Skip to content

Job 38:36

“Source of Wisdom and Sustaining Providence”· Job 38:36–38Read in context
King James Version
Who hath put wisdom in the inward parts? or who hath given understanding to the heart?
KJV (with Strong's)
Who hath put H7896 wisdom H2451 in the inward parts H2910? or who hath given H5414 understanding H998 to the heart H7907?
Complete Jewish Bible
"Who put wisdom in people's inner parts? Who gave understanding to the mind?
Berean Standard Bible
Who has put wisdom in the heart or given understanding to the mind?
American Standard Version
Who hath put wisdom in the inward parts? Or who hath given understanding to the mind?
World English Bible Messianic
Who has put wisdom in the inward parts? Or who has given understanding to the mind?
Geneva Bible (1599)
Who hath put wisedome in the reines? or who hath giuen the heart vnderstanding?
Young's Literal Translation
Who hath put in the inward parts wisdom? Or who hath given To the covered part understanding?
Douay-Rheims Bible
Who hath put wisdom in the heart of man? or who gave the cock understanding?
Translation
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 13,830 of 31,102 · 44.5%

Study this verse

Summary

Job 38:36 presents a profound rhetorical challenge from God to Job, emerging from the heart of a divine whirlwind discourse. This verse serves as a climactic assertion of God's absolute sovereignty, not merely over the vast cosmos but also over the intricate, unseen realm of human intellect and consciousness. By questioning the origin of wisdom and understanding within humanity, God underscores the inherent limitations of human knowledge and unequivocally declares Himself as the sole, ultimate source and bestower of all intelligence, discernment, and insight.

Context

Literary Context

This verse is strategically positioned within God's first and most extensive speech to Job, spanning Job 38 and Job 39. Following the exhaustive, often circular, arguments between Job and his friends concerning the nature of suffering and divine justice, God directly intervenes. His discourse is not an explanation for Job's suffering but a majestic display of His omnipotence and omniscience, primarily through a series of unanswerable questions about the natural world, cosmic phenomena, and the intricate behaviors of animals. Job 38:1-3 sets the scene for this divine interrogation. Verse 36 marks a significant shift from the external, observable wonders of creation to the internal, mysterious workings of the human mind, thereby extending God's sovereign reach into the very core of human identity and capacity. The rhetorical questions are designed to humble Job and all humanity, demonstrating the vast chasm between finite human comprehension and infinite divine wisdom.

Historical & Cultural Context

In the ancient Near East, the "inward parts" (often referring to organs like the kidneys or liver) were not merely anatomical but were considered the seat of deep emotions, moral conscience, and profound thoughts. Similarly, the "heart" (Hebrew: lev or levav generally, but here, sekvîy) was understood as the center of intellect, will, and emotion—the very core of a person's being and understanding. The setting of the book of Job, likely in the patriarchal period, emphasizes a worldview where divine intervention and the direct hand of God in all aspects of life were readily acknowledged. God's appearance from a "whirlwind" (Job 38:1) is a classic biblical depiction of a theophany, a powerful manifestation of God's presence, underscoring the gravity and authority of His words. This cultural understanding amplifies the impact of God's questions, asserting His authorship over even the most intimate and fundamental aspects of human existence.

Key Themes

Job 38:36 powerfully contributes to several overarching themes within the book of Job and broader biblical theology. Foremost is the Divine Authorship of Intellect, asserting that God alone is the ultimate bestower of wisdom and understanding. Human beings do not inherently generate these capacities; rather, they are a divine gift, showcasing God's creative power even in the intricate design of the mind. This leads directly to the theme of Human Limitations and Humility. By posing the unanswerable questions, "Who hath put wisdom... or who hath given understanding?", God underscores the finite nature of human knowledge and the profound humility required when confronted with His infinite wisdom. Job, who had presumed to question God's justice, is confronted with his own intellectual boundaries, echoing the sentiment found in Proverbs 3:5-7. Finally, the verse implicitly teaches that God is the Source of All Knowledge. Every facet of intelligence, intuition, and discernment within humanity originates from the Creator, encouraging a perspective where our mental faculties are seen as divinely endowed, leading to a necessary reliance on God for true insight and discerning truth, as seen in Psalm 119:104.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Wisdom chokmâh' H2451

(Strong's H2451) This term signifies not merely intellectual knowledge but also practical skill, discernment, and the ability to apply knowledge effectively. In this context, it refers to the profound insight and understanding necessary to navigate life and comprehend truth.

Inward parts ṭuchâh' H2910

(Strong's H2910) Literally referring to the kidneys, in ancient Hebrew thought this term was often used metaphorically to denote the deepest, most hidden parts of a person's being—the seat of profound emotions, conscience, and innermost thoughts. Here, it signifies the source of intuitive, innate wisdom that operates beneath conscious reasoning.

Understanding bîynâh' H998

(Strong's H998) This word refers to the ability to discern, distinguish, and comprehend. It implies a deeper grasp of truth, moving beyond mere facts to grasp relationships and implications, enabling a deeper insight into complex matters.

Heart sekvîy' H7907

(Strong's H7907) While "heart" typically translates lev or levav, sekvîy specifically denotes observant intelligence, understanding, or intuition, sometimes linked to "sight" or "insight." It points to the conscious faculty of intellect, discernment, and the ability to comprehend and reason.

Verse Breakdown

"Who hath put wisdom in the inward parts?"

This clause challenges Job, and by extension, all humanity, to consider the origin of their deepest, most intuitive wisdom. It refers to the innate, often subconscious, capacity for insight and moral discernment that seems to reside within the very core of one's being. The rhetorical question implies that no human or created entity could possibly be the source of such a profound internal endowment; only the Creator possesses the power and knowledge to implant such a faculty.

"or who hath given understanding to the heart?"

This parallel clause extends the inquiry to the more conscious faculties of intellect and discernment. The "heart" here, representing the mind and will, is presented as the recipient of understanding. The question highlights that the ability to comprehend, reason, and make sense of the world is not self-generated but is a bestowed gift. Both clauses together emphasize that every aspect of human intelligence, from the deepest intuition to conscious reasoning, is a direct impartation from God.

Literary Devices

Job 38:36 is primarily structured as a Rhetorical Question, a powerful literary device where a question is posed not to elicit an answer, but to make a statement or produce an effect. God knows the answer (He is the one who did it), and the question serves to highlight Job's (and humanity's) ignorance and God's unparalleled wisdom and power. The verse also employs Synonymous Parallelism, a common feature of Hebrew poetry, where the second line reiterates or expands upon the thought of the first line using different words ("wisdom in the inward parts" paralleled by "understanding to the heart"). This repetition amplifies the central message: God is the sole source of all forms of human intellect. While not strictly Anthropomorphism, the language of God "putting" and "giving" to human internal organs attributes human-like actions to God, emphasizing His direct, personal involvement in the intricate design and function of the human mind.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Job 38:36 profoundly asserts God's exclusive claim as the ultimate source of all wisdom and understanding, extending His creative and sustaining power not only to the vast cosmos but also to the intricate, unseen mechanisms of the human mind. This truth grounds the biblical teaching that true wisdom begins with the fear of the Lord and is not something human beings can generate independently. It challenges any humanistic notion that intellect is purely a product of evolution or self-development, instead pointing to a divine endowment that enables humanity to think, reason, and discern. This verse reminds us that our cognitive abilities, far from being inherent, are a miraculous gift, intended to lead us back to the Giver, fostering humility and dependence on divine revelation for genuine insight.

Reflection and Application

Recognizing God as the ultimate source of our wisdom and understanding profoundly reshapes our perspective on learning, decision-making, and even our own identity. It cultivates a deep sense of humility, reminding us that no matter how intelligent or accomplished we become, our capacities are derived, not inherent, and pale in comparison to God's infinite knowledge. This understanding should drive us to seek God continually for guidance, insight, and discernment in every area of life, acknowledging that true wisdom comes from His Word and His Spirit. It also calls us to be good stewards of the intellect He has graciously bestowed, using our minds not for pride or self-aggrandizement, but for His glory, to understand His truth, to serve others, and to navigate the complexities of the world with godly wisdom. Our ability to think, reason, and comprehend is a miraculous gift, prompting us to use our cognitive faculties to know Him more deeply and to make His wisdom known.

Questions for Reflection

  1. How does acknowledging God as the source of your intellect influence your approach to education, problem-solving, and decision-making?
  2. In what specific areas of your life are you most tempted to rely solely on your own understanding, and how can you intentionally seek God's wisdom in those areas?
  3. Considering your mind as a divine gift, what practical steps can you take to better steward your intellectual capacities for God's glory and the benefit of others?

FAQ

Why does God ask rhetorical questions instead of directly explaining Job's suffering?

God's primary purpose in His discourse with Job is not to provide a direct explanation for Job's suffering, which remains largely a mystery in the book, but to re-establish His own absolute sovereignty, wisdom, and power. The rhetorical questions, such as those in Job 38:36, serve to highlight the vast gap between divine omnipotence and human finitude. By demonstrating His mastery over creation and even the internal workings of the human mind, God shifts Job's focus from his own plight ("why me?") to the incomparable greatness of God ("who is God?"). This approach ultimately leads Job to humility and repentance (Job 42:1-6), fostering a deeper trust in God's character rather than a mere intellectual understanding of his circumstances.

What is the significance of "inward parts" and "heart" in this verse, and why are they distinct?

In ancient Hebrew thought, both "inward parts" (ṭuchâh, referring to kidneys or inner being) and "heart" (sekvîy, here denoting intellect or intuition) represent the deepest, most intimate aspects of human consciousness and intellect. While often used somewhat interchangeably in broader biblical literature to signify the core of a person, their distinct usage in Job 38:36 emphasizes the comprehensive nature of God's control over human intelligence. "Inward parts" likely refers to the more intuitive, subconscious, or innate wisdom—the deep-seated understanding that seems to reside within one's very being. "Heart" (specifically sekvîy here) points to the more conscious, active intellectual faculty of discernment and comprehension. Together, they underscore that every facet of human intelligence, from the deepest intuition to conscious reasoning, is a direct, divinely bestowed gift, not self-generated.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

Job 38:36, with its profound assertion of God as the sole source of wisdom and understanding, finds its ultimate and most glorious fulfillment in Jesus Christ. He is not merely a recipient of divine wisdom but is the very embodiment and personification of it. Colossians 2:3 declares that "in Christ are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge." As the eternal Word of God, through whom all things were made (John 1:1-3), Christ is the active agent of creation, the one who indeed "put wisdom in the inward parts" and "gave understanding to the heart" of humanity. The wisdom of God, which confounds human intellect, is most powerfully revealed in the cross of Christ, which to the world appears foolishness but is "the power of God and the wisdom of God" to those who are being saved (1 Corinthians 1:24-25). Furthermore, it is Christ who, after His resurrection, "opened their minds to understand the Scriptures" (Luke 24:45), demonstrating His ongoing role in bestowing true spiritual understanding and insight to His followers, enabling them to grasp the divine truths that originate from the Father.

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Job 38:25–41. His four-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 17 verses
Passage under commentJob 38:25–41
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details[1.] [2.] Fine details

Hitherto God had put such questions to Job as were proper to convince him of his ignorance and short-sightedness. Now he comes, in the same manner, to show his impotency and weakness. As it is but little that he knows, and therefore he ought not to arraign the divine counsels, so it is but little that he can do, and therefore he ought not to oppose the proceedings of Providence. Let him consider what great things God does, and try whether he can do the like, or whether he thinks himself an equal match for him.

I.God has thunder, and lightning, and rain, and frost, at command, but Job has not, and therefore let him not dare to compare himself with God, or to contend with him. Nothing is more uncertain than what weather it shall be, nor more out of our reach to appoint; it shall be what weather pleases God, not what pleases us, unless, as becomes us, whatever pleases God pleases us. Concerning this observe here,

1.How great God is.

(1.)He has a sovereign dominion over the waters, has appointed them their course, even then when they seem to overflow and to be from under his check, Job 38:25. He has divided a water-course, directs the rain where to fall, even when the shower is most violent, with as much certainty as if it were conveyed by canals or conduit-pipes. Thus the hearts of kings are said to be in God's hand; and as the rains, those rivers of God, he turns them whithersoever he will. Every drop goes as it is directed. God has sworn that the waters of Noah shall no more return to cover the earth; and we see that he is able to make good what he has promised, for he has the rain in a water-course.

(2.)He has dominion over the lightning and the thunder, which go not at random, but in the way that he directs them. They are mentioned here because he prepares the lightnings for the rain, Psa 135:7. Let not those that fear God be afraid of the lightning or the thunder, for they are not blind bullets, but go the way that God himself, who means no hurt to them, directs.

(3.)In directing the course of the rain he does not neglect the wilderness, the desert land (Job 38:26, Job 38:27), where no man is.

[1.]Where there is no man to be employed in taking care of the productions. God's providence reaches further than man's industry. If he had not more kindness for many of the inferior creatures than man has, it would go ill with them. God can make the earth fruitful without any art or pains of ours, Gen 2:5, Gen 2:6. When there was not a man to till the ground, yet there went up a mist and watered it. But we cannot make it fruitful without God; it is he that gives the increase.

[2.]Where there is no man to be provided for nor to take the benefit of the fruits that are produced. Though God does with very peculiar favour visit and regard man, yet he does not overlook the inferior creatures, but causes the bud of the tender herb to spring forth for food for all flesh, as well as for the service of man. Even the wild asses shall have their thirst quenched, Psa 104:11. God has enough for all, and wonderfully provides even for those creatures that man neither has service from nor makes provision for.

(4.)He is, in a sense, the Father of the rain, Job 38:28. It has no other father. He produces it by his power; he governs and directs it, and makes what use he pleases of it. Even the small drops of the dew he distils upon the earth, as the God of nature; and, as the God of grace, he rains righteousness upon us and is himself as the dew unto Israel. See Hos 14:5, Hos 14:6; Mic 5:7.

(5.)The ice and the frost, by which the waters are congealed and the earth incrustrated, are produced by his providence, Job 38:29, Job 38:30. These are very common things, which lessens the strangeness of them. But, considering what a vast change is made by them in a very little time, how the waters are hid as with a stone, as with a grave-stone, laid upon them (so thick, so strong, is the ice that covers them), and the face even of the deep is sometimes frozen, we may well ask, "Out of whose womb came the ice? What created power could produce such a wonderful work?" No power but that of the Creator himself. Frost and snow come from him, and therefore should lead our thoughts and meditations to him who does such great things, past finding out. And we shall the more easily bear the inconveniences of winter-weather if we learn to make this good use of it.

2.How weak man is. Can he do such things as these? Could Job? No, v. 34, 35.

(1.)He cannot command one shower of rain for the relief of himself or his friends: "Canst thou lift up thy voice to the clouds, those bottles of heaven, that abundance of waters may cover thee, to water thy fields when they are dry and parched?" If we lift up our voice to God, to pray for rain, we may have it (Zac 10:1); but if we lift up our voice to the clouds, to demand it, they will soon tell us they are not at our beck, and we shall go without it, Jer 14:22. The heavens will not her the earth unless God hear them, Hos 2:21. See what poor, indigent, depending creatures we are; we cannot do without rain, nor can we have it when we will.

(2.)He cannot commission one flash of lightning, if he had a mind to make use of it for the terror of his enemies (Job 38:35): "Canst thou send lightnings, that they may go on thy errand, and do the execution thou desirest? Will they come at thy call, and say unto thee, Here we are?" No, the ministers of God's wrath will not be ministers of ours. Why should they, since the wrath of man works not the righteousness of God? See Luk 9:55.

II.God has the stars of heaven under his command and cognizance, but we have them not under ours.

Our meditations are now to rise higher, far above the clouds, to the glorious lights above. God mentions particularly, not the planets, which move in lower orbs, but the fixed stars, which are much higher. It is supposed that they have an influence upon this earth, notwithstanding their vast distance, not upon the minds of men or the events of providence (men's fate is not determined by their stars), but upon the ordinary course of nature; they are set for signs and seasons, for days and years, Gen 1:14. And if the stars have such a dominion over this earth (Job 38:33), though they have their place in the heavens and are but mere matter, much more has he who is their Maker and ours, and who is an Eternal Mind. Now see how weak we are.

1.We cannot alter the influences of the stars (Job 38:31), not theirs that are instrumental to produce the pleasures of the spring: Canst thou loose the bands of Orion? - that magnificent constellation which makes so great a figure (none greater), and dispenses rough and unpleasing influences, which we cannot control nor repel. Both summer and winter will have their course. God can change them when he pleases, can make the spring cold, and so bind the sweet influences of Pleiades, and the winter warm, and so loose the bands of Orion; but we cannot.

2.It is not in our power to order the motions of the stars, nor are we entrusted with the guidance of them. God, who calls the stars by their names (Psa 147:4), calls them forth in their respective seasons, appointing them the time of their rising and setting. But this is not our province; we cannot bring forth Mazzaroth - the stars in the southern signs, nor guide Arcturus - those in the northern, Job 38:32. God can bring forth the stars to battle (as he did when in their courses they fought against Sisera) and guide them in the attacks they are ordered to make; but man cannot do so.

3.We are not only unconcerned in the government of the stars (the government they are under, and the government they are entrusted with, for they both rule and are ruled), but utterly unacquainted with it; we know not the ordinances of heaven, Job 38:33. So far are we from being able to change them that we can give no account of them; they are a secret to us. Shall we then pretend to know God's counsels, and the reasons of them? If it were left to us to set the dominion of the stars upon the earth, we should soon be at a loss. Shall we then teach God how to govern the world?

III.God is the author and giver, the father and fountain, of all wisdom and understanding, Job 38:36.

The souls of men are nobler and more excellent beings than the stars of heaven themselves, and shine more brightly. The powers and faculties of reason with which man is endued, and the wonderful performances of thought, bring him into some alliance to the blessed angels; and whence comes this light, but from the Father of lights? Who else has put wisdom into the inner parts of man, and given understanding to the heart?

1.The rational soul itself, and its capacities, come from him as the God of nature; for he forms the spirit of man within him. We did not make our own souls, nor can we describe how they act, nor how they are united to our bodies. He only that made them knows them, and knows how to manage them. He fashioneth men's hearts alike in some things, and yet unlike in others.

2.True wisdom, with its furniture and improvement, comes from him as the God of grace and the Father of every good and perfect gift. Shall we pretend to be wiser than God, when we have all our wisdom from him? Nay, shall we pretend to be wise above our sphere, and beyond the limits which he that gave us our understanding sets to it? He designed we should with it serve God and do our duty, but never intended we should with it set up for directors of the stars or the lightning.

IV.God has the clouds under his cognizance and government, but so have not we, Job 38:37.

Can any man, with all his wisdom, undertake to number the clouds, or (as it may be read) to declare and describe the nature of them? Though they are near us, in our own atmosphere, yet we know little more of them than of the stars which are at so great a distance. And when the clouds have poured down rain in abundance, so that the dust grows into solid mire and the clods cleave fast together (Job 38:38), who can stay the bottles of heaven? Who can stop them, that it may not always rain? The power and goodness of God are herein to be acknowledged, that he gives the earth rain enough, but does not surfeit it, softens it, but does not drown it, makes it fit for the plough, but not unfit for the seed. As we cannot command a shower of rain, so we cannot command a fair day, without God; so necessary, so constant, is our dependence upon him.

V.God provides food for the inferior creatures, and it is by his providence, not by any care or pains of ours, that they are fed.

The following chapter is wholly taken up with the instances of God's power and goodness about animals, and therefore some transfer to it the last three verses of this chapter, which speak of the provision made,

1.For the lions, Job 38:39, Job 38:40. "Thou dost not pretend that the clouds and stars have any dependence upon thee, for they are above thee; but on the earth thou thinkest thyself paramount; let us try that then: Wilt thou hunt the prey for the lion? Thou valuest thyself upon thy possessions of cattle which thou wast once owner of, the oxen, and asses, and camels, that were fed at thy crib; but wilt thou undertake the maintenance of the lions, and the young lions, when they couch in their dens, waiting for a prey? No, needest not do it, they can shift for themselves without thee: thou canst not do it, for thou hast not wherewithal to satisfy them: thou darest not do it; shouldst thou come to feed them, they would seize upon thee. But I do it." See the all-sufficiency of the divine providence: it has wherewithal to satisfy the desire of every living thing, even the most ravenous. See the bounty of the divine Providence, that, wherever it has given life, it will give livelihood, even to those creatures that are not only not serviceable, but dangerous, to man. And see its sovereignty, that it suffers some creatures to be killed for the support of other creatures. The harmless sheep are torn to pieces, to fill the appetite of the young lions, who yet sometimes are made to lack and suffer hunger, to punish them for their cruelty, while those that fear God want no good thing.

2.For the young ravens, Job 38:41. As ravenous beasts, so ravenous birds, are fed by the divine Providence. Who but God provides for the raven his food? Man does not; he takes care only of those creatures that are, or may be, useful to him. But God has a regard to all the works of his hands, even the meanest and least valuable. The ravens' young ones are in a special manner necessitous, and God supplies them, Psa 147:9. God's feeding the fowls, especially these fowls (Mat 6:26), is an encouragement to us to trust him for our daily bread. See here,

(1.)What distress the young ravens are often in: They wander for lack of meat. The old ones, they say, neglect them, and do not provide for them as other birds do for their young: and indeed those that are ravenous to others are commonly barbarous to their own, and unnatural.

(2.)What they are supposed to do in that distress: They cry, for they are noisy clamorous creatures, and this is interpreted as crying to God. It being the cry of nature, it is looked upon as directed to the God of nature. The putting of so favourable a construction as this upon the cries of the young ravens may encourage us in our prayers, though we can but cry, Abba, Father.

(3.)What God does for them. Some way or other he provides for them, so that they grow up, and come to maturity. And he that takes this care of the young ravens certainly will not be wanting to his people or theirs. This, being but one instance of many of the divine compassion, may give us occasion to think how much good our God does, every day, beyond what we are aware of.

Copy as

Historical interpretation

Two Centuries of Reception

2 surviving comments on this verse. Each one is dated, so this reads as a timeline rather than a list.

2 quotes · AD 604–850
Post-NiceneEarly Medieval
600700800

Select a marker to jump to its quote. Markers stagger vertically where authors wrote within a few decades of each other.

AD 604Gregory the DialogistEarly Medieval
9. Who else are designated in this place by the name of the cock, but these same holy preachers, mentioned again in another way, who strive amid the darkness of this present life to announce by their preaching, as if by their notes, the approaching light? For they say; the night is far spent, but the day is at hand. [Rom. 13, 12] Who by their voices arouse the sleep of our sluggishness, exclaiming; It is now the hour for us to arise from sleep. [ib. 11] And again; Awake, ye righteous, and sin not. [1 Cor. 15, 34] Of this cock it is written again; There be three things that go well, and a fourth which goeth prosperously: a lion, the strongest of beasts, will not be afraid at the onset of any; a cock girt in the loins; and a ram, whom there is no king who can resist. [Prov. 30, 29-31] For He is in this place mentioned as a lion, of Whom it is written; The lion of the tribe of Judah hath prevailed, [Rev, 5, 5] Who is called the strongest of beasts, because in Him the weakness of God is stronger than men. Who is not afraid at the onset of any one; for He says; The prince of this world cometh, and hath nothing in Me. [John 14, 30] The cock girt in the loins, that is, holy preachers announcing the true morn amid the darkness of this night. Who are girt in the loins, because they keep away from their members the looseness of lust. For it is in the loins in truth that there is lust. Whence it is said to the same persons by the Lord: Let your loins he girt about. [Luke 12, 35] And a ram, whom there is no king who can resist. Whom else in this place do we understand by a ram, but the first rank of priests in the Church? Of whom it is written: Bring to the Lord the offspring of rams; [Ps. 29, 1] who lead the people which is walking after their examples like a flock of sheep following them. And whom, if they live spiritually and rightly, no king is at all able to resist; because whatever persecutor may stand in their way, he is not able to hinder their intention. For they know both how to run anxiously to Him, Whom they long for, and to come to Him by dying. The lion is therefore placed first, the cock second, the ram last. For Christ appeared, next the holy preachers, the Apostles, and then at length the spiritual fathers, the rulers of the Churches, the leaders, namely, of the flocks, because they are the teachers of the peoples who follow them.
10. But we enforce these points still better, if we subjoin an exposition of the remainder of the same passage. For since after these things Antichrist will also appear, he added there a fourth point, saying; And he who appeared a fool, after he had been lifted up on high. For if he had understood, he would have laid his hand on his mouth. [Prov. 30, 32] For he in truth will he lifted up on high when he will feign that he is God. But he will appear a fool when lifted up on high, because he will fail in his very loftiness through the coming of the true Judge. But if he had understood this, he would have laid his hand on his mouth: that is, if he had foreseen his punishment, when he began to be proud, having been once fashioned aright, he would not have been raised up to the boastfulness of such great pride. And let not that move us which has been said of him above; A fourth, which goeth prosperously. For he said that three went well, and a fourth prosperously. For not every thing which goeth ‘prosperously’ goeth ‘well,’ nor in this life does every thing which goeth ‘well,’ go ‘prosperously.’ For a lion, a cock, and a ram, go indeed well: but not prosperously here, for they suffer the assaults of persecutions. But the fourth goeth prosperously, and not well: because Antichrist will go on in his craft, but his craft will be prosperous for a short space of this present life, as was said of him under the person of Antiochus by Daniel; Strength was given him against the continual sacrifice by reason of transgression, and truth shall be cast down in the earth, and he shall do and shall prosper. [Dan. 8, 12] That which Solomon says, goeth prosperously: this Daniel says, shall prosper. According to this testimony therefore which is stated by Solomon, A cock girt in its loins, we fitly understood in this place also holy preachers by the cock. The Lord therefore referring all things to Himself, says; Who hath placed wisdom in the inward parts of a man? or who hath given the cock understanding? As if He were saying, Who hath infused into the heart of a man, who savours of human things, the grace of heavenly wisdom? Or who, but Myself, hath given understanding even to holy preachers themselves, to know when, or to whom, they ought to announce the coming morn? For they understand both what to do, and when, for the very reason that they know it, through My revealing it, within. But it must he observed, that divinely inspired wisdom is placed in the inward parts of a man; because, doubtless, as far as concerns the number of the Elect, it is given not in voices only, but also in the thoughts, in order that the conscience may live according to what the tongue speaks, and that its light may shine forth the more brightly on the surface, the more truly it glows in the heart.
11. But it is a matter of great labour to examine with still more minute exposition, that which is added; Or who hath given the cock understanding? For the understanding of teachers ought to be the more subtle, the more it exercises itself in penetrating things invisible, the more it discusses nothing material, the more, even when speaking by the voice of the body, it transcends every thing which is of the body. For it would not, in truth, be at all suited to the loftiest subjects, did not the Creator Himself of things above, bestow it on the cock which crows, that is, on the teacher who preaches. The cock also received understanding, first to distinguish the hours of the night season, and then at last to utter the awakening voice. Because, in truth, every holy preacher first considers in his hearers the quality of their life, and afterwards frames the voice of preaching, fitted to instruct them. For to decide on the qualities of sins is, as it were, to distinguish the hours of night, to reprove the darknesses of actions with fit voices of reproof is, as it were, to distinguish the hours of night. Understanding is therefore given to the cock from above, because to the teacher of truth there is given from above the virtue of discretion, for him to know to whom, what, when, or how to introduce his instruction.
12. For one and the same exhortation is not suited to all; because the same kind of habits does not bind all. For those things that benefit some, often hurt others. For frequently even herbs, which refresh some animals, kill others, and a gentle hiss pacifies horses, urges on dogs; and medicine which lessens one disease, gives strength to another: and bread which strengthens the life of the strong, destroys that of the young. The speech therefore of teachers ought to he fashioned according to the quality of the hearers, in order to suit each class according to their own case, and yet never to fail in the art of general edification. For what are the attentive minds of hearers, but certain strings which are strained tight in a harp? which the skilful performer touches in different ways, that they may not produce a discordant sound. And the strings give back an harmonious sound, because they are struck with one plectrum, but with different force. Whence also every teacher, in order to build up all in one virtue of charity, ought not to touch the hearts of his hearers with one and the same exhortation.
13. For men must he admonished in one way, and women in another; the young in one way, the old in another; in one way the poor, and in another the rich; in one way the cheerful, and in another the gloomy; in one way subjects, in another rulers; in one way servants, in another masters; in one way the wise of this world, in another the dull; in one way the shameless, in another the modest; in one way the insolent, in another the retiring; in one way the impatient, in another the patient; in one way the well-wishing, in another the envious; in one way the pure, in another the unclean; in one way the healthy, in another the sick; in one way those who fear the rod, and therefore live innocently, in another way those who have become so hardened in iniquity, as not to be corrected by the rod; in one way those who are over silent, in another those who give themselves to much talking; in one way the timid, in another the bold; in one way the sluggish, in another the hasty; in one way the gentle, in another the angry; in one way the humble, in another the haughty; in one way the obstinate, in another the inconstant; in one way the gluttonous, in another the abstinent; in one way those who mercifully give away their own, in another those who strive to seize others’ goods; in one way those who neither seize the goods of others, nor yet give away their own; and in another those who both give away their own goods which they have, and desist not from seizing those of others; in one way those who are at variance, in another those who are reconciled; in one way those who sow strifes, in another the peaceful. Those who do not rightly understand the words of the sacred Law must be admonished in one way, in another those who understand them rightly, but speak not of them humbly; in one way those who though they are able to preach in a worthy manner, are afraid from excessive humility, in another those whom imperfection or age excludes from preaching, and whom yet precipitation urges on; in one way those who prosper in their temporal desires, in another way those who desire indeed the things of the world, but who yet are wearied with the toil of adversity: in one way those who are bound in wedlock, in another way those who are free from the bonds of wedlock; in one way those who have had experience of carnal commixtion, in another way those who are ignorant of it; in one way those who deplore the sins of their deeds, in another those who deplore the sins of their thoughts; in one way those who lament their sins and yet do not abandon them, in another those who abandon but yet do not lament them: in one way those who even praise the unlawful deeds which they commit, in another those who blame their misdeeds, and yet do not avoid them; in one way those who are overcome with sudden concupiscence, in another those who are deliberately fettered with sin; in one way those who commit frequently unlawful deeds though most trifling, and in another those who guard themselves against trifling faults but are sometimes overwhelmed in grievous ones; in one way those who do not even begin good courses, in another those who do not complete what they have begun; in one way those who sin secretly and do right publicly, in another those who conceal the good deeds which they do, and who yet by some things they do publicly allow people to think evil of them. We ought indeed to mention minutely what course of advice should be observed in each particular case, but are hindered by fear of prolixity in our remarks. [S. Greg. Naz. Or. 2. §. 28.] But we are anxious to carry that out in another work [The ‘Pastorale.’], by God’s help, if some small portion of this painful life still remains to us.
14. But we have another point which we ought to consider concerning this understanding of the cock, namely, that it is accustomed to utter its louder and longer-drawn strains in the deeper hours of the night, and that when the hour of morn is now approaching, it utters altogether more gentle and feeble notes. And a consideration of the discretion of preachers shows us what the understanding of this cock in these respects suggests to us. For when they are preaching to minds which are still wicked, they declare the terrors of eternal judgment with loud and great voices, because, namely, they cry out, as it were, in the darkness of the profound night. But when they know that the light of truth is already present to the hearts of their hearers, they turn the loudness of their cry into the gentleness of sweetness; and bring forth, not so much the terrors of punishment, as the allurements of rewards. And they sing at that time even with diminished tones, because as the morn approaches, they preach all the subtlest mysteries, that their followers may hear more minutely of heavenly things, the nearer they approach to the light of truth, and that the shorter note of the cock may charm those when awake, whom its long drawn note had aroused from sleep; in order that every one who has been corrected, may delight in knowing minutely the sweets of heaven, who used before to dread adversities from the judgment. Which is well expressed by Moses, when the trumpets are ordered to sound a shorter note, for the summoning forth the host. For it is written, Make thee two trumpets of beaten silver. [Numb. 10, 2] And a little after, When a short blast hath sounded, the camp shall be moved. [ib. 5] For the army is led by two trumpets, because the people is called by two precepts of charity to the girding of faith. But they are commanded to be made of silver, in order that the words of preachers may be clear with the brightness of light, and may not confuse the mind of their hearers, by any obscurity of their own. But to be hammered out, for this reason; because it is necessary that they who preach the life to come, should grow up by the blows of present tribulations. But it is well said, When the short blast hath sounded, the camp shall be moved: doubtless, because when the word of preaching is more subtilly and minutely enforced, the hearts of the hearers are more warmly excited to meet the contests of temptations.
15. But there is something else to be carefully observed in the cock, namely, that when it is preparing to utter its note, it first flaps its wings, and striking itself, makes itself more wakeful. And this we behold plainly, if we look carefully at the life of holy preachers. For they, when they utter the words of preaching, first exercise themselves in holy actions, that they may not, while themselves slothful in act, arouse others with their voice. But they first rouse themselves by lofty deeds, and then they render others anxious for well-doing. They first strike themselves with the wings of their thoughts, because whatever is slumbering uselessly within them, they discover by anxious examination, they correct with severe punishment. They first take care to punish their own faults by tears, and then denounce those doings of others which demand punishment. They flap with their wings, therefore, before they utter their song, because, before they put forth the words of exhortation, they proclaim by their deeds all that they intend to say: and when they are perfectly awake in themselves, they then summon others who are slumbering to awake.
16. But whence is this great wisdom of the teacher, that he is both perfectly awake in himself, and that he also summons the slumberers to awake with a certain elevation of voice; that he first carefully dispels the darkness of sins, and afterwards manifests discreetly the light of preaching, that he suits each one singly, in manner and in time, and that he shows to all at the same time the result of their doings? Whence is it directed to such great subjects, and with such subtlety, unless it be taught inwardly by Him, by Whom it was created? Because then the credit of such great understanding is not the merit of the preacher, but of his Creator, it is rightly said by the same Creator, Or who hath given the cock understanding? As if He were saying, Except Myself, Who have instructed the minds of teachers, which I marvellously fashioned out of nothing, more marvellously, to understand those things which are secret. Whence also, to show that He is not only the Inspirer of wisdom in the sayings of teachers, but also the Author of their words
AD 850Ishodad of MervEarly MedievalSourceCOMMENTARY ON JOB 38:36
The words “Who has put wisdom in the inwards parts?” means who else [but God] has secretly put the wisdom of reason in the souls of mortals?
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Job 38:36 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8