Skip to content
Translation
King James Version
For this they willingly are ignorant of, that by the word of God the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water:
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
For G1063 this G5124 they G846 willingly G2309 are ignorant of G2990, that G3754 by the word G3056 of God G2316 the heavens G3772 were G2258 of old G1597, and G2532 the earth G1093 standing out G4921 of G1537 the water G5204 and G2532 in G1223 the water G5204:
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
But, wanting so much to be right about this, they overlook the fact that it was by God’s Word that long ago there were heavens, and there was land which arose out of water and existed between the waters,
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
But they deliberately overlook the fact that long ago by God’s word the heavens existed and the earth was formed out of water and by water,
Ask
American Standard Version
For this they wilfully forget, that there were heavens from of old, and an earth compacted out of water and amidst water, by the word of God;
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
For this they willfully forget, that there were heavens from of old, and an earth formed out of water and amid water, by the word of God;
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
For this they willingly know not, that the heauens were of olde, and the earth that was of the water and by the water, by the word of God.
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
for this is unobserved by them willingly, that the heavens were of old, and the earth out of water and through water standing together by the word of God,
Ask

Study This Verse

SUMMARY

In 2 Peter 3:5, the Apostle Peter confronts a deliberate and culpable ignorance among those who scoff at the promise of Christ's return. He asserts that their skepticism stems not from a lack of evidence, but from a willful disregard for God's past, undeniable acts of creation and judgment. Peter reminds his readers that the heavens and the earth were formed "by the word of God," with the earth emerging from and sustained by water, a clear allusion to both the initial creation and the subsequent global flood, which serves as a powerful precedent for God's future intervention and judgment.

CONTEXT

  • Literary Context: This verse is a direct counter-argument to the scoffers introduced in the preceding verses of 2 Peter 3. Peter has just described their mocking question, "Where is the promise of his coming? For since the fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they were from the beginning of the creation." (2 Peter 3:4). Verse 5 begins with "For this they willingly are ignorant of," directly addressing the intellectual and spiritual posture of these mockers. Peter then immediately points to God's past actions – creation and the flood – as irrefutable evidence against their uniformitarian worldview, setting the stage for his argument in 2 Peter 3:6-7 that just as God judged the world by water, He will judge it by fire. The passage serves as a foundational defense of the certainty of Christ's second coming and the final judgment.
  • Historical & Cultural Context: Peter is writing to a diverse group of early Christians, likely facing internal doubts and external pressures from those who challenged the core tenets of their faith, including the parousia (Christ's return). The concept of "scoffers" (ἐμπαῖκται, empaiktai) implies a deliberate, derisive rejection of Christian hope, possibly influenced by Epicurean philosophies that denied divine intervention or a general skepticism born from the delay of Christ's return. The Old Testament narratives of creation (Genesis 1) and the global flood (Genesis 6-8) were foundational to Jewish and early Christian understanding of God's power and sovereignty. Peter leverages these well-known historical events, which were understood as direct divine interventions, to dismantle the scoffers' argument that "all things continue as they were." The reference to "the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water" would immediately evoke these foundational accounts for his audience.
  • Key Themes: This verse powerfully contributes to several key themes within 2 Peter. Firstly, it highlights the theme of Divine Sovereignty and Power, emphasizing that God is not a distant observer but an active agent in history, capable of both creation and judgment through His powerful word, as seen in Psalm 33:6. Secondly, it underscores the theme of Willful Ignorance vs. Divine Revelation. Peter asserts that the scoffers' error is not intellectual but volitional; they choose to ignore the clear evidence of God's past interventions, a stark contrast to the divine knowledge Peter encourages believers to pursue throughout his epistle (e.g., 2 Peter 1:3). Thirdly, the verse establishes a crucial link between Past Judgment and Future Judgment. By recalling the creation and the flood, Peter lays the groundwork for the argument that God's past acts of judgment (by water) are a precedent and guarantee for His future judgment (by fire), as explicitly stated in 2 Peter 3:7. This reinforces the Reliability of God's Promises, demonstrating that His word is not idle but has always been, and will always be, effective in bringing about His purposes.

EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

Key Word Analysis

  • Willingly (Greek, thelō, G2309): This word (G2309) signifies a deliberate choice, an active desire, or a conscious intention. It indicates that the scoffers' ignorance is not accidental or due to a lack of information, but rather a preference or a decision to disregard certain truths. It highlights the moral culpability of their skepticism; they want to be ignorant of these facts because they contradict their desired worldview or lifestyle.
  • Are ignorant of (Greek, lanthánō, G2990): This verb (G2990) means "to lie hid," "to escape notice," or "to be hidden from." When combined with "willingly," it forms a powerful phrase conveying a deliberate act of forgetting or ignoring. It's not merely that the facts are unknown to them, but that they actively suppress or choose not to acknowledge what should be obvious, effectively making themselves "hidden from" the truth.
  • Word (Greek, lógos, G3056): This term (G3056) is highly significant, referring to something said, a divine utterance, or even the mental faculty of reasoning. In this context, "the word of God" refers to God's authoritative, creative command. It emphasizes that creation was not an accidental or natural process, but a direct, intentional act of God's powerful speech, demonstrating His absolute sovereignty over the material world.

Verse Breakdown

  • "For this they willingly are ignorant of,": This opening clause immediately points to the core issue: the scoffers' ignorance is not passive but active and intentional. They have chosen to suppress or disregard a truth that is readily available and historically evident. This sets a moral framework for their disbelief, implying a rejection of God's authority rather than a simple intellectual misunderstanding.
  • "that by the word of God the heavens were of old,": Peter here provides the first foundational truth that the scoffers ignore: the origin of the cosmos. He asserts that the heavens (sky, universe) were not eternal or self-existent but were brought into being "of old" (from a long time ago) by the direct, creative "word of God." This echoes the Genesis creation account where God speaks and creation comes into existence (Genesis 1:3, 6, 9). It underscores God's omnipotence and His role as the sovereign Creator.
  • "and the earth standing out of the water and in the water:": This phrase alludes to two distinct but related aspects of God's interaction with water in creation and judgment. "Standing out of the water" refers to the initial separation of dry land from the waters during creation (Genesis 1:9-10), demonstrating God's power to form and order the world. "And in the water" likely refers to the waters above and below the earth (the "waters above the firmament" and subterranean waters), which were instrumental in the global flood. This dual reference to water serves as a bridge, connecting creation to the flood, setting up the argument in the next verse about the world perishing by water. It highlights water as both an element of creation and an instrument of divine judgment.

Literary Devices

Peter employs several literary devices to make his argument forceful. The central device is Allusion, specifically to the Creation Account in Genesis 1 and the Global Flood Narrative in Genesis 6-8. By referencing "the heavens were of old" and "the earth standing out of the water and in the water," Peter implicitly calls upon his audience's knowledge of these foundational Old Testament events, which serve as irrefutable historical precedents for God's direct intervention in the natural order. This is a powerful Argument from History, where past divine actions are used to validate future divine promises. Furthermore, Peter utilizes Contrast by juxtaposing the scoffers' "willing ignorance" with the clear, undeniable evidence of God's creative and destructive power. There is also an element of Irony in the scoffers' position; they claim to be rational, yet they deliberately ignore the most fundamental historical truths about the world's origin and God's past judgments.

THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS

The theological implications of 2 Peter 3:5 are profound, establishing a robust defense of God's sovereignty, the reliability of His word, and the certainty of future judgment. By grounding his argument in the historical acts of creation and the flood, Peter emphasizes that God is not bound by human expectations or natural uniformitarianism. His word, which brought the cosmos into existence and subsequently judged it by water, remains eternally potent and trustworthy. This divine power, demonstrated in the past, serves as the ultimate guarantee for the future promise of Christ's return and the new heavens and new earth. The scoffers' "willing ignorance" is thus a rejection of God's demonstrated character and His revealed truth, highlighting the moral dimension of unbelief.

REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

For believers today, 2 Peter 3:5 serves as a crucial reminder to guard against the insidious trap of "willing ignorance." In a world increasingly prone to skepticism and the dismissal of biblical truth, we are called to actively remember and affirm God's past actions. Our faith in Christ's promised return and the ultimate consummation of all things is not a blind hope but is firmly rooted in the historical reality of God's creative power and His justice demonstrated through events like the global flood. This verse challenges us to diligently study and recall God's interventions in history, allowing them to shape our worldview and strengthen our confidence in His future plans. It encourages us to live with an expectant readiness, grounded in the unshakeable truth of God's word, rather than being swayed by the prevailing doubts or secular narratives of our age. Our awareness of God's past acts should fuel our present obedience and future hope.

Questions for Reflection

  • In what areas of my life might I be "willingly ignorant" of God's truth, perhaps because it challenges my comfort or desires?
  • How does remembering God's power in creation and the flood strengthen my faith in His promises for the future?
  • What practical steps can I take to deepen my understanding of God's historical interventions and their relevance to today?
  • How can I lovingly and effectively address the skepticism of others, pointing them to the historical evidence of God's power and faithfulness?

FAQ

What does "willingly are ignorant of" truly mean in this context?

Answer: The phrase "willingly are ignorant of" (Greek: lanthánō thelontas) signifies a deliberate, intentional, and culpable suppression of truth. It's not a mere lack of information or an accidental oversight, but an active choice to disregard or forget facts that contradict one's desired worldview or lifestyle. The scoffers in Peter's day chose to ignore the clear historical evidence of God's creative and judgmental power, preferring a uniformitarian view that denied divine intervention. This highlights the moral dimension of their unbelief, suggesting a rebellion against God's authority rather than a simple intellectual deficiency. Peter implies that they knew, or should have known, these truths, but actively suppressed them.

How do creation and the flood relate to the promise of Christ's return?

Answer: Peter uses creation and the flood as powerful historical precedents to affirm the certainty of Christ's second coming and the final judgment. The scoffers argued that "all things continue as they were from the beginning of the creation" (2 Peter 3:4), implying that God does not intervene in history. Peter refutes this by pointing to two monumental interventions:

  1. Creation: God, by His powerful "word," brought the heavens and earth into existence "of old" (Genesis 1). This demonstrates His absolute power to initiate and transform the cosmos.
  2. The Flood: The earth, formed "out of the water and in the water," was subsequently "perished" by water in the global flood (2 Peter 3:6). This demonstrates God's willingness and power to judge humanity and drastically alter the physical world.
    These past acts of divine intervention serve as a guarantee that God is capable and willing to intervene again, bringing about Christ's promised return and the ultimate judgment by fire (2 Peter 3:7). The consistency of God's character and power across history validates His future promises.

CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT

While 2 Peter 3:5 primarily focuses on God the Father's creative and judgmental power, its implications find profound Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and work of Jesus. The "word of God" by which the heavens and earth were created is none other than the pre-existent Christ, the Logos of God, through whom all things were made (John 1:1-3; Colossians 1:16; Hebrews 1:2). Thus, the very power that brought the cosmos into being and judged the world by water is intrinsically linked to the Son. Furthermore, just as God intervened in the past, Christ Himself is the promised intervention for the future. He is the one who will return in power and glory to judge the living and the dead (Acts 17:31; 2 Timothy 4:1). The "new heavens and new earth" that Peter anticipates (2 Peter 3:13) are ultimately established by Christ, the Alpha and Omega, who makes all things new (Revelation 21:1-5). Therefore, the historical acts of creation and judgment, which scoffers willfully ignore, point forward to the ultimate and decisive intervention of God through His Son, Jesus Christ, who is both the agent of creation and the coming judge and restorer.

Copy as

Commentary on 2 Peter 3 verses 3–7

I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points

To quicken and excite us to a serious minding and firm adhering to what God has revealed to us by the prophets and apostles, we are told that there will be scoffers, men who will make a mock of sin, and of salvation from it. God's way of saving sinners by Jesus Christ is what men will scoff at, and that in the last days, under the gospel. This indeed may seem very strange, that the New Testament dispensation of the covenant of grace, which is spiritual and therefore more agreeable to the nature of God than the Old, should be ridiculed and reproached; but the spirituality and simplicity of New Testament worship are directly contrary to the carnal mind of man, and this accounts for what the apostle seems here to hint at, namely, that scoffers shall be more numerous and more bold in the last days than ever before. Though in all ages those who were born and walked after the flesh persecuted, reviled, and reproached those who were born and did walk after the Spirit, yet in the last days there will be a great improvement in the art and impudence of bantering serious godliness, and those who firmly adhere to the circumspection and self-denial which the gospel prescribes. This is what is mentioned as a thing well known to all Christians, and therefore they ought to reckon upon it, that they may not be surprised and shaken, as if some strange thing happened unto them. Now to prevent the true Christian's being overcome, when attacked by these scoffers, we are told,

I. What sort of persons they are: they walk after their own lusts, they follow the devices and desires of their own hearts, and carnal affections, not the dictates and directions of right reason and an enlightened well-informed judgment. This they do in the course of their conversation, they live as they list, and they speak as they list; it is not only their inward minds that are evil and opposite to God, as the mind of every unrenewed sinner is (Rom 8:7), alienated from God, ignorant of him, and averse to him; but they have grown to such a height of wickedness that they proclaim openly what is in the hearts of others who are yet carnal; they say, "Our tongues are our own, and our strength, and time, and who is lord over us? Who shall contradict or control us, or ever call us to an account for what we say or do?" And, as they scorn to be confined by any laws of God in their conversation, so neither will they bear that the revelation of God should dictate and prescribe to them what they are to believe; as they will walk in their own way, and talk their own language, so will they also think their own thoughts, and form principles which are altogether their own: here also their own lusts alone shall be consulted by them. None but such accomplished libertines as are here described can take a seat, at least they cannot sit in the seat of the scornful. "By this you shall know them, that you may the better be upon your guard against them."

II. We also are forewarned how far they will proceed: they will attempt to shake and unsettle us, even as to our belief of Christ's second coming; they will scoffingly say, Where is the promise of his coming? Pe2 3:4. Without this, all the other articles of the Christian faith will signify very little; this is that which fills up and gives the finishing stroke to all the rest. The promised Messiah has come, he was made flesh, and dwelt among us; he is altogether such a one as in stated before, and has done all that for us which has been before taken notice of. These principles the enemies of Christianity have all along endeavoured to overturn; but as these all rest upon facts which are already past, and of which this and the other apostles have given us the most sure and satisfying evidence, it is probable that they will at last grow weary of their opposition to them; and yet, while one very principal article of our faith refers to what is still behind, and only has a promise to rest upon, here they will still attack us, even to the end of time. Till our Lord shall have come, they will not themselves believe that he will come; nay, they will laugh at the very mention of his second coming, and do what in them lies to put all out of countenance who seriously believe and wait for it. Now therefore let us see how this point stands, both on the believer's part and on the part of these seducers: the believer not only desires that he may come, but, having a promise that he will come, a promise that he himself has made and often repeated, a promise received and reported by faithful witnesses, and left upon sure record, he is also firmly and fully persuaded that he will come: on the other hand, these seducers, because they wish he never may, therefore do all that in them lies to cheat themselves and others into a persuasion that he will never come. If they cannot deny that there is a promise, yet they will laugh at that very promise, which argues much higher degrees of infidelity and contempt: Where is the promise, say they, of his coming?

III. We are also forewarned of the method of their reasoning, for while they laugh they will pretend to argue too. To this purpose they add that since the fathers fell asleep all things continue as they were from the beginning of the creation, Pe2 3:4. This is a subtle, though not a solid way of reasoning; it is apt to make impressions upon weak minds, and especially upon wicked hearts. Because sentence against them is not speedily executed, therefore they flatter themselves that it never will, whereupon their hearts are fully set in them to do evil (Ecc 8:11); thus they act themselves, and thus they would persuade others to act; so here, say they, "The fathers have fallen asleep, those are all dead to whom the promise was made, and it was never made good in their time, and there is no likelihood that it ever will be in any time; why should we trouble ourselves about it? If there had been any truth or certainty in the promise you speak of, we should surely have seen somewhat of it before this time, some signs of his coming, some preparatory steps in order to it; whereas we find to this very day all things continue as they were, without any change, even from the beginning of the creation. Since the world has undergone no changes in the course of so many thousand years, why should we affright ourselves as if it were to have an end?" Thus do these scoffers argue. Because they see no changes, therefore they fear not God, Psa 55:19. They neither fear him nor his judgments; what he never has done they would conclude he never can do or never will.

IV. Here is the falsehood of their argument detected. Whereas they confidently had said there had not been any change from the beginning of the creation, the apostle puts us in remembrance of a change already past, which, in a manner, equals that which we are called to expect and look for, which was the drowning of the world in the days of Noah. This these scoffers had overlooked; they took no notice of it. Though they might have known it, and ought to have known it, yet this they willingly are ignorant of (Pe2 3:5), they choose to pass it over in silence, as if they had never heard or known any thing of it; if they knew it, they did not like to retain it in their knowledge; they did not receive this truth in the love of it, neither did they care to own it. Note, It is hard to persuade men to believe what they are not willing to find true; they are ignorant, in many cases, because they are willing to be ignorant, and they do not know because they do not care to know. But let not sinners think that such ignorance as this will be admitted as an excuse for whatever sin it may betray them into. Those who crucified Christ did not know who he was; for had they known they would not have crucified the Lord of glory (Co1 2:8); but, though ignorant, they were not therefore innocent; their ignorance itself was a sin, willing and wilful ignorance, and one sin can be no excuse for another. So it is here; had these known of the dreadful vengeance with which God swept away a whole world of ungodly wretches at once, they would not surely have scoffed at his threatenings of any after equally terrible judgment; but here they were willingly ignorant, they did not know what God had done because they had no mind to know it. Now therefore we shall proceed to consider the representation which the apostle here lays down both of the destruction of the old world by water and that which awaits this present world at the final conflagration. He mentions the one as what God has done, to convince and persuade us the rather to believe that the other both may be and will be.

1.We begin with the apostle's account of the destruction which has once already come upon the world (Pe2 3:5, Pe2 3:6): By the word of God the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water, whereby the world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished. Originally the world was otherwise situated, the waters were most wisely divided at the creation and most beneficially for us; some of the waters had proper repositories above the firmament, here called the heavens (as it is also Gen 1:8), and others, under the firmament, gathered together unto one place; there were then both sea and dry land, commodious habitation for the children of men. But now, at the time of the universal deluge, the case is strangely altered; the waters which God had divided before, assigning to each part its convenient receptacle, now does he, in anger, throw together again in a heap. He breaks up the fountain of the great deep, and throws open the windows (that is, the clouds) of heaven (Gen 7:11), till the whole earth is overflowed with water, and not a spot can be found upon the highest mountains but what is fifteen cubits under water, Gen 7:20. Thus he made known at once his terrible power and his fierce anger, and made an end of a whole world at once: The world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished, Pe2 3:6. Is not here a change and a most awful change! And then it is to be observed that all this was done by the word of God; it was by his powerful word that the world was made at first, and made in so commodious and beautiful a frame and order, Heb 11:3, Katērtisthai. He said, Let there be a firmament, etc., Gen 1:6, Gen 1:7. And let the waters under the heaven be gathered together unto one place, etc., Gen 1:9, Gen 1:10. Thus he spoke, and it was done, Psa 33:9. Thus, says our apostle, by the word of the Lord the heavens were, as they were of old (that is, at first creation) and the earth (as it was at first a terraqueous globe) standing out of the water and in the water. Not is it only the first frame and order of the world that is here said to be by the word of God, but the after-confusion and ruin of the world, as well as the utter destruction of its inhabitants, were also by the same word; none but that God who stretched out the heavens and laid the foundation of the earth could destroy and overthrow such a vast fabric at once. This was done by the word of his power, and it was also done according to the word of his promise; God had said that he would destroy man, even all flesh, and that he would do it by bringing a flood of waters upon the earth, Gen 6:7, Gen 6:13, Gen 6:17. This was the change which God had before brought upon the world, and which these scoffers had overlooked; and now we are to consider,

2.What the apostle says of the destructive change which is yet to come upon it: The heavens and the earth, which now are, by the same word are kept in store, reserved unto fire against the day of judgment and perdition of ungodly men, Pe2 3:7. Here we have an awful account of the final dissolution of the world, and which we are yet more nearly concerned in. The ruin that came upon the world and its inhabitants by the flood, we read, and hear, and think of, with concern, though those who were swept away by it were such as we never knew; but the judgment here spoken of is yet to come, and will surely come, though we know not when, nor upon what particular age or generation of men; and therefore we are not, we cannot be, sure that it may not happen in our own times: and this makes a very great difference, though it should be admitted that they were equal in every other respect, which yet must not be allowed, for there were some, though very few, who escaped that deluge, but not one can escape in this conflagration. Besides, we were not in reach of the one, but are not sure that we shall not be included in the other calamity. Now therefore to see the world to which we belong destroyed at once - not a single person only, not a particular family only, nor yet a nation (even that which we are most nearly interested in and concerned for), but the whole world, I say, sinking at once, and no ark provided, no possible way left of escaping for any one from the common ruin, this makes a difference between the desolation that has been and what we yet are to expect. The one is already past, and never to return upon us any more (for God has said expressly that there shall never any more be a flood to destroy the earth, Gen 9:11-17); the other is still behind, and is as certain to come as the truth and the power of God can make it: the one came gradually upon the world, and was growing upon its inhabitants forty days, before it made an utter end of them (Gen 7:12, Gen 7:17); this other will come upon them swiftly and all at once (Pe2 2:1): besides, there were in that overthrow (as we have said) a few who escaped, but the ruin which yet awaits this world, whenever it comes, will be absolutely a universal one; there will not be any part but what the devouring flames will seize upon, not a sanctuary left any where for the inhabitants to flee to, not a single spot in all this world where any one of them can be safe. Thus, whatever differences may be assigned between that destruction of the world and this here spoken of, they do indeed represent the approaching as the most terrible judgment; yet that the world has once been destroyed by a universal deluge renders it the more credible that it may be again ruined by a universal conflagration. Let therefore the scoffers, who laugh at the coming of our Lord to judgment, at least consider that it may be. There is nothing said of it in the word of God but what is within reach of the power of God, and, though they still should laugh, they shall not put us out of countenance; we are well assured that it will be, because he has said it, and we can depend upon his promise. They err, not knowing (at least not believing) the scriptures, nor the power of God; but we know, and we do or ought to depend upon, both. Now that which he has said, and which he will certainly make good, is that the heavens and the earth which now are (which we are now related to, which still subsist in all the beauty and order in which we see them, and which are so agreeable and useful to us, as we find they are) are kept in store, not to be, what earthly minds would wish to have them, treasures for us, but to be what God will have them, in his treasury, securely lodged and kept safely for his purposes. It follows, they are reserved unto fire. Observe, God's following judgments are more terrible than those which went before; the old world was destroyed by water, but this is reserved unto fire, which shall burn up the wicked at the last day; and, though this seems to be delayed, yet, as this wicked world is upheld by the word of God, so it is only reserved for the vengeance of him to whom vengeance belongs, who will at the day of judgment deal with an ungodly world according to their deserts, for the day of judgment is the day of the perdition of ungodly men. Those who now scoff at a future judgment shall find it a day of vengeance and utter destruction. "Beware therefore of being among these scoffers; never question but the day of the Lord will come; give diligence therefore to be found in Christ, that that may be a time of refreshment and day of redemption to you which will be a day of indignation and wrath to the ungodly world."

Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Commentary on the Whole Bible. This section covers verses 3–7. Public domain.
Copy as
Shepherd of HermasAD 160
Shepherd of Hermas, Commandment 1
First of all, believe that there is one God who created and finished all things, and made all things out of nothing. He alone is able to contain the whole, but Himself cannot be contained.
Eusebius of CaesareaAD 339
CATENA
“In the beginning you, O Lord, laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the works of your hands,” said the psalmist. If you did not know from the beginning, O Lord, who laid the foundation of the earth, and if the heavens were not the work of your hands, it would be impossible for them to be changed or to be transformed into anything else. If they had not been created, they would have to remain incomplete forever. But since you were their maker, you can do whatever you want to with them. They are made of destructible matter and did not exist at all until you made them by your will and power. There is only one that is eternal and can never be removed and that is you, the only maker of everything that exists.
Hilary of ArlesAD 449
INTRODUCTORY COMMENTARY ON 2 PETER
The whole creation is basically formed out of water, even if it is solidified in the form of earth or elevated in the way that heaven is.
BedeAD 735
Commentary on the Catholic Epistles
For this is hidden from them willingly, that the heavens existed long ago and the earth, out of water, etc. The earth consists out of water, for at the beginning of creation God said: "Let the waters be gathered together in one place, and let the dry land appear;" and it was so (Gen. I). It consists also by water by the word of God, because by divine arrangement the veins of water fill the whole depth within, just as we see the bodies of living creatures overflowing with veins of blood, lest they fail in dryness if the irrigation of water ceases. Finally, we see that with the heat of summer, the lands with their absorbed moisture wither away, and soon are turned into dust which the wind casts. Another Edition has: "The heavens existed long ago out of water and through water." But it signifies this humid and cloudy air. For Scripture is accustomed to call this air, and sometimes the heavens. Whence it is written: "The hawk in heaven knows its appointed time" (Jerem. VIII).
OecumeniusAD 990
Commentary on 2 Peter
For they willingly do not know that the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water by the word of God: by which the world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished. But the heavens and the earth which are now, by the same word are kept in store, reserved unto fire against the day of judgment and perdition of ungodly men.
And what is it that they do not know? That just as in the flood, the heavens were from the water according to the creation of the world narrated by Moses: (for he himself says that God commanded that a firmament be made in the midst of the waters (Gen. 1:6), that is, a firmer substance than the waters): so also the earth appeared from the waters at the command of the Creator, which had also been submerged at first. And just as the flood unexpectedly came upon the heavens and the earth constituted from water, so it has now been established that the corruption of the universe will occur through fire, with which the wicked will also perish. Since these two elements, water and fire, were created along with the universe, from which the other two elements are also derived: air indeed from the evaporated waters, but the earth from the compacted ones: namely, just as it was made from fire through evaporation and compression, with no one who has a mind objecting (for this virtue has been bestowed upon fire by God the Creator), since these two, I say, have always existed in this way, and previously the destruction of the wicked was made through water, it is necessary that the destruction of those who act wickedly will again occur through fire. Moreover, that the corruption of this universe is evident not only to Christians but also to the wise men of the Greeks, as is the case with Heraclitus of Ephesus and Empedocles of Etna12. But someone might say: And what is the reason for its creation if the world must again be reduced to nothingness? And we will say that the world does not tend entirely towards corruption, but towards renewal; therefore, the Prophet also says: "And you will renew the face of the earth." (Ps. 103:32) For just as the creation, being from God from the beginning, was good, and not merely good by chance: through the transgression of man, the creation itself became subject to vanity, that is, not having a firm existence, but being in a state of instability and change.
Then in the flood, when few men had persevered in divine worship, the world again seemed to take on the beginning of its reconstruction through Noah and those who had been saved in the ark along with the animals for the establishment of seeds: nevertheless, even then, human nature did not persist in its previous state, but rather declined to worse conditions than those that had existed before, from which neither the law given by Moses turned them away, nor the presence of the Lord, except that a few turned aside to those things which led to salvation. For how great is the multitude of those who are saved if you compare it to the multitude of those who perish, who are generated daily? For this reason, it seems to me that the time of fulfillment is delayed until the number of the saved is completed. Therefore, since the call to salvation has been made in various ways, and the destruction from unbelief is diverse: for this reason, a cataclysmic fire is necessary, indeed a destruction, although not entirely perfect: not indeed of souls, but neither of bodies. For we must all be revealed before the tribunal of Christ (2 Cor. 5:10), not with our souls naked, but together with our bodies, and with them incorruptible. For how could a naked soul account for those things which have been done through the body? Indeed, it is not the part of a just judge, when two have sinned in the same way, to dismiss one and transfer the whole crime to the other. Furthermore, if we are accustomed to melt certain corporeal things again with fire, not to attribute to them absolute destruction, but to provide them with purity and sincerity: let no one doubt that God, who has promised completion through fire, will either not bring about corruption, or will indeed do so in such a way that through the corruption of one, He makes another. But even if it were to corrupt, what would it corrupt? The superfluous and those related to present life: and what are those? Beasts, herbs, plants. Indeed, herbs are for the beasts, and the beasts are for the service of this corruptible life. "Producing," he says, "hay for the beasts and herbs for the service of men." (Ps. 103:14) As for the plants, some are indeed for covering and for building houses, while others are for providing food. Moreover, the fact that animals require food is a sign of corruption. For what else could the middle and fullness provide but corruption? Therefore, those things which are superfluous to immortal life would be corrupted. But He will create new heavens and a new earth (Isa. 65:17), not another in terms of material. For even one who builds a new house does not indeed make it from non-existing material. Thus, God created the material and shaped it from the beginning, as much as was certainly necessary for the use of that time.
To the incorruptibility, however, which will corrupt that which is useless and unnecessary after the present state. If something is useful, it will allow for an improvement with immortal and incredible beauty, so as to perfect and complete another and incorruptible world.
"and the earth standing out of the water." The earth indeed from water as from a material principle, but through water as through a perfecting principle. For water contains the earth like a certain glue that is to it; unless it were to touch it, it would necessarily dissolve and be carried into the air. However, perhaps someone will approach us with vain thought saying: For what reason did God, who produced this visible world, not create it firm and unchangeable from the beginning, but subject to changes? Hence, it was also immediately necessary to be restored, indeed at the time of Noah through water, but reserved unto fire, as Peter now says? To which we will say that it was not possible for it to have changelessness.
How indeed, for he who has received his being from change? If indeed it was produced from non-being to being, which no wise person would say is not a change. And in what way has the change progressed to worse, mixed with worse, it was necessary for this Creator to restore it to better; indeed, at the time of Noah he purified through water, but in the end he will do so through fire. Just as we are accustomed to melt certain material things again with fire, not for destruction, but for purification.
"by which," namely heaven and earth, indeed submerged by waters, but the heavens sending down their gushes, that is, as if through gushes urging water downwards. "by which the world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished." It perished, not for the entire world, but for the living beings, which indeed represent the whole world.
If indeed the place was deserted of living beings, the world would not even be considered. Furthermore, what is stated, "reserved for fire on the day of judgment of ungodly men," is thus arranged: reserved for the day of judgment and for the day of destruction; for "on the day" is resumed from common sense. However, judgment means condemnation:
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying 2 Peter 3:5 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.