Skip to content
Translation
King James Version
So I sware in my wrath, They shall not enter into my rest.)
Ask
KJV (with Strong's)
So G5613 I sware G3660 in G1722 my G3450 wrath G3709, They shall G1525 not G1487 enter G1525 into G1519 my G3450 rest G2663.)
Ask
Complete Jewish Bible
in my anger, I swore
that they would not enter my rest.”
Ask
Berean Standard Bible
So I swore on oath in My anger, ‘They shall never enter My rest.’”
Ask
American Standard Version
As I sware in my wrath, They shall not enter into my rest.
Ask
World English Bible Messianic
as I swore in my wrath, ‘They will not enter into my rest.’”
Ask
Geneva Bible (1599)
Therefore I sware in my wrath, If they shall enter into my rest.
Ask
Young's Literal Translation
so I sware in My anger, If they shall enter into My rest--!')
Ask

Study This Verse

SUMMARY

Hebrews 3:11 presents a solemn divine oath from Psalm 95:11, serving as a profound warning to the readers against the perils of unbelief and disobedience. It underscores God's righteous judgment against the wilderness generation who, through their hardened hearts and persistent rebellion, forfeited entry into His promised rest, thereby urging contemporary believers to heed this historical lesson and diligently pursue faith and obedience to secure their own spiritual inheritance.

CONTEXT

  • Literary Context: This verse is a direct quotation from Psalm 95:11, which the author of Hebrews strategically employs within an extended exhortation spanning Hebrews chapters 3 and 4. The writer's primary aim is to warn his audience, likely Jewish Christians facing persecution or wavering faith, against the dangers of apostasy and spiritual apathy. He uses the historical account of the Israelites' failure to enter the Promised Land due to their unbelief as a powerful cautionary tale. The preceding verses in Hebrews 3:7-10 already introduce this theme, emphasizing the hardening of hearts, provocation of God, and forty years of wandering. Thus, Hebrews 3:11 functions as the climactic declaration of God's irreversible judgment against that rebellious generation, setting the stage for the author's subsequent appeal for steadfast faith and perseverance in Hebrews 4.

  • Historical & Cultural Context: The historical backdrop for the quotation in Hebrews 3:11 is the forty-year wilderness wandering of the Israelites following their miraculous deliverance from Egyptian bondage, as detailed in Numbers 14. Despite witnessing God's powerful acts, including the parting of the Red Sea and the provision of manna, the vast majority of that generation succumbed to fear, doubt, and rebellion, particularly after the negative report of the spies regarding the inhabitants of Canaan. Their repeated murmuring, idolatry, and refusal to trust God's promises at the border of the Promised Land led to God's solemn declaration that they would not enter His rest. For the original readers of Hebrews, this was a well-known and deeply significant event in their national history, serving as a poignant reminder of the consequences of disobedience and a failure to appropriate God's covenant promises through faith. The concept of "rest" (Canaan) was deeply ingrained in Jewish thought as a symbol of peace, security, and the fulfillment of divine promises.

  • Key Themes: The verse significantly contributes to several major theological and narrative themes within Hebrews and the broader biblical narrative. Firstly, it highlights the Divine Oath and Unchangeable Decree, emphasizing that when God swears an oath, it is an irreversible and binding declaration, reflecting His immutable character and purpose, as further elaborated in Hebrews 6:17-18. Secondly, it introduces and develops the crucial theme of The Nature of God's "Rest." While initially referring to the physical land of Canaan, the author of Hebrews expands this concept to a deeper, spiritual "Sabbath rest" that remains available to the people of God through faith in Christ, a theme profoundly explored in Hebrews 4:1-11. Thirdly, the verse powerfully illustrates The Consequence of Unbelief and Disobedience, presenting the wilderness generation's exclusion from the Promised Land as a direct result of their persistent lack of faith and rebellion, a lesson the author urges his readers to internalize to avoid similar spiritual shipwreck (Numbers 14:22-23). Finally, "in my wrath" underscores the theme of God's Righteous Wrath – a holy indignation against sin and obstinate unbelief, which is a just and principled response to human rebellion against His divine will and goodness, rather than an uncontrolled outburst.

EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

Key Word Analysis

  • sware (Greek, omnýō', G3660): This verb signifies to take or declare on oath, emphasizing the solemnity and binding nature of God's declaration. When God swears, it is an absolute and unchangeable commitment, making the consequence certain and unavoidable. It underscores the divine resolve and the gravity of the pronouncement.
  • wrath (Greek, orgḗ', G3709): This term denotes a settled, principled indignation or a righteous displeasure. Unlike human anger, God's orgḗ is not an uncontrolled outburst of temper but a just and holy response to sin and rebellion. It reflects His unwavering opposition to evil and His commitment to justice, indicating a deliberate and consistent divine judgment.
  • rest (Greek, katápausis', G2663): Derived from a verb meaning "to cause to cease," katápausis signifies a cessation from labor, trouble, or wandering, implying a state of peace, security, and fulfillment. In the context of the Old Testament, it referred to the Promised Land of Canaan. In Hebrews, it expands to a deeper, spiritual reality—a Sabbath rest available to believers through faith in Christ, representing true spiritual peace and communion with God.

Verse Breakdown

  • "So I sware in my wrath,": This clause emphasizes the absolute certainty and solemnity of God's declaration. The adverb "So" (G5613, hōs) indicates the manner or consequence, linking directly to the preceding narrative of Israel's provocation. God's act of swearing an oath underscores the unchangeable nature of His decree, highlighting that this is not a casual statement but a divine, irreversible pronouncement born out of His holy indignation (orgḗ) against persistent unbelief and rebellion. It reveals God's character as one who is just and who holds His covenant people accountable.
  • "They shall not enter into my rest.)": This is the content of God's solemn oath and the direct consequence of the Israelites' disobedience. "They shall not enter" (G1525, eisérchomai, negated by G1487, ei) signifies an absolute exclusion. The phrase "my rest" (G3450, moû G2663, katápausis) refers to the promised land of Canaan, which symbolized a state of peace, security, and fulfillment after their wilderness wanderings. For the author of Hebrews, this "rest" transcends the geographical and points to a deeper, spiritual reality—a divine Sabbath rest that remains available to God's people through faith in Christ. The exclusion of the wilderness generation serves as a stark warning that unbelief prevents entry into God's intended blessings.

Literary Devices

The author of Hebrews masterfully employs several literary devices in Hebrews 3:11 to convey his urgent message. Primarily, the verse features a direct Quotation from Psalm 95:11, a common technique in Hebrews to ground theological arguments in Old Testament authority. This quotation is part of an extended Midrashic Exegesis on Psalm 95, where the author reinterprets historical events to draw contemporary spiritual lessons. The phrase "I sware in my wrath" utilizes Anthropomorphism, attributing human emotions and actions (swearing, wrath) to God, making His divine judgment relatable and impactful. This anthropomorphism serves to emphasize the depth of God's righteous indignation and the certainty of His decree. Furthermore, the entire passage, including this verse, functions as a powerful Warning and Exhortation, using the negative example of the wilderness generation as a didactic tool to urge the readers to avoid similar spiritual failures. The stark contrast between God's promise of "rest" and the "not enter" highlights the Irony of a chosen people failing to receive their inheritance due to their own hardened hearts.

THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS

Hebrews 3:11 profoundly connects the themes of divine faithfulness, human responsibility, and the nature of God's judgment. It underscores that while God's promises are steadfast, their appropriation depends on a faithful and obedient response from humanity. The "wrath" of God is not arbitrary but a just reaction to persistent unbelief and rebellion, demonstrating His holy character and His unwavering commitment to righteousness. This verse serves as a critical bridge, expanding the Old Testament concept of physical rest in Canaan to a deeper, spiritual rest that is still available to God's people in the New Covenant era, emphasizing that faith is the key to entering and experiencing this divine provision.

REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

Hebrews 3:11 stands as a timeless and urgent reminder for believers today, echoing across millennia with a profound call to spiritual vigilance. The historical failure of the Israelites in the wilderness is not merely an ancient tale but a living parable for our own walk of faith. We are exhorted to learn from their mistakes, recognizing that spiritual lethargy, persistent doubt, and a refusal to trust God's promises can lead to a hardening of the heart, preventing us from experiencing the fullness of God's blessings and the true spiritual rest He offers. This "rest" is not just a future hope but also a present reality of peace, security, and cessation from striving found in Christ. It calls us to actively guard our hearts against unbelief, to humbly receive God's word, and to persevere in faith and obedience, ensuring we do not fall short of the glorious inheritance prepared for us. Our daily lives should reflect a diligent pursuit of this rest, casting our anxieties upon the Lord and finding solace in His unfailing promises.

Questions for Reflection

  • What specific areas of my life might indicate a "hardened heart" or a reluctance to fully trust God's promises?
  • How does the concept of God's "rest" in Hebrews differ from common understandings of rest, and how can I actively enter into this spiritual rest today?
  • What practical steps can I take to cultivate a heart of faith and obedience, learning from the negative example of the Israelites?

FAQ

What is the "rest" that the Israelites failed to enter, according to Hebrews 3:11?

Answer: The "rest" initially referred to the Promised Land of Canaan, which God intended as a place of peace, security, and fulfillment for the Israelites after their liberation from Egypt and their wilderness wanderings. However, the author of Hebrews expands this concept beyond a geographical location. He argues that the physical rest in Canaan was a type or shadow of a greater, spiritual "Sabbath rest" that remains available to the people of God. This ultimate rest is a state of peace, security, and cessation from striving, found through faith in Jesus Christ, and it encompasses both a present spiritual reality and a future eternal inheritance in God's presence (see Hebrews 4:9-10). The wilderness generation failed to enter the physical rest due to their unbelief, serving as a warning against spiritual apathy regarding the true rest.

Why did God swear "in His wrath" that they would not enter His rest?

Answer: God swore "in His wrath" because of the persistent unbelief, disobedience, and rebellion of the Israelites during their forty years in the wilderness. This "wrath" (Greek: orgḗ) is not an uncontrolled outburst of temper but a righteous, settled indignation against sin and obstinate defiance of His will. It signifies God's holy character and His just response to human rebellion. Despite witnessing numerous miracles and receiving divine provision, the Israelites repeatedly challenged God's authority and doubted His promises, provoking His righteous judgment. God's oath, therefore, signifies the absolute certainty and irreversible nature of their exclusion as a consequence of their hardened hearts and spiritual apathy (see Numbers 14:22-23 and Hebrews 3:7-10).

CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT

Hebrews 3:11, while rooted in an Old Testament warning, finds its ultimate Christ-centered fulfillment in the person and work of Jesus. The "rest" that the wilderness generation failed to enter due to their unbelief is perfectly embodied and made accessible through Christ. He is the true and ultimate "rest" for our souls, inviting all who are weary and burdened to come to Him and find peace (as promised in Matthew 11:28-29). Unlike the temporary rest of Canaan, Jesus offers a spiritual rest that transcends earthly boundaries and temporal limitations. His finished work on the cross, His perfect obedience, and His atoning sacrifice have opened a new and living way into God's presence, into the very "holy places" (as described in Hebrews 10:19-22). Through faith in Him, believers cease from their own works to enter God's rest (as explained in Hebrews 4:9-10), experiencing a present peace that surpasses understanding and a future hope of eternal communion with God. Thus, the warning of Hebrews 3:11 serves to highlight the immense privilege and profound responsibility of responding to the superior revelation and salvation offered in Jesus, the Son, who leads us into God's true and lasting rest.

Copy as

Commentary on Hebrews 3 verses 7–19

I. II. Main points1. 2. Sub-points(1.) (2.) Details

Here the apostle proceeds in pressing upon them serious counsels and cautions to the close of the chapter; and he recites a passage out of Psa 95:7, etc., where observe,

I. What he counsels them to do - to give a speedy and present attention to the call of Christ. "Hear his voice, assent to, approve of, and consider, what God in Christ speaks unto you; apply it to yourselves with suitable affections and endeavours, and set about it this very day, for tomorrow it may be too late."

II. What he cautions them against - hardening their hearts, turning the deaf ear to the calls and counsels of Christ: "When he tells you of the evil of sin, the excellency of holiness, the necessity of receiving him by faith as your Saviour, do not shut your ear and heart against such a voice as this." Observe, The hardening of our hearts is the spring of all our other sins.

III. Whose example he warns them by - that of the Israelites their fathers in the wilderness: As in the provocation and day of temptation; this refers to that remarkable passage at Massah Meribah, Exo 17:2-7. Observe,

1.Days of temptation are often days of provocation.

2.To provoke God, when he is trying us, and letting us see that we entirely depend and live immediately upon him, is a provocation with a witness.

3.The sins of others, especially our relations, should be a warning to us. Our fathers' sins and punishments should be remembered by us, to deter us from following their evil examples. Now as to the sin of the fathers of the Jews, here reflected upon, observe,

(1.)The state in which these fathers were, when they thus sinned: they were in the wilderness, brought out of Egypt, but not got into Canaan, the thoughts whereof should have restrained them from sin.

(2.)The sin they were guilty of: they tempted and provoked God; they distrusted God, murmured against Moses, and would not attend to the voice of God.

(3.)The aggravations of their sin: they sinned in the wilderness, where they had a more immediate dependence upon God: they sinned when God was trying them; they sinned when they saw his works - works of wonder wrought for their deliverance out of Egypt, and their support and supply in the wilderness from day to day. They continued thus to sin against God for forty years. These were heinous aggravations.

(4.)The source and spring of such aggravated sins, which were, [1.] They erred in their hearts; and these heart-errors produced many other errors in their lips and lives. [2.] They did not know God's ways, though he had walked before them. They did not know his ways; neither those ways of his providence in which he had walked towards them, nor those ways of his precept in which they ought to have walked towards God; they did not observe either his providences or his ordinances in a right manner.

(5.)The just and great resentment God had at their sins, and yet the great patience he exercised towards them (Heb 3:10): Wherefore I was grieved with that generation. Note, [1.] All sin, especially sin committed by God's professing privileged people, does not only anger and affront God, but it grieves him. [2.] God is loth to destroy his people in or for their sin, he waits long to be gracious to them. [3.] God keeps an exact account of the time that people go on in sinning against him, and in grieving him by their sins; but at length, if they by their sins continue to grieve the Spirit of God, their sins shall be made grievous to their own spirits, either in a way of judgment or mercy.

(6.)The irreversible doom passed upon them at last for their sins. God swore in his wrath that they should not enter into his rest, the rest either of an earthly or of a heavenly Canaan. Observe, [1.] Sin, long continued in, will kindle the divine wrath, and make it flame out against sinners. [2.] God's wrath will discover itself in its righteous resolution to destroy the impenitent; he will swear in his wrath, not rashly, but righteously, and his wrath will make their condition a restless condition; there is no resting under the wrath of God.

IV. What use the apostle makes of their awful example, Heb 3:12, Heb 3:13, etc. He gives the Hebrews a proper caution, and enforces it with an affectionate compellation.

1.He gives the Hebrews a proper caution; the word is, Take heed, blepete - look to it. "Look about you; be upon your guard against enemies both within and without; be circumspect. You see what kept many of your forefathers out of Canaan, and made their carcasses fall in the wilderness; take heed lest you fall into the same sin and snare and dreadful sentence. For you see Christ is head of the church, a much greater person than Moses, and your contempt of him must be a greater sin than their contempt of Moses; and so you are in danger of falling under a severer sentence than they." Observe, The ruin of others should be a warning to us to take heed of the rock they split upon. Israel's fall should for ever be a warning to all who come after them; for all these things happened to them for ensamples (Co1 10:11), and should be remembered by us. Take heed; all who would get safely to heaven must look about them.

2.He enforces the admonition with an affectionate compellation: "Brethren, not only in the flesh, but in the Lord; brethren whom I love, and for whose welfare I labour and long." And here he enlarges upon the matter of the admonition: Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God. Here observe, (1.) A heart of unbelief is an evil heart. Unbelief is a great sin, it vitiates the heart of man. (2.) An evil heart of unbelief is at the bottom of all our sinful departures from God; it is a leading step to apostasy; if once we allow ourselves to distrust God, we may soon desert him. (3.) Christian brethren have need to be cautioned against apostasy. Let those that think they stand take heed lest they fall.

3.He subjoins good counsel to the caution, and advises them to that which would be a remedy against this evil heart of unbelief - that they should exhort one another daily, while it is called today, Heb 3:13. Observe, (1.) We should be doing all the good we can to one another while we are together, which will be but a short and uncertain time. (2.) Since tomorrow is none of ours, we must make the best improvement of today. (3.) If Christians do not exhort one another daily, they will be in danger of being hardened through the deceitfulness of sin. Note, [1.] There is a great deal of deceitfulness in sin; it appears fair, but is filthy; it appears pleasant, but is pernicious; it promises much, but performs nothing. [2.] The deceitfulness of sin is of a hardening nature to the soul; one sin allowed prepares for another; every act of sin confirms the habit; sinning against conscience is the way to sear the conscience; and therefore it should be the great concern of every one to exhort himself and others to beware of sin.

4.He comforts those who not only set out well, but hold on well, and hold out to the end (Heb 3:14): We are made partakers of Christ, if we hold the beginning of our confidence stedfast to the end. Here observe, (1.) The saints' privilege: they are made partakers of Christ, that is, of the Spirit, nature, graces, righteousness, and life of Christ; they are interested in all that is Christ's, in all that he is, in all that he has done, or can do. (2.) The condition on which they hold that privilege, namely, their perseverance in the bold and open profession and practice of Christ and Christianity unto the end. Not but they shall persevere, being kept by the mighty power of God through faith to salvation, but to be pressed thus to it is one means by which Christ helps his people to persevere. This tends to make them watchful and diligent, and so keeps them from apostasy. Here observe, [1.] The same spirit with which Christians set out in the ways of God they should maintain and evidence to the end. Those who begin seriously, and with lively affections and holy resolutions and humble reliance, should go on in the same spirit. But, [2.] There are a great many who in the beginning of their profession show a great deal of courage and confidence, but do not hold them fast to the end. [3.] Perseverance in faith is the best evidence of the sincerity of our faith.

5.The apostle resumes what he had quoted before from Psa 95:7, etc., and he applies it closely to those of that generation, Heb 3:15, Heb 3:16, etc. While it is said, Today if you will hear, etc.; as if he should say, "What was recited before from that scripture belonged not only to former ages, but to you now, and to all who shall come after you; that you take heed you fall not into the same sins, lest you fall under the same condemnation." The apostle tells them that though some who had heard the voice of God did provoke him, yet all did not so. Observe, (1.) Though the majority of hearers provoked God by unbelief, yet some there were who believed the report. (2.) Though the hearing of the word be the ordinary means of salvation, yet, if it be not hearkened to, it will expose men more to the anger of God. (3.) God will have a remnant that shall be obedient to his voice, and he will take care of such and make mention of them with honour. (4.) If these should fall in a common calamity, yet they shall partake of eternal salvation, while disobedient hearers perish for ever.

6.The apostle puts some queries upon what had been before mentioned, and gives proper answers to them (Heb 3:17-19): But with whom was he grieved forty years? With those that sinned. And to whom did he swear? etc. Whence observe, (1.) God is grieved only with those of his people who sin against him, and continue in sin. (2.) God is grieved and provoked most by sins publicly committed by the generality of a nation; when sin becomes epidemic, it is most provoking. (3.) Though God grieves long, and bears long, when pressed with the weight of general and prevailing wickedness, yet he will at length ease himself of public offenders by public judgments. (4.) Unbelief (with rebellion which is the consequent of it) is the great damning sin of the world, especially of those who have a revelation of the mind and will of God. This sin shuts up the heart of God, and shuts up the gate of heaven, against them; it lays them under the wrath and curse of God, and leaves them there; so that in truth and justice to himself he is obliged to cast them off for ever.

Matthew Henry (1662–1714) — Commentary on the Whole Bible. This section covers verses 7–19. Public domain.
Copy as
John ChrysostomAD 407
Homily on Hebrews 6
But it is necessary also to unfold the history, to make the argument more clear. For when they had come forth out of Egypt, and had accomplished a long journey, and had received innumerable proofs of the power of God, both in Egypt, and in the Red Sea, and in the wilderness, they determined to send spies to search out the nature of the land; and these went and returned, admiring indeed the country, and saying that it abounded in noble fruits, nevertheless it was a country of strong and invincible men: and the ungrateful and senseless Jews, when they ought to have called to mind the former blessings of God, and how when they were hemmed in the midst of the armies of so many Egyptians, He rescued them from their perils, and made them masters of their enemies' spoils; and again, in the wilderness He clave the rock, and bestowed on them abundance of waters, and gave them the manna, and the other wonderful things which He wrought; when they ought, I say, to have remembered this, and to have trusted in God, they considered none of these things, but being struck with terror, just as if nothing had been done, they said, we wish to go back again into Egypt, "for God hath brought us out thither" to "slay us, with our children and wives." God therefore being angry that they had so quickly cast off the memory of what had been done, sware that generation, which had said these things, should not enter into the Rest; and they all perished in the wilderness. When David then, he says, speaking at a later period, and after these events, after that generation of men, said, "To-day, if ye will hear His voice, harden not your hearts," that ye may not suffer the same things which your forefathers did, and be deprived of the Rest; he evidently said this as of some future rest. For if they had received their Rest (he says) why does He again say to them, "To-day if ye will hear His voice harden not your hearts," as your fathers did? What other rest then is there, except the kingdom of Heaven, of which the Sabbath was an image and type?
John ChrysostomAD 407
Homily on Hebrews 6
Paul, having treated of hope, and having said that "We are His house, if we hold fast the confidence and the rejoicing of the hope firm unto the end"; next shows that we ought to look forward with firmness, and he proves this from the Scriptures.

His discourse was concerning Hope, and that it behooves us to hope for the things to come, and that for those who have toiled here there will assuredly be some reward and fruit and refreshment. This then he shows from the prophet.

He says that there are "three" rests: one, that of the Sabbath, in which God rested from His works; the second, that of Palestine, into which when the Jews had entered they would be at rest from their hardships and labors; the third, that which is Rest indeed, the kingdom of Heaven; which those who obtain, do indeed rest from their labors and troubles. Of these three then he makes mention here.

And why did he mention the three, when he is treating of the one only? That he might show that the prophet is speaking concerning this one. For he did not speak (he says) concerning the first. For how could he, when that had taken place long before? Nor yet again concerning the second, that in Palestine. For how could he? For he says, "They shall not enter into My rest." It remains therefore that it is this third.
Theodore of MopsuestiaAD 428
FRAGMENTS ON THE EPISTLE TO THE HEBREWS 3.12-14
This word comes to ones who have already come to faith, as I understand it. So that it is fitting for you to praise the same things so that you might remain in the same opinions once and for all. This then Paul says, because those who believe and who have received the Spirit “share” in the substance of Christ, since they have received some physical fellowship with him. Then finally it remains to guard thoroughly this beginning with an uncontaminated mind.
Photios I of ConstantinopleAD 893
FRAGMENTS ON THE EPISTLE TO THE HEBREWS 3.12
Many have evil, unbelieving hearts. To have an evil, unbelieving heart means to have no faith. Evil is the love of property, wantonness, alcohol, and the like.… Beware that your heart may not become evil and unbelieving; unbelief, he says, is separation from the living God.
OecumeniusAD 990
The Pseudo-Oecumenian Catena on Hebrews
Saying that it is necessary to hope for good things from Christ, he now says that we must not harden our hearts towards this faith and hope, so that we do not suffer the same things as those who, in the desert, became unbelievers. And today, which is always evident, as if he were saying: Whenever and as long as today is, if you hear the voice of the one calling Christ, do not harden your hearts and become stubborn so as not to hear him.
"do not harden your hearts." For the hard and unyielding and stubborn are against the one who speaks to them.
"your hearts." For the Israelites, he says, becoming hard-hearted, provoked the God who was speaking to them.
"On the day of testing." And what is this rebellion that occurred on that day? When, distrusting God, they tested Him. "Will He be able," he says, "to give bread, or prepare a table for His people?" (Ps. 77:19)
OecumeniusAD 990
The Pseudo-Oecumenian Catena on Hebrews
"where your fathers tested me." Where, that is, in the desert. Or, where they tested Him in temptation, so that it may be the "where," not the indicative place.
OecumeniusAD 990
The Pseudo-Oecumenian Catena on Hebrews
"I was provoked with that generation." That is, I was burdened by it, because they always distrusted and tested Me.
"as I swore in my wrath." To such an extent, he says, they did not know my ways, until they brought me to this point, so that I swore they shall not enter my rest, that is, the land of promise, in which having entered they were to rest from wars.
"If they shall enter into my rest." But those, having been unfaithful and having tempted God, did not enter into Palestine. For this is the rest. But what will be for us, he says, since there is no other rest on earth, of which we are to be deprived by being disobedient to God? Yes, he says, there will be now the true rest, of which that old one was a type, and you will be deprived of this, if indeed you disbelieve in Christ. For there are three rests. One is the Sabbath, in which God rested from his works. The second, the promised land of Palestine. The third, the truly real one, of which the two mentioned were a type, the kingdom of heaven, where all sorrow and pain and sighing have fled away. Therefore, he says, you will be deprived of this by being disobedient to Christ.
Thomas AquinasAD 1274
170. - Having proved that Christ is greater than Moses, the Apostle now concludes that Christ is more deserving of our obedience. He does this by the authority of David the prophet in Psalm 94. He does three things: first, he proposes the authority which contains an exhortation; secondly, he explains it (v. 12); thirdly, he argues from the authority and the explanation (chap. 4). In regard to the first he does three things: first, he hints at the authority of the following words; secondly, he makes the exhortation which is the authority (v. 7b); thirdly, he presents a similitude (v. 8b).

171. - The authority of the words consists in the fact that they were not uttered by human lips, but by the Holy Spirit; hence, he says, Wherefore, as the Holy Spirit says. As if to say: Christ has more grace than Moses. Therefore, if we hearken to Moses, we ought not harden our hearts against hearing Christ. But he cites the words of the Old Testament for the New, lest anyone suppose that they refer only to the Old Testament; for they should be referred also to the New and to another time. They are the words of the Holy Spirit, because, as it says in 2 Pt. (1:21): ‘Prophecy came not by the will of man at any time, but the holy men of God spoke, inspired by the Holy Spirit.’ For David himself says of himself: ‘The spirit of the Lord spoke through me’ (2 Sam. 23: 2). Therefore, in this he shows that the authority is true, because it is from the Holy Spirit—against the Manicheans.

172. - Then (v. 7b) he gives the admonition in which he does three things: first, he describes the time; secondly, he mentions the benefit (v. 7b) thirdly, the admonition (v. 8).

173. - The time is today, i.e., day time. For the time of the Old Law was called night, because it was a time of shadows: ‘For the law, having a shadow of the good things to come’ (below 10:1). But the time of the New Testament, because it repels the shadow of the night of the Law, is called day: ‘The night is passed, the day is at hand’ (Rom. 13:12). That time is called day, because it witnessed the rising of the sun of justice: ‘But unto you that fear my name, the Sun of justice shall arise’ (Mal 4:2). This day is not succeeded by night, but by a clearer day, namely, when we shall see the Sun of justice with His face revealed, when we shall see Him by His essence.

174. - And in this day a benefit will be given to us. For he continues, when you hear his voice, because we hear His voice, which was not true of the Old Testament, in which the words of the prophets were heard: ‘In times past God spoke to the Son’ (Heb. 1:1); ‘Therefore, my people shall know my name in that day, because it was I myself that spoke, behold, I am here’ (Is. 52:6); ‘Let your voice sound on my ears’ (S of S 2:14). For in this the benefit so long desired is shown to us: ‘If you had known and in this your day, the things that are to your peace’ (Lk. 19:42).

175. - Therefore, if that is the benefit, here is the admonition, harden not your hearts. For a hard heart smacks of evil. That is hard which does not yield, but resists and does not receive an impression. Therefore, man’s heart is hard, when it does not yield to God’s command nor easily receive divine impressions: ‘A hard heart shall fear evil at the last’ (Sir. 3:27); But according to your hardness and impenitent heart, you treasure up to yourself wrath against the day of wrath’ (Rom. 2:5). But this hardening is caused by two things: first, by God not offering grace: ‘He has mercy on whom he will, and whom he wills, he hardens’ (Rom. 9:18); secondly, by the sinner hardening himself by not obeying God and by not opening his heart to grace: ‘And they made their heart as the adamant stone, lest they should hear the law and the words which the Lord of hosts sent in his spirit by the hand of the former prophets’ (Zech 7:12). Therefore, harden not your hearts i.e., do not close your hearts to the Holy Spirit: ‘You always resist the Holy Spirit’ (Ac. 7:51).

176. - Then he presents the resemblance when he says, as in the rebellion. This is a resemblance based on a past event: for the faithful are instructed about the things to be done in the New Testament from the things that occurred in the past, as Rom. (15:4) testifies: ‘What things soever were written, were written for our learning.’ In regard to this he does two things: first, he gives an example in general by citing their guilt; secondly, he gives specific examples (v. 9).

177. - If we are to follow the Apostle’s explanation, we must use the senses which fit the explanation. Thus we read that among others there were two sins committed by the Jews which were severely punished: one was the disobedience of the spies mentioned in Num. (13 & 14), for which the Lord wished to wipe out the people. Hence, He swore that no one but Caleb and Joshua would enter the promised land. He calls this a rebellion, because, although they had offended God in other ways, this sin was particularly bitter; for just as bitter fruit, not being ripe, is not suitable for eating, so then God’s anger was inflexible: ‘How often did they provoke him in the desert, and move him to wrath in the place without water’ (Ps. 77:40)? ‘You have provoked him who made you’ (Bar. 4:7). The other sin was that of tempting God. For they frequently tempted Him, sometimes for water, sometimes for meat, and sometimes for bread, so that they tempted Him ten times: ‘They have tempted me now ten times’ (Num. 14:22); ‘Behold, these ten times you confound me’ (Jb. 19:2). Hence he says, in the day of testing. But someone might suppose the signs of rebellion and testing are the same, and that the Apostle should say: ‘Harden not your hearts as in the rebellion, which occurred in the day of testing.’ But this does not agree with the Apostle’s explanation. Therefore, we should say, Harden not your hearts as in the rebellion, and again, as in the day of testing, so that there are two sins; hence, Ps. 77 (v. 41) says: ‘And they turned back and tempted God; and grieved the Holy One of Israel.’

178. - Then (v. 9) he considers their specific sins. In regard to this he does two things: first, he mentions the sin of testing; secondly, the sin of rebellion (v. 10b). In regard to the first he does three things: first, he mentions the sin of testing; secondly, he shows its gravity (v. 9b); thirdly, the punishment (v. 10).

179. - He says, therefore, that they were guilty of the sin of testing Him in the desert, because your fathers tempted me there; and I speak in the Lord’s person. Here it should be noted that temptation is an act of testing about something one does not know. Hence, it is from unbelief that a person tempts God, yet it should be noted that sometimes one tempts God, not with the intention of trying and testing, although it is done after the manner of testing. For one who uses an object of his own, because it is useful, is not, properly speaking, testing it; for example, if someone fleeing were to ride on his own horse he would be testing it, but not with the intention of testing; but when his action is useless, then he is testing. Likewise, if someone were to expose himself to danger, compelled by necessity in the hope of divine help, he would not be tempting God; but if without necessity, he would be tempting God; hence the Lord says in Mt. (4:7): ‘You shall not tempt the Lord, your God’, because there was not need to cast Himself down. So, they tempted the Lord, because they doubted His power, complaining against Moses, as if the Lord could not give them food, even though they had witnessed His power in greater matters; therefore, they were guilty of the sin of unbelief, which is the greatest.

180. - Then he mentions the gravity of their sin when he says, they proved and saw my works. For the greater the benefits one receives from God and the greater the certitude he has of God’s power, if he later doubts, he sins more gravely. But they had seen signs and wonders in the land of Egypt, the dividing of the sea, and other miracles, and yet they did not believe; hence, it is stated in Num. (14:22): ‘Yet all the men that have seen my majesty and the signs that I have done in Egypt and in the wilderness, and have tempted me now ten times, have not obeyed my voice’. Hence he said, proved, i.e., wished to experience, and saw, i.e., experienced my works, i.e., effects which not have taken place, unless they had been performed by one with infinite power. And all this not for one day, but for forty years, during which they remained in the desert, because they always had manna and the pillar of fire and the cloud. Or, they proved and saw me, because He never failed them.

181. - Then (v. 10b) he describes the punishment for their sin. For which cause, i.e., for which sin, I was provoked, i.e., outraged: not that there is anger in God except metaphorically, because He punishes as one in anger does. This punishment is frequently mentioned in Exodus and Numbers, for they were often prostrated. Hence in 1 Cor. (10:5) he speaks of the punishment of that sin. Or I was near, namely, by punishing them. For when the Lord helps the good and punishes the wicked, He is near them; but when He conceals men’s sins because they repent, and dissembles the affliction of the just in order that their merit may increase, then He seems to be far away: ‘The clouds are his covert, and he does not consider our things, and he walks about the poles of heaven’ (Jb. 22:14). Or, near, in regard to divine mercy, because the fact that he punishes them in this life is a sign of great mercy: ‘Here burn, here cut, but spare me in eternity’ (Augustine).

182. - Then (v. 10c) he describes the sin of provocation in detail. And this is clear from (v. 11). In regard to this he does two things: first, he mentions the sin; secondly, he adds the punishment (v. 11). In regard to the first he does two things: first, he mentions their persistence in evil; secondly, their departure from the good (v. 10d).

183. - He says, therefore, I was always near them, namely, by punishing them, and I said, namely, in the eternal plan: They always go astray in heart: ‘You have always been rebellious against the Lord’ (Dt. 31:27); ‘If the Ethiopian can change his skin, or the leopard his spots: you also may do well, when you have learned evil’ (Jer. 13:23). Thus, therefore, a person provokes God in one way, when he obstinately clings to evil; in another way when he scorns the good. Hence, he says, They have not known my ways, i.e. not with simple ignorance, but affected. The sin, therefore, is this: they have not known, i.e., they refused to know: ‘We desire not the knowledge of your ways’ (Jb. 21:14); ‘He would not understand that he might do well’ (Ps. 34:4). Or, they have not known, i.e., they have not approved, as the Apostle says: ‘The Lord knows who are his’ (2 Tim. 2:19).

184. - Then he shows the punishment when he says: As I have sworn in my wrath: they shall never enter my rest. In these words he suggests immutability; for when God or an angel swears, it is a sign of the unchangeableness of that concerning which He swears: ‘The Lord has sworn and he will not repent’ (Ps. 110:4). Yet at times He swears only conditionally, because if He did not repent, these evils would come upon them. Then he suggests that that punishment is not given as a threat but is aimed at their destruction, because he says, in his wrath: ‘Lord, chastise me not in your wrath’ (Ps. 6:2). Therefore, He swore in His wrath, they shall never enter my rest. Now there is threefold rest: one is temporal: ‘You have much goods laid up for many years: take your rest; eat, drink, make good cheer’ (Lk. 12:19). The second is the rest of conscience: ‘I have labored a little and have found much rest to myself’ (Sir. 51:35). The third is the rest of eternal glory: ‘In peace in the self-same. I will sleep and I will rest’ (Ps. 4:9). Therefore, what is stated here can be explained in each of these ways, namely, they have not entered the rest of the promised land or the rest of conscience or the rest of eternal happiness.
Source: Quotations drawn from early Church Fathers and historical Christian theologians (AD 100–1500). Some quotes address the surrounding passage context rather than this verse alone.
Copy as

Continue studying Hebrews 3:11 across the web’s major study libraries — every link below opens this exact verse, chapter, or book on the destination site.

TrulyRandomVerse is not affiliated with these sites and doesn’t control their content. They’re linked because they’re genuinely useful.