Ecclesiastes 6:12

KJV

For who knoweth what [is] good for man in [this] life, all the days of his vain life which he spendeth as a shadow? for who can tell a man what shall be after him under the sun?

KJV (with Strong's)

For who knoweth {H3045} what is good {H2896} for man {H120} in this life {H2416}, all {H4557} the days {H3117} of his vain {H1892} life {H2416} which he spendeth {H6213} as a shadow {H6738}? for who can tell {H5046} a man {H120} what shall be after {H310} him under the sun {H8121}?

Complete Jewish Bible

For who knows what is good for someone during life, during the days of his pointless life spent like a shadow? Who can tell what will happen under the sun after a person is gone?

Berean Standard Bible

For who knows what is good for a man during the few days in which he passes through his fleeting life like a shadow? Who can tell a man what will come after him under the sun?

American Standard Version

For who knoweth what is good for man in his life, all the days of his vain life which he spendeth as a shadow? for who can tell a man what shall be after him under the sun?

Commentary

### SUMMARY
Ecclesiastes 6:12 encapsulates the Preacher's profound and humbling inquiry into the limits of human understanding concerning what constitutes true good in life and the inherent uncertainty of the future. It underscores the transient and insubstantial nature of human existence, likening it to a fleeting shadow, and highlights humanity's inability to discern lasting benefit or predict what lies beyond the present moment, thereby reinforcing the book's pervasive theme of the vanity of earthly pursuits.

### CONTEXT
* **Literary Context:** This verse is deeply embedded within the Preacher's systematic exploration of life "under the sun"—a phrase recurring throughout Ecclesiastes to denote existence viewed from a purely human, earthly perspective, divorced from divine revelation. Chapters 5 and 6 specifically delve into the futility of wealth and material gain. Chapter 5:10-17 discusses how increasing riches do not bring satisfaction and how wealth can be lost or enjoyed by others, often to the detriment of the owner. Chapter 6 continues this theme, lamenting the tragedy of a wealthy man who cannot enjoy his riches (Ecclesiastes 6:1-6) and the insatiable nature of human desire (Ecclesiastes 6:7-9). The Preacher then observes that even if one lives a long life, if they have not found satisfaction, it is better to be a stillborn child (Ecclesiastes 6:3-6). Verse 12 serves as a culminating rhetorical question, drawing a conclusion about the ultimate unknowability of what is truly beneficial and the future, thereby reinforcing the preceding arguments about the emptiness of worldly pursuits. It sets the stage for further reflections on the limits of wisdom and the inevitability of death in subsequent chapters.
* **Historical & Cultural Context:** The book of Ecclesiastes, traditionally attributed to King Solomon, reflects the wisdom tradition of ancient Israel, albeit with a unique, often pessimistic, tone. The "under the sun" perspective is crucial for understanding the Preacher's argument; it represents a worldview that attempts to find meaning and purpose solely within the confines of human experience and observation, without explicit recourse to divine intervention or revelation. In a world where life was often precarious, marked by famine, disease, and political instability, the questions of what is "good" and what the future holds were deeply practical and existential. The concept of "shadow" would have been readily understood as a metaphor for transience, given the stark contrast between the bright, enduring sun and the fleeting, insubstantial shadow it casts. The Preacher's lament reflects a universal human struggle, amplified by the limited scientific and philosophical frameworks of the ancient world.
* **Key Themes:** Ecclesiastes 6:12 powerfully contributes to several overarching themes in the book. Firstly, it highlights **Human Ignorance and Limitations**, emphasizing that despite human striving for wisdom and success, our understanding of what truly benefits us in the long run is profoundly limited. This resonates with the Preacher's earlier declaration that "all is [vanity](/ecclesiastes/1-2 "Ecclesiastes 1:2 - Vanity of Vanities")" because human effort often yields no lasting advantage. Secondly, the verse underscores the **Fleeting Nature of Life and Earthly Endeavors**, portraying human existence as a "shadow," a vivid metaphor for its insubstantiality and brevity. This theme is central to the Preacher's argument that all human achievements and pleasures are ultimately ephemeral when viewed in light of death and the passage of time, echoing sentiments found in [Psalm 144:4](/psalms/144-4 "Psalm 144:4 - Man is like a breath"). Lastly, the verse confronts the **Uncertainty of the Future**, questioning humanity's ability to know "what shall be after him under the sun." This profound lack of foresight contributes to the pervasive sense of futility, as human plans and legacies are subject to unknown outcomes, a reality also touched upon in [Proverbs 27:1](/proverbs/27-1 "Proverbs 27:1 - Do not boast about tomorrow").

### EXPOSITION AND ANALYSIS

#### Key Word Analysis
* **good (Hebrew, _ṭôwb'_):** This word (H2896) is expansive in its meaning, encompassing everything from beautiful and pleasant to morally upright, prosperous, and beneficial. In Ecclesiastes 6:12, it refers to what is truly advantageous or profitable for humanity in the context of life "under the sun." The Preacher's rhetorical question, "who knoweth what is good for man," implies that this "good" is elusive, not easily discernible or attained through human wisdom or effort alone, challenging conventional notions of what constitutes a fulfilling life or lasting prosperity.
* **vain (Hebrew, _hebel'_):** From H1892, _hebel_ is a cornerstone term in Ecclesiastes, appearing over 30 times. It literally means "vapor" or "breath," but is used figuratively to convey emptiness, futility, transience, absurdity, or meaninglessness. When life is described as "vain life" (_hebel_ life), it emphasizes its fleeting, insubstantial, and ultimately unsatisfying nature. It's not necessarily "evil," but rather "without lasting substance" or "ultimately unprofitable" from an earthly perspective, highlighting the transient and often illusory nature of human pursuits.
* **shadow (Hebrew, _tsêl'_):** Derived from H6738, _tsêl_ denotes shade, whether literal or figurative. In this verse, it serves as a powerful metaphor for the brevity and insubstantiality of human life. A shadow has no independent existence, substance, or permanence; it changes with the light and eventually vanishes. Comparing human life to a shadow vividly portrays its ephemeral quality and lack of lasting impact when viewed apart from an eternal perspective, reinforcing the theme of _hebel_.

#### Verse Breakdown
* **"For who knoweth what is good for man in this life":** This opening rhetorical question immediately establishes the Preacher's central inquiry into human limitations. It challenges the assumption that humans, through their own wisdom or experience, can truly discern what will bring ultimate, lasting benefit or satisfaction during their earthly existence. The implicit answer is "no one," suggesting that true "good" is beyond human grasp or foresight, especially when viewed solely from an earthly perspective.
* **"all the days of his vain life which he spendeth as a shadow?":** This clause further elaborates on the nature of human life. The phrase "vain life" (life of _hebel_) reiterates its emptiness, meaninglessness, and transience when pursued apart from God. The comparison of spending life "as a shadow" is a potent simile that underscores the insubstantial, fleeting, and ultimately impermanent quality of human existence and all its endeavors. Just as a shadow lacks substance and quickly disappears, so too does human life and its accomplishments.
* **"for who can tell a man what shall be after him under the sun?":** This concluding rhetorical question extends the theme of human ignorance from discerning present good to foreseeing future events. It highlights humanity's complete inability to control or even predict what will happen after one's death, or even in the immediate future. This applies to one's legacy, the fate of one's possessions, or the general course of events. The phrase "under the sun" again limits the perspective to earthly knowledge, emphasizing that from this vantage point, the future remains an impenetrable mystery, leaving human plans and aspirations vulnerable to unforeseen circumstances.

#### Literary Devices
Ecclesiastes 6:12 is rich in literary devices that amplify its somber message. The most prominent is the use of **Rhetorical Questions** ("For who knoweth...?" and "for who can tell...?"). These questions are not posed to elicit an answer, but to emphasize the Preacher's conviction that the answer is unequivocally "no one." They powerfully highlight the profound limits of human wisdom and foresight, underscoring the futility of human striving for ultimate knowledge or control. Furthermore, the verse employs a striking **Metaphor** and **Simile** when it describes human life as "vain life which he spendeth as a shadow." The term "vain" (_hebel_) itself is a **metaphor** for emptiness and transience, while the comparison to a "shadow" functions as a **simile**, vividly illustrating the insubstantial and fleeting nature of human existence, which lacks permanence and substance. The **Repetition** of the interrogative "who" at the beginning of both clauses ("For who knoweth..." and "for who can tell...") creates a rhythmic emphasis, reinforcing the universal and inescapable nature of human ignorance regarding life's ultimate good and the future.

### THEOLOGICAL AND THEMATIC CONNECTIONS
Ecclesiastes 6:12 serves as a profound theological statement on human finitude and the sovereignty of God. It challenges the human tendency to seek ultimate meaning and security in earthly pursuits, demonstrating that even the most fundamental questions—what is truly beneficial, and what does the future hold—remain beyond our grasp. This humbling realization implicitly points to the necessity of a divine perspective. If humanity cannot discern true good or control the future, then ultimate wisdom and security must reside in the One who does. The Preacher's conclusion in [Ecclesiastes 12:13](/ecclesiastes/12-13 "Ecclesiastes 12:13 - The Whole Duty of Man")—"Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man"—provides the ultimate answer to the questions posed here, suggesting that true "good" and lasting purpose are found in a right relationship with the Creator, not in ephemeral earthly endeavors.

* [Psalm 39:5](/psalms/39-5 "Psalm 39:5 - Man is but a breath")
* [James 4:14](/james/4-14 "James 4:14 - Life is a Vapor")
* [Proverbs 27:1](/proverbs/27-1 "Proverbs 27:1 - Do not boast about tomorrow")

### REFLECTION AND APPLICATION
Ecclesiastes 6:12 offers a sobering yet liberating perspective on life. It forces us to confront the inherent limitations of our human understanding and control, particularly concerning what truly constitutes "good" for us in the long run and what the future holds. In a world that often encourages endless striving for wealth, success, and self-determination, this verse serves as a powerful antidote to pride and self-sufficiency. It calls us to humility, acknowledging that our best-laid plans and most fervent desires may not align with what is ultimately beneficial or enduring. Rather than succumbing to despair, this realization should prompt us to re-evaluate our priorities, shifting our focus from transient earthly gains to eternal values. It encourages us to live with an open hand, trusting in divine providence for the unknown future, and to find contentment not in what we can grasp or control, but in the simple gifts of the present moment and in seeking wisdom beyond ourselves, ultimately in God. This perspective frees us from the anxiety of needing to know or control everything, allowing us to rest in the wisdom of the One who holds all things in His hands.

#### Questions for Reflection
* **How does the Preacher's question, "who knoweth what is good for man in this life," challenge your own assumptions about what constitutes a "good" or successful life?**
* **In what ways do you experience life as "a shadow," fleeting and insubstantial, and how does this awareness impact your daily pursuits?**
* **How does the uncertainty of the future, highlighted by the question "who can tell a man what shall be after him," influence your planning and anxieties?**
* **What practical steps can you take to shift your focus from seeking ultimate good in earthly things to finding it in a relationship with God?**

### FAQ
**What does "under the sun" mean in Ecclesiastes?**

Answer: The phrase "under the sun" is a recurring motif in Ecclesiastes, appearing nearly 30 times. It refers to human experience and observation from a purely earthly, empirical perspective, without explicit divine revelation or an eternal viewpoint. When the Preacher speaks of life "under the sun," he is examining life as it appears to human reason and senses, often concluding that from this limited perspective, much of human endeavor is "vanity" or "hebel" (meaningless, futile, transient). It sets the stage for the book's ultimate conclusion that true meaning and lasting good are found only when one looks beyond the earthly realm to God (as seen in [Ecclesiastes 12:13](/ecclesiastes/12-13 "Ecclesiastes 12:13 - The Whole Duty of Man")).

### CHRIST-CENTERED FULFILLMENT
Ecclesiastes 6:12, with its profound questions about what is "good" for humanity and the unknowability of the future, finds its ultimate answer and fulfillment in Jesus Christ. The Preacher's lament over the elusive nature of "good" is resolved in Christ, who is the embodiment of all good and the source of true life. While humanity "knoweth" not what is good, Jesus declares, "I am the [good shepherd](/john/10-11 "John 10:11 - Jesus, the Good Shepherd")" and offers life in its fullness, a life that is truly abundant and enduring ([John 10:10](/john/10-10 "John 10:10 - I have come that they may have life")). The "vain life... spent as a shadow" is transformed by Christ, who brings eternal life and substance to human existence. Our fleeting days are given eternal significance through His resurrection, which conquered the transience of death and the grave, offering a hope that is "an anchor for the soul, firm and secure" ([Hebrews 6:19](/hebrews/6-19 "Hebrews 6:19 - Hope as an Anchor")). Furthermore, the inability to "tell a man what shall be after him under the sun" is overcome by Christ, who not only knows the future but is the very Lord of it. He assures His disciples of His return ([John 14:3](/john/14-3 "John 14:3 - I will come again")) and reveals the ultimate destiny of humanity through His victory over sin and death ([Revelation 21:4](/revelation/21-4 "Revelation 21:4 - No more tears, no more death")). In Christ, the uncertainty of the future gives way to the blessed hope of His coming and the promise of a new heaven and a new earth, where the "vanity" of earthly life is swallowed up by eternal glory. He is the wisdom of God, providing the ultimate "good" and the certainty of a future beyond the shadow of this world ([Colossians 2:3](/colossians/2-3 "Colossians 2:3 - In whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge")).

Note: Commentary is generated by AI with a directive for Biblical fidelity. Always rely on the Holy Spirit for discernment. The Scripture text and cross-references are from verified, non-AI sources.

Cross-References

James 4:14

Whereas ye know not what [shall be] on the morrow. For what [is] your life? It is even a vapour, that appeareth for a little time, and then vanisheth away.

Ecclesiastes 3:22

Wherefore I perceive that [there is] nothing better, than that a man should rejoice in his own works; for that [is] his portion: for who shall bring him to see what shall be after him?

Job 14:2

He cometh forth like a flower, and is cut down: he fleeth also as a shadow, and continueth not.

Lamentations 3:24

The LORD [is] my portion, saith my soul; therefore will I hope in him.

Lamentations 3:27

[It is] good for a man that he bear the yoke in his youth.

Psalms 144:4

Man is like to vanity: his days [are] as a shadow that passeth away.

Psalms 39:5

Behold, thou hast made my days [as] an handbreadth; and mine age [is] as nothing before thee: verily every man at his best state [is] altogether vanity. Selah.