TRV
See on the biblical-era map
Study This Verse
Public-domain commentary
Matthew Henry
From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers John 16:16–22. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.
Our Lord Jesus, for the comfort of his sorrowful disciples, here promises that he would visit them again.
I.Observe the intimation he gave them of the comfort he designed them, Joh 16:16. Here he tells them,
1.That they should now shortly lose the sight of him: A little while, and you that have seen me so long, and still desire to see me, shall not see me; and therefore, if they had any good question to ask him, they must ask quickly, for he was now taking his leave of them. Note, It is good to consider how near to a period our seasons of grace are, that we may be quickened to improve them while they are continued. Now our eyes see our teachers, see the days of the Son of man; but, perhaps, yet a little while, and we shall not see them. They lost the sight of Christ,
(1.)At his death, when he withdrew from this world, and never after showed himself openly in it. The most that death does to our Christian friends is to take them out of our sight, not out of being, not out of bliss, but out of all relation to us, only out of sight, and then not out of mind.
(2.)At his ascension, when he withdrew from them (from those who, after his resurrection, had for some time conversed with him), out of their sight; a cloud received him, and, though they looked up steadfastly after him, they saw him no more, Act 1:9, Act 1:10; Kg2 2:12. See Co2 5:16.
2.That yet they should speedily recover the sight of him; Again a little while, and you shall see me, and therefore you ought not to sorrow as those that have no hope. His farewell was not a final farewell; they should see him again,
(1.)At his resurrection, soon after his death, when he showed himself alive, by many infallible proofs, and this in a very little while, not forty hours. See Hos 6:2.
(2.)By the pouring out of the Spirit, soon after his ascension, which scattered the mists of ignorance and mistake they were almost lost in, and gave them a much clearer insight into the mysteries of Christ's gospel than they had yet had. The Spirit's coming was Christ's visit to his disciples, not a transient but a permanent one, and such a visit as abundantly retrieved the sight of him.
(3.)At his second coming. They saw him again as they removed one by one to him at death, and they shall see him together at the end of time, when he shall come in the clouds, and every eye shall see him. It might be truly said of this that it was but a little while, and they should see him; for what are the days of time, to the days of eternity? Pe2 3:8, Pe2 3:9.
3.He assigns the reason: "Because I go to the Father; and therefore," (1.) "I must leave you for a time, because my business calls me to the upper world, and you must be content to spare me, for really my business is yours." (2.) "Therefore you shall see me again shortly, for the Father will not detain me to your prejudice. If I go upon your errand, you shall see me again as soon as my business is done, as soon as is convenient."
It should seem, all this refers rather to his going away at death, and return at his resurrection, than his going away at the ascension, and his return at the end of time; for it was his death that was their grief, not his ascension (Luk 24:52), and between his death and resurrection it was indeed a little while. And it may be read, not, yet a little while (it is not eti mikron, as it is Joh 12:35), but mikron - for a little while you shall not see me, namely, the three days of his lying in the grave; and again, for a little while you shall see me, namely, the forty days between his resurrection and ascension. Thus we may say of our ministers and Christian friends, Yet a little while, and we shall not see them, either they must leave us or we must leave them, but it is certain that we must part shortly, and yet not part for ever. It is but a good night to those whom we hope to see with joy in the morning.
II.The perplexity of the disciples upon the intimation given them; they were at a loss what to make of it (Joh 16:17, Joh 16:18); Some of them said, softly, among themselves, either some of the weakest, that were least able, or some of the most inquisitive, that were most desirous, to understand him, What is this that he saith to us? Though Christ had often spoken to this purport before, yet still they were in the dark; though precept be upon precept, it is in vain, unless God gave the understanding. Now see here,
1.The disciples' weakness, in that they could not understand so plain a saying, to which Christ had already given them a key, having told them so often in plain terms that he should be killed, and the third day rise again; yet, say they, We cannot tell what he saith; for,
(1.)Sorrow had filled their heart, and made them unapt to receive the impressions of comfort. The darkness of ignorance and the darkness of melancholy commonly increase and thicken one another; mistakes cause griefs, and then griefs confirm mistakes.
(2.)The notion of Christ's secular kingdom was so deeply rooted in them that they could make no sense at all of those sayings of his which they knew not how to reconcile with that notion. When we think the scripture must be made to agree with the false ideas we have imbibed, no wonder that we complain of difficulty; but when our reasonings are captivated to revelation, the matter becomes easy.
(3.)It should seem, that which puzzled them was the little while. If he must go at least, yet they could not conceive how he should leave them quickly, when his stay hitherto had been so short, and so little while, comparatively. Thus it is hard for us to represent to ourselves that change as near which yet we know will come certainly, and may come suddenly. When we are told, Yet a little while and we must go hence, yet a little while and we must give up our account, we know not how to digest it; for we always took the vision to be for a great while to come, Eze 12:27.
2.Their willingness to be instructed. When they were at a loss about the meaning of Christ's words, they conferred together upon it, and asked help of one another. By mutual converse about divine things we both borrow the light of others and improve our own. Observe how exactly they repeat Christ's words. Though we cannot fully solve every difficulty we meet with in scripture, yet we must not therefore throw it by, but revolve what we cannot explain, and wait till God shall reveal even this unto us.
III.The further explication of what Christ had said.
1.See here why Christ explained it (Joh 16:19); because he knew they were desirous to ask him, and designed it. Note, The knots we cannot untie we must bring to him who alone can give an understanding. Christ knew they were desirous to ask him, but were bashful and ashamed to ask. Note, Christ takes cognizance of pious desires, though they be not as yet offered up, the groanings that cannot be uttered, and even anticipates them with the blessings of his goodness. Christ instructed those who he knew were desirous to ask him, though they did not ask. Before we call, he answers. Another reason why Christ explained it was because he observed them canvassing this matter among themselves: "Do you enquire this among yourselves? Well, I will make it easy to you." This intimates to us who they are that Christ will teach:
(1.)The humble, that confess their ignorance, for so much their enquiry implied.
(2.)The diligent, that use the means they have: "Do you enquire? You shall be taught. To him that hath shall be given."
2.See here how he explained it; not by a nice and critical descant upon the words, but by bringing the thing more closely to them; he had told them of not seeing him, and seeing him, and they did not apprehend the meaning, and therefore he explains it by their sorrowing and rejoicing, because we commonly measure things according as they affect us (Joh 16:20): You shall weep and lament, for my departure, but the world shall rejoice in it; and you shall be sorrowful, while I am absent, but, upon my return to you, your sorrow will be turned into joy. But he says nothing of the little while, because he saw that this perplexed them more than any thing; and it is of no consequence to us to know the times and the seasons. Note, Believers have joy or sorrow according as they have or have not a sight of Christ, and the tokens of his presence with them.
(1.)What Christ says here, and in Joh 16:21, Joh 16:22, of their sorrow and joy, is primarily to be understood of the present state and circumstances of the disciples, and so we have,
[1.]Their grief foretold: You shall weep and lament, and you shall be sorrowful. The sufferings of Christ could not but be the sorrow of his disciples. They wept for him because they loved him; the pain of our friend is a pain to ourselves; when they slept, it was for sorrow, Luk 22:45. They wept for themselves, and their own loss, and the sad apprehensions they had of what would become of them when he was gone. It could not but be a grief to lose him for whom they had left their all, and from whom they had expected so much. Christ has given notice to his disciples beforehand to expect sorrow, that they may treasure up comforts accordingly.
[2.]The world's rejoicing at the same time: But the world shall rejoice. That which is the grief of saints is the joy of sinners. First, Those that are strangers to Christ will continue in their carnal mirth, and not at all interest themselves in their sorrows. It is nothing to them that pass by, Lam 1:12. Nay, Secondly, Those that are enemies to Christ will rejoice because they hope they have conquered him, and ruined his interest. When the chief priests had Christ upon the cross, we may suppose they made merry over him, as those that dwell on earth over the slain witnesses, Rev 11:10. Let it be no surprise to us if we see others triumphing, when we are trembling for the ark.
[3.]The return of joy to them in due time: But your sorrow shall be turned into joy. As the joy of the hypocrite, so the sorrow of the true Christian, is but for a moment. The disciples were glad when they saw the Lord. His resurrection was life from the dead to them, and their sorrow for Christ's sufferings was turned into a joy of such a nature as could not be damped and embittered by any sufferings of their own. They were sorrowful, and yet always rejoicing (Co2 6:10), had sorrowful lives and yet joyful hearts.
(2.)It is applicable to all the faithful followers of the Lamb, and describes the common case of Christians.
[1.]Their condition and disposition are both mournful; sorrows are their lot, and seriousness is their temper: those that are acquainted with Christ must, as he was, be acquainted with grief; they weep and lament for that which others make light of, their own sins, and the sins of those about them; they mourn with sufferers that mourn, and mourn for sinners that mourn not for themselves.
[2.]The world, at the same time, goes away with all the mirth; they laugh now, and spend their days so jovially that one would think they neither knew sorrow nor feared it. Carnal mirth and pleasures are surely none of the best things, for then the worst men would not have so large a share of them, and the favourites of heaven be such strangers to them.
[3.]Spiritual mourning will shortly be turned into eternal rejoicing. Gladness is sown for the upright in heart, that sow tears, and without doubt they will shortly reap in joy. Their sorrow will not only be followed with joy, but turned into it; for the most precious comforts take rise from pious griefs. Thus he illustrates by a similitude taken from a woman in travail, to whose sorrows he compares those of his disciples, for their encouragement; for it is the will of Christ that his people should be a comforted people.
First, Here is the similitude or parable itself (Joh 16:21): A woman, we know, when she is in travail, hath sorrow, she is in exquisite pain, because her hour is come, the hour which nature and providence have fixed, which she has expected, and cannot escape; but as soon as she is delivered of the child, provided she be safely delivered, and the child be, though a Jabez (Ch1 4:9), yet not a Benoni (Gen 35:18), then she remembers no more the anguish, her groans and complaints are over, and the after - pains are more easily borne, for joy that a man is born into the world, anthrōpos, one of the human race, a child, be it son or daughter, for the word signifies either. Observe,
a.The fruit of the curse, in the sorrow and pain of a woman in travail, according to the sentence (Gen 3:16), In sorrow shalt thou bring forth. These pains are extreme, the greatest griefs and pains are compared to them (Psa 48:6; Isa 13:3; Jer 4:31; Jer 6:24), and they are inevitable, Th1 5:3. See what this world is; all its roses are surrounded with thorns, all the children of men are upon this account foolish children, that they are the heaviness of her that bore them from the very first. This comes of sin.
b.The fruit of the blessing, in the joy there is for a child born into the world. If God had not preserved the blessing in force after the fall, Be fruitful and multiply, parents could never have looked upon their children with any comfort; but what is the fruit of a blessing is matter of joy; the birth of a living child is, (a.) The parents' joy; it makes them very glad, Jer 20:15. Though children are certain cares, uncertain comforts, and often prove the greatest crosses, yet it is natural to us to rejoice at their birth. Could we be sure that our children, like John, would be filled with the Holy Ghost, we might, indeed, like his parents, have joy and gladness in their birth, Luk 1:14, Luk 1:15. But when we consider, not only that they are born in sin, but, as it is expressed, that they are born into the world, a world of snares and a vale of tears, we shall see reason to rejoice with trembling, lest it should prove better for them that they had never been born. (b.) It is such joy as makes the anguish not to be remembered, or remembered as waters that pass away, Job 11:16. Haec olim meminisse juvabit. Gen 41:51. Now this is very proper to set forth, [a.] The sorrows of Christ's disciples in this world; they are like travailing pains, sure and sharp, but not to last long, and in order to a joyful product; they are in pain to be delivered, as the church is described (Rev 12:2), and the whole creation, Rom 8:22. And, [b.] Their joys after these sorrows, which will wipe away all tears, for the former things are passed away, Rev 21:4. When they are born into that blessed world, and reap the fruit of all their services and sorrows, the toil and anguish of this world will be no more remembered, as Christ's were not, when he saw of the travail of his soul abundantly to his satisfaction, Isa 53:11.
Secondly, The application of the similitude (Joh 16:22): "You now have sorrow, and are likely to have more, but I will see you again, and you me, and then all will be well."
a.Here again he tells them of their sorrow: "You now therefore have sorrow; therefore, because I am leaving you," as is intimated in the antithesis, I will see you again. Note, Christ's withdrawings are just cause of grief to his disciples. If he hide his face, they cannot be troubled. When the sun sets, the sun-flower will hang the head. And Christ takes notice of these griefs, has a bottle for the tears, and a book for the sighs, of all gracious mourners.
b.He, more largely than before, assures them of a return of joy, Psa 30:5, Psa 30:11. He himself went through his own griefs, and bore ours, for the joy that was set before him; and he would have us encourage ourselves with the same prospect. Three things recommend the joy: - (a.) The cause of it: "I will see you again. I will make you a kind and friendly visit, to enquire after you, and minister comfort to you." Note, [a.] Christ will graciously return to those that wait for him, though for a small moment he has seemed to forsake them, Isa 54:7. Men, when they are exalted, will scarcely look upon their inferiors; but the exalted Jesus will visit his disciples. They shall not only see him in his glory, but he will see them in their meanness. [b.] Christ's returns are returns of joy to all his disciples. When clouded evidences are cleared up and interrupted communion is revived, then is the mouth filled with laughter. (b.) The cordiality of it: Your heart shall rejoice. Divine consolation put gladness into the heart. Joy in the heart is solid, and not flashy; it is secret, and that which a stranger does not intermeddle with; it is sweet, and gives a good man satisfaction in himself; it is sure, and not easily broken in upon. Christ's disciples should heartily rejoice in his returns, sincerely and greatly. (c.) The continuance of it: Your joy no man taketh from you. Men will attempt to take their joy from them; they would if they could; but they shall not prevail. Some understand it of the eternal joy of those that are glorified; those that have entered into the joy of the Lord shall go no more out. Our joys on earth we are liable to be robbed of by a thousand accidents, but heavenly joys are everlasting. I rather understand it of the spiritual joys of those that are sanctified, particularly the apostles' joy in their apostleship. Thanks be to God, says Paul, in the name of the rest, who always causes us to triumph, Co2 2:14. A malicious world would have taken it from them, they would have lost it; but, when they took everything else from them, they could not take this; as sorrowful, yet always rejoicing. They could not rob them of their joy, because they could not separate them from the love of Christ, could not rob them of their God, nor of their treasure in heaven.
Historical interpretation
Six Centuries of Reception
11 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.
Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.
If we rejoice with the world, it is to be feared that we shall also mourn with the world. But let us mourn while the world rejoices, and we shall afterward rejoice when the world mourns.
“A time to weep, and a time to laugh.” A time to weep, when it is the time of suffering, as when the Lord also says, “Truly I say to you, that you shall weep and lament.” But to laugh at the resurrection: “For your sorrow,” he says, “shall be turned into joy.”
Nothing is wont so to cast down the soul that is anguished and possessed by deep despondency, as when words which cause pain are continually dwelt upon. Why then did Christ, after saying, "I go," and, "Hereafter I will not speak with you," continually dwell on the same subject, saying "A little while, and ye shall not see Me, because I go to Him that sent Me"? When He had recovered them by His words concerning the Spirit, He again casteth down their courage. Wherefore doth He this? He testeth their feelings, and rendereth them more proved, and well accustometh them by hearing sad things, manfully to bear separation from Him; for they who had practiced this when spoken of in words, were likely in actions also, easily to bear it afterwards. And if one enquire closely, this very thing is a consolation, the saying that, "I go to the Father." For it is the expression of One, who declares that He shall not perish, but that His end is a kind of translation. He addeth too another consolation; for He saith not merely, "A little while, and ye shall not see Me," but also, "A little while, and ye shall see Me"; showing that He will both come to them again, and that their separation would be but for a little while, and His presence with them continual.
And He said not, that the pain shall pass away only, but, "she doth not even remember it," so great is the joy which succeedeth; so also shall it be with the Saints. And yet the woman doth not rejoice because "a man hath come into the world," but because a son hath been born to her; since, had this been the case, nothing would have hindered the barren from rejoicing over another who beareth. Why then spake He thus? Because He introduced this example for this purpose only, to show that sorrow is for a season, but joy lasting: and to show that (death) is a translation unto life; and to show the great profit of their pangs. He said not, "a child hath been born," but, "A man." For to my mind He here alludeth to His own Resurrection, and that He should be born not unto that death which bare the birth-pang, but unto the Kingdom. Therefore He said not, "a child hath been born unto her," but, "A man hath been born into the world."
"And ye now therefore have sorrow-but I will see you again, and your sorrow shall be turned into joy." Then, to show that He shall die no more, He saith, "And no man taketh it from you. And in that day ye shall ask Me nothing." Again He proveth nothing else by these words, but that He is from God. "For then ye shall for the time to come know all things." But what is, "Ye shall not ask Me"? "Ye shall need no intercessor, but it is sufficient that ye call on My Name, and so gain all things."
(Hom. lxxix) Our Lord after having relieved the spirits of the disciples by the promise of the Holy Spirit, again depresses them: A little while, and ye shall not see Me. He does this to accustom them to the mention of His departure, in order that they may bear it well, when it does come. For nothing so quiets the troubled mind, as the continued recurrence to the subject of its grief.
(Hom. lxxix. 1) But then, if one examines, these are words of consolation: Because I go to the Father. For they show that His death was only a translation: and more consolation follows: And again, a little while, and ye shall see Me: an intimation this that He would return, and after a short separation, come and live with them for ever.
(Hom. lxxix. 1) Either sorrow had confused their minds, or the obscurity of the words themselves prevented their understanding them, and made them appear contradictory. If we shall see Thee, they say, how goest Thou? If Thou goest, how shall we see Thee? What is this that He saith unto us, A little while? We cannot tell what He saith.
(Hom. lxxix) Then He shows that sorrow brings forth joy, short sorrow infinite joy, by an example from nature; A woman when she is in travail hath sorrow, because her hour is come; but as soon as she is delivered of the child, she remembereth no more the anguish, for joy that a man is born into the world.
(Hom. lxxix) By this example He also intimates that He loosens the chains of death, and creates men anew. He does not say however that she should not have tribulation, but that she should not remember it; so great is the joy which follows. And so is it with the saints. He saith not, that a boy is born, but that a man, a tacit allusion to His own resurrection.
"A woman when she is in travail hath sorrow." And He hath used a comparison which the Prophets also use continually, likening despondencies to the exceeding pains of childbirth. But what He saith is of this kind: "Travail pains shall lay hold on you, but the pang of childbirth is the cause of joy"; both confirming His words relative to the Resurrection, and showing that the departing hence is like passing from the womb into the light of day. As though He had said, "Marvel not that I bring you to your advantage through such sorrow, since even a mother to become a mother, passeth in like manner through pain." Here also He implieth something mystical, that He hath loosened the travail pangs of death, and caused a new man to be born of them.
"If," saith one of them, "we shall see Thee, whither goest Thou? And if Thou goest, how shall we see Thee?" Therefore they say, "We cannot tell what He saith." That He was about to depart, they knew; but they knew not that He would shortly come to them. On which account He rebuketh them, because they did not understand His saying. For, desiring to infix in them the doctrine concerning His death, what saith He? "Verily, verily, I say unto you, That ye shall weep and lament"-which belonged to the Death and the Cross-"but the world shall rejoice." Because by reason of their not desiring His death, they quickly ran into the belief that He would not die, and then when they heard that He would die, cast about, not knowing what that "little" meant, He saith, "Ye shall mourn and lament." "But your sorrow shall be turned into joy." Then having shown that after grief comes joy, and that grief gendereth joy, and that grief is short, but the pleasure endless, He passeth to a common example.
(Tr. c. 1) The meaning of these words however was obscure, before their fulfilment; Then said some of His disciples among themselves, What is this that He saith unto us, A little while, and ye shall not see Me: and again, a little while, and ye shall see Me: and, Because I go to the Father.
(Tr. ci. 1) For above, because He did not say, A little while, but simply, I go to the Father, He seemed to speak plainly. But what to them was obscure at the time, but by and by manifested, is manifest to us. For in a little while He suffered, and they did not see Him; and again, in a little while He rose again, and they saw Him. He says, And ye shall see Me no more; for the mortal Christ they saw no more.
(Tr. ci) Which must be understood thus, viz. that the disciples sorrowed at their Lord's death, and then immediately rejoiced at His resurrection. The world (i. e. the enemies of Christ, who put Him to death) rejoiced just when the disciples sorrowed, i. e. at His death: Ye shall weep and lament, but the world shall rejoice; and ye shall be sorrowful, but your sorrow shall be turned into joy.
(Tr. ci) This comparison does not seem difficult to understand. It was one which lay near at hand, and He Himself immediately shows its application. And ye now therefore have sorrow; but I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice. The bringing forth is compared to sorrow, the birth to joy, which is especially true in the birth of a boy. And your joy no man taketh from you: their joy is Christ. This agrees with what the Apostle saith, Christ being risen from the dead dieth no more. (Rom. 6:9)
(Tr. ci. 6) To this joy it is better to refer what was said above, A little while and ye shall not see Me, and again, a little while and ye shall see Me. For the whole space of time that this world continues is but a little while. Because I go to the Father, refers to the former clause, a little while and ye shall not see Me, not to the latter, a little while and ye shall see Me. His going to the Father was the reason why they would not see Him. So to them who then saw Him in the body He says, A little while and ye shall not see Me; for He was about to go to the Father, and mortals would thenceforth never see Him again, as they saw Him now. The next words, A little while and ye shall see Me, are a promise to the whole Church. For this little while appears long to us while it is passing, but when it is finished we shall then see how little a time it has been.
(Tr. ci. 6) Nor yet in this bringing forth of joy, are we entirely without joy to lighten our sorrow, but, as the Apostle saith, we rejoice in hope: (Rom. 12:12) for even the woman, to whom we are compared, rejoiceth more for her future offspring, than she sorrows for her present pain.
(Tr. ci. 5) This fruit indeed the Church now yearneth for in travail, but then will enjoy in her delivery. And it is a male child, because all active duties are for the sake of devotion; for that only is free which is desired for its own sake, not for any thing else, and action is for this end. This is the end which satisfies and is eternal: for nothing can satisfy but what is itself the ultimate end. Wherefore of them it is well said, Your joy no man taketh from you.
What he added by way of explanation to those inquiring of him, “Truly, truly, I say to you that you will lament and weep, but the world will rejoice. You will be sorrowful, but your sorrow will be changed to joy” is fitting to their condition and to that of the entire church. Those who loved Christ lamented and wept when they saw him apprehended by his enemies, bound, led before the Sanhedrin, condemned [to death], scourged, exposed as an object of derision and finally crucified, his side pierced with a lance and buried. Those who loved the world … rejoiced when they condemned to a shameful death one who was troubling for them even to look at. The disciples were sorrowful when their Lord was put to death, but when they acknowledged his resurrection, their sorrow was changed to joy. And when they saw the mighty power of his ascension, they were raised up to an even higher level of joy, praising and blessing God. …But this discourse of the Lord is also appropriate to all believers who are striving to arrive at eternal joys through the tears and distress of the present [life]. They rightly lament and weep and are sorrowful during the present [time], since they are not yet capable of seeing him whom they love. As long as they are in their body, they recognize that they are on a journey and [absent] from their fatherland and kingdom. They have no doubt that they must reach their crown by labors and contests. Their sorrow will be changed to joy when, after the struggle of this present life is over, they receive the prize of everlasting life, about which it is said in the psalm, “Those who sow in tears will reap in joy.”
Or thus, It will be a little time during which ye will not see Me, i. e. the three days that He rested in the grave; and again, it will be a little time during which ye shall see Me, i. e. the forty days of His appearance amongst them, from His Passion to His ascension. And ye shall see Me for that little time only, Because I go to the Father; for I am not going to stay always in the body here, but, by that humanity which I have assumed to ascend to heaven. It follows; Now Jesus knew that they were desirous to ask Him, and said unto them, Do ye enquire among yourselves of that I said, A little while, and ye shall not see Me: and again, a little while, and ye shall see Me? Verily, verily, I say unto you, That ye shall weep and lament. Their merciful Master, understanding their ignorance and doubts, replied so as to explain what He had said.
Continue studying John 16:17 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.
Read & Compare
BibleGatewayThis verse in more than 200 translations and 70 languages.
Bible.comThe YouVersion reader — hundreds of translations, reading plans, and highlights.
ESV.orgCrossway's official English Standard Version reader.
NET BibleThe NET translation with 60,000+ translators' notes on every rendering decision.
STEP BibleTyndale House's free study tool — original text, vocabulary, and scholarly resources.
BibliaLogos Bible Software's free web reader.
USCCBThe New American Bible (Revised Edition) with the U.S. bishops' study notes.
Commentaries
BibleHub CommentariesDozens of classic commentaries on this verse, gathered on one page.
StudyLightMore than 100 commentary sets — the largest collection on the web.
BibleRefPlain-English commentary on what this verse means, verse by verse.
Enduring WordDavid Guzik's free commentary on this chapter, widely used by Bible teachers.
Bible Study ToolsVerse commentary alongside Greek and Hebrew study aids.
Original Language & Research
- BibleHub InterlinearThe verse word by word — original language, transliteration, and English.
- BibleHub LexiconEvery word's original-language definition and Strong's entry.
Blue Letter BibleDeep-study tools — Strong's numbers, concordance, and word studies.
CNTR CollationThe earliest Greek manuscripts of this verse, collated letter by letter.
Sermons, Hymns & Audio
TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.
Summary
John 16:17 captures the profound confusion of Jesus' disciples as they grapple with His cryptic pronouncements about His imminent departure and return. During His intimate Farewell Discourse, Jesus speaks of a "little while" until they will not see Him, followed by another "little while" when they will see Him again, all explained by His going to the Father. This verse vividly portrays the disciples' struggle to comprehend the spiritual realities and divine timing of Jesus' passion, resurrection, and ascension, highlighting their earthly expectations versus the unfolding of God's redemptive plan.
Context
Literary Context
This verse is deeply embedded within Jesus' Farewell Discourse, spanning John 13 through John 17. Delivered in the Upper Room on the night of His betrayal, this discourse is Jesus' final, extended teaching to His disciples before His crucifixion. John 16:17 directly follows Jesus' statement in John 16:16, where He first introduces the enigmatic "little while" phrases. The disciples' private questioning among themselves in John 16:17 serves as a narrative device, underscoring their bewilderment and setting the stage for Jesus to offer further clarification and comfort in the subsequent verses (John 16:18-24). The entire discourse aims to prepare them for His physical absence, the coming of the Holy Spirit, and the continuation of their mission.
Historical & Cultural Context
The setting is Jerusalem, during the Passover feast, a time imbued with deep historical and eschatological significance for the Jewish people. The disciples, like most Jews of their time, held strong messianic expectations of a conquering king who would liberate Israel from Roman rule and establish an earthly kingdom. Jesus' repeated allusions to suffering, death, and departure, particularly His "going to the Father," directly contradicted these deeply ingrained nationalistic and political hopes. Their cultural framework lacked a precedent for a Messiah who would die and then return spiritually or ascend to heaven. This fundamental disconnect between their earthly understanding of the Messiah and Jesus' divine mission explains their profound confusion and inability to grasp the spiritual implications of His words, even as He spoke plainly about His impending passion and glorification.
Key Themes
The central theme in John 16:17 is the disciples' profound perplexity and limited understanding of Jesus' divine plan. Despite three years of direct teaching, they struggle to reconcile His talk of departure with His promise of return, especially in light of His going "to the Father." This highlights the human tendency to interpret spiritual truths through a material lens. Another key theme is the significance of the "little while", a phrase repeated twice. The first "little while" refers to the brief period leading to Jesus' crucifixion and burial, during which His physical presence would be absent from them (John 19:30). The second "little while" denotes the even shorter interval until His glorious resurrection appearances, when they would indeed see Him again (John 20:19). Finally, the phrase "Because I go to the Father" introduces the crucial theme of Jesus' ultimate glorification and ascension. His return to the Father is not an abandonment but the necessary culmination of His earthly mission and the prerequisite for the sending of the Holy Spirit, the Helper, who would enable a new, deeper form of communion with believers.
Exposition and Analysis
Key Word Analysis
From manthanō, meaning "to learn," a mathētḗs is a learner or pupil. In this context, it emphasizes their role as students of Jesus, yet despite their proximity and instruction, they remain perplexed, highlighting the gap between intellectual hearing and spiritual comprehension of divine truth.
A primary verb meaning "to lay forth" or "relate in words," often implying systematic or set discourse. Here, it refers to the disciples' internal, private discussion, contrasting with Jesus' more formal teaching style. Their "saying among themselves" indicates their inability to directly ask Jesus, perhaps out of fear or embarrassment, and their attempt to collectively decipher His enigmatic words.
A neuter singular noun meaning "a small space of time or degree." Its repetition underscores the brevity of the periods Jesus describes—both His impending physical absence (death) and His subsequent reappearance (resurrection). The disciples' inability to grasp this brevity, despite the direct statement, points to their focus on the immediate, tangible loss rather than the spiritual victory and new form of presence to come.
Verse Breakdown
"Then said some of his disciples among themselves"
This opening clause immediately establishes the setting of private, internal dialogue among the disciples. It reveals their confusion and hesitation to directly question Jesus, perhaps due to the solemnity of the moment or their embarrassment at not understanding. Their discussion "among themselves" indicates a shared bewilderment.
"What is this that he saith unto us"
This rhetorical question expresses the core of their perplexity. They are not merely confused by a single word but by the entire concept Jesus is presenting. The phrase "this that he saith unto us" highlights their direct engagement with His words, even if their understanding is lacking.
"A little while, and ye shall not see me:"
This is the first part of Jesus' enigmatic statement that causes their confusion. It refers to the brief period between His imminent death and burial, during which His physical presence would be absent from them. The disciples interpreted "not see me" in a purely physical, permanent sense, failing to grasp the temporary nature of His absence.
"and again, a little while, and ye shall see me:"
This second part of Jesus' statement, seemingly contradictory to the first, deepens their bewilderment. It refers to the even shorter period until His post-resurrection appearances, when He would physically manifest Himself to them again. The juxtaposition of "not see" and "see" within two "little whiles" is the crux of their misunderstanding.
"and, Because I go to the Father?"
This final clause is Jesus' explanation for the preceding statements, yet it only adds to the disciples' confusion. His going "to the Father" implies His ascension and glorification, which they could not reconcile with their earthly understanding of the Messiah. They couldn't connect His departure to a higher purpose or a new form of presence.
Literary Devices
John 16:17 employs several literary devices to convey the disciples' state of mind and the unfolding drama. Repetition is prominent with the phrase "a little while," emphasizing the brevity of the periods Jesus describes, yet paradoxically, it contributes to the disciples' confusion because they cannot reconcile the two brief, seemingly contradictory "little whiles." The disciples' question, "What is this that he saith unto us," functions as a Rhetorical Question, not posed for an answer from Jesus, but as an expression of their collective bewilderment and internal struggle. There is also a subtle Irony at play: Jesus is speaking plainly about His death and resurrection, yet the disciples, despite their close relationship with Him, are completely unable to grasp the spiritual reality behind His words, demonstrating the profound gap between divine truth and human perception. This moment also serves as Foreshadowing, hinting at the impending sorrow and temporary separation the disciples would experience, which would then be transformed into joy upon Jesus' resurrection.
Theological and Thematic Connections
John 16:17, though a moment of confusion, profoundly connects to the broader theological themes of divine timing, the nature of spiritual understanding, and the transition from physical presence to spiritual indwelling. The disciples' inability to grasp Jesus' words underscores the human limitation in comprehending God's redemptive plan, especially when it involves suffering and departure before glorification. This passage highlights that God's ways are often beyond our immediate understanding, requiring faith and patience. Jesus' "going to the Father" is not an end but a necessary step in His glorification, which paves the way for the sending of the Holy Spirit, transforming their relationship from physical proximity to spiritual intimacy. This shift is central to the New Covenant, where believers experience Christ's presence not through sight but through the Spirit's indwelling.
Reflection and Application
The disciples' perplexity in John 16:17 offers a mirror for our own spiritual journeys. Like them, we often face seasons of confusion, doubt, or perceived absence of God's clear direction, especially when our expectations of how God should act clash with the unfolding reality. The "little while" reminds us that even the most challenging or seemingly contradictory periods in our lives are temporary in light of God's eternal purposes. It encourages us to cultivate trust in God's perfect timing and His overarching plan, even when we cannot fully comprehend its immediate details. This passage invites us to move beyond a purely physical or immediate understanding of God's presence and to embrace the deeper, spiritual communion offered through the Holy Spirit. Our ultimate hope is anchored not in what we can immediately see or understand, but in the certainty of Christ's promises and His eventual return, which will bring about a complete and eternal reunion.
Questions for Reflection
FAQ
What did Jesus mean by the repeated phrase "a little while"?
Jesus used "a little while" to refer to two distinct, brief periods. The first "little while" (when they would "not see" Him) referred to the very short time until His crucifixion, death, and burial, during which His physical presence would be absent from His disciples. This period culminated on the cross, as recorded in John 19:30. The second "little while" (when they would "see" Him again) referred to the even shorter interval until His glorious resurrection appearances, when He would physically manifest Himself to them again, as seen in passages like John 20:19. These were not long, drawn-out periods but brief, intense moments of transition.
Why were the disciples so confused by Jesus' words in John 16:17?
The disciples' confusion stemmed primarily from their deeply ingrained Jewish messianic expectations. They anticipated a conquering Messiah who would establish an earthly kingdom and liberate Israel, not one who would suffer, die, and depart. Jesus' talk of "not seeing" Him and "going to the Father" directly contradicted their understanding of a perpetually present, reigning king. They were thinking in purely physical and temporal terms, unable to grasp the spiritual and eschatological dimensions of Jesus' mission, including His death, resurrection, and ascension. Their earthly perspective prevented them from comprehending the divine plan that required His departure for His glorification and the subsequent sending of the Holy Spirit.
Christ-Centered Fulfillment
John 16:17, a moment of profound confusion for the disciples, is ultimately fulfilled in the person and work of Jesus Christ, marking a pivotal transition in God's redemptive history. Jesus' "little while" of not being seen refers to His sacrificial death on the cross, the ultimate act of atonement for humanity's sins, as prophesied throughout the Old Testament and completed at Calvary (John 19:30). The subsequent "little while" when they would "see" Him again points directly to His glorious resurrection from the dead, demonstrating His victory over sin and death and inaugurating the new creation (John 20). His declaration, "Because I go to the Father," is the necessary prelude to His ascension and glorification (Acts 1:9-11), which in turn enables the sending of the Holy Spirit, the Comforter (John 16:7). This spiritual indwelling of the Spirit means that believers now experience a deeper, more intimate communion with Christ than even the disciples did during His earthly ministry. Thus, the temporary physical absence leads to an eternal spiritual presence, fulfilling God's plan to draw humanity into fellowship with the Triune God through Christ's completed work.