thing we have reason to be ashamed of, but we must avoid all appearances of ostentation. Let what passes between God and our souls be kept to ourselves.
2.The hard censure she fell under for it. Eli was now high priest, and judge in Israel; he sat upon a seat in the temple, to oversee what was done there, Sa1 1:9. The tabernacle is here called the temple, because it was now fixed, and served all the purposes of a temple. There Eli sat to receive addresses and give direction, and somewhere (it is probable in a private corner) he espied Hannah at her prayers, and by her unusual manner fancied she was drunken, and spoke to her accordingly (Sa1 1:14): How long wilt thou be drunken? - the very imputation that Peter and the apostles fell under when the Holy Ghost gave them utterance, Act 2:13. Perhaps in this degenerate age it was no strange thing to see drunken women at the door of the tabernacle; for otherwise, one would think, the vile lust of Hophni and Phinehas could not have found so easy a prey there, Sa1 2:22. Eli took Hannah for one of these. It is one bad effect of the abounding of iniquity, and its becoming fashionable, that it often gives occasion to suspect the innocent. When a disease is epidemical every one is suspected to be tainted with it. Now, (1.) This was Eli's fault; and a great fault it was to pass so severe a censure without better observation or information. If his own eyes had already become dim, he should have employed those about him to enquire. Drunkards are commonly noisy and turbulent, but this poor woman was silent and composed. His fault was the worse that he was the priest of the Lord, who should have had compassion on the ignorant, Heb 5:2. Note, It ill becomes us to be rash and hasty in our censures of others, and to be forward to believe people guilty of bad things, while either the matter of fact on which the censure is grounded is doubtful and unproved or is capable of a good construction. Charity commands us to hope the best concerning all, and forbids censoriousness. Paul had very good information when he did but partly believe (Co1 11:18), hoping it was not so. Especially we ought to be cautious how we censure the devotions of others, lest we call that hypocrisy, enthusiasm, or superstition, which is really the fruit of an honest zeal, and it is accepted of God. (2.) It was Hannah's affliction; and a great affliction it was, added to all the rest, vinegar to the wounds of her spirit. She had been reproved by Elkanah because she would not eat and drink, and now to be reproached by Eli as if she had eaten and drunk too much was very hard. Note, It is no new thing for those that do well to be ill thought of, and we must not think it strange if at any time it be our lot.
3.Hannah's humble vindication of herself from this crime with which she was charged. She bore it admirably well. She did not retort the charge and upbraid him with the debauchery of his own sons, did not bid him look at home and restrain them, did not tell him how ill it became one in his place thus to abuse a poor sorrowful worshipper at the throne of grace. When we are at any time unjustly censured we have need to set a double watch before the door of our lips, that we do not recriminate, and return censure for censure. Hannah thought it enough to vindicate herself, and so must we, Sa1 1:15, Sa1 1:16. (1.) In justice to herself, she expressly denies the charge, speaks to him with all possible respect, calls him, My lord, intimates how very desirous she was to stand right in his opinion and how loth to lie under his censure. "No, my lord, it is not as you suspect; I have drunk neither wine nor strong drink, not any at all" (though it was proper enough to be given to one of such a heavy heart, Pro 31:6), "much less to any excess; therefore count not thy handmaid for a daughter of Belial." Note, Drunkards are children of Belial (women-drunkards, particularly), children of the wicked one, children of disobedience, children that will not endure the yoke (else they would not be drunk), more especially when they are actually drunk. Those that cannot govern themselves will not bear that any one else should. Hannah owns that the crime would have been very great if she had indeed been guilty of it, and he might justly have shut her out of the courts of God's house; but the very manner of her speaking in her own defence was sufficient to demonstrate that she was not drunk. (2.) In justice to him, she gives an account of her present behaviour, which had given occasion to his suspicion: "I am a woman of a sorrowful spirit, dejected and discomposed, and that is the reason I do not look as other people; the eyes are red, not with wine, but with weeping. And at this time I have not been talking to myself, as drunkards and fools do, but I have been pouring out my soul before the Lord, who hears and understands the language of the heart, and this out of the abundance of my complaint and grief." She had been more than ordinarily fervent in prayer to God, and this, she tells him, was the true reason of the transport and disorder she seemed to be in. Note, When we are unjustly censured we should endeavour, not only to clear ourselves, but to satisfy our brethren, by giving them a just and true account of that which they misapprehended.
4.The atonement Eli made for his rash unfriendly censure, by a kind and fatherly benediction, Sa1 1:17. He did not (as many are apt to do in such a case) take it for an affront to have his mistake rectified and to be convinced of his error, nor did it put him out of humour. But, on the contrary, he now encouraged Hannah's devotions as much as before he had discountenanced them; not only intimated that he was satisfied of her innocency by those words, Go in peace, but, being high priest, as one having authority he blessed her in the name of the Lord, and, though he knew not what the particular blessing was that she had been praying for, yet he puts his Amen to it, so good an opinion had he now conceived of her prudence and piety: The God of Israel grant thee thy petition, whatever it is, that thou hast asked of him. Note, By our meek and humble carriage towards those that reproach us because they do not know us, we may perhaps make them our friends, and turn their censures of us into prayers for us.
5.The great satisfaction of mind with which Hannah now went away, Sa1 1:18. She begged the continuance of Eli's good opinion of her and his good prayers for her, and then she went her way and did eat of what remained of the peace-offerings (none of which was to be left until the morning), and her countenance was no more sad, no more as it had been, giving marks of inward trouble and discomposure; but she looked pleasant and cheerful, and all was well. Why, what had happened? Whence came this sudden happy change? She had by prayer committed her case to God and left it with him, and now she was no more perplexed about it. She had prayed for herself, and Eli had prayed for her; and she believed that God would either give her the mercy she had prayed for or make up the want of it to her some other way. Note, Prayer is heart's-ease to a gracious soul; the seed of Jacob have often found it so, being confident that God will never say unto them, Seek you me in vain, see Phi 4:6, Phi 4:7. Prayer will smooth the countenance; it should do so.
Prayer is, then, to speak more boldly, converse with God. Though whispering, consequently, and not opening the lips, we speak in silence, yet we cry inwardly. For God hears continually all the inward converse. So also we raise the head and lift the hands to heaven, and set the feet in motion at the closing utterance of the prayer, following the eagerness of the spirit directed towards the intellectual essence; and endeavouring to abstract the body from the earth, along with the discourse, raising the soul aloft, winged with longing for better things, we compel it to advance to the region of holiness, magnanimously despising the chain of the flesh.
This Hannah does in the first book of Kings [Samuel], portraying a type of the church, [she] prays to God not with a noisy petition but silently and modestly within the very recesses of her heart. She spoke with a hidden prayer but with manifest faith. She did not speak with the voice but with the heart, because she knew that so the Lord hears, and she effectually obtained what she sought, because she asked with faith. Divine Scripture declares this, saying, “She spoke in her heart and her lips moved, but her voice was not heard, and the Lord heard her.”
Let the virgins likewise form a separate band, singing hymns or reading; silently, however, so that while their lips speak, no other’s ears may hear what they say. For, “I suffer not a woman to speak in church.” Let the married woman imitate them: let her pray and her lips move but her voice not be heard. So shall Samuel come among us: your barren soul, that is to say, shall bring forth the salvation of “God who has heard your prayers.” For that is the meaning of “Samuel.”
For I seek those tears which are shed not for display but in compunction; those which trickle down secretly and in closets and in sight of no person, softly and noiselessly; those which arise from a certain depth of mind, those shed in anguish and in sorrow, those which are for God alone. Such were Hannah’s, for “her lips moved,” it is said, “but her voice was not heard.” Her tears alone uttered a cry more clear than any trumpet. And because of this, God also opened her womb and made the hard rock a fruitful field.
At home her rival mocked her. She went into the temple, and the priest’s boy abused her and the priest upbraided her. She fled the storm at home, entered port and still ran into turbulence. She went to get a remedy, and not only did not get it but received an additional burden of taunts, and the wound instead was opened up again. You are aware, of course, how distressed souls are susceptible to abuse and insult: just as bad wounds cannot stand the slightest contact with the hand but become worse, so too the soul that is disturbed and upset has problems with everything and is stung by a chance remark. The woman, on the contrary, was not like that, even in this case with the boy abusing her. Had the priest been intoxicated, the insults would not have been so surprising; his high rank and heavy responsibility convinced her against her will to keep her composure. But in fact she was not even upset with the priest’s boy, and hence she won God’s favor even further. Should we too be abused and suffer countless misadventures, let us put up nobly with those who insult us, and we shall thus win greater favor from God.
But observe even after this her deep reverence. “Only her lips moved, but her voice,” it says, “was not heard.” And in this way does the one who would gain his request draw near to God; not consulting his ease, nor gaping, nor lounging, nor scratching his head, nor with utter listlessness. So was not God able to grant, even without any prayer at all? So did he not know the woman’s desire even before she asked? And yet had he granted it before she asked, then the woman’s earnestness would not have been shown, her virtue would not have been made manifest, she would not have gained so great a reward. So that the delay is not the result of envy or of witchcraft but of providential kindness. When therefore you hear the Scripture saying that “the Lord had shut up her womb” and that “her rival deeply provoked her,” consider that it is his intention to prove the woman’s seriousness. For observe that she had a husband devoted to her, for he said, “Am I not better to you than ten sons?” “And her rival,” it says, “deeply provoked her,” that is, reproached her, insulted her. And yet she never once retaliated, nor uttered imprecation against her, nor said, “Avenge me, for my rival reviles me.” The other had children, but this woman had her husband’s love to make amends. With this at least he even consoled her, saying, “Am I not better to you than ten sons?”But let us look again at the deep wisdom of this woman. “And Eli,” it says, “thought she was drunk.” Yet observe what she says to him also, “No, do not count your handmaid for a daughter of Belial, for out of the abundance of my complaint and my provocation have I spoken up till now.” Here is truly the proof of a contrite heart, when we are not angry with those that revile us, when we are not indignant against them, when we reply only in self-defense. Nothing renders the heart so wise as affliction; nothing is there so sweet as “godly mourning.”
As often as we apply ourselves to prayer, dearly beloved, we should above all pray in silence and quiet. If a man wants to pray aloud, he seems to take the fruit of prayer away from those who are standing near him. Only moans and sighs and groans should be heard. Indeed our prayer ought to be like that of holy Hannah, the mother of blessed Samuel, of whom it is written that “she prayed, shedding many tears, and only her lips moved, but her voice was not heard at all.” Let everyone hear and imitate this, especially those who pray aloud without any embarrassment and in such a chattering fashion that they do not allow those near them to pray. Therefore, let us pray, as I said, with sighs and moans and groans, in accord with the words of the prophet: “I roared with the groaning of my heart.” Let us pray, I repeat, not with a loud voice but with our hearts crying out to God.
Continue studying 1 Samuel 1:14 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
SefariaThe Hebrew text with Rashi and centuries of Jewish commentary.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
SUMMARY
In 1 Samuel 1:14, Eli, the High Priest, mistakenly accuses Hannah of being intoxicated, sternly questioning her behavior and commanding her to abstain from wine. This critical encounter reveals a profound misjudgment by a spiritual leader towards a woman deeply engaged in fervent prayer, setting the stage for Hannah's humble yet firm explanation and offering vital insights into discernment, perception, and the authentic nature of heartfelt supplication before God.
CONTEXT
Literary Context: This verse is a pivotal moment within the opening narrative of 1 Samuel, immediately following Hannah's profound anguish and silent, fervent prayer at the Tabernacle in Shiloh. Verses 1 Samuel 1:10-13 describe her weeping bitterly, making a solemn vow, and praying with moving lips but no audible sound. Eli's observation and subsequent accusation in verse 14 serve as a dramatic turning point, directly prompting Hannah's respectful yet resolute defense of her actions in 1 Samuel 1:15-16. This interaction is not merely an isolated incident but is central to the unfolding story of Samuel's miraculous birth and dedication, establishing the spiritual climate of the time and foreshadowing the broader themes of spiritual decline within the priesthood and God's sovereign intervention that permeate the entire book.
Historical & Cultural Context: The events transpire at Shiloh, which served as the central sanctuary for Israel during the period of the Judges, housing the Tabernacle and the Ark of the Covenant before the establishment of the monarchy and the building of the Temple in Jerusalem. As such, it was a crucial pilgrimage site for annual feasts. Barrenness in ancient Israel was a source of immense personal sorrow and social shame, often interpreted as divine disfavor. Eli, as the High Priest, occupied a position of supreme spiritual authority, responsible for upholding the sanctity of the Tabernacle and discerning the spiritual state of the worshippers. His mistaken assumption that Hannah was "drunken" might reflect a broader societal concern regarding inappropriate behavior, including intoxication, at religious gatherings, or more pointedly, a significant lapse in his own spiritual sensitivity, a theme further underscored by the later depiction of the moral corruption of his sons, Hophni and Phinehas, in 1 Samuel 2:12-17.
Key Themes: The passage introduces and develops several profound themes. Prayer is paramount, particularly the concept of pouring out one's soul before God in deep anguish, even silently, as seen in 1 Samuel 1:10. The verse powerfully illustrates the theme of misunderstanding and hasty judgment, as Eli misinterprets Hannah's intense spiritual devotion for drunkenness, highlighting the perennial danger of judging by outward appearances rather than spiritual reality. This leads directly to the theme of spiritual discernment, especially critical for those in leadership positions, where Eli's failure to perceive Hannah's true state represents a significant spiritual failing. Finally, the interaction subtly foreshadows the theme of divine intervention in response to sincere, desperate prayer, as Hannah's supplication ultimately leads to the birth of Samuel, a pivotal figure who will reshape Israel's spiritual and political landscape, as promised in 1 Samuel 1:20.
EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS
Key Word Analysis
Verse Breakdown
Literary Devices
The verse employs several significant literary devices. Foremost is profound Irony, as Eli, the spiritual leader entrusted with discerning the hearts of the people and mediating between God and Israel, completely misjudges Hannah's profound spiritual devotion, mistaking fervent, silent prayer for drunken revelry. This creates a stark Contrast between Eli's superficial, worldly perception and Hannah's deep, genuine spiritual earnestness and anguish. The direct Dialogue form, a pointed question and command from Eli, immediately engages the reader and heightens the dramatic tension, setting the stage for Hannah's subsequent, crucial explanation. Furthermore, the passage uses subtle Foreshadowing, as Eli's lack of spiritual discernment here hints at his broader spiritual blindness and the eventual decline of his priestly line, paving the way for the rise of Samuel as a true prophet and judge in Israel.
THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
1 Samuel 1:14 serves as a powerful theological lesson on the dangers of hasty judgment and the paramount importance of spiritual discernment, particularly for those in positions of leadership. Eli's error underscores the timeless biblical principle that outward appearances can be deeply deceptive, and true spiritual reality often lies hidden from the superficial gaze. It teaches us that authentic prayer can be intensely personal, deeply emotional, and sometimes manifest in ways that are unconventional or easily misunderstood by human observers. God, however, sees beyond the outward display; He perceives the heart and hears the cry of the afflicted, regardless of how it might be perceived or misjudged by human beings. This incident ultimately highlights God's profound attentiveness to the humble and desperate prayers of His people, contrasting sharply with human fallibility and the limitations of even well-intentioned spiritual authority.
REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Eli's misjudgment of Hannah is a poignant and enduring reminder for us to cultivate empathy, patience, and careful observation before forming conclusions about others, especially concerning their spiritual state or intentions. In a world quick to judge based on superficial cues and outward behaviors, this passage calls us to pause, to inquire with humility, and to extend grace rather than condemnation. It powerfully affirms that true devotion can be deeply personal, intensely emotional, and may not always conform to external expectations or observable norms. Hannah's example encourages us to pour out our hearts to God without reservation, regardless of how our raw, honest supplication might appear to others, trusting that He understands our deepest cries and hidden anguish. For leaders, this passage serves as a sober call to cultivate genuine spiritual discernment, seeking to understand the underlying spiritual realities and motivations of those they shepherd, rather than reacting impulsively to outward manifestations. It challenges us to be sensitive, compassionate shepherds, not quick accusers, fostering an environment where people feel safe to express their deepest needs before God.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
Why did Eli assume Hannah was drunk?
Answer: Eli likely assumed Hannah was drunk due to her unusual and intense physical manifestation of prayer within the sacred space of the Tabernacle. She was weeping bitterly, her lips were moving rapidly, but no sound was coming out (1 Samuel 1:10-13), indicating profound emotional distress and fervent, silent supplication. This behavior, while a sign of deep spiritual earnestness, was apparently uncommon or could be easily misinterpreted by an observer. It's plausible that Eli, as the High Priest, had previously encountered individuals who were genuinely intoxicated or behaving inappropriately within the sanctuary, leading him to a quick and erroneous conclusion. Ultimately, it highlights a significant lapse in his spiritual sensitivity and discernment, causing him to judge by outward appearance rather than discerning the true state of her heart.
What does this incident tell us about Eli's leadership?
Answer: This incident reveals a significant and concerning flaw in Eli's leadership: a marked lack of spiritual discernment and a tendency towards hasty, judgmental conclusions. As the High Priest, Eli was meant to be a spiritual guide, a guardian of the sanctuary, and an intercessor for the people. Yet, he failed to perceive the genuine, profound spiritual anguish of Hannah, misinterpreting her fervent prayer as drunkenness. His immediate assumption of intoxication, rather than inquiring about her distress with compassion, highlights a spiritual blind spot and a failure to "judge righteously" (John 7:24). While he does offer a blessing after Hannah clarifies her situation (1 Samuel 1:17), his initial reaction foreshadows the broader issues of spiritual decline within his own household and leadership, which are detailed later in the book of 1 Samuel, particularly concerning the corrupt and irreverent behavior of his own sons.
CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
The misunderstanding between Eli and Hannah in 1 Samuel 1:14 finds a profound Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and ministry of Jesus Christ. Eli, the earthly high priest, misjudged the true spiritual state of Hannah, failing to discern her fervent prayer. In stark contrast, Jesus, our ultimate and perfect High Priest, perfectly understands the human heart and our deepest cries. He is not one who misjudges or misunderstands our weakness, but rather one who can deeply sympathize with our infirmities, having been tempted in every way as we are, yet without sin (Hebrews 4:15). While Hannah poured out her soul in silent anguish, Jesus, in His earthly ministry, frequently demonstrated His perfect knowledge of people's thoughts and hearts, knowing what was in man even before they spoke (John 2:25). Furthermore, Hannah's earnest prayer for a son who would serve God ultimately points to the Father's ultimate gift of His Son, Jesus, who came not to be served but to serve and to give His life as a ransom for many (Mark 10:45). The Holy Spirit, sent by Christ, now intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words (Romans 8:26), a divine echo of Hannah's silent, heartfelt prayer, ensuring that our true spiritual state is perfectly understood and presented before the throne of grace.