پرش به محتوا

Joshua 24:9

“God Recounts His Deeds”· Joshua 24:2–13Read in context
King James Version
Then Balak the son of Zippor, king of Moab, arose and warred against Israel, and sent and called Balaam the son of Beor to curse you:
KJV (with Strong's)
Then Balak H1111 the son H1121 of Zippor H6834, king H4428 of Moab H4124, arose H6965 and warred H3898 against Israel H3478, and sent H7971 and called H7121 Balaam H1109 the son H1121 of Beor H1160 to curse H7043 you:
Complete Jewish Bible
Then Balak the son of Tzippor, king of Mo'av, rose up and fought against Isra'el. He sent and summoned Bil'am the son of B'or to put a curse on you.
Berean Standard Bible
Then Balak son of Zippor, the king of Moab, set out to fight against Israel. He sent for Balaam son of Beor to curse you,
American Standard Version
Then Balak the son of Zippor, king of Moab, arose and fought against Israel: and he sent and called Balaam the son of Beor to curse you;
World English Bible Messianic
Then Balak the son of Zippor, king of Moab, arose and fought against Israel. He sent and called Balaam the son of Beor to curse you;
Geneva Bible (1599)
Also Balak the sonne of Zippor King of Moab arose and warred against Israel, and sent to call Balaam the sonne of Beor for to curse you,
Young's Literal Translation
`And Balak son of Zippor, king of Moab, riseth and fighteth against Israel, and sendeth and calleth for Balaam son of Beor, to revile you,
فارسی · OPV
و بالاق‌ بن‌صفورملك‌ موآب‌ برخاسته‌، با اسرائیل‌ جنگ‌ كرد و فرستاده‌، بلعام‌ بن‌بعور را طلبید تا شما را لعنت‌ كند.
Translation
See on the biblical-era map
In the KJVVerse 6,486 of 31,102 · 20.9%

Study this verse

Summary

Joshua 24:9, situated within Joshua's final, poignant address to Israel at Shechem, functions as a potent historical anchor, vividly recalling God's unwavering faithfulness and protective hand over His people. This verse specifically recounts the malicious plot of Balak, king of Moab, who, perceiving Israel as a formidable threat during their wilderness journey, sought to undermine God's redemptive purposes by enlisting the renowned Mesopotamian diviner, Balaam, to pronounce curses against the nascent nation. The inclusion of this incident in Joshua's farewell speech powerfully underscores the absolute futility of human and supernatural opposition against the sovereign will of the Almighty, thereby laying a crucial foundation for Joshua's subsequent call to steadfast covenant fidelity.

Context

Literary Context

Joshua 24 serves as the climactic conclusion to the book of Joshua, detailing a pivotal covenant renewal ceremony at Shechem. Following the successful conquest and subsequent division of the Promised Land, Joshua, now aged and nearing his death, convenes all the tribes of Israel. His address commences with a comprehensive historical prologue, meticulously recounting God's gracious and powerful acts from the initial call of Abraham through the Exodus, the arduous wilderness journey, and the eventual conquest of Canaan. This sweeping historical review, which spans from Genesis up to Joshua 23, is designed to impress upon the people their solemn covenant obligations and to remind them of God's consistent and steadfast loyalty. Verse 9 specifically recalls a significant incident from their recent past, detailed extensively in the book of Numbers, emphasizing God's miraculous intervention even against spiritual warfare, thereby reinforcing the imperative for Israel to "fear the Lord and serve Him with all faithfulness" as exhorted in Joshua 24:14.

Historical & Cultural Context

The specific incident involving Balak and Balaam unfolded as the Israelites were encamped on the plains of Moab, poised on the precipice of entering the Promised Land. Balak, as the reigning king of Moab, viewed the immense numbers and the formidable military potential of the Israelite multitude as an immediate and existential threat to the sovereignty and security of his kingdom. In the broader ancient Near Eastern cultural landscape, it was a widespread and accepted practice for rulers and communities to employ diviners, seers, or prophets to invoke divine favor or, conversely, to pronounce potent curses upon their adversaries. These spiritual pronouncements were believed to possess tangible, efficacious power. Balaam, hailing from Pethor in Mesopotamia, had garnered a widespread reputation for his uncanny ability to bless or curse, making him an exceptionally sought-after and influential figure. Balak's strategic decision to hire Balaam, rather than immediately engaging in direct military confrontation, powerfully illuminates the pervasive cultural belief in the efficacy and necessity of supernatural warfare. Joshua's deliberate recounting of this event in his farewell address underscores its profound historical significance and the indelible theological lesson it imparted: even the most potent spiritual attacks, meticulously orchestrated by powerful rulers and executed by renowned diviners, were utterly powerless and ultimately futile against the sovereign God of Israel.

Key Themes

Joshua 24:9 profoundly contributes to several overarching theological and narrative themes prevalent within the book of Joshua and the broader Pentateuch. Firstly, it emphatically highlights God's Unwavering Protection and Sovereignty over His chosen people. Despite Balak's malevolent intentions and Balaam's formidable reputation as a diviner, God actively and miraculously intervened to prevent any curse from being uttered, thereby demonstrating that His divine plans cannot be thwarted or undermined by human machinations or even by demonic schemes. This incident vividly illustrates the Futility of Opposition Against God's People, reinforcing the profound theological truth articulated later by Paul, that "if God is for us, who can be against us?" as found in Romans 8:31. Furthermore, the detailed narrative in Numbers 22-24 reveals a remarkable aspect of Divine Sovereignty Turning Curses into Blessings, where God not only prevented Balaam from cursing Israel but, with divine compulsion, compelled him to pronounce blessings instead. This transformative and redemptive power of God is explicitly echoed in Deuteronomy 23:5, which states with clarity that "the Lord your God turned the curse into a blessing for you, because the Lord your God loves you." Finally, Joshua's act of recounting this specific event serves as a crucial exercise in Remembering God's Faithfulness, urging the new generation of Israelites to recall the mighty and miraculous acts of God in their collective history as a foundational pillar for their present trust and future obedience.

Exposition and Analysis

Key Word Analysis

Balak Bâlâq' H1111

Meaning "waster." This name is highly significant, as it reflects the character and intent of the Moabitish king. Balak sought to "waste" or destroy Israel, either through military means or, as the narrative reveals, through a spiritual curse. His name subtly foreshadows his destructive ambition against God's people, an ambition that ultimately proves futile against divine sovereignty.

Warred lâcham' H3898

Meaning "to feed on; figuratively, to consume; by implication, to battle (as destruction); devour, eat, [idiom] ever, fight(-ing), overcome, prevail, (make) war(-ring)." While the primary account in Numbers 22-24 does not detail a conventional military conflict between Moab and Israel at this specific juncture, Joshua's use of lâcham here implies a profound hostile intent and active opposition. Balak's "war" was initially a spiritual one, seeking to "consume" or undermine Israel through supernatural means rather than direct physical combat. This highlights that warfare, in a biblical sense, encompasses more than just physical battles; it includes strategic, political, and spiritual antagonism. Joshua's choice of "warred" emphasizes Balak's aggressive posture and the serious nature of his attempt to destroy Israel.

To curse qâlal' H7043

Meaning "to be (causatively, make) light, literally (swift, small, sharp, etc.) or figuratively (easy, trifling, vile, etc.); abate, make bright, bring into contempt, (ac-) curse, despise, (be) ease(-y, -ier), (be a, make, make somewhat, move, seem a, set) light(-en, -er, -ly, -ly afflict, -ly esteem, thing), [idiom] slight(-ly), be swift(-er), (be, be more, make, re-) vile, whet." While the more specific and potent verb for cursing in the Balaam narrative is often qābab (which denotes a binding, ritualistic curse), the use of qâlal here by Joshua broadens the scope to encompass a general intent to "bring into contempt" or "make vile" Israel. Balak sought Balaam precisely for this specialized ability to invoke a powerful, effective imprecation that would, in his belief, guarantee Israel's defeat by diminishing their strength and favor. The fact that Balaam was utterly unable to utter such a curse, and instead was compelled by God to bless, underscores the absolute supremacy of Yahweh over all other spiritual forces and human machinations.

Verse Breakdown

"Then Balak the son of Zippor, king of Moab, arose"

This initial clause introduces the primary antagonist, Balak, providing his name, his lineage ("son of Zippor"), and his royal office ("king of Moab"). The verb "arose" signifies his decisive initiative and determined action taken in response to the perceived existential threat posed by Israel's presence. It effectively sets the immediate scene for the hostile actions that follow.

"and warred against Israel,"

As elaborated in the Key Word Analysis, this phrase refers not to a conventional military engagement but to Balak's aggressive and hostile intent, which primarily manifested through his strategic attempt to employ spiritual warfare via the diviner Balaam. It powerfully conveys his active opposition and his fervent desire to inflict harm upon the nation of Israel.

"and sent and called Balaam the son of Beor"

This segment meticulously details Balak's specific and calculated strategy to execute his "warfare." He dispatched official messengers to summon Balaam, a non-Israelite prophet or diviner, from his distant homeland in Mesopotamia. The dual action of "sent and called" emphatically underscores Balak's desperation and the extraordinary lengths to which he was willing to go in order to neutralize the perceived Israelite threat.

"to curse you:"

This concluding clause unequivocally states the explicit, malevolent purpose behind Balak's summoning of Balaam. He ardently desired a powerful, supernatural imprecation against Israel, firmly believing that a divine curse would debilitate them and consequently allow him to achieve victory over them. The direct address "you" refers personally to the Israelites whom Joshua is addressing in his farewell speech, thereby making this historical event profoundly relevant and immediate to the present generation.

Literary Devices

Joshua 24:9 masterfully employs several literary devices to amplify its impact within the broader context of Joshua's farewell address. The most prominent device is Recapitulation, as Joshua intentionally recounts a specific, well-known historical event from the recent past. This act of remembering serves a crucial didactic purpose, reminding the Israelites of God's unwavering faithfulness and strengthening their resolve for future obedience. There is also an element of Foreshadowing, as this past deliverance from a potent spiritual attack subtly foreshadows God's continued and unfailing protection over His people against all future forms of opposition, whether physical or spiritual. Furthermore, the broader narrative from which this verse is drawn (Numbers 22-24) is rich in Irony: Balak's desperate and costly attempt to invoke a curse upon Israel ultimately results in Balaam being divinely compelled to pronounce blessings upon them repeatedly. This profound divine subversion of hostile intent into a beneficial outcome powerfully highlights God's absolute sovereign control over even the words and actions of His adversaries.

Theological and Thematic Connections

Joshua 24:9 powerfully encapsulates the overarching biblical theme of God's sovereign and protective care over His covenant people. It serves as a profound demonstration that Yahweh is not merely a localized tribal deity but the supreme and omnipotent God whose divine will cannot be thwarted by human rulers, political machinations, or even by the potent supernatural forces invoked by renowned diviners. The incident with Balak and Balaam stands as a profound testament to God's active and miraculous intervention on behalf of Israel, transforming an intended curse into a resounding blessing. This divine reversal underscores the absolute futility of any opposition mounted against God's purposes and highlights His unwavering commitment to His covenant promises. It is a foundational narrative for understanding God as the ultimate defender, provider, and champion for His elect, a truth that resonates powerfully throughout the entire sweep of salvation history.

Reflection and Application

Joshua 24:9, by recalling God's past, miraculous deliverance from Balak's spiritual assault, offers profound encouragement and vital practical application for believers today. In a world where we frequently encounter various forms of opposition—whether from societal pressures, personal struggles, or the unseen spiritual forces that wage war against us as described in Ephesians 6:12—this verse serves as a powerful reminder that our God is an active, vigilant Protector who consistently intervenes on behalf of His people. Just as Balak's malevolent curses were rendered utterly powerless, so too are the schemes and machinations of our adversaries when we are faithfully aligned with God's sovereign will. We are called to diligently remember God's unwavering faithfulness in our own lives and in the broader, sweeping history of His redemptive work, drawing profound confidence from the immutable truth that "if God is for us, who can be against us?" as triumphantly declared in Romans 8:31. This historical account is designed to build and fortify our faith, assuring us with certainty that God can indeed turn what others intend for harm into ultimate good for those who love Him and are called according to His divine purpose, a promise beautifully articulated in Romans 8:28. Our appropriate response, therefore, should be one of unwavering trust, steadfast faith, and faithful obedience, knowing with absolute certainty that the Lord Himself actively fights for us.

Questions for Reflection

  1. How does remembering God's past faithfulness, as Joshua encourages, strengthen your trust in Him for present and future challenges in your own life?
  2. In what specific ways might you be tempted to fear "curses" or various forms of opposition in your life, and how does the story of Balak and Balaam fundamentally reframe your perspective on such threats?
  3. What does God's remarkable ability to turn an intended curse into a blessing reveal about His character, His power, and His sovereign control over all circumstances?
  4. How can you actively "remember" and recount God's mighty acts and faithful interventions in your own personal life and in the life of your community, mirroring Joshua's powerful address?

FAQ

Did Balak truly "war" against Israel in a physical sense, or was it primarily a spiritual conflict?

While Joshua 24:9 explicitly states that Balak "warred against Israel," the more detailed and expansive account found in Numbers 22-24 primarily describes a spiritual and strategic conflict rather than a conventional military engagement. Balak's "warfare" was his desperate attempt to hire Balaam to supernaturally curse Israel, firmly believing that such a potent curse would weaken them spiritually and physically, thereby allowing him to defeat them. There is no historical record of a direct, large-scale military confrontation between Moab and Israel at this specific juncture. Joshua's use of the term "warred" in his address emphasizes Balak's hostile intent and aggressive opposition, even if the primary means of attack was spiritual and divinatory rather than conventional military force. It highlights the biblical understanding that warfare against God's people can manifest in many forms beyond the physical battlefield.

Who was Balaam, and why was he so significant in this narrative?

Balaam, identified as "the son of Beor" in Joshua 24:9, was a non-Israelite diviner or prophet originating from Pethor in Mesopotamia. He had gained widespread renown throughout the ancient Near East for his perceived extraordinary ability to bless or curse effectively, indicating a recognized connection to supernatural power and insight. Balak specifically sought him out because of this formidable reputation, believing that Balaam possessed the unique capacity to manipulate divine forces to bring about Israel's downfall. His profound significance in the biblical narrative lies not only in his prophetic abilities but, more importantly, in the fact that God Himself intervened directly through Balaam, compelling him against his own will and Balak's desires to utter powerful blessings upon Israel instead of curses. This divine intervention served as an unequivocal demonstration of God's absolute sovereignty over all spiritual powers and human agents, even those operating outside of His covenant people.

Why is this specific incident recalled by Joshua in his farewell address to the Israelites?

Joshua deliberately recalls the incident of Balak and Balaam in his farewell address to serve as a profoundly powerful and enduring reminder of God's unwavering faithfulness and sovereign protection over Israel. By recounting this pivotal event, Joshua emphatically underscores that even when faced with the most potent spiritual attacks and the malevolent intent of powerful enemies, God actively and miraculously intervened to defend His people and to transform intended harm into ultimate blessing. This historical precedent was absolutely crucial for the new generation of Israelites who were now fully settled in the Promised Land, reinforcing the vital message that their security, prosperity, and very existence depended entirely on God's omnipotent power and their continued, faithful obedience to His covenant. It powerfully underscores the overarching theme that "the Lord your God loves you" and will always contend for and protect His people, as affirmed in Deuteronomy 23:5.

Christ-Centered Fulfillment

The historical incident of Balak and Balaam, so pointedly recalled in Joshua 24:9, finds its ultimate and most profound Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and redemptive work of Jesus Christ. Just as God sovereignly intervened to turn Balak's intended curse into a blessing for Israel through the unwilling mouth of Balaam, so too did God take the ultimate curse of sin and death—a curse meticulously intended by Satan and brought about by human rebellion—and miraculously transform it into the greatest blessing of salvation, reconciliation, and eternal life through the crucifixion and glorious resurrection of Jesus. Christ Himself became "a curse for us" as proclaimed in Galatians 3:13, willingly bearing the full, crushing weight of divine judgment and the penalty for our sins so that we, by faith, might receive the promised blessing of the Holy Spirit and inherit the promises made to Abraham, as further illuminated in Galatians 3:14. His decisive victory on the cross disarmed and triumphed over the spiritual powers and authorities, as described in Colossians 2:15, rendering Satan's schemes, the world's opposition, and all forms of spiritual warfare utterly powerless against those who are united with Him. The Church, as the spiritual Israel, stands eternally secure in Christ, knowing with unwavering certainty that no weapon forged against us will ultimately prevail, and no curse can stand, because the Lamb of God has definitively "taken away the sin of the world" as declared in John 1:29 and promises abundant, overflowing life in John 10:10. In Christ, every intended curse is not merely averted but fundamentally reversed, yielding eternal blessing and confirming God's unwavering, unshakeable love for His redeemed people, a love from which nothing can separate us, as triumphantly stated in Romans 8:39.

Copy as

Public-domain commentary

Matthew Henry

From his Commentary on the Whole Bible. Henry comments on passages, not single verses — this entry covers Joshua 24:1–14. His three-level outline is real structure in the source text, so it is rendered as structure.

1662–1714 · 14 verses
Passage under commentJoshua 24:1–14
I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

Joshua thought he had taken his last farewell of Israel in the solemn charge he gave them in the foregoing chapter, when he said, I go the way of all the earth; but God graciously continuing his life longer than expected, and renewing his strength, he was desirous to improve it for the good of Israel. He did not say, "I have taken my leave of them once, and let that serve;" but, having yet a longer space given him, he summons them together again, that he might try what more he could do to engage them for God. Note, We must never think our work for God done till our life is done; and, if he lengthen out our days beyond what we thought, we must conclude it is because he has some further service for us to do.

The assembly is the same with that in the foregoing chapter, the elders, heads, judges, and officers of Israel, Jos 24:1. But it is here made somewhat more solemn than it was there.

I.The place appointed for their meeting is Shechem, not only because that lay nearer to Joshua than Shiloh, and therefore more convenient now that he was infirm and unfit for travelling, but because it was the place where Abraham, the first trustee of God's covenant with this people, settled at his coming to Canaan, and where God appeared to him (Gen 12:6, Gen 12:7), and near which stood mounts Gerizim and Ebal, where the people had renewed their covenant with God at their first coming into Canaan, Jos 8:30. Of the promises God had made to their fathers, and of the promises they themselves had made to God, this place might serve to put them in mind.

II.They presented themselves not only before Joshua, but before God, in this assembly, that is, they came together in a solemn religious manner, as into the special presence of God, and with an eye to his speaking to them by Joshua; and it is probable the service began with prayer. It is the conjecture of interpreters that upon this great occasion Joshua ordered the ark of God to be brought by the priests to Shechem, which, they say, was about ten miles from Shiloh, and to be set down in the place of their meeting, which is therefore called (Jos 24:26) the sanctuary of the Lord, the presence of the ark making it so at that time; and this was done to grace the solemnity, and to strike an awe upon the people that attended. We have not now any such sensible tokens of the divine presence, but are to believe that where two or three are gathered together in Christ's name he is as really in the midst of them as God was where the ark was, and they are indeed presenting themselves before him.

III.Joshua spoke to them in God's name, and as from him, in the language of a prophet (Jos 24:2):

"Thus saith the Lord, Jehovah, the great God, and the God of Israel, your God in covenant, whom therefore you are bound to hear and give heed to." Note, The word of God is to be received by us as his, whoever is the messenger that brings it, whose greatness cannot add to it, nor his meanness diminish from it. His sermon consists of doctrine and application.

1.The doctrinal part is a history of the great things God had done for his people, and for their fathers before them. God by Joshua recounts the marvels of old: "I did so and so." They must know and consider, not only that such and such things were done, but that God did them. It is a series of wonders that is here recorded, and perhaps many more were mentioned by Joshua, which for brevity's sake are here omitted. See what God had wrought.

(1.)He brought Abraham out of Ur of the Chaldees, Jos 24:2, Jos 24:3. He and his ancestors had served other gods there, for it was the country in which, though celebrated for learning, idolatry, as some think, had its rise; there the world by wisdom knew not God. Abraham, who afterwards was the friend of God and the great favourite of heaven, was bred up in idolatry, and lived long in it, till God by his grace snatched him as a brand out of that burning. Let them remember that rock out of which they were hewn, and not relapse into that sin from which their fathers by a miracle of free grace were delivered. "I took him," says God, "else he had never come out of that sinful state." Hence Abraham's justification is made by the apostle an instance of God's justifying the ungodly, Rom 4:5.

(2.)He brought him to Canaan, and built up his family, led him through the land to Shechem, where they now were, multiplied his seed by Ishmael, who begat twelve princes, but at last gave him Isaac the promised son, and in him multiplied his seed. When Isaac had two sons, Jacob and Esau, God provided an inheritance for Esau elsewhere in Mount Seir, that the land of Canaan might be reserved entire for the seed of Jacob, and the posterity of Esau might not pretend to a share in it.

(3.)He delivered the seed of Jacob out of Egypt with a high hand (Jos 24:5, Jos 24:6), and rescued them out of the hands of Pharaoh and his host at the Red Sea, Jos 24:6, Jos 24:7. The same waters were the Israelites' guard and the Egyptians' grave, and this in answer to prayer; for, though we find in the story that they in that distress murmured against God (Exo 14:11, Exo 14:12), notice is here taken of their crying to God; he graciously accepted those that prayed to him, and overlooked the folly of those that quarrelled with him.

(4.)He protected them in the wilderness, where they are here said, not to wander, but to dwell for a long season, Jos 24:7. So wisely were all their motions directed, and so safely were they kept, that even there they had as certain a dwelling-place as if they had been in a walled city.

(5.)He gave them the land of the Amorites, on the other side Jordan (Jos 24:8), and there defeated the plot of Balak and Balaam against them, so that Balaam could not curse them as he desired, and therefore Balak durst not fight them as he designed, and as, because he designed it, he is here said to have done it. The turning of Balaam's tongue to bless Israel, when he intended to curse them, is often mentioned as an instance of the divine power put forth in Israel's favour as remarkable as any, because in it God proved (and does still, more than we are aware of) his dominion over the powers of darkness, and over the spirits of men.

(6.)He brought them safely and triumphantly into Canaan, delivered the Canaanites into their hand (Jos 24:11), sent hornets before them, when they were actually engaged in battle with the enemy, which with their stings tormented them and with their noise terrified them, so that they became a very easy prey to Israel. These dreadful swarms first appeared in their war with Sihon and Og, the two kings of the Amorites, and afterwards in their other battles, Jos 24:12. God had promised to do this for them, Exo 23:27, Exo 23:28. And here Joshua takes notice of the fulfilling of that promise. See Exo 23:27, Exo 23:28; Deu 7:20. These hornets, it should seem, annoyed the enemy more than the artillery of Israel, and therefore he adds, not with thy sword nor bow. It was purely the Lord's doing. Lastly, They were now in the peaceable possession of a good land, and lived comfortably upon the fruit of other people's labours, Jos 24:13.

2.The application of this history of God's mercies to them is by way of exhortation to fear and serve God, in gratitude for his favour, and that it might be continued to them, Jos 24:14. Now therefore, in consideration of all this, (1.) "Fear the Lord, the Lord and his goodness, Hos 3:5. Reverence a God of such infinite power, fear to offend him and to forfeit his goodness, keep up an awe of his majesty, a deference to his authority, a dread of his displeasure, and a continual regard to his all-seeing eye upon you." (2.) "Let your practice be consonant to this principle, and serve him both by the outward acts of religious worship and every instance of obedience in your whole conversation, and this in sincerity and truth, with a single eye and an upright heart, and inward impressions answerable to outward expressions." This is the truth in the inward part, which God requires, Psa 51:6. For what good will it do us to dissemble with a God that searches the heart? (3.) Put away the strange gods, both Chaldean and Egyptian idols, for those they were most in danger of revolting to. It should seem by this charge, which is repeated (Jos 24:23), that there were some among them that privately kept in their closets the images or pictures of these dunghill-deities, which came to their hands from their ancestors, as heir-looms of their families, though, it may be, they did not worship them; these Joshua earnestly urges them to throw away: "Deface them, destroy them, lest you be tempted to serve them." Jacob pressed his household to do this, and at this very place; for, when they gave him up the little images they had, he buried them under the oak which was by Shechem, Gen 35:2, Gen 35:4. Perhaps the oak mentioned here (Jos 24:26) was the same oak, or another in the same place, which might be well called the oak of reformation, as there were idolatrous oaks.

Copy as
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Joshua 24:9 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.

Related study articles8