Skip to content
Translation
King James Version
Remember ye not, that, when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
Remember ye G3421 not G3756, that G3754, when I was G5607 yet G2089 with G4314 you G5209, I told G3004 you G5213 these things G5023?
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
Don’t you remember that when I was still with you, I used to tell you these things?
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
Do you not remember that I told you these things while I was still with you?
Ask
American Standard Version
Remember ye not, that, when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
Don’t you remember that, when I was still with you, I told you these things?
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
Remember ye not, that when I was yet with you, I tolde you these things?
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
Do ye not remember that, being yet with you, these things I said to you?
Ask

Study This Verse

SUMMARY

In 2 Thessalonians 2:5, the Apostle Paul issues a poignant rhetorical question to the believers in Thessalonica, serving as a gentle yet firm reminder of the crucial eschatological truths he had previously taught them during his initial visit. This verse underscores Paul's consistent pastoral care and his foundational commitment to grounding the church in sound doctrine, particularly in the face of confusion and false teachings concerning the timing and nature of the Day of the Lord.

CONTEXT

  • Literary Context: This verse is situated within Paul's second epistle to the Thessalonians, specifically in chapter 2, where he addresses the church's profound distress over eschatological matters. The preceding verses 2 Thessalonians 2:1-2 reveal that false teachings, possibly even forged letters purporting to be from Paul, had convinced some believers that the "Day of the Lord" had already arrived. This misconception led to significant alarm and a disruption of their daily lives. Paul's immediate response in 2 Thessalonians 2:3-4 is to provide a clear sequence of events that must precede the Day of the Lord: a great "falling away" (apostasy) and the revelation of the "man of lawlessness" (the Antichrist). Verse 5 then serves as a direct appeal to their memory, reinforcing that these were not new revelations but consistent teachings delivered orally when he was physically present with them, thereby validating his current written instruction against the deceptive rumors.
  • Historical & Cultural Context: The church in Thessalonica was a relatively young community, founded by Paul during his second missionary journey Acts 17:1-9. They were a Gentile church, recently converted from idolatry, and facing significant persecution from both Jewish and Gentile opposition 1 Thessalonians 1:9-10. This persecution, combined with a fervent expectation of Christ's return, made them particularly susceptible to eschatological speculation and deception. False teachers, or perhaps well-meaning but misguided individuals, exploited this vulnerability by spreading misinformation about the Day of the Lord, leading some to believe it had already occurred, causing fear and idleness. Paul's letters to the Thessalonians, therefore, serve as crucial pastoral interventions, providing theological clarity, practical instruction, and encouragement to a church under duress, reminding them of the foundational truths he had laid down.
  • Key Themes: Paul's rhetorical question in 2 Thessalonians 2:5 contributes to several overarching themes in this epistle. Firstly, it highlights the Consistency and Authority of Apostolic Teaching. Paul emphasizes that his message about future events was not new information but a reiteration of what he had already taught them in person, underscoring the unchanging nature of divine revelation and the reliability of his apostolic witness. Secondly, it stresses the Importance of Remembering and Adhering to Sound Doctrine. The implied affirmative answer to his question serves as a gentle rebuke and a call to memory, urging the Thessalonians not to be easily shaken or deceived by every new teaching or rumor, especially concerning sensitive topics like the end times. This theme is echoed throughout the New Testament, emphasizing the need for believers to be grounded in truth. Lastly, the verse points to the theme of Preparation and Discernment Regarding Future Events. Paul's earlier instruction was designed to equip the believers with knowledge so they would not be caught off guard or deceived when these events began to unfold. His teaching provided a framework for understanding the sequence of events before the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, fostering spiritual stability rather than panic.

EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

Key Word Analysis

  • Remember (Greek, mnēmoneúō', G3421): This verb (G3421) signifies "to exercise memory, i.e. recollect; by implication, to punish; also to rehearse." In this context, it is a call to recollection, implying that the information was previously given and should have been retained. Paul is not introducing new doctrine but reminding them of established truth, appealing to their own memory as a basis for correcting their present confusion.
  • yet (Greek, éti', G2089): This adverb (G2089) means "still" or "yet" (of time or degree). Its inclusion emphasizes the continuity of Paul's presence and teaching. It highlights that the information was given while he was physically with them, reinforcing the direct, personal, and authoritative nature of his original instruction.
  • told (Greek, légō', G3004): This primary verb (G3004) means "to 'lay' forth, i.e. (figuratively) relate (in words (usually of systematic or set discourse...)); by implication, to mean." It suggests a deliberate, systematic imparting of information, not merely casual conversation. Paul's teaching was a structured discourse, designed for their understanding and retention, indicating the gravity and importance of the "things" he communicated.

Verse Breakdown

  • "Remember ye not,": This is a rhetorical question, characteristic of Paul's pedagogical style. It expects an affirmative answer ("Yes, we do remember!"). It is not a harsh accusation but a gentle, yet firm, pastoral prompting designed to jog their memory and draw them back to foundational truths. It implies a degree of forgetfulness or perhaps a failure to fully grasp the implications of his earlier teaching, which has now left them vulnerable to deception.
  • "that, when I was yet with you,": This clause establishes the timeframe and context of the original instruction. Paul grounds his current correction in his personal presence and direct teaching. The phrase "yet with you" emphasizes the continuity and recency of his physical presence, reinforcing the idea that these were not ancient, forgotten truths but relatively recent, vital instructions delivered face-to-face. This direct connection adds weight and authority to his reminder.
  • "I told you these things?": This final clause identifies the content of his previous communication. "These things" refers to the specific eschatological details Paul outlined in the preceding verses, particularly the necessity of the "falling away" and the revelation of the "man of lawlessness" before the Day of the Lord. Paul is appealing to their own recollection of his systematic teaching, demonstrating that the current confusion stems from a lapse in memory or attention to his established doctrine, rather than from a lack of prior instruction.

Literary Devices

The primary literary device employed in 2 Thessalonians 2:5 is a Rhetorical Question. Paul uses this technique not to elicit new information, but to prompt the Thessalonians to recall what they already know, thereby affirming the truth of his prior teaching and gently rebuking their forgetfulness or susceptibility to error. This question serves as a powerful form of Anamnesis (recollection), guiding the audience to remember and internalize past truths. Furthermore, there is an element of Apostolic Authority conveyed through this reminder; Paul, as their spiritual father and founder of their church, is appealing to his established credibility and the consistency of his message. The overall tone is one of Pastoral Concern, as Paul seeks to correct their misunderstanding and alleviate their distress by reminding them of the stable foundation he had already laid.

THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS

The theological weight of 2 Thessalonians 2:5 lies in its emphasis on the enduring importance of sound doctrine and the consistency of apostolic teaching. Paul's reminder underscores that Christian truth is not subject to shifting interpretations or the latest sensational rumor, but is grounded in the authoritative revelation delivered by God's appointed messengers. It highlights the pastoral responsibility to not only teach truth but also to reinforce it, ensuring believers are firmly rooted and not easily swayed by deception. This verse implicitly teaches that spiritual stability in times of confusion or persecution is directly tied to a faithful remembrance and application of previously received biblical instruction, particularly concerning critical eschatological events that shape our hope and understanding of God's sovereign plan.

REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

Paul's rhetorical question in 2 Thessalonians 2:5 resonates powerfully with believers today, serving as a vital call to spiritual vigilance and a firm grounding in truth. In an age saturated with information, often conflicting and sensational, the temptation to be "tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine" Ephesians 4:14 is ever-present. This verse reminds us that spiritual maturity involves not just hearing truth, but remembering it, internalizing it, and allowing it to shape our worldview and responses. It underscores the critical need for discernment, urging us to test all teachings against the consistent, foundational truths of Scripture, rather than being swayed by novel interpretations or fear-mongering. Just as Paul sought to anchor the Thessalonians in what they had already been taught, we are called to continually return to the wellspring of God's Word, allowing its unchanging truths to provide stability and clarity amidst life's uncertainties and the clamor of competing voices. Our spiritual resilience depends on our commitment to remembering and living by the sound doctrine we have received.

Questions for Reflection

  • What foundational truths about Christ or the Christian life have I learned but perhaps forgotten or neglected in my daily walk?
  • How susceptible am I to new teachings or rumors, especially concerning complex topics like the end times, if they contradict what I've been taught from Scripture?
  • In what ways can I more intentionally "remember" and internalize biblical truths so that they provide stability and discernment in my life?
  • How does my engagement with sound biblical teaching contribute to my resistance against deception and anxiety?

FAQ

What "things" did Paul tell the Thessalonians that he expected them to remember?

Answer: The "things" Paul expected the Thessalonians to remember primarily refer to the sequence of events leading up to the Day of the Lord, which he had taught them orally during his initial ministry in Thessalonica. Specifically, these "things" include the necessity of a great "falling away" or apostasy, and the revelation of the "man of lawlessness" (also known as the Antichrist), before the actual Day of the Lord would commence. Paul reiterates these points in 2 Thessalonians 2:3-4, clarifying that these events must unfold before Christ's return and the Day of the Lord, thereby correcting their mistaken belief that it had already arrived. His previous teaching was meant to provide a clear framework for understanding future eschatological developments, preventing them from being deceived or unduly alarmed.

CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT

While 2 Thessalonians 2:5 speaks of remembering past instruction, its ultimate fulfillment and significance are deeply rooted in Christ. The "things" Paul taught were not merely abstract eschatological details but pointed to the climactic return of Jesus Christ, who is the central figure of all prophecy and the ultimate hope of believers. The "Day of the Lord" is fundamentally the Day of Christ, when He will return in glory to establish His eternal kingdom, defeat all opposing forces, and gather His elect 2 Thessalonians 1:7-10. Paul's instruction, therefore, was designed to prepare the Thessalonians for His coming, ensuring they would not be caught off guard or deceived but would remain steadfast in their faith in Him. Christ Himself taught His disciples about future events, urging them to be watchful and prepared Matthew 24:36-44. Thus, remembering Paul's teaching is ultimately about remembering the sovereign plan of God, which culminates in the triumph and reign of Jesus Christ, the one who holds all things together and in whom all prophecies find their "Yes and Amen" 2 Corinthians 1:20. The entire eschatological narrative, including the warnings about apostasy and the man of lawlessness, serves to highlight the absolute necessity and ultimate victory of Christ as Lord over all history and creation.

Copy as

Commentary on 2 Thessalonians 2 verses 3–12

I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points

In these words the apostle confutes the error against which he had cautioned them, and gives the reasons why they should not expect the coming of Christ as just at hand. There were several events previous to the second coming of Christ; in particular, he tells them there would be,

I. A general apostasy, there would come a falling away first, Th2 2:3. By this apostasy we are not to understand a defection in the state, or from civil government, but in spiritual or religious matters, from sound doctrine, instituted worship and church government, and a holy life. The apostle speaks of some very great apostasy, not only of some converted Jews or Gentiles, but such as should be very general, though gradual, and should give occasion to the revelation of rise of antichrist, that man of sin. This, he says (Th2 2:5), he had told them of when he was with them, with design, no doubt, that they should not take offence nor be stumbled at it. And let us observe that no sooner was Christianity planted and rooted in the world than there began to be a defection in the Christian church. It was so in the Old Testament church; presently after any considerable advance made in religion there followed a defection: soon after the promise there was revolting; for example, soon after men began to call upon the name of the Lord all flesh corrupted their way, - soon after the covenant with Noah the Babel-builders bade defiance to heaven, - soon after the covenant with Abraham his seed degenerated in Egypt, - soon after the Israelites were planted in Canaan, when the first generation was worn off, they forsook God and served Baal, - soon after God's covenant with David his seed revolted, and served other gods, - soon after the return out of captivity there was a general decay of piety, as appears by the story of Ezra and Nehemiah; and therefore it was no strange thing that after the planting of Christianity there should come a falling away.

II. A revelation of that man of sin, that is (Th2 2:3), antichrist would take his rise from this general apostasy. The apostle afterwards speaks of the revelation of that wicked one (Th2 2:8), intimating the discovery which should be made of his wickedness, in order to his ruin: here he seems to speak of his rise, which should be occasioned by the general apostasy he had mentioned, and to intimate that all sorts of false doctrines and corruptions should centre in him. Great disputes have been as to who or what is intended by this man of sin and son of perdition: and, if it be not certain that the papal power and tyranny are principally or only intended, yet this is plain, What is here said does very exactly agree thereto. For observe,

1.The names of this person, or rather the state and power here spoken of. He is called the man of sin, to denote his egregious wickedness; not only is he addicted to, and practises, wickedness himself, but he also promotes, countenances, and commands sin and wickedness in others; and he is the son of perdition, because he himself is devoted to certain destruction, and is the instrument of destroying many others both in soul and body. These names may properly be applied, for these reasons, to the papal state; and thereto agree also,

2.The characters here given, Th2 2:4. (1.) That he opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God, or is worshipped; and thus have the bishops of Rome not only opposed God's authority, and that of the civil magistrates, who are called gods, but have exalted themselves above God and earthly governors, in demanding greater regard to their commands than to the commands of God or the magistrate. (2.) As God, he sits in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God. As God was in the temple of old, and worshipped there, and is in and with his church now, so the antichrist here mentioned is some usurper of God's authority in the Christian church, who claims divine honours; and to whom can this better apply than to the bishops of Rome, to whom the most blasphemous titles have been given, as Dominus Deus noster papa - Our Lord God the pope; Deus alter in terr - Another God on earth; Idem est dominium Dei et papae - The dominion of God and the pope is the same?

3.His rise is mentioned, Th2 2:6, Th2 2:7. Concerning this we are to observe two things: - (1.) There was something that hindered or withheld, or let, until it was taken away. This is supposed to be the power of the Roman empire, which the apostle did not think fit to mention more plainly at that time; and it is notorious that, while this power continued, it prevented the advances of the bishops of Rome to that height of tyranny to which soon afterwards they arrived. (2.) This mystery of iniquity was gradually to arrive at its height; and so it was in effect that the universal corruption of doctrine and worship in the Romish church came in by degrees, and the usurpation of the bishops of Rome was gradual, not all at once; and thus the mystery of iniquity did the more easily, and almost insensibly, prevail. The apostle justly calls it a mystery of iniquity, because wicked designs and actions were concealed under false shows and pretences, at least they were concealed from the common view and observation. By pretended devotion, superstition and idolatry were advanced; and, by a pretended zeal for God and his glory, bigotry and persecution were promoted. And he tells us that this mystery of iniquity did even then begin, or did already work. While the apostles were yet living, the enemy came, and sowed tares; there were then the deeds of the Nicolaitans, persons who pretended zeal for Christ, but really opposed him. Pride, ambition, and worldly interest of church-pastors and church-rulers, as in Diotrephes and others, were the early working of the mystery of iniquity, which, by degrees, came to that prodigious height which has been visible in the church of Rome.

4.The fall or ruin of the antichristian state is declared, Th2 2:8. The head of this antichristian kingdom is called that wicked one, or that lawless person who sets up a human power in competition with, and contradiction to, the divine dominion and power of the Lord Jesus Christ; but, as he would thus manifest himself to be the man of sin, so the revelation or discovery of this to the world would be the sure presage and the means of his ruin. The apostle assures the Thessalonians that the Lord would consume and destroy him; the consuming of him precedes his final destruction, and that is by the Spirit of his mouth, by his word of command; the pure word of God, accompanied with the Spirit of God, will discover this mystery of iniquity, and make the power of antichrist to consume and waste away; and in due time it will be totally and finally destroyed, and this will be by the brightness of Christ's coming. Note, The coming of Christ to destroy the wicked will be with peculiar glory and eminent lustre and brightness.

5.The apostle further describes the reign and rule of this man of sin. Here we are to observe, (1.) The manner of his coming, or ruling, and working: in general, that it is after the example of Satan, the grand enemy of souls, the great adversary of God and man. He is the great patron of error and lies, the sworn enemy of the truth as it is in Jesus and all the faithful followers of Jesus. More particularly, it is with Satanical power and deceit. A divine power is pretended for the support of this kingdom, but it is only after the working of Satan. Signs and wonders, visions and miracles, are pretended; by these the papal kingdom was first set up, and has all along been kept up, but they have false signs to support false doctrines; and lying wonders, or only pretended miracles that have served their cause, things false in fact, or fraudulently managed, to impose upon the people: and the diabolical deceits with which the antichristian state has been supported are notorious. The apostle calls it all deceivableness of unrighteousness, Th2 2:10. Others may call them pious frauds, but the apostle called them unrighteous and wicked frauds; and, indeed, all fraud (which is contrary to truth) is an impious thing. Many are the subtle artifices the man of sin has used, and various are the plausible pretences by which he had beguiled unwary and unstable souls to embrace false doctrines, and submit to his usurped dominion. (2.) The persons are described who are his willing subjects, or most likely to become such, Th2 2:10. They are such as love not the truth that they may be saved. They heard the truth (it may be), but they did not love it; they could not bear sound doctrine, and therefore easily imbibed false doctrines; they had some notional knowledge of what was true, but they indulged some powerful prejudices, and so became a prey to seducers. Had they loved the truth, they would have persevered in it, and been preserved by it; but no wonder if they easily parted with what they never had any love to. And of these persons it is said that they perish or are lost; they are in a lost condition, and in danger to be lost for ever. For,

6.We have the sin and ruin of the subjects of antichrist's kingdom declared, Th2 2:11, Th2 2:12. (1.) Their sin is this: They believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness: they did not love the truth, and therefore they did not believe it; and, because they did not believe the truth, therefore they had pleasure in unrighteousness, or in wicked actions, and were pleased with false notions. Note, An erroneous mind and vicious life often go together and help forward one another. (2.) Their ruin is thus expressed: God shall send them strong delusions, to believe a lie. Thus he will punish men for their unbelief, and for their dislike of the truth and love to sin and wickedness; not that God is the author of sin, but in righteousness he sometimes withdraws his grace from such sinners as are here mentioned; he gives them over to Satan, or leaves them to be deluded by his instruments; he gives them up to their own hearts' lusts, and leaves them to themselves, and then sin will follow of course, yea, the worst of wickedness, that shall end at last in eternal damnation. God is just when he inflicts spiritual judgments here, and eternal punishments hereafter, upon those who have no love to the truths of the gospel, who will not believe them, nor live suitably to them, but indulge false doctrines in their minds, and wicked practices in their lives and conversations.

Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Commentary on the Whole Bible. This section covers verses 3–12. Public domain.
Copy as
Apostolic ConstitutionsAD 380
Apostolic Constitutions (Book VII), Section 2, XXXII
For in the last days false prophets shall be multiplied, and such as corrupt the word; and the sheep shall be changed into wolves, and love into hatred: for through the abounding of iniquity the love of many shall wax cold. For men shall hate, and persecute, and betray one another. And then shall appear the deceiver of the world, the enemy of the truth, the prince of lies, [2 Thessalonians 2:3-12] whom the Lord Jesus "shall destroy with the spirit of His mouth, who takes away the wicked with His lips; and many shall be offended at Him. But they that endure to the end, the same shall be saved. And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven;" [Isaiah 11:4; Matthew 24:1-51] and afterwards shall be the voice of a trumpet by the archangel; and in that interval shall be the revival of those that were asleep. And then shall the Lord come, and all His saints with Him, with a great concussion above the clouds, with the angels of His power, [Matthew 16:27] in the throne of His kingdom, to condemn the devil, the deceiver of the world, and to render to every one according to his deeds. "Then shall the wicked go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous shall go into life eternal," [Matthew 25:46] to inherit those things "which eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor have entered into the heart of man, such things as God has prepared for them that love Him;" [1 Corinthians 2:9] and they shall rejoice in the kingdom of God, which is in Christ Jesus.
John ChrysostomAD 407
Homily on 2 Thessalonians 3
"Remember ye not, that when I was yet with you, I told you these things?"

Seest thou that it is necessary continually to say the same things, and to enlarge upon them in the same words? For behold, they heard him saying these things when present, and again they had need to be reminded of them. For as when they had heard concerning afflictions, "For verily," he says, "when we were with you, we told you beforehand that we are to suffer affliction"; they nevertheless forgot it, and he confirms them again by letters; so also having heard concerning the Coming of Christ, they again needed letters to compose them. He therefore reminds them, showing that he speaks of nothing strange, but what he had always said.

For as in the case of husbandmen, the seeds are indeed cast into the earth once for all, yet do not constantly remain, but require much preparation withal, and if they do not break up the earth, and cover over the seeds sown, they sow for the birds that gather grain; so we also, unless by constant remembrance we cover over what has been sown, have but cast it all into the air. For both the devil carries it away, and our sloth destroys it, and the sun dries it up, and the rain washes it away, and the thorns choke it: so that it is not sufficient after once sowing it to depart, but there is need of much assiduity, driving off the birds, roofing up the thorns, filling up the stony ground with much earth, checking, and fencing off, and taking away everything injurious. But in the case of the earth all depends upon the husbandman, for it is a lifeless subject, and prepared only to be passive. But in the spiritual soil it is quite otherwise. All is not the teachers' part, but half at least, if not more, that of the disciples. It is our part indeed to cast the seed, but yours to do the things spoken for your recollection, by your works to show the fruits, to pull up the thorns by the roots.
Thietland of EinsiedelnAD 945
And, that is, Christ would not come unless the Antichrist came first.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying 2 Thessalonians 2:5 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.